Fay Report Annex: Statement of Major General Barbara G. Fast re: Conditions at Abu Ghraib Prison

STATPMENT OF MC; 'BARBARA G. FAST AK E.:\ CA.Mp •IC.TORY. IRAQ DATED 11) ,11.!LY 2004 CfRA(`F f.AST MAJOR GEN USik. C2, MNF.1 1111NINNE (.....AMPV CIORY, IRAQ (14r: Tele-C.:onf...;“..,ticz. by LTG Anthonv R. .1‘ ) 1,"\ ES. and MC.: GEORGE FAY. Prt.:Nen: wus ante., ov .29 ill: 712: transfonnintit !Vita. there wtAs ord;;:r ests.lbli4;kti CT1T-7 o.:4_•45 _lune 03; however 1 nevetr Sa¦V Lh Onfra. 711CIT W41:: jus: after I ariived, t‘rw spew. a number ofdays visiting nitnitviktons Irevic;:...x1k. .anil the ittteitt.;ence :n I !.:;-R.:s1rAtici51nBto,fatittl. I began to.undeTsand hosk• $•4:• Thc CTIT• was beginhing wor1. ys:t1,74th,.; : r C.'7 I in and fuitction, ftc first re•viqon lv:ts 3L 41 11 ii Nt)), rttiti i finaIapprov;i1.1 ill Dec Thezitc far inorQ accurate pictur,e. of our f.)perution, .At arn:::110.re nuur our fill (about 00% is • 'sc.Y c:ra 3 : by t:Ii.N11,1:0M lor sv‘!. ; rna.; , up 0. .;) t Were t3.,..rvei0pttti for tht)st ne-o. !•:*nOnln intel III t3 fusion. 14 on thc iIttet gtrt.:cturc nk 1( bc CM ." :'• , • ;.; : 13 iU: For triztartc ,..!. snonld th hri of oat Intel k.13n!ht.: 0! C'pIoylri ,nliC.N.',t.! more import;A:st: to Wi331 he en;line e533:411 , r :1114::: at uli ciossification leVek. In natit zrr.- cUi.:1WelnnWith itc.:ip rOnnvoning t.;.S. '-s1ittor .:41: (-+:1 Nvas '1V(.` t)InJ1.!,S ara:1 ;.oro nIttue, t)ut CZ!: that ‘eould providtz 1:17.,::;;;.77,.;7. 1...,n;:t3dlil:I3 .:1111liiy....:.31,!o. Seventeen in::, Thom anti 4:0111tibZ11;-.:n;C:en ;it:n41•:::;;;;.;;.n(..)1•:;e3 : 7 : Vt'f: ?14,.)1`.• tiln?).1/4 foetts on ar.a rat61:::.tence A, C.I...\:T( ()%1‘ .ISC)Tr. t...i:rnc Stati;inn huh: NIC'. U. y. as an thcn ivcri7 :) ,,ilerv,J5 CO:11Fik(Cii: Iflicerated it.410 t etrect4.-ti \;:2712Ferrh:TiL and kl.2 -Y4'..ndt t'n i;r:C1:;. On (ht.:. :1;.t.x-romutIon:(lete3Ifi(ti side. zt-rive,,i,l had directed Abti Out (this had to h right :41)0A: ht;f1:-re!. ,A.s. I rA;a111il.rIttti, We 113:;t ,Tg.t.) t.r v;r 1N;&; ar; INTL.-;!..s i PERSON NiAKIN(i PACiF, k(:)F AG0000567 STATEMEN.I . liARBARA FAS1:fAK AT CAMP VICTORY. 11Z AQ .DAVE.D ,11)1..\7700-1 . wc: SOTt:n Of tht.'. approv• .i.!: techniques, but .1 do not k'notk wI ii fat puitcy was ;;o(d and clear, .1 .;xcentio ,,),. 4j I. it ,t:otaki.on -: .k,.;nappipvc$1by. l..T(3 $ramint..,:tearrs., ar.d ;.s.:rriniar.;.:i and N.1.0rc;encd inTerro;taters.; And w h w.s pressuiv 4) perform. I n'ver feh no do I btAiev i:. then was: pressure ettee:.:r.ttnnue.til to C.ITi;ic; to prQdtiCT tnailzty, rel,evalu. ittlelf:gunce. Fponto iiisp::;.c.n)r can' 16 did make nir.;: to regtliari -.... FTerui tirm, arounki . stra.s: Lind eitam.:.:' tail; to . a .1 inciudePU EDC. ,dis.i.:19-K.tint....zd th:lt o ,: . the oatlcn. 1' orily 3.:10LII 3 I vvm toth.iy. ex,cosw.,;::: in :Jur ::::.....•a!mLs a: a C.4 rati:Iy. .-s'orkirtg . .wit.11 what. wt., sn +J2ni.14Y 4:z.tp;thility 1 think we nectiett II n detainees but with OM'ni..N11:N11 ) ) :1) Ory;2111i.J.41 as •;s: 11V:Ste1 Beginti111.:1 in ()Ct. War:, abie II Y.L'!'& pr?scnee. Given iti&siot•. all thret:: 1.VCn 7.)1):;:3: i31g!Orriat.:0Z1 trld Cominimictition; coaldn'l !c, thc riith a t017.1.::;.coznInimication rrIcn‘n:-• a; . :: and rnailndici:n14, cou;ki 1101 trainoti tor. tit) enc. arc 'I' contha; prott.Tctio , our force, ancratii)ris. I ;-)day• 1.)usf:.oIti. h:! irttnTogivions that iva.e.t‘ • :.:• .fort.;.i riv.i.arah;;:mgX1 H 'f.."\ (Ty L.' L.A.D HAV 11.A.1) Itt:A.D TO `A:111(.1-; FNDS 0.N . PAGT:. _2:1% I ADERSTANI) TI !F IRT: ST.,\."1-ENIEVF MAD)::, 'Pi **111::: . ..1 r AVE CORRECTIONS AN I.E) THE 1-.3OTT:. ­ )NT O'r PA61:. CONTAIN:INC) Tilt : , ATENIENT • TEmEN.7n -HOPE OF RENITIT OR REWARD, . ND WITHOUT C01::R(...1()N, ;N:!AW1,11 FNp, ••••••1 ••.'•••- • 17 ,2 0PLINOn iikinf..? nalCrilL'Ir ••••n1 \ •••• •• any: $.%koon: i;i 31«, PgrAvli :Ii;114, -d ?)y aw I 1, • . VITA PAGIAf.)1.' 110A01.7. AG0000582 STATEMENT!' OF MG BARBARA G. FAST TAKEN Al. CAMP VICTORY, liZ.A.t.,"1 DATED 20 JULY 2004 insI•rIctions frorr: itet:C.4.3tiartem. I n ay..are. of arty i C 2.c. ;g1 basts tor dt)ctritic tiii 1•.)n We 013;.Faten arc C x m are :tisk) individnai:s rriay 1t61-tef ()am doctrut c!. ileetits k :a 101 -that Icchnoiolvy t;;:::: 14:: filfl''s,: EM .34-52 :1Wity--t.ser rze.t.,(1 tt) ttpdat. 11;;:n tifisk; ',7ah.mbit, a (.72X and )h:• 1:n1`:n df.. ,.:•lrin;nOn our 111:111TUTIg doctutrctits. inton 1: or :r•C;',.:11ple.. ti7.4.`.‘ Tiger 't ekInl concept is a grett corizej.v. 0:1nztn;isio 17)issc.m.ination: there is 1 T:111$1 LiSei 1112k1.; ;.'11‘.."!: 1: ( ., ; i',; ;sJflk n1tiagen3t.Irtli; Ittry can or‹..i?ratior.1.I LP;ma1 • 1-1L;N:II'.' T .renorLin14, and btlow lilt. and ari tmt-Ts 1.11 ::1;;;iL be evr.z. 1V;:: :::., u1;1111 for :nt. LO t ti TWAXis to tmderstand rIttetg, Avitcy. t4V.i, (11aineti rCitZ•SL., Ca:C.? St.nlitt.011C'. ::hort of' the 1:"Ci and th..;i • f. ig: ;.1rc out tte.::c respoissibDitic;; naek: ccivIly during forcc '2111n Tht.71:' • .,:.•n fot. HICM [Ni r.;pcnttiorif, ir,•n • :;ftLcir eltp31)ilzty -arid eelnisclettc.:.:,:. bc:ca u;::er.1 ars: ix.rmv inmn noir: the iiut):r 1:0 Sta *¦: With dt:tgi ;ICC 7:iin inthts, hut it 11:.n.'ds 07; Ch.9...1-.1 ¦ 0!:n no. sk. V): 0!..n1•¦ • ¦ :(lit.' .dat.'1111011 InIniS • isn• arL" iIi and to.frcal inZhv::+10v).•nattac•i:r v, as,n1.;:sii..te3gh0 ft:ii10•:;.nktitr.k-. • (1hrS I: "..111n1 t;n v,:hethel 5.11n :thui;;;. Af; Nit's tilatte detaintws, ii to r.);: iI ts, Ticrn.ips evz:a zneot,iragirtg. then to Co:nil/It tilest 1 .r.;;i7nand ;001..;nofiktainees Who caitid 11%. 1 CaTi!Minig.)11111C ¦ t. ¦ :.1:n1.0n apparent STA AG 000058]. STATEMENT OF M.Ci BARBARA Ci. EAST TAKEN AT CAMP VICTORY, IRAQ • 1)ATED 203I.II,Y 2004 • . inaci.niri.:to +N.)11.t..1.11:71. C:atri:!. frOltl, I did: not voic.% or ro.finw to r1:14;a54; anyone a.lit!r cit.:. iN.M: ai.14.$1rine.. I :.:i.oT.Ipctisittizirt! !ii,.... boar:1:, t.).i., 1 .. Nos, 03. •1.1.i2h Value .Detainms (ft Vil)y, i'..2,7;:,-::' hti:i no ,;f1;;;;-,1 dircz conmuitild r,,,:i I.,,..,ii, With litf.' !SC.:: .I .w.t ESC: sAns resniiny.::::1 fol . ritnninf. iht. inttrroi.atic;11 opt...rations i H. •.:...il vai...tairic,,zi::, 11.ivi:) .,hc.,:)...11.1,..„it... i..,.. ...„;...1that th.ii...; „vas tht,i,,... .sion alone. crry....7 L.,t. th„.. ) ..„,.3 .....t[ tical. 1.1.6...4 .1,cas N...ouircd 10 ...,a ,i)nor! :hen': iv. fifq.;:nt:i.; .: ...liv..: N.vul: olltvr . non- ulterrogation oartF,. of .:1::. (ktv:mtion clTration 111 tbL. tivr) filciwys ..:n..t: -tol. 0-:: ti::: 1:iiic..i.; vie of ianill :'aluc wottlei coinc i.0 (.:111'..7. Wi.' ii:wa ¦.....3 • TIV t,3(: :,c1P Bit:. bat: ;:i.t .,,-.F.;notibili': :: !.,,..,' rolln1311! L 1 •11:0..p.1 .i ,J vvt:I. ...-iisi hiii. ,:„. inif.rnaii)n Rellort:,. ilIks). They ilidn't zi.lWiloyS ItSli Ilk: qi3VSIKIIIF Vec. I Vti: 1.i.." i'llik bv...eaus..-. c)f Til.‹4 dit'ZZ'Ct1::.:::: In ntisf.ion, ­ 6o we submitt.;:d Solimc Di;:txl, R;:ouircz...::'..nit'is f..SDR) to ansv,•.::' an k.. i .. .:u.::::ion , we I-nigh:. :lave. ()tiler ciovern meta Agency (()t;.34): The iiirection I te‘...eiv Ni „:.• it work as ;:i.o ,Aeiy as c.,,.,. (--: :::::: ::. f.::...r.11 :1 :::,11:' 1:z.arn. s'.);if,' !! .:;:trc..itln. C.,rit:: -Cffi)T::..n -ncouragc:. a elose ‘,...q:.,F.-::.ii;..•: 3-,.,!:::,,..,.:-,.:shir. :,Js j.i;.;. '...)(...)!;) .!-::•,i1,. c:4. ser,:wr j....ta(krsh.ip to th, CG.. From k1 .1sio1 ievo: J bc 0.0.- ,.,.,. t:.rn--.7 ,...q);:,:rvions 'i ii 0.\ and tilt:: tnir.v. I --i..,,,. hot 1.:; ,:: plii);1 -:*. n7:0•S'.... if 110:, :ail (....)t...i..A tvooniny,., .1:.:&' op,...:ri-; ; ,..,.,..,.. c':ialm:.,..:::::. Tit.,I,..- -.. --... ....1.-....;. s.,...rmen dir ..;:ilon 4)?.1.i; cAnzuriatici. eclattortAilp. Titci:: . i:.,-...: ahar ,-;7;t:1!:i.i.ati;v:.: in illc:nt.....-....1:i.%!i 3 key (me. I wal...: rardy a.dviseci of th.oir spoe,ific wt:T1 11 .: 1.1i::-til.;:;.;%::-n.A.... • :1 -1ll'i tO lincrto:.,;ation, C.)CiA 'tad to abli.le . b). tit:. C;r17:. 7 11.i0 : ., a n t; Covtil,:.,...t;;; ¦ lail;:,_s nolii.",¦ :it an tilrac:, in C.l. 17F:-.^.' :11c:dines. Their (...1.tief ::•=7:-,:irr..::.::1 -, .A...: -...1,--.. ,:.,;3 im.., 1::.1 Cloy 1-1:1:: 1;: 7-:-.7 .-..:1. -.; :..r.::.i.,7T nrn.ary ;:zsualorTs.. iti. -i:,i inal 111.:.%. i....,.-::;...-,..i. (..';.,..:• ;:p-p:,.:::;: ..,... 1,.1-; i:::ric.: ;;;.1;-c..ii if =. .wouicl i..). possible to piae ,..' ..:::,:.•:11,..;.,, ,, ,...; `.. n1:.'nn..."..‘ •1 is:ere ,..y.f•..ro contmuciiis probliziti',:: '''. : .:', 7. ".n:r.: ...: :`:rn.1 .. r Y 7"!..n:.....1 ¦...A:::¦••n: .'s..1 ...' 1i...::...fr..11:‘,. i',.: i...-..-1:::in:.....c .:. -.. : i .;L' .. .,-.,.....i. ,.; ..!-.... .,',...;.-!.rc having lo look for ciot.i.tinve,:. 1.11:..y ci.-n.Cii.i ' S• Lk tal-;:.. . • d.-..v.:=. it) fint} . (TOL. l'.APPAI-; was. trifthiy !ri;;;:: :'!. -..%•:.:', I ., il...: t.'::: .-o:.i:i:,. :i.:,..:.::::::ii iii.,--,:ti Lqiort. .1 .1: nliviscd in times vtnr Vs . CY:IIC n_ Ir:.;L t ':,:: 1:•;Ii.': 016:. in ItIC: ....Zell.era ivt)tilattorl. This . i.,': ,1":: .::,:::::i .‘..• d'...::,',.; -:(:!:-:.t1;7::F. iii., :.:DIJ:::, ::) d... 4..iiiiii:1 Ar,;:rily,.:r.111()1).,.,:, rto to Imviion the fact that it P.. ,,n:i.t.i.:.: .:; ,:.11: ,. f.:•• ::::‘;.:-....‘...:.:11t th:..-:.. ii:::::,h vallt; .; t..ictz:.,iins 1f1 narttcalar veils. 's( , ?.:.,:.. t; :i ,;:,..:.,..-; 1 rotrid ar,1:;..01 i ,-; (:. ;r -..11 ,:: s.:(..,:::;ri.:, pc..,paillion vch;:rc. Lite). couk. coliaboraio .. :.)!.i.:..: ';1 ,.:1..1;: -1,:.-.:::, ! .i:::: ,..s..; (TOL.. .'..!)':'1,..... I,-.] w‘rl: ....k..1 ,:h t'! -w. N.1!)'s ano !;..q.. ,.(q.ild b:". ifthF. i'­:::.-.::::::..:;.. , ..1 ,..',,..... •I'' ' .,:' ' '' ' •." i ' :. '''''.:• ¦ •• :;''''' n... ..' II'. COW :I :-...is.':•: Iht".; ,:::1 ¦ 11:.• ',.,..i 1..S21 . ia:;:iircle6, :V.II •Ilik'7: ror;..••s..... ,::!.;;:;,,:.:.n • ..., :'..4::. .%. :;...... 1 il..:: 3:.4 .; %.%• ¦ • :n .-ton1 : A .:::', V, ...3 ,i ::‘.1..I :Cti ‘;;;.:1 rt.,.5.Dect ...;(...;.A., FBI or 1., Lr no:)-1.n.),I.:, :..,.i4;...n..: ..,-,...,.. or......:-....o.c.,:i ‘,..... ,: 1:::::, i .i. i.::iliaboTiiit(1 ztnISI ;ilk .' not ::i(at.:: seripc..: ..,...31,(.,:: iiii-ii u.. tii-fs .t.:ikr; ;.-r“,.-...:i :: :,. i..i .-iv:.i.:1 ‘,..i.....r.i.i.11.nors. li n.ii...1ny ;11, :tet...N .vs":)ttid havt: li.:. . 1,)r.s .,, , Cm:. 1-1 ;:et: !;;; t:; ,,Is-::: ¦ .-. :.&:f.: "t'•;',1". •.v1.:i : anornt..r. ',.)-()D os...aiii..lidot.i ha,';'. i.; -:.-, ..J.1 ...,.. :'.2.1:: ,.\.;;::sitt.. ...:1-.... in ..c.i .;:‘,1:(1r::, tip.i.71.IF.s,;('. .iir. :::•:;.i 1.n1.:..t.1 til ,.: d.,::;. Ti.;;:.r.: v,...ar a Dian! ..: .....,r...:f....:Ii.r..... „CI .1.'.$0:.., inleiTc12:Atior...1 , •..-...11,..,:l.,... br.11 ;h ..: AA:V:7'.::. n (1 .,-. '..v4s C111 d itITOrii: %C .::)•;!::: ,:::):: j.&t::;11. 1:0:•;*: Ai (ih.tilib v,....A... ;Jisil 1.)n the ..11:M.) 1.it.'i.Or:ni :U . ...id tht. ¦ S•,-.:".1,....; Z::::: :::::“1:At li. , kc.:r. Lir,1:;; t-A;.-.-: kl;:..r.ili:.. -.:1.:-n1 :;:r i101 . nOf l IA C,I i.',1'::2:;.t::1 -,f;•::::•.:',nr:-.. , ;1111;1:.! zo.::i: :-:•• ow_ 11:::.1 -: ,.);!itor...;. but i..id iilIi ii': ciri sor;le f.'i oi.tt ii:iri:.,, i n;ivi: Pio 1 o....:3o:; i, ,;r: "A :f1"..! abotu -Cil log 1):::t;w1fxs" Ilc(.l at Atm (...1117:1:b 1r,c1 ;1'..; J71 ', -.;.Sl17.".Ii.i:3!. *riv.., :::f.1:10,1i:',' 'AIWI d:(2‘.`, On 4 Ncr..: had app:in..nuit: ji.im been int.u.43114. in a1ti Li 1.71tZt:.11 1 .:..7,;':::iiCt;;;;I.nI 11:1: ,,.;', al .k: oily S'. I :)11i: citht.'r tit!tailits+: Oil vs,h1t,)-; (A1l'.7 4 i. :,..S)N 7,,,._11KfN; -: ¦:::- :\ ...C; V, ''..7-' ¦'.,,..r....,_,n . ) ..11 C..) fl) LI.OFn P.AGE. AG0000580 • .• STA.TEMENT OFMG HARB.AR• FAST FN AT CAMP 'a:1(71'0R 1R.AQ DATED 1 1...1 JULY 1904 . ClIVilV.in.T11C;n1 Lh V.-in:1. Ai tilt tit. Vet'ir 110 iljltTriagati(111 booths arid tl• I s "A1C.)1TIJ t.rrilb cit•A•s nii•,..,:air i :,..i..T.;.N-ST.1.1ritv ................. in 'MN ii z r: at t.n.. roquirernt.mt for dogs in the snia Ak..titaistipuft cariiih;,, n,Abtist!'s al. Atm 1nkl:;1,71:1;::: J:01112. ill Abilnd•Arirtg :in iincrrooi: on 4 No‘ .,...)3.n1nfirs•n PAI.T.A.S to •Ik I On . io (!•.Ka1111 it ,:.• hurl of tilt: situLttion un;,4. ilectiedb3 11I 4:1 1"1;-: said no, issue and ;hal netxied havc • anti notifictl i. Al)parzritiy, heddqualcr,z..CID .i..;;;• an investigation on 4 No. J !..z.A=...:4:1 interim in the evenin 2 I.)ix I lepor: 1 notifit:d everiin?.s. aziti tvcntn •h:. parcrri yusl• in ,...estigauon Ai)!! 1 1) .k1) 3n("dr n of abii.fie baek Intir!th . 004,7.7n(.) 1riotentiai; ablige dv bin i)vn f Alitottnl'UUI3 il ;3 itutii.-n1,111)8): '4) :1 thes,nsnotiiti • •;.11...r.);n;. koni i.t. ‘t..;": I threotipn ill iniel 31 ,""• a • ;; " -1 qieCtion. (TJTV-7 .1(1.1.•.•1'.1(;r1 10•,!er rd any vtys•K•k,i-n. irori cf,A had .4 joi briefed h-i; aid :.!: ¦ •IS?•1.1 , 2 r71'•\ irai;i's,;)flcn [1;1.0114 .-\ it.N1n1'k&'aSt• N,i 1. ••••••‘..• A fZPI;t;N:R.I . Lt:i thy!.noveTly f;at • 13o4t-d n th:.1 11 1 1 1 :: CC; dc.:11.n.:-;•iltr:s-1!IL.:1::::11T1..s.I I i it.a.t).tifer„ i3oardnadtiltiorml i(.111 ..) or N1',n ;3s11431 it this vta:', forn3IIntilan tAvonTheintr:Ibt; n 1n I,)nhL ovzi. ‘ver:11);Anr.... n .Jarin"'cors 421: 1.=':r !!1'S: a1r,,Cdr4r;;;;'; ii'l.1:711:7 111:r 31 P.::.:ZSONnST:\ T:'‘ • AGO 000579 STATE:Mt:NT OF 13AR.BARA FA.ST TAK.EN AT .cii VICTORY, DA]) 2.ti 2(Ik:34 • SUITIITILTitS wrre s 'm v ill:. C2X to the $....•very nig..bt: laic: the ADC Sfl 1 intst,srromttc:n SU Mill zr: . had many oprrational sutcessc ib SI cc orn;:!. Oih;• uncl.asified s . :orn inurv:; gaf.i(rs. zit ac111.;I hi 1;uI S.A.N(. -.3 .i.E1 is a if.•.:ugh., uoilsztati4.' eormilarzi.kr tata:t1; his re4pOiltubilitg:;;. st.”14.)11e,iy.n b1 drovo At', fat' L. rlbero help build IL. 11..­ 1.0 z..10. and prOSSUrt!. W;:r-• at. nk :id rie,..:er Dre...a.zstfre aktt wotild CT ellCollr4v cn&Ni& to. SA:\ICTIEZ ha:1 an eye fir de.aail. wit.h no detail i !rip. io arat willozd throitv.il every ipccof nov. crrcc. k:ri. 14dC :1..:.:. ;$.1Stinellt'S and th:1I Tn1have been percaived as pro .,....sar•ocn0.1 ,.? an1. v• -:1,S o pc.(vs.ack cbrzeti(n.:: 'and. gUithtnz.:.(' tOnthc 3.fd)(• I flfel!. tha; t'i _t_. natured to rnev. th necess:iri: shan:::: and dontribule to -Our '2.:7:1:-; fOr0.11.I: r•Cg1111 .:::eie1nflts uId other threats.. lip Lind •sylitent, t.totting oornrns that couid riace, and getting rho taetios, ant.: wnOts prvthioetl. tha; L.TC: SANt,:lifF.2, ,NVZI very satistiet.I after 1-11 znvironmint Viriataily the whole \.-! r:•een bar $:;.,rength in Old Army. liti¦ alm order i4 JittErthc.i 0% . \\. 1 • tare!iiV., :- ff.sivc iOcvs 1,11 :airnbcr Tuainsii r •.y31;hr,.,1;:../.: :And ti1C nlormaurI arid export's: 1•::1)1;n:. ov niore of the 1.TC; d;ring an! eti :civrro:i.ation ) k.1ITWI a huui o netWOrl: ‘vorked ver . ., !lord ti dl!it;r;s;A•i- :V•0:11 il2rd TILV a 11:11.4:-:' ,Ori b:11 diSr.1pLI:xi fmLbm .......i; 171Icrn.Talifiri Lu; uulhor;;Td. lht. 1)i1cynth::;: the dot?. tia,j 6.; T,thdiCr '41 ("4LD for NIP Call be the kind of iii (lit:I:C:11. f.'appa: 2i Aug BaseLi fl t.)UT ;;;F.'.1%.1Si;lCm. i thriughi that thc. intent frir for tb;; s.Y svhf.:11 they wf...!rf... it: tis s•wvinZ 1 1n•n:nfnNnS . 1 , 40- PAM:1'20F '-A( F AG0000578 STATEMENT OF MG. BARBARA G. FAST TAKEN AT CAME' VICTORY. IRAQ DATED 20 JULY 2M4 die krox variety of ifrona thugstotetTorists) ako CI 1. p.:-!rsor:Oi'... thz7. St Opczaiiiig MY.; V.0: COpy 61011 and perh2p.; :ht MP';: and C2%. .k.v1-.1;11 Liothoriue:, (.? I MO ;;Reil, exc.:er tiuz their cis wc.re cat:4;01.1/dd. 1 belirvu, as cr...mn .", covabaialih,fIc.i the (jtme-si:n Hagtu.Cvnu ruics.. ingl, e tktn:11eeS. We mad: iumce ciaingos to Oar operation z.1: a he:. rnc.otn.znowianon. ,.; • The ;tic ILD(.. "and Ori..',Uili2c11 into 3eCtiOr; and.C'e4ieCtit:r; .: rilaridE$eincri: 5CL1100. had ;Ai A:ad yhJ i171 TI C2X., bt tidod tho roquirernent. HUMINTvc (OHS) reprcsenti(s: -wrheo.:. I a.b.4. ensured the [R.-:ncotporat,...d ane anaiyth:-,.! --izatt?rroy.ation ank LC enable i.wttor interro :uuons and CiTF-Policy Nitqnos: Interrogation & Connter-R.egistnnee: ilefory (TC.'n on estailv-elivil,=. was r:01 ba.s; on2:-an ,_;n:i. and belicytui rto he mon:" thaii f..i&quaL icr out . he' 14 .Scpt.embt,f iincrrogatio'n t u. o inedical duri.n& tirms.. z.11.:d• SANCHEZ Se.lt. :::01:111: .•;rhe 12 0,.;1 nw. in tilt; polii.‘.1.1;.:wr had .to t) .% -•I These cxoepliorp?„ throt4th ;;-v..nThen.' (.: 011CV7Ith:;.; :‘,t;rc:nttuthu.!xi.ties. yon ec.aik: ‘); • t:n Lczhniquez; documerus, r ds;:witcr:„ tbn: yOu 2n( tgke was :1 .;:i1717.111;11;;.! .11:1r1 :In intz.Troy:ttor. ohl,,...rv.cali (1‘ a dia. 4i houni there werc other requetur.; bu! 10 41111:31 1:1;:\ Ti..;7\•CT. mu& ii thc L('n tn.a: ha‘i hy. 1 hal 1 ,,. erc: 111t;;;-;:::, t2i11 ,.)f":•-ax. • ;i ;i0•1 ;;; INSCOM was antl ..lwrnent t:31s d not ha\ c Di sz:nt1:1 „. :7: Li::: Sep fortonzte I I 1 I 1101.:1 OM' Cif th;:. centre:non,: worc :;. 4;;;I:1;;;; Lihd IS C:r:l.titi1:11).:. 1: 1::a jivc ai ;1'.41: nitl, zans: iittyrro!)atisla Successes. (24.)nciitions and Abuses Abu Ghrflit).: cminoi F,iate svbv, ?)ertn. 1flili oihers Tilt.' R.. ix: the mie.r.F0 ,2nttOr;n kt.'.11,.. in al ()r P.AC;.1: AG0000577 • STATEMENT OPMG BARBARA 6. FAST TAKEN Al cAmp vicrotzv, DATED 20 SUI...7 ;2i)t)4 . 1 wtisnt awarc 1:1;11 . I. T(ii .,'s,NCI--11:-7. had dr:pp:it:el:I' COL.. APPA S ft,: titt. Fot-v..--,11 .....:• OD:Nati:1i:: -;iat.': iF{...) 13) Ccir until tile 1:1: AGO carnc. out. Nly. tinders-tat-With; was that PA.Pl'A. ‘...,,Ii h 1.:;.:srx)asibie ;Or rfc$pi71.' prot;!.;;:tio d."',.; ti;_'. ins;alialicin its a whole. Espooi4.11:: ii.::ell ;ha; thei . ;. worn a lot of tairtar attacks at Ah o Ohntib. tho C(...:i want:xi to oinurc thcro v...as unity of izzlior and a ti . , 111 :1;ecto-ity plan fi.ir (k1•11SC of lila faci)ity. I do know that COL PAPPAS identilkd NtNCrai 171 -citknti of misconduct Cr ',:i)4 ..31);:lard behaA/tor 4nd addraised those tssties. Ilk: N.11 4ii • v.,,,,rt:. TACON to th:i• lf.).:::` :•' but 1 rev; th-e; impression that COL PAPPAS was in i.thari.4:-.. of detentipn oneriltie.7ins or MP ofw.rtii.tiont; it run:c..t: CU,ne thr01;gh to me Thal' svva:,,.. Tit,: Nits wcrt: . resriciitsibl: l.6:-detentic.ill orn.-rwioni: n:.aial.t?.ing tlie eatitv dctetnitm Pacility. ..::.tirit ..,• and pwtcof, of dol.ailtrz.;:s, Thr): ;:iro;lot 1 ,-.;:,::0 , -1)v.ttion opt:ratio:1s. They ar:: no! )risibit: loT inter­:.:..3i .git.:? ir.,:::::Tos.::11::.E.' Tilt? (%n.h.; ...)citt 1 vicvsi . thcir nivok..enwrv. is it; rci4y::. r.•-•:_m'i -a; . mrcif.Fr.:):Ind informalion on .:::; Jetairttv a'S tilt.ty have an . opportunity to oh senT ttiff ictat i I ', t!(:'.:', --... -...'':i!. W . .....,: . et ti i'll.11;7i. : !I :.; 2.1?.00iliblid dispoidtion, did Ile ittteraci.. with otlic.t . if y.:(-:,...A:t.thv....11, -.) .11.f.'Ili, il, i.--.-i.7. ,nassive, no: alive aztivity.. Ili= is .::: vcry cit.iir; • w;di.:..,:: im:-ii:t:e) d:..1:::iatio-11.i'in ui:,..-:74.):Nitical opc.T20:ion6. I an not ;me how titcy Tilight NAN; vi ,;',.\• 3:.:j thti.i -irok on n'ilpiumcmtinl:. ,i,n;.11 :ilui , ..-: as Fiit..,g7 managoroont. CUL PAPPAS would :t..t('i,.• t.k.-.'ii:, ctialo: thc:•• had 1,,,,-;;; d .R. ,•1:i'i as tills would have Ivtii .doric lit Ow unit 11;.vei. I 2• 1) , ,,r, rtlw'w.s,::;,.T11; . tt:thritque and wc,U1k.'1 illive :11 "::..d:.::. ii::1', an atilhOli::'.L:t1 iT.'r.::::. Ivz:-;:•7:: ;:;p.:.•,;•;:vc-,:.; 6::.:' l'1•; ,::' (:(; i-i: 2: -::::....01).:(111 (1 S;Ity mi N%.3tiesti Ism thil,.. t.x(st.,.ption). I d.n.in't -!.; ,J1-..-..--,..:-.::d :: isi::; , :i•...;,.;•;.: planmn,2 0: -i ;:?;:i17V:S. :-.':: !:::::: iY .ZSO.:: f.a.ZI irty. ))., ::....;‘,..... 1,•.S.--;-”tiA: .,-..i...;:,;:a:;) i,.','S:::..1**ii ‘.•1 track thltIliTlel!'f, tvOrki. I.Vic:k. b1.1! it SVCS AO L:.1' fr;:nd;•,, ill•id •.,-,•;:y. r;i,i F.t.tit..xtc•t ;1. ;):- t•::: -;:;:i.,.:. ti .as 11.)e of largc scait:,.. c...oalition op:Talon. .1...-rt"..1 A...i..: --; -,,,.. -...:, -iii,1 itc tl.;:!. hes!: n•.:3 .-,: ,! Lt) :•,:ii yo;.: abotlt t.ht: N.11:-M1) collaboration on HATS. It Y.. ,....N1.).::1 v;a: :... z•• •,-si.t!. 1 '.ii:..;‘:':•:.: r::..1,•::.. f0: . primc '.:n.:. ::Tid Tt.::,. ic.:t 01 trig. is ramlirtni i z seemcd liki: thc •i'il.,.r..,. 1.1.-, .:.,-,i.::--, :.;...-;::- ki,•:.:::r•if.:::: . . for dale:Ilion oporntione, which tracks of (..:;:irRucc 1. :. 1::.:::: '..: !:'..':',.: n11 :::'7Ip s a.;:cmint fol . ti ,etarnoc. and their nockoi lid::t .., 7..' .,..- f:on) :i.::::4:t0ti 11` ¦ ii;-;...?:7 's.;!ht . 111! los.mg th data. AdditionaLls., `:...; (:SA•:: j ,.'s:o: , • . a p,:.%c _-,. (.:o...;1 , !: 7i ,..-.:. m1;n:11; 1.,;;ct-nt.is :ouldn1. -t1.1 tit? tr*.insirred to tiw : -:g-:: ,-. ;)...,•: Ci-:-::!;f1 . .: LIR' :%:1:S1:::r%.':.:. h ...., i:-..:;.i: :::::.:*01. The ::.3ATS devcioper:s irav;.7 iecti vvorliiiii: to : f•if,1 : t:: ',•; opt,:rz,.;ii.,r: •;,..! th.•:1! ifilt:gt.rit•c ,:.: rri.n.”1:its ootilti also be ‘1-...an.i..%... daza 1•s.. of . l'ht,. 1..T1c (f •JOC!rii•: ,.•. V..:::. I::•;;:::.,.`. !! as u e,:xpc,,ii ,.:51: nrcoply:.. 14? :ac our ha•d: aroumi Ow; nrolrn. ThL• :,sti o! .. •:Cj GLOIFTREV M:I.LFR %;:isnlisiteci ;-r,, eitil,i the joint SwiT or OSI). _ l: ', n-----: ',•, :ofr7.s ;If ;:i11111!) . :' :: v; ff.':`: I‘ .: ,....;;;:: mission ..10 =.11 operalionAJ miRsic.ns arid 1... f..( i S,•`, V IIH7 k`• PAM:7JY aiTCrlf.C:j l'is: V: ..;::.nA'¦ Ca': il;:, OIC P...):1.)1.1 ViRil.. I ti• i) 1,.?! :.:'(..."J 110 ¦!: 1: ";;;!S ',:`..'.-­ f:".:r:¦ :.':: ¦ • .;¦¦ "'•"•. ;:s nP n"\-`: , ...... NI I P2:. r.tI ocuF, vs,•a.',., to havc i1eCti 071.1.11::: Iraq: Stir-. .c ..... CirotT) i IS(0. hitt if, t....trAlof..: it ('.77F-7Oe....-.idQt.3 tilfyy Ikvre Itti itoinj,; to t-pz);h•,c., : sO !:!..•.• 791Pn :) ilein 1:1...:.M::::.: ',: . IL ¦ ':':ii 3:,..1.;! .(1k.idiril.: OfilL;;: i;:lif.:::* 1:71(i ildP i)ikz te::::1 :.i:' vs l: ;H•;:-..--r;: i!% gc.:. '..s... •• •-•..-;•• er:.;l,l.F.•7: ;.1114.1 IV.' prOVI(kli ill; (u;-hr.. r 1.: ;1 Ti.;nl',..:•;(71:1F.:2. ni :,..2.s in thos1/4- ii.n.i.;;;;I:i.::.nJ Lio ncl, klz();:, y..I.tat Nic.-; Miller't, ru:.-ttors t:.: il:r:::: ig:en i'l!yl.,:iii :1: -: i71 .'fi ,:ic ,:. lic looked a: both i,Itqai;.10c .n,1 inte.riogalioni”lerationf.„ Wo in.s.roc.,1 that there s.:-e renniher-of -thiilgs that cliiin'. apply because COM() wilt; dift'cronl. dt:it:. 1:-, ic CifIv1.0 docs not :cae:.il Iraq. Autlaorititn v.:erc.- different. (. -iTl'40 was a sell' :oni.i1in,-7(1 on---,.:ilt,7 opcNItin:.: in ...1 •.---i1c. f;,..7...ate.g:•enviroillnenl. rot us. interrogation ..atis. c1-• :3:az-. i. -, p1.-Tatioa v..ei. ,-- ..•.i:1:.,.: ...: ittn . .ii] par: of :::: Fii ,... ihin4s cc do in intei, intvrrogation Ix; ongoing onc ..,:is a!:t . ....iti:. ,flielpt; l;:AS tslyie:., a, ,...--. -,.1.1•;:zsar,... tn a cornim e;t:"uournetn. Sheer nal:hors oi . .n Ifi. • MAKNG S'fAV17N7-:47--,_ P.A.012,/Cir:s AG0000576 STATEMENT CWMG-BARLIARA G. FAST TAKEN .AT CAMP ‘,•icroRy. IRAQ • DATED 20 BAY.2004 • • azisignccr b th ADC ()IC. asttghoteins for C2 in his Dotity C.:.(and. V .Coris G2)."1he (1? (JF.F. 7 vrcr4:: itt di::: Corps Cs CI Cot.ps . iith made it a natura: for him to work att:5:pr: Krioh it:o! th.;:re fOr1 1. ¦ )• 1;0 it) thc; ADC, he seiected hIle. good credentlai--11,2vai.commy from •INSC.0i where hc: was the iniellige.u.• 11%,;:srsii!ht Officer. had anaivne de A: good renutation, and had arrivoi.: rh.,.111 Spleit•Lbe vent to Abu Cihraib and bogati it, • work foi PAPPAS as the wiii7C.()L. PAPPAS as bill • MD(' was part of. I •1 Lk y o!. flTim CO1. pAPPAS, not •r am told . 1•::,;! did 1•1:.): reeeive ffi; OF.P. du :,timc;i f.sition. C... Pappas Ma& jIDC operations hy7 -11tOved o AhL£ Clihraili uiNovan to 11:-•,";' :.i! the crd Dc::,.....tmlbcr. is now :i: and Intild Iraqi c4ipa,::ly. . . and ‘i :.1ter. .1 -ald grades (Ai Se:rit4N-. 1¦ -ttenior rate ail OR • vz:u.t ol the S MI Br/ vitantait assigned to the rsjac.;::: ticr j. wasn'ttv1ved in th detaik ?)!:: 1 11 3V'are that shr had departod le2Ve She Wag the ;YritiCi.P:e ;11:.: i1oiToi:::2.-,or: cpc'rrntOrt:::: Abo tj1uUt3 iuiii1 her k.11 .n1Titen.-okt.ation. pianS and `:11) only recall meeting OtitT. Hi: was I ..r.(1 10 sit dow•h with :x..3Idiers of the: TierTans UI ;.e;td thz.111 .s..licturt,‘--licAs , we were seizing !lc iii 'he ()vs:Tali effpri... %A:11v whni they 1:r.:.,...)7141•::. tv...0 and sed thcm how friiiko (1r, 1,•.n or:.• ot•tf: e,r11-t9Se. 4) 3.StIlltS Nviiat their lett and rigin Tht!.y lin said yes.I toid them erat: Itur...,:be lilt didn't LZI.Vf.' to bt? j • n(,;n\ -;:rn they 11710.:TStOad and tt total f IL:11 day. I also he.litve was.staikt, mt. 1.zti 1.z..1 that kids, I neve! ha(1 i OJ %);!en he 071.. n.n•epelv oh that ;S:it:C.nI Nk"I1S ap.d accounis 111 of which nt¦n:1n uuthnr:::....s. I iJSi individuaty., svouldhi ur; thal •wlnild • Chwtl :Aso met Sun, Rcv;ev,.. AbLi (.:;.1;,;•.. in IhOSCniori, I do a sinniar rundown of providlh,:.; 1.1%, );;;Inr.;:, i117,o1arl; t h cimmnd. prioritits. %‘•hat thy' re doing. :";•C v • PAGE AG0000575 STATEMENT OrMG BARBARA G. FAST TAKEN AT CANT ylcroRy, IRAQ DATED 20 flay 2i, ­ .i4 • . a CPA .MOrrlith.! upd::te. Km ot my s;;:tri wil;,.. lowed rn CPA to work Mu:theca= ;p3 oar. ol ate Joint 0Nrations C...:!IM . Sk.IT. Wt! WOrk•d '4..0.111 CPA On de5igniat an. h.f.fi!Nt'v­builit the i..ra05.tecurity i: -.a.t.s.w.iticii„ espe&sial.iy IOCUirq Or! the MOD and MOL COL PAPPAS didn't work tol: roe but &,,,c: worked toatther in what could be conervd , -•• - ,,-- the tori!til (.:i .s 2•I'vl: Cih•TViatIOntiinp: NR i ViC.VDAKOWSKI W.11:3 COL PAPPAS rater and 1..-tc, SA.NCI.TE2'. was hi senior rater. l iiii.:: not inow how ofteiz•they talk.ed. :I.ntit recently, I di ,.1 not !•alm... th',it:th.:: EI:ARPINSi,:;.1 Nk-n:-.: 1 ACC:r, to IITIF, 7; I aimtys thought she wori&•&n.: for NIG 3 DAKOWSK.! . • .1 'recall %-.16 V.,:'():9:',.1“.AVSK.I__ wori,inv MI vommand re.lutk;:.i !:5F,Liirt::, r::S.C),...tr:::;:' urtis:&.,hitto., supt-Kni to &ktmtto.r.: u:-..1.:vities. unit gequeru..tirt! rte. I didn't. work with '.B(i KARP:NS1.i :mien excel); tiwit4!, th::: Detairte.c Appeal and Releaite Boards. t wouid gee her Ic.c.c.tic:4::,' t!•': lht•7- .30.illt. Ot:it:sratioa:: Coller. Lsauliv at the evening update. but real'i never had mud: 1i!-(1;,, i.,.•; dC'',),;!::!.11 atIv1:int -:: of :,....mal relationship those were-busy times fOr me,. ' ..v1C; .k.q.).Th ..................... t ar.ii,ei.: . to .linvc n :Jose rrlationhip.. NG AVOSDAKOWSK i d !.': : ,:;c1 ::.'.:.\-'01 ,..::;,:l :1;. ,..L:il *.,••:!.;:: Inte.r;0;;azw: opt,TaiCra.S.. Cr,...d... PAPPAS wr...v,iicl kri(riv :XV; abOL;', .,••h -1 :,v0c,l...)A.KC.r:vSK -I's:, irtvolveiriz.m. ,...rom k‘0111Illand perspective, but IMG WO.M.A.KOWSK; • r:- . 4:.tri,,I i s:17,:::::.Lath:: t.,:rie or: th-e mx:J&.-:;!.. I f:.: (litIlitive L iloo( dzgret.: &yr ird.e;rine,. • ! When i: Unit-(.1t.r.....:nor, opt.:ralit.: iii hr, did 1-.., ,...:: i-r..o-c ;fine .)verail deleution operations. 1..k wits io -••.e..i ft :i 01. Tisc„3", :::::: r,:rsoohC: resources (MPs were gclixtet, mai foree !:t::'; )%1: t:1 ) 4, '.. : :rc neny da.iiv in'antsi. He WAS aisO involved with ;:•: -:::::inc:c :-.,, .11.:.: i..Ya.:. the driver of a work of iletcnuon - . . ;Isr,,-,e.:.:5 relat ;:.::: ti:. , i.:1.:... ,:1tic, :' :i::...inl::::s. . S;::;7:•:.;1; II;:L.: ,..,•:,.7 n!.:2•:•:'';'• :,..:Av tf.:. ', 1::•., :•:-.. I:iri :: ,:.›.;1 d':enliiIrl operiTiOnS nCarliMandtTS and action .::.:..:i i: -.r„: p :.,-,,,,.,,L.:d b.-, -.1-ir,;.:. io ithr e.irti.i iii -.. r%.i.. in ordrr TO 141:q. Snidarii:.0 and The way ahead The .:.::,-• • : ...•.:•..7:::::'.he:•.,...1e:.::;317d :-11 -::: IL; Aiit,i1s; .: September ori-tt.fruiri;,.... • opctitions orficcr for •(..I3T1:- 7. Ho liad ta.fi . ,:::po:1: ... -i.-;,-...:--. 1: :;,:::r oh:..iriit:o1 ,:.. :;:irt': 0:,..e...s.:', -• !:.- P;orost %Li-shall. In February. the (7G asked.vviv :.:ini-:.in! i'.•:-. 1,z-::: .:,. ki:::en:ioti opf:f.:::; -1::: ;:::, V:1. T. Ntlicr illi&t.t:41 that he was the (2('s man. . ..1 -k-..., ,nMi-.1 .::::. ,.,•d.-: Ri.zrno ,:.,,1 ,, ht.. !.bi...'.. for (it:ail:ton cperziltiom, Lan :ht.:. ;panty :\ls.-. s:I:,....,.. ::.ti:himt,.i.c:-..: 1.•..., (7.,.,11:.:::: ,.. :-,:11:;:-Ir;..-.. to illIcrITO.11.1. Tin: firs?. one was a TITAN 1:,:,,r!.;•:::-:....,]•::el: was p:sr: (.,::::; .1.:\ ,..(-):": v..orl‘vitit.' ;:ontt•:::;21. Vi:'..:. lit,tvc 41 Titait manager :.11 Camp U. :.•.:1 .:-:ie..:.: operat;:.,as and Ta::r• rt..ritc.einntives in variOus rctioris 1. 61' twe..n, iV.iit. arid la-:•:.iiis:; ur: a‘i1:114 .:tc...: t.,:: si on;t zid t:K; unit rias re,weon.sibility ior thcm. 'D: :.4:1::::: -::o::,:: .at.: • I.: .: (..?..f.71 ;..so::tri,.-— kr ,iII;;;To..,......4:or:-. The fire:r :.pntra,:.1 waii done it: .it:I :,: 200 .file 5:.,•::,i1::: i. ,..:::::',.ro,..3.?..:1 the Con:: .:,tet:hlf (..)111:.::: of tne I .);Irirfl¦;':0. t.j-j -intrriOr a: For. Biraelmen.• :InparnI isci.s ., L.1c;ii.:::. i:.1!.:7 S11711111 .C1 und;:r ,I. Dunartnicri of fieRmse n:r.. ..; ;I:iti.:.L.:rril wtitt Ille',... arc as.sitmed to 1.:; :.; Ccinractin, Offiz. ,;!-1(;:p: ,..;:.'nt:iti ,..e (1,7(K for boils: CO t '1-!"-• ::, ,AL• ( 'OR i.Mid jarA:::::' ,.. 2th.:- aoa 1:: was re;;;;4:-Al -0.... 1 ii,.' 4.. •&..i,:. s;.7r:.;;.• , i as ;:i. cr,-)TILi-JI: for th;-: t:nn: cc..-. 1­ n.' irr trackiri prrfortnam.e,::::•,:-.._:. :1:::...v::. v,;: ,..z... ...;:'..L:11 -%viz:: s,••:: ;.r..m.: I s0:•:?,::11::-..; Lilt' ri01:. zq:rvic;:, IA. ;N: rt.•::..:47:1 f..“ th:: iiTh: 0.1atithorny :or \I? units ;Ind MI ;min:. Pic Mf's are responsible svith that. .".\li resnonsihh: for interrogation •7:illi-';)S.n¦ i*".: ,... C'I.j.... i.:rOSSIWV1 . 1%r: .iWz`.I . :.: 0: V. :.1: •i::.:: ilC3 K.A.RP1NSKi Po •oneei allowed the k' e.scorz 6::::•ntrt.:=, LC, ;411: IrO:r the iLlerroition booths fOr interroiantiorn:), I. personally do 11,x. i•:::o&,.' extictiy wt-i ...: site retin-iee.: to :.-ormra.a.:. th'41 has. 1.11: . PA Pp.ks wo u id rvason. :NTI:.S or AKAI:; STA fl:NIE:NTIIII PAGF5i•OF AGO 000574 sTATEmENT OF MG BARBARA C.i. FAST TAKEN A.T .(::-AN1.? VI( .T:)RI. 0::,',.(,) DATED 2 it.,:IN fi..". ,....4 iv .as jp..li.:.ible. f..)ti.rirq: ..1 vi..i.:.:.; 111(I 0: 3,:i1::g1N. 1tiCli -W2.1.1... WI I?.: -.7i.J1 f14:1, :017.Itibi.111;;;:i k) i."4,1.r lowtr numbei. o!' ,:.u.ii..,',.:-.•. a...... cndlics ou;. ..sokilas exr:rienced 41 t]y...-11)ec!.lan lir:xi:ram: TECII -m)1..()Gy. Builliin: iv: zntekigertec arcluil.:clur: urid irsteilig.erice cApat.iiiiiies were •ev lo' U.:11:.:11 1cm:%:.. sic.' 5,.,3nl':,:.st. appropriatel\ . cleared indduals ar. !: levels ilnd 0:::il(alitttr:::11:I{A:kii 1:i ht: Z.Ii:31:: VI LicS dat;::.. .,\F, } rnemonzxl, ironJ. Illy ITIV-1.1ephly:11:I'V: Vitlit acti ,;:ils ::.1.: ,..;ineit 7-..1 math: in jahttar•, ! lauded the itaarogators L .7 i)k: and 1.....11.ii .01 .1. ! fT-senior 1;,!:,..;,., .; I';;;f..S ',..:.. '..:•:::'... corrirnand, is vas co:1st...tatty sur..ssd iiti.... vio.i•, h. .!'.:‘ ,.1:-..! 8.‘. on? wie*euce e.itort. WI:: le all OhL'. ai::erv..‘ie ,.: had thO.. 'ilk`.'f AL.{.3 1:1S:.', in: :1f.11I:As.a.`;:t.::': 01 :I.L"Cni*:: Tcps it:: 01.';.:, Ilaaly11:: COlge't :1.110V.V.J ac.1:QN:i ftwtr. $. lathiltif...t.s ails niortnati. ,, :,uiii makt: il. i.t . vailobk r() 31-"prorrizite wialysiF.. o;:snes -svcrc rito -::.iial 't.c analysti.; so Int.y could accefis infonnatior thenise3‘,.'c?hntht: nomi rrvvi; ‘‘'t!':' irisInirnental innavil..wing illrotigh`. littiRt! dr;tabliSCS. 1112 1\".'( '1 i:riiiirnmtion Di...innnani::c. Ct.-nu:7 .,,..:r!.; a eenterpiect tr., access and tc iinaiyt.P..‘ 1.00:S. V. 'as' ',Try ;::::1 , t.liti ...hin:?. ii;?..,.....:: ,..1•,,,: : ,-.,.....rvoh,...: :vas, on :-.4:ii.Tcrit syst.i.trr. and follwart. The.: iinkill?... ,,:a.,.--, r.i.,,•..:idcd Kok....-it to ItiC .7.31T•7 di .....n,.ioii:i :Art:-Iixi;:uutic. through Litt: Ai: Source Ariaiysi - S,,•..:..1;.‘m.. -.1..i....,,.i: i.....i.v-....nicl.:..h... i .),-.,, (1;2 iviti ,,....,..: k()rked hard to nol,3,. Tor . the firsr tint:. till':: '1111. di: iif::..'.... •:: : i:,.: ,::h .r.:. ha...,Qiiti i;vst;m. -s.n-• .:. the s -aart.... One oi' ii1.'. biggt. st winners wc, ..s'•••0":-L,..;..,j •i -.-:v1,1 '-,\. i.- :tie ::'llui.,.i:,-: Nfil-: apnlicxr.lori, 'k:%, it.iell allowed tor linked analysis -ii•i.1n.1:ar.`i. if. Ii;P•1::6 wantiess hours of uriai .yst till)t:t i'it)d trLiii:S, We procured enoug..h . LI •ti-N. di .,..:-i:: ,,;::,. .....;...-id ririokkiri, (1)1.ir goai is to field It. beio-,8.: Iti.:: -., :\:...-s. :t ...-ailzlil...: `..1 ',....!:.;:' 7 '-k . 1.1Cfl 1 thrived, but -;?,..-:::! cottli.lonl.. talk to higitc: . i ::,.::;..,., w ,.., -;.' cholienre., ...,A•::: -,.. as Triod.:1 ..it...ations ad .:i '..., nz...... tlivisioit..!i., tile VIV. fr1n., , -, i ,..;n,::: , .;ril.iii ,..3..::::loii...: O:u: it. , o:nr.:,,,:..nc:'.:.... it:-,....%.: 1:-.1:.‘ I.v.p.I.r1N.:10 :n Aug, but '-..'s n.`!kn-:: t.''.:' n'"'''':: n ..;01-• fis,1..:..".-n'f*I-nit'l-: .W..1.171; il.S. s•A'QiIIIV it; •:-..'0::.,.:n:•,,n¦ ., :::.:1 -:.H......'. v. -C- i1:1', 'i' s;n1:',...nk ,..-. \ -II' ....• f..t,s•:..izrice. suppor: ir. :,ise .AO i:Ind . -. . V\ ICS :Upiliiiiit :.1. tilt: JIDC due to bandWidel) ',.1.).:1:,11.-:::::: :-*Z:: '',-..:.: ,:1i:.:; `A'0: .iiiI•1',2. Or :!nT1 ,,..- ,­ .::::.....r.....i: .....)o corriplIn.. und ..it is hard li:v iiY. to he goil1......i I:: .,H , , , i-:: : : ,..J!.._•clitill., 1:',.;);1;nLt...;.: coi,,..i h::: )flan-mii or nrateoc or Yiet, vereta. Tilt' nail L'Ii:II:.1 1.1%::.:-r : n iin& h_ ni.'n• :•:11';',:1!. ,..'r!;;-:. it nter.1,;.:: it nil -Wi; a.rc now worlina afi gotny bole:: S 1( i.: VI" Corrananti arid Staff Rules .K Relationships - lrog-Avitle: Tiv:... (.."..:,, (1'4 ;Ind i :1/2ere rl -i: :..:(.1.......si oiIksers to,. ::::f: -. C '.- Ti -7 . il I 01 . ili ....11'tiVitl:' ¦` -iti'in NA .Cd:S: 0 I nael ()Iite:. 1; 1:11L'.1;1]'::::11 . 1k; Ati.I1;:;. 1 kV;1:.:. C011:::;:•ti:::.: :.:1:! ..7111::.'. :Ink; inlysn...t5Sif,q1 lila! I i1.11.S lite111:: 50:11 ill lf. ;.'..:.-. :,,.); .::::1.1;:1;? th:.:; \\, ,,I,•¦ k.01:‘ ,..-1i- -iiil.....r I. i (1' ,...1---i, ;-..,,,u; per:0:11,11:;::: flrilhahtiv durno.; the War. ..!..,:,..11:(::,.: ;., 1;:,11.:., 1: -:.1. import:1:u.. So I , %-oi -: th..-\ c".',....r:if paft.1.. Orr (......Y.:r;fli:ii . reiauon.:;liip was Id-:,.' :In',. -i'ill .::'n•1"::1::. `.::::y :-. Cf.illtinalid :+:1'.71 i.::'::: .1. '.'il:i, ::h:::in.:nN'1!: ft.'"1):.):1;iiblliti: are stiir ::,1•1 011.::j!:.1.::,::•!:: w: hai:lit.::::•:174: ,.... ) .r,.:•:. ,...i i''i;..)i ...rt...., S.A.W.H.I.1 wa.:,.'. tlic. (..ornirnandin!:: 1 1).AK(i'‘S:::: ,.... a, ..i.., 1.); : 0 ;i t:;.' 1..:0. InIxid cl- ;I:)(2.i::',.) .:: , The OC(3 :z.....•::tarar.: 1.1:11!,.. t. Mi. Nr-..' ;.-... :.C: and fot.74.4.4,,,-.,J 0:1 sliollori ,,I cti vilic:‘,. il,: cc: : i.i: in,-con,,¦ , :,! operation:, %lost 0 . t:ns. inti:ract.if.in vv-a -: v...nt.i :.21'.(:; AN(714137.. I v.,214 the Priic.;P:,ti nOR..1(11.411 in (11'.! Ci. 1711TrIalUi i (1 :' lit:: tnidily..C71C4: pur4:- ii11it1!1 itItOrlacC in ihai rimi..... v.--itii ;'-'011nassiitior Brt:ritrri;::r unt": illi. irlan .,s. • ; s!..“'" 1 roi.z..1:i .••• :••(!"---,, or ITiy zirr,.....;: (a.mr. , Victory an•50 1 .!....,: al. lilt: (.:orilition Provisional .4.01 ,.101:l .; C..P. ..,\ 1. 1 4,,:::1l :. lot o': tilt -w v,r.1 -: C . :),A pv.roilyi.s.fl and AIVIl.i.A.SSAIKiR. RREMliii proA..i.: i.:::. ;w..:...ihF..en ,,c brIel.-::.,n SS nBREMM ER f.-..ve.r): tyornini?, followed. h' INILA. i..S ,!....):;.; 'PERS() \ \1 ,10..INC...; S.7 AIT:MEM . PAGE:14:W 1/4,-1-PAC3L - AG0000573 DOD 000660 STATEMENT or: 4( BARBARA G. FAST TAKEN AI . . CAMP VICTORY, IRAQ .D.ATED 20 JUI.A.7 ..::014 rvisory rol. : , ross.i...isi4 c:n .pri.-!,...ijirig limeit.. reif.".r.trit intoiliyerid to the conairana; ,..; :I:M .. • 1:If.:• ilf..117 ,::', thz: ...]ie:• -...tt:::, arKi copabil. itict;: that rnab: intelligto -ux oporiaixt. " tic .,:ret:ito:­ IF...C.' ,.,....t,.. cull-inns:1; ol. c urns a....i:.a.i.:., ailu V:. :...n. lti- \'3 ? id e tntii Vit114:,;t A 1,1gM ent et S yStf.:1T-; ( Ili, 1.:',,S:: no:VIC:0115 Oil 111:: joint Manninv.i)oetiment 13N11)). IA:e had billets.. but the.,' . .w. eto 1101. t'ver fili,:d. ...,;.... `A'e h:ad :oJJ rerri:sontatio.n from tiN:. National Scourily Ati.tatcy (NSA). v...h:-:• 14-. • (...'- S.,.:C.:J.Cir. ;:1: -. ,.: P:\:SCCThel.. w ;Yrovidt,..d. ,iippon lioni th...: Inforniati: 4b:,3 1Lli10:i oir... .1 a 101M-,,1 •¦-..rY.L1 1 : 1) ,:rni: . cf,. -.., :t. :•:-tl!..)i...` . . • ;..1.- ;...-::,;., dctani-Al TM.TSOTM.1 h.orn (1.7 NT('.();v1 ()02.„. 1)1 :7,-Cootii(. ....1:. :t?•:,': '....:.:::::...i.:J u...,....: •::•... As a•coitcorte:: offcir t:) roort; ,....: ttIOTI.:.. c.:iitIlitlItio .Fr2;1:-, 1:,;:. -.­ 1 ri.i.-i .iL. r..." .1:Z.L.Wilbe: ,..!:. '.. f., .:.i!' .5.1,...; ti ..:!!".and 11111i011a .i level,. the al; sat logo:Ili:n . 10 nr4SS tilt' IOC:Lis, ner!'), ::Li'L': avi::::::::.y citvaliiill; ,.':n ti•::: vory hard insurectioy and terroris.ni•thn•Ntt$. We aist .I.-.77LIII1:•Ik' 10 nit yl'; 1:31:it•isb aad .: ,..astialiatt partioimaitm. 1 rocitpailitzt:ti them ivinzoIly to ni. :•.r., i•.ottcr.,...;.tional k.t. ;:.: %.'a:ii,.! and n( -).1 ., : . .. i-odantlittit with clwon intolligendo atialy.K. When C;..):-ns .,:-..:s in nrf.'.r;.: :,:. i').1.1.:}.ti•:.:S Chill May); goolz.raphie t•intanization was :•:...,...,......;,..'.,. bi.•; .. l':•• .n:: ..:c:.: i.:.) ! ,-: ,,..:..... r.b.::7 3:1.:M.:11: eT.:Virnntneni., MiSS:0.11. .V.I.CIM... 4.r .3 -,1 \- C::::';': ,...'• . nS:::'.: V...... ::. ..., .%I ;...'n ULM: .,.& Ih• from .. arc.ilittictkire 'us U eit::parturt - • OT ,•;i2:ii•I:i :11:;',21. 1:rijit11 ...:8'..•Lots1,1'::: 1: 11. : CLI-11--e:' (NI(T) Dian. Whiza Wo stood up tilt! 31..1.-ri:-1:.-. ,-,.::..,:,...-:,.....,.. ,:v.:!---, ,.-1:‘,1 ...-.: ..,:pa ,..•:., imd it) ..114.....1•1; was t.....;:i-Ityeated 111 a trollor i. ,::.:• -: ....::::•.::i...::. . '...;.• also ,.: : 1.(...:: (..cli and i: C.:2X tiCide in Tril1iCr5 due to f,paCQ (1 rm :::;•sinced this NY:IS: 11.1C right deCiSion. (...k.)ii.:111()N. A NAl .VSIS (.1:1.1.. TI.;... (..:ool•ition cell syrti in thy Palate and \vat; raakk :.':p ,.•.: : r....::.:..):•:: , .. :::'; !•:1....li:c.t ..1 .. th...1..:. •I i.c.-, eporated i.i.: the ;:ealititql oialtsitie.otion level, whic1 . .:,::::i... ,::• ::.:: -0 -..::::... ¦ ': --1::I•... ..:1.....• ..'..: Li .:Ci.:;. .aathor :hail give thorn the ionic. typos ol . -tive• dim tv.si.a:. at tilt: coalition olassilioetion '..:::.:,-, an-.. .1::.••;.;- ..:::•:•:: ......,:.:: ...: :' :.::: :: bac::: I :z ::...,..': .. -: -.,...71:- .; ,c,.. t):::.• C:'!iii:l !To.'n ,.!'. `." 7--':1 in'- "W '.j :.' n:li,(.':::rvaitc. .'... So, for :::x oritplo, tiiey. ;....-..•;:..:...,•:s... .,.:: .-:: ::: •:..... 1.: .• .. :0711•J0:1, :::U.S &mat:tics. atiaok alii*.,,sis. ::::..:.:.::..::.:-:,: .-, :.::: .i v: ,:...'•:: .....:::-....:•=:.:•...::-:: ‘...• : -, 0 ..1,-:.' :...) ::•s: .,..::: ,...: :....i.-. 0 '.:7:... :-• ;11:-, ...•,.:::::i .,':.!;•:•:r....:.: :..,..: :.1.1".. nU'i ,:.:", h;:lped provide 1.1.1ca.:.tbit:. nrf)ducts to :.%:e .and ileir.il the t..iniied Nations with tl.n.L..3 1. :-.,._.. ...• 1.,.: ,..... ._. sii:1 ,..:•:• v.0: i:. -,::: ....,-:-.,....- INTI.:R N.( )CATION TI.) AN.ALYSIS. .-•\!: reports were a . vailoble to the IFC arid th.:: : •;:•:::::: n . : --.,.: ...1/4.ere ilna;;...- aH ,.., ii. . reporting ilitci IfIC A.utoinated NiletiNtago H -..:H. -. ......n: i.-:\ '....., De: -dr.... !,.• toclin':-a.;', and prst.inn:.1 ...:4Faic.i...), int:....i.n.y.vation ronort: • ,,,L....:,ii,:::::.v,.::::..:ti::.:':'•; : avaiiii..... :0 C:i..: \.:::::.;.:.'.. ,:1 .•;:.!ezion:s. :',.,.....; .: ..-,:: :Hs. -....•n i ...:.):. :•....:01:. reperi,-: ‘,......:.• : -::::1: : ...:s.....:LI ani.; t..I LL';' pf f..V-,:lt.k:d !he N.:st inforniatit.in iv...al. :able .....Kilirip:::.n;\ yo:1n::::' ,-... s.'. .,'..:', ()IV ilom ittr,,lr)vzseci 1.:xp1t)1,;!•; !.),-,...;!•nII:..:);.Iiilin zInvihir:L!. Cil.::.n\I• ,- i;.,.in',. L.'Nr•:11n•.%11 DIA wizo iocust;d• M this trcoblorri. I'.."..: r.I .: ¦ ':',. .V.,:::": k,.1:!1•n.,.':' .'.::.: ••• ¦ ::1,: , %¦-;:i.': 11 .:.:11 -:;r::'.?. Olt:';ii.. nHe v...utilt.: road ftto 3'.':',:•:-":, 01.: -,: ,,i; ,:.:1: v,:)!-b..'nCiosely V:10,, :::;.: ;;;;;J•ro:...!:AC$T': .t: I:•;::: ilD:-.n11:: v...ould send cluostioi . ts or ,..a.. 1:•::.Zt.• to itL:i•-, '..t,Trii tilL.: i:netTL)(:110:•; L.)1 ,,tis.• ;,'IL-::::iill! ..C.;i iMiV1111; cotrm'etierir:: WIth 1't 'S\ WI ',.::', 1)..7 in:nY. -n'. -,.:11.., 1::... ir::-..:.rt...-1:,.:.:,.(.;.nTiw Ii.,Irgt.1,inu, pu,,,...i. at the i•-:•:. ,v(-I...:.• Llis c' 1.:'.:: ".....'p...'1.¦ Ull.i.1 1.1:.:1:n ...... III:. II:r.: ,. F .::1 Or 1•::!•:;;;:i n;.;., *.• after bow& rnaiiers i•in. . 1 : re...lie,: .):•::::iai ion A f . fz.:: Li! ..... sadda;..,..iir-i• unoovi...rt,d and VS' C S uo.cessfail: '.: .;::: ,..:"..'.:':i..' ,... ::;:1.1 ,....;.1 ­ ::.•: ..." ...0,14.111:.-;alit.", ..,i0t....; .;1;,1 c.x 2,¦. 10 i ix ;oil . v„:c wert. 1:1 ,:t....r: . --.•abk: irs loo : 1::1,.n n::1 \:::. i-;.:.,i.1,:.,%,. to he :ti-7L,•,:;.7t:11 :. 111.11 1.:S3diiiirLiWil:S.atternptiflF i‹) I . 0..-.,;.:;,i)j,: . ,,J.,....1 . 1 .4.:i.iiit-.3:-s di..i*:. re.:.:,1::. n,;,:n .1;01. :-. :::-r; i hi :.--¦ ": k'ry niiT(t and tune sensitivc t•:,151, : 7: .,:.:::...•...' lyi.)::::, ...-:.oporationS, :.:;iil.' :::: i..-.. ::::.n 1C;.;.n t.',n: tinpL;;.1-.Ative to turn information into t, • .. iill. f)Zi:SC.),'..... \•.I A I.C .;N:(1-:.n•.' "...11:\117.NT PAGE Cid.).1: \ .- PAGE AG0000572 sTA..E1:::MEN1.. OF TAKEN Al (:•MP V.1(71().R.V... . I)A1131.7) 70 it.11.Y ..f.Ki. lit:iCovrfi:1:; -! . 1-i'lt:. 472 ."..\; I.-S.-tlw s',2f, unni3::!:;tr,,,:m. ant.', sv.ncliron:Lmior.: ticlueni lor 1.1tAIIV ;:ount=ttelltpz.ni.-oitt;I:11CIn ernpitasts ; Si'OTiuf. ,.i.,. .:. (i.i), proNitint ,.? Rtiorilits, iaatistical ar-e1y(...s.s, Stzs.liatliolvz.: iltiff..t:.‘t' (..NIC;()M ;:llitii !1/4.1111:,,,. art(i $iserninnttoo of r;rxwiitig, ;len: \yen: st:m:.-, cmliaths vd.v..: .kt,:vr-. cto-ttet.wrt: and reoik: helped rnake itivtres.K. Tilt-rt. :k.a rio nt rprt:'semati:)n front 1 ...11.A's DHS. I ,,...:: fothilix 4irC:ati., ‘vith tile (.72X. stmotore of ilklit ako ut.1:..lpit,td ti .t:i5 Ofg:MIZatiO51 .:1. EL.;(1:(1)M. l'ill. (72`.1/4:: matured with the ',1rrivzi: of persinutel. five firtzi hvir1;:l. the Cf.ione: k5414.‘$ ,:rri ,..,.i.'d a:. th.:: .v•ery end of Sertomher. LILA rnarty othv7 ••••':'-''..: 71 i.:•'•:-...'• , i l': ., 1• 1:-Mi 1:....n(:).:-.1*..2iirl',. -'!••••t.'?'," i"lj.ron2- il "4":'::i -.,.; ret.to111.: cat:able o: . iitr: :•nC(‘!r•V.;r: . st.it..1N-i;.NI -;:zIci CI Oper:ilion: (prrficiriJily dur rs irr'ik and v,ettitrJ, priu ..r..1s in :::.. ..:-: h:.i.(1 a.“::: -td .s... i-,::.tn :-.: rorm2...t: ./..0: :yolit,ctior. eMptaisiS iri Atig.usl and it it(it tuti:t. l:totet .. . ; ...,Tiit .­ ,::: .. ,;hich ;:. ii•.... 1 1.12 C2X folks kier: out. at At, h (Await) C.,,,Cr:., :.11.:R:!.1•,1] .%.. 1,0 work Otr. C. :;i::::C[i( ,,: :•TI:.inli:.::S and uncienstand the .111)C's e.bilily io satily iri'C.7:'::. ,:.::: '•::.-;:::•r•:11"4.::'::1:s. as •v.-.:.'n a: V is. from. eitht.,:r th;.: Ji.).1C. or ClIT.7, Vi;tits 1;;;:.:',•:.‘ :.,.::.;:itp of days widunit good ..sth::. e ,.•.:nhr ro.e: :: so poor Lila': titc,ri: izould flo i: ir.:::::;:. .1 ii::.. :11)(.: pri:4.1:;:;(:`,n-;;;rjori.s, statislics to \s•::::, ,........ ,..:-.:;1:.......: i..% :;;;:t: .„1: the C.2 verrt, interro;.pAtion .1%)1:;).‘:•.?n .-.,1.,..; Uv,. oc,p;.143.t.t.nr .': :A1,;: 1.....:hp' , i, lind wil0 vv-,:i... Of.mielligence interc:it. 1 -4.)\-1 ,:::: , :: ]n1.:77:Tc.'”:-.;.:1::::: s:n;31:)...:rts wa5 aiso an ov.i..sight rtt'chanisin desigilt:d t;.) rn.::,:..o::0: -i.: :.:1111: N.: Cf.):ii .:..i :l!ld f.ain 1.11.)•f :: .:*.::•',':'_.:;i1;.:? ,.:: IflibtrilitiOn4:m M0rt' signi ticant Entorrogati ii1::: ,:,...' ;So ,: t.;:t:-: :III Siif.111"::: .1ffi'ityit:i ef. A eimbination of th pnr.ch..:.1.artl .11:t...nved f()r 1...aetter coliection :atI, oz: ..,...:1;.: ,:a; a(. Hi.;: f,....r...;:F, PIRs; A:,..; the detainees flies were sero to . ..:) ,,i 1[DC worke.d in tandem to orovitle infomlation or: : . :...por ::. ':::., .hat.: rtao;rive..,:: on that particular dtaine. .I. 1 ,-..­ ' 1-,.:-.. ‘,01- ,:ko a:_:!pct: ,.:, :dcluify :::,i,.. , tly...c-,..:::: -it:h. z:d 1o:. 1.hK...ititcrrt)14aiion operatitum, ‘Altil:: the i-,-;.-...;Li.• ‘...,,,.., -.-..H.7-.0 , :.;:1,: ,, for x:dt.i .:..: .,...!:::7 , ...::: , ::. -: -!Av.' C2 p•ovnt . . :1 1:. . , ...::. 1 hc!p: adv i., wisii t.aocc.,. ..... -H.: ...:.• - ,,...)---,:t.-d „:::::.1 . ,:....:, §o..:2: 1... s-,-:,..i.t :1:0::-,. -..,.! .,:-....,.. ;1.:•.:..I . lin:N.slore. .1t.V1 F: rH.-, .i.o -,i.:: inl...--..s.....E-.. :....,,•, ;;IATI.) foroc. ;vas noi p;Art cl: th::.. ilDC: ,..,:::,...:•: ,r, ­ :',:i.,.. ,..:-o -:.-rat::.171,- :1 ..:i:::;ioi --,.. l'i. .. \T:. =.‘..:4:i to ,....-.11sod initivily on ;7ountl.:. on . thc- nu:Ines, z11:. ',1:.in2.:, :.. ;-,,-... :;nal)ler and if' you dc11 -‘. it, Yoli Ink tic ':r.:-. ,•:• ..::: ;,....,:!..io:: :-J op:.'r:Ii... ,:: Tb:: 1..Li:. :";.,\ . -i. t .:::::,,,ary1"iotn.;.'1'..Ini.:1Stzconty and NSA trre• 2-:i "l'=".1.,r"-J1n.': ..'•••• -1:ATI"n.A.1 th .• : ,: -F.:: .. ii:=\*L. :I C:1+A:1..%.7.: ',Vi:Iirt 01.:::' i.q. Ininitlit);1.. SO t: :::::•../.:'n' .:'[;•':!' ,.,::-1.n.....:::% ¦ ';7,:::',...;niin(.:n:10\:Cl0p .,1;.:....!:'. ii.:ii2:-: Wil) i);1*+".; 1 1:iinii:.-,-.n11::..`,::: Wt.'.1 .f.' tik'tilinC .:::!-: Who LIA)• -ititAi haviiipnct Of' :-.; li:c.' ::::' ,..Ti . .n r . ; . : -w;, 1;::: 3..)',..1.:-. ,.:s.i.,..1,-Himi., 1:: , 111C I'liViTovi•ItOF, .V.0 OW to lilt .H.D(. W ..:.•.-:- ,.- .nd..1:. , :;........-•: -) -n ;s.h.:::i,.:::.:; H . ;;; .!,...:,;;;;: ; ;np:'..),),.i .!. le.:.:tilIJC;H c.x.,:alts.-. il:•VIT did F:orth.. ri.. ,.;i:..:111(,...::::.V. and yo..toper7:!::: tn•...• ::::::.:1';'..;t1or:: oi: htmc:re.iis of rniliion.;,., or dollay,,.. ,..•:/.:":: ''is, 1 •11•!(", 'nCii• -':‘. :2(:nbaCkninlo ira: :.):7N -.21, -)7rx:tr. 1, and to ht,to in !ht.. avy.f.;:oprtlew.. t•:. --. It :.4.1 Tit::: .11ATI' :..d..;:‘ i:f.. . :;.:...: ,A, Itb i&..:n!ii-2.. ,in: and rist,..;riol:. Ls) t- Non- coi..-..:!1:Actlt ”.. !).. ­ ...-•:•-• :1-7-: .!1.: ,:17'..::: t.)1 .:...:::;::: ,:;071s (Nci:"..)? ..--,r ,.1..,-r. Hr. :n7:1....,.%, ore ,:.n;:f":.' ntnnber or SI.ISI)::::: NC...i(Yi.;i.::: :­ ; .r,::;:::: \,;:::: tv...: ,:;::;cstrc .nlIF, supj;',.?:-ni.i..1 .: : ,7%.7•itit ir: iiiit-;..n. x¦.;):41 cios:.Ar will; 11)A 10 Nt..f(.?., r::1&:::z•:7:1 If.' opv'Zi.t .s . ii: :•le c ,,,intr'• • In N.:*; lic;,:at.::,tf.: 1! prOviCie I.;:s fur StilltP111.; a h;:•,:..4aolf.i;nor:. Sonic N(...1( Y.:- i;Mi Cs.c , ino.u.:11.c..s ..k.c.r....,ti .:z.t.c.:1.1:.11;:11)111 to ()lir effort the:, .ic:.....it:1:: COIT1;,:411:1? -¦`.i..if.kt.'d .1 it:: L.15.: to • •• .V. (10W11 44;;C.mItS jtlibilted Wilil : \%.*I':, ( .):::'1 . r:.,4.1i;ilt*:i. other 1......7);,:: of opera LiOn:; . l f:( • .1 . 1:•:.. l..1l.11i..-,c--1' L.T, (. 1}:-.C) wz): ­ ....J to: . Inc. "Ilic! i$rn2adc! ::.orn.rnandc.;.. as tilt, coYr.71 -::tr:-Je:T and :::isca n • m:.:;.71.'r. and I. as the still! C ., . had thf‘ r)'.... Pi:'.()N .,1,-:\.1, INi ., :':;1ATTAIEY's:'.1 .111111112n-n T'AGF 501 .:',''.¦.PA.C.ii7. AG0000571 DOD 000658 S-.1%4:1-.I.:MTNIT Or Ma .R. AR.BA.R.A G. FAST TALEN.. AT (AMP ‘..'1,Cfl.)R Y. 1iZ.AC. DATED 20 . . have tit:It' pi an ki;e. you wi.tiki• do 11ot-trial onaatton, IL' 10i: 10 the ins!, yoil can with JZ•1(..;n `101: morph arid opefirtt; stimti ttp ;.Toe,edure..,.. anti tmnabiitie. ,:., and you ITy t& nlake e•s/er.y day a irU.cu And, -you prodilee. tr:tclhgence as y..-;its tilc: cnettly i i1 Ju ).'ott t!:vktf-7' 1,10y ;nOn:" fOi. you At filmic porizt Fall, we. td•d on::? m?.•son 1.;) run c•IC.%; 1110::1•3:.;ii:'IS of issues.. 1n this regard, Nr: liaye ff1:1 f.:s•,(rls,-;trz:tviicom.mand and 8,.oritc4r.t;.: t.o lo;;;... ow for ;,u)d the titat Offie• walt a.ppropriutc,1n1 :her.wa..5 no 0,irtt Fitv on e..o:fiti take :his ,•-•!•: 4:1 nt.'CI ;lid amyone MO Nititer I 1.%:•1(li thectc...1 by tile fit:-.ntagon, Saricht.-7 said t•it' • Wt:.:iIi mJ stalcd that GIN.1.0 did 11(4 We op,:,-rim•:. clthi-rc.nt \vc much iarger ;nsuiar trr.r.rtion is on:v•nne smatier part of ths: PittLua.:i• elftnt; ih torni%at ; : ".inibk,srs and '; ,....p"sntititintiXt'S vaSiiy larger. :mil I at teas: dillfls rtri M(3-CiEr:OFFREY pi.rs,;!`: f.mar:sfSS tbeiint interrogations di/f.: th.:" 'uL inI n s UZ:pt -;11 H-sl thC.' Wuin. (7.C)L. PAPPAS aod both J-e de ad.t.g.:(thtJ1I)C.; mode:. thin' c•sritterylltguoon ilooths. thc ' !Lit.t.tc; et%Y;t4tisciet.. we.1(.)cizz..tt hoothl; flitrrr.: AS notirtit.ir ;•• !I:1)( ¦ OVC IX% 1)1 .LI .111)(7. ihr: oireadv It•Y:)kect 1.o app)' ovt.,7noperwiori:, CO!. PAPPAS iiis ov.ti operaiion to nieet t•Ar iret.;d.. • 111L;12gerle111.. eIC1. I ••0I'kCil V.ith ;7;'N 1.1;;" 1"..iC171;:711 I Lb.: ity and rtmnimt :11;1;1.... ;II Jrnato,,,,atws tint: ooertiicin. As 13Lit. I FA. :11t.'vt.- it 1:06e. C()1 !)n lo-4dership k,,,;.;!';!. :1110 D;:crribrr tiiat the •1 IDC ss,..u:.; fully cliplthit: noIi. !: thc'n TranSiernAaitlICtritV 205-111 M.i 13DL kuld tit( 50.1th M 13D L nThninwJdc.tv.lt thcy ttns.stoti le•v2;th dt;rulcn .n. •ki..•4::11.:td capabtf..; t..,•.%inrttm..•.:: anti stnlior RSONn \L\111' 11. LtOF kAC •n 1ATEMENTOF MG BARBARA G. FAST TAKEN AT CA:NIP VICTOR\'.. IRAQ . .!).ATFD J 1.;!.:V 24(4 V (7(11): ti'oat a corps nit'sstoit to a ;A:Mb:Tied joint task tome miw. A rrie,Jiantsn:. suhrrlivxd K Pertapon tfink fry cerinrrtrnis very •erirrac:... and wa. .; Om! thC (71:\ •t;':n hirn bettu::. an info a .. dre.S5CC On the original tagking •k;N:111d:::..n Boykip t1)c4. , trip hi f.n. 4:4 L'Ifort tc look t.'anI J h SLn1 knintht..7.y c.oukt rendez. Thciririrwen.: separate and t: an d U to n1‘.: Aiemtader put toge.x.ther gamc pbsi) (r) bow • 01' tht in the recltiuval nrena. LTG A le .xander TCP0i.tict SySi.:211: (A1S) tcr tts .+vall • t I-, a gotf: ai)iteit or tiZip i:Oth ;lac al';0 m is 1 _Analyst Nott:b('oi . which effectively linked h t Jolla interrogation Debrieting Center i.11.1.)C} • . -...-:, :nnnuticatiori System (MICS.i; ASAS-Lites this envirtyaratrirt; the INS . :()1s4 IDC Porta: ''''''''' tit'n itlICrri.1Or to leverage. worldwide • :or :te.a.;111:;:ih!litV. ilriaiVtiernittrtragror conalloration iaJ 1-101Th: checks on bad aCTUIS. an intelligence system. ells:. • 01 rth.•.sanic 'cam ono:: tt.) Use. Abu (_;ltrailt as tlk. Deleution & Interrogation Locution: -111 1.-thi(k:..ne:6roI arrived (or at le,ast itist rr. ,.zI %Va.::: '..S•hyInk.-n1 di) legICIItiV.,",' hearing Snirrpct:3 ilh(tat KIghdad. 7YlvP Abu Cihrolb was 20 m.‘ 7:1(i1ti; bC•ing nr.- i` M. ilen I CtiLlIc..in ' t Met: My I )C.:';'7n •n Febtliar`f:, N'%IrCh. May and •.' n;.! , 1n1 :" n rnr.".yn On fn':.'"n ;..:(1J:113.r .,.;:ily,L.n1 facing a great y :t1 ;did rt:,' tr.ake:it hc•;:ot .;t. of the 1on Ittf, !al:1:10 SCait.' Ont,ITIV b;11.n;nNV:: ,..01":!;111.iel 11. 3•13 ,..'OM:W.Ibim AI 211::n ..\ugus: 1 bar-:::1)011L'S and i -;')'-.;i; Iiunib0)..dc;11. i irli;;;,:sn i n t.i.tnigence. 43I:d riln1 hefirrenn:1;7rtIvator.... arrivcd, with a in;errotsitt...tr time ztad not tlad prLitated them for Ai%; 0! . (•01 T.VC.)1).3A.i:OWSKI. .111)C . . t:1 arcai, ti,.hercU IILf 'ndd up t.;ri the battlefield. thc for tvral beyond the 4icticiti 10-ay.; 01; (711aliCT:2:e ".tnd w had to fi;) ;nn ccss.w.iozi Ci iliis iTtd titt: PA(....i.E -10rvkPA(.31:.? AG0000569 STATEMENT (if MG :BARBARA G. TAKEN Al CAMP V)(TORy. IRAQ DATED 20 JULY 2Th04 . tinrlakihti, a we &tort:mental bii!et:::; an;i posiOons. The SMD took a. lonli ttinc to be y IP Ortt::ratt:. 11 1 11.r.::!:::, Wli;.±.11milered till ane ottr atiilit ­ U!r•!:a.S 0.10Fticlil In VCSt:gi:t10:::: or 4::ffici .: .. ;:6 testimmy 1 Ir.4.,. .4.: bcon questioned abotilll ...: .:\ loi... i.;itrall; ai .iti iineliii!.e.rie._. operations in ii kJ th.IS(.1-11.1±SINGER. fildependeni Patnei. ‘ ,• . 1c.s..[-' ... . Al.):8.11I,I.A1... 1.:.:H I. 1.i.:.::1:1 4 , and tv.,ict' by I'vlf.. J 'AY . I Itavi also heirs ,;;C: in ans\verinl:, a number (3•I ot.:1:;iltiott,ii by thc Sl .an-: tnrrently the C2, NINF-i. and . U11...7 ......N.A.TE and. otiict. Vt : as tile C:2 fe.q • ,ost7c:.:•;.,:. hth.. 70::;i7.,. I .s.a.... probabh• s..-.i.et.i ii., , the C:•2 for C:SIT..--7 bcat.1 ,,,z1 v....tfi thz;.'itios': :.,n7a ,:JtIv 4Va.1.ii..':..• ??.enen:tIcittier and ilild s:•Jrnt.; c -xpvmancc In thv arca of:operatic:11s. As the (.::, •;:: .; WOJ DA.1:.(:)1,1,rSr( f :.. De pu i v is. .:ammandir4.7. Genova:, .C.ITE, T. My directit)m, c.ft ron ...I.Ci SA.NCEZ. I did hi-:.•-t.. e iet oldialof.,:av with the S2, ClICS(1tl . 11(.);SALI) BijR.61:.r.SS) i.m.C.; .1 . 2.. CENT(..:O.M i1...5(.$ ;()J \• Cl..', S•ER"), hut rn:y , guid.ance,earne fr(ntitLIV SANC`f•if ...• 1:3C.:: Cl'.US'IER t. ii.i GEN Ai3VAI1 usualry ihrit.FIC,C.13STER) _svolild relay aity. ..-,:::-...,..'..,.. ;1! ,:1-.0. ,-.s.J . :;., S ,..1::::: tilf:: . 11;1211: nAli•-2. lc) ',A:I.:I!. ii":1;. enemy was dng,44S,S2SSIntAti.,.. leChni)iUg:‘,•, or 7'. s.1,.!.:;.ml .,-... tra;:11 . lif.:TiC'C iStiraC.,. .; 4:i'..t.: liIC hit.";ST dia1012.'Lie With M(...: BURGESS, -who PL."11%.a.i!..'n ', .(n': illteR:,S1S. IlleSe WIT usaaliy gc.neral discussions. .„, :•n• n ,...-.:,:.:.: . •,.! :,...: . ;.i.: ,: .,:iyo:-.1.,:-. ,.:;:'...Al. tullie.?; of irtf: , '-'711V `Cnlzt terms ni-:,:'...•J';h:ii'::1%:: i;: 7!!;:i; :)::::1);:l L.:7U. COI ¦ C f.'11 iS abt)tit i):: I . inii'i i 4.'1 . ....ficl:ret.lorts. nig: being available at the nationa.: te ,. c: Lf m% ( , t::. .ion, !his s; .i ii.'ooniii,I.,:. ;:oncern, ] litnicai Human Initflii-gence f TitiMINi i :-...v.::: (i .s andartaiydeeision.ntalat.. ..Ts ss,vere ',•_-..11..d. ::: r,,.r7.i.:....:.,:c .o ‘.v..?:- mar.-einally itst:T friend:v. hilt t".11. bt.lier I .!1::::-: ::::', `,:li•U .:c. ',.,.',.., h.::.:.: h..::+.: Ilk!li:m-:-n:::::!-,.: :,. :- :: evcr..vitelnithy ,...7ontinunicatkin.F.. and automation . v-,•.::::-:!...1:1. ,.:o.•..:10!). :on-,',•'-',.: Ce.`01.iired rtri)Ort 16rIllat changes. report.; ....t.' he. iii:i,,, it.f.:.\..?....: -,,. : -. -:::n•', ;.0 . •ii.'p :c..nt ,..-. pr:::rct-3 ,-.7.1 -o.. in% 7‘,1:' (:07111e•C'ti011. ;tiaii t.:0110iCOCieS. ThiF it)01( t5n±t: r.) ..¦ .rr. of:!;:c1 .s,,.L. :: 4:.'.:11!?2::C nOnce tlf it.; was ill rthi. :1/2. C.' Ve•C'n:'• ..":.: 1 R.:“.`i V .: • il;.:•1 i!.C .:.ir...,,' • •:.;'.:!:1:.,,i!::,:.,,T: -,....p,:,:l .,,.n:'. 4. 11;1`..,.. !,/:.! 1: :!.,...1il i .0 (WC': tht; naliunal automated me,3sage ::,.-,,:,.•:.' ,--•••.,-:::,"-I :: ,..-...!..1z ..,..)., :..,. :.nil: te....::•. f ;:.: !.:, r(....t!iy gct ...thr fri..z.rid1). portal into place 1 p;-...-4;:."71:::,..ib:.1-:k ith'. 4. ,;.!4illtY,i i01:Z111:-,. di..;. :1:::.: C)llitill . : • ', C:. :, :., .: J'.1 . , ::);L:7n',-:::-'). Ti .! -;!':: V.:',...:",..•n.i:..',..: ...'..-.., .:7.v Cr Chnati)::::Cti•Z'itt;kill? il.; I i'Veali, MOS: Oil . thiS -. h::::": :-.:. ,.:'," :.I'. ,.' ,i;Zt:".11 ,::' , •71 Vi',:%'1111CttOyal.it....!' ;:1';:.:. • ..i•:^,:rt.. ‘'..x.i diso Interest in Whilt WO WeT'V u•.`dirtf.:). Ifi:-.1.-,: :,'..:: .;‘,.-n2. din....0K%i to 1).;?Iii nt . ¦..)vi,iini; ,: `..',.:;t:k I v N.InniiItetnimt R..eport to Se,-...1)c.f . \1:..1.)%1 .:(:S..l.'SI.)-- Ir.: i,....c. Oct.-J.:ill:. No•.. ,.:,..' .,. :::.*.S111Kis It The.x.t...r interroa.ati:ilf. i iiL. .1•.:1::qt:i:. ... ...2 .1 . 's.,.lC.) :s.a.:. sircadv pt0V.ii.il:_: ..1n',::::• rcf:ort and we were askvd to tli) Itt! S:1111e. .1 . --zul Ii.:-;:i or ..i..:iliru.q.'-', \' ,•e :;;Ci, :1/4.'.10...,..zz . ..: of intelligence nacres:. V..'t- ... r;: ;N;r: v, •;);.(Al ;)Fli'...•iii.c: xvi 0iatioil Hi ...,b1i LIv.z: tor '.::::e v..1.70i., Tilero was Interest frorn the Pentii4in.on 'et' t!ettlite.,. il ,.: theY wen:: 11.1:::: . ::..., ti:.• ::::.,•-io-ci.ty diret.tions ov t...:11m2 us who or :...., :J .:: .-. ­ •: :...,.:..t1'... ir. 2:.K.i4_ Ink': v,..n: ri:::. ;•...0.0!...;i:. mid N.I6 BURt,:i* ESS. o w. :inoi:n..7on(';.. :ATI: :::: . o......_ ir,1-.-,.t.,.....:.cf ,.‘);:f was ran. tho rYsodornitn...;f::: it)pfc. The e....:w. ,.: iat:02:n(iodi-ro :., L .;),f..,•; .: ,.: 9-.;.: 1;111.'J iommull;t ,,..) tva .. ;., 10 have n d isclawfion ,, Il n:11. I7zit-: vc:ii, :: kc ., :.. -.7);,.. fr.:nco WK..- r.mui.s.s!: .1.% :17. 41:oildata,.. :..•..-.;.,:i.f): -y :1 -:.L. waia: :a . s:;..sfinf:.:1:, ::or..... 1 Il f... -?r i:-,:i4, I had an orunitatior !rip 10 i.)( .: to :.::...1nlli': :.1 ,.. : nli::: With 1);, CAN4i3CM..F.: :4.:111.;RGES:..-;. I do rio: recall if I saw DepSecrit:r t Vs:0 1.171.)Vcri..7.. but I did no : see Sec RUN :1:1::..1..1.). I dist; visited the Nation ­ a! *bite:lige:nee ,V„.....eiv,... -• "Il-; ,.:. Sc ttiTvolivh .JCS anti C1::NTC:::)M, tacked ntt .f. to dt.. , an evaluation 'of :rii.. i do no; kt.10V, "‘,VIIX. !ii,.. .:!,01 .:;':Sis Or tili :i . U'VetiVs..: WilS. I 11.S.41.1:111 :::d at the unit: he*.liiliti-:. li•tt.:: cod...ti and s.,... were. stiffing fr;:rn Ph2i.s.t. 111 I-..) Pha: IV, athi 1•: S \J1:\IENT AG0000568