Formica Report Annex 120: Command Investigation (Death of Farhad Mohamed Ali, April 4, 2004)

07 APR 04
From: LT IIIMONION To: Commander, Navel Special Warfare Task Group
Subj: PRELIMINARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH 0111111111111111.111
Ref: (a) JAOMAN Section 0204
L • This reports completion of the preliminary inquiry conducted in accordance withreference (a) into the events surrounding the death of while in the custody ofiNMS11/11111111111111111111
2. Personnel contacted (all contact info is DSNANNIIIIM DWAINE.):
lip
LCDR, .SEAL TeanrllIllb LTC, CISOTF Surgeon, pi LT, AOIC, SEAL T , , AOIC, SEAL Team
HMCS, TU LCPO, SEAL Tor
CS, PLT LCPO, SEAL Team
GM, TU Interrogator, SEAL Team
• HM1, Platoon Corpsman, SEAL T
ICI, Detainee Guard, SEAL Tess
Platoon Corpsman, SEAL T
ITZ. TU Interrogator, SEAL Teems

111-1102, Platoon Corpsman, SEAL T
IT3, Detainee Guard, SEAL Team

3. Materials reviewed:
CONOPs I .44 Co, on Summary SSE Item Inveaoo NSW Detainee Receipt f
c
Interrogation and Couhter-Resistance
C
Detainee Medical Screening Sheet (02 APR 04)
SF 558 Emergency Care and Treatment Form (05 APR 04)
SF 600 Chronological Record of Medical Care (OS APR. 04)

Sworn Statement from
bLO
Sworn Statement from
Sworn Statement from
Sworn Statement from
Sworn Statement from

„sioRmispigatti--3
Fermin Report •Ards*x 120
.
3131
DOD JUNE
Sworn Statement from 411111.111111118
4..Summary of finding: conducted mission.'".1 - 4(.0.1)
the es ti morning•ours of 02 APR 04. 14-0 Including were detained on unto slang wi 6 Ry. emembled Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs), a large quantity of MD component auttaial, 27 grenades, and numerous explosive bons.
-During approximately 64 hours of detention and . 1,4(A)
personnel followed all procedures outlined in bo.Irdenogation and
Counter-Resistance Polley and
Interrogation end Comate-Resistance Policy At regular intervals,
fully qualified 18D corpsman took the detainee s and documented this
information, none of which was °aside healthy parameters.
41111111111gained significant actionable intelligence from the questioning of .1.41Co%
both deudned AI members. .A, .4-R, .

exldbited signs oil:dense dilates: and extremely unusual . behavtor.bis.Maly based on the stress of detainment and the fact t,.464 that 1hit verY eomnattedllil member had provided *climb!, intelligence during
his detainment.
-At OSOIO4CAPRO4, apptoximately thirty minutes prior to the detainee's andiac arrest, his body core temperature wad measured at 97:5 &pees Flinadmit Nee within normal parameters). Based on this body temperature, both HMS
•
. ARM Vitircided out the possibility that the detainee was even .
12C-0
mildly hypothermic at time of his cardiac wart. medical history, previous health sad exact age.10 ate all unknown at this pant. Ids reported age of27 Yam old filmed os
infornuttion pined during his intaroption, and given his pattern of providing misleadireg or false information when given the chance, is of questionable
-According to LTCIIIIIIbthcre have been a surprising number of cardiac .kso (A°
Problems, balance the anent full cardiac arrest of an Iraqi citizen in bit mid-30s,
vthieh have muted kthevicinity of Mosul. Ilse health demographics of young
to iniddlouged Iranian zanies are complaelymiknown at this time.

-Prior to the detainee's caulks oast at.0137C, he was wrapped in two blankets
and laying hy a fue in preparation foihis futal medical screening and turnover to

the Stryker Brigade holding facility.
-After the deednee's cirdiac arrest, be vies attended bY five 1 CI =Poem and.
• 12 Li")
the QOM Surgeon (LICIIIIIRMID, who had full accas to all necessary modal% medical equipment in. a nearby aid station.
,---SECRIFFOOPORN--
orrnica Report - Annex 120
3132
DOD JUNE
11111111
LT USN
FIRST ENDORSEMENT Caesar with reconmeodetiou
X.
Other:

1111Mt„
AIM
ormica Report - Annex 120
DOD JUNE 3133
12 Apr 04
• From: LT, J USR
Arinimumume
To:

Offic r,

Subj: PRELIM/NARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH OF FABBAD MOHAMED ALI

Ref: (a) JAGMAN Section 204

1. Pursuant to section 204 of reference (a) r have
preliminary inquiry (PI) conducted by LT
regarding the subject above. I found that
vestigation was thorough and expedient.

•
•
armies Report Annex 120
3134
DOD JUNE

Subj: PRELIMINARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH OF

e•
6(0
•
ormica Report - Annex 120
IMP
MI
OM MINIMMI

DOD JUNE 3135
NSVITGAPaJAG
OF eleirl
ar:32 P
Cc: (GPI JAG)Subject: 'Pfellnilnery RE Deb Death
Classification: 5•E•Cirri,-
Caveats: NONE

NONE
vested that I forward you the 10 on the pntilminary investigation on the detainee's dean In Mesa 120)

eingreq
s my written recommendation. COR the Witte enclosures and bdn them Is
sal
b (000) C-4160
Finely. the CID told
WV'
LT to)
Prelim inner" 07 MG
APR Kea Iseawnenctstion.da

•
^asiliOrt:rti.KET
Caveats: NONE

• I
orrnica Report - Annex 120
I I I
DOD JUNE 3136
NSWTGAID, JAG

NFL

sugpcG
Classification: gEr...Reor-
Caveats: NONE

Enclosed with this e-mall is my endorsement of LT . Ingot Into the detainee's death In Mosul. On a
related note, I contacted CID In Mosul Let me now W you.to discuss anythkg
Vh

JAG.
JAG
Inclonternertdoc

Attachment Classification:.t.
Attachment Caveats: NONE
Classification: a/ CIEX
args: NONE

•g
•
•
°Fmk= Report -Annex 120
.
DOD JUNE 3137
Page I of 4
NSWTGAP JAG
Op Fran:_
CJ1}7•.1A
Sent: Thursday, Apdi 08, 2004 2:18 PM
To:

1/11111/11111.A0;4111/11~//111.
Cc:
Stet
WA;.

Chief of SSW
JAG)
Subject: RE: Update on Detainee Death Irwesa0eddrutSECRE4-

LIAM
Thank—s

— for the update. Critical issue, based on my time in this theater and responses to other
inquiries of this nature, is a thorough investigation. I think that issue Is well in hand now.
----orictnd
Suit Thursday, Awl OS, 2004 at4:08
m
To;
aassiseatkaa
Caveats: NONE

Sir,
• S/23/2004
ormica Report - Annex 120
313 8
DOD JUNE
Page 2-of4
SO
• 5/23/2004
DOD JUNE
—Original Message-FromlM111.1.111SM OIC IlosaoliaraMaNallINO
Sent.
Apfil 07, 2004 6:50 PMTo:.
CITF7-53A
Provo St Marsha.

0101111.111.1. tidal d Stet CHIEF OF STAFF­

min we%
Chief of Star-
DEP COR Su RE Death Myatt
Sin it is our understanding that NOS personnel are on their way here to Irreestigate. OurCID aro now only assisting with the ifteatigatIon by Mid% statements of the detachment Personnel before they re-deploy and potentially coordinating the autopsy. v.g)(
assistance. LTC
Mardsge--
FroaulgolmilleaTP7-SIA
Sent Widen*, April 07, 2004 4:35 PM

T
()IC Provost
imif;
Chief of Staff;_DEPUTY OIIEF OF AfF•
SIA
Subject: RE: Detainee Death InvestlgatemASSERE47 -4-¦

e
ase see my most recent e-mails. This represents the most currentinfo that I have received from CID and LT
Frew
Naito
Sent:.

Aprli 07, 2004 0E53 SIA Ole
CG
Provost Marshal (E-mail •
ADMIN LAW E-mail);
Chiti of
Staff
CHIEF OF STAFF;
SJA
Subject: Detainee Death Inestlgetbn (3eCRS"­
Importance: High
r­
416011111PA191FORINk* tA•
-haw 120
3139
Page 3 of 4
ClassificatIonArsONER-•
Caveats: NONE
1111111111111111
Sir,
I was up In Mosul for the lest couple of days, but I returned b Bachdai today. £m sorry that my schedule did not allow me to swing by your once *tile I was them (though I did meet LTC111110. your PM). Here's an update on the status at the detainee dealt investigation:
Pease keep me updated from your end, and ES do the same eam here­
vfr,
tIw 1111111.11.110
Staff Judge Advocate
•• 5/23/2004
-1111CRIBM40160101--
ormica Report - Annex 120
3140
DOD JUNE
DOD056956
Page 4 of4
D8N (ale) 2304273 --0 final.-
SIP
Prow.
SIA OK Cm& Sent Wednesday, Aore 07, 2004 11:07 AM
TotellinmiliAG OIC Dc anommerme 83A; MIN 8:08;(111111.111
(MNI.N) Provost Marshal Subject Detsinee Issue
Phone kee me posted. Thanks
•100,)
dassifeabon: SESIttr"--
Caveats: NONE

Canaltattoo: Stimtrr
Caveats: NONE

p
• 5/23/2004
ormice Report -Annex 120
3141
DOD JUNE
Pagel of 4
MI!

Frown 4111111111111111.1AG Sent Thursday, AO 08, 2004 12:08 PM CAM'
Tc:.
Cc:_ Provesttlarshat tAw; STAFF; CO._SJA Of 0 SJA 01C;1•0111111111C477 "BiN; Mg of Staff' TIEF AMAIN UTY CHIEF OF Chief of slit:
0

Subject Update on Detainee Death investigation meefterr Classification: SECRET Caveats: NONE
Sir,
I Just returned from Mosul. Hwe is the latest on ale Detainee Death Investigation:
•
Wr
LT A
1. .
—Original Hesse e—•
Pm°.. SA DE (flialba../.11.1.1.1111.

Sent: Wednesday, Apd107, 2004 6:58 PM Ec ol.($14
Tai. TF7-50,
ta. Provost Marshal 01C;

Mil EF ADMIN LAW*. OEPUTY
JAG;.die of Stuff'.
CHIEF OF STAFF ,. SU;.SIA;. Chief of Walt DEP COR Subject RE: Detainee Death Investigation 4666REF)--
Sri. it is our understanding that NCIS personnel are on their way here to investigate. Our OD are

40 5/23/2004 --8EGREVINOWORNI--
orrnkm Ropost - Annex 120
3142
DOD JUNE
DOD056958

Page 2of4
now only assisting with the investigation by taking statements of the detachment flannel before
they re-deploy and poWntlelly coordinating the autopsy. 6 cs)(0)
OD Therefore, we have no outetencingissues for C/TP-7. Thanks for the assistance.
--WOW Mange--
Frani SIMMINIMINIIIII•SM
Sent.., April 07, 2004 4:35 PM

To:.•
SM OIC
Ccs
Provost MarshaMIIIIIIMIMS C.17F7•CHIEF AMIN LAW:AG•.
A=1114:110Chief of SUM CHIEF OF Sr. SM Subiect RE: Detaktee Death Investigation4SECRED
IIIIb
Please see my most recent e-malls. This represents the most current info
that I have received from CID and
"—OriginalMessage—
rionuallINNISM Eillea0a../1/11111111/111111111111MMI
Sent Wednesday, Neil 07, 2004 Ma

b (0)1.4a
To:. SM OIC Millell Marshal; Inaitit ff ;eF Lralla
.sta awn Dem,
(E-maif);.chief CRS' OF STAFF. Sie Subject Detainee Death Invesugadon4Sellterr
Importaace: High
Classiticatbw.SEGRer
Caveats: NONE
I was up in Mosut for the cast couple or days, but I returned to Sechdad today.
rm sorry ihat my schedule did not allow me to swing by your office while I was there(though I did meet LTC110111b. your PM). Here's en update on the status of the
detainee death inveatigebon: .•
•• 5/23/2004
-410Rwrimorai
ormIce Roport - Annex 120
.
3143
DOD JUNE
Page 3 of 4
immummEmp

'
Moose keep me updated from your end, and ra do the ammo form here. Wr,
v, (0)
Staff Judge Advocator.
1. (A)
alli"11
.11111
DM (315) 2304275
--Original Message--

From
SM OIC
----1•••••••¦•=mmigml
Sent: Wednesday, April 07, 2004 11:07 All
Tcnalmmusw 0IC
Cc:.
Provost Marshal SMAINIIIP
Subject: Detainee Issue

(.5
(474,
5/23/2004
4111911aMonner t¦, Ars= 120
DOD JUNE 3144
Pqe 4 of 4
boca.v#5
11111111111111111.11.11.
00_ 6(0
zierimPme "tad ihmti°34.1111111111111.11.1"
Classification: s=eller Caveats: NONE
Classification: SPeelitt&T" Caveats: NONE
• 583/2004
440110120

3145
DOD JUNE
CO) -D02.

o.00 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY.• TO' IMP DITlinenta OD) U111110 STATES AMSY COMM IMATITISATION COMMAND
LSA DIMIONDEACK - MOSUL, MAO APO AZ SSIM4111:1 •
asPLY To
ATTMilais OF

.
CIRC-WBE (195-2) 15 May 2004
MEMORANDUM FOR: SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION —FINAL-REFERRED -4111MIMMINS .
4,V 1 11:1(31
4181•1121111110
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1. 5 Apt 2004/0200 — 5 Apr 200410215; Special Operations Carapace, LSA
Diamondbac ic. Mosul, Iraq
DATEITIME REPORTED: S Apr 2004„ 1700
INVESTIGATED BY: SA. BA k7
SUBJECT: 1. (NONE) [UNDETERMINE DENIM]
=Mk 1.11
(DECEASEDMINENSIMINI IRAQI;
CIV; M; MUTE; XZ (NFD) !UNDETERMINED DEATH!
INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY:
"'This is an Operation Iraqi Freedom Investigedon"
This office was Ratified by Mortuary ATMs, Mosul, that the rerosins of an Iraqi denim* had
been delivered by 67° Combat Support Hospital ((S/1) personnel.
Investigation disclosed Mr.was detained kalliliallaglibenound and
subsequattly ineropted, During the sensing of S Apr 04, Mr 4111111110 was allowed to
seep and when checked Navy corpsmen was found to be unresponsive. Mal
we transported to the 6? CSH where he received emergency medical are. MrallgEM

was unable to be revived and subsequeudy died of unimown canes.
•
On 26 Apr 04, an autopsy of the remains of.was conducted by LTC (Dr)
4111111111111111811111111 USAF, Deputy Medical Examiner, Ma of the Armed Forces Medical
Examiner (DAME), Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AM), Roalcville, MD. DANN
meted the cause and moaner of death were both =determined with no obvious signs of a

homicide nor of a name death.
FOR OFFICIAL USE °ICY
.
3146
DOD JUNE
b
CIRC-WBE
SUBJECT: QD REPORT OF INVESTIGATION -FINAL-REFERRED

On 11 May 04, the Naval Criadnil Investigative Setvice (N•i), accepted investigative responsibility for this snifter. STATUTES: N/A EXHIBTTS/SUBSTANT1ATION: Animated:
1. Agent's Inveldgation Report (AIR) of SA111.11 12 May 04, Mailing Initial notification; coordination with Morality AM,. Provost MAMA Sad Totettara_
.LT 41111111111 NCIS, and CW .interviews of SPO MMa¦111 IRKS111.1.111.. am.LM
IIIMCS WM. death scene
CPTAIIIIAIMund
eitaminetiotc and antapsy•

2.
Certificate of Death (Overseas), S Apr 04, pertaining to Mrd

3.
PhotottloPkiePacketof 23PhetolicePhe• 04411111111111110

4.
Packet containing trek meters, medial information, and SIllteMentl obtained flaw

Seal
Tangy,

5.
Waiver Certificate and Sworn Statement of HM2 .1 7 Apr 04, Midas he provided treatment to Mr.41.11.6dier he went into mediae crest.

6.
Sworn Somme of 1041.11111111. 7 Apr 04, Wain he meshed in flee Prigal"110110Thettt of

7. Sworn Statement ofilM14111., 7 Apr 04, relating he administered primary aid ID
IL Sworn Statement ofIBMCSANI.O. 7 Apr 04, misting he was oa duty when Mr 4111111111. went into max wrest.
9.
Waiver Certificate and Sworn Statement of GM'_ 7 Apr 04, Mating bewee on detainee vestdi while Mrd was in custody.

10.
Sworn Statement of LTC (Dr.)... $ Apr 04, relating he provided primary llocarerd tomr aglINni after be west into cardiac anew.

11. Death mein *etch, i Apr 04, prepared by SAdigai
•
--#011CRITCROPMer

.
3147
DOD JUNE
Oil

CIRC.WBE
SUEUECT: CID REPORT OF INVESITOATION -FINALAUIFERRED -4•8110111111•111111111

12.
Photographic packet comprised of I I photographs. (scene)

13.
Compact disk,1111111111111 contabdng °demob of Exldbits 3 and 12.

Not Attecbed: None.
The originals of Exhibits 1 sod 5-11 are forwarded with the NCIS copy of this report. The
original of Exhibit 2 is retained In the files of the 67 6 CSH. The originals of Ebdsibit 4 are
retained In the Elea of Beet Taman Coroaado, CA.

STATUS: Ns is s Final Referred Report prepared lAW CZDR 195-1, Nail-logo in that the Army cu) does not have the primary investigative responsibility and NCIS has accepted reheat
of this investigation.
Report Prepared By RoPort APProvol
diUMNISM.
411n1.1111111NMIND
Special Agent, 6079. Special Agent in Charge
DISTRIBUTION:
I - Dleccaor, USACRC
1- NCIS Field Office Middle East, PSC 451, FPO AB 09:34-2800 (origineb)
1- THRU: Commander, 2271 MP ESN (CID) (FWD), Baghdad. Iraq

THRU: Commander, ra MP Group (CID), Ft Olikim, GA
TO: HQUSACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-COP, 6010 66 Street, pee Belvoir, VA 22060
1- Director, OAFME, ARP, Rockville, MD 20850
1- Chief of Stott TFO (e-mail only, less addbita)
1- SIA, SECT (e-mali only, Ism exhibits)

-PMO, SECT (e-mall only, lens exhibits)
I -File

•
•
ormica Roixnt - Annex 120
3148
DOD JUNE
07 APR 04
From: LT
To: Commander, Naval Special Warfare Task Group

Subj: PRELIMINARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH OFEINIEma
Ref (a) IAOMAN Section 0204
1. This reports completion of the preliminary inquiry conducted in accordance with
reference futionsi=homm
the events.• the death of while in the custody o.
2. Personnel contacted (a11 contact info is DSN4111111111111111111 DNv1411111111)
LCDR, .SEAL Tasman
LTC, camp Surgeon, LT, AOIC, SEAL T AOIC, SEAL Team
}UMW LCPO, SEAL Tar CS, PLT LCPO, SEAL Team OW , TU Interrogator, SEAL Team 1111111111111111 HMI. Platoon Corpsman. SEAL T
Wiu,
ICI, Detainee Guard, SEAL T
Platoon Corpsman. SEAL T ITZ TU Interrogator, SEAL Team}wz Platoon Corpsman, SEAL T
04.
IT3, Detainee Guard, SEAL Team
3. Materials reviewed:
I • 4-1 Co.,
CONOPs on Summary
NSW Detainee Receipt f "'an lay Interrogation and Couhter-Ftesistance Policy,
Detainee Medical Screening Sheet (02 APR 04) SF 558 Emergency Care and Treatment Form (05 APR 04) SF 600 Chronological Record of Medical Care (OS APR 04) Sworn Statement front Sworn Statement from Sworn Statement from Sworn Statement front Sworn Statement from
Fmk. Repot •Annex 120
3149
DOD JUNE
• 4.
•
•

DOD JUNE

Sworn Statement from 4111///0
Summary of conducted ntissaon.t .4(0))
the ear monies-hours of 02 APR 04. T . 'vL 1 including .we detained on target along with assembled improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs), a large quentity of DID component material, 27 grenades, and 11LtalUOINI explosive items.
-During approximately 64 hours of detention and • . . 4 (4personnel followed all procedures outlined in Interrogation and Counter-ResistanCe Policy Interrogation and Counter•Resistance Policy .At regular intervals,fully qualified 1$D corpsman took the detainee's .and documented this information, none of which was outside healthy parameters. -11111111111pined significant actionable intelligence from the questioning ofboth detained AI members...
exhibited signs Air:tense distress
tress and extremely unusual behalf=.his.likely based on the stress of detaimnent and the feetthat this very member bad provided actionable intelligence during
his detainment
-At 050104CAPR04, approximately thirty minutes pier to the detainee's anise serest, his body core temperature was measured at 973 degrees Pahreelseit (well within normal parantetia#Inilnd on dds body teraparenre, both HMCS
l e
and LTC out the possibility that the detainee vas even V2(0mildly.is at time of his cardiac arrest. .;-1111111mimifamily medical history, previous health and erect age (.44Ire all unknown at this pOint His repotted age of 27 years old Wised on information gained during his interrogation and given his pattern of providing misleading or false information when given the chance, is of questionablevalidity.
-According to LICIIIIIIIthere hove been a surprising number of cardiac problems, including the recent full cardiac arrest of an Iraqi citizen in hi mid-303, which have occurred kelp vicinity of Mosul. The health demographics of young to middie-aged Iranian males are completelynnknown at this time.
-Prior to the detainees cardiac arrest at0137C, he was wrapped in two blankets
and laying fire in pmparation foihis final medical screening and annoyer to
Bra

the Stryker Brigade holding facility.
• After the detainee's cardiac arrest, he was attended by five ISD corpansen andthe OMSurgeon wrcamump, who had full access to all necessary modern medical equipment in a nearby aid station.
e_SECRIFFINOPORINI---
()rake Report -Annex 120
3150

19(.4(0i
FIRST ENDORSEMENT
Concur with lammneedatiou
% Other

11111111,„
ormica Report Annex 120
DOD JUNE 3151
• 12 Apr 04
From:

LT, JA C USNR

To;

Offic r,

Subj: PRELIMINARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH OF

Ref: (a) MOHAN Section 204

1. Pursuant to section 204 of reference (a) I have
preliminary inquiry (PI) conducted by LT

regarding the subject above. I found that
nvestigation was thorough and expedient.

S
•
ormica Report Annex 120
3152

DOD JUNE
ap
Subj: PRELIMINARY INQUIRY INTO DEATH OF

b0)(0) ,c9) t-0 bCs1)(1)
• • -----SEcRETIftwonti--­ -­1(
r OM II N •111 NOON I I ormica Report - Annex 120 INN
DOD JUNE 3153

NSWTGAP.JAG
OF .rwrntr32 P
Cc:
1111111Milighim mumum
Subject: (GPIJAG)
Preliminary JAGLIAN E.
Ines Daub.
Classification: title!".
Caveats: NONE

Sir,
irmirersted that I laniard you 01410.
on preliminary imintlgation on the detainee's loath in MosuL San with enclosures and •.Pram b 10%. w/
6.))
b( Finally, the on.(.4
CID told
%mama
UMW

• b(4)
Prelim Inquirt 07.JAG
PPR 04.dcc twommendatimula

:6tUrttr
Caweats: NONE

• 1
ormic.a Report - Annex 120
.
DOD JUNE
3154
NSWTGAP, JAG
JAG
8:22 PM
, I bcts)PGA)
•
, IMO • eMinee Death Investigation
Classification: ILE.C.Atsor-^
Caveats: NONE

Sir,
Enclosed with this email Is my endorsement of LT . trawl into the detainee's death in "Inset On a
related note, I =Wed CIO In Mosul if you need to discuss wiping \Or. JAG
E1
JAG
Enclorumentsbc
Attachment CiassificationAK-eftefit,
Attachment Caveats: NONE

Classification: 81Wa
srNONE
•
•

•
ormica Report -Annex 120
.
3155
DOD JUNE
Page I of 4
NSWTGAP JAG
From: 81.1.111C01 cnrr-sJA fiftwaimmunim Sent: Thursday, April 08, 2004 218 PM To; 111.111111411. JAG; efiN/011/111111/11111.
Cc; CO. &IA 0IC; CJTFT-014;
IRAON
Chief of
Chief of SW'
P1 JAG)

Subject: RE: Update on Detainee Death InvasVatimUSECRSW
LT Thali
a the update. Critical issue, based on my time in this theater and responses to otherinquiries of this nature, is a thorough investigation. I think that issue is well in hand now.
COL.11.11
ROM'
Seat llassday, Aprl 08, 2004[04:08

ot T
Stsbjeob
Classificatiortu$4441.4.;_,
Caveats: NONE
Sir,
S/23t2004
ito
ANICRETAIOIRMI-
ormica Report - Annex 120
3156
DOD JUNE
Page 2 of 4
41.111R
OD Wr
MEM --Original Message--FraimallinallIMINSVA OIC (malito.111111111111101111.1111,
Salt Wed.Aprl 07, 2004 6:58 PM
To:. CIIFT-SIA
Ca.
PlovoSt Marshal; .Or4011.111111.IN W;. Irara.
Chief of !tell;
LIN ClUEF OF STAFF.
ail=WA;
Chief of Start
Subject RE:.
Death InvestIg.- z
Sr it is our understanding that NOS personnel ens on their way here to invesdalds-
CID are now only assisting with the kwestigotion by taking statements Otte.rnent personnel baton May re-deploy and potentially coordinstMg the autopsy.
re, we
for the
assistance. L.Tediip
---Orighel Message— From:amensigOTFT•SIA Sent: Wednesday, Aprl 07, 2004 4:35 PM
•
To;
OTC Provost Abash.'.
•
ADMIN tAW;Chief of Staff;.DEPtITY CHIEF OF MP
53A
Subject: RE: Detainee Death IrwestigationOrtGRETri....,

Please see my most recent egnalls. This represents the most current into that I have received from CU) and LT
•
ADMIN LAW Start
su

Subject Detelnee Death Investigaticsi trtreartF)---
Importance: High
• 5/23/2004
r—OlOrPRIVINOPFORN---
•Annex 120
3 15 7
DOD JUNE
Page 3 of 4
CleSsificatIon4idffirrT—•
Caveats: NONE
Sir,
I was up In Mosul for the lest couple of days, butt returned to Baghdad today. rat sorry that my MINKIIAG did not snow me to swing by your dice white I was there (though t did meet LTC 11110, your PM). Heirs an update on the status of the detainee dealt Investigation:
Please keep me updated from your end, and Ii do the same form here.
• v/r.
Staff Judge Advocate
fA
seativitioMitir.
5/23/2004
ormica Report - Annex 120
3158
DOD JUNE
DOD056974
Otitt WS) 234-0275
—Orl.-From.
SM OK
(mato
Sent: Wednesday, April 07, 2004 11:07 AM

TolIMINIMISJAG OIC
co INIUMINNIMMIN SA;.S-1411111111.

041411-N) Provost Marshal
Seeks Detainee Issue

b(4)(
11.111111MIR
•
Reese keen me Posted. TheeksailIMIIMIMMINIIMM
AMIN
Classircabon: tamer—

Caveats: NONE
Classincation: S-E-erfttn
Caveats: NONE
• 5/23/2004
ormIca Report - Annex 120
DOD JUNE 3159
Page 2 of 4
11111111111

lle From:
NIMINMAJAG
Sent Therlidatt. April 08. 2004 12:00 PM
To: 4111111111.11111 0APr
CC:
CJTF74./14% CJTF7 HIEF ADMIN WY CHIEF OF Chief of gat UEP Subject Update on Detainee Death Investigation (3LPeRLITT Classification: SECRET Caveats: NONE
Sir.
I just returned from Mosul. Here is the latest on the Detainee Death InvestigaSon:
--Original Messege---
FfitmaIRMaNairMa SA OIC EirelftnaNIMMINSOMMOMI

Sent: Wednesday, April 07, 2004 6:58 PM b(41‘,444To:. -SA
•
Cc
Provost Marshal;-OIC;
ADM
DM IADMIN LIM'
JAG;.Chief of Staff'.DEPUTY
CHIEF OF STAFF,
E3a;.SI/4. Chief ofStaff..
DEP COR
Sub$act RE: Detainee Death Investigation 4sEGREF)--

Sir it is our understanding that raCtS personnel are on their way here to investigate. Our CID are
• 5/23/2004
-mg CRETINWFORN-
ormkm Report - Annex 120
3160
DOD JUNE
DOD056976

Page 2 of4
now only assisting with the investigation by taking slidemenb of the detachment • rsonnd beforethey re-deploy end potentially coordinating the autopsy.
Therefom, we have no outstandingissues for C,ITF-7. Thanks for the assistance.
—Original Message--
From! 418.1111111111111.11111-SM
Sent:

, April 07, 2004 4:35 PM b A4T o: •
SIA OICCc: Frorre SarthIllAIMNIPMG 0M111111.111111111/0
OrF7-stiff ADMIN tAW; JAG Chief of Staff;
illimpoutrrr Ch EF OF sr
Subject: RE: Detainee Death InvestigationOSCRED

Mb
Please see my most recent e-mails. .represents the most current info b (-4)12\that I have reoeived from CID and b0p.rif%
(-6 (1)
—Original Message--ImalkoMM/1/111111/1111111..111MM
Sent Wednesday, Port 07, 2004 08:53 b (011.qc.To:
SIA DEC
C.= (E•mallNall11¦1111110.0
4arailli;(E-lor4 JAG;11111111111 Chief gaol; NMI DEPUTY
CHIEF OF STAFF Subject: Detainee Death Investigadone(GEStETrImportance: High
Classifloallon.-SSGRer
Caveats: NONE
I was up in Mosul for the last couple of days, but I returned to Baghdad today. rm sorry Shat my schedule notmeow me to swing by your office while I was there(though did meet LTo , your PV). Here's en update on the status of the
detainee death investigebon: •
•
5/23/2004
ormice Report - Annex 120
3161
DOD JUNE
Page 3 of 4
Please keep me updated from your end. and rd do the woo form here.
sur,
*11
v,., Staff Judge Advocate 1. C.4)
MiafiellISSNRIMInseal
DM (3 18) 230.0216
--Original Message—
Feu

say OIC
toodto.M111.11111.1empiam1
Sent Wednesday, April 07, 2004 11:07 AMTo3111111111... 01C
Ccall111111111.11111111.11. SAMNA!S1k1111111111111111111111111.11.
Provost Marshal
Subject Detainee Issue

t) c C.1.)
• 5/23/2004
liNCREVIRPOREIF
s •AMMIX120
3162
DOD JUNE
DOD056978

Page 4 of 4 1111.11111111.11011111 .b MIP me i _ Thal411111111.10.11110.111" Classification: sumer ¦••••¦¦¦ to4CW
Caveats: NONE
Classification: freeitt-r"
Caveats: NONE

•
5/23/2004
---111ECRET11/110FORN--6N.
3163
DOD JUNE