Marine Corps Memo re: Possible Article 32 Investigation in to Alleged Detainee Abuse

Two (2) suspects in the theft from the Iraqi National Guard (ING) Training Camp at Camp Junction City, allege being abused while in custody. Both suspects provided facts "proven to be false and established patterns of not providing the truth". One of the detainees’ claims that he was hit during questioning, but stated that neither of the Marines present had any contact with him during any of the interrogations. The other person stated he was taken to a dark room where he could only breathe through a small hose. Pictures of the cell show that no hose, of any type, could not be placed under the door and there is no evidence that either of the suspects were mistreated in any manner by either coalition or Iraqi forces during their detention at the ING compound or during their subsequent detention at the 1st Brigade Detention Facility.

Doc_type: 
Investigative File
Doc_date: 
Wednesday, September 22, 2004
Doc_rel_date: 
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
Doc_text: 

111167= OWES NAM= CORPS

15T MARINE 0/VISION (RSINO
DIC 40120
YPO AP 96126-0120

IN REPLY Rum TO:

5830
eSJA11111

ID 2 2 2004
FIRST ENDORSEMENT on Memo from CO 1BCT dtd 23 August .2004

From: Commanding General, 1st Marine Division (Rein)
To:

Commanding General, I Marine Expeditionary Force

Subj: - investi ation d detainee abuse at 1BCT by

• and (0)(7(C)
viSiiSli
1.
Readdressed and forwarded. I only considered the addendum
portion of the investigat 9, P. •= alt with the alleged detainee
abuse of (b)(7)(C)

and (0)(7)iC)

2.
I concur with the recommendation of the investigating officer
as endorsed.

3.
No further investigation is warranted.

R. F. NATONSKI

Copy to:
File

6 [ USMC 1ST MARDIV (27)
DOD JUNE 1354

DEPARTMENT' OF THE ARMY
HEADQUARTERS
1ST BRIGADE COMBAT TEAK 1ST INFANTRY DIVISION (MECHI
CAMP JUNCTION CITY. IRAQ
APO AE 09394

IMPLY TO
itTT*M11011 0?:

AFZN-BA 23 August 2004
MEMORANDUM FOR Record
SUBJECT: and Recommendations for 15-6 Investigation Conducted by
1.
The findings of the Investigating Officer are approved.

2.
1 direct that a copy of this file be sent to US Army CID with a recommendation that no further action or investigation be conducted.

(b)(7)(C)
DOD JUNE 1355

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
1ST BRIGADE COMBAT TEAM, 1ST INFANTRY DIVISION (MEDI)
CAMP JUNCTION CITY, IRAQ
APO AE D9394
INIEKV TO
ATTIOMDM Of:
AFZN-BA 17 August 2004

MEMORANDUM FO
SUBJECT: Order to Reopen AR 15-6 Investigation
1.
On 20 July 2004, you were appointed to conduct an informal investigation into the circumstances surrounding the loss of approximately $190,000 at the Iraqi National Guard (ING) Training Camp located on Camp Junction City. You are now ordered to reopen that investigation and consider whether the two suspects in the theft of the money were mistreated in any way by coalition or Iraqi forces during their detention at either the ING compound or the 1st Brigade Detention Center.

2.
Your investigation should focus on the entire duration of their detention. You will interview all soldiers, marines, contractors and any ING soldiers that may have information valuable to the investigation. You will advise military service members of their rights LAW Article 31 UCMJ if you suspect them of a violation of the UCMJ prior to questioning. Your findings must resolve any contradictory statements. You will make findings that are supported by the evidence and you will make recommendations that arc supported by your findings.

3.
Your legal advisor for this investigation is F t E Trial Counsel. You will complete your investigation not later than 27 ugusgNi n i f) yot.u. findings midrecommendations to your legal advisor

(b)(7)(C)

DOD JUNE 1356

' TH E ARMY
Camp Junction .tty,Iraq APO AE 09394
ArLN-BA-OPS. 21 August 2004
MEMORANDUM FOR Commander, 1st Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division, Camp Junction City, Iraq, APO, AP. 09394
SUBJECT: Addendum to 22 July 2004 15-6 Investigation
1.
On 17 August 2004, I was ordered to reopen the 13 -6 investigation tamoeming the kiss of approximately SI90,000 at the Iraqi National Guard (ING) Training Camp located on Camp Junction City. I s instructed to consider whether the two suspects in the theft of the money were mistreated in any way by Coalition or Iraqi forces during their detention at either the ING compound or the 1st Brigade Detention Center.

2.
On 19 August 2004, I was informed by ( b 7,1( C 1st Brigade Trial Counsel, that I had been ordered to reopen the 15-6 investigation that I had completed on 22 July 2004. I was provided the suspects detention packets and their statements identifying that they had been abused at various times during their detention at the ING compound.

3.
On 19 August 2U04, after reviewing the suspects' statements, I discussed my qualifications to reopen the •• ve ' "on_ In both suspecti statements, they identify thatthere was a Coalition For present during the initial interrogation of the suspect

I was than:mad at ;on and wanted to ensure that there was not a conflict of interest in this case (b) ( / ) ( C ) 1st Brigade Trial Counsel, advised me that there was no reason or my • isqua ; teat on due to the fact that much of the alleged abuses took place after the initial interrogation. My sworn statement on the facts as I witnessed them during the initial interrogation is found in Exhibit G.
4. In the course of the invest statements fromEINI, ( b ) (7)(C) the former 501 a BN INCL the former 50.1 BN INC S3, were unav fired from his position on 14 August 2004. i b )( 7) { C Iiit shortly after
as fired. Additionally, I took several photographs of the detention cell at the ING compound as well as the mosque room; both rooms were mentioned in the . suspects' statements as locations for some of the alleged abuses. I did not question the two suspects as " • ' statements did not agree with each other as to what thealleged abuses to . Both suspects provided facts in their statements that were
Page 1 of 5

DOD JUNE 1357
AFZN-BA-OPS
SUBJECT: Addendum to 22 July 200415-6 Investigation
proven to be false and thus established patterns of not providing the truth in their original statements.
5.
As of 20 August 2004,111111Muidillilare in the 1st Brigade Detention Facility awaiting transfer to Abu aharib prison in Baghdad.

6.
Findings. There is no evidence that either of the suspects were mistreated in any manner by either coalition or Iraqi forces during their detention at the ING compound or during their subsequent detention at the 1st Brigade Detention Facility.

The discussion relevant to the findings is presented for each suspect. Each incident of alleged abuse will be discussed below:
A. The sospectilliiiilleges in Exhibit 1 that many Pains and incidents of abuse took place while he was being detained at the ING compound. There were no reported incidents of abuse during his detention at the 1st Brigade Detention Center.
(I) he was taken by the • .• CD ed
his family. hi his statement, Exhibit B, (.
ted that he did not strike or make physical contact with • -• • • y time during the interrogation process. In his statement, Exhibit b ) ( 7 ) (C ) that when the suspect was being taken to call his family that he saw t b )(7);C) rt the suspect by the kit atm and lest shoulder. This action was in keeping with normal procedures when escorting a detainee to ensure the suspect does not try to flee or injure himself or others.
2
N , .ed that he was hit when the number that he tried to call was ed to hi every time that he dialed and got no one.
Exhibits B 1,112 stated that there was no bodily contact be 61 they left b) ( ( C ffice.1111.11dated that he herdligy left arm as escorted him out of the office. This action was in keeping with normal procedures when escorting a d

(3) stated that as •d his head in to the door as he
4 y I • ¦..4
was him from (r)` ,'7Y,C) ffice. stated, Exhibit C, that he did not push '.v1t in to t were leaving fflce after
t I.
nor as
phone call to his

(4) ated that he called his family he was taken backlog.'• • • ,.., .,•_.:• was assaulted and shocked with a Laser (electronic shocking
ce). ; u ; i i ,( C ) • • • i .) , (7 C) stated in Exhibits B and E that they neither used nor saw anyone use a o any time.
-,,- a
5 .I. ,„., that after returning KIEMoffice for more
.,4 v.,.
uesti .1 rt,s , ( 7)(G) s laced him in flex cuffs k • an questioning him. (b , (7 , ( C ) stated in Exhibits B and B tha c , c 7 1 t” ' as not flex cuffed at any mterrogations.
Page 2 of 5

DOD JUNE 1358
AFZN-BA-OPS
SUBJECT: Addendum to 22 July 2004 15-6 Investigation
(6) !Mated thatillilalkiMicalled him a liar during

the que4ionin 7 a roceeded to hit him after they called him a liar. This physical contact ca . .t. • chair on to the floor where he landed on his
stomach. .• (:7)(7)(C) .ted in Exhibits B and E. that neither of them had
any contact with wring any of the interrogations that occurred.
ted he was taken to a ue in the ING • uarters where
(7)he was interroga some more and hit in the head by 7 le, mily. 71 .C' further states :.(b)( /AG) the Tamil to I 11 the h
family continued to o so anyway. ( b )( I)(C.. ( )17 C) stat in Exhibits C and that they did not see an one strike or hit any way.
(8) he was taken to a dark mom where there was little air
:11 I
and that • I I a small hose that was provided by another
soldiers. ted in exhibits B, C. E, and F that the detention
cell, that erred to as the dark morn, had a window in it that provided light and
air. On 20 August 2004, i went to the 501st EN INC Headquarters to inspect and
photograph the detention cell. The pictures of the detention cell are shown in Exhibit P
through R. In the pictures you can see that the door to the detention cell has not been altered and that a hose of any type cannot be placed under the door. Additionally. a hose
is not necessary due to the window being in the room. There is on the window
so it is not possible for the windowto have been sealed ' • stated that
, lot • • the detention cell was converted to n ffice for use b ',U 1 r7hCi and that the window was installed after he left the room. (b)(7)(C) • 1.,b)(7)(C) stated in Exhibits C and V that they were responsible for the construction of the eadquarters in various capacities and that the detention was constructed with a window in it. They also in th same exhibits that the detention cell had never been used as an office
9 I, that he forced to move rocks the first day he was there.
ted in Exhibits C and F that they did not havelinfrnove rocks at any time while he was detained at -the ING Coropound.iplwas ed to clean the latrine after he used it as well as pick up trash that they accumulated both in the courtyard and throm.
(10)1111111stated that another ING 3211lig. was the Mosque room with him because the other soldier provided InErood. so alleges that he had not been vided food for two d s and that is why the so ter was trying tosneak him food. , (7 i( . I • (D)( 7)(C ) admitted in B and E that the
detained another ING soldier and that e was kept in the Mosque room The ING soldier was detained when he was caught trying to sneak something, pima ci the Mosque Room. They placed the ENG soldier in the room with
or approx el), 2 hours and then he was released. They also stated in those same exhibits that they rovidedlilliwith 3 MIRE meals and bottled water daily.
stated that he was s !, • b one oldie interpreters but didnot specify when this occurred. 11(7 } and (t.); ; 7 )(C.; ) ted in Exhibits B and E that they did not see anyone strike or hit n any way.
Page 3 of 5
DOD JUNE 1359

AFZN-BA-OPS
SUBJECT: Addendum in 22 July 2004 15-6 Investigation
(12)
Wherillinwas brought to the 1st Brigade Detention Facility on 4 August 2004, it was noted that he had no current injury or medical complaint, Exhibits H and J. During his subsequent irate 't , Exhibit 3, it was also noted that he had no injuries and denied being abused. ' vided his statement, Exhibit 1 on 15 August 2004 claiming the above mentioned abuses. These claims came 13 days after being transferred to the 1st Brigade Detention Facility.

(13)
In his statement1.111.11eges many incidents of abuse. Given the fact that both the detention cell and Mosque room are well ventilated and are not dark he creates a doubt about the validity of the rest of his statement 1-Es physical condition at the time he was brought to the 1st Brigade Detention Facility also suggests that he bad not been abused during his detention at the INC compound.

13. The suspect leges in Exhibit L that many forms and incidents of abuse took place while he was being detained at the NG compound. There were no
II I I :t IL
reported incidents use u his d 1st Brigade Detention Center.
(1)
(1',)( 7 )(C) tated tha (b);T(C) ocked him in the arm with a taser after repeatedly answering the same question. (1'n("7iC fb';',7)(C) tated in Exhibits B and E .0. . use nor did y see anyone use a taser (electronic shucking device) ) 1,C3 any sir

(2)
t. stated umped on him after used the laser on him. C and (b)(:)(C) toted in Exhibits B and El that they didnotiump ,7 ,(;) n . see anyone jump on him at any time.

(3) , • ' ed that he denies havin written. a statement for1111
r 'The statement 34 Y 71 (C i vided ut the theft of the money is included as N
(4) vides details of the various abuses that received during his detention at the INC coal md. The statement as it pertains to
is based on di: .1 4. 4. with the remainder of their detention at the 1NG compound. (C ferences the initial interrogation which occurred over 12 bouts prior to (b fore lie could not have been prose it raw the interrogations. A iiiunally l b) i 7:(Ci e undersigned, was present for the initial interrogation ofillinuld stated in Exhibit G that there was no physical contact by anyone during the initial interrogation except when 7 I 1. C escorted to call his relatives.
(5) As withillillivilenMarias brought to the 1 st Brigade Detention Facility on 4 August 2004 it was noted that he had no current injury or medical complaint, Exhibi K . During his subsequent interrogations, Exhibit M. it was also noted tha had no injuries and denied being abuscd,111E111111111 provided his statement, Exhibit L on 15 August 2004 claiming the above mentioned abuses. These claims came 1 I days after being transferred to the 1st Brigade Detention Facility.
Page 4 of 5
DOD JUNE 1360
APLN-BA-OPS
SUBJECT; Addendum to 22 July 200415-6 Investigation

(6) In his statemen=11111two incidents of abuse against
agams4
himself and numerous inci , -, ts of abuse • Neither incident of abuse can
be tne

aidar:borated. 1:-, ) 7)(C) -.tterrtpts to te a story or abuses againstA, as not t tor ., e alleged abuses. Thus 1 assume that he o
arc &legal abaci limp ing their detention td both the 11.1(i com und and the 1st Brigade Detention F tty. By stating the alleged abuses indicated a willingness to paint a false story to help out their current - • situatio
bu di
7. Recommendations.
A. That no criminal charges he brought against ElliEllind
Mind that the 15-6 investigation be officially closed a it pertains to the theft of money and the alleged abuses.
Exhibits
A - DA Form 388I (19 Aug 04) 13 DA Fonn 2823 (19 Aug 04) C DA Form 2823 20 Aug 04)
D DA Form 3881 (19 Aug 04)
E DA Form 28 19 Aug 04) F VA Form 2823 20 Aug 04) G DA Form :r, 19 Aug 04) Picture of 9 Jul 04) Statemen (15 Aug 04)
•J t and medical =port (4 Aug 04)
Picture o t:D)i7)(C) 9311104) L Statement -bi.7)(C) 15 Aug 04) M ._);+,7)‘'C) mprocessing sheet and medical report (4 Aug 04)
(1
N il:)(7)(C) 'dal statement (22 Jul 04)
0 Diagram of the front portion of the 501' ENG headquarters
P - Picture oiDeterition Cell Door
Q Picture of Detention Cell Doorway from Hallway—showing window in cell Picture of Detention Cell window
Page 5 of 5
.
DOD JUNE 1363.
„....--
•RHIO” voarsive PROCEDURE/waive' CE4IICWE Wow 0 00 Ism. se• AN 1110-30; toe 0014444118111100, le
DATA REQUIRED SV na ravAcy.AcT
,
Ai/MONTY: . Ilea 10, Unload Stew Coda, Bosun 3012w Te pnxido ossentandaro and Iwo IdIthddellOODI olitelolt wtel mons by idtIch bdatvattion may be ammaloody Idssefhpd,
PlilliCIPAL PURPOSE: Vesst Dodd Sacwity bombe if used ea an ebtrionaltaitatnata mews of idardimoedon te beim. Ms and impiovig.
ROUTINE USES: •
DISCLOSURE:

Dloaltleas of your *odd Smithy Nuinber Ii voliwtootc•
2. DA I 1. 1‘111 4. PUN NO.
LOCA11011C apvtair z,441
1 I i95-I
)
tY.(3) - 10 USC 130b
(b)(5.) -SSN ( - ,(7,,,
' Mt' Mae
my I • naffs wArVERAMMI-WAPAIN (INTIMATE
i.
tiEcdatt A. MOW

mop teeeseme ere. new eppore Imhof leaf ape Int beNbe Is ebb the Waled Omen bawd.(b)(3) - 10 USC 130b
...1.....• so 00010 dm* ihe folmebi 010•00 it Woke I an
kg=-11,t -. •q-A3147---"'"-''-'—'--.

Nispenidfs•oweet
0.40.
Wile eased so amp Ipmelleso elost Del ollaseei.). lassordaa. heish• 4044 I dr es we Mae , Nom Ow 1010•03 Vow

1.
I de ail 100 1e 1000ar •••4•04110 fir OT Bea i•16

2.
ANON' I am err.do ego Imummid .. •4006. NOW ma.IN • 0000 Me.

3.
We( powsomotessigbar 800 UM) I heras Os 4•14 aredb 00001 to a Imrcer beiste. Ming. NM 4114t mosiesks one to Mrs a Wow pleaswe with ops

*oft qmsolomIng. Th10 heal., as be • *Su. Norm I snow be 0.0 1aps0•16 is Govasomme or • wasom weir dialled Ns wear ar wpm, to me.
et bade.
• or -

1140 044.8. am egIVort es Me IICatli I I have the diM to ta pawl* te a Iverfer balsas. babe. and War qurielig sod No bow a betv•er 0.0•• vol0
Ise *MI Illossbnies. 1 sailwelare1 0* d.. Warm ts• I. am. UN I maw 10 at tuy Nom weasa. or II 108e0 0100 a lawyer and meal 00, •1800, ve be sp00•041 tor mg balmy IAA Iparodusdni begins.
4. V I tar tow vibes 46 demo 110 ansuaaisi NNW Wn.lgs0*. 100 0 wasetat a Wow paean. I owe a Mei to 14.1t imumehmi gunleme si wry Vow or
Nub 000eN 010 a broyin 1000. rumadne bodes, ease II 1 iiip lbs weans Wow.

---....-
IC commits gentaan es t 'wow ales)

Section a Walvis
I suslontaid SW *Ms e• ado* shave. I at ow willog Is ammo the eftsersteI swabs hassedollut end nimbi • 000•01 widow Nekdo• 0 •Warp Ow too %awn
boob* 1•00,01080
• vollb 00.
VRTIIMNSI N/ wraNsbisi
1.. NA* (pp e or Aft,
Lm).)iii71.4Clirm%
- --.0.---
b..OPOANNATION OR ROOM* AND NMI
. (b)(7)(C)
... was frit, re ar Paw. . . . _.
(b)(7)(C)
b. oneinvmoto ON AWN)! N43 PINION
WO) - 10 USC 1301-)
..
Ilerlieer C. Nar•arntra
1. I fle sal area to oke up my tlebe
ra / wind • beerat .
Ida pal want to b. quemlonad •• es• moyohlne
2. NANATUNI Of INTERVINNOR
.......—.

.--
MUM TWO WAIVER CERTFICATE TO AMY WORN STATEMENT MA NMI 2111231 SUBSEQUENTLY EXECUTED BY ME SMUT/ACCUSED
AIMIIMmIMMY
RA ICRRIA .11112115NI ..a.. AA. —__. — —___ __ ._ ____. _
USAPA sot
DOD JUNE 1362
DODDON001100

1-01400NO4CIOCI

E9ET
mar aoa
. . ,
M•l& Verna

wee WHOA va 10 atatanall
Nonlimeopme
ge¦¦••ftwil
• 4 •
L•A.*usain ft !m• LIOVAINP 106101440fte Lipp arL M. SO sallow* woe you •iimoso
10111 'GP* del•milm owl flOPKONIS•d•il 1,811•4111•olp N P
69 um Ave •41111m201, w W•lowee eAfist else/sap op is Sq Mpussmss 41••••••••11••d•m •
,11 w•llawit Mw art 'seed sci• 1••14•tagpaus• NMS loara OgIopua0 mai% 1,-aatoss s 111 pposp i maim, 'whom Jodi pilivftbs •opimassi moo solopopus el*** imams Na volso•os•ul '
00 Oar. 44 *MAW. 010010 MUM* MIN tlO $114
NO Nassiaaala ItAVId•113 Gitinxtvamains mew
11011••0••aluel• Na 144POPI Pi• 44140solos
.44444a •ws oss sappso ossormso •sa is ppm og prowl Seuposesoo
pow, •it peossoossardies sop pop fen es•segildo g 1

%Lou
'PEPSI Ol•si 4••••I aW &We* aq 01••011••• Jas& S••••sa• apt WWI *•oon' 0•Por
Its•w•• • • • ••11. mu -pampa so •• Moo po•oao• loossonom
8141 Na N Gismdent sm s w suess wipe* moos As sp•" melpp lumpy. Gun so••pss mops wows. ••••••••1 moos pooswoorpokoto sip A ••
r*
to~WNW iLli••YPIOS
'IU pm& "Immo 4MM/a sl INIMIMM WWI• Som aviammsesqs •••• nip ppm oil plump *O• OAS &AIM •• 0••1•P• 441•41•4•44” 010041 smssamms lkqpumpraq assamsmie wpm 155 promomposoberg, atal LV L• IMILLVIda111121• UMW
•••••••••l•m smt los vim
M pomp may i••a•si Assumbms sq Mm seSspose •sipsSomp•l 11045 p else ap
Vews paspkoss Immo elopmaso amp* oiss inplog tolimapeeti Mn ••••• •••011•as *Nom mg emerges N woo ois mop yam MBAS "awilowd is Iwo r•mtik•w as Mise 06414.440 MMA ••• Nom w 011 :A1SIVICERWIS 011.•1010.1 Is .1.01111VO ILVOLILLit33 IGNWA A
'allekllia• MAWS Na lap oupo••u pro •ospeapasout
'Na i•1•odo18• •••. •111 N num.. •851•••1 • swot pm •••40 ••r osif•N
allolow•••• aq1004 aasP Perna MN algal YAM ••• s a osmosis *mom
&moor sem Supim•••ap sop mom possa•r• Nos ma •olossaino
roam oil map os onsios uol WISP
PHIllerAYPegiene rilMMUMia itarowa mos 1211121111016 cmisimviAmeens UMW
VVIOUWallalf(IVI^Jadll
/VMS
mpfil M/Isple •m w •sd•psh, alms* cis or wpm* "ow op gAi pa

0•P•lab 11,441.14. I*11 J•441.II IP* •111•014 MO NM maim pew 4.0441 map. at trAmlxviiklAwreArte 44a
um* ins •• 4fort ago ow sopd op a is .•4¦1,. Moo peoworpiaolope op a ••.•••cesse• Na or•lPoo• es somas "Nos Opp mom rolossior
alpe memo, 4•404141 41A111
as asSals PIN 111+1114 TAO M. CC IMP aka* -eg MOM NM Pi • •4•1•111,4 AM ..'est wk. morom•oollor op ay
aissA apps rood loonbod Na a lumps Paas Mow ms /VA .'s.A. MAM v•..M•semsl OM al
A•S••l • &Soul loomPlos aims, • al MSN Sam pota po•ussms* • *p• aSsmie ins.¦ pace aim map a•Orom • posessiol satAM Mow pm espos•amm rpm •pompo asp o••m. N lumps nal me muis mu iv.
l'Impposb •pme•m am mit ook
ruswas•i &swam Na• *rows PR .'Na. Mee •••••••41244.4.4 Na N IBM. IMP.IMene••b• ma a •oos000pp. arils oimpllsoMo *Is WNW Alsku•dig41 am wpm' ism Su••ummb
dips .4164. Mao poonsoopoo•e. up AI
11••••••••• Iwo %MON 110(1111MAp .p•••m•po•k•w al asitim •ms w saAmm a pus ear In.
-MISS SM p•m•sepot •rA op.
11:1NWS ii141
*map swim •ssolsompurs lips& poso•oopowdono Na spits, •PM 6•00•0 SAO sal ¦ mom 'moot Suposuolo messii mu, lh••••.mb Rapp oat gips s•••ooll mires • ••¦• mom rim!s spa iso•pal wale riling Jan is ropiamb
at pis Illypoporb A441 psi loop *memo sham yos Aelvahlmil
Sopoasolle 1..M Naafi e way INA •Passent A/4mi • IllolaPo 10 VP*

4181 A 1•4+ Jap ammo invoti WIN asikra "mood aid
••P•SII••oy apon issloousip sip wow N Snap mom SN Mil

• :Pia ~la .•••••• •soepo•oll Ante Nom mg so, moods@ • s• 0•A paper sompas rem sq r sv as km mat essmArv.
sq IA salami • vas sown pi* anima • paw ~so assA N as ••••sdito A011 a 40•1140111 4111 ~Me is .via aaP MA.
sew NM I* MI SIMMS OM Ms eV me imams' opu Aario•asoo• lope Nal

,copelpSM pos•estun MA •loopo•stb *SA gm I WPM.
sops Wend Weal • •••• poo el•quelmr• eye Pam *gm %mom 2•Ss•l

Mmil004 " 'PIMP JOIMPI Po P••••••••••••1 Jap &RACY 'SAWN
• N *WO qpm et 44•44 Na Msq MA *VIM Na M StS1M +yar NIIMIMI "MU
Vally•••Poodoal Is sl apposi top spa Mall 'a - as -
• oPmslis MIMS.. • .• .'Meq a VosS r osuodar su is owl !ssi pomp *Aso/
• "4180044 IIPIIV•awA • • 7 ' -
imnpv, • is osimpai.A. •¦•

oliSI log oliSsot SIA ulllior •••
44.91MiaelledalMS m4.414 . : titiievviA • ‘i
OMAN" NIL
• llufiaeraar Olorarmt sweat
PlUVACY ACT STATISM,/ Ati1110111TY: 'IAM 10113C Section 301; NM II UBC Swam 2961; LO. 9397 doted November 22, 1943 MM. plIDDIPAL MOOS& To perAd• eommendere and law enloresnent ernsids with maims by eolith Inforieedon insy be simuisisly NOUN* USES: Tem aside eseurity number is and Is ¦a eadiskaWsissmais resins al kisndilioides la fain= WW1 awl rsaisvil. DISCLOSU&Ilis Clesisbas el your maid seouritx number is volusbaY.
TION1. LOCA 12. DATE fITYNAMDLy 1 S. TOW 4. ALE NUIVNIEN
elcso.f ...1AiNpuppops... I 200 tY80 iti i Zoic ,_ • .•
(b)(7)(C) (b)(6) • SSN (b)(7)(C)
( , 1 " ) - 1 ( --, I :" ,...LCAL; Ago 4€, 043qti
b (/ . WMR TO MAKE ME FOILOYANO STATES Ir UNDER OATIt
we. ArtLciAtel LA.IL,SN ar5 afts...eQ 4.41SWC..." 01044 Il //e,.va OV ..

ti ¦
.
10. COUSIT [ 11. INITIALS OF PERSON MAIM sroanien 1 ,I PAGE 1 OF —.2.... PAGES
ADDITIONAL Molls *MST coNrAtt Tiff WADING •STATEMINT TANEN AT.DATED
T1 BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITION4L FADE MUST BEAR Tiff Perms OF THE POISON ,WAKINO TIff STATEMENT, 4W PAIM MAMA R
muFr W W AWNED.
OA FORM 2823. DEC 1218 DA FORM 21123. An. 72.18 0060LETE maw" v e.se
DOD JTJNE 1364

STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED
S. STATEMENT (Continuo*
AFFIDAVIT
. HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, MP ENDS ON PAGE . I FUUX UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE WTATBNITET MADE SY ME. THE STATMAMIT IS TRUE, I HAVE INITIALEO ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIAUCt THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING TIE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF SWEAT OR REWARD, WITHOUT
THREAT OF PUNISHMENT. AND WITHOUT COERCION, I. •

(b)(7)(C)
WITNESSES: Subscribed and worn to before me, a person authorized by kw to ednirdster oaths, Die MIA. day of 2-1604 rf
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS fagnmetav of Eamon
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT 1 PAGE .2 OF A PACE{
EMI 3, DA PONE 3823, DEC 1818 NAM V

DOD JUNE 1365

DODDON001103

Illintatement —1.9 Aug 04
Q. D. ever strikeMEEliwith any part of your body? If so. how did you strike him?
A. ha)
Q. Did yuu ever use an electronic shocking device on any part 0111=11110. any time? If so what part of his body did you use the device on?

A-MINI
Q. Did you see anyone use an electronic shocking device on any part ofillanlat any time? Wm) what part of his body did you see the shocking device being used on?A.NO i
Q. Did ram linE
onnat any time during his questioning?
A. t10
Q. Did one onEEEllat any time during his questioning?
A. Kt
Q. if who did you g on Where did this take place?
11! 1
A. ki 0 / A
Q. Who ( b) ( 7)1 C ) his return to the Headquarters?
A. 1.151) (b)(7)(C) SPar--ZgLO
Q. Did you have any physical contact withESElibefore, during, or alter thequestioning sessions? If so, please describe the incident.
A
ZEE
Page I of 6
DOD JUNE 1366

Q. Did you have any physical contact wi ( b)(7)(C) on the day you turned him in to the Ar Ramadi Detention Facility? If so, please ,escribe the incident.
A. 104. :r: paeLcA. 0.4. 604:%Ati bsecit4
Q. How long did you detain (b)(7)(C) before being turned over to the Ar Ramadi
Detention Facility?

A. colo,1--0 - 15
A
Q. Now and where was ( 7) (C) • mined tmtil being turned over to the Ar Ramadi
Detention Facility?
co-ciik.L.

Q. How did you transpo
vehicle used and the • ysical state

A. hiA6
Q. Who transportedillMao the Ar Ramadi Detention Facility?
A.
(b)(7)(C)
Q. Did anyone strikeingillihetOre, during, or alter being transported to the Ar Ramadi - 114. e n Facility?
Q. Did you ever strik a ith any part of your body? If so, what part of your bodydid you strike him witlfill
A. Ai 0
Q. Did you ever use an electronic shocking device on any part oill=1 any time? If so, what part of the body did you use the shocking device on?
A.
)( C;
X.1 0
Page 2 of 6
DOD JUNE 1367
Q. Did you nee anyone use an electronic shocking device on any pan ofallat any
time? f so, what part of the body was the shocking device used on?

A. 0
Q. Did yotivonillitt any time duri ng his questioning?
A. 00
Q. Did you sec anyone on11111t any time during his questioning?
A. ill0 (7 Ci
Q. If so, who did you see jumping or' Where did this take place?
a.
ig AM
Q. Who questioned his return to the 501st 13N ENG Headquarters?
Q. Did you have any physical contact with before, during, or alter the
quesAjtiaiessions? If so, please describe the incident,

A.
Q. Did you have any physical contact with Minn the day you turned him in to the Ar Rasnadi Detention Facility? If so, please describe the incident
A.
azfrtAct. L, Av.—% *, 6(24.J sobtrItc,
Q. How long did you detainillabefore he was turned over to the Ar Ramadl Detention Facility?
a.
,((:7 ;( (_;;
C&&%-t GlAtb.p.6
Q. How and where wasillialetained until being turned over to the Ar Ramadi Detention Facility?
A. aj-.11,a1 u6 ) ( in (7 )(C)
elbusf
Page 3 of 6
DOD JUNE 1368
Q. Bow did you transport o the Ar Ramadi Detention facility? Discuss the vehicle used and the hysica state of Akram.
p 7Y2,1
A. 1JTV
16"v6
Q. Who trans the Ar Ramadi Detention Facility?
A. ',Au

(b)(7)(C)
Q. Did anyone strike before. during, or after being transported to the Ar Ramadi
A. Nib
Q. Describe what happened when you tooliellito call his brother.
it. a: .20144 (b; (7) (C)

-E. coead L.k.ce It'A-z. p 44 ,..... tnestaA 4t, cat,,, (b)(7)(C) C.C.11 .
144 bAKCA C44*-4 6.....3-
e tt.41.sit a
oho Lick k bs\y-4LA (16k% S‘veA.4..0 cit4e-lib, LL cAmirote LA-, a Ems. W kL--, lyclisi- 40 64.;_,x4L2
4. (0) ( 7)(C)
l‘A.ANQu3 Otwf ,.,.
Q. Did you strike or make any bodily contact withnlit any time before, during, or after the call to his brother?
A.
65cutAtei
-Mei a" 27- kaa ksuz j ())(,)(c) rr
Page 4 of 6
DOD JUNE 1369
Q. Where did you takelMen he was done calling his brother?
A.
(b)(7)(C)
Q. Describe they lst ING Detention Cell?
A. z11.1.,114, 2 CeL.,s Wc'%—cl et•~1
4 cL.Ct(istr—
Q. Are there any windows in the cell?
A.
Q. WasIllatlex-cuffixl at any time during his interrogations?
Q. Is them a Mosque or sonic type of prayer room in the 501st FIN ING hcadquarters7 If
so, describe the room and its location. itk. ?A-41r,, 9.40d.w. LAOS, dia.c.
ire Nociv," .`"
Q. Wasliallaken to either the Mosque or prayer room during any of his interrogadons or at any time during his detention?
A. az.
Q. Did you provide food and water to bothMillillandlinvhile they were being kept at the 501st BN LNG headquarters?
..
A. fm. AbitiitAte).501-4-4-1.0.4va, t-kaA4-t
ail
IV, 3.40416 ctx,c, 6.14ta ° was responsible for feeding and providing water to both EMBIlind
4.1

(b)(7)(C)
Did u ever punish any other soldiers for trying to help eitherillillor
Km how did you punish these other soldiers?
/001` "ItA, 5bettiii*, o4-M ttal allta
TrA¦L 7:515c.eek,. d .41
Page 5 of 6

DOD JUNE 1370
DODDON001108
Q. What did you haveIMIIIartd EMIG while they were detained at the 501st BN ING Headquarters?
A. (L) (7) ,(3'
‘1 1.-aot" 0-t..04.b4 .
Q. WrzellEgind kept in the same detention location or were they kept apart while they were being detained at the 501st BN Headquarters?
A.
.H :702 )
Page 6 of 6
DOD JUNE 1373.
TAKEN AT
STATEMENT OF
9. STATEMENT fesitt/ .ai
Q. Has die detention cell ever been used byMilles as office? If so, !Awn was it conversed to a &senate cell?
A' az, WITS, Aktex cutdul.yet
VIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME MIS STATEMENT
WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, AND Enos ON PAGE Z. . 1 RALY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE BITIBE STATEMBff MADE
BY ME. ME STATIM IIT 1117NUE. I HAVE WHALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. t HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT NOPE OF SEI BERT OR REWARD, WITHOUT
THREAT OF FUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT comma&

(b)(7)(C)
Ilithsodbed swan Is Was auelon
_L Pod Ibyez7 sdroirdsew oaths. *Is 21, dw Aftilchsi¦ •
.t .
) /(6i
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
RIVALS OF PERSON MAMA STATE EI PAGE 1.,,OF Z PAGE$
AIRF 9. DA MIH 2823, DEC ISM UMW VIA*
DOD JUNE 1372

MOM STATEMENT
For ugg of Sig form we AR 150.43; do roopoilsw goorayN ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT AUTHORITY: Tide 10 USC Sonless 301; Mk 5 USC SoetIon nil: L0.10307 doted Nagsmogg 22. 1543 maw PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To proaido monandorg and Ow erevramgas ofeIgight with anon by which lolcarrotion may b. steunnsty ROUTINE USES; Yaw mini malty waren I. 'slid as age addoialsom000moto Doom, or idseditkedco to *Alta* owe and rodevii.
DOCLOSURE: Dlookom oliosa genii socurlig Number is voluntary.
1. LOCATION Z. DATE irrrratmow 3. TIME 4. FILE NUM11134
Ounp All, Iraq
• OS 4.0.I X5:3 tt
(b)(7)(C) (b)(6) - SSN
(b)(3) -10 USC 130b k_s
(b)(7)(C) WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOW NG STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
Q. Did you anyone (Le. interpreter, family members or sheiks) strike or hit 11111111MBIn any way? Nan, please describe
A.
. Did you havellillotrillit both of theta move rocks annmd Cann, Ali wink they were detained at the 501n BN 9 901 *ID You have which task? .
A. 14
Q. Aftergillivas al* to contact his family on the phone, did you take him InE111111111Sua, yourIMIlloffme, or the Octant= cell?
t
A. %1 m Tibor_ detr
Q. Did you have both of them clean the latrines after using them and pia uP their trach that was left
amide? If

A. tinn
U-Criax.re arb C1.04440 fot
rte,.

when his phone call?
Q. How long have you 411 Camp Ali?
7:1C1

*AMASON.
Q. Were • i0, 111 at Camp All during the construction of the 501st BN ING Headquarters?
A. ICS
;b 11
Q. Did cell have a window in it when the 501n. RN INC Headquarress was ccostricace
A.
v e:111r
Q. Went you involved in the CODURICfiCID of the 501st RN INC Headquarters? If so, in what capacity?

1-4, =1.41,d CRM-hadeci
10. EXHIBIT
11. MAKING armuura I IPA= 1 OF la PAGES
ADOMONIK FAOM saw coNTAIN 771! HIMAWG VTArzsame.TAATN AT.WU, .
107T ON OF EACH ADOMOIL41 PAGEMUST DEAR INFMIMAIS OF ME PERSON AMMO I7E OTATEMOVT, AND PS1GF MAWR
MOST NOE avacATED.
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 DA FORM 21129, JUL 72. IS OBSOLETE
IMAPA V1.00
DOD JUNE 1373
DODDON001111

PUTS • =YTS WARNING reocieuit;
0111•••••••
1NEWA11111110 .
WA1,00!" !Woo tib eeleelefelliObe •b .
'
a. •Yame dada, peel*.. • . • •
rg *deed eV elleelblel..-1•
v.. The feet feet babe b a masesetheetobed.


PIOIITS • Advise doe wheestiesseweed et bedew dolt% se Meese:


Ilektie I aeb se ow lopedows, come meet umbeeteed year slidds."

a.
'Yoe do lees Woe le mower wN speedere ee me eaystdae."

b.
'Asseehlood lee SW or de ere be wed lee Weep• •post Pea b ¦ ,tebrind MA• •

e.
IT* blo•seted e•l** w *a WWI "Ns.* haw lee Met to its *bark lb a berms MAN• du**. ad Mel opetaleabeg 0.4 hew a lb** osemat wet ya . dab, etstedeab• The boyo

'De rets umbleand yerrylehte?"
11 she esseeeeuesiese•d mos 're,' determine whet Is net undereteed. and If

steatesary mem the eppreotime doh& Molummt. N IM ummettmemod rays alk iia feepabo toemeselo
"Ham ••• ever m•estal • Mora OM INIMI seed Tm. lighter tN di. sellteefineekeell a us 'Tee: Awl ow whoa ams when. If ibe moue* woe newel A....feiver *ea 30 &pi spat. rill bps WI** obsboo ern modern the been•oadoe N the itespeetiocested aeoe 'so.' et If *e Rim mom* wee Not nomed. •51 linoher Il fellwahte somirdee.1
WWI 3lY1PeCT/ACCUSIO 1101/313 TO NOM WAIVER CEOTWOCKIE: II the spreeeUestesed walk *elves Geller *Orbs hent meat le Min IM ¦••••• awslam10. ins nay peewee *l . fee somelleseng.. *Me reseduse ea tet weber etedoeme r be Me* Om Wade Me mead Met bebbe tessberemede
bledter •lOhtl, deed no went • bower. awns to deem the oftweelel wafer
Irmoliplam, NW Mums Is 41.1 the mim
IF wanore cenTIRGATE moor re COMMIE* IMINEDLITIFIV: le el arm the webers swam* Raw be eesepbted es seem es p•eeilla beef asst Amid be teepee thempoht Oslo weber oesillbede balers eft seoerdesibe beef*. N tole mime owilIcale seem% be obledleted id •stee. le b *a aft lif
• noel lelestededee. teterleSee *eV be imereltelo oempaere. New eleseld be kept ea the e.sueselesuat.
1 .sseoe eICIIMOINATNO STATuddesT*
I. If the eapeeedeeweed foe rode epentaneeee Inerladembsi reetemeets
Mhos Wed p*Olthsekuid of WI*/ Hobo hebbe should be mkt O•t
each saber ate de net eldheela WAIN to •ew* bet . pasescee.


feffshmelf
• i• !ip • 1••••••••• toirms• Mill ••• same. le ria Oeveliemem es a Isdistre boyar ditalledfor ilea a so *pee= b yes, et belh.•
- ce -Per rhe set ma aiiibef h i flo UAW Tee bra *se Vol it a& *bet* to ¦ waver leetem dudes• and albs queedlasing sod* law • beget pawn wile yew **se er enbeleg. The bosper ens be erne vets amotot kg at my ems ••••••II. II I ••• NOM, anent a harper end memo erne. • feserer lea be appointed Ige yea bakes way gpmedebled beleek.
• d. It yea en RIM MON Se dime* dee offeweeDI mho loveledmiee, aids es .Mas showy*, peare•, pee heves dtde • mop eneseedas 4111111,11st INV Woe, vi. wek pekoe* wilb skew beam istoweelno briber. oven II ewe eta • sabereseddres.•
Mae *Ma the siooselhoweed WIN voisemwde labIlow Wilw.
ME WAIVER
"0e ore went a brow et sbee wee?• Wthe worpeeteeereeed teas "vie: may se Ifeledeekie will Was kern W ept. I the •reepronieeeueed sew "Po." nab IdeeAor 16 0 fel*** W•edee.)
'At thle dee, aro Iwo wive to dhow. the edletrafal seder • end
mobs s •Memen1 MIMEO MIMIrt• • Mims red *thew •OE• • bow Nepal alis Yee' sly the mr•oltalloomodser. Mandmirm• ism Nobbovauf end elm dt. wee oofofe soofon Ike irulow wafts* ot abs 004,440. d thPr Ma. # doe asereeebeemetteep. "kw. elysibpromil MO. SSW MO MEW, ~AM k ser maim oeveNbete lee SW mfr. Ws of Ws fewo.1
• N doe ehodeetheesoted Wee leeelbeted ea Aelft Wee Able* bebop edeleed ot kleNtree deem er mono qesstien abbe es to Ise reprise" , of fee Nps eumemeest, the emend wens be ft adebed. Ito eel e el Ile o-des apse Judge Jidmme• Amid I. ImateaMI ten moidam• b MOM" Ohs mow debts •ereed.
. OTT: N 1 se 2 apples, she but list ten empeeVeseesed wee /Mud erosorarept elbeade lee meld in Ms mamma maim •• are weivw seellicase sod Webbed IT Ow elbeeteemellent
WHIM sysrecT/aciufWIe CoSeLA•E 1111:001111011 011 EMMONS NW OR
WM WARTS DuMb1110IMTERIIOSATION PROCESS: Vierbeg Wu insereepathw let .emcee *paw indwelawt about eirowelbre earned Set exemple. "PrIelles I doruW we • herpor.'1. hying W6661011611MM MOO
Isepeesboele. As deet pal*, ems err %mud= the seerethsegfeed Ado esteeedng vibe** be of she dale* le **be ..sed. The wookiewp way wet be 'rifted N dlowurego a wepoetbrearred hoot weeeleloglulenen WAse. Spit essesees. IS sot ;Nig web easenteeW lee IP w• Adel de anything may, mu
Memblet aril M MIMB••..1
•REVERSE .OF DA FORM 3881 PUVA V2.01
DOD JUNE
1374
DODDON001112

WARNING PROCEDUREPHAIVER ClicIroptTE

*Stoma Perot we All ISIP-MIS Do pswpoplat opoor
RATA 11001$1160 BY THE MOVACT•ACT
Armoury% This ID. WIWI WNW Cod% Section 30124) PRIMPAL 'Mom to prowl& 5....m* deg and law wiftwownwst 'officials WIN wawa by weigh for onnytion may be actaximly ki¦gdped mounts masa
'yam ;paid Seawitf Rumba is used se an addlearairsitenuote wawa a( iclawillesiku. ID Wawa Nog NW raidaval, OISCLOSURE:.Obslostro o$ your Dodd South, *mew is vokootogY.
a. . Pia NO.
i. LOCATION
egkey Zokrrmak Till i.100'' S-
161 11 01)4
1
(0 ,'1 3) -10 USC 130h N?• e vi, ell
(b)(6) - SSNJ t» 7)IC)
PART 1- ISMS WANEMION-WANIDI CERTIFICATE
Birliwo A- IEBIDIo
..a
Anti ¦ '..)11:31 -10 1 ,:-, C. 1 '-'(`,11
Tow im•••••••• wan. 11111110 wove blow ear nowtha Wale le with ihm Wise *Wm ha
mod *said mo grothe as Orrdr therwbgailia•ths1 ehebieb I arm apipsaxwasommdt Were WAD weed ••• mg embers abed -----
the Warawts). binvever. MAW meth If deer *melbaI arm go adiram. 'We:
I. I Mt ea Woe ool wow* my gr••ima w vat elrfther•
2. hafebby I war er de mu bowed ea IVakilloOD wire Er by . etb•led MEL
a PorpoloolosooMytot MN PC1 I haw the AM rte! _0*sup a r• INIVillt WOOL defy, red Wow spackle's' NW or awe • bow presemt wile gm

Mao wood wing. ITN Worm we No a Wallin Wow, I wawa* Ir st n• maws. ao woo Dowalarat or a WNW tem,* dialing/ for me at is esporpor* ow. wawa-
•w -Ow chows woo aalikaa at saa LW 1 Mew Iloo split is wok FTIvehoy N. slipover 110,5S, Wolosj. woll Wow weallsoips awl ea haw claw.. pre volia me *.1s ,._Sewing. I areserfred Owl 01. WAN/ ow be ow der 1 romp fir as.wqr thew ompemer. re 0 I gassoof effe•d 4 legirpr ••• weal mow. • IPIMPIR moil bel erpthobm1 for the fralfere enr irwledie• Mr Ins. If I we weer wn.arle imam the Wiwat aw b•bbor wiltaut *Wryer anieent, thaw a ,111 th seep amevrethro ••••••¦• el awl thole, er
4 Nosmgre•th•••• Bu .pd "WNW, Valli Dower Moro swamoNg Whir. wag li I .i W. wither Wow.
coairieffill to/ maw* wo wow,
emotion S. Waiver
1 martand art NOW as swag AWN. Isra aro May te datum the effe•••fei rod* lifthithifles ,ltd meths • erefe••• palm, *Oily ie aim,* OR eat* wawa Irene • ker. •••••• *NI ma
wrotesses IN eavaahlal
in. NAME /TM* er PAW

(b) (7)(C)
......_
-a.+.-T1+1'+
b. ORGANIZADON OR A13011Blit AND PHONE

(b)(7)(C)
2a NAII1 (1)... or Ptivtl.
IMENMIIIIIIIMM
b. 0110•NIZATION OR AMU= AND MODE . . . .. . . . .. ..
II_ / I ?, 1 -, CI lt:-2.,C, 13i1) Guy .,±1piplip
Soolon C. Noorwavor
1. t de am wen te Swop ow drift
O.I worn it Worm 0 I as not wait to ay gormismoi at NW aiNollai
INSDASUPIa DP INTINNewn
ArrActi THIS aunt Wagon To ANY SWUM STEW
EfirdIT IDA 111/111 2,211 sUinimulintv EXECUTED FT re aerecrAccuso
EDMON OF NOV 84 II (4110119I UI4M Let
DOD JUNE 1375

DODDON001113

tr. ...No WI WY M1110. NM of o 1.14..14ij vie onmonent agency ts UU1.750P8
MACY ACT STATOMINT AUTHORITY: Tide 10 USC Seetion 301; Tide 5 USC Seedon 2951: E.O. 9397 doted November 22. 1943 ISSN. PIUNCOAL PURPOSE: To !provide oommanders and law enfomment offIciele with meow by which "demotion may be eteuremy ROUT= USE Your =NM etemoNY number h used es an addltionellelterrwee mow of identification to teolltale Sem and retrieve'.
DISCLOSURE: 0110108010 Of Velar social number is voluntary. DA 4. FILE NUMBER
w""Nfil, Atz TM' fritaFc
• . • •
(b)(7)(C) (b)( 6 ) - SSN ( b )( 7 )( C ) b 3) - 10 USC 130t)
MIT TO MAKE TIN FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OAT%
(b)(7)(C) te. IP% 1AL A.nskx.,) ces.i4 /eiiht.vstA
10. comm. 11. INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT I
PAGE 1 OF , PAGES

all••••••¦••¦•=1/10
ADDITIONAL PAM MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT - TAKEN AT .DATED
ME 1107770M OF EACH ADDMONAL PAGE MUST SEAR THE .UTL4LS OF THE PERSON PAAMPIO THE STATE:10DYT, AND PAGE NUMBERMUST SE SE mucAreo.
DA FORM 2923, DEC 1998 DA FORM 2823. JUL 72. IS OBSOLETE IMAM VLOO

DOD JUNE 1376
DODDON001114

• • ••¦•410.• • •
S. STATEMENT iContinvadi
(b)(7)(C) VIT
I. , HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT
WHICH BEGINS ON P , AND DM ON PAGE RI . 1 FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MAW
BY ME. THE STATEN IS TRUE. I HAVE INMALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE *STALED THE 'arrows OF EACH PAGE
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FRIBELY OR REWARD. WITHOUT



THREAT OF PUNISHMENT. AND wrniour COERCION. upaAwFu
INITNESSER
odinaviollfOMh., We day of oo.1-1( . 2e09

ORGANIZATION OR ADORERS

(b)( 7)(c)
1 T/1rii'lphi. * C
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS roa4ority Atkin/nor Oatbs.0

INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE .OF OZ PAGES .
PAGES, DA AM 2123. CRC ?SW 12111A.A V1410
DOD JUNE 1377
DODDON001115
ILT Hagan Statement - 19 Aug 04
Q. Did you ever strikellinalwith any part of your body? Wm, how did you strike
him?
A.
Q. Did you ever use an electronic shocking device on any part o t any
time? of his body did you use the device on?

A.
Q. Did you see anyone use an electronic shocking device on any part ofrliEllat
any pat of his body did you see the shocking device being used on?

I- (7);C,
(H7)iC )
ou see jumping on MEM Where did this take place?
Q. Did you have any physical contact with
quest' • • ? if so, please describe the incident.

A. .
)
Page 1 of 6
DOD JUNE 1378
DODDON001116
Q. Did you have any physical contact witl on the day you turned him in to
the Ar Rmnadi Detention Facility'? If so, glean deem* the incident.

A. ottiq urteA 4itci• 1 A ,i kid
'Al AMA* to,`
n
Q. How long did you demi
Detentiag 7

Q. How and where wasEinidetained until being turned over to the Ar Ramadi
Detention Facility?
t

taieOzem cLirifyA,*kat matt-)
he Ar Rimadi Detention facility? Discuss the
Q. How did you transportliangessa

vintraIYOMADA ifti-k0. oak
Aug kiwi-II-v.0 gm
, alion't a(eici era
the Ar Rimadi Detention
tkkb 413[0.1S
Q. Did anyone strike IlliMiefore, during„ or after being transported to the Ar
Rome& _ _ aciliv?

A.
Q. Did you ever stultellilivith any part of your body? If so, what but of your body
did you

A.
Q. Did you ever we an electronic shocking device on any port orillind. any time? If
so, y did you use the shocking device on?

A.
Page 2 of 6
DOD JUNE 1379
DODDON001117
Q. Did you see anyone use an electronic shocking device on any part ofillilat any
of the body was the shocking device used on?

t7 11C1
Did Cr';i1J. at any tiny during his questioning?
Q.
A.
4 Ln-1 I
Q. Did ne on any time during his questioning?
A.
a. •.ay I .a
Q. Ifs° see jumping on Where did this take place?
A.
ir) , (7)'C
• .Tr.7".4 717777. • -• tat BN ING H
Q.
»17 ) (C)
A. (b)(7)(C) n (b)(7)(C) *kW a
Q. Did you have any physical contact witlaMliefore, during,, or after ? If so, please describe the incident
Q. Did you have any physical contact withillion the day you turned him in to the Ar Rawadi Detention Facility? If so. lease describe the incident.

ott.Vd
vut OcklikilmW ! (b)( 7 )(C)

Q. How long did you deist Detention Facility?
A.

i
Q. How and where wasillinetained until being turned over to the Ar Ranuzdi Detention Facility?
A-'44 W.C1 ?)1\ ICUS lat
. 100M M tall) ea%
f

a Voa l gux
wt
Page 3 of 6
DOD JUNE 1380

Q. How did you transportMo the Ar Ramedi Detention amity? Discuss the
AhlseZZAPa= (Ji) QYIk. otkiu tiat IAA), Vol* .A‘6 Aplea WrIU &IV ,kki Qui
4.e.0 idt -Alatak cui tikun
Q. Did an 'k ore, during, or aft being transported to The Ar Ramadi
Q
trttetw4 wtS;IIIT "n'tiot
rtviod . (kkill tied-Nu() tvootul wow .kao CLAWYi We. elf MCA? DUXi-01-11 UV. YLUMA tit Ulu).tb-i k93 td 0-t
Q. Did you ;ace or make any bodily contact witaillat any time before, during, or
. Jr%
(1.,m7)(c)
Page 4 of 6
DOD JUNE. 1381
Q. What did you have nd do while they wen, detained at the 501st.
MA* uattUstA atieR -VARVIUSCOlt 1-iia.gl-tRf iroik4kkal t&t.b futtd, (b)(7)(C)
Q.. Were the :erne detention ktention or were t eY
while they wescor epi

(b)(7)(C)

Page 6 of 6
DOD JUNE 1382
done calling his brother?
'be the 501st INGQ -Mention Cell? MTh kD1
OR.

II le1614.1 IV V
Arc in the cell?
A. (b)(7)(C) -cuffed at any time during his interrogations?
A. (b)(7)(C)
Q. Is there a Mosque or some type of prayer room in the 501st HN INC1 headquarters? If
so, desert the mom ts Waddi.i
A-.P., WWI a bi
ti

en to either the Mosque or prayer room during any of his y time during his detention?
Q. Did you provide food and water to bot (b) (7) (C) lie they were kept at the 501st BN G headquarters it
3 Nab a ib)(7),C)
—a a I
. Who was responsible for water to both ( b C) and
A.
CIO (b)(7)(C) (h ))(7)(C)
•ou ever punish any other soldiers for trying to help eithmilill or If so„hpw did you sh the other soldi
oa Nam (kitu

. tw-k kum ikt

ok.amq \itui\O.

?age 5 of 6
DOD JUNE 13 83
SWORN STATEMENT For use of Ms tem. we AR 190-4E: the popsmsret moony Is 011CSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
AUTHORITY: Mho 10 UM Emptiest 301: TM* 1$ 1100 Swats 2011; 5.0. 02//7 Mod November 22. 11143 ISM
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: T. provide sonwnendoes and law sntwornant vela mews by ibliah lakweallon way be taarunittay
ROUTINE USW. Yew mid wow/ft number is used es an addltistaiistesnwit awns 01 Ideralthatkot twatete sod retheyal.
DISCLOSURE: Dielsowe of yew 'odd sobwIly_numbat Is wigwam

1, LOCATION 2. OA 3. ril!
4. FILE EILISSER
Camp All, Iraq eft
cigTommali
(b)(7)(C ) (b)(6) - SSN :b)(7)(C)
-10 :1SC ;')OE & • . C.! fd
-,...
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATBAENT UNDMI DATN:

(b)(7)(C)
maw interpostor, family members or sheiks) strike or hit 111111orilealn any way? If wt. please
both of dams =NC rocks around Camp Ali while they were detained at dm 501st BN
you ve do which task?
the phone, did you take him 15N 7)( C ffIce, or die
dfire,
Q. How lams hag •otcp1
A. tha
Camp Ali during the ccestructioa of the 501st BN IRO Headquarters?
a window in it WWI the 501st SN INC Headquattas was constructed?
(b)(7)(C)
Q. Was rsu involved la die Ilesciguseters? If so, in what capacity? A ke 11) cett3 ti • 0 V'1 1l` (b)
(7) (C )
all ever been used for eneffice bYalins en office? If so, when was it converted to a detention
10. 100iairT 11. 1NMALS
PIG STATEMENT b ( 7) t U PAGE 1 OF th PAGES
A0121770441 /146211 MIST CONTAVI ME4111/18 'STA MONT .WSW AT.
adrat .
ME BOTTOM Of EACH ADDITIONAL FAGE NWT SEAR THE 'MAU OF THE POVSON AMMO 17E STAMM; ANO PACE AVNERMSTOF FIVICA
DA FORM 2023, DEC HMS DA FORM 21122. AR 72. NI ONSOLETE MANI V1.011
DOD JUNE 1384
DODDON001122
STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED
S. STATEMENT (Continued)
AFFIDAVIT
HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH SEGMS ACE 1. AND ENDS ON PAGE . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE ST ME. THE STATEARNT IS TRUE. I HAVE SST ALL CORRECIIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM QF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREE.Y WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD. WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT. AND WITHOUT COERCION, MIA

(b)(7)(C)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(b)(7)(C)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS t T MAO
IMTIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEN! 0:»(7) (c) PAGE a OF a PAGES
PAVE) DA PORIA 2823. DEC TM MAI% vt .00
DOD JUNE 1385
DODDON001123

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of This fawn. sea AR 190-49; the pieseramI MINN Is ODCSOPS

PRNACY ACT IITAIEMBff AUTHORITY' 7111e 10 USC &maw 301; Nee 5 USC Section 2951; EO. 9347 sated November ra, 1943 MN). PRINCPAL PUTIPODE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officiate with means by which information may be accurately SWUM UM; Your social security member is wad an en etklitIoneasItemet• means of Mentiffeation to teeilitam filing and estnews. DOCLOBLIPA: Disclosure of your mob* sweeilY ambler it vol unary. 1_ LOCATION 12. DATE NYVINATIDE9 I3. 4, RLE NUMBER
Camp Rama& Imq 1004/08/ 19 TIM2120E MIDDLE NAME l8. *MN 7. (b)(7 )(C) -SbN
• nc...c. ... .
, Iraq APG, AE 09394
• INEE111.11_, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNGER OATIF.
On 19 Aug 04, I was ittftamed t, MC) I was bring imeirta•cd to mopes a rusk= 15-6 invealigatial Mat 1 hadconducted. As I case, decOVered tint I was included in mend of the alleged incideats. At191600A to determine my cptahfications or disqualifications for this 15-6 in
that 1 wait proscat when the *aim fist manned to was in the room and asked several gondolas. At no ume durmg the When. it was determined that family m gm the 'money of the MOM by placing ah arm and shoulder. bid for the on 1 was cominetng. I then m Camp -I ha be dlspaitaI was also not presets tbr say adthdonal questioning of to Camp Ali
10. EXHIBIT 11. INMALO
ING STATEMENT
PAGE 1 OF :2-PAGES
(b)( 7)(C;
ADDITIONAL PAGES war currrAIN TIE HEADING 'STATEMENT .TAKEN AT - DATED
THE BOTTOM OE EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUSTBEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING SIA7EMEN7. AND PAGE NUMBER
6/147 BE OE MICATED,
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS 013130(2USAPA V1.01)

'."=T
DOD JUNE 1386
DODDON001124

fmllwr•m.¦.¦
.uir•••¦•• ¦¦•mmwIL=m==nklsm"°•"wmmo,...r•waIIIAIL.I..STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED
9, STATEMENT ICwrimnfl
AFFIDAvif

(b)(7)(C)
t. . HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1. AND ENDS ON PAGE I. . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE COP/TENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT Kt TRUE. I HAVE DATIALED ALL CORRECTORS AND HAVE INHALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD. WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT. MD WITHOUT COERCION. UNLAWFUL
&SNOW and mom ID roe mo, • Dimon out/wind by low to
sdrninistet oalhe4 eft _IL-de, 1$1"rf ,0
(b)(7)(C)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(b)(7)(C)
ORGANzATtoN OR ADDRESS -¦•••••• -151-ro rAf kfluznancy To Adminfater Oatial
¦••¦•¦•¦
norms OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE OF 2_, PAWS
PAGE 3, OA FORM 2.23, DOC IMM no% VIA°

DOD JUNE 1387
DODDON001125

Doc_nid: 
2945
Doc_type_num: 
66