Emails between Army Officers re: CID Report: 0184-04-CID259-80230

These are emails concerning CID Report No. 0184-04-CID259-80230. This document is related to ACLU RDI 1538.

Doc_type: 
Email
Doc_date: 
Monday, October 25, 2004
Doc_rel_date: 
Monday, September 19, 2005
Doc_text: 

" . '.
\.
....
'.;
'.,:
.',
'.
:.....
.. ~1
. .,~~".' . .'" .\\ .' ...... ', .,.
.\
, " '
:'. :··:· ..::' ..··:·t···: :.~' ..;.... ~.~~. ";"l~":"
.f14j(fhkt: ; .'
';',
....... :':..:' .i'1~.c.ltI~,.(' ,.'

.... " r'7(~IIc..'-I'
. ~. . &:
.', ....
, '
..; .
'j
,000109

" .....
":;"
--.
'. ~~.
;f ••
,.'
' ..':
.'...r.
...,~._""..',.,..t~~9:~tl~~~~~::.fll:fj:;:
c~U:s~4 by pa1,'b~4 t¢tti;J;"ped Qo.~OSi
'.. f ha"t"e' . .' ... , .' . ' .
. ·······wiir-ihc1ude·6 7(~'1%~tjt ". $·t t?tit; P99~'·':-·
un:j.'t$ 'it the' .. it diHicult wiii be the'" tepcirt .~tit:~ .
r/ .6'1t:4!'((9~~"
. s1?~¢HX A9.~h~S· .. . Na,va:J,qI:i~Ml, In.vestiga.t:j::ir~· Sel;'vice IMEf; Camp. A,); A.$Cid, Iraq .
/

','
, '

..
1 ~ , 0001' .
, . .". 10
",
',.,: '
'.' .':... -;
, .' .C,18.t{~¢:t{~Q~;ijd
)
"., ,
.',
.', ,
.~' .'
I'
~ .:., .
. ....
~..
"
...,::
'.
015.167,
00011.1
. . . ·i .' ....
.'.. ' ~
, ... . ":l! :' . .....
. ¥: .': .:'.~.:: .... .i: ....:..:. . . .:~J!l ...... : . "." . ".,: ';'::)
..... . '.:
i.
": .. '\
"
,:",r
;, "
1.
,
.'." le'tth' tb 'au 01115 oct 04 butheverrec'd a;' "~:
.•.•• ;.•• '.~1~~~I~~~~!~=tri1!~

a~(~n~····;·.··lWA·dt·~~4
t. r,A .'
;/,7-'
(;.~~
7
PH
eEL
'Em
Ern
,.',"':'\)":';i·:j:.:.:.:~:~7'. ~'~',:', '
:~ ,
, .1 $-dct.-04 . '.
,
,~. .: ,
",;
..... ', . . :,::;
.,
' ...! • ;~ .. ' .\":".,
"
'! ,"
."
' :, " .' .~:; .
;;'.' ":'.
. ..
~'
. ';'
rhiil'ri'T....• 1. $e~9rrnv~~g~tiy¢ , iAy¢~til~Ilt~g ofwhich. is. ~Wmant
~i1,re~lg:·,a·tJ!'p.·~]iSei!t!~ .
~~~!1!q.;ay..to:.... _...... ....... .... . . , .... The bri IS a£e.,.......t1iert,_ .,

. ...,.. .;: ..... e...... :.
LlIJ\.&a.L.Iii.. ~tQb.8:v¢., curieAt. h1yestigiltiv~ ~ct:ivity .(S.~~Y".·.$atu.r4ay).; .We"ge.~ reportS _.
~lti:l1,1;~Md.,. .. . .. . . O,¢teiltiotJ.pacHit.ies. in. th~ ~eii; and tli~~elve~~, .... l'zWi?iY:effQrt$~e ti'ymg lQ tta~~' .' . . .. Alot ~eaeti,y¢ d~ty, ~dre!l~tve~i .OIice"they tQ.tLte out of
... .t6 their various locati(11S it !him b6cbines a littleiaskin .: .... tlle ·P~1"s~~AAi~At~&:p.tes~~ttitilb~' theobly c~~{we)i~y~pot
. PfQ.yjclean.y Vali4 fu.vestig~tiy¢ a¢tivity o~ate.tl1e ()ii.eSPQt~4 a.bov¢. . .y Battailoil (Y etat16iiS' secti6ii that the:·· are·eff"ectiri-
I was·. -h triy '-.'. :,.... p.. .;-.. ..... -.,.-y ..... : .... " g. ...
CO(it4ii,latjiQQ.with NelS, above our level, to discuss what yoU and I talked about~
referr'in$ investi~ati6tls. i am still awaitih~ a: response. .
ar¢~..
I Just r~ve(f~sPQMevi~ ¢~il..They want US t( re$.en4 theRF1\$: tQ yo~, I ha.v¢ ~~1iedthe MAs f6r yom tevi¢w. 1request thai YQU r~View them ~4 :
dete· ..•.... what .efforts C81l.bemade.· As noted above .we are r 'urred to Ive a ...__~____r:~'.~··p.~:"•..~,*':.rts~:: ...~'._.~ •.•.·..e.~ ....~_.~.w._.~._.:.:r~.i, .. _~w=~-,::.~~ ~,~~~.,~~._."
..... .... iJ#\l'D'.:.~~.:' .•_ ..._.~._;r.· ..
•.;.:""""'".~.t.~
." .•~ .:...~::......~fi:.:we,;iiMo;q-sW-;Q~ I : :tAt aai .. : r' . ~ -.-
I hav¢ 4ttached; the SRFAs;
, 0184-04
ol~i69
., 00'0·· .....
.. . 113
16-OCt-04
.

'
"', ,',

'l~-Prft~
-~~~""""""",~"*""_~~~~~j~~~M~~~~~,,,,,,~.......

'A~ ~ = :' ~''''''~'."-'''''l!!_''

i~'t~~~pdin~ ~e. fiye. RF~,-t.,sent them t9 you on, 1. So~04, but
",:.' .• ,t 1 ...... .'
, . "015170' , '
16-0ct~Q4. 000114,
. ;'.: ...,.....
' •. ·t .. .... :: .... . .. ' .
' ... :;':).. ,.';....... '.... ;..... .... :.\..

. .; '" . .. !,'.
.. . . , .
. '. .. .~: ~ '.:'
..
'.
ate. ..
r~tat¢.
NelS·· above oUt '
mh. 8.tiii·aw~tfuga·tespollSe.

';.'. ':..
Break--' '
. . .;; . , . . . , . -. ..: '..
". .
Ijw;t received·response, VIa ·email. They want us to resend the RFAs to yoU, I ha'v¢ aita,ched. th~ RFA$ for yolitj:evleW. 1~questthai you tevi~wthein'and det¢;i;il:line. what eftb.rts tan be :tnade. As noted above~ we ate ~equifed to giv~ a respo:nse/update every
.week, . . . '. .,' .
.' I Imve. a~hedthe 5 R.FAs;
0184-04
Oi9~-Q4·
Q193-04,
022$..0,4,:
O~$0~04
. .~
0151'}1··'
08-0ct-04
. ,. , ..

!to ':
,t­
"
.' ..•.. -'.: ..', ", .
'.
' . ,::'­
'.~ .'.
015172
Og..Oct-04.

.,'
.}
..
, .'
:',
........ ····,I~~~!i~t~~~li!,~~~';i~~~-~fk; ­
I(bu~te"eftirihoth~n .... from Nelshere let ilieknow and'we will ttl'en submit th'e' RFA$ thrblih
c&n.in.·~.~.~lt~·'N91*1~:,?~~¢.v~fh$nf'· ...... ..' '. ....... '. , . '. 9·

.. ..' '. ..,
". n-I'~nk.~~: $.Qtft"" ~
~-,·6.f~~/f-.· '.
t'7c.r.4.;e,.-r. .' .

. MN.C~l CIt;) Speciai Agent .
..... ~~l~i:fMPBtl (~D) ~PS Chle.f·· . ~ ~6~ ~t,-i. w~n:&.-~~¢f:..1jhl;t hope we do'not g~t beat up foi' .NClS' failure to respondin a
tiJii~lftH~~er.~:",-.'~ . "i'i':' .. . '. :..' " .
. ~_C7t;.Ij~j;-I' ~

.' ·000111· '
O$-Oct-Q4
,.

..... :.": " ,~ ." . . .' ,~
.,) ~ "
"
.
.; .
~
"

Nb·Y9UGa~hQt ref$dhecases to NCIS; R~$~h~"t!le RFAs to Nel$ at;ld we"Win reviSIt the r$$ti~ Qf..r~f¢li'lng the casei;; to NCI$ when tI1$ R.fAs a.r~ ¢Omp1~t"ed and recq~ "If tneY' $tf1t~ the ma(itie~ were hivolved th~h we may cQh~ider: referring
them: .But not until that time: . "' .. , " . . " " ". .
. " ,.: .... ... ,., '" ':1.... '., .... , .
~

-.
.. '9(~-f;~j
··~h~.·t~~db~lq{v:~boutref~r~I\Q the NelS Prt fiVe of de~l~e'e a.~use coJ:t .
--~ .. -.:'~... :p""-~~e~':·S~~§;.~W~E~h~'L~~~"

'. .~. .
0:15"174·
, : .
"(1(10118
O~-(ct-04
-':.'
. ,
" .
r ,.';............ "... "rl.lJ¥ir~xc~;t~/l.

: .' ~ ". .

·Ca'w~:et'thi§ Waived?
t~;;l,~u/(§r~ '.

, f

'.' .-°e£·
Chi,
." .

'", ";~' '.
J. ! ..j
. :.,
015175
. ! . .
()~-Oct~()4 '.. OQ0119
"'Y".~
-', ",:
... '., -.\
..'
::.­
pH
CE

Eifi .1 .
Enl "ii'
.'
, .
to"',,.,
\
•..
OQO~20··
08-Qct-04 ,.
.:' .....\ ... '.­'...
,
...... '."; ....
. : ~ , .', .
'.':
.'0:' •..•:. . r"
.'H~t~d~
-. , . ':
,~~'ii(~~~c .
.•..,:/~h64i;.with:.un~no\¢. V·~qtiI!l/S\lbj~qt.:.. ;.~:~rfrfk;\~~\~ ~~$pfy;i~i~.·,,"¥#.ri.;'(nitt?L 6jf iMQ,",.HQ~ 1 Tq!; 1021H HIDOO1! ldt!i ) ~: ,'Ol
. Th$ ~t,p·t,ut ~e,pbr1;; wa~ Ms~~tc.11$4 04.1Q ju): 04., ac!.q5,hej· ahothelt unknow.i:i and the twO. vs,cHins nQt~c!. a~6V~;. . , .', . th~ ptat~~ent of. .J;ibs~ip1.E:! M't.i.$~ ~ece~vec;i with TOl 0.279-04 :i.~ the same .bne ret:eiv~d with' ~rI 054$-64.~¢IbOOi; otli,E3;r than c;ni.¢ is typed (0$49.-04), and th¢ bthei (0479-04) is .
"'~d~~~t~oj;. .of ~ossibl. AbU'. has tho .""•.dote, ~ l.~ P~. th" ._ ~;'ldi."·':"J{(;:"ft!i
.',' ~¢'typ'~'9~lh¢id.¢q~ c;:p,~qk~d. (phy~~ca~ ]lliuse) D~ta,l,Jl¢~ op, Pet~..in~e {;?;"1;6C,;';';~ ..: .
f~e.T6i:1~w:;!Qi'~!~d.m~~ti 'O~~~:g4: have' h~re ~n my han.ds, deta:U$. th~ailegation$ p~rta~nint,
'. '. .,' .... ~'. .J ...•
67 (.;"/; ft-f , "G -(, ;?-t'
"
OK! p'~pet tb.~y. ,i'!,r.~ wf9i1c;i:! ~~Cqt9ipgtQ PA.TIt. ~~,corq:s. Acc;ordiing to ,tile ,2d
. ('.
$'t~t'9n; O:l,S4'/ th.,~. v:i,.qt:Lm ~es. a~¢:! diff~:r;~p.t from tn.~ vic't;:~I(\ ~'n; ~his ;IrE']; C!..n~, the.,. de$Cf}'J?~r?4,p;f abu$~ l.S '¢()mpl~tely cl;i.it'e~Emt.
, .' .
1j '.
01517';
'.,.
','
:. ~.! • "..;

:' ,.';

,: ·::'·,t.~~.f,~,i.~~:~,:.i...:;.,.;~,~~~.:
":•.: " \.~ (' .. " . .. :.:
.'.=-,:). \,~:~.~ ..'y.~.~.~.!.,~., .·1.¥~.'~i:'.'~9€*,:.·.~.~.~·~7.~ $Il?a 'bz.:N±~fR;~·Xj~:l \b~);,~ck. on s;ti;a i.n aI) hop~ or·
...~.",'.";." ; :~ ~'.: '. ,~?;~

t.'. A.
'. -: -;'
. "
, This inci~ert~J..,$ a,iieadyb~ih9 LJ).v:~~tig~Hqti ut;ld$lt. Rot .oia'4~04-.¢:tD2:59-~O~3b
(itE.!~ 'r.railsmlttiil q',f Ipt9i.:'mat.iQ~ Q:279,-04-ClbQOl (Un)¢, a!:nis'e 'o;f unk detainees
, pt an link 19¢:?-t:tod ip" traq). Th¢ inl,tial.+e;i?Qrt wa.$ dispatched 25 juri 04.
. .'. ". ' " ~ ,;t.'..fitt...··"f". . . . . .

., cJ;!.;~e " " 1;1 ('r -'I 'l j .
,'­
'. -2ZNP. ME!, 6?'-t'tf,-('
(~-iilail); b. -;, -r, .
.::",
~ . .' ~ ... ; ~ ,,:
Gent.l.~mE!xi f.~
.015178
.... i;
'. ; OOOt,22.
, . . .
... ~ ..... ;... ;

.!.
'. ,
.r.. .-~
:.1. ";" ',' ;', "
". ,:'~.i:J, ~ ! . ~ , ' ~.. -'\ ,
,
. ~,
.;: .....)~~:~~.~.~. ~~.nq t;h~. a:t:t~c;heg lWll ;
:.... :
'to ;-\"
'
'. "·~i.~~.~~/~6:¥~d~f'~~~·~:~~~~~r.~; " ., ..
\ . ~ -"
'.f.h~;kH.i.:::·': ." .' ".. .;
:: ...
::....
.';
\.
,. ~ .
":';
:"...:.' -,.:..•.­...:•.~.~'.~,:r. ": ... ~: ;.~'.' .;..J~;­
.1., ,:'1..: ..-:........: ..:.~,.~
;J~ '. ·~~·.:~·~~L
.. ' '.

015179
.. '
3 .
.'.
... :: ....

. ...
~ .9ini9·~ N;iu~' .. li}ve~tigatl()h$;: . t ~enci yo4 :tM NelS' Case' Control' Ntiml;er
~ri,i;f tHl¢ b . !¢r:m~Uoh~fitE:!r.' 1;oc1ay. A~; thE! prElsent t.iiti~ t· only 'have
rily'~~U a.ncif ... ... t9 .wo~~ the :I:.ivltt .Are~ 'o~ Ope~at:i,ons'" ~ dQ 'not h~.ve·
t::f).~. capi;i.bili ... stippo+'t. al;ea'$ wheI;€!' the ag'Edi1:: .' Cgn be plac.ec;l. in· harini!i..

. . t •
, . ;.
,.

000-024255

i .
::, : .:' . . :.... .."t ~".
, .. . .. ", ··)0'.lfr~·"~'6¥fao~· ';, 1.t;d~St:\,; ",:', . .,' 't':
. }.:
' 7g~!'~,fl~':J2%n'c;"!, ;i~b~'~"f;,~~i ~n~ , ·6r~-I;t-i..I' ,".~
~;; ,C;:a~~ ~eI)~'£0:£ tpe :[oiiQWih9. 'Jriv¢$tig~d,6~~~
" ?: ;;;
:i
,':'::
.. ;
'."inV9~!~'}~~ai.?;:~, a.~,~~~, 'f.. fiiQ~~'.$.en..d, " '. tQimn~bci :LP Wa~hj,i191;on; DQ ahd requj.t,¢· w'~eklY-tlPd,ate$
,... .
',.
, ,

.
, ,
, .
), 'i'Qjns~~ cl long, Rtpty short~ ~ riee4. ybl,l.~ h¢ip; ,
-fti¢\i!q' top lqi9\1 t;h.~~t,atu,$ Of th,e RfA' s .wE! ha;j~ $E)nt., 09 YO,il l?1~j1
~. to,': , ..,.
-~~eH, \i~ qQ: th.$~¢ ~.fp;.I:?-t~ $9;:. t'w:L.li n$~q the Ga$~'htirnbet .tha~

~ !i~g~:}: ~~:;'~~:~~;'fiq Qll QPenihq up m' the•.; investig.t),o"" I
-n¢e~ 1:9 document that tOd;, $Q ~ carr justify the C;!bsihg '0£ iha

~' i~ttn~2~~, y';u ·i~ a.dv.nC'; fpr arty ...istance you cart provide,
, r~k(" safE! '. .' /?'~ .
' ': .. -'.1.... "7t,."';'(r.'? .' .
~' 0

,
• ...; l •
. . ... ····--~S.i.!!f,!#~~··;=· .. :i~"':~iI.!· 6IO;J~' ~:.. ~~~'iIi!~":":::'/ '''''~l$~ 'p':':;"-' tl&',\ .·t.~~~_....L6a.•,-r~~~~...~~~"_"'';':~.iIa'io:I~I-'''" ~ I ..(.' ... iJfr=:'f.:•. ', ..,.-.-.~.....;~
.... :.
" " ·015~81.
000125
. i ..
000-024256
. . , ~ ~. ", . .~ ':.:
. "'~'. :" ':~ . ::o{.. . .: '. "" • .: .:.i;J;.
'.:: :'.
. '..
:.:....
...... . '.. \ ;.... '. "'::. " .., 1',. . ·..... r.;..
":: .....
. ,
' '
..
; " .
'. .' i. ~; .':', " . ,.
....,.
".~ .
.··;'44~~M~~.~;r-~~~~i·
. ....;..
~ "
"G~¢~tt·~;;;j
; ,
.,.~.~,;.~,'."..~.,.:.~,:"':if :Y.9~,;ti~Y,' ~.: ~:4.r~~~i $t~~4~,.of.th(b.~lgWii~t~~
". " . , , /:';
~ :
, ..
. '.,' '.
" . .', ','. b. -?c-:-~. ~'"
ito ('
mil: . . $ pm"
b.1(¥Ii t~~
.' . ,.:
'·· ,.~/( I~.;""'(
'..' 7~~h~:P DET (ctb)f C~mp Victory, lraq~' and b7 ~
a$ C1=ls,eA9.e.n~for the foilQwih'S Irives~isatJ9hS:
~-.,.....,.'-';, q1Q4-d4-~IbtS9-aol36l019~-04~Clt2S9.-8'02~1i and 0225­
""'l.1I "-" •. ~Q. i'.';... .'. . " .... ......
c::aS¢$ i1ave l;eer'l sent a. R~quest Fpr A$si$tai1t~ tQ'

. .,'..... .... ,. .. . ..
'. .~. ..! .
. : ifi'NCl~A()k:,: '. " . : .' ' .., , .. '.
'" "rlvesff'atidhS hi~ol\te detain~e abuse i must send' .

. . ". ":.' Q ... , '. '.' : ...... .. ........... : .. .. .............. i ..'

", t~cn' t~iilliiandj'n Washln~lon DC aiidrequir~\veekly update$
: RFAs se.nt. '. ..'...
: . 'riiak¢ 'l:). 1909 $tory shQrt, t need' your help.
:' t i'leed' to. khow the. statu$. of th~ Rt=Ais W$ ni;ive sent. D.g xou plan

. to' .
. : open up on these RFAs? If so; I wiil need the case nur'nberthat'
.~ ~~l~'~a~:~$Si~~e~~ ", ", ,~ .' '.:' '. . . ", . ','
. If YQY ~hi not pi~rinh'lg on Opening' up o.h these InvestlgatlOns·I

· 'wHi'. " . ...... :. .
-ne~d tq qqCl.!ment that too; sp t can justify the c1os(ng of the.

: c~s¢. pn. '. . .
. ~h.js.~l!;fe; ...', .... " ..
· ~ 1. w~n.tt9 th~nk yoy iO advanCE! for any a~sl~t~nc;:e "yoy ~~h proVide •
. : fClk~s~r~ ~ndbe~~fe:~' "';, i . . . ..' ,',., ' .
. ........:.. :",.,.: ..... e..-lf6~-t. . .

_.-.,
I
$ . \:7 7 .., . .
" 78th !VIP DEY CIIJt;;·,·,"·· . . ., .
.'
') '.:' II,::',}' ~..-:"'.,.".. p.::.~,~.. ~
...·~=~r~~~!~2Sk~.~~~.:.~~~.
. ':
, ,"
.'
• ..;.

0.00126·
·hUp;II*o~tus.anriy.smiLnrill~a,m~.1itm1 812lIZQ04,
. . " . ,... . .. . ~.. .
......

~ .' .' . 'i .
\:." '.' ',.
: ..:,
"
'V,e']'Cs,tJ$at$d, th~s~ p~pl~, maybe W~ Me4 tQ s9.h.d an, RFA P1'lC~'to Ii~V~ the.m
Dosu:'le', d$te$ anq w~~twoukj h~v~ happ~o~~ ~o the ii1~Qb:~rrecOrd~, :Wer~ they
""..""'...ii,,;"9;· "~'" ' .~:. " .......:~ .... :. ',". . . . . . .

, " .....
. '~::.' .
Initial 01 S4-~4-ciqZ$9,doe ~;;;
i. 7~·1i ;t;'.--('
j.1( ~If ~,.--e

. :~ .
,.'
.'
"
.....
. "
, .
015183
. , '
" '

i , 000121
. ,
"
000-024258

Doc_nid: 
3841
Doc_type_num: 
67