Command Investigation (Fleet Hospital 20, Guantanamo, May 10 - 23, 2002)

This Commander’s Inquiry in to an incident at the Guantanamo Bay hospital facility where a detainee became violent and attempted to assault military personnel by tossing a jar of urine upon them and using a metal chair by throwing it at the personnel. The Commander’s decision on disciplining the Military Police commander centers on the commander allowing the MPs involved in the incident to continue to be in charge of the situation after they admitted acting inappropriately towards the detainee, and allowing them to keep and carry their weapons in the hospital facility. The conclusion is that the commander failed to establish a positive leadership climate among the non-commissioned officers.

Doc_type: 
Investigative File
Doc_date: 
Wednesday, May 29, 2002
Doc_rel_date: 
Thursday, June 23, 2005
Doc_text: 

JOINT TASK FORCE — 160
Commander
}bedpans:0, Jokt Task Force •160
Guammenao Bay, Cuba
APO AE 09360

JTF-CO 29 May 2002
MEMORANDUM FOR Commander, Ile Military Police
Bandits, Joint Detentka Operations Group, Gontammo Bay, Cuba.
SUBJECT: Comminder's Inquiry Regarding Incidents at Fleet Hospital 20
1. Hums reviewed your ranks of the commader's inquhy regarding the events at the
Fleet Hospital on 10 May and i3 May 2002.

Wed to address what I consider* be blue.
leas made aware ofa aitustion invokiog I100 hours on 13 May
to 1.11111.61M Mud Mod inappropriately towards a *Mines. Yet M 1330 boas* was armed witka loaded 4. ‘ ¦ ' hi second incident with the sense deteinsa. k is clew to me that failed to discharge his duties as a non•ammdsationed officer and a soldier and detainee at risk kr use of lethal force.
3.
You were directed on 14 May 2002 to remove all watery police belonging to the 1154 MP. Battalion Bova the Field Hospital 20 gamily detail and to remove lethalviscous from that location permanently.

4.
You kneel to establish a positive leadership climate among your nota-commissioned officer corps. You me dreclad to tab positive steps to comet this situation immediately. Failure to coffee this deficiency will cause me to take more drastic adieu.

.
Brigadier General, USNGJoint Task Faros 160, C.onunander
CF: LTC.Clitie; JDOO CDR

0 0 0 0 5
DOD 13333
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
JOINT TAM POMO Oa
Jelid 041010.4 Openilms Om.

111Ory RAW 11.1•111m IMO) oast— pos Ass POO Ai IMO
WV 10
• amass Of
J17 MOO — 11S HQ 2$ May 2002
.407-
DOG, Guanumuno Bay,

FOR BeitliMitElt Commander, JT/7•160, Onentammo Bay, Cuba
SUBJECT: Commander's Inquiry Reprding 10 May and 13 May 2002 incidents at
Fleet Hospital 20

1.
Enclosed are statements born individuals concerehts the events of 10 May and 13
May 200Z Fleet Hospital 20, Ommtamme Bay, Cubs. I have also =inducted several oral
interviews with regard to this inquiry.

2.
My investigation has revealed the following floc On 13 '
1330 been detainee]. threw his mine bottle in the direction oL
who was walking bed at that lime on his way to thro . some trash
into a nearby trash tun. the bottle back in the direction of detainee

11111 The detainee then even more agitated — be lilted himself up on his bed,
began scumming, bed and swung a metal chair at the guards as they
',method (because as mined, tie sat down and did not pertieill
subduing the detainee c su teed off of one and hit Detainee 11.111who
had an external Sufi= device on his amt. ultimately subdued,
restrained by the gook and immediately suffered a small laceration to
a flags and an *basica on hb ankle. medicated for pain and sent for
orthopedic evaluation, which proved negative.

3. Statements Rom several witnesses to the 1330 incident revealed neprevocation of
Detaineekatin of or any other military personnel. Detainee/I
did state to (the ward NCOIC) eat another guard bad kicked his bed prior to
the 1330 ' so witness this account. In fact, none of the

Abases that I interviewed saw any offensive action towards DetaineeIllas be wdked by tbe bed.
• 1111111111s looli4.'yrari6edarsevoltArmy 6 to 16 66 goer of setivadoty. lis
Is a amber of6e 4$S• be Detadvemo, ewer odoll by


00006
DOD 13334

&I
0 0 0 0 ...3
9ZZZ1. non

9CCC CIOCI

80000

09L gracyz fiat mor uapausuusirj
vsn

4159 Ixo 444100APV f jigs 091-11.1 3041
loomr .amiwow dPILIPIS 8/1.1 lam ma wen= Ana no) "swap =moo evegdoidde us mum= cs ammo(' s al are ea( paw put kith! mot papaw= mug and saw. a u.. uodev
*Mau! ana tee stuougam nags apron
03 mg 3003113 =PM 1 n$91 52 s 0$ Pam 3111A mumonal 4113P11133d 11113MIS ttrepaao mxn spit of prxotien oast /Immo Mil • WIPP= Plow spouFaaP 01330003 mul3000 01 Padua n ImPle An *xis 41PAPRPIAT mnic
Al 30 Valland I =RS laPnll ROOM Pohl wo wimp Da tiazo pad gam Antal 'gip =Kam Mg meq* ofq Aqaba, se exppq og papaw an Ng ¦Ciptygods z
.521141 ammg BRIM Psapuoloo mamasumo award as pampa gampamasp Pus Mg qsufinsaage el el Aibtrf magJofmoduldnI. lunaq out actamstxoaddeie COM £1 Pag Von VW Pane *Pug ollauPoP 10(i API 01 u 0 OZ 1,11throli PM m 1101210210 quare ell Amboy Vapmeanoos pazigm us at as sats) I el
Or rqicholl solid sumP1301 ZOO! AM Mao atiVi ot siatabut simpgautuaaio golwOtal ;MIMS
WO 'AEI =Ppm wog Nteasavil cord Asaiowt vos t t impusuale3 Int MICIKV1101411111
toot Ari 91
JO NNW

spa 52uarimpung
NS =ON IMAM
o Matt= sn
38f43.430 0114311111V4130

• •• i3111Ay.o9
.. • • .•
.••• •• ••• • Afitox tmgray-IZ30 OH. LairTMCSSCII patMA.=
"Theeka...huS_Faamonf-E-64 V. little401‘. ••• •••—•
or_
Ther-72mr--- • -

Z. hock saux....ta matssciLimay. ptratiumoh)._
Afies.....-rassise..... r.64e.m.hat . .
Iltiar.111111Frawnas--Atley -Atm emu, Yht. Saw- uivogt.. Ina? pvast... Tiny_ WERT. 7t0 FiESTILF04...`144- ef JIC
L 1-1Eir tons.. .
META I dm* "dun: Was. Oft= NEXT' To. ba Aim) ha-PM-10yr .111Txtka Akt., _
plexED Lkp thghtt ANZ.'Carocamb . Pr caw", 1-tiE. 4.5CZNE .
-

'MAT is kekA covvawszep.
SWORN STATMENT 1110414 is permed la 00OBOPS
For um d Oft long No AA
NS NU UER

ami • MK
=mow
1.E7 He StIVIL rtAY r'j'
MEV

111111111M1
AtVITTO MS THE MUMS STAMM' UNDER OAT
WY( ‘1, Ion. bc.444es. •Ai leas Co",14:+i aP f ck be•A, kickpg :0Sktr )4 kf.i% ossfi, low,. +4e. wAlk ttAt itiritwt kto4 w
4..c.f 1444 h•m.l
k n SO how 'Si ‘Uk *An ce, III +cos .116 t/c 0.U. 44..* pt.,k

hsvt 1•ct a 1•14rtaSias hp" enA 440A was rt. spalut1/4 For Jessica) his tack,
1 tows •Jiartssi Lis e •

+ MI 441.1 Aidunt6 ,0
Nresg.w..
-pm tick.;.. ..4, tno w.f. Z „.,,,s .0 c lost 44 lam /As z (...lar4 Ipy
,i ist

p¦ s an ^J.
Age. at Am 1 104 :Lk I. kfiSck41 .hAck iii his 4:tecio«..
Tht., -14se A•t4ALsol Lc c.. near i ei$
t Xiferti3 II/ St+ Aad Vic Itch A 40, C Wr
•4$1
PA f's• 4„71&44at il) S4", +Is 4 s 44E4+44 IIII 4" 4
" "14 sack 1.4"
s ficr me-4t w+kg, mt s', mi¦4 whits 2 iota/ 4Ack 4** ,. 3 Seat
tomposoi• The tk&tr was puilcA Pro.111111%44.1.,404tr tic fo. k. 06 560)f1.1 1.044
p'4 A.

11". 4e-0'1'mA ;" IK0c 11 f4L.linc44isziell.ei;94..41.41.41 fv.4....---...- .: 1),E—Xc4;.:4;.. 4,..4-iii..iel C.3 melica sikriCkii.cf is g c/..4. A aw.1 • • Adi pt
Foor feserreSrliso..ki. isIA • fit PC-..
:. • • .

.•.• •.ICJ/.•.••• I.•
• • . a• • • •• •.I• •.
• •.". •.•

INITIALS winos:mama
IH • •• . . : D IIDT
POSE i CF PAM
ADDITIONAL AWISMOTOONIAW IMENSWINIS "STATVAINT OF -avassm._ DATED ' CONTINUEl• • ' . •
Deammo arocet AMMON% PACE MIRTNYW THE NOUS OF INEPIDDIONWIDNO MESTATIMENTANDIENMED •
AD •PAGS_•__OPOsislive/A00103MO:PADISANIE IMMO NEM=WM*. kigititt.1113) OUT, ONO 00. •

StATIMINTMAIL RECONOWD110 ON nattnewscimvanetCOMP ME FORM
siDPERIEDBD DA PONS MA, sam Ss, *WM WILL SEIM°
OA FORM 252,1 AIL rz
00010
DOD 13338


SWOT 1 STATEMENT .. For ups al Vds fon% ow AR MAN Gs peperwreTM
sai le WOOFS LMT!111110.* T lip ALE WNW
LOCATION
Rev/ lie is 14440 i; /'y 7In Mr/
MOLE NNE
NNW . lir
OROANGATIct_OR memo
Ilirm/07.7

1 L. , WANT TOW= THE FOLLOWING OTATELENT MOIR OAT
fb, 44.4 /51.4 4 f 'VT 0. 7i AP/r¦ r /31 0 rwhk ire#0'..1.;„„
egeopdr Af•tee S -,/,,0, 24 01447. 1

r oitig.4 "0%4 elf r..41dre 6.44p, & pit,,e+e lip/ ••40,e0 ,fej t; p.4' rwe,..,.., iv44010• is 0., 1 ire,. Ae, ol,r/..;,,,1111,,,,,,,e
X /11194.41 fr• /0L 741• Am/se tsrika/ •0,/
ii,•- ....fr.. f.se, &Omer",
onbn/f 4 Me ofeee4;• /Pe 111¦11111114
,0„„, y' it.r1p, Ai' r ofi.....fre4 re foyie vie
evi •.1 0
Ph*/ rha 'LAN". lie t74•0.;Aer- ilVr rimort, Elltitek

1*•k 6' a.re......
4e7' elY• tia Ai Ag ‘4-04 p40/41/1/ Pe4Ars. Ar
tn.0,0•41
pi as HO ikiik plit wide#054/). if Ind
44 ie " . I s,0. .,, / .../YA,

Pe, ,/III• • 144P/ fide ?row Jewi4
...../ 'Awe 4. ek Yome.r
e", ... oifiredd 0?.?"
4•Pal/ d •/
. .
exterfro*/ "wer- j',.../.4./ ?le el.:, .4.1 Aro..../
0 /IA .k"mA ••ar
4:a. ;4 AP Aidrio A,.
fSe011111 Pe011oia;A0
jekow ler. / e. yel: eValowd• ..... 4, pme......
e•r•Viloatw,

16.14.1 mbe ch
74.„ ,,,/„, ,/,,,,,,,.; IIIII fie* freitivoi., At. • eh•i., sviii4-ti
14•40f 4?•/ do,' e.4.-,/ fiee•wa ....../ decked ereA7.0. law 0004..04
"fix.
“4,11 1:4.9.?...,....../ /4
,,,,e. mg.,/ . .14or A-#.,1„,.:4,;"'Afte ......1 Asow,f 04 00;;;;;;:-... .,,h. .
el. A /...;,' Jece.g.r•,:**..1:,,,r.""
liempii. ?We :,4,•,,....lips:. -1,.!1,..•J't VI • •I• • •••• • •••••1••
..• . -. • • J.:. s •
if tj, . • l•
. .• ..• . r • •-•4 ,.. :• .,,
-
••••••- - ' .i., r : ......, ; .- .. . ..•.• • .
.
• • : • s. . •
' - - ' ' • •"1...
Pi bed.
. ; . •
:•' • ::.•
f

• V-
INMAN LLIq NTATENINff PACO 1 OF
mou
AMMON& PANSsuircavrms.na MOM IffATIMEN T OF MIN

I I
DATED ..--..COMILANI• •
-THE 00770MOMEACH *201170MAL PAM MAT ME MKS OP PENNS= wow THE STAMEN TAW OE MAIMwpmea.;_, Av_=:0169IN • WWWMODIRCONCPAGOSme{RL ONO:THE WICK CIF PAGli $.Mt
OUT Ara nit
someNrvau.ircomeunigewnembensmoscroontercorfarnisFellit DA FORM 2124 41A. 72 summon OAFOINI 3 1.1ANgs,vmat %mu. us woo .. •
SWORN alATIMIDff
For use of Nla tonal too AR 111044 Se papaw. seam la COMPS
MT00- M4V' FLEE! worm MAY 69 i 77336
uli=111.1111111.11 MOM I P"

111111.1

747,407"74* *Teti- t*MtPhit
. WPM
ATEMINT UNDER OAT
• tou)LE pRovibING sEcoarry FORrWAVY NvAse)
(.4) A ) wA5 RITEODIOG biElcorEE ollsEtZVEb bETAIMEE `PICK UP META FOLDING, CHAl2 ii-sup FlreffiPT It) `STRIKE WHo
.WA5 TA'?wX To RESTRAIN) MM.
• a551510) 0\1 VYING TO RE5TA4 A MEE ,q AEQUE5TE -b /Mar a. 6E7-frloR&-RESTatliPlf5. 10 THE PRoets OF I ORE RTR.Aiprrs, z WRS Cinifb BY hltio
bErAmleE111111 TO 'NE LATRINE, ESCORTEh fiki) REPLAC.EI) 1-liM 5u MOT RE COLD ATTe b :THE SITOATKA1 inNOLVINI& DETAWEE rAND
.. ft ........... ..... . .. ,......... •,, ., .• • ..........1.7.zw• ............. 0Np. ••...._.... • ...wow ¦

• ....••• .4. wow ••• WO •
7ac
rl L. • •• ..• :. 0" b °E. ./ StgrEMENTO •
4, • , • .• 44
. • • r • • • • y.. • • • • !•••••: • v
•,
• • ••r • *•
er• • •*" f!{•14: • 11.4.1 :•.•• . • ,r;••••• •
• . • •
• .• •1
AMIE 1 OF s MIS
leannsiiranivanew
ADDMONN. PACES MUD 1' COMM DO MINN 'STAMM'
TANINAT-- DATED--ICCEITIMADV
11 DOTION OF EACH MOWN& ANN I MUST WE TM MAUI CF MIIPINIONMANNO THESITAWMEiffImsae atm=Arraseg_z_ce,zz_patalit• MEN NXEDDNAV ANN AR E WIDER ME &WC CINMEEMPIMINIr IMO OWNS 11W •
StAIWANT NELL SE CONCLUDED WIN E MOW WE OP NICriNER CCM FOP TN I ft FORK
DA Kum 2.2$, .72
sso PON son, 1.0411 es, mons mum MOD
111101111111/11
00012
DOD 13340
11W0161 STAIIMENT

Far aft Weston% anARrTRSs peoponitrcyIs 00CSOP8 OM ISE FILE NANO
LOCATION
_2T Itc 40 pa Ct., 1,WI-/330

WENN °lift
AVANT TO WAKE Tie POLLOVANCI ITTNIENENT UMIR OAT
aver/ 4•'h git roe; e 40- foe ii#001-4••••¦ iv+At C•i" .A td, P•4. 4 r;04 peer., "pro 4+• •¦••• Cy./ if-44; CA ;Si :;43 eft 44031.4 d...cs d.,...ecer. P*44.0. :40‘,45.10 r.',44 01.4 wi vent 1.0. teiit 4+.
• • .......••••••••••• ••• 8••• 41. w• • ••• • • l•o••••••• ...mom. • we.... ••¦•••¦• ••••• .••••••••••• MOONS 011•¦¦•• • • en ...DN., • ••110 MINIM. 00 MO

•• • a ••••
•: •,taalla$,•
• .• 91 •.• a
. . • . •: •• •

: 'ON • '6.1' 4. • • -.. %stf • .. •:61• • •nil: • •i • • v• ••:1,••••
•r •
• • • ;•••••.-. • • • l• • • :
. • ••:' r.
• I • • .• gje.
;obvert maul or remoiligron
s, 1104111 1 OF -.L-moos
mamma PAM WIT COWMAN tILIDINII ISTATINENT OF AT—..... DATED ' itONTNNNI• " • THE *MON CP EACH ACOMONN. P41111411111111841R THE IMMO OF NE PERSON IINONI-IN II! STIMINENTIND IIE WM=
AS frAer..:_-_0 — • mow tswormootoomeivisoomouramok nasacartwag 1,s¦ccea WO otk.vo nit
SPYINIINTKULIE oceicwoo cis rre sawn scoop r moms con' ai NIN IMAM . DA FORM 2$231 JUL. 72 ILIPENNOss VA PORN 2223, WAIN, FINICHVAU.1111 WED
InVORN For use al fhb fobs, see AR MO; Po mewl Is000SOPS
LOCATION0r4s, 040 41
4 Pr" allsa if/k4os I ME Num:
NNW

fir' thri4i
AWRT10 MEMO MOMS Mown umOAT : 04 oi pram./ ammo/ As/ ,off.. Iii. M.
:
6.0.4 sso'd41
04.414 •,¦• 44.sea
r 4.4./ orty eSA?
I. imee•iiidaos
...ne.f 40. ...a
of 407 04.; .4.44/ 41. de: .,14•27 .1/
1 4404 ;
Mil

4..od
...a/ et -.4%•,‘.1 A:".+9 •‘/•,-;.-/
a. 40 44/
64 'I
dawn 444 flO Li MO 144r Adne0
.. 14414 a

4, mya,,,e
.6"./ • 1 54.40.07;r*
.• • •••••••• ¦•••••• ••:¦ ••• .• •••• •••• • • 1•••• ••• • ••••• •¦•••• •••••••••••••• ••••••••• ••••• •. •••••••••¦• • • . ••••••• •••••••••••• ••••••••••••••• •S.

. • • • • •'" : • • • •
. •
• • • • • .3 r • 1:1'• • .•;:$• •••6 . " • .4 ;• S • 4.114 •

5'
-I MCA 1 OF / MU ADDITIONAL Meiatuaramm trasmora ma TAKENAT__,DATeD_Lcrintiszt ..• ..-.
EiNISIT swam summer
•Ire scrrrom orsfamaamows. me musrams THOINTVASOF neratnetaware wararawirmtin ammoAll I-may...L..0p • mow ItheIVADD/7112M1. AWINAREIMMO. 1P1SACKOMION: Wilto OUPVO ip •STATOMENT MIL MO CONCILOIDON Me MOW VOWAMMERCOPY CIF ThIll FORK
DA FORM 282s, AL ia supotstrenDurawm asts, UMa, loutionvu me usuo
11111“1116111
I . II
SWORD STAMM • •
For use of Itio boo, ooe AR 1e941 Do proposal lo 00CSOP8 ' Dm we MU MAKER
WICA7,
soraitoispplo •
I. 11111•1111111 , wow noionor woo QT
•; uog • on At 66,-
i ay '3p, 1 at, Plaiiire• A no. ,

4,0 A 44;04,01 s•Alk 4 44C& Ogee awc 'At re "4 k


Ad iNw i a a III I igovespot As 40 ;WA eaIIII8ei. DeAdipee. '

tii4mP • birp
••01414 Arow vs -win6 home Atippill A# are' .S

Alasvprof rift" e• res ), Desisapbas
14
• 445;.e p4k mbr A. ctraser ^...4 "mo . A' a it witsw,
ig A _l_p

Ebek ;# cAsuaii ;4-O° kaiiie 10km N),
44. mom 4.,*.iii pi. )€1400460. vilgs giaa.,
A•1•1 fat Wolf' Ma&41 •

%sal •••• • • • ••• • OP • • • •••••••••••••••••••• ••••••••••••••••••• •••••••••••••••• • • • • •••••••••••• • .• ...sow •••••
• • • • ••••• •• •.• ?'" .i 'r • • • • • • iiter • • • • . V.. • • • it ••
.
••• .

I • • :•t
whew • • . • immos.s WINO orwromocr :
PACK t OF _...L. moss
=7&& PANSmawCOWIN TMMANN I VIITAinieff CP maw Ar— DA7110 -.-CCIAMPAINV • ' ''' • THE SOTION OP 11001ADOMDAMLPACEARMTIMMTME DMUS or 1111 PINSON MONO 7111E 37471IMENTAND If NIKO Ai TAGICL-OF.L.::-..."11311V1Wiff =MOW AMMAR Itilt1Lala MUCK OFAMMASILLIE 1.6111) Our, Age nig/omen-was aff ayemosp as I PIIIIIIIVORMILICOF ANOMERCOPV OP MIS PORK
DA FORM 2szir .1141- 12 SIMOKIEDIES DA FORIA 3KM, SAW Mk lvalICMMILL Es WED 1011PICa
00015
DOD 13343
DOD13344

S11 OI
Forum of Ns Iowa, seem 410411B b plapment Y 00CEOPS 134111 111111
IREM1rR
Lc:craft iixertag ao n insi r
0110411EXTATIX
111111111"
11111111rt
A
: I. . VONT TOME THE MILOMIG STAIIIMIEff MOIR OAT
or. i = usdkj weir?. 8 1 ai KA. esuti 4 riast 1%1+4 24).
an 13 f44 Aiwa. 1313-
3: idol POO ID WC/ kill, 10611 Cer 4.¦ det; .11.±
....- WaS Slroge.th". ht Acpugi . 133o "T. sue:14".0 abah.fn ^ifi, it., tAamma ef--44. fed.ew • • 5464 01464 is oe dm ti.ut Ai 44 r", 'T W4 (411400.4 of 144
r Its,:f
41,40 We Prod 14"? a* OVA egink 0144 t c't. M r•1 6„, 0 , „„ 4. )ore me tkill kitief • 101.49.M offriva °t
di 4
e 1A 14 tAchaiu of
444 u4suul
l ciairpar4• kb Ikea , 14f.
beta.4.a. . otiv.:AlluusleFtwett
'4 0.410.‘ a Snytta cA4tal
epaS C•mt audied fra4.4. raAhcai 41tams 1ition...03) he 4.4 Avow 44 ovt4 side PC klo 0014)44 41.00, VW tiffs. :r_ 4 urtitj c& 0," Mis 'vv.,/ SWilit .11(§L•2 Cit/14^ e.t.a.. T Chsirv.Mt
41tat )‘4. if ‘,L,,, to es onct nudia i,vel c.iews4 iti• cp.& ) ealtI 1 5 1 .46 0)-F+ Nacr-c ar Sado., ; MAAT *la =I 50 4 ead, ia Wiatui4­
41"1.64117:.7
-Alb— at t sikAT .04'.3/41148-sfekiiv -tile4ezt . coma . 'eta
(-efor14. 44%; .)* c46:4-cit '"$41:14:." Si4;!4.c."43 fnaf) .
i:11.14 46i0 $04.4t
re.d aiwi0;4010'sg9..
ti.)cvs bx; t 4v

mealSTATEMENT
I . PPM 1 CF I
PANS
ADO11101141. MEN stuarcotivanOMODINS•ratnainwrap_ rAmemr_.--auro--:.cannust-
11111010M OP EACHADOMONAL P40111UST SEAR TNI FORMS OF Milt PERSON AMINO ME STATEMENT AND warmer,

AS vA08.,;_,..Ps 'Weft ADDITIMM:
ive urageDmit matOF imogiAir.Liurumisioq,;vonii
StAYOMENT HOLM CONCLUDE) ON ME MIME SCOOPANOnNtCOPVOF1lNIPORK
DA FARM 2524 ht. i2 WJPEIPIEDINIMA POW Mt WA* MICHvataismus•
917CE 1. 404

8t000
onsammit asn arramscow vt.myr win WSWva nanvidnir gL vv. vaic:4 va
WSW NUMAND SIMONY dO SOW WOMAN NU NO WKSVONO3 SS TINUNSWILVIS WU avvuoctitn SI Tow s sawsworwarst IMMO DIV WWOUSOWSIKSI AVOW .""'"1I0 IOW. Sr
OSMUM ONCUMWSIVIS &WM" NOMMILINLIO MUM AU uwws anw IOW WWWWWW NATIO WILLOW SNI .vsmstssuge—anon Alumna 10 ANNUM" WPMAU NWJNO3 ISM! WWOUJOOV
SIMI AO I SOW
ParelVIAIIIIIL AO OMNI

lir
Pa, u&VIIIHri tiftwyoompl,tooiF AsJolso 3' tt. mi ,
"TOIv ieV
121. 1' masoll pet 6 iti. 37 *(4_ 'VII I ..legrowlyla1"11.1911744 .
,w.4a 1itiff ..Litv pre) 4040, art Wiri¦ fprorzisv,'llwisse wow Postger0
,
meridY '&127 /4/ff 'sty ligav. ausai•AfteMpitOgg 7,1 4 jrwrispiev 1
e70lirAv117111 21^,""lilt ,, 144 us. at1.1.114191sie twnt
MS • foorrurretyft, V ,ighlf y .V•V 797J7CW
feigtistap r

.faTriNVIVOICI 'Peri
200941 sitiv If ryssof mei* In, 1
flP
VIPOuntsf2V

WaYli "14/1"41f -00041erfrt
orlalliffhattilio, YA Poswjpro OCOWO ,i,
/4,0441, slit so par S iy reit,: .

frageillipil ptwo-ords-
fistero~7.wispgrw-myy six,94 &Am* army.miumtp,o-
, ;104-19/7././Wearsr,iy/•09 rirfotimataffsruderw. 744•114,4ov
AstAw ,~44w ow/ syriPprici q VW 4 fit .1frW-e pmfont-Orht
rirr ftr a 11 tregaifioIll11.1. .11r17ani`ge(4161V PT avffilli mit 2'

•sriesw prof aoo)tani Stetn Phry.py4ti eye' ....,6402 Q/ is esir INV i mot L Allvi "I grl
1 ..tt 1
30V
A...ix roue* w vp PsP4791 214
4iiiiiom PV__ I. PairlPitY3.4

OWPPY
,9-10'sr
VPRev 11 olf ft
9'1°PP V evAif (*Ai -
ePted__
44".8*,44,
-41(
asap, Itiy.www,sra w 4/ /0041.8fril 7.1"6"14
3geW fl*PAY 71."all Plif "'PPM"frfia", r

_- `, 1.1 PIZ
elm lion( y a ipippypidv• .w•Nits W 40w.er.P."
iti • osii,1-570Avhss, lyslowepawarAY'Vests?r,rrvoiew aLooP
'im.2ppeur pro WM, Pm "Av . 11 (0040't

AV .111.412 nog fil craeselwris seams..1 WC, NO
utvo NONA LWOW OL LAVA '


„..EINIPINEMPL,
1111101] ..
100,11111117.ifitroho.../.0&
jzia-zoAist/4./
NOILV301
vilivne4 nil IWO
SA011300 sl parai a WW1sa s WV Ing 111114SIMI gonad

LN31131.V13 MIMS .
.II. a.
.1 in Hama .9 a NOM • II „„„. , „, a..0
STATE . :1ff Nontinea0
Tiwurmilly•Z bickat
h6e A 7greel atXrD Arnifir51144(..r.41,44.44,4oirs
rhs; ib4bI pfradikrotietiby tieforvx Ighaagro3 Asttal f.nlliswirmbirk-taped iscospee ito Whitvgkei A. rVac/ CSfiglierwr5p co& mckorAlvel 1114
11$1 4.) boast reasAkirc.e. iistik4uP 'WA' gwiA 10 i414 Alir hrOtrisat 9 kahleacikig. avow mwpritir.i.Cryd6ic •:: evig¦oli svc4 40 Aar
0 gedP I/1

AA swiiNt L • _ • NOE MAD ON NAVE NAP READ TO ME MB STAMM'
wpm.wpm ON pAin ANDWM
riaLAL... I FULLY UNNIMITAND THE CCOnvirs WOW MTN STATEMENT mai
WY Ml. THE STATIMENTES TAM I HAVE INMAIMOALL CORRECTIONS AND NAVE OVITMUEVINE MOTION OF RAM MOE
COMMONS THE STATIMINT, 11111•11 NADI STATIVINTRIBILY
MURAT OF FUMOSIENT; AND ¦wneout =exam MAWR& OF oviertrat NE1NAD, UMW Minerm Perm Mow almiwastve
VIMOESSAlk
166.1•1•80 sail swam le WAN. me. • mom auftfilleg bir lowadoilalsor soft thlt_`_ ow at
le
ORGANUAMON OR ADM*
Nignowe arPorson •40****Fing OINN
• MPled AMON AdMinkifed/* DAV
ORGAMMON OR ACCRUE MadharitylbAdneelagrOuteri
INITIALS OF PERSON MOM ITATIMINT
PAM OF

00019
DOD 13347
loss, Pm ;* sein O P= S I I INN III II lin NM ON sums I sou. III or N 1
For use of Nis fain, we*? 1110-4114 So racemes lb 00CSO.S LOCATION • OM WAR MLR NUMMI .23 Osof SPX I oe&7
Ca 'townie Idn : ____4*
K0a.111,
LA NAME, FIROT NAPACIACOLS NAME 1100AL -.. TV MONSEN
IMO
ORGANEM71ON
00:11TIVediait
WANT TO MAU THE POLLVAINO STATEMENT. UNOIN OAT*
1111111111
op.. is piDZ ‘141.:t :es Weic .Pel‘isee, ill ea, 44
)
Pr•ps 414 .N44 silitf 111111116bwv ids kid1E1'7icier deli Or Any AIN& Aiwa A• aubn • 44k jie4,44.e
la
Bed. •
amy.m• wok
4 % Am.& se kokeitte ••• 0.•Pau.
8.15

enol Of
j rip.hime.st
WC/NW INITaiirONALAIMO SWAIM:NT PAGE 1 OF mites
1
ADOMONAL PAGES AILEITCONTAW ITIENEAOPIO "STATEMENT Of TAWN AT GMEOcorineviza• THE yarrow of EACH ADOMONAL PAGE 1NUET WAR ME *EMU OF THE MOWN warm 7NE STAITAWff AND WIEVALE0 As wet OF PACES" I morrow& PAWS ARE VW= ME MIX OF PAGE 1 RILL W LEND OM MOWN STATEMENT NIEL WI CONCLUDED ON ME MOW NOE Of ANOMIE COP/ Or INO IOWA
I ' DA FONPA /23, JUL 2 M;PERMDIS PON* MGM 444Vs. vauctivabse
0 0 02 0
DOD 13348

g III ig I I II III le I 11 I el I #5 I M I 1 Is
WARN STATEMENT

For a• of thle Ms, ow An 1014%M plums,* or 00CSOPS LOCATION gc. DATE 7164.Lmumen 4e0 • MSfDLE NAME GRADVSTATUS
OitGANIEWORApplMs.
,AM7-7-Atir•
WANT TO MAIM THE FOLLOwiNG STATEMENT UNDER ONne
7 0(.44
mit
,e ,t,„ 4„4„4,4 ,,,,eff.„. 444 4,41. „rit
40./.. /tap 0.7 #44", to #'444 434"04'
% 4.64 .2. 14 .4.444 4:01.1.44 eemv42
-othi d1 doidarAg
RAMAPO' I PAGE i OF / PAOLI

ADDMONALpAGES &WIT CariniuN INS Hamm@ %unworn:W--71 u WHAT AMID Commusr Thi 1101TOU OP EACH ADDITIONAL /WS MUST WAR Ile pirnALS Or ME reliseN wawa Tie STATERS9ff Aso Is sallAtSD As fAss Of Man* WON ADDITIONAL PAWS ARE MUM TM SACS Of MOE MILL SE UNIO On AND De STATEUENF *UBE CON:LWOW MI MOW SCE OF ANODE:18CW OF DO MAL
DA FORM 2823. JUL 72 $1111DIDDIE6 DA Mann: I .MN ea. mom MA Ma usio. UMPC111.0
00021.
DOD 13349
I #1.1 111.11411 .#1111.1.1. 101 PRO .11
N
"
Per use ORM MN% ow AR 10.11;
LOCATION rCPAINIFE

#44 AVCO t4r oiesqk 674,4
NUN WCIAL MUM Kamm
0 OR AMOS
.wr
. WANT TO MAKE 'ME FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNTO OAT*
I re foiri,Xi r. vede,,d, ,,,,,, Alit 0 -, FA-, dig:
RgliPAlRIAA
Offrigt: RAI r w , " a6„..• IrArk .41.0;.e.

gi o....:
or kfre ,re44% 0144 r let;* 1woot. ..r Aionee t OA
•ite
3 Pr Y "ivy-croo~, fawn .eie /41A Low* /4 P, PA..
e/401;eto, 4, 7%##e owstri;),, foe lelfk owi 441- am,fewpw
drtnies./ of If Awl /4140.4.01 r:, tqat 4.100,1¦fr el i g1 W 4'I orraa"../# s . 4:4 /1044* . eh./ ii./......e
•,"/YdAti, A .
I1•1111Allail MAKING STATEMENT I PAGE 1 OF Z. PAGE$
ADDITIONAL PAGES ANISTODWAIN PIE HEADING %TAMELY? OF
DATED_ CONTINuna•
THE SOITO*1 OF EAGNADDETIONAL MOENWT MEM TNE ramsDPME MOON MONO THE STATUS'? AA N INTIMED
AS 'AGE OP MONS° WEINADOMONAL PAGES AM UDLIZECC ME Amore WAVER I MU BE UM out N.D.
STATEMENT SU I I ODICLUDED ON TINAMOUN Ref OP ANOTHER COP r OPIDES FORM
DA FORM 2123, JUL 7Z sureassou OA FORM 21123. .1 4IL WNKM WILL REUSED.

munevaaa
00022
DOD 13350
26 May 2002 Additional gnostic= asked bylintwolliloladas to events of 13 May2002. Fleet Hospital. Guantanamo )
Q:%you the NCOIC for fir Secorky at the Fleet Hospital during the incident
ou t3 May 200,1 1
A: ism
Q: kick the
A: Yes, I swarms it heppen,billarlige
im told malilkdid. 1.11)
Q:mac.deliberate?
A: sac it was deliberate, wackier did it oat of frostoules. IF .
lia
Q: How otaithis happen?
d as I know and dtst was about 1100 hes. That was according to

eis
Q:
assigned lethal tom at that time, in the ward?
A1111111111r

Q:
why wasilliMilliose to dewinglat ateadly force?

A: Be wasn't, at the time;ukieked the bed, because
. off a break at
approaimetely 3100 los. Mimed the weapon. 9reni pill to
...
befogsliian break. This was standard procedure did you do, as shift
A: Based on my assessammt, 11;1111111evr
bal Me dme
of the incident, about 11
whorl* kicked the detainees bed. I told bbgto avoid and
gay away from detainee about 1330 hrs. the incident owned when detaincelliithrew his urine bottle at was sitting at his dray long.
ta want" UA•441% 6lA* So. er
Sbi
/11 41,41111.20 "Sy medical, WIN a A. areds600"vers, Ake Aaat'
0 l) al., do INV am. "'wow derOftro• #,1461. ;A s. S Wan Ada. hAusas fe 7sow*. milvarss. okes «gob . . Xambe roar of4amaebo¦ 4.6127 . r «re Ps mar 7ef. . Ate,Nsir woe. Asmoirob „ear
... AA,
..#6it ifyitu•df. tp!. vadNe. moboadth..741Pr 144 le. _WO

• fridiNhAVII Mairelafa MAK .44/IIMAHMOS.,..711er.. 7Ms ame, . &maw 7* Amor affsinat. r*we Wali Arose" at . . :Of Alma, OW . A 724. aitgr 411PaAvaik. "WO lammace. :PAW meobillf...
Vtaiat. Wt .41).v.43. rat. 4144. Xcial ...,34&4", aemeaamo 770 .betbeiv:. eitsat. . 4C. ma' . *tont".
• . raw . Ab. 4141500st oi! WO. dorsi aires. • AV otembeib.
..‘rayms4 zwarcopme, sr,. ..4.014.7. . ...,#€V 016 1400114 11 Aage rtfaain OW' ors. WO Ate" tit :rear Asowed Temm Aoki
....r
wf.CAdt1/4:0171C.
IMMOMMOIMMIMMOIT
Forseedidela nsi mmAn18041timpropeneesqmsybCOCSOPS
OAT( INA MINN
LOCATION
Guantanamo Say. Cuba.28 May 02 1400.

ORACIERTATLIS
11111111611111130tE
6"11111111
ONCIANIZATION ORM/OM( Inte4115.t.h. MPId. 4Ti-t6fi
.WANT TO MIME The PaLLOrnie STATING:Kr wain OAT
On 27 May 02 at approx. 1400 bra, I was questioned by JAG at the JDOG Headquarters in ref to knowledge of detainee complaints. Specifically, whether or no T had any knowledge of Military Police officers running up behind detainee•* quickly in an acted striking thew And then backing away laughing. I was also specifically asked in ref to knowledge of Military Police officers removing blankets from the detainee's beds and throwing them
to the floor.

ID both instances. I related that this was information that I Aad not heard of, nor did I have any knowledge of any of the We assigned under mg commend committing these alleged eventi. I was directed by JAG and 11111111.11111111 to ascertain who was working the midnight shift of May 10th, 2002. sake contact with those soldiers and ascertain their observation', knowledge or participation o the alledgsd events.
revealed thatmyself, 11111110
were working the shift in question. Contact wasmadewith these soldiers on a one on one basis an the question was posed specifically on each alleged incident. Mo soldier assigned indicated
that they had any knowledge of the incidents occurring nor were they aware of any other MP committing these offenses.
JI EC;'
Nothing Follows
MOUT 1:3101111116AMMIT
PAM OF 1 PAM
AVOMONAPMCOUNITCONrAwTHIMMIONG r TORMAT-DAND
CCWONUIR•
THE 10371ON OFFACHADOMONAL MOE worm. off oases OPIrif-MIRSONMONO net smirar
awnvo se awns=
IIIMPIADOMONAL Am0l1AELREIOD. 71111 lACILOPPMEMILLIE UAW CAM AND /NE
STATEMENT WILL ME CONCLLOID ON MO MUNI( SMEOPNIOTHIR COPYOF TNIOPONIK DA FORM 2623, JUL 72 ammo m POW MAW 1111. IASICNVALI. KUNO WMVas

Doc_nid: 
3584
Doc_type_num: 
66