Email from Jeremy Caddel to William Taylor concerning a Reuters article about US rejecting the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission access to Afghan detainees. However, it is noted that the International Committee for the Red Cross (ICRC) does have access to the detainees and that it is a neutral and trusted human rights organization.
UNCLASSIFIED
Caddel, Jeremy D
From:. Caddel, Jeremy D
Sent:. Friday, May 14, 2004 1:46 PM RELEASED IN FULL
To:. Taylor, William B; SA-AR-DL
Subject:. AIHRC access to USG detainees
Amb. Taylor,
I confirmed with Amb. Prosper after the AIOG today that the ICRC is the only body we recognize with a mandate to visit
detainees in Afghanistan. Barno's comments are in the story below...
U.S. Rejects Rights Group Access to Afghan Prisoners
Reuters
05/11/2004
By Sayed Salahuddin
KABUL - The U.S. military, under fire for its treatment of prisoners in Iraq, Tuesday turned down a request by
Afghanistan's human rights body for access to Afghans in its custody.
Concerned that local prisoners may be treated like those in Iraq, the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission has sought access to Afghans detained for suspected Islamic militant links and held at various U.S. bases in Afghanistan. 'We have no Intention right now of changing our policy with regard to access to persons we control," said Lt. Gen. David Barno, commander of U.S.-led forces in Afghanistan.
He told a news conference the International Committee of the Red Cross, which has a traditional mandate to visit
prisoners of war across the globe, including in Afghanistan, represented the world in this regard.
"We are confident that the ICRC can represent all organizations who have interest in persons we control. We feel they provide more than sufficient outside objective look."
The Afghan rights body said it had received complaints from more than two dozen detainees released from U.S. custody
about their treatment in detention.
And many Afghans are still waiting to hear from the U.S. military about its investigations into deaths of two prisoners in late 2002 at Bagram airbase to the north of Kabul.
Bamo said he was not aware of any allegations of abuse from detainees and that "significant changes" had been made at
the facility since those deaths.
"I'm very confident in our procedures there," he said.
Graphic photographs of U.S. soldiers abusing Iraqi prisoners have been shown around the world, infuriating the Arab world and damaging U.S. credibility.
And in a report late last year, Amnesty International criticized the United States for its failure to make public any details of an investigation into the deaths of the two Afghans, saying it showed a "chilling disregard for human life."
The U.S. military said in March last year that the deaths of the two prisoners at its Afghan headquarters at Bagram Air Base in December 2002, had been listed as homicides, and it was investigating whether criminal charges would be brought.
Amnesty said interviews with former prisoners of the United States in Afghanistan showed they were subjected to illtreatment that may constitute torture, including blindfolding, prolonged forced kneeling, sleep deprivation, and cruel use of shackles.
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF STATE
REVIEW AUTHORITY: SHARON E AHMAD.1
DATE/CASE ID:-29 NOV 2004 200303827.DOS-002184
UNCLASSIFIED