Emails between Army Officers re: Documents Relating to CID Report 0128-04-CID259-80194

A CID Report reports the death of an un-named detainee on November 4, 2004 at 1000 hrs. The report states that the 10th Military Police Battalion (CID) was notified that a prisoner at Abu Ghraib died while in custody. The report concluded "The investigation did not conduct any interview to determine the circumstances surrounding the deaths; there was no investigative effort made to obtain the victim's medical records that could have been used to determine if he was under medical care prior to his death. The investigation was closed without opening a full Report of Investigation (ROI). The case file was closed without any preliminary or final autopsy report, or any information to whether or not an autopsy was conducted

Doc_type: 
Email
Doc_date: 
Tuesday, November 4, 2003
Doc_rel_date: 
Thursday, July 14, 2005
Doc_text: 

CE FORM 66
:

1„ . DATE 2. TIME RECEIVED 7. CASE NUMBER
4 $0.1i. 0235-03-CID259:

5, OFFENSE
Pt1040 Death

.4, SUBJECT 9, TYPE. OF-ACTONNone , SST ONLY-
5. VICTINI 10: REPORTS
. ..
TYPE S'tj'SPENSE.
••-•
6. CASE DESCRIPTI6X-. .• ,
C-
A prisoner died while in U.S. custody at the Abu Ghraib prison.
OTHER ACTION 12. CID FUNDS
ACTION CRIMINAL INFO EVIDENCE CUST to"¦‘; RQRD COMPL DATE • ••!m ....

01 879

0 0 0 0 01

Circle tastName Date ISsued Ciide Last Naiiie Date ISSUed Circle Last Name Date IsSued V W
ACTION •-••• . COMPLETED = • N/A ACTION • COMPLETED: • N / A;
Kip. Report / MPR NCIC entry on stolen prop U Medical records requested FilM submitted for Contact sheet atoe check dispatched
Copy pf AIR 'posted in AcTgs El Name check results received
INVESTIGATIVE STANDARDS ACTIVITY/ PERSON: PHONE . NUMBEIV
..„
Investigative Plan FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
013880 tinnno2
Coritio3 25gmbeg
tThIMARY XN.VEST.I GAT ;LAW • AV/ 41 V :LT Z
_
_04 . 10.004 -4 No 03i: rp11, -.._ „.. FROM; THE . 10:;:1:1- MILITARY I
POLICE BATTALION:: (CID), BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (E3IAP)i 5A0FMAO:t IRAQ, THAT
. .

. . s•-• • :
PRIBONtg-tonr,z OT)811015
:

Tho 10" NP BN p:otTicied.:4 copy of the SI1R on • incident

i46 Ahoit ,1455;. 4 gpIt 03,. $A• coordinated MR13nt and obtaiRe. _ ..3449rn144,:ply1 qan: 55;:.(14t0. of Oct 03 ;. .attacks
(ce ) b(4-)Cc_) Pr epared S SI ONLY report. TO SAC for review: only tepOtt etrialied to

013881
CID. TORN 28 PREVIOUS. EDItIONS. OP THIS .&.0144 WIIS, SE USED UNTIL iXiINOSTEO. Oct. 80:
• 0 000 0•3
.

• AGENTS ACT: yl summAR • _ COntrOI Nuiiibee : 03.,(1­
. ... : 925

• : ( " 'ttiulififoii-ios=11: ' -• -" .
SUMMARY

:,..r
4

• 013S82
CID FORM 28 . • FOR oFPICIAL USE ONLY PAGE
1 OCT 80.
000004
20 MaY 04IMPL-ZA

MEMORANDUM FOR Commander, USACIDC, ATM: CIOP-COP-OP, 6010 6th
Fort Belvoir, VA 22060

SUBJECT: RFI (0212-04-CID001)
review of ROI # 0235-03-0j:0259 determined the investigation was operationally
1. Th

insufficient and was administratively insufficient. This investigation was reported as an
SSI only report of death,

-,

2. The review disclosed the following deficiencies. The investigation did not conduct a
'--
•­
•­
• 1,0­

crime scene examination or explain why such an exammattan was not conducted. The
investigation did not conduct anyinterviewt to determine the circumstances surrounding .
the deaths , :there was no investigative effort made to obtain the victim's medical records
that could have been used to determine ifhe was under medical care prior to hiS death.

__ ,

The Weveatiglition was closed without openkg a fall Report of Investigation (ROT). The
• •.

case file was closed without any preliminary or final autopsy report, or any infonnation as,
to whether or not an autopsy was conducted. There Was in email intbe case file that the
ONLY email message was received, however, there was no paper or electronic copy

SSI
of theSSI,report ill the case file.

• 127&/'
.

3. The Point of contact is the undersignedat ans-armv.mil, DNVT 0101 MEM
•:
CW4, v•• Special Agent
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY •

013883 00000.5 •
Your• Meg.000:
-..,,.:..: L......... . • . ;.,..., .,. _ , • .: 7 . • _ fYo .C.W4 PM-0PS .. _ .....:. :.... . :„. ..
riled: MTN: CW3 E4411) .:(01 a11 ) . .F04.1440 '
;(Eiii011); ,.. 4(F7,40.
-01410i 0040* (E1:1141). 0.t.!gr ;

.!ga 0-0P$: 10P$0t,,:(g1 ." Officer
,MA3. crrE7S3A.OPERATIOAL LAW A , git_ .064,:qtri.-

t.S.G iTFI,C4) .*4;
,:( 4,Vail)IIIIIIIIIIMPW4IotH t4 P tofsgele4iiii'

..,_ .. ........ 03: cytq-COOPS oto

-
ooPMO) (E-mail}7. :-OfieWOOtut (Ety1011);
c tpoolgiii..c.Yr 007 .. , '
:.....
• Subject SSTOW Oz15-03.17p2,51. ',
Sent 11/5/2003 7:52 Rii....s.: -. . •

• '
.1 r

was dewed to the following reciOtent0.:',
E-mail) od 11/5/2003 7:52 PM
C414 MR-OPERATIONS
6 7c- ,(4-

01.3884
(Moons

104 '4

W02-12THIVIP-GID-D

-• l• •••
CW-3 CJTF7-CID.OyS Officer.: . .

• „.• •
• Ttle,tdayi: November 04; 2003.523

Sent.
LOWS C-407i-A0.17$_.1

T•Ok • 40 DMAIN-'44:10P,g17;.
-. Team ITtewlizirroll.a.MF:74r094
Os OffIcei
,q4.76.004'.

„cm Detachment CDat, AD MP QUI:
-‘540;

.0441 1
Y\14, 19TH MI 13. vii02.01iN:0,11H.
64,
.9-41,TE7-ON OPS Nco. Wo

P:Ff CJTF7,010 LNO;' Q4:1.-F7791b-k../4"2/
Cc ,-.
RAP (U) SIR 03: NOV 03 Prit bled:

Subject:
• • .

• FYI
V/R • s
,•

CVV3
6 0-

Metsag47=t7, blef -
so-cri.V-PM0 Wall Dfite..r --
• • ___... ,
2003 8:59 pm:
.

sent: monaoy,40eHler 03,11¦=1111rt (y-t1)',.. co14.cq-rFT-cscop;
CG-AIDE; OTF74;313.T1MAI; OT.F7-aIRREN.tOpSOIC; CITF7-SJAOPS; 4SsG. cpA6/G-!•;l1

To MAI cs FOOPS;-CN93 077-CID PPS ter;
.1 SSG, CPA PMO (E-mail'i

-.".• ,.'
0401110. (5-reolD;-,-.
ierly 44-

Subject; EW.: al) SIR 03 NOV 03 pi.; Die -,
ciTT7-pmo Dat ops officer

From:'
November 94; 203 0:40 PM

Sent:
TO: sqr C] .-PMO Watch Ofickt
WOO sm. 03 NOV 03 Pris Died

subSecO
citaaafte.00011111114.
Caveats: NONE '

For ydur It: 7 4
Maj.

• ---OriglivIMessag . • • • .• . • • (7 74' ' ••• •
From: .-11111111111111111111101•MA) G1177-801P1-1 MP BDE-S3 _-•-:

.

•Sent; • ‘.• Monday, November cd,. 2003 8:36 PM 4 it
-To .liming-roail)11¦111111(0-4) (E mall) 67.' .-1,
Subje47... FVV: (IQ SIR 03 NOV 03 Pris Died . --
, • .

. • •
Classification : UNCLASSIFIED . •
Caveate: NONE '. , .
Wig* 4.060npie was MEDEVAC due to chest pains. CPR performed by one of themPs at
FYI: SIR fro

.
Camp "Oancl a ever, the detainee as DOA..
' •
-----Original Mtssagg s ::
MA1 C177-320 tip I3N S3.
-.-q ay, WornJ8g037.4t0-11:72414 •

• SOF14: MAI QTR-80011-1 MP BDE-531111110WilirriF7
OOMPS1FWD (E-mail); MP ODE Si 800 (E-mail)8­
To • (E mail) ;:"4„, 4 i_ .... •
Ma CPT C3177-320Th MP BN Si
Cc: 7' L '7;4./. Ok--7-*
Subject: (U) SIR 03 NOV 03 Pris Died -

Msla
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
1 001007 ,
. Classificatton: UNCLASSIFIED#FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SIR Plk10‘140e
ClasSifitAtim.: UNCLASSIFIED

Caveats; 'NONE
classification
Caveats: NONE

0.13886

2 mono
, =
• Z/144': 7741cr,i3,1 .
:
. , Xj1:0111r,,IN 4st . •A:
; ... ' T . 7 .:—.., , , 'frO? , -— , '"- - ' ;•11.-.*flil.":470-,.;,? ;WOOTO;i.r,-.10 V* :.- :::':.'.. ',•?:7tiZ5:f:::','.*1.',32.4.;.s.74Yi.tp,...-..*:szz,r,g10.,:. ..,t„ :. .4/ '..56•17,1. • -4-4Atk-4. rt Ara,-
DOD-015836

Doc_nid: 
3628
Doc_type_num: 
67