Documents Relating to CID Report (Death): 0140-03-CID389-61697

0140-03-CID389-61 Ag7
DSCN7191

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit:
01340 j u „z

For Official Use Only
CONTROL NUMBER
AGENT ACTIVITY SUMMARY
0.711)12EGULMON 0140-03-CID389-61697 Time, Date and Agent (Summar} of Investigative Activity
About 0930, S-3 SGM, 503 rd Military Police Battalion, Ft Bragg, NC0930, 9 Dec 03 reported an Iraqi prisoner died while detained at 2nd Brigade Holding Area
SAMOnet°141
I:10 (BHA), Mosul, Iraq. 1015, 9 Dec 03 Depart Mosul AF, traveled to Brigade Holding Area (BHA) under MP
SAIIMM10-14.4 1,610-1 Escort.
SAWN. 64c-i t b(°-
SA
(ALL SA'S)
T: 45
1040, 9 Dec 03 SATS I lob-I Coordinated with WO1 OIC of BHA.
I:5

1045, 9 Dec 03 Examination of Body. (See AIR for detail.)
SAS61c-1106 -f
1: 60
1053, 9 Dec 03 Interview of CPT (See Sworn Statement for details.)
SAWN./ I"- I
I: 20
10-4449 -4 1107, 9 Dec 03 Interview of SPC 11.11111111111111111MIP (See Sworn Statement for details.)
SA allliii014-11kr°1
1: 10
197C-41 tioG -14 1115, 9 Dec 03 Interviewed SGT11111.01111111. SAINim la -1 (See Sworn Statement/AIR for details.)
I: 15
1118, 9 Dec 03 Interview of PFC SA WN.. -tofri (See Sworn Statement/AIR for details.)
1: 15
1120, 9 Dec 03 Interview of PFC SAM. k 1 )64( (See AIR for details)
- 1
"et 1130, 9 Dec 03 , 411116111111 121('-4( ki7
and SGT
Conducted Canvass Interviews. SGT 11110SA 111111111..1b6•t glimpp(See AIR for details.)07c...q ikkg PAGE:
cro FoRm 28-E TIME: TVL: ADM:
For Official Use Only

,,...... 2„.“:,:-....•—._,...—. ., ..,,...-------„..,.. — .
.1......
•., v,:gr•z.--;-.---'''''c'''' ' •.
, .s.',.\ ':IR7,7 i' ,.$
l'.i.'"-., .' ,.
,.....f...,.„e, ,
t.•.-.:11$.•z,.;
, . 'Ilsidaet. •.c.a,,INft.114Mktk..:‘:',ii,kg rilEialai.,•!th,..ag
, 2...*. .
AI
0 "I 7— FCA //, ,4fr70.,,r5-.(PEA./..a•ve.- Afuo afietlenty..
/ I 0 D
Ia/e6,0Ar-f..6 --.,,Pir_ect---7 ,..1.4./.4e
).F////S 40-., -,A..--49- C.-.Jib" 1:7.-/" eaiAftSite.ri4'6 70.M9 Cee'7 G (_,e-1 ze_. pr,-,-4-TE.A--.0102 7..dil-f- f".2..4-H&"-)
tS.
A i e 10 me/ e 4 re.....-% / c c ve "te-/7tv4r ''
, Pilly... TT.. mwemolr747„,,•77,F
, V ‘, '74rOT: 0 . ' ,741 r s . , 4!: C I. a .,APL A - -W • 1
ACTION COMPLETEDACTION COMPLETED
Sources targeted
NCIC entry on stolen prop
Medical records requested

2701 Given to Victim(s)
Name check dispatched

2701 Given to Witness(es)
Name check results received

Case # on all documents
INV ES T I G ATI V E STANDARDS

'':',.'''.5 . Ngr,...,.. 0.AI T . RH.• ,I.I R' . s sl.:,.ik-.Vs'''.'' ,:z
:'..
*,--T"-":7,1-----T. .z., ....,. ,.
ACT1VITY/PERS"J PHONE NUMBER '
01C-1 11;473
..,.),...•
,4,.
/S-Ce of.4.7-3.,e,
;..
s.1.,.,
"'tel
,...
,,...e . ... _ -. , . •. . .,... -.-4:: :it: ....A.
01_ :.14 ;i1
DODDOACID 007906
0300, 9 DEC 03 BY GUARDS STATIONED IN THE HOLDING AREA. MR ABDUL KAREEM DID NOT MOVE WHEN ORDERED TO WAKE UP AT 0730, 9 DEC 03 AND WAS CHECKED FOR HIS LACK OF RESPONSIVENESS. NO PULSE OR RESPERATION WAS APPARENT AND MEDICAL ATTENTION WAS REQUESTED.
be-ABOUT 0830, 9 DEC 03, DR11111114111111110.1111111111) EXAMINED MR ABDUL KAREEM AND PROUNCED HIM DEAD. NO EFFORTS TO RESUCITAE MR ABDUL KAREEM WERE ATTEMPTED, AS HIS PUPILS WERE FIXED AND UNRESPONSIVE TO LIGHT.
A CURSORY EXAMINATION BY CID PERSONNEL REVEALED MR ABDUL KAREEM DID NOT HAVE ANY VISIBLE INJURIES THAT WOULD HAVE CAUSED DEATH, AND FOUL PLAY IS NOT SUSPECTED.
AN AUTOPSY WILL BE CONDUCTED AND THE RESULTS ARE PENDING.
THE CID CASUALTY LIAISON OFFICER (CLO) IS CW2 31 ST MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID), MOSUL, IRAQ AT DNVT 302-581-
INVESTIGATION CONTINUES BY CID.
7. CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF PROTECTIVE MARKINGS IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY J u t; „ 49 01363
DATE: 10 DEC 03 CDR, 31 s-r MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID)
FROM: DIR, USACRC, USACIDC, FT BELVOIR VA
TO: CDR, 10th MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID)(FWD)
CDR, 3D MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID) (FWD)
CDR, USACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-COP, FORT BELVOIR, VA
AFIP, ATTN: OAFME, ROCKVILLE, MD

PROVOST MARSHAL, 101 ST AIRBORNE DIVISION (AIR ASSAULT)
SJA, 101 ST AIRBORNE DIVISION (AIR ASSAULT)
CHIEF OF STAFF, 101 ST AIRBORNE DIVISION (AIR ASSAULT)

SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION - INITIAL/SSI - 0140-03-CID389-
61697 - 5H9B
DRAFTER:
rimmeammo 104clibp-i
RELEASER:
1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1.
9 DEC 2003/0300 - 9 DEC 2003/0730; BRIGADE HOLDING AREA (GRID COORDINATE 38S LF 308 190), MOSUL, IRAQ

2.
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 9 DEC 03, 0930
to Cr

3.
INVESTIGATED BY: SA 1.1111111111111111=1¦111•11SA

10(ri
w—'-71117-
IOWA UMENIIIIIIMO SA glagagliggialg.104
4. SUBJECT: 1. NONE [UNDETERMINED MANNER OF DEATH]
1. ABDUL KAREEM, ABDUREDA LAFTA (DECEASED); 25 OCT
5. VICTIM:
1959;BAGHDAD, IRAQ; M; OTHER; [NFI] [UNDETERMINED MANNER OF

DEATH]
6. INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS
BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND
MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.

"THIS IS AN OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM INVESTIGATION"
THIS INVESTIGATION WAS INITIATED BASED ON INFORMATION PROVIDED
BY THE S-3 COMMAND SERGEANT MAJOR, 503RD MILITARY POLICE
BATTALION (MOSUL, IRAQ), WHO REPORTED A DETAINEE IN THE BRIGADE
HOLDING AREA DIED WHILE IN U.S. CUSTODY.

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED MR ABDUL KAREEM WAS
DETAINED ON 5 DEC 03 BY ELEMENTS OF HHC, 3RD BATTALION, 502ND
ABDUL KAREEM WAS PENDING TRANSFER TO

INFANTRY REGIMENT. MR
ANOTHER FACILITY AND WAS PLACED IN THE GENERAL POPULATION
HOLDING AREA. MR ABDUL KAREEM WAS LAST OBSERVED AWAKE AT

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
01362
0140- 41- ADM- 4/07

err 11 f411"Itrol, os6 anal
Jlot; .47
01361

Page(s)

•
•

Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
MS. JACQUELINE SCOTT scottj@centcom.smil.mil
(813) 827-5341/2830
O44€ - - az.589 - 6/697
1 Pe e9 3
DATEDTAKEN ATSTATEMENT OF
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
o o rA re
eAA AL( rCiSanCr 'ON t 5 erefti-e_
e
etitte\ avcr 1/ "1-1's hd, a
S o n sk-F'-a 1-
(DO ,
"
was
pert aff n:3,
la;(-1 laa--I
SA-11111.01110

PF 1111111•1111 61.6 Cle4
bt r) Pais Noe or?. m4xts7. 41-Vr. relL 4L Al o s er /A--c-rule-A./ a or r cbchtl-+ r.naitt any s'a) ; s".e rh.c nt's h
ct: bt D 14-SIf e Ctue-S-7 4. Iv% e otc.Art... PPS S ?
Q: DI D 'rot-) c. 73 SE /2 tz A oavG To tic RI C H c S LE EPVARCI-.)
A. /VD
os-) f-r wVE 4 7 tur 7 AT t')t 7 0 '1-0t../v1._ S 7A7 6,41
,te n of S 7.4r7FM NIP bic't 1b -
A :
AFFIDAVIT

b1-C-4 (0
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGE
BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR R ARD, WITHOUT
THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFL

(Signature of Person a r Cement)
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law to
WITNESSES:

administer oaths, this 5 day of 2) E C Z003 at /$1 05
knz,-/A-
(Signature of Person Administering ath)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
SA
yped 'ame o son mintstenng Oath)
A e -r 136 uc
(Authority To Administer Oaths)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIALS OF PERSO KING STATEMENT PAGE 2.-OF -t_. PAGES
L014 (06
irt 0
u

USE ONLY EXHIBIT
—"0135 9
,
449 -0:-C/40,{fel- 0497
SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
(SSNI.
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943
AUTHORITY: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: Your social security number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES:
Disclosure of your social security number is volunta.14,ry , k,. IRc,-4( A5-1
DISCLOSURE:
2. DATE (YYYYMMDD) 3. TIME UM 4. FILE NUMBER
1. LOCATIOW
q llt2S-
7. GRADE/STATUS
6. SS
T NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE NAME is641

E_ 7
S. 0 GANIZA
0/4 111 1064 -2-YY
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
rtss dr
ve te.
Pi; o r k,-/Gt koti

iehisnj A,. 5 (hack dk.cac,cc 0-C -At visr
)ioch
cl-re/c fief! 5 orn iCns j\, rix" J S 6,4-C
rer_ , A-c-ter thoo-
11;0 A6aa
is 'At ¦nr-xmi't tket+ v. etc
r+ Sfeci
r;roherS vJA6 ft
teilk;11 °f1 I 5Ckers‘°k1 etk C AC1" C
"c°4'h CICA.C6(c+-War
A :f."
hirtd(
141 fp." /
100-Okfit r ptV.11/15 b ke ride?. TA, ne.x+ neo en/ ns-
Ire -(1.1.ali, s-ev'e n e,,:jki we wer(L a4 dvt to vJatice

AftIvnj
dts.
At ()rico fterr ve . 1`7 hear)

xf i.0 cloor
cA 3 1' rvi;9 f be
ask -Cor /lel() h oetv s, At 5.04 1410,jr
isr;contrS Sand 15045 vets r‹"Ived
ejokj P-C-ter Fvfse. J:scove( ;0;
Lim cilexkut -for
ov4 tie
4-0 ye+ .-
=It terri"
Ohlh't hav enf
room IV Cat." c A" ci took ott
Arytnt fro, tl, ( pgr
6-Fitr Thai. t"' tee Call ed to GO tv`e Otn01
-14 /1"-d lea A.-1-X1 (4 +Lc Pr; so n "'"/ G HQ rv1 0 VeJ
' 611
6\n °I
11. INITIALS RSON MAKING STATEMENT
10. EXHIBIT
PAGES49/C ht!
PAGE 1 OF 2-
TAKEN AT DATEDADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER

MUST BE BE INDICATED.
HY/A V I . UU
UA WHIVI Lt3LS, Utl. TVOU 131' USE ONLY ass
DODDOACID 007900

__IVO -03 -0Di/5'1'9-64 97
STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED
9. STATEMENT #ntinued)
ty4c -4 t ipr / S is t is S •
1.) 0
A-7 /47[=i' ..01-1
,
5 -
-104c-c( ibbf
A lir
1')O l•A\ lJ tz%, vs—) '7 "7 f--( / cr e 0 1-4- nn -T o
e-rn -7 Th.
1 10‘0"1
1\)(7 eNa 5474hr-v-r-mallIP

AFFIDAVIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
3 .
WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGEHAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THISBY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I
STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCI N, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
19q C L lb( cm um of Person Making Statempnt) 111-C-41 ofro"--(
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person autho law to
WITNESSES:
,
administer oaths, this 5 day of at L-J..1 //2 ,4
(Signature of Person Administering Oath),
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
:I '1 i :1 •
(Authority o m nater tat s
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
p, a-) I 3 (4, tic r•-\
Eric- 66-4
4,4 1.¦
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
3 PAGES• '
PAGES
PAGE OF
USAP A VI 00
on-1 ,IAL larr 3€
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998

USE ONLY EXH
DODDOACID 007899

0 -03-C/0,4W -/6, 9 USE THIS PAGE IF NEEDEL IF THIS PAGE IS NOT NEEDED, PLEASE PROCEEL. . 6 FINAL PAGE OF THIS FORM. liiiirlie
t
I rA CZ 2 0 C•73 ( R. Oct
TAKEN AT DATEDSTATEMENT OF
C. ..4-. T( rim 'Continued)
11111-tuAti,,,,, jd lin co.ta (Alt ii.,,, mai-0
a 4- 1

Q1 s Ar
/ q 04'4
A' s c.---r
-frk. r., ta.y. c-ta, cv-7 (_) NI (.) S (J A, L— TA 0 \ $ E S Cs u ‘2-( r-a c,,,--1-f-/ E:

0: l ¦ SX
MI c.-i--(7 -

•
A: Ai 0
b 1 I" -a-S g-ASIC Fc IL IN -N -WCA'1,--
C4.* A7 AN1'r TWA '---
.L\-,....5 1 S -TA-I\..)C..A:-..
P1/4 . kit)

-"TOL-) .. -CS'SE•alieAv----' --‘ 0 1-1-I (:._.= 12. p a. k c, (-_, I., e ,-/.. --FuLici-1
0 -- i'D‘ 1(.) -
101C "-Li i °Ie 'N
t=t-• 5g-L....) i-I 1 Le -1-1 E--M u.../;-k- s se._ & rd, / 6-, 7

11-Mo
F C,Q 1,-) 1-5 }I 1 iv\ .
IA c U.FiEr--)
Q • i-4 t-) Li L3 tN.
A: 5stivd1,) Ovt, Ai htfta , 1,14Axi- 0,. ;,, Advil cu4ed Le.14i.,1 11,A,
0 a (3 is Lvero-, c (- 0 i Iv c.,_ AA, 7 o r:
s-i FlAi G
Ciz • b( f) 4= 5S A PP e ,ko_ ;0
-k OLC I S t--1 Th.

1". f-t C---C: 0 12-12 t=-. c -7( d A-) /1-1._ TI7 4 t 0--I IL'C-6--
A` 1\)(9
Q.: w t-se /4 r) . (-' "Tu ,-..1 Lo. S7 C F E f* S. S A 1- I 11 4:--- 7
d1/4 atuic,..t-ZAkit 0. A6.-,

Pr .-Al-61(4 1 Not“-.d 41,1 grwita 6,14.1 off 1 mov,j Ai... Jar cowl() rvi-
-...0_,....3 A 1-., -1 i r--c) I C '1,--1 ( k_., ---' rt 1._.--7

Q; rA 1 t'' 14 S8-(-I t_i G !,
111C 66b —Lf

INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
INITIALS
PAGE 2 OF PAGES
USAPA VI 00
PAGE 2, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
OFFICIAL

EXHIBIT g
USE ONLY
dIASO 7
DODDOACID 007898

/ - - /) —6/4
SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is °MOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
EC. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SSW.
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
AUTHORITY:
To provide commanders and law enforcement means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:
Your social security number is used as an additionallaltemate
ROUTINE USES:
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary. t1C- LI (t -4
3. TIME 4. FILE NUMBER
2. DATE trYYYMMOD/d.
1. LOCATION
(55.1 7,403 Ii O ko c-
L 4111(11A1 PRA
iIi6-ci ( 1ir1:40-q 7. GRADEISTATUS

E FIRST NAM , MIDOLE NAME -q X 66-C( r /Ae-fii/4_
8. ORGANIZATION OR A
-FiLki 9 ADA
c.-,---7

02(0-(1
4.0-46T
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH: ti•4(a.eu--i4 1 ife-44
Ami IS15.1dr /4),,,.+4 dui) 14+ A. zim, a*. I tit 4iter4 r
Ns *t Aii4Ii• of 9 DGC43 A1- 2344hrs, FR PROW
4. Pati /l it fr.,,,A de,,,,A, „,„/ A.„4,A;,,,,,
it JAhAt45 1, 4v fait Aroup,A . r proc,.4.1
Nuf,ci-344144 -4SIS c.obiliNuclID nidi I k
I/ .• . 4:1/Vid A GA i.AA h; g 90-4 lort
e LL. i _At L. . ¦
" r J; .:' e • .
1,,.., 9 ,W, • P ; 4.-4 -
ilk" 1„..L.,i k, 419dc.4i s, i44 ko, cry 1:14,64, 7.("1 mu,/ att..1-1,sco,,.
T lboic 1 1.14.1AA, 0f2c r24 clef
MAI-ild:A.. 144. CIACIAittkA4 Lit& live.tv
?FCMW 44 I
L sal kr% ()tot*, , Betkk.,,,, 44.-Lir ; Of Z 346 Aii..i 13/1/0
r0 'I )+11 .0. -to r ii . , y.../ so A 1
LI' , 4itilt.) . Li 4. • 513 4 ti r. -1.4. •
14 coati .. ,t, . mil X ,..,, w -,.. 41.7 + • ,
U5-._ 41.4 Co'„ 412 • )Ik 1 1 , SAW: s
In/Wol in: itt, COW/iAMA Iv Jo FLS coLoAALL), +Jilt, 4. kilic.., 4.11. 141J all 411,- debvihkt.s
P4 CP01111 O:,, k1 S
on, .1k4. Matsui i oc 017)44- CY3 111-coAA.i.k.i 40 nu m. tiro t."41 o.v ill-L.
-413 in 410 Auer AI- or A( v-3 01416
41,) Iv .40,uhwv. 4.7 -174 iiL +v 4/1., 011,,,c. eicht;m.,...., „r„v.e
All L 1,41,4. i ,s
clooit Am) 14600 AAA £h i,vie.t.
wc-1 Evy-ci
117,E Av.. ,. ,r, rz
. 4 ¦ '14 1 , ,f cti r
ik ..i..),,, ../ .‘,,.. 1
n i. L..
ifilC '1 j,,­
mt
i • . CPA) 90‘ 'No, -, •. JO
1 .w 1,3 , at 19 „I 1. I. , , 1 q
b7C-ti ( 19(91
At. I-onm -k IR Lit-tiliivve.,‘ • ilt NA& 4 4 V c43 14LAS Alai Pyrkii A, 1 Aivd it,cov6,4-J

PlAvt t). wak, vp 411,..
C:4 i bk,-(-1 1 i 4-ubrs-A 14,4 iowilk Ai.,61 („a0/641 414,4X .. SPC W///plle (IOW or 4 rvis, 49-
ple. , 04, 14sitti I i ..., mica_
ific,-(4,1c6 -,4
v... ii,.SU_.„ bo,f,,,s,,,..,-,,Co • ,
SJ "0,444 i,.,,,,,,,,i,,,,m,..„ i AI I
111- I:040. -e.-L.t DAN-2
11. INITIAL OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
10. EXHIBIT .3
PAGE 1 OF PAGES
(03--q(141-1
I
TAKEN A T DATEADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF
.
)tJ ks
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
USAPA VI DO
CIFIPCM142, IS OBSOLETE
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 EXHIBITUSE ONLY 0135 5
TAKEN AT /90-03-C/ 30- 4/‘ ATED • ce-7...c.z
STATEMENT OF
o qi4TEMENT (Continued)
094-1/
qvCAIrA)5
-f ' c_ PriNi prorD -1-t)
Vve Q-
C) 71-+AS 6T1\-1-

AFFIDAVIT
b(7
HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT
,
. I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
NTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS
WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE , AND ENDS ON PAGE CO
BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTO OF EACH PAGE UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.

COERCION, STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WIT
b& -
Signature of on Ma mg Statement)
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law to
,
WITNESSES: administer oaths, this Cl day of
at 1 IC&

mi tedng Oath)gna ire
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(Typed Name of Person Administering Oathl (Authority To Administer Oaths)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
PAGES

OF Li
PAGEINITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
USAPA V1.00
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
OFFICIAL EXHIBIT' 414# IS USE ONLY 01354
DODDOACID 007896
....,yei -C.1J -C/1.1.,c77-t/9
.INAL PAGE OF THIS FORM.
USE THIS PAGE IF NEEDED.HIS PAGE IS NOT NEEDED, PLEASE PROCEED .
4C ' 1" "4

9 • (De c--._ 0 z
TAKENN AT AltY i tA1 2-kQ DATED STATEMENT OF
1 s
witTEMENT (Continued) k-OtAc 1,,fir ,
I if)-•• -• \oek eAre-J1/4-ActIca,,Nyz_Vos \-06C-sk-Ni"--Q - r R-Cs-c,C.-
V-4_ W ,_,..1-( c v L. 4(k---121--
-
.. i_ms -.A.r_ ---5g?-, reAr.,-,f2 c.,u_..)--r 'me)( e cz-oe,L.­, %A.-cp.S %Mx-y o\-\ 4-11... ¦-•L-k-17:%."-e.e_s do. 0e.

Q. •%A. -IA.
1 Ve\iAy \i.k; \06,1( . Qe„, vie)
--CAIr.e..) 4L.:tc, to\o\cv,". \fi ,\ 6,,e2A ,/,‘\\":“, Las
Erk.-tv 0...A...PA /7 -Iry re4r(601.- VV. ‘/VJAP-04 r .
, '0_-_—L. t 1 ,v -1-4-i5 Eft 'c. A'SVI

'. il l e' '710o f71--e-Ncie.--it- -----•?) ' s 1-t-Ptr-ST
e_A_k(---e t-1-vti\,
CiAEX
swcf... Lta-v•Se- ....312.-L.At-e-40 v•kal 1 v.e.e5 . --r-k-'S \A(..,-,1 A-0
I\ • --... av,. v¦Ok-
c-S .

&.) As.zolc civ---o-ekoAl\n 4at
_sof..im.e.„...\se.ctik,_.A.,-... taus
onoe_ -cc, 103-it -Li , to 4:, "I
Air /-:, 4,:xix./ IA-pc° q co INYcii—t,e17J r\"1 Li
C-EX_)/sm
&. •14CA-12----tD3
IN-
)2.31.12-C-k2 01J c*--R47 i-tr I-4-1 -s i 7 `? 7,

VA-­
-c.,,N,D, •¦¦,-. wele,c, .
Ci
N Na cl-Le....) -.A.A.A" u1/4-str-
1/4S
7-e6-4 c.?
'Qnc_.) c-c, 0'V AA._ ..9., s„...)-{ -0 ,-„,'D,._) !..__-., -(c.Q...,
&-Per-1-7---19
ir•
.v:.u..6c. ...„.,. . a
4 -U-¢,../. ... ,.
-Z. CA-4SVoi¦e ---fal Oe-«-
4-4--' -e.1(c.tig-S . " -cli¦PA-\ft¦l1/4/¦ \\IV/1/4 ova VA S
VC0/1 /4 1S -
,-58 ,fAcuto ---)..
LA3 Pc -N-1.--4--1--(A .6-7----i-t ivv, Yo() --3-PN-uQ i:s-
6? k/J4-1/4---;--N
16-0,....,..i 1€5!00 .., )0% -N...• P3 . 1,07.c.--11( bi
vol-k. L;),_-_) 3 c-io () c-1 '7---4:V-'512, Lit, c-t--A--i-L}3 AS IA c s q=)an--)P---'', Ill 1.07-c -1. f1 66-1
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
11 PAGESPAGE S OF
Oil 34
J imitiomo4
PAGE 2, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
OFFICIAL
I JSF ONI V Ex111§114,--
DODDOACID 007895

"......
r
USE THIS PAGE IF NEEDED

. IF THIS PAGEIS NOT NEEDED, PLEASE PROCEED TO FINAL PAGE OF THIS FORM. /
‘-ei
C-- C.D 2
TAKEN AT 4.5)11,-1 e41--Q DATED 9 C3E-STATEMENT OF -
41074 -qj bb4

MOO cA-4-e-c-...De_
%-30..\e,i, -c,-¢_ Llo,104e5 C-couv.A 01:30 +0
k)c'"AtAVI ',i.e.
14003 ,-..,00 k:-,-. -Ti-f-ca. '4 -r-pci kY,.c.:s 0P
-w\. ‘ocAL e.....ski•-

taIv¦e
2' lie-vjAi.e. ¦.-11_, c\R_A-c:¦ .....ets kti 3 -6-ALA". -1.--o e.---4- 1
csA 0-1-0.L0-.1A-14-ov,o-s Ar4... ,:nn* 0..tm‘morAokAv -5\-D...--() v-t act f.L0\4.,..... \, 6.\-Ves-
1
Vo.,i oc wok-. kA.11,4 ., %,..144. ,\Akr_ Apo,..... \ \-- \s ,..-sN...c.,)c o-Vc,.\.) o.v...,) ,,,,cA-CA. VOL .
\i,s.k-r—G MAIS 0 -"tll'tle•IC--

.-
0 P (** SQ,' -
D .. 1-4-00.1 riAD fo 0 Pert-GM-Pr TO tk .. gAlx .\\,e_ ',v ;a\ y.a.e.3 57.6 vms\--celov,4) 4b
tAVA
l...)A-Vil crYSIC .
Q '. u we.--N1 '* c---s. . '7c r Nor -0-6S-R-_,,--q-Lx) Lar ,. ,_N _G. *b,---)e, .A.a--Lcpds • -' 41/4 . I. ‘cwwc-Nr )01.01/¦.. ci,v-rtu,Awea As 4o-v--3 xAc-L-Lan_ vs..0\-;,...e_c) 4-&-c
\-s
\AIA Tics L-Se-Ce— V1001-Cr"\--
N: (A u-Nrs ‘i i,n3 ,e_. p.)13--1-kcsfc-_,, kk-K--_, *757._0ZDO .-t-k-CCT e.--:`-(..7-. -D
L's) (Clz--
A :.--' AVIAPC,XISIP-e,Va-\Ac ?ASP.. o4 S; c) -k\J-c---\ VQ... Mv¦ -k- LoA..4._

-
&llr:W..e,. e. • a ik4-- e...04Me, A'-0 CLA4 ChA...
ovuz......r 4-ok\ovJe. \ny
--J v.A.Q.c..4.--ntke- v,Ate.. ¦ c. C.44.NAIL. -sco

.3t--\••••11 043-i.:..n.e..e.-. V\€,-.9...¦/,-
0_,c,v,A1-*N._ -L c e45A./... & 441..-ICZACCl/avv9J2-. 71:- L L1009-4) \ Ir.A.nSt".

i
lat-q
4........ ) ..- \--f.n%se-a, 4_ -VO G.. ate-fl.NMA"- . PFS NMI afilsc-e-) %NW-t". v4A0J-¦

bil
•A"( 1) 2:--A ut,C_ 11-tz-6 (-clasp '10--l51-0
..- 616 )ez-;, -/
\-1 0 u v3I.C.N
bait- (/
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE Z. OF PAGES
ucnae v, no
PAGE 2, DA FORM 2823. DEC 1998
OFFICIAL EXHIBIT__._ USE ONLY
J k, 33
01352 DODDOACID 007894
SWORN STATEMENT
/ .50_05_ ao "a, _6.4
or use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is (Mary
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
AUTHORITY: Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SSN/.
To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: Your social security number is used as an additionallaltemate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES:
iiijob.4.1 014_Lb&-LI
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntg. , 4... -14
2. DATE trmusiNI 3. TIME UMW 4. FILE NUMBER1. LOCATWt(
1 T 1 0(1111-, ita Ao°3 12 09 12*-2. 11
LE NAME q4 "I .. 6. SS -44 b&-q 7. GRADEISTATUS
5. .,tr---
8. ORGANIZATION OR ADORE
laac....-q 1 156-ll _ -c-q I bfl,
-1--(.......

6 _Con.t.soprev -i 31 i Nk I i\-4,....,0c... I 12A-4qi
• .w6,-Li b6-
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
CI. 09 41.e. os Z 0-rd.re e-4* Av.. gr-;&4- 1Noklat Acct, GA--0(4:00. Aro..w.A biiiiiiq i
s.k-vie,....41-.. 0 \-.. .. U ex-lci,(1A A,0
c)G.:LiS rAystl-c 6.4 c.c......) )ot c•voJ.J Olt 30
t %-w-v,1/4 "%0A-0 13rokh clbo.". 4 2. -tis v3olte.. tk.t. .skt_ei.,0.5 LAG:WI-Q-4 . A 6 I ...a...5
oc...V.,43 AVIL ItA-0.mxt_P s = &us/J.4. .1.90/‘ OvvI.- At.4--Sc wau.S Al aGe-. r-A-L."- kat__
q¦ •
• ,.. Ake- % . .1 -` _ '110 1.* • iL SMO V e-f) "
S .C0,n,& \AS \MIA . A\f`ii• If ...AN WU\ -4 40.1C V\4 41ALS ki3 472 I- 42. 42-X.k ce•VAAly 0\ 00 LA.
6.1"••• N\rsCA \ f kJ)." ll) 0-5 SIC;Il WOli-1V1/40‘i 1. .' ji 1'4-••Al 6.\".e.c-Ve-c) co,- \d ti,Xst._
kr+C.-6-44

04,4 toa) v. (1/l-k-t4 ova... --L -\•-11"•.--AL:rAr 43 64. MI -ka u.SAr....k k,..30.4
Ist.-\--r.:.,AiLe.. Vkt, A-,..e.4.....
\•Ncit-A/ AIL toNA.Q. vo'Af. VAJL Al0 eli-e...A.4 ov, .4-4._
41Ackaiz) \cAl exAtfLcstVe_ oKetc.S . k_3\"4,". AV42_ v.AJz.kc, o.c-ewe-1.4_
1114-4 10-14

,,.,c-vA.(1 ..\,....c.N -\\,...4-(\ e.......\-6.1..kee, %.3c,..s i.e.c,c) . AyseA ay.) P Ft-

ce4A0Q4 -L #....k-r•,..Ate._ o \c-Let)ANA/. 'wy avokL. ('00 VA .
10144-1 104-1

R '. S,L\
(4-c-c-i .126 -44
A\ ' 1:;'c_

it4t4-11/4.1"" 1 \ rn .- 1C)Ci "TbL) 1Y,.,- E._) 21\ki_L-q Lops-v_k_., ue '114-E DErIN(1. -43)
11. I , OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE 1 OF q PAGES
10. EXHIBIT
b3C, b&-
DATED
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
1.0 t 1E43020
DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLETE
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
OFFICIAL
USE ONIN

TAKEN AT DATED
STATEMENT OF
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
ter+c---1-1
AFFIDAVIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT PAGE . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
WHICH BEGINS
BY ME. THE ST TEMENT I TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT. FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT
THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.

1D4c-ct ;
ture of Person Making Statement)
(04c-G -(.4
Subscribed and sworn to befot.. ,. ,:„.. ° ..e o aut ' •ri d by law to
WITNESSES:
• ,eiktIs.r.-,tit
administer oaths, this 9 day _..nallon• am.*
at

137-c.- bb-[
(Signatu r n Oath)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(Typed Name of Person Administering Oath)
14-r 136 oemo-
(Authority To Administer Oaths)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE Z OF Z_ PAGES

YAM& d, UR I-UPIM tam, urt..
_854)1
J611
DODDOACID 007892

/4AP- 05-C/0 387- 6/6 77

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
ISSN,.
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943
AUTHORITY: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:
Your social security number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.

ROUTINE USES:
Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
DISCLOSURE:
d (- E NUMBER
2. DATE (YYYYMMDDOc..4.4 1k1,0-491E I Fll
1. LOCATION
-
2003/12/09.0p
Brigade holding area, AO glory
6. SSN — 7. GRADE/STATUS

5. LAST NAME, FIRST F. MIDDLE ( NAME
03/ AD ARMY
NAM151-( cip-q
111.111111111.11111044

8. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
C. Co. 526 FSB 101rst Airborne Division
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
I was called to evaluate a detainee this morning at 0830. The detainee had was suspected to be deceased and had briefly been
physicians assistant at charlie company. She noted his lack of pulse, dusky and cool skin, unresponsiveness
seen by 1 LT
notified myself. She also noted having never seen the patient dining any of her previous sick-call visitsand fixed pupils
1LTOMINIk cool,
to the holding area. I went to the holding area and evaluated the patient. He was, as previously noted byI determined at that time he
dusky, unresponsive. Pupils were fixed and unresponsive to light. No cardiac activy was present.
was deceased. The patient was not familiar to me.

At this time I did a full exam and noted the following findings. Several ulcers were noted. A 2x3 cm ulceration at the right
wrist, radial side. Grade II without surrouding erythema, yellowish base. A slight indentation from previously present wrist flex
cuffs remained which did not touch the ulcer but went around it. A 2x2 cm ulcer was seen on the left wrist, radial side but mostly

I ulcers were
on the extensor surface. The left wrist ulcer was othewise of the same description as the right wrist ulcer. Grade
present on bilateral lateral malleoli of the ankles and over the fifth mtp joint. A 1 cm laceration was noted on the superior
occiput with minimal blood matted in the hair. A hematoma was palpable of approximately 3x3 cm in size. A fluid filled bullae
was present on the medial side of the right biceps muscle. This was 1.5x0.5 cm and somewhat linear. The epigastric area has a
3x4 cm region which has several smaller 1x1 cm ecchymoses within it. The limbs were easily mobile and not rigid. All

measurements were estimated.
I briefly interviewed the personnel present and learned that following. He had been here for four days. his initial interview on
1 1:6-4
admission did not reveal any medical problems or medications he had been taking. He had not been noted to have previously1A4 -9
corn lained of any unusual symptoms. He had not been singled out previously as a detainee who might need medical attentio n

Q: "f.-
A:
Q: t e =dant have any type as wounds you would describe as defensive?
A: No.
Q: Do you have anything to add to this statement?
A: No.//END STATEMENTWObl.c. ,4 k2 -q
N MAKING STATEMENT
11' INITIALS el •10. EXHIBIT
PAGE 1 OF 4— PAGES
b4C-44 fdp-
TAKEN AT DATED
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE All)114)9Ekt,, MUST BE BE INDICATED.
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT
U0141-"H V I
ULt Ie

ruOTTICI
LEA 1-UKIVI LUZ'S, Utter lUMS
USE ONLY
3'1VDS01ION

0 CD
Traci pauiuxiappun
Casenumber: 0140-03-CID389-6 1697
)100TH 3'1I11,

Gd
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

0134S

Flat ATT C
0140-03-C1D389-61697

DSCN7197 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit: 4

01:347

0140-03-C I D389-61697

DSCN7196
DSCN7195
DSCN7197 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit: 4
0140-03-CID 389-61697

DSCN7196

DSCN7197 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Exhibit: 4
Juk;yy
01345
0140-03-C1D389-61697

DSCN7195

DSCN7197
4
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit:
0 1 :34
0140-03-CID 389-61697

DSCN7194 i-OR OFFICIAL use ONLY Exhibit: 4
01:34s

0140-03-CID389-61697

DSCN7193
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit:

oi34n 6k, t,Z3
0140-03-CID389-61697

DSCN7192

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Exhibit:
0 1 a 4 in4

; INVESTIGATIVE STANDARDS
—'4'lia:M4
01364
DODDOACID 007908