Emails between Marion Bowman, Valerie Caproni, John Curran and Others re: Documents FBI Reports of Detainee Abuse at Guantanamo and Afghanistan

Email details FBI investigation of mistreatment, abuse or "highly aggressive" treatment of detainees in Iraq that are known or observed by FBI agents who have cycled through Guantanamo. The email states that fourteen (14) agents have witnessed abuses such as: 1) use of strobe lights; 2) cold interview rooms; and 3) extremely loud music used on detainees. One agent (who was in Afghanistan) witnessed abuse, and a lab tech took pictures of a prisioner with an eye injury. No specific details of particular detainees, times or places mentioned.

Doc_type: 
Email
Doc_date: 
Thursday, July 15, 2004
Doc_rel_date: 
Tuesday, December 14, 2004
Doc_text: 

_
1
b6 -1'
b7C -1 . • i i From Caroni Valene E OGC) (FBI) INSD) (FBI)
To b6 -1
cc
b7C -1
Subject RE GTMO Update I
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
i
thanks I
1
;---Onginal Message---
b6 -1
From I(INSD) (FBI)
b7C -1
Sent 'Tuesday, July 13, 2004 11 21 AM
To Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Cc MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI),1 I(INSD) (FBI) b6 -1
Subject ' GTMO Update' ' b7C -1

UNCLASSIFIED
NON;RECORD
On Fnday 07/09/2004 and Monday 07/12/2004, einalls were sent to Bureau personnel who served in any capacity, at GTMO, requesting any observationof aggressive mistreatment of detainees There were a total of 530 personnel who were identified and sent the email As of Tuesday, 07/13/2004 morning, there have been 163 responses received There have been 14 employees who have identified themselves as observirig some sort of mistreatment, but unsure If this was within DOD interview guidelines The
majontylof the "posit ye" responses have stated detainees were subjected to "strobe lights" aimed at their
face, cold interv!ew rooms and:extremely loud 'music Others have documented their observations in EC
format I will continue to provide updates as the results come in
'
UNCLASSIFIED
'
UNCLASSIFIED
_
Ata, V7-/UMW
47.FittATIa4 HANIN IaUNCLAsszFreo riktE 11:7"q3''Z 1 a 4 : Pv_DO/ PLC/JAC
DETAINEES-1512
iso
DOJFBI-002125
I
..... ....
b6 -1 . .
I ' '
b7C -13, % .
1
I I
1
I here it1is b5 -3
I
_
Message-7-,
Fr
om
Frorn KALISCH, ELENI P (Div00) (FBI) '
Sent Tbesday, May 18,;2004 12 23 PM
To Calironi, Valene E (D,v09) (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M

i i
'(Div13)I(FBI) , 1
Subject RE treatment of detainees

i
i ,
I 1
1 i

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
I I

i :
.
Val !

1
Attachment is missing !
Elem. I ,
!
L---Original Message--
From Capron!, Valene E (Div09) (FBI)
pent Tuesday, May 18„2004 12 23 PM . I
fro CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M (Div13) (FBI)
Cc KALISCH, ELENI P (Div00) (FBI)

¦
Subject treatment of detainees
i
i ,

I
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

l'
I
1 ,
' I
Attached is a proposed EC dealing with treatment of detainees
I . .
Cassie' I Can:you deal with this from a PR perspective? b5 -3
1
i
Eleni 1 iditto from a Hill perspective?
i I , Gary drafted this as coming from den'eral Counsel, with Pistole and me as approving itr b5 -3
b6 -1
b7C -1
,
:
1 1 ;
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
1
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
I

1 DETAINEES-1544
944

II
I ,
DOJFBI-002157
I b6 -3. b7C -1 1{{MSG014 RTF 1 , • j i P . ' ' I ; SENSIT VE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD I : I Pape
! I I
I I b5 -3 1 1 i IOriginal MessageT---I From Capront, Valerie E (Div09) (FBI) Sent Tuesday, May 18, 2004 12 55 PM To KALISCH, ELENI P :(Div00) (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M (Div13) (FBI) ISubject RE treatment of detainees
; i I SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD I '
i I I
b5 -3
, Original Messagelr---I ' s From KALISCH, ELENI P (Div00) (FBI) j1 tSent ,Tuesday, May 18, 2004 12 53 PM To Caproni, Valene E (Div09) . (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M (Div13) (FBI) I ' 1 ISubject RE treatment of detainees i
! 1 1 S ENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD I t i 1
Val b5 -3
Eleni ' I
Messager----From Caproni, Valene E (Div09) (FBI) Sent Tuesday, May 18, 2004 12 46 PM To KALISCH, ELENI1 P (Div00) (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M (Div13) (FBI) Subject ,RE treatment of detainees . I
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD
DETAINEES-1543
/513
• DOJFBI-002156 I

• 1 1- C(MSG014 RTF Page 1
I ' '
b6 -1: :
1 ; t
b7C -1 i

1
i 1
FroM Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
To BALD, GARY M (CTD) (FBI)
i

1 ' I
'Subject RE treatmenrof detainees
I i I ,
i ' 1 ' 1
, ISENiSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
!1 '

'Subject
i
;That is how it is now set
! I I
----Onginal Message--,-,
iFroth BALD, GARY' M '(Div13) (FBI)
Sent Tuesday, May1 18, 2004 6 40 PM
,.To Caproni, Valenei E (Div09) (FBI)
!Subject RE treatment of detainees

HERRIN 'IS UNCLASSittg°

3'.':=1574 EX44/PLE/aAC 04-CV-4151

BUT UNCLASSIFIED
i
'NON-RECORD
i I

' I I
! k
I b5
I
Val 1 -if this helps
:_'_1
---Onginal Message-7-I From Capron!, Valene E (Div09) (FBI) pent TUesday,,May 18, 2004 1 28 PM To KALISCH, ELENI P' (Div00) (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00) (FBI), BALD, GARY M (Div13)1(FBI) 1 1 Subject RE treatment of detainees
I,
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

i
I i
Here's the plan
I b5 -3
OK?
I_i_I .
r---Onginal Message—
Fromi KALISCH, ELENIll, (Div00) (FBI)
'sent Tuesday, May 1l '

08, 2004 12 57 PM To Capron!, Valene,E (Div09) (FBI), CHANDLER, CASSANDRA M (Div00).(FBI), BALD, GARY M iDiv13, (FBI)
1 ,
Subject RE treatment of detainees
1
DETAINEES-1542
/
DOJFBI-002155
^1.
-({MSG012 RTF

;ECRU: Pige
.....„... ... .
b6 -1 b7C -1;
'
Eleni
, $
Slightly imodthed As for the Qs' b5 -3 VC
*I:A.SetEZI
DETAINEES-1541
.

:SECRET /3-01
A •
. 1
DOJFBI-002154
b6 -1
I ({MSG012 RTF Page i
tCRE I-
I -,....,
, .
I
1
i
. ' b7C -1I i
14 ' 1 I I
From KALISCH, ELENI ,P (OCA) (FBI)_
To CaProni, Valene E (OGC),(FBI)_i
cc ,_H
i_
'Subject RE Q&A l .
tirn=44atEZ
NON-RECORD

Valerie
The Direetor wants to meet on this after the 9 00 am tomorrow

Thanks) Eleni !
I ;_Original Message----Frorri Capron% Valerie E (Div09) (FBI) Sent Tuesday, May 18, 2004 6 44 PM To KALISCH, ELENI P .(Div00) (FBI) Subject RE Q&A
511:b, areater NON-RECORD
I
cLAS:37MTIPL6157:3iDMEVEnt3ACAA-!C7+41.5.,.:
4EJ!,7 144'Aq;::

D3itz,Ms2r 2=02C-2,
sorry:— I just forget I should have the final info on the agent complaining abou reatment bl
Of a detainee by tomorrow morning_1 I_ !_,
,_Original Message---2,-_, From KALISCH, ELENI P (Div00) (FBI) sent TUesday, May '18,,2004 6 42 PM To Cap1roni, Valene E (Div09) (FBI) SubjeCt RE Q&A_
I
1
liza,ra.

,

NON-RECORD
I
'_._I
I can teach you how to use the i attachment function -) .
I_I_,_
---Original Message--Froni Caprom, Valene E (Div09) (FBI) Sent Tuesday, May 18,2004 6 48 PM To KALISCH, ELENI P :(Div0b) (FBI) Subject' Q&A
i
mmepg!dzC

NON-RECORD
Atli.::p:ECMIA7.XCM'COLITAINE
ii.:*/4::±*,..ii%iqtAiiiiiEZ .i*tEg.'4°,
E!i:isitt:: sHaurn. Oiqi ­
giinibii
DETAINEES-1540
a

MIMI-002153 i

b6 -1
b7C -1
.1
Frorri Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
To KALISCH, ELENI P' (OCA) (FBI), WAINSTEIN, KENNETH L (DO) (FBI)

CC
Subject treatment of detainees
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

attached is the latest on what we know about treatment of detainees There are still a few little nit pieces that haven't come in yet: but I don't think the macro story is going to change from this
Ken I don't thin WHat do you think?
b5 -3
I
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
I
". LT. -X '.F.r' RICA." A.113 8 a,r7 A : qbhOtTFI a: P pki'E;41;HP.E.Z13:0•:::BY: ti3A,d::: 15:1;
DETAINEES-1539 (S3
DOJFBI-002152 1

I
b6 -1

b 7C -1
‘ ' .
From I_I (OGC) (FBI)

Cajironi, Valene:E (OGC) (FBI)
b6 -1.
CCCC I I . 1

b7C -1
Subject FW Detainee EC draft 3
I
i
I
Valene, I sent this to you yesterday at 2 30 pm i
I . i
----10nginal Message—
b 6 -1 Fromi 1(1)1%09) (FBI)
b 7C -3. Sent Mbnday, May 17, 2004 2 38 PM To Cap:roni, Valene .E (Div09) (FBI) Subject Detainee' EC draft 3
' Valerie, Under the paragraph I_'there'l reference to
b5 -3
1

Et .pcLASSIFIEP
DETAINEES-1538
/5-3g
r
• DOJFBI-0021 51
)
b6 -1

b7C -1
;
SubjeCt Interrogation Guidance
I
_1
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

i
I b6 -1
Yalenei land (the other guy) leave for Afghanistan today Do you have additional thoughts on b7C -1
the guidance
I ,
t

I
SEIFIED
NSITIIVE BUT UNCLASS
I

I
, 1 I

i 1
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
.
.
I
i I

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
i
S ENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
I

DETAINEES-1537
/S3 7
lb DOJFBI-002150
Page 1
I ,
b6 -1
b7C -1 i I 1
I i 1
!From Capron!, Valene E (OGC) (FBI) I

To W 1
BOMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
cc I
Subject IRE Interrogation Guidance

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

b5 -3
Message7—:'
1
From BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Tuesday, June ,01, 2004 10 19 AM
To Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject RE Interrogation Guidance

I

I .
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
liON-R ECORD I_'

I
b5 -3
Messager----,
From Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Tuesday, June ol, 2004 10 09 AM
To BOWMAN, MARION,E (OGC) (F51)
Subject RE Interrogation Guidance

• I ,
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

KION-RECORD I
I met with Bald and Pistole this morning Cummings is over there this week and is supposed to come .ack with some policy decisions' b5 -3
-;---Original Message i--,
From' BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Tuesday, June 01, 2004 10 01 AM
to Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)

DETAINEES-1536
/536
DOJFBI-002149
b6 -1
i

b7C -1 1 4
1
IFrOM I l(CTD) (FBI) b6 -1
b7C -1
To Capron;, ValenetE (OGC) (FBI)
-cc : I I 1
Subject, RE AGreements

1 II b5 -3
Valerie -I
1 I 1
b5 -3
b5 -3
.
let me (know if you need anything else We are looking forward to your visit
. l
(Regards,
b6 -1 I
b7C -1 I
1
1
I
..LL Ii:r.,-FikaOff::00tAitilli
: , I
I HEREIN -ze-,. 0i4CLASIF repI Message--¦_/147 0.31t...al il 4 ::#y561.5..75i.: DicHi PLOAC... II i—{.7.11r. 415.
Mt 8 .
;From From Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI) ,
iSent Thursday, June 03, 2004 8 56 AM

b6 -1
1(CTD) (FBI)
b7C -1

;Subject AGreements i
;Su
bject
} 1 '
'UNCLASSIFIED I
'NON-RECORD
b6 -1 b7C -1 I I 1 i answer Leahy, DOJ needs to know
To answer a letter f m Sen
I We are checkino our the I b5 -3
;Valerie!
'

t
UNCLASSIFIED

DETAINEES-1535
._¦_;
DOJFBI-002148

({MSG009 RTF __)ECRET 4 Page 3. 1
b6 b7C NON-RECORD

that have never formally been reported Please take a
This is a very rough letter to DoD to report events ,
look and modify as you think appropriate I'd like to get this to DoD next week Who else should see

this?

,
4 ;

DETAINEES-1533

SECRET;
/5-3
DOJFBI-002146
...eCRfT
b6 -1 i
b7C -1
1
Valene_
b6 -1 ,Attached is the onginal and the edited copy done by BAU I UCI land ASAC Jan Fedarcyk
b7C -1_The edited version of the OGC letter is attached as "OdCDODIetter wpd"

iPat per my telcal
t b6 -1_.The attached is modified version of your draft that incorporates sum:tested changes based on Ur: b7C -1 !c.on ay with SSA's' as presen :withru11219nth another interview and was not with_hen he 'observed the detaine His additions to the draft letter are bolded and
i , 1
bl_deletions are bracketed { I
1Z
I I
Although the recommended changes add detail that Aelglikve is important, I have a broader concern about the letter and IGTMO issues in general'
b5 -3
As alWays, we stand ready,to assist in any manner
1
Steve
---Onginal Message--;
prom TIDWELL, J STEPHEN'(IR) (FBI)
pent Friday, July 02, 2004 7 59 AM

b6 1-
J To Fedarcyk, Janice K (IR) (FBI) (IR) (FBI)
b7C -1
Cc Caproni, Valene E (OGC),(FBI)
Subject FW

,_1
NO
b6 -1_id Jan b7C -1_If_hasn't gotten this to you,'please review so GC Caproni can get this gone S eve I
Message,----L
From Caproni, Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Thursday. July 01. 2004 6 58 PM
Tc _ I(IR) (FBI), BOWMAN MARION E (OGC) (FBI)

b6 -1
b7C -1 Cc TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)
Subject

cizeceratinEZ
DETAINEES-1532
tECRET
I
'

DOJFB1-002145

1 1.
-
1
{(MSG009 RTF Page 11ECRET
."'• --
b6 -1
, .
b7C -1 ' 1 I , . ' From TIDWELL, J STEPHEN
,, (IR) (FBI)
To Caproni, ValenelE (OGC) 1 (F131)
CC

i
Subject RE Detainne Matter
i

i I
ON,-RECORD
,
I
Boy, I see why you are General Counsel That question is at the heart of the matter
b5 -3
Steve I I ' Message---kFrom Caproni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI) Sent ;Tuesday, July 06, 2004 10 32 AM To TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI) Subject RE Detainne Matter 2Ot4 CLAsatrizv . sr; 6.3.15 '71' :Mike? RZPAq."4,01;.*A4 D3CLAS8IFY­'0Ui -42-ae2.6.2,?

AtiWINgPRii*ticiCgOini0;x6
HERNINM2'MMCLA3S/TTEDMXCEDT
UI k;°,q14341 . • ....... •• ••

voltResuclqw0TRuPAXs4
NONLRECORD
Steve,
Thanks I don't disagree with the notiorl b5 -3 Do you have a view on that?
VC
-,----Ongmal Message—
From T DWELL, J STEPHEN ,(IR) (FBI)
Sent Friday, July 02, 2004 5 09 PM
to Caproni, Valene E (OGC) ;(FBI), KELLEY, ,PATRICK (OGC) (FBI), BOWMAN, MARION E

1,
(OGC) (FBI)
Cc Fedarcyk, Janice K (IR) (FBI)) ((IR) (FBI)

b6 -1
Subject FW Detainne Matter'
b7C -1
NON-RECORD
DETAINEES-1531

SE:CWT.' 1
•.DOJFBI-002144
1 , 1 :
b6 -1
I
I
b7C -1 I_ , 1 _,

i-rom Caprom, Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
To 11R) (FBI)

b6 -1
CC }

b7C -1
Subject RE follow up
1
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

b6 -1
b7C -1
Nota piloblem Thanks for your suggestions We have hopes of getting this out this week
VC i
----Original Message--
b6 -1
Frorri 1 , (IR) (FBI)
b7c -1
pent Wednesday, July 07, 2004 10 59 AM
To Capron', Valene E (OGC).(FBI)
Subject' RE follow up . 4k4Ng.P.RW4#Nif:cPkg7t,TPAP..

.1!.'MPf.4g4Nq4.4N4ATg1gP

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Hello Valerie, ,
b6 -1 I am sorry but I was out of the office and did n 13 all until today I certainly would have done a
b7C -1 draft had i known I did bo over your draft with on Fri and I think he was going to forward the

suggestions to you 1
Ain, am sorry that I did not draft

know of your request for a dra
b6 -1 . ,
b7C -1 . 1
1
1----Ong nal Message--
Frorri Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Thursday, July 01;2004 9 21 AM

b6 -1 tol RIR) (FBI) b7C -1 Subject 'RE follow tip
1'
UNCLASSIFIED
NON; RECORD

b6 -1
b7C -1
Can you take a whack at a draft letter? I just moved andl although I am hoping to turn to this today, if you can bang out a f rst draft it would be helpful If not, don't worry about it One way or the other, you'll see a draft before it goes out of this building
VC
DETAINEES-1530
/S-3C
1 DOJFB1-002143
.
b6 -1
i
b7C -1 i

think Steve I_Orpinal MPSSA&P--4--I
1(INSD) (FBI) b6 -1_tSent Wednesday, July 07, 2 04 5 23 PM b7C -1 .To MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
¶Cc I I (INSD) (FBI) :Subject) From I _
UNCLASSIF IED
NON-RECORD

1
:Steve, per your request .
UNCLASSIFIED
I
UNCLASSIFIED
. . I '
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
I
'
I
'
;
DETAINEES-1529

DOJFBI-002142

_I
b6 -1 I b7C -1
I
From MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
To Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
cc
Subject IRE

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Valene, thanks, will do ,
1
---Onginal Message--
From Capron', Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent 'Wednesday, July 07, 2004 6 14 PM
To MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
Subject RE

1
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Ilt.r0.7.1CATI011CONTAIII113 ER= K .
: I s AnimAssin
p.
I.Tz.....11,n.ast.pockt:AY.OtA7:.P.mHtR14136.7AC ;: 0 4:7
t 1 .
Three reactions
1 You guys are great
I
2 Can we limit the email to the group of people who we know have been to GTMO 7 Tom Hamngton's
group:has'a list of who has been down there
1_.
I_

b5 -3
3 How about instead of)
I_
I
This sounds good to me I will be out of the office tomorrow and Friday, but can you let!

b5 -3

'know ebni .tibis before it noes out I
b6 -1
b7C -1
Aso, I told Tom HamngtOn this was going to happen and asked if he wanted to weigh in on the wording of the question I haven't heard back from him
---Otiginal Message--
From . MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
Sent Wednesday, Ju y 07, 2004 5 27 PM
To Capron% Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject FW

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Valene, attached it our recommended e-mail We also have a process to get the interviews done, document them and reconcile the responses to ensure we have queried everyone Let me know what you
DETAINEES-1528
1_ I
b6 -1 b7C -1
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED I SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

DETAINEES-1527

1: ;
DOJFB1-002140
rage
b6 -1 i I ,
I
b7C -1 i i
(OCA) (FBI)
qr r b6 -1 To (OGC) (FBI)
b7C -1
cc Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA), Capron!, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI) Subject RE GC Testimbny '
I , ;
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
b5 -3
I
----Oininai Mp,ssane--
1'031n I(OGC) (FBI)

b6 -1 . Sent .Friday, July 09! 2004 9 52 AM
b7C -1
Toi_ (OCA) (FBI)
Cc Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA), Capron', V lerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject IGC Testimohy

HSABXNUYON=6121/1,70 DilitifrAl;.M420141S116kWAIV4ACA1441S1
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON1 RECORD

, b5 -3
r
After discussing the issue with John Curran
b6 -1 b7C -1
b5 -3
b5 -3
b6 -1 b7C -1 I . b6 -1 b5 -3
b7C -1
.Office of the General Cbunsell
b2 -1

DETAINEES-1526
152
DOJFBI-002139

b6 -1 ! b7C -1
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
fi
DETAINEES-1525
1
'
flt^
DOJFBI-002138
Rage 3
_I
b6 -1
b7C -1
;
IUNCLASSIFIED
'NON-RECORD
It'll bring hard cc's to our 3 p rri
--Original Message--
b6 -1 'From I (CTD) (FBI)
b7C -1 ay, June{ 14, 2004 2 38 PM

Sent Mond
ITo 1 1(IR) (FBI)
'Subject FW

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
I .
(Can yob all help with answering these??

¦
I
i I
.--- aural Messaae---.1-
I
Fm!
b6 -1

ro 1 (CTD) (FBI)
Sent Thursday, June 10, 2004 2 39 PM
b7C -1 To BATTLE. FRANKIE (CTD) (FBI)

.
Cc 1 ect II (CTD) (FBI 1•1¦11•1¦N CTD) (FBI)
I
Subj
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
i I
frankie,
I

Carl you look over the attachment? The Director testified on 05/20/2004 before the Senate Judiciary, (which resulted in 270 QFRs coming back to the FBI The attachment are the questions for your section Could I [please get the response by 07/08/04?
i
Thank
'Thank You,
b6 -1 1
b7C -1 I
'
1
,UNCLASSIFIED
'
UNCLASSIFIED
DETAINEES-1524
DOJFBI-002137
Page
b6 -1
b7C -1
all of the folks you are dealing,with Thanks
FtevIe
Original Message---L
From Caprom, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Sunday, June 20, 2004 1 29 PM
To TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)
Subject; RE

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Steve,
1

b5 -3

We will f course coordinate on the answers to th QFRs'
Valerie
7--Original Message--
From TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)

. Sent Friday, June 18„ 2004 5 07 PM
To Capr:oni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI), KELLEY. PATRICKIW (OGC) (FBI)
Cd Fedarcyk, Janice K (IR) (FBI)

Subject 'EW
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Valerie and Pat
'appreciate you tak ng 'a look at the QFRs reference FBI detainee interviewing matters generated by the Director's recent testimony 'As o(;r: has the rinint nnIttug I wnidri annrprnatp wnticinn with vin all the responses that are provided!

b5 -3
m in t..reece next weeic ASAL. Jan reaarcyx has me poi nt for us on the QFRs, however, we want toWork WO you all on ttiese'respOnses to make sure:we're on the official BU track Steve.Tidwell I
b6 -1
From IR) (FBI)

b7C -1
Sent Friday, June 18, 2004 2 58 PM
To Fedarcyk, Janice K (IR) (FBI), TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)
Subject FW

DETAINEES-1523
/51-3
•_
DOJFBI-002136
b6 -1
b7C -1 From TilDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI) To Capron!, ValenelE (OGC) (FBI)
cc_I_
!
Subject' RE
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

_r
_
!Let us know if there's more you orlPat need
Steve

---Ongral Message— r
From Capron', Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent .MOnday, June 28,2004 8 57 AM
To TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)

r
Subject IRE , A47.4: zirzok4AwaNc%Nlwno anntrAl.axmucuisiyin wiTaAIf.ps200cyvAinuto.,13/.1.1:,:oacv441.5.1::
I
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

One issue I'd like your imput on
_1
b5 -3'
-J--Onginal Message—,
F.rom TIDWELL, J STEPHEN (IR) (FBI)
Sprit Mc:41day, June 28, 2004 7 05 AM
To Capri

oni, Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject RE

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Madam General Counsel As long as you and Pat are getting what you need ,: )am good to go Jan Fedarcyk is the ASAC that has
t_ 1 DETAINEES-1522
b5 -3 b6 -1 b7C -1
b5 -3
b5 -3
DOJFBI-002135 I

b6 -1, ' b7C -1, 1 •
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED 1 I UNCLASSIFIED I ,
UNCLASSIFIED I UNCLASSIFIED ! 11 I
t I
; : I !_ I ;_ ' ;_ ‘ :_i t_1
; DETAINEES-1521
4 I 1 4 DOJFBI-002134

I- {{MSG004 RTF
Pag"e 2
b6 -1
b7C -1 fyi Ong nal Message--2-From dap
roni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Monday, June 28, 2004 11 53 AM
To Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA)
Subject IRE TRAINING FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
b5 -3
Messagel
From dirran, John Fi (OGC) (OGA)
Sent MoInday, June 28, 2004 11 35 AM
To Caprbni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject FW TRAINING FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
b5 -3

---i-onoinai messacre— ,
Frorri_, ,___J(OGC) (FBI)
b6 -1
Sint Mnnrinv .lune 7R 9904 10 57 AM
b7C -1

TJ J(OGC) (FBI)! I (OGC) (FBI)
CC BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI), Curran, John F i(OGC) (OGA)
Subject TRAINING FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS I
i
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
JOhn, Spike, I received a telephone call today from I I DOD-Polygraph Unit
b6 -1,2
(headquarters OU aro Ina) about having an'FBI NSLB attorney conduct training on August 17th
b7C -1,2
from 9 30am-10 30am in Linthicum, Maryland The topic would be about FBI interrogations (legal
parameters) relative t h es overseas Th'e audidnce would be FBI and DOD polygraphers
direct line is Thanks,
UNCLASSIFIED
DETAINEES-1520
R
ii • DOJFBI-002133
_
I I_({MSG004 RTF
Page 1
_I ,
.
b6 -1
I
b7C -1 i. ! , ! ; I

1
' rFrom Capron!, Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
;To Curran, John F ;(OGC) (OGA)_I
'cc BOWMAN, MARION'E (OGC) (FBI)

subject' RE TRAINING FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS
I
UNCLASSIFIED 1
NON-RECORD I

I_
I
I
b5 -3
_Ondinal Message—
from Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA)
Sent' Monday, June 28,.2004 2 47 PM
'To Capron!, Valene E (OGC)1(FBI)
Subject FW TRAINING FOR IDOD RE INTERROGATIONS

UNCLASSIFIED
Ai74:p4p...*!AszoNA7oNTAxplp
NON-RECORD
HERAIN:WANPIA44IFER DATtr11*p .
7,20131.61574HIviat3Aciac*cv-4151;
NI_ .
i----Onginal Message--_,
From BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI) :
Sent donday, June 28, 2004 1 15 PM
' To Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA)
Subject' RE TRAINING'FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

b5 -3
1----Onginal Message--;
From Curran, John F (OGC) (OGA)
Sent MOnday, June 28, 2004 1 07 PM
To BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject FW TRAINING FOR DOD RE INTERROGATIONS

UNCLASSIFIED
fpN:RECORD

DETAINEES-1519
/
DOJFBI-002132
b6 -1 b7C -1 From! 1(0GC) (FBI) :To CaPront, Valerie E I (OGC) (FBI) Icc Subject RE GTMO ;b6 -1. !b7C -1
UNCLASSIFIED 'NON-IECORD
.0K
----Onginal Message--:From Caproni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI) Sent Monda June 28, 2004 :11 01 AM iTo (OGC) (FBI) !Su ject 0 b6 -1 b7C
UNCLAISSIFIED NON-RECORD
b6 -1 b7C -1
'Can yoil get me cop es Of1 pleasel VC IASAP, b5 -3
UNCLASSIFIED y?.: OR:1;01' _ori:.; NERgta: 0 Q4; y:703 6:15.7:1; :!: : 1)140/ VLF) 0 4 7 4151
UNCLASSIFIED

DETAINEES-1518

/ Cif
DOJFB1-002131
1
b6 -1 ; ,
NON RECORD

b7C -1
Valerie, 'fit
' Onainal Message-----
From 1(INSD) (FBI)

b6 -1
Sent , MOnday, July 12, 2004 5 00 PM
b7C -1
To MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI) ((INSD) (FBI) Subject I GTMO Update
t
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

. After day'one of the GTMO email survey, I handled approximately 150 email responses and about the same iriphone calls There were 12 Bureau employees who have been marked as possible interviews,
b6 -1 one to include observing mistreatment ip Afghanistan and a Lab employee who took photos of a detainee
b7C -1 with injuired eyes One employee, SSA 1 IIR, advised he documented the abusive ireatmeni in an EC and provided it to Chief Counsel Capron' some time ago He stated it also had endo:sues and addit ional information Yet, he did not have a copy of it Can one of you obtain a copy of this EC or you I contact Ms 'Capron' directly;
. ,
ENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE
ENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIS./E BUT UNCLASSIFIEDI
DETAINEES-1517

a
DOJFBI-002130
{(MSG016 RTF
Page
I_I
b6 -1 b7C -1 I I
From Capron', Valene"E (OGC) (FBI)
To, torr..RAw STFVFN (INSD) (FBI)
I cc I I(INSD) (FBI) b6 -1
Subject RE GTMO Update

' b7C -1
' SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
1NON-RECORD

10k
1----Onginal Message----
1From MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
+Sent Monday, July 12, 2004 5 37 PM
1 To Capron', Valerie E (O C) (FBI)
IC01 I(INSD) (FBI) b6 -1
'Subject RE GTMO' Update b7C 1

I :
!SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIHED
NON-RECORD I

.

I I
b6 -1
Valerie will do If you don't mind will come by in the morning to make a copy for us
b7C -1
---Onginal Message--
From Capron', Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Vonday, July 12, 2004 5 30 PM

1

To MCCRAW, STEVEN C (INSD) (FBI)
Subject RE GTMO Update

HERZIN-IS UNCLAESIPIED.
tpATE,,..11-os-nacErt-61E79. ENE/PLBOAC 04-CV-4151

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

Steve, I
b6 -1
Ntioevjr is going to nterv'ewFIshould give me a call I'll get them a copy of the EC
b7C -1
VC
r—Ong!nal Message--
From MCCRAW, STEVEN C '(INSD) (FBI)
Sent Monday, July 12. 2004 5 05 PM
To Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject IFW GTMO Update 1

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
DETAINEES-1516
/ Sao
DOJFBI-002129
I_
b6 -1 b7C -1
b5 -3
i i ;I
Meanwhile, I was going to talk to Steve McCraW about having Inspections send an email to the agents who hame cycled through GTMO asking about any knowledge of mistreatment or highly aggressive interrogation of detainee's Do you want to weigh in on exactly how the question(s) should be worded'?
Valene
UNCLASSIFIED
L1JNCLASSIFIED
I

UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
U NCLASSIFIED I''
;_,
UNCLASS IFIED

UNCLASSIFIED
I
DETAINEES-1515
/C/1

DOJFBI-002128

I_ I
b6 -1
i
b7C -1
'b5 -3
I )
i I :
1----Onginal Message--
From Capron', Valene E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent MOnday, July 12, 2004 3 35 PM
To BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
Subject IRE GTMO

I
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
1

1
i
spike,
_
b5 -3
1 _I
VC
--Onginal Message--
F rom BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI)
Sent Thursday, July off, 2004 8 17 AM
To Caproni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI), HARRINGT N, T J' (CTD) (FBI)
Subject IRE GTMO

I
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
. !

b5 -3 b6 -2
1 _
I I 1 _1
b7C -2 Onginal Messager---i From Caproni, Valene E (OGC) (FBI) Sent Wednesday, July 07, 2004 11 07 AM To HARRINGTON, TIJ (CTD) (FBI) Cc BOWMAN, MARION.E (OGC) (FBI) Subject ;GTMO
i
UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

I
Tom, I
1
I /called earlier but your v-mail isn't picking upl
I b5-3 1 !
DETAINEES-1514

I
1

11 i,' 4
DOJFBI-002127
VVVI J IA 1 T-
ridge
b6 -1
b7C -1 ' Frorn •Caproni, Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
To BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI) 'cc Subject RE GTMO
'
'I .UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD
F---Onginal Message-----
rom BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI) 'Sent TUesday, July 13)2004 6 02 AM To Caproni, Valerie E (OGC) : (FBI) Subject; RE GTMO '
UNCLASSIFIED NON-RECORD
--Original Message--From Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI) Sent Monday, July 12, 2004 6,33 PM To BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI) Subject RE GTMO
I
UNCLASSIFIED
NON1RECORD

--0,nginal Message— From BOWMAN, MARION E (OGC) (FBI) . Sent MOnday, July 12, 2004 3 38 PM To Capron', Valerie E (OGC) (FBI)
,
Subject IRE GTMO

UNCLASSIFIED
NON-RECORD

b5 -3
b5 -3
b6 -1
b7C -1
LL I^FCR1 rA :ICN C^[JTPI?1BD
x7.,,Fxxf... ......_...._c.::IE.':1.picw:14xxx en__......._ ..... ......
D4 S i1 C3 .................

b5 -3
DETAINEES-1513
DOJFBI-002126
i
b6 -1
I
b7C -1 _'
.
t . I_

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED I
1I
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
I
I
l
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
i I
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
I
!
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
¦
I DETAINEES-1545
I
. ) 4 DOJFBI-002158

Doc_nid: 
5369
Doc_type_num: 
67