CID Report (Death): 0020-2004-CID259-80183

OFFICIAL VSF,pNLy: . LAW
LAvv. ENFORCOAENT SENSITIVE
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY

UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND 48m MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID) (FWD)
311.6 MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID)
CAMP VICTORY, BAGHDAD, IRAQ APO AE 09342

CIMPL-FC. 16 SEF' 2005
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION — FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL - 0020-2004-CID259-80138 —5H9B
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1.31 JAN 2004, 0156 31 JAN 2004, 0156; 28 Tx COMBAT SUPPORT HOSPITAL
(CSH), BAGHDAD, IRAQ (IZ)

DATE/TIME REP(fRTED 31 JAN 2004, 1650
SUBJECT: NONE; (UNDETERMINED DEATH)
VICTIM:
1.. (DECEASED); CIV; IRAQI; INTERNMENT SERIAL NUMBER (ISN):(ISN): ,111111111MEGYPT;
EGYPT;© MALE; WHITE; CELL B, BUILDING 4, CAMP CROPPER, AGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), IZ; AKA:
ETERMINED DEATH)

INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY:
This is an "Operation Iraqi Freedom" Investigation.
ito(c)

About 1640, 31 Jan 04, the 10 thMP BN (CID) reported, via Serious Incident Report (SIR), a detainee died while in the custody of U.S. Forces at the 28 th CSH.
Investigation disclosed that about 0700, 25 Apr 03, 1111111.11as detained by Coalition Forces for reasons unknown and detained at Camp Cropper. On 26 Jan 04,01 was treated by the 744 th Military Police (MP) Battalion (BN) for -a minor injury
1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 023525 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
0011001
DOD-049092
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

complained of dizziness, headaches and chest pains.

whe a11111111
was air evacuated to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), 28 CSH for observation and treatment On 26 Jan 2004, while in the ICU, fell out of his bed and sustained a severe head injury. Between 26-31 Jan 2004 condition worsened and a CT scan disclosed hemorrhaging to the brain. Surgery of disclosed hemorrhaging to the brain from the fall from the bed however a second brain hemorrhage, estimated 3-4 weeks old was also found.
About 0156, 31 Jan 04, Dr (LTC) Neurosurgeon, 28 th CSH, (1-) °Z pronounced eceased as all life saving measures during surgery mel
witA. (1-Yo

negative results,
Originally it was believed an autopsy o was not conducted and the Death Certificate prepared by U.S. Forces only listed a cause of death, which was "Brainstem Compression" due to "Intracramal hemorrhage and Coagulpattry" The manner of death
was undetermined.
On 3 Mar 05, this office received-Request for Correction (RFC) 0136-05-CID001 from
HQUSACIJOC, reporting there were Investigative and Administrative deficiencies and
requested this investigation be re-opened to conduct additional investigative activity and
obtain additional documentation.
stoicpDuring firther rove on this officefice obtained a co of the aut report o the death of was prepared by Dr. orensic Pathologi sts,
Medico Legal Institute, Ministry of Health, Baghdad, IZ.= e • topsy report listed the cause
of death as ternal bleeding in the brain as a result o low to the head"; however,
there was no manner of death listed. Dr. ed in the autopsy report that he
agreed with the cause of death as listed ificate issued by Coalition Forces.
CID interviewed Dr and Dr Forensic Pathologisth, Director,10 0) pi Medico Legal Institute, Ministry of Health, Baghdad, ,"and were briefed on AL edical history while in U.S Coalition Forces custody and the circumstances of as reported by hospital staff. Both Dr. and Drain agreed based upon ,(1---/Le-T-edical history, the injuries, which were noted in the autopsy report, could be consistent with a fall causing the brain hemorrhage, which caused his death. Dr. flier related there were no injuries on the body of that were consistent with being beaten or abused. 1, NO
Although all available evidence and informationindicat Was
accidental, neither the Death Certificate nor the Autopsy report lists a manner of death;
therefore, the manner of death will remain as undetermined.
1/1)N-2-

• On 13 Sep 05, this investigation was briefed to CPT1111111.1111.11 Staff Jud e Advocate, Multi National Corps-Iraq, (MNC-I) Camp Victory, IZ who opined
023a2b -
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000002 DOD-049093
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

STATUTES:
N/A
MalIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION:
ADDED ATTACHED:
i(
l iiiii ............,

32. Agent's Investigative Report (AIR) of S dated 7 Jun 05 detailing the basis
,

for re-opening this case; coordination with Dr. o obtain copy of auto s report; coordination to have autopsy report translated; and coordinat on with Dr. to review the autopsy report.
33.
Request for Autopsy Application (written in Arabic), from the Al Juaifir Police Department, IZ, dated 18 Feb 04..

34.
English translation of Request for Autopsy Application, date translated 14 Sep 05

35.
Autopsy report (written in Arabic), dated 19 Feb 04, pertaining to Mr.

36.
English translation of autopsy report, date translated 14 Sep 05, Cc)

37.
AIR of S ated 12 Sep 05, detailing interview of Dr. and Dr, d coordination with SJA.

ADDED NOT ATTACHED:
NONE.
The originals of Exhibits 32, 34, 36 and 37 are forwarded with the USACRC copy of this report. The originals of Exhibits 33 and 35 are maintained in the files of the Medico Legal Institute, Ministry of Health, Baghdad, IZ.
STATUS: This is a Final Report. Commander's Report of Disciplinary Action Taken (DA Form 4833) is pending.
Resort Prepared By. Report ApprOve By:
Special Agent Detachment Comthander
023527
3 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY . LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000003
DOD-049094
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

DISTRIBUTION:
1- DIR, U_SACRC, 6010 6th Street, Fort Belvior, VA 22060-5506 (ORIGINAL) sbelvoirdins.army.smil.mil ) , 11 th MP BN (CID) (FWD), APO AE 09342 jraq.centcom.smil.mil) iraq.centcontsmil.mil) Thru: CDR, 3rd NTT Grou CID , 4699 Nort s. treet, Forest Park, Ga- 30297 5119, Fort Stewart, GA forcet.army.sinil.mil) -
To CDR, USADDC, CID Current Operations, AfTN: CIOP-ZA, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060 IffirMasbelvoirdirts.army.srnil.mil 1- Chief, Investigative Operations Division @sbelvoirdrns.army.smil.mil)
asbeivoirdnas.anny.smil.inil)
1- Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations t nus.arm .smil.mil) 1- PMO, MNC-I, ATTN: COL , Room 13A, APO AE 09342 (email only) (less exhibits) @iraq.centcom.smil.miD 1- Office of the Staff Ju ge Advocate, ATTN: MAJ HQ MNC-I, APO AE 09342 (email only) 11111111.piraq.centcom.smil.mil) 1-CDR, Task Force 134, Detainee Operations, MNF-I, ATTN CPIalle Camp Victory, IZ. APO AE 09342 email onl less exhibits centcom.smil.mil
1- File
023523
4
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

000004

DOD-049095

o. •
• UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

DATE: 25 MAY 2005
FROM: SAC, 48' MILITARY POLICE DET (CID) (FWD) TO: DIRECTOR, USACRC, USACIDC, FORT BEI,VOIR, VA CDR, 11' MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID) (FWD)
•
CDR, 3D MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID)
CDR, USACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-ZA, FORT BELVOIR, VA
CDR, 48 MP DET (CID) (FWD)

•
DET SGT, 48th NEP DET (OD) (FWD)
MNF-I, CHIEF OF STAFF, DETAINEE OPS .

SJA, MNC-I
PMO, MNC-I
CHIEF, INVESTIGATIVE OPERATIONS DWISION, USACIDC

DEPUTY CHIEF OF STAFF FOR OPERATIONS, USACIDC
• CID CURRENT OPERATIONS, USACIDC
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION —3rd SUPPLEMENTAL - 00204)4-CID2801.38-5H913
DRAFTER: RELEASER:
1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
L 31 JAN 2004, 0156 —31 JAN 2004, 0156; 28' COMBAT SUPPORT HOSPITAL (CSH), BAGHDAD, IRAQ (IZ)
2.
DATE/TIME REPORTER:- 31 JAN 2004, 1650

3.
INVESTIGATED BY

SA (4-)tt,..) 4 (z)1
4.
SUBJECT: NONE; (UNDETERMINED DEATH)

5.
VICTIM:

1. (DECEASED); CIV; IRAQI; INTERNMENT SERIAL NUMBER (ISN) . EGYPT; MALE; WHITE; CELL B, BUILDING 4, CAMP CROPPER INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), IZ; AKA:
(UNDETERMINED DEATH)

6. INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.
THIS IS AN "OPERATION IRAQI. FREEDOM" INVESTIGATION.
0?3529
UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY _ LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
•
n0005
DOD-049096
UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

3" SUPPLEMENTAL:
THIS SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT IS BEING SUBMITTED TO REOPEN THIS
INVESTIGATION IN ORDER TO CONDUCT ADDITIONAL INVESTIGATIVE
ACTIVITY AND ATTEMPT TO OBTAIN ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION,
THIS OFFICE RECEIVED INFORMATION FROM THEUNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND (USACIDC), WHICH STATED A NEWS ARTICLE DATED 24 MAR 05, TITLED "U.S, TO PROBE IRAQ SCIENTIST'S DEATH", REPORTED THAT A DR.11111111111111 WITH IRAQ'S FORENSICLAVA Li
, HAD PERFORMED AN A OPSY ON THE BODY OF V"' MEDICAL INSTITUTE

AFTER IT HAD BEEN TURNED OVER • THE FAMILY.
_

EFFORTS TO LOCATE D AND THE AL EGED AUTOPSY REPORT ARE ONGOING BY THIS OFFICE.
INVESTIGATION CONTINUES BY USACIDC.
FINAL REPORT:
ABOUT 1640, 31 JAN 2004, THE 10TH MP BN (CID) REPORTED, VIA SERIOUS INCIDENT REPORTISIR), A DETAINEE DIED WHILE IN THE CUSTODY OF U.S. FORCES AT THE 28 CSH.
INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED THAT ABOUT 0700, 25 APR 2003, 111111111. WAS DETAINED BY COALITION FORCES FOR REASONS UNKNOWN AND DETAINED AT CAMP CROPPER. ON 26 JAN 2004, AS TREATED BY THE 744TH MP BN FOR A MINOR INJURY WHEN OMPLAJNED OF DIZZINESS, HEADACHES AND CHEST PAINS. AS AIR EVACUATED TO THE INTENSIVE CARE UNIT (ICU), 2S CSH FOR OBSERVATION AND TREATMENT. ON 26 JAN 2004, WHILE IN THE ICU,1111
OUT OF HIS BED AND SUSTAINED A SEVERE HEAD INJURY. BETWEEN 26-31 JAN 2004, CONDITION WORSENED AND A CT SCAN DISCLOSED HEMORRHAGING TO THE BRAIN. SURGERY 0111111 111111111DISCLOSED HEMORRHAGING TO THE BRAIN FROM THE FALL FROM THE BED; HOWEVER, A SECOND. BRAIN HEMORRHAGE, ESTIMATED 3-4 WEEKS OLD WAS FOUND.
ABOUT 0156, 31 JAN 2004, DR (LTC) , NEUROSURGEON, 28TH CSH, PRONOUNCED DECEASED. AS ALL LIFE SAVING MEASURES DURING SURGERY MET WITH NEGATIVE RESULTS.
AN AUTOPSY OF WAS NOT CONDUCTED AND THE CAUSE AND MANNER OF DEATH ARE UNDETERMINED.
023530
UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
00006
DOD-049097
UNCLASSIFIED - FQR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

7. COMMANDERS-ARE REMINDED OF THE PROVISIONS OF AR 600-8-2 PERTAINING TO SUSPENSION OF FAVORABLE PERSONNEL ACTIONS AND AR 380-67 FOR THE SUSPENSION OF SECURITY CLEARANCES OF PERSONS UNDER INVESTIGATION.
cm, REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55.
023531
UNCLASSIFIED FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000007

DOD-049098

' FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT S7 SITIVE

DATE: 30 MAY 2004

FROM:' CDRi,•2 11P MP'BN (CID) //OPS//

,
CDR1 HQUSAOIDC iiCIPP-ZA//.

• TO: DTR, VSACRC. -.

'
CDR, 3. 1' MP GRou?4/opsj/-
CPR; BCCF

• PJX: EccF:

PMC,, BCCF
PMO, MSTd-Z

DCG, Detainee. OPS.

C-I
DTR, 'AFTPi AFME

1S T

SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION -SUPPLEMENTAL -

0020-04-CID259-80138. -5H9B

DRAFTER: SA

RELEASER: SA

1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:

IZ

2.
DATE/i'IME ,REPORTED: 31 JAN 04,1650-• '

3.
INVESTIGATED BY: SA

4.
SUBJECT: 1. NONE; [UNDETERMINED DEATH]

5.
VICTIM: 1. 11.11.111111111111111 (DECEASED); \01)641
CIV IRAQ; NATIONAL DETAINEE REGISTRATION SYSTEM NUMBER

; M; WHITE; CELL B, BUILDING 4, CAMP CROPPER, BAGHDAD
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), IZ; (NFI); [UNDETERMINED
DEATH]

6. INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT
IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION
AND MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE
INVESTIGATION.

ABOUT 0920, 30 MAY 04, AFTER ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW, THIS.

/ )Le‘
INVESTIGATION WAS REOPENED. TO FURTHER INVESTIGATE. THE 20477

WO-'
UNDETERMINED DEATH OF DETAINEE

ABOUT 1640, 31 JAN 04, THE 10TH MP BN (CID) REPORTED, VIA
SERIOUS INCIDENT REPORT (SIR),-A DETAINEE DIED WHILE IN THE
CUSTODY OF U.S. FORCES AT THE 28TH CSH, BAGHDAD.

• 023532

.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY -LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE . •

000003
DOD-049099

FOR OFFICIAL'USE ONLY -:LAW ENFORCEMENT gATSITIVE

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED THAT ABOUT. 0700, 25 APR
3, DETAINEE WAS DETAINED BY COALITION FORCES FOR

.
REASONS UNKNOWWANDDETAINED AT CAMP CROPPER. ON 26 JAN
4, DETAINEE WAS TREATED BY THE 744TE MP BN FOR A
MINOR INJURY WHEN DETAINEE COMPLAINED OF

DIZZINESS, HEADACHES AND CHEST PAINS: DETAINEE 1111111111,

WAS SUBSEQUENTLY AIR EVACUATED TO THE INTENSIVE CARE- UNIT
(ICU) 28TE CSH FOR OBSERVATTON-ANDTREATMENT. :ON 26 JAN
04, WHILE IN THE ICU, DETAINEE .

OUT OF HIS
BED AND SUSTAINED:ASEVSRE HEAD INJURY.: BETWEEN. 26-31 JAN
04, DETAINEE 11111111111111CONDITIONED WORSENED AND A CT SCAN
DISCLOSED HEMORAGING TO THE BRAIN. SUBSEQUENT SURGERY OF
DETAINEEM111-DISCLOSED HEMORAGING TO .THE BRAIN FROM
THE FALL FROM THE BED, HOWEVER,:A.SECOND BRAIN HEMORAGE,

APPROXIMATELY 374 WEEKS. OLD WAS FOUND.

ABOUT 0156, 31 JAN 04, DR (LTC)
NEUROSURGEON,. 28TH.

PRONOUNCED DETAINEE
DECEASED AS ALL LIFE SAVING MEASURES DURING SURGERY MET
WITH.

NEGATIVE RESULTS.

AN AUTOPSY OF DETAINEE WAS NOT CONDUCTSD.AS THE
CAUSE OF HIS DEATH WAS OPINED TO BE RESULT OF THE FALL,
THUS DETAINEE REMAINS WERE RELEASED FOR
DISPOSITION.

THE CASUALTY LIAISON OFFICER IS SA
2e2. MP BN (CID), APO AE 09342 AT DNVT (302)

INVESTIGATION. CONTINUES BY THE USACIDC.

7. CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF
PROTECTIVE MARKINGS IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 22-55.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

. /I
00001
• ,

DOD-049100
'

SECRET. LAW ENFORCEMENT SENT ITIVE
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
-E.

22mD MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID)
UNITED STATES ARMY CRZMINAL'INVESTIGATION COMMAND
.

APO AE 09342'

CIMPL-OP 31 Octob6r 2004

(U)
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION .

(U)
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION - FINAL
SUPPLEMENTAL - 0020-04-CTD259-80138-5B9B

(U)
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
31 JAN 04/0156 - 31 JAN 04/0156; 28 T5 Combat SuPport
Hospital (CSH), Baghdad IZ

(U)
DATE/TIME. REPORTED:31 JAN 04, 1650

0-)(0-1 ). ).(2) -1

(U)
INVESTIGATED BY: SA

(U)
SUBJECT: 1, None; [Undetermined Death].

(U)
VICTIM: 1. (Deceased);
CIV IRAQ; InternMent'Serial Number !If7)(0-1
1111111Egypt; M; White; -Cell B, Building 4i Camp Cto er,,
Baghdad 'International Airport .(BIAP),

(AKA:
[Undetermined Death]

(U)
INVESTIGATIVE.SUMMARY!

(U)
About 1640, 31 Jan 04, the 10th MP BN (CID) reported,
via Serious Incident Report. (SIR), .a detainee died while in
the custody of U.S. Forces at the 28th CSH.

stigation disclosed that about 0700, 25 Apr 03,11111
as detained by coalition forces for reasons unknown

1)(4-4 and detained at Camp Cropper. On 26 Jan 04, was treated by the 744th MP BN -for a minor injury when complained of dizziness, headaches and chest pains. 41110111was air evacuated to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU), 28 CSH for observation and treatment. On 26 Jan 04, while in the ICU, fell out of his bed and sustained a severe head injury. Between 26-31 Jan 04, conditioned worsened and a CT Scan disclosed hemorrhaging 023534
tol4e0 6,rpeLA-no3 Fitio4 CC/4 SSir(072 150(-(06L-keta.
(..SeCyterm ovrmale, J. R.
Pe-n-.
SECRET - LAW ENFORCEMENT SENTITIVE
. 1100 01 9
DOD-049101
—

sECREir LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION -7 FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL
-0020-64-C1D259-80138-5H9B
to the brain. Surgery of MUM disclosed hemorrhaging
to the brain from the fall from the bed; however, a second
brain hemorrhage, estimated 3-4 weeks old177'. :found,

(U) About 0156, 31 Jan OA,. (LTO)
Neurosurgeon, 28th CSH, pronounced 'deceased as all
life saving measures during surgery net with negative

results. .

(U)
An autopsy' of ImmiliWas not conducted and the cause
and manner of death are Undetermined ,

(U)
EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION:

(U)
ADDED ATTACHED:

(u): 11. Agent's Investigation Report (AIR) of SA

27 Oct 04, pertaining to re-initiation of
Investigation, receipt of SIR, Requests for Assistance,
review 'of investigative file, receipt of Information
Reports, medical coordinations, medical consultations with
the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, significant
interviews, coordination with Detainee Operations, receipt
of documents, coordination with detention facility, review

, of ,detainee files, and review of medical records.

k

(U) 12. SIR, 31 Jan 04, pertaining to the death of 11111

MIN

fiC i-)(6-1

(U) : 13, Individual Sick Slip, 27 Jul 03, pertaining to 11111
Detainee bio sheet, 7 Jul 03, pertaining to

(U)
15. AIR of SA 31 May 04, pertaining to
database searches and Detainee Operations coordinations.

(U)
16. AIR of SA 2 Jun 04, pertaining to
significant interviews.

(U)
17. AIR of SA 11111.111 3 Jun 04, pertaining to
significant interview..

(U)
18. Statement of SSG..111111i 3 Jun 04 pertaining
to his knowledge of the death of

2 vitlye.).1 023'535

SECRET -- LAW •ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
13E101111 .•
DOD-049102

SECRET — LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
SUBJECT: CID 'REPORT OF INVESTIGATION - FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL
0020.-047C1D259-80138-5H93

(U)
19. AIR of .SA 1111111 4 Jun pertaining to
cOordinations.

(U)
20. AIR. of SAIIIIIIII pertaining to
significant interview.

(U)
21. Statement of. LTC 9 Jun 04 pertaining to
his care and treatment of at Camp Cropper.

(U)
22. Information paper pertaining the death of1111,
11111111

IdentificatiOn photograph of

Hospital Report of Death, 31 Jan 04, pertaining to

(U)
25 Certificate of Death 4 Feb 04, pertaining toil.

(S)
26. Detainee file pertaining to11111111111"

27.- Camp Cropper medical records of

(U)
28. Interview/Interrogation Schedule of

(U)
29. AIR. Of SA 24 Aug 04, pertaining to
significant interviews,

(U)
30. Statement of. SPC 20 Jul 04, pertaining to 6MN
his knowledge of

(U)31. MeMotanduM for ROCOrd, 27 Oct 04, pertaining to
the AFIP consultation o medical records.

(U)
ADDED NOT ATTACHED:

(U)
None:

(U)
The originals of Exhibits 11, 15-21 and 31 are

.

forwarded with the USACRC copy of this report. The
original of Exhibit 12 is retained by the 744th MP BN. The
originals of Exhibits 13-14 and 26-28 are retained by Camp
Cropper. The original of Exhibit 22 is retained by
Detainee Operations. The location of the original of
Exhibit 23 is unknown. The originals of Exhibits 24-25 are

3 023530

-

SECRET LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000012
DOD-049103

SECREt — LW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
-

SUBJECT:.. CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION--FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL

-0020-04-OID259-80138-5B9B

,

retained by the 28t" CSH The originals-of Exhibits 29-30

are retained by the Ft McCoy Resident Agency (CID).

(U)
STATUS: This is a Final Supplemental report.

(U)
Report Prepared/Approved By

CW4.
Operations Officer

(U) DISTRIBUTION:

1-USACRC (original) 1-Thru: CDR, J MP Gp (CID) 6010 6 "` Stmt
Belvoir, VA 22060

1-PMO, MNC-I, Camp Victory, Baghdad, IZ (amail)
1-DCG, Detainee OPS, Camp Victory, IZ (email)
1-File

023537
4

SECRET — LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000013 DOD-049104
)
-_, DEPARTMENT OF THE ARIM-

UNITED -STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
75TH MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CIDOWP).,
BAGHDAD BRANCH OFFICE
APO AE 09335

CIRC-ABE (195-2b) 22 Feb 2004
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION - FINAL(C) - 0020-04-CID259-80138 ­
5H9B
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:

1. 28 Jan 2004/0100 - 31 Jan 2004/0156; CAMP CROPPER, BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), APO AE 09335
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 31 Jan 2004, 1650
1),(c)--) RC2)
-
-

INVESTIGATED BY SA
SUBJECT (S): 1. NONE; [UNDETERMINED DEATH].
VICTIM(S): 1. CIV; IZ;

M; OTHER; CAMP CROPPER, BAGHDAD 1 AL AIRP T (BIAP), APO
AE09335; (NFT) [UNDETERMINED DEATH].
INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY:
This is an Operation Iraqi Freedo investigation.
On 31 Jan 04, this office was notified by the 10 th Military olice Battalion (CID)(FWD),

Baghdad, Iraq, of the receipt of a Serious Incident Repo regarding the death of a

prisoner at Ca p Cropper, BIAP, APO AE 09335. Investigation established probable cause to believe .ied after sustaining head injuries fro a reported fall while ad itted to the 28 Co bat Support Hospital (CSH), Baghdad, Iraq, for self-proclai ed chest pain. No autopsy was perfor ed, as the body was released by the 28th CSH to the International Red Cross, Baghdad, Iraq.
STATUTES: None. EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION: ATTACHE:
. 023533
1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
000014
DOD-049105
0020-03-CID0259-80138 )(c -1 17(1)(0 -2:-

1. Agent's Investigation Report AIR of SA 4 Feb 04 detailing the basis for
investi ation• interviews of LTC SSG SPC
SPC SSG LTC and SGT1
and crime scene exam.
2 Crime Scene Sketch, 31 Jan 04, prepared by SAM.
3.
AIR of SA 9 Feb 04, detailing coordination with CPT and SFC

4.
Hospital Report of Death, 31 Jan 04.

5.
Certificate of Death (Overseas), 31 Jan 04, pertaining to Mr.

6.
Photograph depicting face of Mr. -earassammumagausamasame....,

.

7.
AIR of Stril 14 Feb 04, detailing collection of medical records.

. ) c' A re.........

8.
Medical records from 28th CSH, 26-30 Jan 04, pertaining to Mr. ammi.

9.
Photographic packet comprised of 8 photographs.

10.
Compact disc, 040212 1111 containing all photographic images and originals of Exhibit 9 (USACRC and AFIP-copy only).

NOT ATTACHED:
None.
The originals of Exhibits 1 thru 3, 6 thru 7 and 9 are attached to the USACRC copy of this report. The originals of Exhibits 4, 5, and 8 are maintained in the files of the 28 th Combat Support Hospital.
STATUS: This is a final (c) report. This investigation is terminated IAVV CIDR 195-1, paragraph 4-17a(6), in that the Special Agent in Charge has determined that furtherance of the investigation would be of little or no value or leads remaining to be developed are not significant. Leads remaining include identification and interview of the ambulance personnel who took custody of the victim's remains.
Report Prepared By: Report Approved By:
SPECIAL AGENT-IN-CHARGE 2 . FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY . 023539
000015
DOD-049106

' 1 0020-03-C1D0259-80138

DISTRIBUTION:
1 - DIR, USACRC, 6010 6th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (original) 1 - DIR, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, AFIP Annex — Bldg 102, 1413 Research Blvd, Rockville, MD 20858
-THRU:
CDR, 10th MP BN (CID)(FWD), APO AE 09335
CDR, 3d MP GRP (CID)(FIND), APO AE 09335

TO: CDR, HQUSACIDC (ATTN: CIOP-COP-CO), 6010 6th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 1 — CDR, 75th MP Detachment (CID), LSA Anaconda, Balad, Iraq APO AE 09391 (email only, less exhibits) 1 - CID LNO, CJTF, ATTN: CPT V Corps, Victory Camp, APO AE 09335
(e-mail only/less exhibits)
1 - PMO, 1st Armored Division, Victory p, APO AE 09335 (e-mail only/less exhibits)
1 - File

0 2 3 5 4 0
3 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
000016
DOD-049107
ROT NUMBER

0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT' S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1

PAGE 1 OF q PAGES

DETAILS .
BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: About 1640, 31 Jan 04, this office received a
Serious Incident Report from the 10th Military Police Battalion (CID) (ABN)

(FWD), Baghdad, Iraq), regarding the death of a Prisoner from Camp Cropper,

Baghdad International Airport (BIAP), Baghdad, Iraq, while being treated

at the 28111 Combat Support Hospital (CSH), =aghdad Iraq APO AE 09335.

4-1

About 107, 31 Jan 04 , SA. and SA this office, interviewed LTC 744TH Police (MP) Battalion r 1 caz crop Baghdad,, Iraq. On 26 Jan 04, LTC rela Mk-(NFI) was being treated for oe 1rTutY, when Mr'. corn lned of chest pains. LTC 111111111 re ate! he arranged forMr. o be transported to the 28th CSH for r hzr, t a ent and observation.
being treated for high sure.,

"4-About-1830, 31 Jan 04; SA and SA conducted an examination of Mt. confinement cell at CaMp-CroPper, BIAP,
C., 1 , , iiimair­
60)(6"/

CHARACTER'S ICS OF SCENE: Mt. Confinement cell was
approximately 9 feet by 9 feet by 12 feet high and was made of concrete
with gray in color walls. The entrance/exit way was located on the north
wall and was about 3 feet wide.' There were no windows present.

CONDITION OF SCENE: Upon entering the room, the light was on and the door
was locked. On the east wall was a red in color plastic bucket containing
what appeared to be urine, two pink in color plastic buckets, and various
hygiene items. On• the south wall were two Meals, Ready to Eat (MRE)
packages containing what apPeared to be laundry detergent, one red in
color plastic chair, one cardboard box containing various clothing, and
two cardboard MRE boxes containing several various items. One of the MRE
boxes contained a small plastic bag of medicatiOn in tablet form. The
plastic bags bore English handwriting indicative of a prescription from
the camp medical clinic. Along the west wall was one metal bed frame
approximately 4 feetlWide by 7 feet longcontaining one mattress and
several blankets with the bed running north, and south. On the north wall

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SE ORGANIZATION.

129'. MP Det(CID), 3D MP GRPACID),
Baghdad, Iraq, APO AE 09335

SIGNATH DATE EXHIBIT

4 Feb 04 023541 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.
000017
DOD-049108

ROI NUMBER;
0020-0.4-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION RE PORT
CID -eVulation 195-1

PAGE 2 OF PAGES

DETAILS

was a yellow in color, plastic container approximately 1 11 feet tall by 1 foot wide, containing what appeared to be water.
ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS: At the time of the examination, the outside

temPerture -was approximately 55 degrees and the inside temperature was

approkimately 50 degrees. There were no odors present and a mild wind

factor.

FACTORS PERTINENT TO ENTRY/EXIT (E/E); Entry to the cell.could only be

made through the north E/E_

L '1

SCENE DOCUMENTATION: Photographs were exposed by SA IIIIIRutilizing a

Sony Cyber Shot digital camera'and a rough crime scene sketch was

completed

COLLECTION OF CRIME SCENE EVIDENCE: There was no, evidence collected.

SEARCH FOR LATENT: A search for latent prints was not conducted due to

the circumstances of this investigation.

SEARCH BEYOND THE SCENE: A search beyond the Scene .,was conducted which

resulted in negative evidence.

NEGATIVE EVIDENCE: There was no Ai vjrnegative eviden

kt, 41W-I
About 1815, 31 Jan 04, SAMIllicoordinated h LTC to verify
the contents of the small plastic bag of m ication discovered in the MRE
box in the decedent's cell. LTC related the medication was both
Mylanta and Motrin, as prescribed by the camp medical clinic, and was a
routine and documented prescription. He related the medication would not
precipitate heart problems. )(1)(0_1

About 1840, 31 Jan 04, SAIIIIIIIinterviewed SSG 11111111 744TH MP BN, BIAP, who related Mr. comp aine chest
pains and was air Medevac TO THE 28 TH CSH for treat ent. SSG
related an MP (NFL) from the 79th MP Company escort -d Mr to the
28th CSH and then turned over custody of Mr. another MP -(NFI)

Vi) C671

143)61111 )441'i)

TYPED AGENT'S NAKE AND SEQUENCE NUMBER. , ORGANIZATION
SA 12t4 MP Det(CID), 3D MP GRP (cIp), Baghdad, Iraq, APO AE 09335
SIGNATURE DATE EXHIBIT
4 Feb 04 023542

CID FP FOR OFFICIAL USE opTjy.
000018
DOD-049109
ROI NUMBER
0020 -04 -CID259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION RE PORT
CID Regulation 19.5-1.
PAGE 3 OF hi PAGES

DETAILS

from the 79th MP Company. SSGIIIIIIIIrelated Mr. never had
complained of chest pains or suffereda head injury

About 1918 SA and SA 11.11111Unterviewed. SPC

79th MP
Company; Rochester, MN, deployed,td:CaP Cropper,
gi.. . Mr to

Ap,..Baghdad, Iraq who related heghdad
via air medevac and released, Mr over . SPC (NFI) upon
arrival to the CSH.' SPC --elated Mr. was conscious and
positioned in a stretcher throughout the flight to the CSH.

79TH MP

About1924', SA interviewed SP
Company,. Camp Cropper, 8TAPi.Baghdad, Iraq who related /*toOkoustodY of
Mr. from SPC accompanied him to the Intensive Care

-.

Unit (ICU) ; where he reCeiVedMediOal- treatment for chest pains. :SPC:

related he and Mr. ja1kec dnwpstairs after mr .
was transferred to the Intensive Care ward (ICW), for further obSerVation-.
SPC related while Mr.

was in the ICW, he(Mr-1111111111
fell out of his bed and sustained a head injury. SPC related he
fall out of bed, but was called to the room

did not witness Mr
by a nurse (NFl) to help put him back into the bed. SPC related
Mr. was bleeding fibm the head and there was blood present on

the floor. SPC related Mr. bed was about 4 feet off of
the ground and Mr. was confused, dizzy, and could not remember
falling from his bed.

About 1935, 31 Jan 04, SAIIIMIlinterviewed SSG

79Ith MP Company, Camp Cropper, BIAP, Baghdad, Iraq, who provided a
verbal statement. .SSG related between 15 Jan 04 and 29 Jan 04,
he was the NCOIC for the 28 CSH hospital security detail, as augmented by
the 79th MP Company. SSG related he recalled the incident where
Mr. 11111111111111 fell from his hospital bed; however, he (SSGallnill did
not physically observe this fall. He stated SPC was working in
the ICW at the time and possibly had better information about the
incident. SSG did not suspect any wrong doing associated with
Mr. fall other than his (SSG speculation that Mr.

robably attempted to get up from his bed and subsequently fell.
SSG did not recall noticing Mr. in the Camp Cropper

. .

facility prior to his medical evacuation ,to ttie h CSH on 26 Jan 0 4 .

TYPED AGENT' S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER ORGANIZATIONN
SA l2' HP Det'(CID), 3D MP-GRP (CID),
_Baghdad, Iraq, APO AE 09335

SIGNATURE DATE EXHIBIT
U 3 5 4 3

. 4 Feb 04
OR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

000019
DOD-049110
ROI NUMBER
0020-04-CID259-80138

AGENT S I NVE S T I GAT ION RE PORT

CID Regulation 195-1
-PAGE 4 OF N PAGES
DETAILS

About 1437, 1 Feb 04, SA telephonically interviewed LTC (Dr.)1111111

Neurosurgeon, 20T Neuro Team, 28th CSH, Baghdad, Iraq who related
Mr. condition worsened after falling from his bed and
underwent a cat scan. LTC related he reviewed the CAT scan and
discovered a severe hemorange in the brain and preformed emergency brain
surgery. on Mr-LTC related, during Surgery he discovered
a chronic brain hemoran e that occurred a minimum of 3-4 weeks prior. LTC

related Mr. cause of death was a bleeding disorder
sustained by a hemorange of ,the brain:

About 1330, 4 Feb 04, SA re-interviewed LTC who related Mr.
had a chronic hemorange that was a minimum of 3 -4 weeks old and
wou ave become fatal if untreated.

AGENTS COMMENT: LTA.= related the chronic hemorange could have been
caused by a minor trauma to the head.

About 1356, 4 Feb 04, SA conducted telephonic interview of Drill.

(NFI), who arranged for Mr. body to be removed from the 28 TH
CSH. Dr. acted the Red Crescent and had Mr. 11111,

related she contacted
body removed along two other bodies. Dr. related the
bodies were removed on 31 Jan 04, and taken to the Foreign Sick Medicine

.

Office located next to the Administry of Health, Baghdad, Iraq. Dr. ill.
related the body would be refrigerated pending being claimed by family
membersor the body would just be buried.

,

m..----

About 1415, 4 Feb 04, SA interviewed SGT
28711 CSH, who related he found Mr. on the'floor bleeding
from his left temple next to his bed conscious, but did not witness Mr.
fall. SGT related Mr. nswered several
questions to determine his coherent ness. After a few minutes, SGT

related Mr. became incoherent and did not respond to
questions asked of him. SGT /elated Mr. was given a CAT
scan, which revealed a brain hemorange.///LAST ENTRY///

TYPED AGENT'S NAM AND SEIUENCE NUMBER , ORGANIZATION

SA 12th MP Det(CID), 3D MP GRP (CID),
Baghdad, Iraq, APO AE 09335

SIGNATUR DATE. EXHIBIT

4 Feb 04 02544
/

CID FORM 94' FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

000020
DOD-049111
Op 3-0 /5 P.
t49-30%.,E¦cto
Zolf,

0

,

R7jcy6 Le-6U
LEGEND:
\,)
rcE

TITLE BLOCK:
CASE #: Cr6,)-03--0q-C-( 11) .D59 - 8013 OFFENSE: Uetv&ternikeAd-SCENE PORT•YED:
LOCATI VI BEPATC:'. SKE HE BY: TED•BY,;
NOT TO.SCALE
100)(.0-1 023545
60" (cm FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 000021
EXHIBIT A
DOD-049112

RPT E 0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT S INVEST IG TION 'EPORT
CID negulAtion 19571
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES

DETAILS

• a out 1336, 9 Feb 04, SA 00 dinatecl wit CPT S-4, 31ST CSH, and obtained a .copy of IDA Forra 4, .Hospital Report o f Death, which hag. handwritin and he signature 0 unknown.
an unknown. person Signing' fo;' Mr. rem ns. (See DA 3894, Hospital RepOrt of Death for details)
About 146, 9 Feb 0 , SA coordinated w h C NCOIC, S-4, 31ST C• H, who related he had re ased r
129.y an ambulance sery ce on 31 Jan 04. SFC rela he believed the`
ambulance driver' worked, for thea Red CreSsan and NFU_ had: arranged for the elease of Mr. remain .1/ LAST NTRY///
6(3)01 6(1)(0-1

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER ORGANIZATION
SA 12 th MP Det (CID), 3 D MP GRP (CID) ,
Baghdad, Iraq, APO AE 09335

SIGNATURE DATE 9 Feb 04 EXHIBIT 3 02.3b46
C D -FORK 94 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 000022
DOD-049113

Page(s)
22 2

Referred to
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COM1V1AND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/
PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl@c en. arnedd.army.mil
(210) 221-7826
English Translation:
• Withheld cue. to:
Photos depicting Americans • • ,.Photos depicting foreign nationals Civilian Agency. Records AuclioNideo.depictirig foreign nationals and American s
023548
DOD-049115

Rol NUMBER

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPQRT 0020-04-C1D259-80138
CID RegulatIO

PAGE. 1 OF 1 PAGES
muium4.
•out 1425, 14, Feb 04, ordihated with Major 3l4T CSH and
obtained oopie$ of Mr. •lete medical recd. (See Mr.
medical recor /LAST ENTRY///
bel)N-z-

TYPED AGENT'S N ORGANIZATION '

12th MP Det(CTD), 3D MP GRP (CID), Baqhdadk Ltagi. APO AE 09335

SIGNATURE .

DATE EXHIBIT

14 Feb 04'

7 023549
OFFICIAL USE ONLY

-
001)026
DOD-049116

Page(s)

Referred to
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/
PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl@cen.amedd .arrny.mil
(210) 221-7826
-sr tr8°-
11,,,rzwmar*6
/.2:" •
• United States Army Criminal
-- k 0-\
Investigation Command
zz . PHOTOGRAPITIC PACKET

.
eSfia."0"GA*
CASE NUMBER`: 0020-04-C1D259-801 3 8: NUMBER DESCRIPTION OF PHOTOGRAPH
1.
Photograph depicting establishing view of Mr. confinement cell prior to entering.

2.
Photograph depicting Mr. confinement cell with door Opened.

3. Photograph depicting view of northeast corner of cell.
4. Photograph depicting view of northeast wall and southeast corner of cell.
5.
Photograph depicting view south wall of cell.

6.
Photograph depicting view of southwest Wilier of cell.

7.
Photograph depicting Mr. 11111111111111bed.

8.
Photograph depicting northwest corner of cell.

\? (7)(01
023551
Exhibit 9 000 113
oA&4? S c .

DOD-049118

Bates Pages 2 3552-23559 depict photos whic0..•othootespdooi8,6000hoo.:".00t b00.1.i provided .. 40$0000.:opp.. qooti00. .of.100 --40cige
in camera rulings (tOtiti$t-ty00 -p4otOs).
DOD-049119

023560 000122
DOD-049120
t 0020-04-C1D259-80138

1 () ( -2-; 0,ec) -

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION RE3-PORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS About 0920, 30 May 04, after administrative review, this investigation,waS re.7o•ened to further investigate the undetermined . death of detainee
About 1640, 31,Jan 04, SA 12th MP DET (CID), received a
Serious. Incident Report (SIR) froM the 744 th MP BN, Camp Cropper, Baghdad,
IZ, pertaining to the death of detainee (See 'SIR)

AbOtt 1106, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a Request for Assistance (RFA) to the Prisoner Interrogation Team, 75th MP DET (CID), Abu Ghraib, IZ, to obtain a copy of detainee dossier file.
About 132a, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatChed a RFA to the Ft Riley ­Resident A USACIDC, to locate,. identify'and interview Dr (LTC)
• •th
Ul OZ U I. Z. .

About 1500, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a RFA to the Walter Reed
ranch Office, USACIDC, to locate, identify and interview Dr (LTC)

Neurosurgeon, Interventional Neuroradiologist, Walter
Reed Army Medical Center (previous 28 th CSH, Baghdad) pertaining to his
knowledge of the death of detainee

About 1615, 30 May 04,. the undersigned dispatched a RFA to the Rock Island ArSenal Resident Agency, USACIDC, to locate, identify and interview SPC SPC and SSG all 79 MP CO, ROchester, MN, pertaining to the death of detainee
About 1800, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a RFA tothe Ft Bliss
Resident A•ency, USACIDC to locate, identify and interview SGT
31st CSH, Baghdad, IZ, pertaining to his knowledge
f the death of detainee

On 30 May 04, the undersi ned reviewed the investigative file pertaining to
the death of detainee The undersigned extracted a DD Form 689,
Individual Sick. Slip, dated 27 Jul 03, reporting detainee was
seen for Thrombophebitis, Cellulitis and a fever. (See DD Fm 689)

On 30 May 04, the undersigned reviewed the investigative file pertaining to
the death of detainee The undersigned extracted a detainee

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
02356

27 Oct 04
CID FORM 94-E FOROFFICIALUSEONLY EXEIMIT

OCT 95 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM 1_41041 2 3 AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16)
DOD-049121

0020-04-CID259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 2. OF 9 PAGES

DETAIL$
dossier pertainin to Detainee ...MI which related detainee
was taking as a daily medication. (See Dossier)

On 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a RFA to the Carlisle Barracks
Resident. Agency, USACIDC, to locate, identify and interview SSG
.

11111111111111. Det 3, 744th MP BN, pertaining to his nowledge the death of detainee
of

On 31 May 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from the
Prisoner Interrogation Team pertaining to coordinations with the Baghdad
Central Confinement Facility, Abu Ghraib, IZ. (See AIR of SAIMIll

About 1120,, 4 Jun 04, the undersigned received a 1 st Information Report
from the Ft Riley Resident Agency, who reported attempts to contact Dr

Allill on-104met with negative results. Contact was made with the
Pennington County Sheriff's Office, Rapid City, SD, who reported Dr
residence appeared vacant. Neighbors reported Dr had not
been seen in weeks and a check of one of Dr previous ospital
employers disclosed he did not work at the hospital in years. On 4 Jun 04,
coordination with the local U.S. Postal Service disclosed no mail hold or
forwarding for DAMN. Coordination with Driaillar National Guard
unit disclosed no detainee medical records were returned to CONUS when the
unit re-deployed-and there was no known contact number for DAMN

On 8 Jun 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from the Ft
Riley Resident Agency, who reported Dr was located and an interview
scheduled for 9 Jun 04.

About 1400, 16 Jun 04, SA this office, coordinated with Dr (LTC) , Executive Officer and Dr (COL) Commander, 31st Combat Support Hospital (CSH), Ibn Sina Hospital, Baghdad, IZ. Dr related that Dr and SGT , both formerly 31st CSH, were no longer assigned to the unit and re-deployed to their CONUS home station. Drill. 'Stated that he was previously interviewed b SA
111111INFI) and provided all details pertaining to detainee
death that were available. Dr recalled that detainee was
admitted into the hospital. He said there were some problems controlling
detainee and that detainee was strapped down tO -hiS
bed. Dr related detainee was strapped down by the arm and
leg on one side of the body. Detainee allegedly awoke from sleep
and attempted to get out of bed and then fell out of the bed on the side he

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
D23562

27 Oct 04
SA CID FORM 94-E FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHiBIT 1-1

1 OCT 95 — PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) 000124 (When Data Is Entered)
DOD-049122

rl

1

0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 3 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS
was strapped down. By falling out of bed in this manner, detainee.",

truck his head, causing interior injury to his brain. The hitting
of the ead caused a brain hemorrhage, for which detainee1.1111111was
treated. During treatment of the hemorrhage r it was discovered that
detainee had a previous brain in'ur. . The cause of the previous
brain injury was unknown to DANN Dr stated that detainee1111

was a diabetic, which had some effect on detainee 11.1.111111111
condition and treatment. Dr related detainee 1111111111ater
succumbed to his injuries.

About 1500, 16 Jun 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from
the Walter Reed Branch Office pertaining to the interview of Dr
pertaining to the death of detainee (See AIR of SA

About 1945, 17 Jun 04, SAIIIIIII1submitted a request to the 31st CSH for
any and all medical records pertaining to detainee...III, SAM.
was advised the USACIDC was previously provided the medical records and the
originals could not be located.

About 1500, 18 Jun 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from
the Carlisle Barracks Resident A ency pertaining to the interview of SSG
(See AIR of SA

On 28 Jun 04, the undersigned dispatched a second RFA to the Ft Bliss
Resident Agency to locate and interview SGT

About 0820, 28 Jun 04, SA this office, sent a request for medical advice to the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology pertaining to the death of detainee Dr (CDR) Chief Deputy Medical Examiner, Office of the Armed Forces Me ica . Examiner related the USACIDC did not possess enough information on detainee brain hemorrhage to make any determination. Dr... related that while detainee ...II could have had a clotting disorder, some disorders make people prone to clots and others to bleeding. Detainee 11111111111, may haveused enough ETOH over the ears or be old enough to predispose himself to the brain hemorrhage. Dr related the Intra-operative dating of a brain hemorrhage is hard unless reviewed by a pathologist. D4IIIIIIII related the brain hemorrhage could have been very old, possibly years, from a previous scuffle. Dr11.11related it was doubtful detainee thrombosis was occurring in the brain. They were probably in the extremities and clots were breaking free and proceeding to the heart
TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
27 Oct 04

SA if
CID FORM 94-E FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIT OCT 95 b/.`\,1 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM JJ I AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) 080125 (When Data Is Entered)
DOD-049123

0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 4 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS
causing the chest pains* could not deterMine the cause and-

Manner of detainee death based on information provided:'

.

About 1500, 28 Jun 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from

the 78th MP DET (CID), pertaining to law enforcement and, unit coordinations
and the interview of Dr (See AIRs of SA

and SA11111111

About 1650, 28 Jun 04, the undersigned re-dis atched a RFA to the Ft Bliss

Resident Agency to locate and interview SGT Coordination with

31st CSH revealed SGT redeployed.

About 1930, 28 Jun-04, the undersigned re-dispatched a -RFA to the Rock
Island Resident A ency to locate, identify and interview SPC -SPC
and SSG pertaining to their knowledge of the death of
detaine

About 1020,1 Jul 04, the undersigned received an Information Report from the 11th MP BN (CID) reporting coordination with the 31st CSH, Ft Bliss, TX, pertaining to the interview of SGT determined he was still in Iraq and assigned to the 31st CSH, Baghdad and could be reached at DNVT
IIIIIIII/and the POC is CPT , S-1, 31st CSH.
About 2100, 8 Jul 04, the undersigned received medical consult information

from Drain who related that after review of Detainee
surgical me ical records, many details pertaining to his previous health

history were missin Dr related there was no documentation as to

how detainee all of t e sudden ended up with a head injury.

Detainee was admitted for heart problems and had a terrible

baseline health status (Arterial Sclerosis Cardio Vascular Disease,

diabetes and other health issues). Drill'Illirelated the death certificate

attributes death to low platelets, causing a bleed. Dr related not

all platelet counts were legible in detainee medical records,

but the ones he could discern demonstrated a downward trend between 27-28

Jan 04 and then' back up with the lowest platelet count being 49,000. Dr

did not concur with the Neurosurgeon, 28 th CSH, that a platelet
count of 49,000 was not low enou h to typically cause spontaneous bleeds.

Factors such as detainee clottin status may have been

involved. Dr related detainee may have been transfused

and his platelet count could have dipped lower then reported, but he did

not have the reports for review. Dr 4111111could not determine the cause

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
0 2 3 5 6 4
27 Oct 04

SA
CID FO FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

1 OCT 95 ) PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) 000128 (When Data Is Entered)
DOD-049124

¦9(7-)(c)-6huo-7t 19(t)(c)--
0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 5 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS

or mariner of detainee death based on the medical history and
records he was presented with

About 1400, 9 Jul 04, the undersigned submitted a request for documents;
detainee file, interrogation file, medical records and detainee interview
and interrogation dates to the Deputy Commanding General of Detainee
Operations, Multi-National Forces-Iraq pertaining to detainee

About 2320, 9 Jun 04, the undersigned interviewed SGT who related that on the night detainee fell from his bed, he was walking out of a patients room when he hear a oud thud. SGT alked into detainee room and found him lying on the floor. Detainee.. 1111111Ippeared to ave injuries; therefore, SGT 11111111111called for the Military Police to release detainee 111111111111from his constraints and for 1LT Charge Nurse, 31't CSH. SGTIIIIIIIIII
stay on the floor until assistance could be obtained. A Doctor was called

and the Doctor ordered a CT scan for detainee1111111111, After the CT Scan
was completed, detainee was placed back in his bed and

restrained. SGT related detainee MEM as result of his

injuries was bleeding from the left e ebrow and mouthand there was blood

,

on the _floor of the roam. SGT did not know the results of the CT
scan. SGT said detainee never said why he was
attempting to get out of the bed from which he fell. When an Interpreter
was brought into the hospital to translate for detaine11111111111, the

Interpreter stated detainee was speaking in broken sentences,

which did not make sense. SGT related detainee after

the fall seemed disoriented and confused. Detainee wa not SGT
patient; therefore, he had no knowled e what detainee was being treated for, did not know why detainee was in t e hospital, saw no monitors attached to detainee and he was not receiving any type of fluids. SGT elated the fall incident was the first interaction he had with detainee After the fall, detainee was moved via stretcher because he was disoriented and confused. SGT related detainee ould not follow hospital guidande becauSe detainee Continuously tried to sit or get up when instructed to lie down, SGT could:add nothing further to the investigation. SGT related he did not notice any signs of abuse on detaineeTiOWeVef, he was riot- looking either.
.

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER I SIGNATURE DATE
27 Oct 040235e5

CID FORM 94-E FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIT
OCT 95 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM6(7)-1 AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) (When Data Is Entered) 0110127
DOD-049125

( (7) (01
0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 6 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS

About 1515, 10 Jul G4, the undersi ned interviewed 1LT111111 who related
that after she received detainee in the Immediate` Care Ward from
the ICU, she noted detainee enzymes appeared normal. He had no
disorientation and he walked from the ICU to the ICW. 1LT related
detainee continuously showed signs of agitation and bei -antsy,
as he always wanted to sit up in bed or go to the bathroom. 1LT
stated that when she examined detainee she noted no signs of
abuse. 1LTIIIIrelated that when detainee was transferred to
her care, she did not use an interpreter because he spoke some English.
While speaking with detainee he never spoke of abuse. 11,111/
related detainee appeared in good health when examined. He did
not request any food, as she didnot have him long enough to get food for

,

him. He fell maybe 5-10 minutes after arriving to his room. 1LT111111
related there was nothing out of the ordinary noted during the initial
treatment of detainee1111.111during his time in the hospital.

,

About 1645, 11 Jul 04 the undersigned interviewed Dr (MAJ) 11111111

31st CSH, who related he was called to assist in
the treatment of detainee 1111111111.after he fell from his bed. Detainee

was received by the Immediate Care Ward from the ICU, and
approximately 5-10 minutes after receipt, was found after falling from his
bed. Detainee was immediatel treated and then taken for a CT
Scan. After the CT Scan, detainee went into surgery and Dr

ad no further contact with him. Dr related detainee

did speak some English and understood English. Detainee 4111,
de no allegations of abuse while in Dr presence. Dr

could add nothing further to assist in the investigation.

About 1710, 11 Jul 04, the undersigned interviewed Dr (MAJ)111.1111111.11111

31st CSH, who related detainee was adritITT777777177—w
ICU for chest pain/congestive heart failure. Detainee was
treated with medications and appeared to get much better. On t e evening
of detainee all, he was to be discharged from the hospital,
but due to convoy difficulties was transferred from the ICU to the ICW to
spend the night until a convoy could be arranged. Drill as detainee.'

care physician, completed an examination of him, looking at his
chests and abdomen, focusing on It and lung problems. Drillillrelated
that during his examination, he discovered no signs of physical abuse . Dr

related detainee s oke English, was educated and knew he had
heart problems. Detainee was appreciative of the medical care he

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
0 abT 6
27 Oct 04

CM FORM 94-E ( FOR OFFICIAL USE. ONLY EXHIBIT (1 OCT 95 W9....1 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM / AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16)
000128
(When Data Is Entered)

DOD-049126
\9( ( 96) 1
00 20-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE .7 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS
was receiving during hig detainment. Drilligrelated that at no time did

detainee allege he was being abused by anyone.

On 15 Jul 04, the undersigned coordinated with Detainee Operations, MNF-I,
in attempts to obtain the detainee file, medical records and interview/
interrogation dates pertaining to detainee The undersigned was
advised the previous contact redeployed; however, the status of the request
would be reviewed.

On 22 Jul 04, the undersigned received an information paper from the DCG,
Detainee Operations pertainin to detainee The information
paper related detainee had not complained of any headaches or
head injuries prior to admission into the 28th CSH. (See Information Paper)

On 24 Jul 04, the undersigned received authorization from the DCG, Detainee
operations to Pnter Camp Cropper and rondnot investigative acttvity as
necessary.

About 0827, 26 Jul 04-, the undersigned received an In ormation Report from

the Ft McCoy Branch Office, USACIDC who reported SPC and SSG
111111111 .were interviewed. SPC was on leave and his interview

would be completed upon return.

On 28 Jul 04, the undersigned coordinated with the 89th MP BDE, Camp

Cropper, Baghdad International Airport, and obtained the detainee file and

medical records pertaining to detainee . (See Detainee File and

Medical Records) '

About 1033, 29 Jul 04, the undersigned received a detainee interrogation
matrix noting the dates detainee was interviewed/interrogated
while in custody. Detainee last interview/interrogation date
was 29 Dec 03. Detainee was removed from Camp Cropper and
transported to Camp Slayer, Baghdad, IZ, between 8-11 Jan 04 and allowed to
visit with his family on 11 Jan 04. (See Matrix)

About 1900, 1 Aug 04, the undersigned interviewed 1LT

31st CSH, who related that while in the hospital, detainee

appeared to be in good spirits and he was very polite. While 1LT

poke with detainee he never mentioned maltreatment and

during examination there were no signs of maltreatment. Detainee ¦
came to the hospital for chest pains, but claimed his heart was not

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER DATE
• p 2 3.5 6 7

27 Oct 4
ID FORM 94-E FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIT

S EXCLUDED 34-MAUTOMATIC MARKINGTIC TE

IOCT95 NED FR0O6)
ATIOI
000. 129
(When Data Is Entered)
DOD-049127
0020-04-C1D259-80138

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 8 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS
hurting. After examinationv there appeared to be no clinical signs of a
heart condition. 1LT related that he was the nursing care provider
for detainee in the ICU and when detainee...Ill/was screened,
detainee was alert, oriented and possessed all mental faculties.
1LT related that while in the hospital, detainee flipped
through magazines and he would not be expected to have such good motor
skills with a recent head injury. 1LT related detainee
was fine until transferred to the ICU.

On 3 Aug 04, the undersigned reviewed the detainee file of detainee..

which disclosed a Hospital Report of Death dated 31 Jan 04
reporting Dr pronounced detainee deceased at 0156, 31 Jan
04 and the cause of death was Brainstem Compression 72 degrees,
Intracranial Hemorrhage 72 degrees, Coagulpattry 48 degrees and
Thrombocytoperia 72 degrees.

On 7 Aug 04, the undersigned reviewed the medical records of detaineeilli,

which disclosed that on 18 Oct 03, detainee was treated
with Nitro tabs for chest pains; 26 Dec 03, seen for suspected high blood
sugar; 15 Dec 03, seen for blood coming from nose over several days; 19 Nov
03, for heart murmur; on 18 Oct 03, detaineelMillicomplained of chest
pains, extreme headaches and was found crying in his cell clutching head
and chest. He was not alert as normal, had dry heaves the day prior.
Detainee had numerous other medical visits, which need AFIP
consult for etermination if the poor health of detainee was a
contributor in his death.

On 9 Aug 04, the medical records of detaineellinallwere. submitted for
Consult by AFIP.

About 1015, 23 Aug 04, the undersigned received, an Information Report from

the Ft McCoy Branch Office, who reported the. interview of SPC was

scheduled for 24 Aug 04.

On 24 Aug 04, the :Undersigned received an Information Report from the Fort
McCoy Branch OffiCe, USACIDC,.pertaining to the interviews of SSG

,

SPC and SPC their knowledge of detainee
death. (See AIR of SA

About 1837, 25 Aug 04, the undersigned received, an Information Re ort from
AFIP,- who reported the Camp Cropper Medical Records of detainee

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIGNATURE DATE
022563

S. 27 Oct 04
1111/

CH)FORN194-E FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIT
1 OCT 95 Kt} PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) (When Data Is Entered) 000133
DOD-049128

0020-04-CID259-80138

AGENT' S.: INVESTIGATION REPORT
PAGE 9 OF 9 PAGES

DETAILS
were:teceivad. The medical reCOrds still'appeared itcomiolate; however,.
was reviewing them.

About 1800, 27 Oct 04, the undersigned received a Memorandum for Record
(MFR), 17 Oct 04, detailing the findings of Drilling (See MFR) /// Last
Entry ///

DATE
02356a

27 Oct 04 CD FORM 94-E FOR OFF CIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIT
1 OCT 95 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) 000131 ' (When Data Is Entered)

DOD-049129

So )38
Cannp Cropper

1.
Category: HVD

2.
Type of Incident: Prisoner MEDEVAC

3.
DIG: 311030(L)JANUARY2004,

4.
Location: Camp Cropper, BIAP

5.
Weekend/Holiday: Nona ---'

•
6. Personnel involved: L

a. Subject1
• I. Nam*
ii. Rank:
ISN

iv.
Nationality: Egyptian

v.
Be*: M

•
vi. DOB: UNK

vii. Facility: HVD
viii Security DP

7.
Narrative of Incident: Notified b CSH at approx. 1030 that Detainee AM.
has died.

8.
Remarks: . tiny! ed on 26Jan04 of chest pain while at Camp Cropper. MEDEVAC to
the 28!'' CSH sa da —1600. Cardiac event was ruled out and was rnonitored for 24hrs.
Subsequently stained head injury secondary to fall while at CSH. CAT Scan revealed
massive cerebra eecl with brain shift. Neurosurgery was performed decompressing bleed
without decompression of brain. An old bleed, 3-4 weeks old, was found on top of the new injury.
All these factors would leave the patient in a vegetative state: LTC neurosurgeon,
estimated hot longer than 72 hour life expectancy.
Note: Medical Records show he was seen at least 8x since 16 J 04 for toe wound and no

•
ddcurnented complaints of headache or visual disturbance. Tlyughout entire records no head

•
trauma has been recorded. Oct 03 has recorded of severe hqadache but no trauma and no signs of intra-cranial pressure.

9.
Publicity: UNK

10.
Command Reporting: 744th MP BN

11.
POC: SSG

12.
Downgrading Instructions:

-.•
02,3570

o 0 01 3 9
DOD-049130

Referred to
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COM1VIAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION!
PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.P eterson 1 @c en. amedd. army smil
(210) 221-7826
7,--.36'1

Page(s

• Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN : CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
Master Sergeant Pamela Andrews
andrewsp@centcom.smil.mil

(813) 827-5341/2830
a3S-1
0020-04-CID259-80138

,.„
Rol NUMBER-

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
0049-04-CID789

CID !Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES

DETAILS
BASIS if014..INVEStIGATICK On 30 May 04, this office received a Request for Assistance (ERFA)(00940:., -22hd Military Police (MP) BN (CID), Baghdad International •
40259-8018).,frOril
Airport (BIAP), Baghdad, Iraq APO A 09342, requesting a copy of detainee file of Detainee
National rlotoihee Reportihd Systrt.).(N-D.FZ.S.)
• • • • . • ... •
, . . .,•.•,.... .... • • "., • :.,„„ ....„-,••••••.

...•„ ..•, , .. • About 1700, 30 May 04, SA attempted to 100010. 000.008111111111111111h.: the Magistrate-C01.1-dOtobOO„ -Wit1)(50t queried the the number name
„ . " . • • • .• •• . • ...••••. .., • • .• • . , . . • • • .
. , •

no matches
,..• •-•. . .

• • ••• . • . . . . • . . . • ,. • • .. . . • . „ . • , . • .• • . . About 0900, 31 May 04, SA COI to obta in a copy of the detainee file and dossier for Detainee riSP-dotOrmihod the detainee file or dossier could 'h'ot located '.0.• 'r system with the
• • ...•... . _ • •. •
itlformaticft,. • • • •.
•. • . .• . . : . . . . statos,:. This RFA is cortipiet0. No further investigative activity is anticipated by this office„ ///LAST ENTRY///
•
L(/)(c)4 ; 6(7- )
TYPE AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMEER ORGANIZATION
g357 3
PRISONER INTERROGATION TEAM (Pi T)( I

SA
Baghdad Central confinement Pacility, Abu Ghruyeb 09342

SIGNATURE DATE EXHIBIT 31 May 04
CID FORM 94

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Nce\r,
DOD-049133
ROI NUMBER .• .

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT

• 0049-04-cIP241

CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF PAGES
'

DETAILS
BASIS. FOR INVESTIGATION: About 1300, 1 Jun 04, this office was contacted by SA Washington District (CID), in reference to a Request for Assistance from 22 nd Military Police Battalion (CID),
DSACIDC, APO AE 09342.
This office was requested to locate, fully identify, and interview Dr
(LTC) , Attending NeurosUrgeon,' InterventiOnal'NetrOradiologisti.. Walter Reed Army Medical Center,
. ,

Washingtoh, DC 20307:in reference to his knOwledge on the undetermined death of adetainee=in Iraq.
About 0950, 2 Jun 04, SA11111condnoted a telephonic interview of Dr pertaining to his knowledge on the death of Detaineellill stated he was consulted around 01004 31 Jan 04,
scan showed Detainee had a brain hemorrhage. Dr was.
told Detainee had fallen from his hospital bed around 2200, 30 Jan 0 4. He s ated during surgerY he .found a brain hemorrhage at ' least three weeks old beneath the one he initiallY decided to perforth surgery on. Dr...related Detainee had not been in his
care or treated by him prior to the tiMe an a e he was consulted for treatment of the unresponsive condition. He understood Detainee'''. 1111111111initial complaint was chest pain and would have been referred
to Internal Medicine. Dr111.111111stated he was consulted after
Detainee succumbed to a coma. He did not observe any signs
of abuse.
AGENT'S COMMENT: Unable to conduct interview in person due to Dr prior scheduled commitments.
About 1740, 2 Jun 04, SA conducted"a telephonic re-interview of Dr He stated the procedure he decided to perform was a
.

craniectomy evacuation of subdural hematoma, and explained beneath the
skull is the dura mater, a membrane, and beneath the dura mater was a
blood clot placing pressure on the brain. Dr stated the
injury was consistent with Detainee falling from the
hospital bed given his pre-existing risk factors: he was taking
asprin, a blood thinner, and the old hematoma. He related that those
.

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE N_ UMBER 1.0 (2)..1 ORGANIZATION
SA Walter Reed BO, 3d MP Group, USACIDC,
Washington, DC 20307-5001
SIGNATU DATE 2 Jun 04 EXHIBIT qse 023574

CID FORM 94 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
1 FEB 77
000135

DOD-049134

069.0- o4-d-TvA59- go 1 3
ROI NUMBER

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
0049-04-CI D241

CID Regulaiion 195-1
PAGE 2 OF 2 PAGES .

DETAILS
risk factors have'been seen in, the general and can turn an
otherwise minor injury into something more. complicated- 0r
further related the:remov:al of the blood ot.. did_n9t r. ypsp.','7t..
injury the brain had sustained. 'Petainee :..remained in'a
vegetative state so the humane thing.to do was to withdraW support of
the: ventilator and allow him to expire nattr:aTIY. 'Dr :cOuld--.. .
not recall the names of the other: , hysician, that treated bet'aiP0e11110

1111111 but believes they 'are stiiI . eplo'yeciin Iraq with th0:31st
Combat SuPPOrt. Hospital:. . He does not know if. an autopsy was petformOd.
on Detainee ---
/ / /7 / / . :. - - -/ // LAST ENTRY / / / / / / / / / / / / 1 I /'/

c —y

TYPED AGENT'S NA i D SEQUENCE NU ORGANIZATION
S Walter Reed BO, 3d MP Group, USACIUC,
SIGNATURE WashingtOn, DC 20307-5001 DATE EXHIBIT 023'575
2 Jun 04 1

CID FORM 94 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
1 FEB 77 000136
DOD-049135

) '

• FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - LAW ENFORCEMENT s.eNSITIVE -
OCgO -04 -C_TP09541f (58
AGENT'S INVESTIGATIVE REPORT 0062-04-CID342-

CD Regulation 195-1 PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES
BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: At 1244, 01 Jun 04, this office received a Request For
Assistance from the 22nd Military Police Battalion (CD), United States Army Criminal
Investi aLion Command, APO , AE 09342, to interview SSG
DET 3, 744th MP BN, Wilson—Kramer USARC, 2940 Ai
18017, pertaining to his knowledge of the death of Mr.
National Detainee Registration Number Cell B, Building 4, Camp Cropper, Baghdad
International Airport, Iraq, an Iraqi prisoner, while in custody of United States forces.

• At..1:729,93.44).. 94; sA. d S , this office, interviewed
._ . . , .

SS who rendered a sworn statement wherein he detailed arranging the
medical evacuation of a Mr. SSGIP1111111111111tated he was unaware of
the medical condition of Mr. d arranged the medical evacuation of Mr..'
er the direction of the Physician Assistant. SSG related he was
aware Mf had died at the 28th CSH, but was unaware of e circumstances
surrounding his death (See Sworn Statement for details).

STATUS: This RFA is closed in the files of this office as no further investigative activity is
anticipated. ///LAST ENTRY///

-•\10-)-(4--1 •
' 4',1-•)'(c)..-1;.. • :
Carlisle Barracks Resident Agency (CID)

SAIIIMMIIIMMII6(
2)-1• 3d Military Police Group, USACDC Carlisle, PA 17013 02 576

re:'Date: 03 Jim 04
Signature:NM Exhibit: (1
CID FORM
•
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
000137
DOD-049136

FOOS- LES
SWORN STATEMEN'r 00c96 -pc4 CCD,A59- (3 DATE TIME mile FILE NUMBER 18013 3 Jun 04

lir $1 MN 0 0 6 2 -- 0 4 -C11)342-

oRCIANIZATioN/ADDn88:
7744Th Military Police Battalion, Bethlehem, PA 18017 \D (-7') (C) (9 IT) CO —4

want to make the following statement under oath: On 5 April 2003, I arrived at Talil Air Base, Nasariyah and my assigned duties were a prison guard for the comPound- We were a central hub between Camp Bucca and Camp
Cropper in Baghdad. Any prison going north and south would have to come through our system. 10 Nov 03, I moved to Camp Cropper with the advance party to get things setup in the facility. I eventually moved into the S-3 about 15 Dec 03. I was the liaison between the S-3 and the prison facility. I also handle the training of the new soldiers that were replacing the 7441 MP's as the facility guards, I also arranged transportation of the
'detainee& I would do mostly the evacuation for the medical detairtees that were being sent out to a hospital for medical reason& I would arrange for doctor visits into the .1.I e i e s : .o our so ters s ep • e 'IT e
I.O II
were unable to handle the inside duties, therefore another unit was coming in to handle those dutie& I left Camp Cropper about the 27th or 28th Feb 04. We went to Camp Arigan, Kuwait in preparation for departure to the United States.
Q: Do you recall arranging the medical evacuation of Detainee

A: I do recall arranging the evacuation ofallinillin late Jan 04, but I do not recall
the circumstances surrounding his death. I do recall him expiring while in the 28 th CSH.

Q:
Did they tell you why he was being meclivaced from the facility?
A I do not recall, .I onl et instructed to arrange the medical evacuation transportation.

Q:
Had Detainee been medivaced before?

A: Most of them had been seen before by the Physician Assistant (PA), for problems, but
I do not recall him being sent out for any. injuries a....

Q: Do you know who questioned or interrogated
A: I do not know them by name, there were so many of them coming in an out, but the
ISG would be able to tell who the specific handlers were. It was their job to authorize
those visits.

Q: Do you have any knowledge of icing abused or claiming to be abused
by anyone?

A: Not while my guards were there, if it had happened it would have came forward and
been reported.

Q: Do you know of the care and treatment thaillilligreceived prior to his death?
A: I do not recall any specific care of treatment that he received. Many of them did
require treatment. There was no need to let the S-3 unless the detainee required medical
evacuation.

Q: What training the guards have handling detainees?
A: The guards did not receive any official doctrine training on detainees handling, but a@ 2 3 5 7 7to the running of the facility, such as meal times, recreation times and what to do in a

Initials of Person Making Statement Page 1 of 2 Pages
a00138. A '10011 /: A
EXHIBIT I g •
DOD-0491 37

00 62-0 4•-CID342-

Statement of Talon at Bringer, PA, dated 3 Jim 04, Continued. c)002o -oq- crDps9-r3g
nledical emergency they were instructed b y me on what to do. I was the major link for the major daily operations of the prison for my guards.
Q: Do you have anything further to ad to this statement at this time? No.///END OF STATEMENT
AFFIDAVIT
, have read or have had read to me this statement -which begins on page 1

an ends on page _2_ I fully understand the contents of the entire statement made by me, Thestatement is true I have initialed all corrections and have initialed the hake of each Page containing thestatement I have made this statement freely without hope of benefit or reward, without throat ofpunishment, and without coercion, unlawful influences or unlawful inducement.
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law toer oaths, this 3RD day ofJLINE, 2004 -
SA
(.1) (-6
(ed Name cif Person Administering Oath)
ARTICLE 136 (b)(4) UCM.T
(Authorio, To Administering Oath)
WITNESSES:

(Signature of lifines#
(Signature of Wfitriess)

(Typed Name of Winless) (1)7pet Name' I Witness)
(Address of Witness) (4deirees of liPlitiees)
023573

Initials of Person Making Statement Page 2 of 2 Pages
• T A
c I e.
DOD-049138

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - Law Enforcement Sensitive

ex00.0q_av sq.- go (3 a

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
0126-04-C11)025-

CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES

DETAILS
About 1245, 3 June 04, this office received a Request for Assistance (RFA) from the 22nd MP BN, (CID) APO AE, 09342, to lOcate, identify and conduct an interview of Dr. (LTC) Co B, 109th Med BN, NatiOnal Guard, (ASMB), 607 Princeton Street, Vermillion, so, 57069-0434 (VSD).
About 1330, 3 Jun 04, S this office, conducted a check of the DOD Employee
Interactive tYata System (DIEDS) for LTC hich confirmed the address of
Rapid City, SD, 57069-0434 (RCSD) as being his hOn16 of record. (See DIEDS report)

About 1530, 3 June 04, SA this office, coordinated with Deputy Pennington Coun Sheriffs Office (PCSO), Rapid City, sb, 57702-0434 (RCSD) to deliver a courtesy message to Dr. (LTC) and provide contact information for this office.
AGENTS COMMENT: Numerous attempts to telephonically contact LTC imillby this office met with negative results.
About 1745, 3 June 04, S coordinated with Deputy PCSO, RCSD who went to LTC address and was unable to locate him. De related it did not appear that anybody had been at the residence for some time Deputy stated a neighbor had not seen LAIIIIIIMat the residence for several weeks.
AGENT'S COMMENT: It is =verified but believed that LTCIIIIIIIIImay be on vacation at this time
At 1430, 4 Jun 04, SAIIIIIIIroordinated with Deputy..Who had coordinated with the United States Postal Service, RCSD, who related there was no mail hold or forwarding.directions for the 11111111111esidence
At 1500, 4 Jun 04, SA coordinated with SFC111111111111111B Co. 109th Med BN, SD,
National Guard, 607 Princeton St. Vermillion, SD, 57069-0434 (VSD) w o was unaware of any detainee
,

records returning with the unit or was he aware of unit members who assisted Dr. (LTC)1111111111when he treated SFC could not provide any additional phone, work or vacation contact information on Dr. (LTC)
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////Last Entry ////////////////////////////////////////
TYP AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER ORGANIZATION Fort Riley Resident Agency, United State§ Army Criminal Investigation Command, 78th Military Police Detachment (CID), Fort Riley, KS 66442
SA (2) I
DATE EXHIBIT

4 June 04
19 023579

CID F FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - Law Enforcement Sensitive
FEB 77 000149
?.,cA I . DOD-049139
.•
•• , ..•

e..7-C-15,4$9..t • -
ROI NUMBER

• AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT 0126-04-CID025
,.„
• • :•. ..•
-•

C/b Regulation 195-1
DETAILS • • , •
nated with Depur Who elated coordination with the •
coordi

About 15 000, 8 Jun 04, SA
arding addr b ess had een left for LTC 1111h Furt er Deputy

local post office revealed no h.old.-Or forw1 1 111 1 • •
at ES residence which met withelated nmnerous attem ts were made to contact LTC eighbots revealed they had not seennegatiVe results : Demi said a canvass of LTC

LTC m weeks Deputy related he' vciOuld have a patrol sent to LTC resid.ence and Would have the patrol contact this office to report his findings':
About 1530, 8 kill 04, S eceived a call from Deputy who related LTC11111111111
--•• •
was at his residence in
whO, rovided a Sworn Statement,

About 1800, 9 Jun 04, SA interviewed LTC
and the incident where was evacuated to the Combatdetailing he recalled detainee did not recall complaining of any .injuries

Support Hospital (CSH), however, LTC
to his head prior to being evacuated to the CSH. (See Sworn Statement)

elated he did not know ame, nor could he re-call

AGENT'S COMMENT: LTC
detainee nuinber, hence, throughout LTC tatemen s referred to as "the Detainee." -:///////////////////////////////////////////////0/0 LAST. ENTRY Mffillffillill0M/M0/0/000/ 0/0/0/0/N/7/

1)04; • 07).(c?-­
tr-.
1
ORGANIZATION-

nth MP Det CID (CSE)SA 6'h MP Grp (CID, USACIDC) Ft. Riley, Kansas 66442 DATE EXHIBIT
TYPED ENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER
09 Jun 04

a
ft
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
000141
nnn_rvtai an
SWORN STATEMENT. -o0.0 -0(1- CT-Dc9513-0/8,5r Foruse of this font, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
DATE Time .FILE NUMBER 2_002,
it) tN \Str,-SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER; GRADE/STATUS • O N
want to make the following Statement under oath:

Tkis-NFosr-0\ad .Vs". To-DAN-5 To ca. ctectihse . Cak-Crd
T'AL ETkei4 (1 044 ,),Ai 11A c'd"`-'1". 5L-er
W-CLN C,5

0-4k-64-ek.
far vtkkate(11 . Core g\A v-i) C3-e )r.) ? Or-to A ot,e6-4( )
trtC1Z.cAoN cte;t1 ./ r" Cctr-42-el'aLerrit
uk) cer— cs¦-. h-e. OE 1115 4esr. 11:4 ,Lioc,c0 ?ryesstore ceir.d bit5oh .s qv

Ast, 4)1„.‘„, _eco , qt-4. -6r,
ck4oVicti,eler vu-ore-wk5--orckc ,keTe4 to 1-1.2..
4;1e cir dc(0 sig caii L. e...al (cii\e0

2-f‘ C5
Cvv‘c.9`rt---.Me-a,.1A-v2.-.j te-cl

6" ,,,omoTtrvc,.5 (al c , 6O ho-t-.dstACT aN s ),‘, 0-to.,9s
oss °
ock-Tv,5 616o-Atike_e u-,ek CAkaLreei 12 clot° 1_, z„.. l ei"cc.
to ck
\c,1 t co91-e-rr; c-A4tt/t‘

G 11 `..' -to gIC C-54), W A/.Itua..tc tkt ,Q6 );t) DN. .569cr 14 siftxTrikr 45-o col -Cry-v.
rfA CC-15
nr. ote.w.1 h\,-11 d--t. keczkri-EY,e)-(14415w e_.o?'

w tred flVekl 1 -4/4:2 uctelckvve-Q- k°0) ea ike- 22-4, UctLtae
1,V5C4 ibt1 CL u\ `cZ-14 LarrQ et\,J) 4v04 to 2,2
csk Iltzkari Alcd, Wxz_ ‘0)2-Y fop ri„cer-
c_F re Dr-ha ov.wei‘kikr ii-ecP 'At5 Y).-e-d)(‘Ctki 5"F1-'eeLtr• ail 4(4
5,0.1-06 -e4 1\-eADI i tZ)\*1 F-0,--.oz- t-ete.)1/44 .-ywa,

oE 1LQ_.Y-evy\ce ; ,-. exT Croirr-,6-v-S
` t\c-e-5e)J4 5-vo-vNo--.1/4.CY vect-Y t c04 Gtkrre4cr
CriN 5
YX.e.af c c-o-hACtlee-- c-4 jvv-es11"-ertit-4164) """1/ 1\ 1,1 ¦ P' rt-Q-2gccicai,

v "11111111111.-- WX6-1-
C'CCAL-1-S C3-SN (N‘'

ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED CONTINUED." THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT AND BE INITIALED AS "PAGE OF. PAGES." WHEN ADDITIONAL PAGES ARE UTILIZED, THE BACK OF PAGE 1 WILL BE LINED OUT AND TH AF WILL BE CONCLUDED ON THE REVERSE SIDE OF ANOTHER COPY OF THIS FORM.
DA FORM 2823, JUL 72 For Official U.S. Government Printing Office: 9 983
ur42
Use Only
DOD-049141

¦2 (7)(6,-2— C., t') 0126 04 -CID 025 0-i.§4114
"STATEMENT OF TAKEN ATIMMIIIMILDATED ck -s,,N 6
CONTINUED." Ob(P.6 -04- cr­
D.Ds9 - so (5g

i/Vt orNa i r\ ck C V-‘ cc' n-4 ; cot? --1-`retai-V¦4..A-1 c9 .E ot..e„.1
5.6k`-'u /r1-e--te- 7t4-Q__ Yet oy-ti a-C-11p_ ) ) cLL Culp GO if,..ctilnicor.€4 v.
LA • C cald c-er-ir•

QS u u.,,t.,t4 he 0...,c6.-,-(ct ¦•¦-,e4 (D v, Aosyirod
tf„ c t...,eAre_. 604 okf Qv- To tte__ 0-ful cc,/ ,„vor r_e_vi _eufq
y,„1/ (Aviel. r) e0--Cor-c6 1,cinc)\..? Skei (^-1 5111) Lal-PeATA-,-r- ccr-ca ) Cr112A--„s ct . 11111
C r•
-4% 4-3.sc.N\ -4c ‘t-r-ps.!
; o_v v,4, Cr -2, cor-t5 LAI
was ff 11,0_ )) g-r
\ exp.A. e e
C•7 ?

L eYwr-c4e_ 4,04 GLADOTZt, Fe-4V la 1-fek„:gs or- Sc'
1A,tict4 c-c'e

6S\ 0.-No 4--)\Ce-c Dov
Cr\-ex-N-\'-V34-•-e.
c:,\C\ ct•\c--e

-A-k, s
c--4c5.9\.(..x:s¦r.e.cN
6* 1101 Y-cuck)i a, )(). covqk o is zr'r kack&clLck-es r t3 r-t9? )-es i 0 v1 -, s 0,2-Gt; c L ‘recov_4 6\i o,A14 fr loy,e ct \k, kv),("' op-etrki
eks,N eli) to be- yt--v),3--ed te,,s2-A cql cur ,_ V e nci • Oveit -Al2--a m L—ct.s ca To 1L__ CO-) ?e at RS 1-1C-5
ke..t,\

Ctr\r1 L/41111
cutt. 30
A ,_.c\c„.e. (Nfei„,cix,rve,e,
..k.cc.y•c

cks-N.N Vie. o_r_AD6,2\-e-C O -Nr‘e•-7 k_ V -e ow(--v¦rx t 5•OK co()) ko t-w-s-,t b 9 t.“0._\r_s 12e\ ; -­
\CA-1 , rhca
S Lori ocir,ktr Yv¦ CA til,
¦.6\oex-, -\-"Nc¦e-(Ne._A-6.2\Ncyc--e, (3,..•:-\...re.,c\ (N.
-\-\c-ve • C...),..\\c-C\ C
a_c_co“-.Ray-vi

\05s
023582
\--k •

nti r0'-P 0.v4 ckS -69Y-ccS re-CA1 q j'"cOrcC MP) elfit c.....ssy 0,1 .-c1„..Q. cy),Q__e VC:M.)4 le\ 01 IA cole- 11 oft! k tAbi-rev-W t 71,4
•

14"\ qteivINITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE 1-OF L. PAGES. —
For Official
000143
Use Only
EXHIBIT 4
DOD-049142
o 1 2 6 - 0 4 -CID 0 25

"STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT11.1111111101CATED (t)
CONTINUED.'.' 0090- -as-- go (38'

'-c-C.rc-NcC-rN\C:se,-c
ON-

"t\k---‘ e,e
"" \L-N

N
, czs-, A 10 ()
-,,
,,...;s, &--e_.--Nr...;-\\r,e,e
\(.es 1 IL A .12,10( jrN Q.Q. ' rDk.,_ L.--.11;,f), \,•.1/4,-_,_, ,,,..,.0),. PO) e-0,, c_4,v-vc-scaiu-,_, A,„, p., sZ ck cc \du-eV-12_ CoOr\--j ,2c1 6 k1/4.1-; rmol ist) a
‘z\z„....i „..„..)„,
-7,......, 6:e...A-0;.2..../..-,...e., , ....N..3 0-C.1/4.3 c).--\--c c:N, Vo 0 .._ ‘___t
-r\csee. vs-) NA, ?
• ,

'Tho_ Q--1 c?N•c-e,e tk)CA3 RN Cv.)..‘a ,--1,1 be_cavu e_ k.e., co c~1 aoh .e 4 6E-
srl-rd ---) ck‘ot--:\ k\i41 11 I's sZc._ /4 ccl v ). ;-t-11,4-Vv¦ RC1 q._ hk-e... ctp mc...s --4 ,(1.1-e4 t to
, tA be 61).,, ;,.1 oi L..psk\c-r atckc , '." .. A e. ,-,,,:r rt cxx) I osckt-t LAKT
S iNfrok,_N

t' pic..e.._ ol-N "Li-l\QT c 0.4 , -11.0.. 6 v)I-1110,y b elcok, 3 tAti q „I/0_ 6,,,,1 ,,,4 ,,,,,,i,
'er,— Vor..e._

z; ,\01 A si5 cl/f-kn-et -e s¦ c. k cell \ eq. Li b e_ 11 ,0 coryl4 .4 st-4 Its
itip.

t -To b-G0--m-R_ str,s,z_vike--7 ogre t1/40A&E; v ei corkcy to v-kki se_ PO
no,-----c' tl 5tck-1-0---b kqvAVAN . 1-1-e- A Cct -Ce-R-Ap¦ 11 5,k ckh..ivv. (,) -74,6i,‘
iiii
., fne v., 06' i ,r,•„,,,Q.4 rock (7 ot c.c.:A:R7-e.4 Aver-51 I) Crt4- 14 4i'l ..,,,,,_.(cor)
. :,.s\,„-,_,-,, \i‘c.„N e_a to t\c-e .A,e-A-ci.v.,(The-e• 0.--\ ..\-\r"-e-c--. \--\ 3 1 ),,,,,,i I 1-41`C'e-c,r\ev\ A(N1 1 LO---44z7ret rk-y tA 1).42em -e_ v co .Lc.q.e.4 4,---)•N i_s ‘ 112101%. I ct \A IA b0_,e,v, ok;ct ) v.\ or-e 4 a 5- h01 1,, „,;,..„‘ 9 h.mri.
\ e`r-T cdckt k q 0 i'v,o, 0 in . T— -RA-1142k-- )1e ckx- u N-cl ; r-e-c-- IA) TLCC.:( 1,,..R. d (4.1i - cli' \ -ed
1\76 kiDS 9 r1-7 c41 Ca \--T

e, Po,-C tO ktj ; r' 1 ” — \ '`)) ;
rN

T.... v.„," 1,, a.N.,-e. k.ez_crti, -c1,;s rt--Nriis. 'U_T
1; r,..a. We ck .Q...e)L.N °L. e -yi

to Ccuctie y-0 Rrx-- co -1 he ikft-La-`iTv„1/4:/ '--z"'d
C

u L ... ... A Co rekr Ito 1,,,,,-1 ' e- , j r,
v\r-r-q) Tc. 4e kg--ickcwa,e_ 1 v-,

0 tk-t 0,\c/-4 INck o
we..c-e-- as c-cfccr-ec-rt Q s vu-e_ c.,, ,,kid0 k.., IPTAIIIIM

l c tot 4 ,
Ygiot)s I-3 ah
uta v,...4t c& -or k(x) -i-1,..0 a ii .‘r-skkx; ip );.ei 0,_,, ,c-
1_61-he \ ;-eve.
ws, 0.t,d t\c.LJ ie-eA,, outi sg_ To ,etvk i &q lj C(190A-7 TL le473-eikicr
O"'"‘ CVt.2-
cc='``CVS \-e--xCN

a 1,3 0,3\ QC.)..\\ --,c-Or`cTh e, \Scr._.R \ C-C=G-\r=e
\ \ciscos.:\
\C-cAre,
c_01,0a S su,ck my\ 1 1-vxv-y
(, r,_‘._

cc-Ne. sc-\(-
\z)---s-\Sc, I ei\c-N &"--AC_;-\\r-NC-e R 61-k\ '14' A ;ckb4.---7 023533
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE OF Lk PAGES.
For Official
EXHIBIT A( (I" 1 4
Use Only DOD-049143
0 2,6 0 14, -COO 2..5 -Az,s; i4

STATEMENT (Continued) ejpg 0'04 al) ,v7S-i-g6 13S1
9,ects-6-
'N'eATPI:\s7N'e-e \`st
, Y1 42\102f-co eo\ c\r\t_ of m., 541.1 Toy-5-v11)1

N )Nct _ '4 . v-, 0%Ald )1tIVA
)\J ,
A-1313Q SI-e4) O\ PI-Kkask
1-1 a) vi!crt I l airw) -1(1;_sTori D ek 1.13 N:A.V1)
delecthl-ez•

C\-4 SO c¦-¦5 OreNcN c-1c-r,,c-Ncx.Xtv

3 7\--epitAnP a1/4 cjier,
re_csz,e-65:,
10 (1) (CS 2_ ,.. .e a
tAT 7 '
1.z 0%1 -a, ot-ecera

:Teti--e-e) c9h T v\-ci 1(9070 SLA". 1-1\0.1 it) I/1 0 L..' '41-ea
NA;
2_6 -TN—eke „tut., %.z.ssc. ,

N
//7 • //7
AFFIDAVIT

HAVE READ OR HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1 AND ENDS ON PAGE t-lt . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME, THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OR BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF TROUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
1,4 Cr
ent)

WITNESSES:
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by Law to administer oaths, this day of ,.Sr , 2004 at

ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(Typed Name of Person Administering Oath)
"Ir 4'M
Article 136 (b)(4) UCMJ or 5 USC -

ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS (Authority to Administer . Oaths)
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT *4- t`' PAGE Llv OF Lk PAGES 000145
For Official I Ir.e. II-S. Government Printing Office: 1993 - 342-027/80494PVT-1Thirr 01
DOD-049144

Page(s)

Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
Master Sergeant Pamela Andrews andrewsp@centcom.smil.mil
(813) 827-X341/2830
D 236 _C
DOD-049145
DOD-049146

Referred to:
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/
) PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl cen. amedd army.mil
(210) 221-7826
)351 7
/ -7W

Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
Master Sergeant Pamela Andrews andrewsp@centcom.smil.mil
(813) 827-5341/2830
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/
PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl cen.amedd.anny.mil
(210) 221-7826

Page(s)
23'7 P 238

Referred to
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN : CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
Master Sergeant Pamela Andrews andrewsp@centcom.smil.mil
(813) 827-5341/2830
D35?"0
(3) (CN
1017)(0-z.r co00-0(4-CtED

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
-

Roi NUMBER CID Regulation 195-1 0073-04-CM065-
DETAILS
BARS FOR fiVEST:GATION: About-e830 29 !un-34 this office received Requestfoz -Assistanct(CC2C--,-04-C1D259-80138) from CVV.
perations Officer, 22nd Military Police
a.ttalio Ba Iran. re uestin this office locate filly identify and interview SP

s S S ssigned to the 79th Military Police Compa.ny, 715 Marion Rd SE Rochester MN 55904, in re erenoe to the undetermined death of a detainee (Mr
(NFL)) who was detained CampCropper, Baghdad, Iraq.

About 0957 20, Jul 64 SA is office 1
while at his

residence, SSC
stated he was the NCOIC for a squad of MPs task e,:secini the medical staff of the 28,, Combat Su ort Hospital (CS
, , ...

Baghdad, Iraq (BIQ). SSG.stated he believes Detainee
ational Detainee Registration. ystezii (NDRS) number Cell B, uilding 4, amp
topper; Baghdad International Airport (BIAP), Iraq, was broil ht to the /su. CSH, BIQ, bhecause he was
complainingg of chest pains,ute not sure. SS.

related he is aware that Detaine fell from his bed at the hospital but did not see it appen, SG said he was comingdoWn from the third floor when he saw the medical staff attending toDetagre
n h.efloor
next to the bed; he went Qver to see what had happened and sonteo t at Detainee

.

it appeared Detain was bleeding as vomiting. SS stated he is not aware of what treatme t Detaine eceived prior to or ury sustained at the 28th CSH, BIQ.. SSG stated he
does not know if Detainee as ever treated at the 28th CSH, ElIQ, for any injuries prior to 26
Jan 04 or if h ver receiv an r m lines riot to that, nor does he know of anyone who interrogated
Detainee SS stated he mainly conducted Perimeter Securit and/or Access

.

Control while a Camp Cropper. SS teed he remembered Detaine poke
English but related he never heard him say anyt ng out being abused while at Camp Cropper.

• About 1535, 20 Jul 04, S 4 interviewed SPC ho provided a Sworn Statement detailing his knowledge of and the actions taken during the inci ent pertaining to Detainee hile at the 28th CSH, BIQ (See Swoni Statement of SPC or details).
About 1115, 23 Au 04 S interviewed SP1111111111 who stated on 26 Jan 04 he was tasked
to escort Detainee m Camp Cropper, BIQ to the 28 -CSH, BIQ.. SP related
he escorted Detainee hile he was transported from Camp Cropper, BIQ via am u ante to a
Black Hawk and then flown to the 28 1 CS BI SP stated when they arrived at 28t h CSH,
BIQ he passed the escort duties off to SPC who was wai mg outside the 28 1 CSH BIQ when the
Black Hawk arrived. SPC related he never left the Black Hawk. SP stated he

TYPED AGENTS. NAME AND SEQUENCE. NUMBER ORGANIZATION
Fort McCoy CID OfficeSA Fort McCoy, WI 54656 .
SIGN TURE
DATE I EXHIBIT
24 Aug 04
09-

1. FEB 77 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
023591
000. 239

DOD-049151

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
ROI NUMBER C°°163-0/ -arj)c9S9 F.013

CID Regulation 195-1 0073,04-CED065-
PAGE 2 OF 2 PAGES

DETAILS
noticed when Detain was in the ambulance he looked confused and seemed unaware of his
surrounding d also overheard th e
Medics talking and that they said Detainee had had a heart

attack. SPC did not re
mber the names of the Medics in the ambul ce. Further, SPCd e didnot have any
, ntact with Detainee o rior o the escort duties and did
not • ow o pervious in'ures Detainee
ay have a• or doe e know of anyone who

interrogated ainee STATUS: T ffice has completed all reqUeste a e act further investigative activity isanticipated by • ffice- ll/Last EntlYill
b MO- 19(1)-1
TYPED AGENT'S. NAME AND QUENCE NUMBER ORGANIZATION Fort McCoy CID Office Fort McCoy, WI 54656 DATE 24 Aug 04 EXHIBIT
1 FEB 77 FUR UFFIGIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
023592
000240

DOD-049152

SWORN STATEMENT 00,90-04-C.:CAG-9-&D/32-FILE NUMBER : 0073-04-C10065-LOCATION : St Louis Park, MN DATE : 20 July 2004 TIME: ) VIII, (c)
NAME
SSAN Grad S -4 / AR
ORG/ADDRESS :

WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH: (3)

RIBI,
I was working security e the 28th Combat Sup ort Hospital (CSH), Baghdad, Iraq during the iiicidentwhert Detainet fell from his bed. I did not see Detainee
from the bed, I heard a nurse called out that they need aMl in the room the DetaineL was in, when I got to the room I saw Detainee on the floor with the bed (gamey) he was in, tipped over next to him, and he was still in his re • ts, one on
his arm and one on his leg. I undid the restraint so that the medical staff could treat Detainee I don't remember if I undid one and the nurse undid the other or if I undid both restraints. Detaine was laying face down when I first saw him, I noticed a small was rr. ig to swell. He was also kind of dry heaving not really throwing up, just like he was trying to. I walked out of the room at that point.
Q: Do you know whyDetainee was brought to the 28th CSH?
A: No idea, I know he came down from the ICU, but I don't know why he was there.
Q: Do you know what type of treatment DetaineerarMeceived while at the 28th CSH?
A: No.
Q: Do you know if DetaineelliMillitad any prior injuries before coming to the hospital on 26 Jan 04?
A: No idea.
Q: What was your job at Camp Cropper?
A: Basically Perimeter Security.
Q: Did you have any interaction with Detainee at Camp Cropper?
A: No.
Q: Did Detainee...say anything about be abused or do you know if he was abused while at Camp Cropper?
A: No, he never said anything to me and I don't know if he was ever abused at Camp Cropper.
Q: Do you know anyone who interrogated Detainee
A: No.
Q: Do you wish to add anything to this statement?
A: No. ///End of Statement/AM
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMEN111111 Page 1 of 2 Pages
•
FO f?1Fi4ilesNINV.,

ONLY Exhibit 5o
LAW ENFORCEMENT 023593
SENSIThE
000241

DOD-049153

HAVE HAD READ OR HAD READ TO ME, THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1 AND ENDS ON PAGE 2. I FULLY UNDERSTOOD THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAIMNG THE STAIEMENr. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF
PUNISHMENT, WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
WITNESSES:
Subscribed and sworn to before ate, a peraoti authorized by law to administer oaths this 20 .• day of July 2004. •
ecial A
(T.YPedWatne
Article 136. ITCMI
(Authority t o Mininister oath)

FOR OFFICIAL uc
• Ov!..
..simas

LAW ENFORCE KEN T

INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STA TEMENTinump Page 2 of 2 Pages
. • SENSITIVE
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

Exhibit 30
... I '4
U 0 0 2 4 2

DOD-049154
4 3

.

U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMANDFREEDOM OF INFORMATION/
PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl@cen amedd.a my.mil
(210) 221-7826
0235-94E-3
DOD-049155
ROI NUMBER

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
0020-04-CID259-80138

CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES

DETAILS
On 25 May 05, this office received Request for Correction (RFC) 0136-05-CID001 from Headquarters US Army Criminal Investigation Command (USACIDC), to conduct additional investigative activity and obtain
additional documentation.
About 1415, 1 Jun 05 SAME coordinated with Dr. Colonel, US
Air Force (USAF), US Central Command, Command Surgeon's Office, Chief, Medical Security Assistance
Branch, US Embassy, Baghdad, IZ, and US liaison to the Medico Legal Institute. Baghdad, IZ. Dr. provided the Final Autopsy Examination Report, Request for an Autopsy, and Death Certificate o
age 65. The Final Autopsy Examination Report and Request for an Autopsy were written in Arabic. The CertHicate of Death was issued by LTC MD, lba Sivan Hospital, Baghdad, IZ. Dr. advised he could translate the examination report and request if necessary.
About 1700 1 Jun, 05, SA provided the Final Autopsy Examination Report and Request for an Auto t Ih Mr. prepare e trans ation but due to the medical terminology we requested D verify the translation.
On 5 Jun 05 SA forwarded a translation of the documents to Dr. about 2000, 7 Jun 05, Dr. replied back indicating his receipt of the translated documents and would respond back when he could, considering he was traveling to another forward operating base.
9() (c)--

1 OCT 95 CID FORM 94-E, LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE FO PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM A T kri`111, TT71-1,171.7 • • •• . A EXHIBIT 3 uu0245
DOD-049156

nano: d Am
DOD-049157

obzo-el-fp-tett- w3g-

Al Juaifir Police Centbz vestigation , The Republic of Ira number 1225
Autopsy Request Application Date 02/18/2004
A Medical Judicial Autopsy is requested on the,c se accompanying this application by
Police Officer: to explain the cause of death and
answering the following questions here un
Name and surname
Middle and last name
Name of the mother and grand father
Gender -/Male
Nationality /Iraqi
Religion / Muslim
Occupation /
Body structure [fat...Moderate...Skinny] / Moderate
Skin color
Hair color
Color of hair of the face
Eyes _
Age. /65
Other significant discretions [tattoos...etc]
Height [tall...middle... short] / Short
Date and time of the accident / 01/31/2004
Place of death

Information could be found in the civil records as follows /Alkarash identifications...the
civil affair identification card numbered as /011111111111111enewal

Civil record number
Page number

State /Baghdad
Coutt
Location

Death circumstances / the investigator have to mention the total of
how the accident happened and every thing directly related to the death like description
of how the corpse was positioned. Explaining the kind of weapon used. And mentioning
the approximate distance in shooting cases.
The dead person was detained by the Multi National Vorces as his family claimed.
Description of the clothes [the number of clothes found on the corpse, should be
mentioned and what is on the clothes like rips, stains and strange substances] / he doesn't
have clothes.
D23597
u00248

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
CAW NORMAN SENSTTIVE MIME EXHIBIT 3 LL.
WM

DOD-049158
000 C37)2,&14

Features of the inp..I.es [features and forms of surface injuries bf the copse shall be
described and confirm their number and positions] / existence of an opening in the
corpse's head sutured by staples
The apparent cause of the death from an investigative point [the cause mentioned if
known otherwise written as unknown.]
The questions the investigator has to direct in addition to requesting of death cause

1-The main causes of the death
2-Explanation of causes led to skull opening "the head" reasons led to the opening
and the date the opening was performed
3-Existence of marks on the nose and the upper left side of the face .what cause
them?
4-Date of the death

• Signature of the application organizer /// [[personal signature]]/// and stamp His name / His occupation . / officer of.... Date and time of receiving I
. ' .

Rank of the corpse receiver, his name and occupation 3
C —

///[[Personal signature]]/// 02/18 12/4
Inside the stamp written:
[[Ministry of Health .Medico Legal Institute.. technical number the year 02/19
The examiner]]

Note ....

The application shall be organized into three copies, two should be returned by the
police officer after filling the vacancies concerning the corpse receiving
[Illegible]

•

This signal written by the institute of the judicial medicine in Baghdad by an admission / from thethe head quarter of the public prosecution by its book num1Derecalliand dated b LPJ 05/27/1970 and I have requested to supplying enough copies of this application to the investigators
Translated by: 09/14/2005 1.1111
ce4.)

Titan Cprporation Assigned to
48th MP CID DET FWD
APO AE 09342

.U2_35$3
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
AW PNIPIIRMANT CPIRTTTIM
DOD-049159

FOR OFFICIAL USE ma LAVit ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
DOD-049160

national nd Am

DOD-049161

The Republic of Iraq Ministry of Health The Medico Legal InstitUte To / Aljuaifu. Police Centre the tunnbe The technical nurnbe 11111, Date 02/26/2004
In regard to the request autopsy order number ate 02/01/2004 sent by Your office:
,

Here under is the autopsy and judicial medicine repOrt for the dead lease examine it with appreciation r Director of the Medico Legal Institute i 02/26/2004 The Autopsy Judicial Medical Report
I the undersigned here Dr have performed the autopsy judicial medical
examinationon the corpSe of the dead at 8 O'clock on
02/19/2004 and the result was as follows'
Age , /65 - -
Gender /male
Height /Tall
Skin color /light brown
Hair color /hair less
Color of face hair /Gray
Color of eyes /Black
Hypostasis [lividity] /At the back of the body [posterior]
Rigor mortis /disappeared
Death trace /transient
Tattoos and special marks / non
Clothes / non
The external injuries 1-Sewn external surgical injury extended between the right temple and the right parietal 20 centimeters in length appears as a result of an operation of head opening surgery with two injuries each 1/2 centimeter in adjacent to the surgery from upper through layers of the scalp. 2-Irregular blunt wound 'A centimeter size in the external collier of the left eye including layers of the skin. 3-Non vital bruises on the nose and right cheek. between 1 to 3 centimeters in site 4-Traces of dark veins in the arms, trace of IV injection
The head

The skull / Wide bruise in its layer facing the two locations. The right
parietal and the right temple. And it was surgically sewn.
The skull and its base / surgical break 7 centimeters wide between the two right
bones

The parietal and the temple bones. It has been put back in place.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

(?-)O-S
( -)I6"-1
to /7,\ t•
0236 Cl
.
DOD-049162

The brain / Wide hematoina localized in the right subdural space in the right parietal temporal region. The brain severely congested and the brain depressed in the location of hematonia. Bones of face, Jaw and tooth The brain / compressed and badly inflated The neck, muscles, veins and nerves of the neck/ The throat and hyoid bone ' / normal with no fractures. The tissues are normal The gland / esophagus : / The chest and chest cavity. / The clavicle and the ribs / The heart and the pericardium / The lungs and their membranes / The diaphragm , / The stomach and abdominal cavity / NO fracture and soft tissue was normal . / The intestines . ._ / The liver, spleen and pancreas 1 The kidneys and... . ' /
. The uterus and its attachnient / 1TJpper parts 2- Lower part The final examination ,results and disci ii
/

ears from the descrptifThe autopsy results seen in the corpse of the
that the cause of the death is internal bleeding in the brain due to sever blunt impact. 2-we agree with what came in the death certificate issued by the multi forces witch concerns the date of the death which was on 01/31/2004 Si atuiiiiiimmo , // The Doctor in the Medico Legal Institute
Translated by: 111111111111111111111119/14/2005
Titan Corporation Assigned to i fc,\
48th MP CID DET FWD
APO AE 09342

023606
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
9t.125q
DOD-049163

. ,
ROI NUMBER

AGENT'S INVESTIGATIVE REPORT 0020-04-CID259-80138
-.- • CID Regulation 1954 -. •

PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGE

DETAILS
About 1000, 6 SEP 05, the undersigned interviewed Dr Forensic Pathologists, Director, Medico Legal Institute, Ministry of Health, Baghdad, Iraq (IZ) and Dr. Fotensie Pathologist§, Medico Legal Institute Ministry of Health, Baghdad, IZ who performed the autopsy on thel
iiii6Mr.1111 IIIIIIII Dr s oke little English so Dr. acted as translator for him. D related the body of Mr was brought to the Medico Legal Institute on 18 Feb 04. A request for autopsy was submitted by the Iraqi Police, Al Juaifir Police Office. The autopsy was performed on 19 Feb 04. Dr.
related his office did not receive any documentation pertaining to the circumstances of Mr
death except for the Death Certificate completed by U.S. Coalition Force's. Dr related there were no injuries on Mr. iody that were consistent with being beaten or abused. The only noted injuries were those annotate
anrotáted on the autopsy report and those "injuries" were primarily the surgical incisions to the head as a result of the surgical procedures performed in an attettpt to save his life. The only unexplained injuries were the bruises noted. on the right cheek, nose and left temple. Neither Dr. nor Dr was familiar with Mr revious medical history or any of the circumstances surrounding Ins death. Dr. related they ha no previous medical documents or treatment history concerning Mr. nor were they provided with any report describing the circumstances of his death. The undersigned bne the doctors on the fact that Mr. was being treated for hypertension, diabetes, and was taking blood thinners and aspirin prior to being medical evacuated to the Combat Support Hospital (CSH) because he complained of chest pains and was believed to be having a heart
.8. is -11 -P.11 -1 S --a • N -e •l - N -•
Drilligagreed if Mr. medical conditions as described, his injuries could easily have been caused by such a fall and the internal bleeding in the brain as noted in the autopsy report. Dr and Dr, reiterated the intracranial bleeding was caused by some kind of impact trauma and the injuries noted on the autopsy report were consistent with a fall.
hospital bed and hit his head. Dr m______ had the pre-existing
Amilmmin iNsmffmtwa
During the interview, Dr.1.111.11111and Dr.a....reviewed the translated autopsy ort and made some
minor corrections. Those corrections were submitted to Mr. Translator, Titan
Corporation, (assigned to the 48 th MP DET (CID), Camp Slayer, IZ) who made the corrections.
•

Around 1215, 12 Sep 05, this case was coordinated with CPT Office of Staff Judge
Advocate (OSJA), Multi National Corps-Iraq (MNC-I), Camp Victory, IZ, whO opined there was no evidence
to believe a criminal offense was committed.
AGENT'S COMMENT: Although all vailable evidence indicates Mr death was an accident, neither the attending physician nor Dr listed a Manner of Death; therefore, the Manner of Death will remain as undetermined. ///LAST ITEM//I

(3)0;-);)9:()0 .-27,.. 6(4).0-9 ;
023601. •

TYPE AGENT SA SIGNATURE NUMBER ORGANIZATION 11th MP BN (CID)(FWD), 48th MP Det (CID)(FWb), Detainee Abuse Task Force, Camp Vittory, Iraq, APO AE 09042 DATE 12 SEP 05 re7
CID FORM 94 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY-LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE • . u0-j254.
DOD-049164

FROM: SAC, 12TH MILITARY POLICE DET (CID)
TO: DIRECTOR, USACRC, USACIDC, FORT BELVOIR, VA
CDR, CIOP-COP-CO, FORT BELVIOR, VA
CDR, 10TH MP BN (CID)(ABN)(FWD) HOPS//
CDR, 3D MP GROUP (CID) //OPS//
AFT, ATTN: OAFME, ROCKVILLE MD
PROVOST MARSHAL, 1ST ARMORED DIVISION
OFFICE OF THE STAFF JUDGE ADVOCATE (V CORPS)
LNO CID, CJTF (FOR FURTHER DISTRIBUTION)
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION- INITIAL/SSI- 0020-04-CID259-80138-5H9B
DRAFTER: SA RELEASER: S
.
UNCLASSIFIED`- FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

1 D A TES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OC,CT RENC,ES •
1: 28 JANUARY 2004/0100 FIRS - 31 JANUARY 2004/0156 HRS, CAMP CROPPER, BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT, BAGHDAD, IRAQ
2.
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 31 JANUARY 2004, 1650 HRS

3.
INVESTIGATED BY: SA

4.
SUBJECT: 1. NONE [UNDETERMINED DEATH]

5.
VICTIM: 1.

; M; , OTHER; CAMP CROPPER, BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), AGBDAD, IRAQ APO AE 09335; XZ (NF1) [UNDETERMINED DEATH].
6. INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.
THIS IS AN "OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM'.' INVESTIGATION.
THIS OFFICE WAS NOTIFIED BY THE 10TH MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID) (ABN) (FWD), BAGHDAD, IRAQ, OF THE RECEIPT OF A SERIOUS INCIDENT REPORT REGARDING THE DEATH OFA PRISONER AT CAMP CROPPER, BIAP, BAGHDAD, IRAQ.
002 5 5
DOD-049165

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED MR DIED AS A RESULT OF
HEAD INJURIES SUSTAINED FROM A FALL WHILE ADMITTED TO THE 28 TH
COMBAT SUPPORT HOSPITAL (CSR), BAGHDAD, IRAQ, FOR SELF-PROCLAIMED
CHEST PAIN.
, • • ' • " • ,
, • ...• , „ ..„ •, .„
INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED ON 28 JAN 04, MR. COMPLAINED OF CHEST PAIN TO THE CAMP CROPPER MEDICAL PERSONNEL, AFTERWHICH HE WAS AIR EVACUATED TO THE INTENSIVE CARE UNIT (ICU), 28 TH CSH, BAGHDAD, IRAQ. SUBSEQUENT EXAMINATION DID NOT REVEAL ANY CAUSE OR AFFECT FROM HIS COMPLAINT. WHILE AT THE 28 TH CSH, MR. FELL FROM HIS HOSPITAL BED AND STRUCK HIS HEAD ON THE FLOOR._ THIS INJURY AND SUBSEQUENT CONDITION WORSENED TO WHERE MR BECAME COMATOSE. A CAT SCAN REVEALED INTERCRANIAL BLEEDING AND MR IIIIIIMUNDERWENT IMMEDIATE SURGERY. THE SURGERY REVEALED A SUBSTANTIAL B MMORHAGE, WITH EVIDENCE OF BOTH OLD AND NEW
_

BLEEDING. MR DID NOT RECOVER FROM THE COMA, NOR • ASSOCIATED HEAD INJURY, AND WAS PRONOUNCED DEAD BY LTC (DR
NEURO-SURGEON, 28TH CSH, AT 0156, 31 JAN 04: •
„: • , .
ON 31 JAN 04, MR. REMAINS WERE RELEASED TO THE „. .
IN it I. !ILL t B _ • -_A_s r_, e
LOCAL AUTOPSY OF MR. IS PENDING BY THE ARMED FORCES
INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY:

• • •• '•••-•

THE CASUALTY LIAISON OFFICER (CLO) FOR THIS MATTER IS CW2111111111111 SPECIAL AGENT-IN-CHARGE AT DSN 302
1.111...11.1.11F

INVESTIGATION CONTINUES BY USACIDC.
7. CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55. ,
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
•
• (d) 6)7:2....).
(1).(4
U'33256

DOD-049166

CBD FORM 66

1. DATE 005. 2. TIME RECEIVED 7. CASE NUMBER. 314a-n 04 1640 0020-04-C1D259-80138
3. OFFENSE Undetermined Death 8. ASSIGNED TO SA
9. TYPE OF ACTION GC tf).N 66—
5. VICTIM Detainee ISN 10. REPORTS
6. CASE DESCRIPTION Detainee allingdied while in the custody of U.S. Forces at the 28th CSH, Baghdad, IL
30v-ku-t
11. OTHER ACTION 12. CID FUNDS I 3.z.0Lf .111 ote
ACTION CRIMINAL INFO RQRD COMPL DATE AMOUNT 3
VIDENCE CUST

06
DOD-049167
— •

• CID FORM 66
1. DATE 005 314aa 04 2. TIME RECEIVED 1640 7. CASE NUMBER 0020-04-C1D259-80138-
3: OFFENSE Undetermined Death . 8. ASSIGNED TO SA
4. SUBJECT
5. VICTIM Detainee ISN 10. REPORTS
6. CASE DESCRIPTION Detainee ed while in the custody of U.S.,Forces at the 28th CSH, Baghdad, IZ. (2c,4 Ark CO3 1:5te_ Lk X1/4.1.i 6 41 .le
11. OTHER ACTION 12. CID FUNDS Oq.35 ¦Madi oLe .30
ACTION RQRD COMPL DATE AMOUNT 3'
CRIMINAL INFO
EVIDENCE CUST

h'A 27

DOD-049168

CID FORM 66

1. DATE 1 2. TIME RECEIVED
(TA-0 14,Y O
3. OFFENSE
noleAl (6R-1451-1k
•
4. SUBJECT
6. CASE DESCRIPTION
GiA, bte43 --1-kidtp I Chtsq--ezu;Isi i/y)
11.11111111 cell au+ koscrig194

A kcy4-01 1;1jov , gir i/a1-ILE Vrfl\t•N,stuvv-.)cdv.-5-2--
11. OTHER ACTION 12. CID FUNDS
ACTION RQRD COMPL DATE f AMOUNT CRIMINAL INFO EVIDENCE CUST
7.
CASE NUMBER 6V-24 CWAry -eacY(P

8.
ASSIGNED TO

9.
TYPE OF ACTION

10.
REPORTS TYPE SUSPENSE

0101

c_ N
1­a­ . 3 ria5
(.3 Pc.- Of
I' -11•44a ,4c4-e-c?4

0-slet5-8
0000U3

DOD-049169

iV."7/ of)e) 3cP-
Circle
Last Name Date Issued
Circle
I
Last Name Date Issued I

. W .
. W
. W

. W

Obtain MP Report / MPR #
Sources targeted
NCIC entry on stolen prop _

Medical records requested
Film submitted for contact sheet

Name check dispatched
Copy of AIR posted in ACIRS

Name check results receivedObtain all documents concerning All documents marked withthe positive urinalysis the ROI or file number

INVESTIGATIVE STANDARDS

ACTIVITY! PERSON
PHONE NUMBER
/67

31st Combat Support Hospital
Ibn Sina Hospital, Baghdad

31d Combat Support Hospital Ibn Sina HOspital, Baghdad

LTC
Executive Officer
OCCOL
CS

538 cliivt
VI3N-24n0 9

uszonymi1
MCI)
:army mil
000d04
DOD-049170

7,AGENT'S ACTIVITY SUMMARY Control Number 0020-04-0O259-80138: (CID Regulation 195-1)
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT
1640 31 Jan 04
11110

1807,:_31 Jan 04

1830, 31 Jan 04

SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: About 1640, 31 Jan 04,

this office received a Serious Incident Report from

the 10 th Military Police Battalion (CID) (ABN)
(FWD), Baghdad, Iraq, regarding the death of a

prisoner from Camp Cropper, Baghdad International

Airport (BIAP), Baghdad, Iraq, while being treated

at the 28TH Combat Support Hospital (CSH), Baghdad,

Iraq APO AE 09335.

About,1807 31 Jan 04, S and SA

this office, in erviewed LTC

744TH Military Police (MP

Battalion (BN), Cam C er, BIAP, Baghdad, Iraq.

On 26 Jan 04, LTC related MR.

was being treated for a toe

injlirY, when Mr. com lained of being

dizzy and a headache.-related he

arranged for Mr. to be transported to the

28th CSH for further treatment and observation.

AGENTS COMMENT: LTC related Mr.
was a diabetic and was being treated for high blood
pressure.

About 1830, 31 Jan 04, SAIIIIIlland SA

conducted an examination of Mr.

confinement cell, at Camp Cropper, BIAP.

CHARACTERISTICS OF SCENE: Mr.

confinement cell was approximately 9 feet by 9 feet

by 12 feet high and was made of concrete with gray
-in col-or walls-r -The-entrancelexit way was located-

on the north wall and was about 3 feet wide. There

were no windows present.

CONDITION OF SCENE: Upon entering the room, the

light was on and the door was locked. On the east

wall was a red in color plastic bucket containing

what appeared to be urine, two pink in color

plastic buckets, and various hygiene items. On the

south wall were two Meals, Ready to Eat (MRE)

packages containing what appeared to be laundry

detergent, one red in color plastic chair, one

cardboard box containing various clothing, and two

cardboard MRE boxes containing several various

items. One of the MRE boxes contained a small

0230 0
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PAGE

clPF( 2-8,,-t
U00005
DOD-049171

AGENT'SACTIVITYS6i1VIARY Control Number 0020-04-C1D259-80138 (CID Regulation 195-1) TIME, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
1
•
plastic bag of medication in tablet form. The
plastic bags bore English handwriting indicative of
a prescription from the camp medical clinic. Along
the west wall was one metal bed frame approximately
4 feet wide by 7 feet long containing one mattress
and several blankets with the bed running, north and
south. On the' north wall

ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS: At the time of the
examination, the outside temperature was
approximately 55 degrees and the inside temperature
was approximately 50 degrees. There were no odors
present and a mild wind factor.

FACTORS PERTINENT TO ENTRY/EXIT (E/E): Entry to the cell could only be made through the north E/E.
SCENE DOCUMENTATION: Photographs were exposed by
a Sony Cyber Shot digital camera
and a rough crime scene sketch was completed.

COLLECTION OF CRIME SCENE EVIDENCE: There was no
evidence. collected.

SEARCH FOR LATENT IMPRESSIONS: A search for latent
prints was not conducted due to the circumstances
of this investigation.

SEARCH. BEYOND THE SCENE: A search beyond the scene
was conducted which resulted in negative evidence.

NEGATIVE. EVIDENCE: evidence. There of negative
1840 31 Jan 04 About 1840, 31 Jan 04, SA who related Mt. .interviewed SSG 744TH MP BN, BIAP, omp ained of chest pains

and was air Medevac TO THE . 28TH CSH for treatment. SSG. related an MP (NFI) from-the 79th MP Company escorted Mr. to the 28th CSH and then turned over custody44.41111111111 to another MP. (NFU from .the 79th kW COMpany.

1815, 31 Jan 04 About 1815,.31 Jan 04, SAIIIIIIII coordinated with
LTCIIIIIIIIIto verify the contents of the small
plastic bag of medication discovered in the MRE box

023611

•

CID FORhi FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PAGE -4-OCT 80 •
•U00006

DOD-049172

AGENT'SACTIVITYS&IIVIARY Control Number 0020-04-CM259-80138
(CII) Regulation 195-1) TIME, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
•
in the decedent's cell. LTC related the,
medication was both Mylanta and Motrin, as
prescribed by the camp medical clinic, and was . a
routine and dotumented prescriptipn. He related
the medication would not precipitate heart
problems.

About 1918, 31 Jan 04,, SA and SA
interviewed SPC 79th •
MP Company, Rochester, MN; deployed to Camp '
Cropper, BIAP, Baghdad, Iraq who related he
escorted Mr. to the 28thHCSH' via air.
medevac and released Mr.IIIIIIIIIIoVerto SPC.

.

(NFI upon...arrival to the CSH. SPC/111.
relate Mr: was conscious and positioned
in a stretcher throug out the flight to the CSH.

About 1924, 31 Jan 04, interviewed SPC

79 MP Company, Camp
Cropper, BIAP,E22hadi Iraq who related he took
custody of Mr. from SPC and
accompanied him to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU),
where he received medical treatment for chest
pains. SPC related he and Mr.
walked downstairs after Mr. 'as
transferred to the Intensive Care War (ICW), for
further observation. SBAIIIIIIrelated while Mr.

was in the ICW, he (Mr. 11111.11 fell
out of his bed and sustained a head injury. SPC
11111111telated he did not witness Mr.
fall-out-of-bed, but Was-called td-the room. by'd

•
nurse (NFI) to help put him back into the bed. SPC
related Mr. plillillwas bleeding from the
od

!Mid there was lo present on the floor. SPC
elated Mr. bed was about 4 feet

o f of the ground and Mr. was confused,
dizzy, and could not reme er falling from his bed.

About 1935 31 Jan 04, SA nterviewed SSG

, MP Company/ Camp Cropper, BIAP, Baghdad, Iraq, who provided a verbal statement. SSG related between 15 Jan 04 and 29 Jan 04, PPP! NCOIC for the 28th CSH.
.

hospital security detail, as augmented by the 79 th
MP Company. SSG related he recalled. the

023612 CID FORM 28 FOkoFFicIALttg ONLY PAGE 3 l-OC:P84
000007
DOD-049173

• AGENT'S ACTIVITY StIVIMARY Control Number • 0020-04-C113259-8013g (CID Regulation 195-1)
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
\9 (1) -11
(9(i)

(1)
0845- 1 Feb 04

IIIIIII

0855, .1 Feb 04.
MO.

()90' 4 Feb 04. .

0956, 1 Feb 04

1000, 1 Feb 04'

1010, l Feb 04'
WNW

1025, 1 Feb 04

111.111

1246, 1 Feb 04

1250, 1 Feb 04

MIS

incident where Mr. fell from his hospital
bed; however, he (SSG i did not physically
observe this fall. He stated SPAM,was
Working in the ICW at the time and possibly had
better information about the incident. SSG

1111111111did not suspect any wrong doing associated
with Mr. fall other than his (SSG

spequlation that Mr.11111111,probably
attempted to get up from his bed and subsequently
fell. SSG did not recall noticing Mr.."

11111,in the Camp Cropper facility prior to his medical evacuation to the 28th CSH on 26 Jan 04. Attempted to contact the BIAP Morgue several times with negative results. No answer, Will keep trying.
Attempted to contact the 28th CSH with negative
results.

coordinated with Major
related Mr.
Inte
related Mr. waspronounced dead at 0156,
31 Jan 04, by LTC (Dr.)
Neurosurgeon, 28th CSH.

Attempted to contact the International Red Cross .
(ICR), several times with negative results. Will
keep trying.

Drafted. Initial Report.

Attempted to contact the IRC several times with
negative results. Will attempt later.

Attempted to contact 28th CSH with negative results.

Attempted to contact the IRC several times with
negative results.

Attempted to contact 28th CSH with negative results.
No answer.

Attempted to contact 28th CSH with negative results.
No answer.

FOR 2.8 • _4-0M:40 FOR ONLY PAGE 023613.:
(moos
DOD-049174

AGENT'S ACTIVITY SUMMARY Control Number 0020-04—CID259,80138 (Cl]) Regulation 195-1)
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT I . SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
About 1437, . 1 Feb 04, SA tele•honically interviewed LTC (Dr.) Neurosurgeon, 207th Neuro Team, 28th• CSH, Baghdad, Iraq who related Mr. condition to worsened after fallin from his bed and underwent a cat scan. LTC related he reviewed the cat scan and discovered a severe hemorange in the brain and refo• ed emergency brain surgery on Mr. LTC
elated during surgery he discovered a
secon brain hemorange that odcurred approximately
3-4 weeks prior. LTC elated MAIN,
11111111pcause of, death was a bleeding disorder
sustained by a hemorange of the brain.

To SAC for review.

AtteMpted to contact 28th CSH pertaining to getting

the body back to the BIAP Morgue for an autopsy

with negative results;

Attempted to contact the 28 th CSH with negative results. Will keep trying.
Attempted to contact the 28 th CSH,with negative
results. No answer. Will keep trying throughout • the

day..

Feb 04 Attempted to contact the 28 th CSH with negative results. No answer.
1815-1 Feb—OA-- Attempted to contact the 28th CSH with negative results. No answer.
1934, 1 Feb 04 Attempted to contact the 28th CSH with negative results. No answer. .
19b)(1)
0807, 2 Feb 04 Coordinated with Ms. IRC, who related
Mr. body was released to the Medical
Legal Institute (MLI) 31 Jan 04. Ms.
related the MLI would release the body to t e
family or bury the body within a day of receipt.
CA will coordinate with the. MLI and try and recover
the body before burial or release. Ms./Ma did
not have MLI's phone number on hand, but would
provide it to this office at a later time.

CID FORM 28 loorso FOR OFFICIAL USE ONIY 02-3 14--
0 U0 Uti9
DOD-049175

AGENT'S ACTIVITY SUMMARY Control Number - 0020-04-CID259-0138 (CID Regulation 195-1) TIME, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
0950,.2 Feb,04

11111...

1033,,2 Feb 04
1235, 2 Feb 04

11111

0900, 4•Feb 04 - -

1321, 4 Feb 04

1330, 4 Feb 04'
1111111

1345, 4 Feb 04

1353, 4 Feb 04
MIN

Coordinated with Ms related they (IRC) did`

not ick u Mt. • body from the CSH.

Ms. provided MLI's phone number, but

indicated they would not have the body because the

IRC-never.picked the body up from the 28th CSH. Ms.

related the body should be at the BIAP

. •

*

OPrglie ,* . 1

'Coordinated with SGT BIAP Morgue,
who related they do not have Mr. body
nor did they ever receive it during the last few

days.

th
Coordinated with SA 10MP BN, and

11111.111111
Provided a brief of the investigation and the
difficulty in locating the body.

Acknowledge SAC review 1900, 1 Feb 04, which was
handwritten while CA was conducting investigative
act-iTlit9-11-d---daTiniihting entries on laptop. Will
address all questions pertaining to review.

1.
Attempted to get body transferred back to BIAP
for an autopsy to be conducted, but as of A
Feb 04, still unable to positively identify
where body is located.

2.
AAS entries updated and place.in case file.

3.
Will get medical records from 28, CSH.

Coordinated with Major pertaining to
'int-erViM=Eg-LTC

About 1330, 4 Feb 04, S re-interviewed LTC .

, who related Mr. had a chronic

hemorange that was minimum o weeks old and

through time and untreated, would have become

fatal

•

Obtained the.copies of the CAT scan results of Mr.

Coordinated with cpaarall S_5,2Bth CSH, who related the S-4 section ha8 all the documentation pertaining to the release of Mr body and they (S74) were on a supply run to BIAP and not

CID FORM I OCT 80 kmtoFFICIALC8EoNLY PAGg 6, 02615
00 0 0 1 0
DOD-049176

AGENT'S ACTIVITY St/AIM/MY Control Number 0020-04-CID259-80138
(CID Regulation 195-1)
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT 1 SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY

041040. until after 170,
..-. - ..,:.2..,....ii•i.

„..
1356 4 Feb 04 About 1356,,4 Fe4:_94e:.S15. 111111111111102nduCted_c telephonic

. • • . ' .
I. (N'

1111111P lotor.v-ow 'Pf P±':'. who arr4riqod .fot Mt..,
body to...., illiilli. t-e.-... .... from... the 28. . TH CSH,.... .
....,..,'_....-,...,..,.., rerttOVed fr..:,-:-.. .

Dr.).' elated 110.. -_,,contacted •th0. R0e.l. Crescent and 4-'..:4:m4':• body removed al ong with two eithei" bodies related the bodies were
-. :.... ....,.,, ...,:. ..
removed onl .,,, .._tAk04' .t.!, the Sick tlooj_cl-r10..Q.ffi'ae lo cated •noct:,ta: the Ad; miniatrS, of Health, Baghdad, Itoq4:. Dr related the body
oa 31 LT:at.:. Q 4:: a ..,..-.... . -
.„ ._
would boet:rigPfate(1 pending being claimed by
. .

family members ot, the body j liSt be buried,
• . . .

1415 - 4 Feb 04 About 1415,. 4 Feb 04,.S. SGT
2eTi CSA, who

1111101

re ated he foUnd Mr. on the floor bleedinl fr°m his le emP efi'ext tO hiS bed
conscious, but did not witness Mr. fall.
SGTEelated Mr.
questlots to determine his co erent ness SGT

(0--z
elated after a few minutes, became incoherent and did' not respond to questions
asked of him; SGTIIIIIIIIIkelated Mr.
was taken for a cat acat as his condition grew'
worse.

to (1)01
1431, Feb 04 Provided a brief of the investigation to LTC

Executive Officer, 28 TH/31sT CSH, who
related he would provide this office with the
necessary documents partaining7tp-Mr,11111111111

0937 c e
OA 'VP +6 Cerck-NCX--

( CSW; SeVe141 41/m.0 ile,pMut
133(4-1 Wolf (6011\4(40 boi4 CPT si
CO,A.Wr-Sofporat /kW Al

alb cuolgOttbA aP rt
135-qi qraol
Cz000ki410 ion intio 1,444t4 401W
-4 644,10,4401. hAr 0A,

CID FORM FOR OFFICIAL, lig ONLY, PAGE; 0 2 3 6 1 6
I ocrs6'
000011
DOD-049177

AGENT'S ACTIVITY Ser141IARY, Control Number (CID Regulation 195-1) 9d-d V -CIDaly-easyTIME, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY,
/ 357, &MI Ailkitt9 Wry 3/, C2S/4-14/4 tz,2-144,20
, ,
Pecoeteo-
COL ,n1
0.) o 1111111._ ch faSeto ,P.Opt -‘04 0 kar figim 0 06-61111 reca6t6j,
i41 .
4
0fi,be
eco h-/ ee-
010. -
Pe-Poi' rem-. eAi)
AcYPie--if (-week).

CID FOR.U.28'.., -FOR OFFIcfAust ONLY
MOO 023617
000012
DOD-049178

(CID Regpla.tip7 195-1) I

" 09r" -04-t1D259 -80138

2TME, DATE, AND AGENT

SUMMARY o

INVESTIGATIVE ACTTTVIT*

1430, 19 Feb 04 SA
lFeb 04
•1050, Fe'b 04
q Mar 04,1111
/Nod OutLiel'i 4,11111111,
re6 co138
T«

Coordinated with SAC; instructed to draft final(c)

Drafted final (c) report
L(4):.' N.7q:
To TC for reVievi
=
rt. (()
f(//j fcV Thn cc31/e1:0,-)c.
Cormc+o-di 4c3 5.4
igcr revie
pi5,444,1 Disho Compwa.; offnaa fo CAC 1 `t/01)1i-cii-ke krill."( IS. GSM Jee-Fay, ctd..Ltts. TN- I-4 ‘rake oeS 4tc-ty•611/44 -/...evo-of--20( 1 ,7v
4.., es -c.-1xs
4.114 14,z_. e,yinkt.e1-
r
•

023C18
000013 DOD-049179

Control Number (CID Regulation 195-1)• 0020.-64-C1D259-80138
AGENTS ACTIVITY SeMbiARY
TIME, DATE,. AND AGENT. summArkt OF INvESTIdATIVE ACIT'IVITE
30 May 04411111 About 0920, 30 May 04, after administrative review, this investigation was re-opened to further investigate the undetermined death of detaineellill
About 1 640, 31' Jan! 04, SA, DET. (CID), -received Serious Incl ent RePOr.. (SIR) .from, the 744 th MP BN Camp eropp.o4:-.1346h44c4 IZ, pertaining
to the d0atk of
About 1106, 30 May 04i the undersigned dispatched a
Request for Assistance,
Interrogation Team, 75th MP IZ, .
to obtain copy of .detainee dossier file°,

About 1328, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a
RFA to the Ft Riley. Resident Agency, USACIDC,,, to
locate identify and interview Dr (LTC)

MED CO 13, 109th MED BN, per,aining to the eath, of detaineelliliM
About 1500 30 May 04i.the .underSigned-diSp4tched a
RFA tOtho Branch Of4.1 USACIDC, to.
iooatb'identify4Pc1._interyieW Dr (LTC)
Neurosurgeon, Interventional NO1rOr440,1TILSH . a ter Reed Army Medical Center
(previous] y 28th CSH, Baghdad) pertaiftiri to 41,$ . —
kflOWledgeJjf the-death of detairia

About . .1615 ; '30. .May 04 ; -. the undetsl_gned:diSpatched a
RFA to the Rock ISlap4 Arsenal Resident,. Agency
USACIDC, locate, identify,andyinterVieWSPC
.SPC and-SSG MP MN, pertaining Bath of detainee

About 1800, 30 May 04, the undersigned dispatched a RFA, to the Ft Bliss Resident Agency, USACIDC to locate identifyand interview SGT
31 st CSH, Bag ac I his knowledge of the death of detainee
On 30 May.04 ; the Undersigned reviewed the

investigative file pertaining to the death of detainee
The undersigned extracted a DD Form 689, Individual Sick Slip, dated 27 Jul 03, reportin -, 6 1 c detainee was Seen fot Thropbophebitis Cellulitis an ever. (See DD Fm 689)
000 )14
On 30 May Iiiiiiinctersi ned reviewed the

CO311111111 Cv,13 ( 1)1.00e4 6046. iYA-P-(11,--t-Arcd 011,
CID 1 Oct 80 YPTPs_ EtW THIS-r ' /14"3 . in 'WI r' sTF'314
DOD-049180

AGENTS ACTIVITY SUMMARY CONTROL NUMBER
(CID Regulation 195-1)

TIM, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY 0 INVEBT;GATIVE ACITWITY
investi.ative file pertaining to the death. of detainee
The undersigned ,extracted a detainee
ossier Pertainin -tO Detainee :.which
related detainee was taking as a
daily medication. .ee' osaier) ,-' '

On 30 May 04, the undersigned-dispatched a RFA to the Carlisle Barracks Resident AgenoYi.....QSACTDCi. to locate,. identify and interview SSGDet 3, 7 44th .R1, BN; pertaining to his now e ge of the death of detaine

On 31 May 04, the undersigned received an Information
Report from the Prisoner Interrogation Team pertaining
to coordinations with the Baghdad Central Confinement
Facility, Abu Ghraib,. IZ. (See' AIR of SAME.

About 1120, 4 Jun 04, the undersigned received a 1st-
Information Report from the Ft Riley Resident Agency,
who reported attempts to contact Dr on 3 Jun

. .

the Pennington countY Sheriff's Office, Rapid City,
SD, who reported Dr11111", Eresidence appeared

.

vacant. Neighbors rePorte Dr had not been seen in weeks and a check of, one o Di Previous hospital employers disclosed he clict not work at the hospital in years. On 4 Jun 04, coordination with the local U.S. Postal Service disclosed no mail hold or, forwarding for Dr Coordination with Dr 111111111
National'GuafdThnit disclosed no detainee
medi1 records were returned to CONUS when the unit
re-deployed and there was no known contact number for
Drill=

On 8 Jun 04, the undersigned received an Information
Report.from the Ft Riley-Resident Agency, who reported
Dr as located and an interview scheduled for
9 Jun 04.

About 1400, 16 Jun, 04, SA this office,
coordinated with Dr (LTC) Executive
Officer and Dr (COL) ommander, 31st
Combat Support Hospita n ina RosPitalf
Baghdad, IZ. Dr related that Dr and SGT

both former y 31' CSH, were no longer assigne to the unit and re-deplOyed to their CONUS home station. Di stated that he was previously interviewed by SP NFI) and provided, all details pertaining to detainee death that were available. Dr recalled that detainee 11111111tG4.0was admitted into e hospital. He said there we some problems controlling detainee and that

eIbrOPS:z0 DRElkIDUS EDITIONS OF TRIS FO*WII,L BR USED UNTIL EXEADDIRDEgo U jj 151 Oct 80
DOD-049181
CONTROL kOtiBER:

AggtS ACTIVIV1
•SUMMAkt
(Iti Regulation 188-1)
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT, -sOmOlOy OF INVESTIGATIVE ACITIVITY
detainee wa8 strapped.down to his bed. Dr
related detainee 'was strapped dOWniiiii,

. ,

'

.r, . . e oy. Detainee

eam and leg on one side of th body Dt

. . . .

allegedly awoke from sleep and attempted to get
out Of bed and then fell out of 'the bed on the-side he
was strapped doWn..., By falling out of bed. in this
manner, detainer :atruck-his:headt causing
interior injury 0: ..his brain The hitting of .the'head

—
cauSed:a brain hemorrhage, for which detainee

--. . .

uring
hemorrhage, it was discovered that detainee
had a previous brain injury ' The cause of t , .

was treatedDtreatment of the

. . . . -

revious brain injury was u kriown t. Dr Dr
' stated that detainee :WaS.adiabetic,
which had some effect on detainee

.,

:condition and treatment Dr elated' detainee
later succumbed t6,:his--. injuries.

_ -.

AbOut 1500, 16. Jun 04, the'undersigned received an
Information Report from the Waltereed:Branch .OffiCe
pertaining to the interview of Dr ertaining

(bee AIR of SA to the death of detainee

. .

About 1945, 17 Jun 04,-SA submitted 4 request
to the 3Vt CSH for an . and all M dical,rebords
pertaining to detaine SA gas
advised the. USACIDC was previously provided. the
medical records and the originals could not be
located.

About 1500, 18 Jun 04, the undersigned received an
Information Report from the Carlisle Barracks Resident
Agehcf pertaining to the interview of SSG

(See AIR of SAM.

On 28 Jun 04, the undersigned dispatched a second RFA
to the Ft. Bliss Resident Agency to locate and
interview SGT

About 0820, 28 Jun 04, this office, sent a request for medical advice to the Armed Forces Institute of Pathlogy pertaiznq. to the death of detainee . Dr (CDR) Chief Deputy Medical Examiner, Office of the Armed orces Medical Examiner, related the USACIDC did not possess enough information on detainee brain hemorrhage to make any determination. Dr related that while detainee could ave had a clotting disorder, some disorders ma1è people pro 9l61 1 clots and others to bleeding. Detaine e
InEY‘) ‘-'

have used ,enough ETCH over the years or be old enough

U00036

CID r0101,. PAW/t0t.t$: EpITIQN3 OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL: Ek4W,STED 1 Oct 80
DOD-049182

laZtEr$ PCTIVITY. atONAAY:

(CID Regulation 195-1)

Tp40, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE AeitIvvr*

predispose himself to the brain hemorrhage. Dr related the Intra-operative dating of a brain
e is hard utilesS reviewed, by a pathologist. related the brain hemorrhage could haVe been possibly years t .from a previouS scuffle , Dr
related it was doubtful detainee thrombOsi$ was occurring in the brain. ire,.
probably in the extremities and clots were breaking
free and Proceeding to the heart causing` the chest
paina'. Pr could not detertine the cause and
manner of anee
informatiOn provide

About 1500 , 28 Jun P4 f the undersigned received •an
—

information Report' from the; 78 th MP DET (CID),
pertaining tO law enforcetent and,unit'coordinations
and theinterViewOf. Dr (See AIRs of SA

Iliilliand SA
About 1650, 28. Jun 04, the'underSigned . re-dispatChed a
RFA to the.Ft Bliss Resident Agency to locate and
interview SGT COordination with 31 st CSH
revealed SGT redeployed.
About 1930, 28 Jun 04, the undersigned re-dispatched a
RFA to the Rock . Island Resident A PrlOy to locate,
identify and interview SPC ' SP and SSG
ertaining to their knowledge of death of .
About 1020, 1 Jul 04, the undersigned received an
.
Information Report from the ll th ,MP BN (CID) reporting coordination with the 31 st CSH, Ft Blis TX pertaining to the interview of SGT etermined he was still in Iraq and assigned to the 31 CSH, Baghdad, and could be reached at DNVT WIMMOMMNIMand the POC is CPT , S-1, 31st CSH.
About 2100,' 8 Jul 04, the undersigned received medical consult information from Dr who related that after review of Detainee surgical medical records, many details per ain n o is previous health history were missing. Dr related there was no documentation as to how de alnee all of the sudden ended up with a head injury. Detainee
was admitted for heart problems and had a erri e baseline health status (Arterial Sclerosis Cardio Vascular Disease, diabetes and other health issues): Dr related the death certificate
C 2 2
attributes dela." low platelets, causing a bleed. 0 Dr related not all platelet counts were legibleinetainee edical records,' but thea one tq_
ut/Oui 7

CID pa* 20 PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE EtEn titmisTEE

Oct 80

DOD-049183

• N9(
At)­
he could discern demonstrated a downward trend between
27-28 Jan 04 and then back up with the lowest Platelet
count being 49,000. Dr ha not concur with the

th

Neurosurgeon, 28 CSH, t at a Platele count of 49,000

was not low enough to typically cause spontaneous

bleeds. Factors such as detainee clotting status my have been involved. D elated detainee have been trans used and his
platelet count: couldha r *rePorted,

dipped 1°wer then
but he did not have the reports for review. Dr
could not determine the cause or manner of detainee
death based on the medical history and
cords he was presented with.

About 1400, 9 Jul 04, the undersigned submitted a

request for documents; detainee file, interrogation

file, medical records and detainee interview and
interrogation dates to the Deputy Commanding General
of Detainee Operations, Multi-National Forces-Iraq
pertaining to detainee

About 2320, 9 Jun 04, the undersigned, interviewed SGT

who related that on the night detainee

fell from his bed, he was walking out of a , Patients room when he heard a loud thud. SGT walked into detainee i room and fouriTTTT'w lying on the floor.'Detain'ee dppeared to
have injuries; therefore, SGT ailed for the
Military Police to release detainee from his

constraints and for 1LT
Charge Nurse, 31st CSH. SGT related detainee

ontinuously tried to get up and was, told to stay on the floor until assistance could be obtained. A DoctCr was called -and the Doctor. ordered a CT scan for detainee After the. CT Scan was completed, detainee was placed back in his bed and restrained. SGT related detainee'
as result of his injuries was bleeding from
'the left eyebrow and mouth and there was blood on the
floor of the room. SGT id not know the
results of the CT scan. GT aid detainee

ever said why he was attem ing to get out

the bë from which he fell. When an Interpreter
was brought into the hospital to translate for
detainee the Interpreter stated detainee

was spe cinQ in en sentences, whiiiiiid not make sense. related detainee UM after the fala,...aaar222 disoriented and confused,. Detainee 111.11111111.was not patient; ' therefore, h. no knowledge what detainee
as being treated for; not know why

detainee was iti,the hospital, saw no-"
U00_1(9
BREVIOLT$ EDITIONS Or THIS El'OBN V7.174, BE VEED UNTIL EtHAVETEOCID FORR 20 1 Oct SQ

DOD-049184

CONTROL NribiBER

AGENTS ACTIVITY SUMMARY
(CIP Regulation 195-1) ,
TINE, DATE, AND AGENT sumiuty or INVESTIGATIVE ACITIVITY '•
monitors attached to detainee and he was not
receiving any type of fluids. SGT related
the fall incident was the first interaction, he had.,

with-detainee11,1111111/ ' After thei-'fall; detai/le

. . -- , .

e was

was move.-Vla-s retCher becaus. .

sm..¦.........

16driented:and.'donftsed, SPTIIIIIIIINFrelated: ,
culd, not follow hospital guidance

detainee , ,

nuously tried tO sit. or get, up wh*e n 1nst;lactd tO"lie down.. SGT
becauSe detainee conti

could:add nothing further to the investigation. SG
IIIIIII.. ., .. related he did not notice any signs of abuse-._ . ..

, -... -. .

_ however, he was not looking

.on' detainee_
either..

About 1515, 10 Jul 04, the undersigned interviewed ILT
who related that after she received detainee 1.

in the Immediate Care Ward from the ICU, she
noted detaineeIIIIIIIIIIIIIrnzymes appeared normal.
He had no disorientation and he walked from the ICU to

the. ICW. ILT related detainee/1W! continuously s owed signs of agitat n an ng antsy, as he always wanted to sit up in bed or go to the bath oom. 1LT stated that when she examined
detainee she noted no signs of abuse. 1LT •

related t a when detainee was
transferred to her care, she di no use an
interPreter because he spoke some English. While .
speaking with detainee he never spoke of
abuse. 1LT elate taine appeared
in good heal wen examined. HJIIIIIIIIIIquest any
food, as she did not have him long enough to get food
for him. He fell maybe 5-10 minutes: after arriving to
his room. 1L11111 related there was nothing out of
the ordinary no e during the initial treatment of-
detainee during his time in the hospital.

About 1645 11 J undersigned interviewed Dr
(MAJ) 31st CSH, who
relate he was cal ed to assist in the treatment of
detainee after he fell from his bed.
Detainee was received by the Immediate Care
Ward from ICU, and approximately 5-10 minutes
after redei tr, was found after falling from his bed.
Detainee was immediately treated and then
taken fore a C can After the CT Scan detainee-

All,_
ent into surgery and Dr had no
ur er contact with him. Dr related

..-, 9

did s eak somep and uN3f
understoPir" Detaine made no
allegations of abuse while in .'D
presence. Dr could add not ing u they to
assist in the investigation.

detainee •.... 0 i

Cuutija

CID FORM 28 911E1400 .TIONS or THIS i*t4Vatt BE USED UNTIL " tlahustkio
1 Oct 80

DOD-049185

AGENTS Ac WIT StrtagARY CONTROL NUMBER
(CID Regulation 195-1)

SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACITIVITY

TPM, DATE, AND AGENT
About l71O, 11 Jul Q4, :.the.undersigned interviewed Dr
(MAJ) 3rt CSH,
related detainee was admitted to the ICU. for

.

chest an/CongPStxv -heart failure.' Detainee

Wee treated with medications and appeared t6
better. On the evening of detainee
fall he was to be discharged from, t

hbaitaf, but dud to convoy difficulties waS .:

transferred from the TCU to the..ICW tloi.Lg21.2,4 the night

until o0n9.o.-could

-, arraftged. as

detainee 'care physician, completed an

examination of him, looking at his Phest'and'at)dOm0114.

focusing on heart and lung problems : .Dr elated

M 4, • .;
that during his examination, he .d1Pcovere Tiosigns of
physical abuse Dr 1111..' related detainee

,
spoke English, • was ear .

,. e ucated and knew he had

ProbleMs- Detainee MOM was appreciative of the.

medical care he was receiving duringhis detainment. , .:

Ca CO 0.
Dr related that at no time did detainee
• MR..

• -'41E
IE

On 15 Jul -04, the undersigned coordinated with'

Detainee Operations, .MNF-I, in attempts to obtainthe

detainee file, medical records and interview/.

interrogation dates pertaining, to detainee

The undersigned was advised the previous contact

redeployed; however, the status of the request would

be reviewed. -

On 22 Jul 04, the undersigned received an information
paper fromthe DCG,. Detainee Operations pertaining to

,
detainee The information paper related

detainee ad nOt -doMplained of any headaches

or head injuries prior to admission into the 28th CSH.

(See Information Paper)

On 24 Jill' 04; the undersigned received authorization
from the DCG, Detainee Operations to enter Camp

Cropper and conduct investigative activity as
nedesSarY.

About 0827, 26 Jul 04, the undersigned received an
Information RepOrt from the Ft McCoy Branch Office,
USACIDC,:whO reported SPC and SS were
interviewed. SPC s on leave and
interview would be completed upon return.

02362 5
On 28 Jul 04, the undersigned coordinated with the 89th
MP BDE, Camp Cropper, Baghdad International Airport,
and obtained the detainee file and medical records
pertaining to detained/111111111 (See Detainee Fi Jj

. • &lag

CID tpR4 28 . pSvOUS EDITIONS OF Tftis FOAM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXRADSTED 1 oct 80
DOD-049186
CONTROL. NT.ME8R

Adt0Tg ACTIVITY ST10161ARY.
(txp.. .itegatiori 195-1) _
TIME, DATE, AND Ad?..NT • sum6mg-)zvEsT....... X OF 1
and Medical. HeCordsiL

About 1033, 29 Jul 04, the undersigned. received "a.
detainee.interrO ation matrix noting the dates
detainee .WaS:interVieWed/interrOgated While

-

_

in custody Detainee last
interVieW/interrcgatiort..—.4-0 was 29 Dec 03. Detainee

was removed from Camp and

-- .

transported tO,CaMP'8rayerf -Baghdadk IZ, between 8 711
Jan 04 and allowed to visit with his family on 11 Jan
($00-Matrix).' .

- .
ott 1900,

A6-1 Aug "r the undersigned .interviewed 1LT

3Vt CSH, who related
that whi e irtne nos'pitai 1 sine
appeared to be in good spirits and he was vé polite .

. .

While 1LT spoke with detainee he
never mentioned maltreatment and during examination

there were no signs of maltreatment. Detaine

came to the hospital for chest pains, but
claimed his heart was not hurting. AftAr exPminatinn,
there appeared to be no clinical signs of a heart
condition. 1LT

related that he was the
nursing care Provl er for detainee in the
ICU and when detainee was screene , detainee
as alert, oriented and possessed all mental

acuities. 1LT _related that while in the
hospital, detainee flipped through magazines
and he would not be expected to have such good motor

skills with a recent head injury. 1LT related
detainee was fine until trans erre to the
'Cu.

__.

Oh 04, the dnder i ned reviewed the detainee
file of detainee which disclosed a Hospital
Report of Death dated 31 Jan 04 reporting Dr
pronounced detainee eceased at 0156,. a
04 and the cause of Uath was Brainstem Compression 72
degrees, Intracranial Hemorrhage 72 degrees,
Coagulpattry 48 degrees and Thrombocytoperia 72
degrees.

023626
On 7 Aug 04, the undersigned reviewed the medical
records of detainee which disclosed that on
18 Oct 03, detainee was treated with Nitro
tabs for chest pains; 26 Dec 03, seen for suspected
high blood sugar; 15 Dec 03, seen for blood coming
from nose over several days; 19 Nov 03, for heart
murmur; on 18 Oct 03, detainee complained of
chest pains, extreme headaches and was round crying in
his cell clutching head and chest. He was not alert
as normal, had dry heaves the day prior. Detainee

CID POEM 28 PriElt­lOtTS EDITIONS OF THIS E`0*iTIO, BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED .az
1 Oct 80
DOD-049187

AGENTS ACTIVITY SUMMARY COBITlif)t, REIMER (CID Regulation 195-1) .E
.
TINE, DATE, AND AGENT SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACITIVITY

had numerous, other• Medical visits, which need
consult for. deterMination if the. Poor health of
detainee was a cOntribUtor in hiP death.

On 9 Aug 04 , the medical records. of detainee

were submitted for'cOnsult by AFIP:

About 1015, 23 Aug 04, the undersigned received a1

Information Report from the Ft McCoy Branch Office,

who reported the interview of SP was

scheduled for 24 Aug 04.

On 24 Aug 04, the undersigned received an Information

.
Report froM the Fort. McCoy Branch Office . IJSACIDC,
ertaining to the interviews of SSG SPC
and SPC referencing t eir' knOwled e o
death. (See AIR of, SA

AIX)ut 1$37i. 25 Aug 04, the UnderPigned ,received an ,
InforMatiOn Report• .froM AFIPr. who. r- sorted. the Camp
Cropper Medical' Recorda . of detainee were

ved The medical recor i aPPeare
incomplete; hOwever, Drswas reviewing theM.

NDPut 1800, 27 Oct,04, the undersigned received a
Memorandum:for Redord (MFR), 17 Oct 04; detailing the
finding8 of Drilla (See MFR)

02362

•
00,002
CID FORM 2$ PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED
1 Oct 80

DOD-049188

AGENTS ACTIVITY ,..4444RT co4t#63 Nuffil2et (CID Regulation 0020-04-c1b259-80138
.E .

DATE, AND AGENT , .04144X 0:0110tsXGATtVEAcITXYTtX
1700/ MAY 05 BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION; On 25 Mar 05, this of ­
fice received information from the United States Army Criminal Investigation Command (USACIDC),

11111111
which stated a news article dated 24 Mar 05, titled "U.S To Probe Iraq Scientist's Death", reported that a Dr with Iraq's Forensic Medical Institute, had performed an auto sy on the body Fter it had been turned over to the family. Dr. repo edly ruled the cause of death was "a blow to the heacl."

1800/ 25 MAY 05 Drafted 3rd Supplemental Report, re-opening this case to Conduct further investigative leads.
111111,
1920/ 25 MAY 05 To DET CDR for review.
023028

CID FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDITIONS. OF THIS FORK WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED
1 n,* An

DOD-049189

Coixtrol. Numberi (CID Regglation 195 -2) . 0020-64-C/b259-801313
AGENTS ACTIVITY St4A4AEVE
TIME, DATt; AND , AGENT
1320, -29 May 05
SAMMY

1445, 29 May 05
SA

1000, 30 May 05 SA 1111111ln
1210-1300i 1 Jun
05,

1415, 1 Jun 05
SA

1600-1615, 1 Jun
05, SAI1111111

1700, 1 Jun 05
SA

1900,Jun 05
SA MN

2000, 7 air" 05

1iAo5
CID FORM 28
1 nm. an

st0,0740 OF INVESTIGATIVE Acxtryrgyy,

SA attempted to Call Dr.
111D.DMj-loath, DTM&H-.Consultat Votensic Pathologist ,

Dir to of Medico Legal In8titUte; MOH, Baghdad, IZ.
Dr, did not answer Phoney Iracifla
dell

spol‹e with Dr, and.reqUestP4 the inal
SY Bkaltinaton RePOrt
age; 65'i which was Per orme Y

'
. DR.1111111 advised he was .not at his-0 ,ice but
check e neXtaY report. also-

wou ch-day fOr. the Port. DR

-r-1 1r4 - f

ted DR.IIIIIIIk-s currently working ,or

is
Medi Legal nstitu . e. An email was also sent to DR.

. ' , ,
requesting the Final Autopsy Report. (See

contacted Dr, DR, elated he

reca -

reca e the auto sY being PerfOrMe. on M .

DR adviSed the autopsy repor t, should
beat s Of ice ut would require one to two days to
look:for it. S told DR this Offide

would reqs; rP thez A itcpgy RAport and photographs along
with an interview of Dr DR. 11111requested

..,

this office call him in

SA 111111 traveled to the US BmbaSsy, Interhational
Zone, Baghdad, .Iraq (IZ).

SA coordinated with Pr .

Colonel, US Air Force; (USAF) U en.ral
Command, Command -Surgeon's Office, .Chief, Medical
Security Assistance. Branch,' US . EmbaSsy, Baghdad, IZ,
and US liaison to the Medico Legal Institute, -Provided
the ' utopsy Examination Report of

age 65,which was written , in .Ara lc,
AIR)

-
SA traveled back to Camp Victory, Baghdad, IZ.

SA Provided Mr111.1.1111111.111.111111! Titan
Corporation, assigned to 48t MP DE , Camp lctorY,
Baghdad, IZ APO AE 09342.

emailed translated documents to D

SA

DR. sent an email indicating his receipt of

the translated documents'and would email back the

final translation.

Orf ii/Do-dr 02362T
PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL DE USED UMTII, EXOUSTED

DOD-049190

AGENTS ACTIVITY Stift¦IARY (CID Regulation iss-l)' • • • Control Nunther 062a-04—CiD259-80138
TIME DATE, EAPPNT sUNI1AA** OF INVEPTIqAir7t.AP;TI7.7TY
25 YON 05 CAT I Update

1111111110 9 Jul 05.
14 JUL 05
MI1111111
4 JUL 05

1200L1 JUL 05
1000/ 19 JUL 05
/1 ikt5
51k

45-1511, i1. or 54
to(1)(4 -1 19tie)(0-41
CAT I Update
•• .10 -14""
Sent e-mail to Dr equesting status of his review of the Final Autopsy Examination Report...
Received an Out-of-the-Office e-mail reply from Dr which stated he will return to his office in mid July.
Called telephone #111111111111vhich is the number for Command Surgeons Office, U.S. Embassy, IZ. Office personnel had not heard of Dr.111.111. or
To DET CDR for review. This case is pending the following: 1.Coordination with Dr. concerning his findings of the Final
MEM • • Autopsy Examination Report.
2.Interview DUNI
T wpc,wk-Co-wi Pijl
lirpiput
11-1.64ApW . 1-0 co.tt Ovt.
/, VO1.L4 c.
MOMN0
023630
PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED. UNTIL EXHAUSTED

CID FORM 28
. 1 nrrh FME

•

A.
DOD-049191

AGENTS ACTIVITY k' om R M T.' CONTROL NUMBER
(CID RegUlation 195-1,' ,-
--,.

SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE

Tri1Di DATE, AND AGENT

1030/ 25 AuQ- Made contact with Dr..who agreed to be interviewed and related he
would arrange for Dr .to also be available for interview. D

dvised that I contact Mr. .Health Attache, U.S. Embassy, Baghdad Iraq to coordinate transportation from the U.S. Embassy, Baghdad, Iraq to the 1VIinistry of Health also in Baghdad Iraq.

1330/ 25 AUG 05 Contacted Mr.. whO advised members from
„-. •
his office make tripS om the.U.S!Emb.
assy to Ministry of Health on a regular basis and it could be arranged for an SA to convoy one day with his group. Advised would attempt to coordinate a trip sometime during the week of 27 Aug­2 Sep 05.

27 AUG 05 CAT I Update lob) Or 2
-

111114 V.” . '-) -i., 6 1,1-) 0 ,--7_,C
1000/ 1 SEP 05 Spoke with DR.via. telephone and. arranged to meet with him at the
IOW . .. i.' . . ..
.
.jimilmmi
Ministry of Health, Baghdad, IZ on Tuesd.ay,-6 Sep 05. Dr......elated Dr.

11.11
-
1111111111woufd be thiere on; Tnesday and T cpuld interview both of theni the,n
... Num ...., •

1015/ 1 SEP 05 Coordinated with Mr..o arrange travel from the 1J.S. Embassy m the
IZ to the 1V1inistry of Healtli -on Tues'clay 6 Sep 05...

1400/ 5 SEP 05 Traveled from Camp Victory, IZ to the U.S. Embassy, Baghdad IZ.
0900/ 6 SEP 05 Traveledto the Iraqi Ministry of Health, Baghdad, IZ to interview Drain
and D

1000/ 6 SEP 05.I Conducted interview of Dr.111111111and Dr1.111(See AIR of SIM
for details).

0130/ 8 SEP 05 Traveled back to Camp Victory.
1900, 9 Se 05 Detachment Commander approved 3 days of non-investigative activity (7 - 9
Sep 05), due to relocation of office from Camp Victory to Camp Slayer. As of 10
Sep 05, resume all normal timelines and investigative standards.

P-05/ t) J 'ela rzcfacc---)
y'- o G rev f.cs 64-f-A -er-/
). DrF Y

a A' 11111111
?r„2., 100.,(( +-3 L 0 ef) A c,t,ok/s5;011
-I- A.)+14.c..•
023631
//
000 ,
•

.u°

CID FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED.
1 Oct 80

DOD-049192

.­
CONTROL NUMBER ,-
.

AGENTACTttlITYIT

Reg aatidai 18571). OOZOL-- 44-.iW.TE•
TIME DATE, AND AGENT

1215/12 s6p 05•
/1010 ) (3 se jof
5 IMO

CID FORM 28
1 Oct 80

- .
IWAAT OF INVESTIGATIVE ACITIVITY

.

Coordinated this case with CPT Office of Staff Judge
Advocate (OSJA), Multi National Corps-Iraq (MNC-I), Camp Victory, Iraq.

'be 04(-e.04;.4"."..•, •
dffr 4-e4 h544:--.. oriu4
CA'in C,(A.
^Li ,yrs
a fiuvrnoi Aili4
At
6(4 et.64/1/(
11,51-atrf-ei/i/Pntpod
Aar
wm-etv/t4,40(40
oied,tAkuhti,
a 5
5.„? p,o,
I, 0 ,t;, rc..5 t9 oc.4_
rG Re.oe-0)
ellA.) Or C o (te,c+ihtr3
rna-.
rc Re ui esJt
e tt1---0 5
ex v\i16(4.5t
t,7tn §PI-J- mhirial4(t ffe(A4 001
6 flAR4L 4J64f141411.
1 '
4 ) 10%, "AC-of4500t1*J6-1/61 ""e) 14441173
rs deiwkle//D 4WAst
1/.1102 :f'
6 3 2
Cec.
p 1 a cAyij Jymur..4 *my.% .sm ArryicsAutt4 A cr he • No
,
PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED. UNTIL EXHAUSTED °U­e

DOD-049193

INVESTIGATIVE WORKSHEET DATA REQUIRED BY PRIVACY ACT

AUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Code, Section 3012 (g) ROUTINE USES: Your social security number and other personal information are used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number enforeement officials with means by which information maybe is voluntary accurately identified 1 REC Code 2 Action Code 3 Date Submitted 4 SEQ Number 5 Year 6 Unit 7 ROI Number 8 Rel to Cast 9 Control 4
A4
INDIVIDUAL DATA
z

31 MOS 33 Position , , 34 Industry r35 Security 36 physical Marks; .
,„, : ,.
\\./.4.\,. S&Nr 10 lj e r bark.
39 Alias- Nicknames)
.

kt,.*-0 C to o 515. 40 Organization 41 If Contractor, Contract
e.dsivrpo. wo\Ae4-cktallotr,„TkakkA6anlie
42 Military SV 43 Subunit 44Fora City 45 State 46 Country 47 Zip Code/APO \330-5V; 0361
53 Juy 54 Family Rel 55 Sponsor Last Name 56 Sponsor First Name 57 Sponsor Middle Name 58 Social Security Number 59 SPON Grade 60 SPON MCAC 61 Sponsor Unit Address 62 SPONCity 63 SPON ST 64 SPON CTY 65 SPON Zip Code/APO
OFFENSE

66 Offense Code 67 UFC 68 Offense Code 69 UFO 70 Offense Code 71 UFC 72 Offense Code 73 UFC
ADMINISTRATIVE DATA

Telephone PCS/DEROS. Date INTERV Start Time INTERV Start
yAr...

ace o n erview tart Date INTERV End Time INTERV End Place of Interview End Fingerprint Photo Vehicle Data Disposition
CORPORATION DATA

74 Contractor Number 75 FED SERV/PROD 76 Corporation Name 77 Corp Address 78 Corp City 79 Corp State 80 Corp CTY 81 Corp Zip Code 82 Contract Number NOTF,S
`51-1 "3
¦....NAkor "' (..)° . -•
Cellular Phone Number:
CID Form 44-R (Automated) Edition of 1 Aug 87 will be used until exhausted

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY, EXhiDit
023633 ues
DOD-049194

outs-(4 -ck0 ir.2.
DATA REQUIRED BY. THE PRIVACY ACT

fttie 10. United States Code, Section 3012(g)..ROUTINE USES: Your sod& security number and other personal information are used as an
AUTHORITY:
additional /alternate means of idenbficallon to %allele filing and retrieval.

PRINCIPAL PURPOSE To provide commanders and lab/ enforcement officials with.DISCLOSURE.Disclosure or your sadal security number Is voluntary_ means by which InformatIcn may be accureta4y YEAR UNIT.ROI NUMBER RM. TO CASE
DATE SUBMITTED SEQUENCE NUMBER.
04. 025

NAME GRADE RANKMIDDLE NAM
CS
POB-COUNTYOTHER ID NUMBER . POO-STATE DECEASED

PHYSICAL Wars I TATIOS
MAIDEN NAME. ALIAS-NICKNAME
MOB MACON SECURITY ETS. BASD . PCS / DEROS . INDUSTRY
(DI
UNIT f ORGANIZATION
-$11T¦ei.c-­c=t UNIT PHONE NUMBER ADDTINAL UNIT INFORMATION INSTALLATION . STATE COUNTRY ZIP CODE/APO
LOC e-+ AL HOME RHONE NUMBER . CITY STATE COUNTRY ZIP CODE / APO
el
PHONE NUMBER CITY: COUNTRY ZIP CODE /APO

SPONSOR'S GRADE I RANK SPONSOR'S alscom FAMILY RELATION JUVENILE PRIOR RECORD UNIT PHONE NUMBER. SPONSORS INSTALLATION . STATE ZIP CODE APO SPONSOR'S LOCAL ADDRESS. HOME PHONE NUMBER SPONSORS CITY
STATE ZIP CODE / API? ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
OFFENSE CODE.DESCRIPTION. '. UFC.OFFENSE CODE.DESCRIPTION... UFC
OFFENSE CODE DESCRIPTION UFC OFFENSE CODE DESCRIPTION UFC
•,,If..4thlr.‘-tal....:LIN
START TITHE DATE • OF INTERVIEW LOCATION • F INTERVIEW ISTART) ADDITIONAL .INFORMATION
END TIME DATE & OF INTERVIEW FINGERPRINTS TAKEN PHOTO TAKEN
kitr¦?:iI.ViaggrtM71:02,1
fitTIEFT

YEAR OF VEHICLE LICENSE PLATE NUMBER & STATE DISPOSITION / REMARKS
ea•

A(1V1?Ir*
•

IF CONTRACTOR. CONTRACT NUMBER CORPORATION NAME
FED SERV / PROD NUMBER PHONE NUMBER CORPORATION ADDRESS CORPORATION NUMBER CITY STATE
COUNTRY ZIP CODE APO
¦-•
(,.r1
C"-Cr..

CID FO 44-R 20 NOV 98
10 (1)(6 —tic
14%23

0 2 3 6 3 4

DOD-049195

AUTHORITY:.Title 10, united slew Cede Salim 3012 (gY.Rourna USES: Your 106111mority number and other personal informstion Aro.used as an adifdinnallalternat..'.'
e mesas of identification •
to llsoilliate and 'Ohio!.

PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commodes* and law en.inset 0E5d:di with DLICLOSIMI: Disclosure of your social security # is voluntarymeans by Aids information maybe accundely
•.

1. Ree Code: 2. Action Code:.3.Datet.4. Rol to Cue.5. C.otarol:.6. Sequence # 7. Yon 8. Office .9. ROI #.Offense:
• . ...BSI • , ' 19. pop
•

20. Sec.21..: 22- Ethnic: 23. Height:.24. Weight.25. Mir:.26. Eye Color:.en:.Edo:.29. Prior Record: 30. bfarital: Male.e41,.unk 72.195.Brown Blue.US.14.NO.Married
31. MOS:.32. Job Description/I-ocatioin I 33. MQ I 34. Security Clr: I 35. Physical Marks/ Tattoos: .I 36. Spouse Military: .Branch:
31B20
37. AliasiNielonnec. I 38. Aliu/Nicknamer. I 39. Alias/Nicknames':
40. Unit/ Orgeniza8on: . I 41. UM Phone Number:.H.Call/Pager: 796 Mita*, Police Company, Rochester, MT
42. Military Service:.I 43. Sub Unit:.1 44. Pert/City:.45. State:.46....4 . 'p Code/APO:
48. Home Address'.. 49. Ci. 50....51. Country:.52. Zip Code/APO:
.
67. UFC: 68. Offense Code: Telephone: STS:. PCS/DEROS:. Dat*/Thns Interview START:
14 Dec 04. Data.Time:
Plaza of Interview: Date / Thais Interview END: Dean. Time: Dispogition:
74. Calegc PoIlcy
79. Year: 80. Make:. 81. Model: 82. Vehicle Style: 83.5 of Doors: 84. Color: 35. Size:
86. V.1.Nt 87. License Plate: 89. DOD Decal Number

LAST ETV TEST:
FOR fIFF17 .

CID FORM 44-8....Online vero.MX, 1999
LAW PJC=

SENS I

000gaj
0 23635
DOD-049196

DATA REQUIRED BY rarvAcy ACT AUTHORITY:.Title lk United States Code Section 3012 (g) .ROUINE USES: Your social security nUmber and other penonal information Are used as an adilitiolmi/allanvitc 112"114 ofidentification to facilitate and retrieval.
PRINCIPAL. PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with DISCLOSURE: Disclosureyourof..social se.L'UTity#.vohildity means by whisk informationmay be accurately identsfied.
1. Rae Code 2. Action Ceder.3. Date:.4. Rel to Curs.5. Control:.6. Sequence # 7. Year; & Office .9. ROI q.Offense: CID •.-
Name: Meer"
• :T¦114.

20. Sew.21. Race 22. Etlutic: 23. Height: 26. Eye Colon 27. Cifizem et Record: 30. Marital:
Male, ..Unit.72 11824H Single
31. MOS:.32. Job Description/Location: 133. Ma 1 34. 31310.Military Police Ole Physical Marl* Tear,* 14- SP__Quis militarr Yes:U No: . Branch:
37. Alias/Nicimarnee 38. Alias/Nickearnee 39. Alias/Niolcoamee:

41. Us* Phone Number, Cell/Pagan 791 Military Police Company, Rochester, MN
40. Unit/ OrPairition:
42. Wiley Service: 43. Sub Unit: 44. Fort/City: 45. Stater P Code/41'0i
32. Zip Code/APO;

53. JUVr .54, pinnly Re!:.55. Lest Nemo:,
61. Unit:

62 City.. 63. State
66, Offirkisa Coder 73. UFC:
Telephone ETS:. PCS/DERO&. Date / Tim_ e Interview START: 22 Mar 08. Dee: ".' Ti Place of interview Date crate Inh:rview END:
74. Category. 75. Type..76. Reoovered:.77. Value.78. Iawre. Policy. Yeer/Date Exp: Yee 0 No:0
79. Yam 80. Make. 8l. Model: 82. Vehicle Style: 83. t/ ofDOOM 81. Sizer
86. V.I.N: 89. DOD Decal Number:
NOTES:.
LAST HIV TEST:
CID FORM 44-R...Online version.FHTX, 1999
•FOR OFFICIAL..
n ,,,
.
v.. • ' •
L.EKE lL ntl
023636

DOD-049197

FOR OFFICE USE ONLY - LAW ENFORCEME1 —'".- SENSITIVE INVESTIGATIVE WORKSHEET
DATA REQUIRED BY PRIVACY ACT

AUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Code, Section 3012 (g) ROUTINE USES: Your social security number and other
personal information are used as an additional/alternate
means of identification to facilitate filing anctretrieyal.

PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law DISCLOSURE: DisclosUre of your social security number
enforcement officials`with means by which information may be •• is voluntari .

. .

accurately identified
1-.RPC Code 2 Action Code 3 Date Submitted 4 SEQ Number 5 Year 6 Unit 7 ROI Number 8 Rel to Case 9 Control #
03 Jim 04 0062 04 342

INDIVIDUAL DATA

10 Last Name 11 First Name 12 Middle Na 13 Grade
E-6
14 Social Security Number. 15 Othir ID NUmber 16 DO 17 POB-City 18 POB-ST 19 POB-CTY

US

20 Sex 22 Ethnic 23 Height 24 We'ght 25 Hair 26 Eye 27 Citizen 28 Edua 29 Prior Rcrd 30 Martial
21 5'6" 145 BRN BRN US N -M 31 MOS I 32 MCAC 134 Industry 35 Security , 136 Physical Marks
I 33 Position ,

31B30 I . AR SEC None,
37 Alias- Nickname(s 38 Alias- Nicknames) 139 Alias- Nickname(s)
40 Or ization 744th MP BN 42 Military SVG-04.:, - 43 Subunit 44 Fort/ City, 45 State. 46 Country 47. Zip Code/APO
..

Army__ Reserve Bethlehem PA US 18017
1
49 City 50 State 51 Country 52 Zip Code
-
US
FAMILY MEMBER DATA

53 JUV 54 Family Rel 55 Sponsor Last Name 56 Sponsor First Name 57 Sponsor Middle Name 58 Social Security Number" 59 SPON Grade 60 SPON MCAC 61 Sponsor Unit Mdress
62 SPON City 63 SPON ST 64 SPON CTY 65 SPON Zip Code/APO
OFFENSE

66 Offense Code 67 UFC 68 Offense Code 69 UFC 70 Offense Code 71 UFC 72 Offense Code 73 UFC
' 7Kr:gas
ADMINISTRATIVE DATA--. -

Tel bone ETS PCS/DEROS Date INTERV Start Time.1NTERV Start Place of Interview Start Date INTERV End Time INTERV End Fingerprint Photo Vehiele Pita Disposition
CORPORATION DATA

74 Contractor Number 75 FED SERV/PROD # 76 Corporation Name
r.

77 Corp Address 78 Corp City 79 Corp State 80 Corp CTY 81 Corp Zip Code 82 Contract Number NOTES
CID Form 44-R (Automated) Edition of 1 Aug 87 will be used until exhausted 1 Dec 87 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY- LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
U Q® L&
023637
DOD-049198
(4.-c:to 02.5
DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT

AUTHORITY: . Title 10, United States Code, Section 3012(g). ROUTINE USES: Your sodal security number and other personal information are used as an ,
-additional I climate means of IdenlificatiOn to facilitate filing and retrieval. . . .

PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: - To provide convnanders and latif enforcement officials will) -DISCLOSURE: Disclosure yoUr sodal security number Is voluntary.
means by which Information may be accurately Identified.

DATE SUBMITTED SEQUENCE NUMBER YEAR UNIT ROI NUMBER REL TO CASE
04.025 tr

(:) 2,
10C6IPAMTCTRUfa'is'
MIDDLE. NAME;

OTHER ID NUMI3ER • POB-STATE
HEIGHT HAIR COLOR EDUCATION
:t"s 6•rz \.)

MOS
k..02t3
UNIT / ORGANIZATION
V-hl t.r.-,• FCS ' 6,-("' -.
..i.

UNIT RHO NUMBER . , ADDTJNAL UNIT INFORMATIONADDTJNAL STATE
. .

tol.)e-1111111.111111 ' \'''N'O'`-.7 \:(5-1/4iNM \ (-7-¦ COCA ..'S-c..•.)e. . Qt.A.S.\ c'S
LOCAL , , DOME PHONE NUMBER . CITY . STATE ZIP CODE /APO • -• -•
caot:. V ...se.,....'cloak.c.0 '' -NLI:) ,C Q.= 0,...%6 S.--71. “.
HOME OF RECORD ADDRESS , STATE ZIP CODE / APO
ip,j 7:7 vr-.7
SPONSOR'S LAST NAME SPONSOR'S FIRST NAME SPONSOR'S MIDDLE NAME ADDTINAL INFORMATION

SPONSORS UNIT / ORGANIZATION
4..OFFENSE CODE
• :r2-DESCRIPTION UFC
..:q.AFVzattir =1. 74.1 °ANSI:1Si
START TIME DATE & OF INTERVIEW LOCATION OF INTERVIEW (START)

ADDITIONAL INTERVIEW INFORMATION

END TIME DATE & OF INTERVIEW LOCATION OF INTERVIEW (END) FINGERPRINTS TAKEN PHOTO TAKEN
r "60)k-et* , .
64.: P-7' n3'tF-77igtkn HMO
YEAR OF VEHICLE MAKE COLOR
MODEL LICENSE PLATE NUMBER & STATE DISPOSITION / REMARKS•
INA:41M)fasil

IF CONTRACTOR, CONTRACT NUMBER CORPORATION NAME FED SERV / PROD NUMBER PHONE NUMBER
CORPORATION ADDRESS CORPORATION NUMBER CITY STATE COUNTRY ZIP CODE / APO
Tt47MINVOMINVIAMMOZO 031 AVAMtaAvt,agervmakt,
CID FORM 44-R
20 NOY 98 00 33
)0(?)
023638
DOD-049199

. DATA REQUIRED BY PRIVACY AcF
Title 10, United States Code Secti3012 (g)

ROUTINE USES: Your social security number and other personal information Are used as an additionallalternate means of identification to facilitate and retrieval.

PRINCIPAL PIJR.YOSE: . To provide (*tsunami= and kw enforeement officials with DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security # is voluntary
•.
. meant by which infbnnagen may be ammateiY identified.
I, Rec Code: 7. Action Codec.3. Date:.4. Rol to Case:.5. Control: 6. Sequel 7. Year: 8. Office 9. ROI # Offense:
-CID

20. Se= I 21. Race: 1 22. Ethnic:23. Height.2424. Weight:.26. Eye Color:
I. 28. Edu :.29. Prior Record: 1 30. Marital:
1 40 1 195.
Male ' le pa 72 . 1 Brown Blue 14.NO.I Married
31. MOS:.32. Job Description/Location: 33. MC: 34. Security an 31:Physical Marks/ Tattoos: 36. Spouse Military:.Branch:
I

31B20 .lvfilitery Police. Secret . .' Yetc0 No:EI
I

37. Alias/Islickname,s: 38. Aliss/Nicknitmetc 39. Alias/Nicknames:
40. Unit/ Organization:. 41. Unit Phone Number:
79th Military Police Company, Rochester, Mti.

42. Military Service: 44. Fort/City:.41 State: 47. Zip Code/APO;
51. Coinitly:

.
. ;
. ".

53. JUV: 55. Leat Maw . 56. First Mem 57. Middle Name:
60. MC: 61. Unit:

62. City:. 63. State: 64. ZIP/APO:. 65. Phone:
66. Offense Code: 67. UFC: 68. Werke co* 69. UFC: 70. Offer-tie Code: 72. Offense Coda: 73. UFC:
Telephone: ETS: PCS/DEROS:. Date / Time Interview START:
14 Dec 04 Date:. Thins
Place of Interview:

Disposition:'
75..:--Policy: Year/Date Exp: /
79. Year: 80. Make: 81. Model; 82. Vehicle Style: 83. # of Doors: 84, Color: 85. Size:
86. V.IN: 87. License Plate: 88. State: 89. DOD Decal Number:
NOTES:
LAST HIV TEST:
FOR OFF In.

CID FORM 44-R-Online version FHTX, 1999
r.
LAW E.s.!FCC:::. SENS I ; ,
c„c
023639
0 U 3
DOD-049200
DATA REQUIRED BY PRIVACY AarAUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Code Section 3012 (g) .ROUTINE USES: Your :social security number and other personal information

•.
Are used as an additional/altemate means of identification' to facilitate and retrieval.

PRINCIPAL 'PURPOSE: ,.,
To provide commanders and law enforcement officialswith DISCLOSURE: DiscloSura of your social security
,..
_ ii is voluntarymeans by which information may be accurately identified..

1. Rec Cod.2. Act.ion Code:.3. Date: .4. Rai to Cue:.5. Control:.6. Sequence #
13. Orade/Ranle
E4/SPC

Number,.15. Other ID l& P013 Se 19. POB Zip:
l

20. Sex: ..21. Race:.22. Made: 23. freight:.24. Weight i .25. Hair..26. Eye Color: 27. Citizen: 2& Ecluo:.
Male. 29. Prior Record: 30. Marital:
72.175.Brown Hazel.US
31. MOS:.32. Job Description/Location: 33. MC: 1 12/HS.NO.Single
34. Security Cir: I 35. Physical Marla/ Tattoos: I 36. Spouse Military:.

31B10.Mildary Police Secret.... . Branch:
I Yes:f;f No:0

37. AliasNicknamec.
38. Alia.siNicknameri:
I 39. Alias/Nicknames: Cell/Pager:

42. Military Service: 44. Fort/Cityi 45. State:
46. Country.4 p Code/APQ:
a'.51. Country:.52. Zip Code/APC):

56. First Name: 57.. Middle Nali101,
60. MC: 61. Unit:
62. City: 65. Phone:

66. Offense Code: 68. Offense Code: 69. UPC: 70. Offense Coda: 71. UFC: Telephone: ETS: .
• PCS/DEROS:
Data / Time Interview START:
.....

22 Mar 08
Time:Place of Interview:

Date! Time Interview END: Date:

Disposition:
74: Category:.-75. Type:.76. Recovered: 71- Value:.78.-Insu Policy: Year/Date Eip:•
Yes: . No:0 /

79. Year:.80. Make:. 81. Model:. 82. Vehicle Style: 83. # of Doors:.84. Color: •.85. Size:
86. V.I.N:. 87. License Plate:
88, State: 89. DOD Decal Number: NOTES:
LAST HW TEST: CII) FORM 44-R...Onllne version FHTX, 199.9 -FOR OFFa li CIAL
LAW E.". FfiRi C EKE I 11.'1111
023640 00003 5

DOD-049201

DATA REQUIRED:BY PRIVACY ACT

AUTHORITY;.Title 10, United States Code Section 3012 (g) ROUTINE USES: Your social security number and other personal information
Are used as an additionelialternate means of identification to facilitate and retrieval:
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of yout social security # is voiuntary
6. Sequence # Offense;

••dal S
IshoOen.:
19. FOB Zip:

20. ex:...:.22. Ethnic: 23. Height.24. Weight:.
26. Eye Color: 27, Citizen:

Male.041/.LTnk.71.29. Prior Record:
210.Blonde Blue.
US NO

31..MOS:.32. Job Description/location: 33. MC: .
34. Security Clr: 1 35 Physical Marks/ Tattobs:

31/310.I Military Police.I I.Secret...I 36. Spouse Military:
... .
Yes:0 No:0

37. Alias/Nicknames:. 38. Alias/Nieto:nines: 39. Alias/Nicknames:
40. Unit/ Organization:
79l Military Police Company, Rochester, MN

42. Military Service:.I 43. Sub Unit:
44. Fort/City: 45. Stale:.
.

48. Home Address 49:
so.51. Coimtry: 52. Zip Code/APO:
•„

53.
JUV:.

54.
Family Rah.55, Last Nadia:. 56. First Name:

57. Middle Name:

58. Social Security: sp. Oracle/Rada
60. MC:

.I 1
62. City: .
63. State: 64. ZIP/APO:
65. Phone:.Wk:
Hrn:

' • ,
,,,,,, ,,
, „ , • „„

66. Offense Code:.67. UFC:.68. Offense Code:.69. UPC:.
70. Offense Code:.'71. LIFC:.72. Offense Code:
73. UFC: •. ,Telephone:

EPS:
PCS/DEROS:. '
Data Prime Interview START:
•

26 Aug 04
Place of Interview: Time:

Date:
Date / Time Interview END: Date:

Disposition: Time:
45X.F";,;,?

74. Category:.• 75. Type:.
76. Reoavered:.77. Value: ..78. Insurer: Policy:
Yes:. No:0 Year/Date Exp:

79. Year: .80. Make: 81. Model: 82. Veluc e Style:.83. # of Doors: •84. Color:
SS. Size:

86. V.1.N:
87.•License Plata: 188. State:.
189. DOD Decal Number:

NOTES:
LAST HIV TEST: Cl)) FORM 44-R.-Online version FHTX, 1999 • FOR , OFF4C.IC 14 _ •.•.ti ll I.LAW EvFORCEERT SENSITIvE CA4/ 1
023841 00003 6

DOD-049202

DATA REQUIRED BY PRIVACY ACT

'

AUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Code, 3012 (g) ROUTINE USES: Your social security number and other
personal information are used as an additional/alternate
means of identification to facilitate filing and fetrieval.

PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and laW DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number
enfcircement officials with means by which information may be .. Is voluntary
accurately identified
1 REC Code 2 Action Code 3 Date Submitted. 4 SEQ Nutnber 5 Year 6 Unit 7 ROI Ntifnber . Rel to Case 9 Control #
A4
INDIVIDUAL DATA •

11.First 5 Other ID Nu 23 Height, 24 Wei 6 Eye 8 Eduo 29 Prior Rad 30 Martial

Alm/N. 5'10' 188 1
31 MOS 32 MCAC 33 Position 34 Industry r35 Security 36 Physical Marks
tikoSdoAr
Pea IAi e lower loot1-

77 A
T A1iaT 39 Alias- Nickname(s) VtiVeArN.ted't erte4
40 Organization 41 If Contractor, Contract #
\)-coNeVer Skesk 1-)IrM3rkacktea eekkVer
42 Military SV. ., 44 Force-t..ity t45 State-.. 46 COUn ry -47 Zip Code/APO,
`,.
V.13-51\ x036°1
ATA

53 MY, 54 Family Rel 55 Sponsor Last Name 56 Sponsor First Name . 57 Sponsor Middle Name 58 Social Security Number 59 SPON Grade 60 SPON MCAC 61 Sponsor Unit Address
1

62 SPON City 63 SPON ST 64 SPON CTY 65 SPON Zip Code/APO
OFFENSE

66 Offense Code 67 UFC 68 Offense Code 69 UFC 70 Offense Code 71 UFC 72 Offense Code 73 UFC
ADMINISTRATIVE DATA

Telepho e # PCS/DEROS Date INTERV Start Time INTERV Start ace n erview tart Date INTERV End Time INTERV End Place of Interview End Fingerprint Photo Vehicle Data Disposition
CORPORATION DATA

74 Contractor Number 75 FED SERV/PROD # 76 Corporation Name
77 Corp AddreSt 78 Corp City 79 Corp State • 8.0 Corp CIY -81 Corp Zip Code
82 Contract NuMber
NOTFS
ocfc-e. 19( wo‘
woad,
023'642
Cellular Phone Number.. 11111111111Pliik ed until exhaustedCID Form 444t(AtiMitiated) U 0037
foR OFFICIAL USE °r ay bibtt

DOD-049203

.

Sent: Saturday, September 17, 2005 1:24 PM
To pt MNC-I OSJA Trial Counsel
Subject: RE: [U10020-05-CID259-80138 (2D Final Supplemental) 48th MP Det CID
Camp Slayer

Categories:. NOFORN, NOFOIRN, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY, FOR OFFICIAL USE
ONLY, UNCLASSIFIED, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

Classification Caveat:.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(,) (6-z

Classification Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Got it Sir. Thank you I will put this in the file as the report has already gone out but the record of this email will be stored with the report at the US Army Crime Records Center. Thank you for all the excellent support that you, your peers and the SJA has always provided me and mine throughout my 17 years in the CID and the Army. Be safe.
CW3, Mid. Butacinnent Commander 48th MP D t DSN 31
_tb7.arfor. armv.mil
slayer.irati.artny.smil.rnil
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Froth. pt MNC-I OSJA Trial Counsel [mailto1.111111@iraq.centcom.smil.mil ] Sent: Saturda September 17, 2005 10:44 AM TO.CW3
i.113ject: RE: U] 0020-05-CID259-80138 (2D Final Supplemental) 48th MP Det CID Camp Slayer
CVV31111111
Good morning. I'm not sure if this has been sent forward, or not, but as to my opine: if possible, I was unable to substantiate any criminal offense...there may have been some piece of evidence within the file, but weighed against the other, no criminal' conduct could be substantiated.
Thanks for all you folks are doing.
From: CW3 [mailtoi slayer.iraq.army.smil.mil ]
Sent: Friday, September 16 2005 :0
To:. W3; SFC; 5 - USAG; G CW4 MNC-I 11th MP
BN ; CDR ); SFC MNC-I S3 Operations Special Agent;
USACIDC (Chief Investic ative 0 erations); USA Cie Investigative 0 erations); USACIDC (DCSOPS);

USACRC (Director); COL. MNC-I PMO Provost Marshal. P MA] MNC-I SJA CH
Military Justice; it MNC-I OSJA Trial Counsel; F-I TF 134 Det Ops

023643 cm

9/17/2005 U3
DOD-049204

Subject: [U] 0020-05-CID259-80138 (2D Final. Supplerhental) 48th MP Det CID Camp Slayer
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
CVV3, Detachment ComMander 48th MP Det CID DSN 31
rfor.arrhy.rnil
slayer.iraq.army.smil.mil

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
023644 9/17/2005 0 0 0 3 9
DOD-049205
e., W2 1111Nd-ItIE)

• From:. yahoo.com] •-
Sent 1 TueSsdey, MAy at 43054T:68 PM
- 4 '
s
,cwzmNic-1 CID Special Agent

ToP'1111111111t ' - ' '
Cc: .. CW2 MNIC-I CID
Subject: Fie: [U] Autopsy Report Need' d

Dear Sir:
I went through the Autopsies during Feb2004,The report of
is available under serial nuinberMIMon Feb.26/20 0 case was referred to fibril

ming

AljUaifir police station on 18/2/2004,
I need some &Jcf§ frov. your girp...to come to the MLI which is very close to the MOH,or to arrange
some thhkg 4,1040 the Anierican'AdiiiSOrs talth0:1\401-1 to get the report in order to give it to you

4 1

Best regFcl.s,,
MD,D1VIS path, pfm&FI 4
MAI T61. .CID SAdatAkent 11,1111111kirdq.centcom.mil wrote:
-.

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFICIAL USE ONLY
•

29 May 05, 1445
DYNE' ,
As I mentioned on the phone, I met you in FebrUary 2005, when 6 autopsies were performed at the
.

- ‘.
131AP, by Postors.filom the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology. I was one of the investigators at the
„.. . i

scene leading the'nvestigation.
' I am requesting the Final Autopsy Examination 'lleport for
in I'm requiring Our seryices. ; age 657Thit autopsy was possibly perfOrmed in February 2004, by
`:-Ti
,.,
)

Your assistance in this matter will be greatl4 y appreciated. I will call you again toporrow. Thank you
Special Agent

.

N. 8 Teanchief
lit cs.
48th MP Det. op

-, '., A -, t,
APO AE 09342
DaN 318
Tracrcentcom:rnil_,

. • t

Claseification: UNCLASSIPIEDHFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
If this e-mail is marked FOR OFFJCIAL USE ONLY it may be exempt from mandatory
disclosure under FOIA. DoD 5400.7K"DolYllieedom of Information Act Program", DoD
Directive 5230.9, "Clearance of DoD Information for Public Release", and DoD Instruction
5230.29, "Security and Policy Review of DoD Information for Public Release" apply.

023645

5/31/2005 0 0 0 0 4
DOD-049206

IN2 MNC-1 C113 Special Agent
From: 111111abol.Corn
Sent-: Tuesday, June 07, 2005 5 59 PM
To MNC4 CID Special Agent
Subject Re: [U] FW: Review of Translated Autopsy Examination Report
Arrive agrarri last night. You have to wait in line for 30 internet aCcesS. here. I'll review
. .
and return ASAP. Take Cate.
Message -
Fro • CW2 MNC-I CID Special Agent 1111111111111.irati.centcom.rnil:
To: ao .coni

centcOM.M11111111111111111111FCVV3 MNC-I 48th MP 1$0E Detachment commander © Ira (4.00 ntcom : MI Sent: Su-n, uri 2005 11:41:01 +0400
. • -,
Subject: [U] FW: Review of translated Autopsy ExaMination Report
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
5 June 2005-,

•,

br.11111111-:
Here are the trarislatianS On the Final Autopsy ExaMinatiOn Repart and the RedUest through the Judge for an
Autopsy. Please review and correct any errOrS, word structure, or medical terminology you deem nedessaty.
Sorry for the delay, I just obtained the documents this morning I understand that you are traveling today to
Afghanistan, so I don?t expect you to complete or review the tranSlatiOn today, but when you get settled in, please
take a look and then email back. Thank you sir for your help and have a safe trip:
SA111.111 Team Chief
•
11th MP BN CID 48th MP Det. CID Apo AE 9342

•
DSN 318

bm.mil
• Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
If this e-mail is marked FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY it may be exempt from mandatory disclosure under FOIA. DoD 5400.7R, ?DoD Freedom of Information At Program?, DoD Directive 5230.9, ?
• Clearance of DoD Information for Public Release?, and DOD Instruction 5230.29, ?SeCUrity and
Policy Review of DoD Information far Public Release? apply:

From:. CIV MNC-I 48th Linguist - CAT II
Sent: Saturday, June 04, 005 10:34 PM
TO:.CW2 MNC-I CID Special Agent
Subject
023G46
00004 1

6/7/2005
DOD-049207
Page 1 of 1

CVV21V1N,C71C9SpecialAgent• -. • . .-
From M CW2 MNC-I CID Special Agent
Sent: Sunday, May 29, 2005 4:04 AM
To:
Subject:. [U] Autopsy Report Needed
Categories:. UNCLASSIFIED, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Classification Caveat:.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Classification Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
29 May 05, 1445
As I mentioned on the phone, I met you in February 2005, wheh 6 autbpsies were performed at the BIAP, by Doctors from the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology. I was one of the investigators at the scene leading the investigation, •
Oncewain I'm requiring your services. I am requesting the Final Autopsy Examination Report fo
Your assistande in this matter will be greatly appreciated. I will call you again tomorrow. Thank yoU, Special
Ag en' • .

8,4igniTeam Chief
•
I1thMPBNCID. --48th MP Det. CID APO AE. 1/ (3) -01

•
DSN 318

iraq.centcorn.mil
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY If this e-mail is marked FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY it may be exempt from mandatory disclosure under FOIA. DoD 5400.7R, "DoD Freedom of Information Act Program", DoD Directive 5230.9, "Clearance of DoD Information, for Public Release", and DoD Instruction 5230.29, "Security and Policy Review of DoD Information for Public Release" apply.
•
023047
000042

5/29/2005
DOD-049208
Page 1 of 1
•
„.

W2 MNC-I CID Special Agent .
From:. CW2 MNC:l CID Special Agent
Sent:. Sunday May 29,2005 4:04 AM
To:
Subject:. [U] Autopsy Report Needed
Categories:. UNCLASSIFIED, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Classification Caveat:.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Classification Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
29 r¦.¦ty.05, 1445
Dr.
AsIl mentioned on the phone, I met you in February 2005, when 6 autopsies Were perforrned at the-BIAP, by Doctors from the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology. I was one of the investigators at the scene leading the
•
investigation.
Once a ain 1-rn requiring your services. I am requesting the Final Autopsy Examination Report for
age 65. This autopsy was possibly performed in February 2004, by Dr

. -
Your assistance in this matter will be greatly appreciated. I will call you again tomorrow. Thank you, Special
Ageni

Team Chief
(1) (C)

11th M.
ID

1\ (c)
48th MP Pet. CID
APO AE
DSN 318

iraq.centcorn.mil
Classification; UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
If this e-mail is marked FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY it may be exempt from mandatory disclosure under FOI.A. Do]) 5400.7R, "DoD Freedom of Information Act Program", DoD Directive 5230.9, "Clearance of DoD Information for Public Release", and DoD Instruction 5230.29, "Security and Policy Review of DoD Information for Public Release" apply.
r 2 3 C 4 3
0 1J0t343

5/29/2005
DOD-049209

$A .AgPot.... • .
From W2 MNC-I CID
Sent: h 28, 2005 2:24 PM
To: A MNC-1 CID Special Agent
Subject: ase 4-CID259 Follow-up: Article

From• CW3 MNC-I 48th MP BDB Detachment commander Sent: s.t64-26, 2005 12:45 AM TC: W2 MNC-I CID
Subject: FW: ase 04-CID259 Follow-up: Article

-

Illi read below. Lets see if we can find the autopsy report if it get it
We Cando a sup to attach it

Commanding
48th MP Det CID
Camp :victory, Baghdad, Iraq .
APO
DSN

itaq.centcom.mil

ihal Message­G CW4 MNC-I 11th MP BN (CID) S-3 OBS
h 25, 2005 9:05 PM
CW4 - 3d MP Group (CID); K'CW3 MNC7I S-3 INTELLIGENCE

WOLMNC-I. S T CW2 MNC-I
-I 48th MP BIDE D tachment commande

1 0W3 CW4; CW5;
Group;

Subject; .RE: Case 0020-04.-CID259 Follow-uP: Article

Have directed CW3-to make contact with Baghdad ME (Dr-and locate
the doctor cited to obtain a oopy of his autopsy report and rIelil if it in
fact exista,

CW4, MP
Operations Officer

11th. MP Bn (CID)
Camp Victoty, Baghdad, Iraq
APO AE 09342

DSN: 318
NIPR: iraq,centcom.mil
SIPR: xra
Iragna Cell:

-0 e­From: CW4 - 3d MP Group (CID) [mailto.1111111111.forscom.-army.mil] Sen ch 25, 2005 4:00 PM To: CW4 MNCzI 11th MP BN CID) S-3 OPS;-CW3 MNC-I S-3 INTELLIGE INATOR;-1 MNC-eci Cc:-' (G CW3; CW4; ­
MA CW5; MSG;. CW5 ; Group;
02364 9 000044
.
DOD-049210

•

3d MP Group
Subject: FR: Case 0020-04-C1025.5 Follow-up Article
Importance: Low.'

11th OPN5: O.:Pry and request as received fro% Mr.

•

From:-[mailto: belvoir.army.mil ]

Sent- -- a

' , •

To: CW3 - 3d MP Group (CID)';

IIIIIIIIIIIII,

E. - rou
Cc:-W5;-CW3;
Subject: ase--uP: Artie e

0-04--
ImPortance: Low -

•

-3A MP Gp,, if. Iraq is not already doing it, can you please have them do follow-uP with Dr
of Iraq's Forensic Medical Institute in Baghdad to obtain a copy of the
auto-he did for the family (see article below), Instrtct them to re-open the
Oase, to do the wOrk...-he Old. in fact die from blunt force trauma, there may be a

-need for more investigative work.

•
• • [I) tc)-+.
02:3650 000045
DOD-049211

English Translation:
WiMhetcl..
Foreign Language
Photosdepicting Americans

,

Photos depicting foreign nationals CivilianAgency Records
.

A-udio/Video depicting foreign nationals and Americans
023651
DOD-049212

From: W2 MNC-I CID
Sent: Wednesday, May 25, 2005 1:18 AM 143)(6-1'
To .e

yahoo corr
Cc: W3MNIC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander(')( C
Subject: Request fOr information

4

it7 (1)(4. My name is. Special Agent from the Camp Victory Criminal Investigation Office, We met
.

several months ago at the Airport during some autopsies. am writingagain to request your assistance in finding and obtaining an autopsy report prepared by D
I the Iraq Forensic Medical Institute, Baghdad. The autopsy was conducted sometime in Febuary or March 2004 and was on Mr. Any assistance you can provide on this matter would be appreciated as this is a time sensitive matter. Thank_you,
SA Camp VictoCID Iragna Cell .
5/25/2005

:023654
000049
DOD-049213

111111111111111FW3.114K71 48th MI" 012. Pet01101.014 commander
From CW3 b61Vbit.'arrty,rhili 5(414 —1----sent imaniv ay 24, 200 .16 PM . . To G CW4 MN1C-1 11th MF BN (CID) S-3 OPS1111111111111111W3 MNC-I 48th MP
e achment commander

Subject FW: Case 00213-04-CID259 Follow-up: Article
Iniportarite: LoW
Here's the information ebollt the Iraqi doctor.

-•

Ori•
From:
Sent: -40 AM
To:
(CI up
Cc:-CW5; CW3;
Subjeot. ase 020-04-ow-up: Ar

. Importance:­
Low

,

3d MP Gp, if Ira is not alreadY doing it, can you please have them do

f011ow-up with D-of Iraq's Forensic Medical Institute in
Baghdad to obtain­
opy 01 t'e autopsy report he did for the family
(see article below). Instruct them to re-open the case to do the
work. And if he did in fact die froth blunt force trauma, there may be

DOD-049214

CW3 MNC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander
From: CW3 MNC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander
Sent: ay 25, 2005 5:05 PM.
To: CW3'
Subject: RE: [U] RE: Case 0020-04-CID259 Follow-up: Article

10( 071.

Categories: UNCLASSIFIED, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Classification Caveat: FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
10 MO

Classification Classification:
UNCLASSIFIED

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.

)1) (c.S

how are you? Good I hope. Sorry, I didn't have too much time to.talk'syesterday.
It is a little crazy over here case wise these dayS.

Bete is the BLUF on this thing. I did not reopen this thing.back when I got this in March. I don't knoW why? I guess I miss illIllsentence that told us too. , Anyway, we'ate reopening it today, I remember having one'IT=T-act our liaison ME to find out if he would contactor get us in touch wit Dr of Iraq's Forensic Medical Institute -to find out. The liaison ME, Dr go ac to us and there was apparently no autopsy done. But,. like I said before,­
wan_ to double chebk this and make sure and alSO (4(5 it officially. We are sendin a 3rd Supplemental to reopen this and get'it dope, We have already tried to contact Dr, UMagain. More to follow. This is my 4.'Upi,
-
sorry. I'll take the hit fOr,it,

11111 •­
.
PS What is your DSN at Command.. I called old onelgillibut no one anSwered,

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
CW MP

Commanding
48th MP Det CID
Camp Victory, Baghdad, Iraq

APO

DSN

@itaq.centcom.mil

From: W3 [mailtopplikelvoir.army.mil]
Sent , 5, 2005 4:2­
M.
To: W3 MNC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander
Subject: RE: : Case 0020-04-CID259 Follow-up: Article

a I still need an answer on this as I asked the media to hold off on providing a
response until I heard something back from you.
Was your Dr111111pright or did this other guy at the institute do one?
Thanks much.

S . 1 Messa•e
From: CW3.
Sent­ , 2005 10:23 AM
To: CW3 MNC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander'
Subjec Case 0020-04.-CID259 Follow-up: Article 023054

In the mean this case closed? I know we re-opened and sent out supplemental but
I don't have a 'final supplemental (would be about the 3rd or 4th final supplemental).

1 000051
DOD-049215

-inal Messa

Or].
From: CW3 MNC-I 48th MP BDE Detachment commander
[mailto iraq.centcoM.mil ]

Sent'

200
CW3;-CW4 MNC-I 11th MP BN (CID) S-3 OPS

To:

Subject: [U t Case• 002-ollow-up: Article

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

•
Dr.­
•-.­
is the head Forel-laid Pathologist in Iraq and initially stated an autopsy was not
done. :Let us double check. Thanks. IIII-•

.-,­

MP

Commanding

48th MP Det CID
Camp Victory, Baghdad, Iraq
APO E 09

'

DSN
iraq.centcom.mil

V.

-

Ori sinal M
From: CW3 [mailt0)1111111belvoit.army.mil]
Sen 2005 6;16­
-
To: W4 MNCI 11th M0 (CID) S-3 OPS;

-

CW3 MN-BDE Detachment commander
Subject: FW: Case 0020=04-cID259 Follow-up: Article
Importance: Low

Here's the information about the Iraqi doctor.

V -Ori -ital,MesSage7:7
From:
Sent -0 AM

To -CW3 - 3d MP Group .
(CI

. Cc:-W5';-W3;
Subject: Case-20-0-.w-up: Article
Importance:­
Low
•
3d Nit? Gp, if Iraq is not already doing it, can you.please have them do

follow-up with Dr-of Iraq's Forensic.Medical Institute in

• Baghdad to obtain a Copyo the autopsy report he did for the family
(see article below). Instruct them to re-open the case to do the
work. And if he did. in fact die from blunt force trauma, there may be

•-

a need fot-mOre investigative work.

-,

Original Message-
From:
Sent:-- 2005 3)12 E'M

,

Thursday, Iviarcnz

• -COL CIDC G3;

To 111111111111 CW5';

CW5­ Subject: Article
Importance:­
Low

March, 24, 2005 Thursday 1:59 PM Eastern Time

02 655

SECTION: INTERNATIONAL NEWS

LENGTH: 957 words

2 0 0005'2
DOD-049216