CID Report (Death): 0007-04-CID259-80133

Error message

  • Deprecated function: Return type of DBObject::current() should either be compatible with Iterator::current(): mixed, or the #[\ReturnTypeWillChange] attribute should be used to temporarily suppress the notice in require_once() (line 7 of /usr/home/documentafterliv/public_html/sites/all/modules/contrib/eck/eck.classes.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Return type of DBObject::next() should either be compatible with Iterator::next(): void, or the #[\ReturnTypeWillChange] attribute should be used to temporarily suppress the notice in require_once() (line 7 of /usr/home/documentafterliv/public_html/sites/all/modules/contrib/eck/eck.classes.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Return type of DBObject::key() should either be compatible with Iterator::key(): mixed, or the #[\ReturnTypeWillChange] attribute should be used to temporarily suppress the notice in require_once() (line 7 of /usr/home/documentafterliv/public_html/sites/all/modules/contrib/eck/eck.classes.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Return type of DBObject::valid() should either be compatible with Iterator::valid(): bool, or the #[\ReturnTypeWillChange] attribute should be used to temporarily suppress the notice in require_once() (line 7 of /usr/home/documentafterliv/public_html/sites/all/modules/contrib/eck/eck.classes.inc).
  • Deprecated function: Return type of DBObject::rewind() should either be compatible with Iterator::rewind(): void, or the #[\ReturnTypeWillChange] attribute should be used to temporarily suppress the notice in require_once() (line 7 of /usr/home/documentafterliv/public_html/sites/all/modules/contrib/eck/eck.classes.inc).

CID report of investigation into the death of Nasef Ibraham, a detainee at Abu Ghraib prison. According to the report, Mr. Ibraham was brought unconscious to one of the guard stations at Camp Ganci at the prison by his relatives. The military police stationed there notified medics who found Mr. Ibraham non-responsive and unconscious. They checked for vital signs with negative results. His pupils were fixed and dilated; no brachial or carotid pulse was detected. CPR was not initiated. The autopsy did not find any signs of trauma, bruising or other wounds. The report concluded that Mr. Ibraham died of natural causes (cardiac tamponade as a result of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease).

Doc_type: 
Investigative File
Doc_date: 
Monday, August 23, 2004
Doc_rel_date: 
Sunday, November 7, 2004
Doc_text: 

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
78TH MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID) (FWD)
3 RD MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID)
BAGHDAD, IZ APO AE 09342

CIMPR-FR 23 AUG 2004
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION FINAL SUPPLEMENTAL /SSI REPORT-0007-04-C1D259-80133-5H9A
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1. 8 JANUARY 2004/1554 — 8 JANUARY 2004/1600 HRS; COMPOUND THREE, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 8 JANUARY 2004, 2004 HRS
INVESTIGATED BY: SA /26 -/ SA
-
2., SA 7C—/ e6-1 h 2-, SA 7C--0 2--
SUBJECT: 1. (NONE); [NATURAL DEATH]
VICTIM: 1. IBRAHIM, NASEF JASEM (DECEASED); CIV; 1 JAN 41; M; OTHER; COMPOUND THREE, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ; XZ (NFI)[NATURAL DEATH].
INVESTIGATION SUMMARY:
This is an "Operation Iraqi Freedom" investigation.
This office received a serious incident report from the 10 th Military Police Battalion (CID) (ABN) (FWD), Baghdad, Iraq regarding the death of a prisoner at the Abu Ghurayb Prison, Iraq.
On 23 Aug 04, this office received the Final Autopsy Report #ME 04-12, 18 Feb 2004, pertaining to Mr. IBRAHIM, which revealed Mr. IBRAHIM's Cause of Death as Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease resulting in Cardiac Tamponade and the Manner of Death as Natural. This report did not change the outcome of this investigation.
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
01443
Page(s)

Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101
MS. JACQUELINE SCOTT scottj@centcom.smil.mil

(813) 827-5341/2830
7e-NO2 12THMP CID DET
t41111111•1111MINI
*--(4
CPT CJTF7-3RD MP CID
From: 1()14 Sent: Thursday. January 08, 2004 7:53 PM 102 12THMP CID DET
To:
Subject: FW: (U) SIR - Prisoner Death

FYI
7e -1 1 )90-1
CPT, MP S2/S3, 10th MP BN (CID)(ABN) DNVT 584• DSN 318-453-
1Original Message From:17C--/ I 6%4 SSG CTTF7-CID NCO Sent:tThursday, January 08, 2004 8:51 AM LTC (101}I MP CID BN CDR);To:t7C-fi 1 1 CW3 CJTF7-A0Pc•1 CW4 CJTF7-OPS; rW4 10TH MP BN LOGSEC; —,,c .r ...,/ ./ 7/CW5 CJTF7-Field Ops. Officer;1/ h , CW2 CJTF7-FSO;1.... 1:PT CITF7-3RD MP CID; 1f / ."'" 1
MA]1CJTF7-3rd MP (CID) 53:1-iio1e-/ CPT CJTF7-CID LNO; /1Maj (10TH MP BN CID XO);1FC OTF7-BN OPS NCO1 Subject:tFW: (U) SIR - Prisoner Death
All, FYI
SSG 704/ 1,0-/
Classification UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SIR 083AN04 ›risoner Death.doc..
(
.1
5
1

756 V WO2 12THMP CIU DET
16;4, bb
/2 " --1 '02 12THMP CID DET
From:
Thursday, January 08, 2004 8:04 PM
Sent: To: (PIT) (CID) "CW2 1/7 b6-/ -FW: (U) SIR - Prisoner Death „Thv
Subject:
.•(,)\\-1-
1601:;--1
on this telephonically for now, but can you take a look into the particulars of the death scene, if any? Really, all
I'll get guys
Ils like anything suspicious. Our guidance in non-suspicious prisoner deathsI need is the death scene se • es "if' it s 1(ie. cardiac arrest) is to repo "t SSI Only. hanks.
r\\)¦-vN
CJA.I¦kl-) 1)
Original Message 1
/1j190 -t/ :PT OTF7-3RD MP CID

From:
Thursday. January 08, 2004 7:53 PM \C° -

Sent:
7C-(1, 174.-I/ '02 1211-1MP CID DET

To: r4
RN: (U) SIR - Prisoner Death

Subject:

FYI \N\ N 'C)N
104, /
CPT, MP

52/S3, 10th MP BN (CID)(ABN)
DNVT 584.
DSN 318-453•

1Original Message
7C.-41, /A' SI" 'SG CJTF7-CID NCO

From:t
Thursday. January 08, 2004 8:51 AM
Sent:t.TC (10TH MP CID BN CDR):
CW4 OTF7-OPS:
-7e..-414,4it-CW3 CJTF7-A0Pc•
To:t CW2 OTF7-FSO; Thf/ .:W4 10TH MP BN LOGSEC;
CW5 CJTF7-Field Ops. Officer; dr/ CPT CJTF7-3RD MP CID;
CPT OTF7-CID LNO;
MA) OTF7-3rd MP (CID) SrA•
;FC OTF7-BN OPS NCO

Maj (10TH MP BN CID XO);
AN: (U) SIR - Prisoner Death

Subject:t
All,
FYI.

SSG 1C--46 b44-
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SIR 08JAN04
'risoner Death.doc..

414:),
1
011 -A,-;

W02 I2THMP CID DET

-

(PIT) (CID) --/C4/ 6 -/ Sus.army.smil.mil] CW2 1C,-/ /0 -1
From:
Friday, January 09, 2004 4:51 PMSent: 7C-(4 is :--'I V012 12THMP CID DET' To: -
Detainee Death AIR
Subject:
AIR-Death.doc
W-q, loh-y

Here is the AIR we did concerning the detainee that died on 8 Jan 04. We
did not obtain swrn ttements from any involved. From all accounts, it

o wass aa natural death (Heart Attack). If you need anything
appears that this
else, just let me know.

SA /c4
ut;l. 1 3 01475
WO2 12THMP CID DET

System Administrator [postmaster@SBELVOIRDMS.ARMY.SMILMIL]From:
Friday. January 09, 2004 7:26 PM
Sent: 1
/ivvDc5main.hq.c5.army.smil.miTo: Delivered: 0007-04-CID259-80133 DETAINEE UNDETERMINED MANNER OF D EATH Subject:
0007-04-CID259 -80 133 DETAINEE... 0007-04-CID259-80133 DETAINEE UNDETERMINED MANNER OF DEATH Your message
E-mail); le-iabv-/ CW4 CJTF7-OPS

'CW3 .--/c_j ;,,

(PI (CID) (E-mail) (E-mail); 7c-iihd'5CM-PMO'

To:

o:

(E-mail); ATTN: CW3 / tit",

. 'CID001 USACIDC CAC

(E-mail); 'CID DCSOPS OPS1(s)' (E-mail);_

E-mail)

7(.1 I i M,OfA-74----//kx,-/A

BELVOIR(sc)' (E-mail); Cid001crcsc (E-mail) CPT

1/1ii:-/ MAJ CJTF7-SJA OPERATIONAL

-7(1,—Iik" e-mail); -X­
le-4 11.2WW3 CJTF7-AOPS -ii k i/

WS CJTF7-Field Ops. Officer 7C

E-mail); /0-1/t

LAW ATTORNEY :144 10TH MP BN LOGSEC
(L,I, //Q.' (E-mail); /600-/Aill (1AD PM())

(E-mail); -1 LTC r7C-­
3SG CJTF7-CID NCO;

k76-1

(E-mail); -7C6A
:.1,14 CJTF7-OPERATIONS McCalister (E-mail); SAC

(E-mail);

:W3 CJTF7-CID OPS Officer

7C-1/196-/

(E-mail);

Subject: 0007-04-CID259-80133 DETAINEE UNDETERMINED MANNER OF DEATH
Fri, 9 Jan 2004 16:36:19 -0000

Sent:

was delivered to the following recipient(s):

CID001 DCSOPS OPS2(sc) on Fri, 9 Jan 2004 1.6:26:04 -0000
LVOIRDMS:KSHCHLO8

MSEXCH:MSExchangeMTA:SBE

CID DCSOPS OPS1(s) on Fri, 9 Jan 2004 1.6:26:04 --0000
LVOIRDMS:KSHCHLO8

MSEXCH:MSExchangeMTA:SBE

C1D001 USACIDC CAC BELVOIR(sc) on Fri, 9 Jan 2004 16:26:04 -0000
ELVOIRDMS:KSHCHLO8

MSEXCH:MSExchangeMTA:SB
CID001 CRC(sc) on Fri, 9 Jan 2004 16:26:04 -0000

ELVOIRDMS:KSHCHLO8

MSEXCH:MSExchangeMTA:SB

4;

014'
8112C4E8@c5mainexch3.c5main.hg.75.army.smil.mi1

Message-id:

C950ABFC2CCA9645AE62COA8 50DC4 F
M1ME-version: 1.0

(5.5.2657.721

X-Mailer: Internet Mail Service doc"

Content-type: application/msword; name="Initial 0007-04.

Content-transfer-encoding: base64 "Initial 0007-04.doc"
Content-disposition: attachment; filename-

message has been successfully delivered to the following recipients:

t@us.army.smil.mil

Recipient address: ,JA.,t

@us.army.smil.mil

/L/ /11J'-'A

-

Original address:

: Message successfully delivered

Reason @us.armY.smil.mi l

v „,

Recipient address:
Original address:

Reason: Message successfully delivered

us.army.smil. mil
Recipient address: lus.army.smil.mil
Original address:

Reason: Message successfully delivered

0 0 0 G1A
2
W02 12THMP CID DET
Internet Mail Delivery [postmaster@us.army.smil.mil ] From: Friday, January 09, 2004 7:37 PM
Sent:
"I it9L,1 @c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil
1C-
To: Delivery Notification: Delivery has been successful
Subject:
itzrr
ATT321750.TXT ATT321751.TXT This report relates to a message you sent with the following

header fields:

1/0 @c5main.hq.c5.army.smil .mil
Return-path:

3c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil

Return-path:

hq. c5 . army. smil .mil
Delivery-receipt-to: /6-1

by

Received: from ims-ms-daemon.akosmail.us.army.smil.mil
akosmail.us.army.smil.mil

(iPlanet Messaging Server 5.1 HotFix 1.4 (built Aug 5 2002))

id OHR8OODOIE639R@akosmail.us.army.smil.mil

); Fri,

(original mail from 1C-'1(04 c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil
9 Jan 2004 11:37:15 -0500 (EST)
Received: from c5mainexch2.c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil
(akosmail [199.56.141.24]) by akosmail.us.army.smil.mi l

(iPlanet Messaging Server 5.1 HotFix 1.4' (built Aug 5 2002))

›; Fri,

with ESMTP id OHRBOOBEDE5B95@akosmail.us.army.smil.mil

09 Jan 2004 11:37:12 -0500 (EST)

with Internet Mail Service

Received: by c5mainexch2.hq.c5.army.smil.mil

id CJAJ35YL; Fri, 09 Jan 2004 19:36:34 +0300

(5.5.2657.72)
Content-return: allowed
Date: Fri._09 Jan 2004 19:36:19 +0300 @c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil
00-1 '02 12THMP CID DET"

From: '

Subject: 0007-04-CID259-80133 DETAINEE UNDETERMINED MANNER OF DEATH
(E-mail)"

'-/C -1 10t7

To: "(PIT) (CID) "CW2 1"1/2&-1(E-mail)"

1C-60bCW4 CJTF7-OPS
us.army.smil.mil,
1c5main.hq.c5.army.smil .mil,

131 b4?

le--1 kge -i (E-mail) (E-mail)"

"ATTN: CW3

IRDMS.ARMY.SMIL.MIL,

CIDOO1DCSOPSOPS2SC@SBELVO
'7e4/AE5CM-PMO"MAJ 76-4,191,1(E-mail)"
,

C5CMPLNSPM0@c5main.hq.c5.army .smil.mil,

"'CID DCSOPS OPS1(s)' (E-mail)" CIDDCSOPSOPSl@SBELVOIRDMS.ARMY.SMIL.MIL

"'CID001 USACIDC CAC BELVOIR(sc)' (E-mail)"

ELVOIRDMS.ARMY.SMIL.MIL ,

CIDOOlUSACIDCCACBELVOIRSC@SB,

"Cid001crcsc (E-mail)" cid001crosc@sbelvoirdms.army.smil.mil

)c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil ,

E-mail)" 16-11igl'1

"CPT , 14%-libt7-/A

-/// (E-mail)'

CJTF7-HOPS 7C.:
W3 1c5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil,

MAJ CJTF7-SJA OPERATIONAL LAW ATTORNEY i'etti(E-mail)"

-6 I3&

76 3c 5main.hq.c5.army.smil.mil ,

-maal)"

CW5 CJTF7-Field Ops. Officer R''Itk,‘-4 1E

@us.army.smY
MP BN LOGSEC (V-marH1"

K. I,bE

W1

4

C1D NCO"
:AD PHO)

3SC CJTF7 ­
1,o1 IA,

DMAIN.P1A.C5.ARMY .SMI L.MIL

qe.4i 0C-
Hmai r.tm. 5 . army . smi I

.m,

-7C -/
K)1?:;
c5main.hg. c 5 . army . smi 1 mi 1

014'72
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
) MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (t
UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
BIAP, IRAQ APO AE 09342

CIMPL-ZA 19 May 04
MEMORANDUM FOR Commander, USACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-COP-OP, 6010 6 th St.,
Fort Belvoir, VA 22060

SUBJECT: RFI (0212-04-CID001)
1.
The review of ROI # 0007-04-CID259-80133 determined the investigation was operationally sufficient and was administratively insufficient. A supplemental ROI needs to be submitted upon receipt the final autopsy report.

2.
The review disclosed the following deficiencies. The investigation did not conduct a crime scene examination or explain why such an examination was not conducted. The investigation did not conduct interviews of those witnesses who found the victim and took his body to the military police guards. There was no effort made to interview the alleged brother and son of the victim who were reportedly present at the prison at the time of death. The Final Report of Investigation (ROI) inappropriately contains the caveat for initial reports where the report is a preliminary investigation and may change prior to completion of the investigation. The investigation has not yet received the final autopsy report.

3.
The point of contact is the undersigned at ic--1 / b6 i, DNVT (302)

jus.arn 584-
1 1 t
&-
/
YVtLYLI
Special Agent
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Arglor; 9 01471
CLOSED FILE COVER SHEET SEQ
INFO REPORT FILE TYPE (circle one):
) 33
1--6 q-C(P-FILE SEQUENCE NUMBER: UV0 7 ACTIVI'T'Y:
"MEANINGFUL" INVESTIGATIVE
DATE OF LAST
KNOWN

SUBJECT STATUS (circle one):
DROP DEAD DATE FOR DISTRO:
CASE TRACKING: 3" TURN-IN 21\10 TURN-IN
1 s1 TURN-IN ce 1-AYAW AGENT
,),t9 003
TC (% _.171-7,/ t2
SAC
EV ID
ADMIN
Juouu(18 0147o
oil-C to J59-liF:6
-1-
1­ - _ bibaki:Ak. tre6C4— 6 C- ° ')0
.. . CUFIC. ,.1. if,,:irlo r•.. .-. I..''
•1i , )1. i.•E1.,
_ .

L C I-C-R uy\
O UO Uvu7
Of46 9
.J7-04-CID259-80133
Control Number1
AGENT'S ACTIVITY Su iviWIARY (cm Regulntiofl 195-I) J
SUMNIARY OF INVESTIGATIVE AC'TIVITY
DISTRO TO CRC, BN OPS, 32O MP BN, AFIP, FILE
0945, 2 FEB 04
,
1 FLIR (11-TICI AI ".;l: )N1
1 I ( )1 ¦ 7¦ 1 I I 811
LI U v014CS
AGENTS ACTIVITY ..,UMMARY
(CID Regulation 195-1)

v.1.1(.
3301- p.. 'c-
7 (s Sp-4r ,}cetivfv fa/9,5 /-7./45
4-1 6:J

( 5 .2tD-54 1-k 91j
-1Jab - 1
/03t,, (,)1`.31N,,,,o et ikco rinpil, To SPI-c- co(_ Veutco ie:(0WE
Pt­7c-/1 k @i.Da ,1c.-Sv-Act-9 0 A . vu¦c-V-evc.) rlL C.IDNitcz-e-c4) uJ
0)4'6. curd1uv. 1( e 4-0 S )qC.,1v C w.
r
ZDqD ZrV—A6
90)
coM
—VD
C'()1
^C A
LL
CP fLrIK

k5\v

\I--11'\c)1'1)c)
76—/1-/
PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED

OTD FORM 25
ct Hn

tr-
J t.J „ J
01467
DODDOACID 008009

:10259-
Control Number
AGENT'S ACTIVITYtriMARY1
Tin1
Tr\siN og
1 ) 104
-
--o-Roo`(
Oclo) , I I
16-/
09( 0.1 1
16 --I i
c)-\
LI 5 , I112&--/
IL

-1 / OLQ-/
le
1,5-6 -o,
i942 -1

I
I d1
poll!? Z-40 1
b(2 -1

0 100, te
le--1 bb
1),\
0E56, /el 7J­
92-5-4,A)oti
I =?v,
---/
la-•-1 I b6-7
('Il) FOqt1+.1
11)4 Igl)

l9S-1) SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
' Peut
3,41do20&1
-3 ciir3 n1
0 V50 aij1
.0.1.,,,,04w,J. a_v
El-•
604-1
Ctki31
ez)c &Yr-PO co_s)..._

t-L e,d,D.
cceeo-ca1 )kucv
11A_ ittjul^;"6"

j.t;41AftufiJziZ •1
/ P1+2e 1/4sorY-) iLktaW,
SrCC-
Coo uiy-,I9-vi1
di a' kV of\Pcc"-(2
Pc4teolvv)v
16-4, 19 2 -4
5P e
1t1
Criutt
061, 010
oA
,A-110-n
ncoli livAviA Ob*­
a 1-
c'00(4v (-rv
0-4 i."0/v C lat
(1
eibj, 03 (1_,v4E e1
4a_sr (-7 a4e-ii/
. (1 ( Ito (AL 10
Mikev
4-0 kAek
evao,/oki_
pa_isod.1
) 6 POIc Veui. 0.4
I 61is
)2-efor I
Pe4f4--v
4500 ktiviv
PAGE
FOR OFFICI Al LISF ()NI Y
014tf;
DODDOACID 008008

0007-04-CI D259-80133
Control Number
AGENT'S ACTIVITY SUMMARY (tin R egulation I95-I)
SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY
TIME, DATE, AND AGENT
2004, 8 Jan 04

70,-/ /
2015, 8 Jan 04
/

1124, 9 Jan 04

76,-// b4.1

1300, 9 Jan 04

hb-/

1353, 9 Jan 04
'7C.-// h&j

re/ v 5,
7c-// 19k-/
BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: About 2004, 8 Jan 04,

this office received a Serious Incident Report
(SIR) from the CID Liaison Of ficer, V Corps,
Baghdad, Iraq indicating an Iraqi detainee died
while under the custody of Coalition Forces at Abu

Ghurayb Prison, Abu Ghurayb, Iraq.

Xiiii:96-/ Abu Ghurayb

SA 767-1/a-/ coordinated with SA
Prison, requested assistance with the particulars
of the death scene or if there was a death scene.

7e-ii it,y who related Mr. IBRAHEIM

Coordinated with SA
was brought to the Compound 3 gate by other
-//1t.—/ -elated medics

detainees unconscious. SA -;0

were dispatched to the scene where they pronounced
Mr. IBRAHEIM dead. SA 7e-/ /b6,11 celated he had
conducted initial interviews of personnel on sight,

medics, and doctor who pronounced Mr. IBRAHEIM
dead. SA 7C-//47b .-/ irther related he would forward
the finished AIR of all activity completed through
SIPER Net.

Drafted Initial Report.

To SAC for review/dispatch.

/26
ce- ucA, 0.41,1a,1(e__,A Co cl o 1- z­
/SST
AU_ Co 1 rc.-tik ¦ un.
o 7 C, -vA-c,L
-
7e.)4 11',,,,/e(77 06 C,
PA(
1 ( ( 1111L1M 1 .1,1 • ¦ 1
01465

SEQUENCE NUMBER
5k1A3 art S plc t7V/AAJ'
Obid-VA
6/4,S CIA SYE-Yie
4
I
1171")(t_Acs: rk. (
r PA)f o,r,r;'1)/p by, 40_4'4 S. iq 76,4b&
01'
Viti-1011;01Mnetiri)
Film submitted for contact shec
All documents marked with
Obtain all documents concerning
the ROI or file number
the positive urinalysis
INVESTIGATIVE STANDARDS
FOR OF-FICIAI LIRE ONI
S t i( 1 ) t f)
el,
01464
('II) FORM 66

2. TuviE RECEIVED
1. DATE 2-0041
3.
OFFENSE l.kA r‘

4.
SUBJECT

ir\t­
e-
5. VICTIM
!Jo--St.-;,3-0671,
\
3-,-A.( -f
6. CASE DESCRIPTION
J j LLAIR , --r-ck-c.
b J._ I Z
11. OTHER ACTION 12. CID FUNDS ACTION RQRD COMP!. DATE AMOUNT
CRIMINAL. INFO EVIDENCE ClST
7. CASE NUMBER
---uc) t 33 ASSulmEn TO
7C/-11e67
9.
TYPE OF ACTION

10.
REPORTS

C
TYPE SUSPENSE
I
J ,.11911/1. /7-
'-.11q11
ic- U3
,54(
01463

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED MEDICS WERE SUMMONED TO COMPOUND 3, CAMP GANCI, BAGHDAD CORRECTIONAL FACILTY TO PROVIDE MEDICAL TREATMENT TO A PRISONER WHO WAS UNCONSCIOUS.
INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED SEVERAL DETAINEES FROM COMPOUND 3 BROUGHT MR. IBRAHEIM TO THE COMPOUND GATE UNCONSCIOUS FROM UNKNOWN CAUSES. MEDICS WERE DISPATCHED AND FOUND MR. IBRAHEIM UNCONCIOUS AND UNRESPONSIVE. NO LIFESAVING PROCEDURES WERE CONDUCTED, AND MR. IBRAHEIM WAS IMMEDIATELY TRANSPORTED TO THE MEDICAL
-kg, -
TREATMENT AREA. AT THE MEDICAL TREATMENT AREA DR. (LTC) .201-1-1 MILITARY POLICE BATTALION, FOUND MR. IBRAHEIM HAD NO
7C--iiia—V-HEART RATE, NO RESPONSIVENESS TO DEEP PAIN STIMULATION, AND THE EYES 'RONOUNCED MR. IBRAHEIM
WERE DIALATED. AT 1554, 7 JAN 04, DR. 74,'-.4/
DEAD AND RELATED THE PRELIMINARY CAUSE OF DEATH WAS CARDIO-
PULMONARY ARREST, AND MANNER OF DEATH WAS NATURAL. DR. 74''
ALSO RELATED MR. IBRAHEIM HAD A PRE-EXISTING HEART CONDITION.

AN AUTOPSY IS PENDING BY AN ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY
(AFIP) MEDICAL EXAMINER AT THE BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP),
BAGHAD, IRAQ, MORGUE.

THE CASIIALTY LIASON OFFICER (CLO) FOR THIS MATTER IS CW2 tar-t SPECIAL AGENT-IN-CHARGE, AT DSN 302-530
INVESTIGATON CONTINUES BY USACIDC.
CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55.
7.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
ei
Fd

01462
DATE: 9 JAN 04
FROM: SAC, 12TH MILITARY POLICE DET (CID) DIRECTOR, USACRC, USACIDC, FORT BELVOIR, VA
TO: CDR, ClOP-COP-CO, FORT BELVIOR, VA CDR, 10 11 MP BN (C1D)(ABN)(FWD) HOPS/: CDR, 3D MP GROUP (CID) //OPSH AFIP, ATTN: OAFME, ROCKVILLE MD PROVOST MARSHAL, 1 ST ARMORED DIVISION OFFICE OF THE STAFF JUDGE ADVOCATE (V CORPS) LNO CID, CJTF (FOR FURTHER DISTRIBUTION)
SUBJECT: CID REPORT -- INITIAL/SSI- 0007-04-CID259-801 33-5 H 9 B
DRAFTER: SA
/ /M -/
RELEASER: SA UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1. 8 JANUARY 2004/1554 HRS 8 JANUARY 2004/1600 HRS; COMPOUND
THREE, CAMP GANCI, BAGHDAD CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, ABU GHRAIB,

IRAQ
2. DATE/TIME REPORTED: 8 JANUARY 2004, 2004 HRS
1---1 ) 19(;-/ 19 ,SA 7C--/ ) b 2-
3.
INVESTIGATED BY: SA

4.
SUBJECT: 1. NONE

VICTIM: 1. IBRAHEIM, NASEF JASEM; 1 JAN 41; M; OTHER; COMPOUND THREE,
5.
CAMP GANCI, BAGHDAD CORRECTIONAL FACILTY, ABU GHRAIB, IRAQ; XZ (NFI)
[UNDETERMINED MANNER OF DEATH].
6.INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS BASED
UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND MAY CHANGE
PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.

-THIS IS AN OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM INVESTIGATION -
THIS OFFICE RECEIVED A SERIOUS INCIDEN1 REPORT REGARDING THE DEAI . H
OF A PRISONER AT THE BAGHAD CORRECTIONAL FACILITY, ABU GHRAIB
MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID) (ABN) (FWD),

PRISON. IRAQ. FROM TIIE le l
BAGIIDAD, IRAQ.

01461 F C;
DODDOACID 008003
DEATH AS ATHEROSCLEROTIC CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE RESULTING IN
CARDIAC TAMPONADE.

THIS OFFICE RECEIVED THE PRELIMINARY AUTOPSY REPORT OF MR.

IBRAHEIM FROM THE ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY (AFIP).

THE AUTOPSY REPORT INDICATED MR. IBRAHEIM'S CAUSE OF DEATH AS
ATHEROSCLEROTIC CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE RESULTING IN CARDIAC

TAMPONADE AND HIS MANNER OF DEATH NATURAL.

INITIAL REPORT:

THIS OFFICE RECEIVED A SERIOUS INCIDENT REPORT REGARDING THE
DEATH OF A PRISONER AT THE ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ, FROM THE
10TH MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID) (ABN) (FWD), BAGHDAD, IRAQ.

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED MEDICS WERE SUMMONED TO
COMPOUND 3, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, TO PROVIDE MEDICAL

TREATMENT TO A PRISONER WHO WAS UNCONSCIOUS.

INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED SEVERAL DETAINEES OF COMPOUND 3 BROUGHT
MR IBRAHEIM TO THE COMPOUND GATE UNCONSCIOUS FROM UNKNOWN
CAUSES. MEDICS WERE DISPATCHED AND PRONOUNCED MR. IBRAHEIM DEAD
ON THE SCENE. AT THE WRITING OF THIS REPORT, IT WAS NOT
DETERMINED IF ANY LIFESAVING PROCEDURES WERE CONDUCTED ON MR.

IBRAHEIM.

AN AUTOPSY IS PENDING BY AN ARMED FORCES INSTITUTE OF PATHOLOGY
(AFIP) MEDICAL EXAMINER AT THE BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
(BIAP), BAGHAD, IRAQ, MORGUE.

THE CASUALTY LIASON OFFICER (CLO) FOR THIS MATTER IS CW2 -76-6
-CHARGE, AT DSN 302-530-

SPECIAL AGENT-IN

INVESTIGATON CONTINUES BY USACIDC.

7. CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF
PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

25
01460

.ec JAN 04

FROM: SAC, 12TH MILITARY POLICE DET (CID)
DIRECTOR, USACRC, USACIDC, FORT BELVOIR, VA

TO:

CO, FORT BELVIOR, VA

CDR, 'IOP-COP-
CDR, 107u MP BN (CID) (ABN) (FWD) //OPS

CDR, 3D MP GROUP (CID) //OPS//
AFIP, ATTN: OAFME, ROCKVILLE MD
ARMORED DIVISION

PROVOST MARSHAL, 1ST

OFFICE OF THE STAFF JUDGE ADVOCATE (V CORPS)
LNO CID, CJTF (FOR FURTHER DISTRIBUTION)

21,1 D STATUS/SST- 0007-04-CID259-90133-

SUBJECT: CID REPORT -
5H9B/5H9A

DRAFTER: ST -7C -1 012
RELEASER: SA

UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:

JANUARY 2004/1554 HRS - H JANUARY 2004/1600 HRS:

1.

COMPOUND THREE, CAMP GANC1, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ

DATE/TIME REPORTED: 8 JANUARY 2004, 2004 HRS

2.

I NA 1C-­
) -A/) b 24
INVESTIGATED BY: SA

3.

'7C7-1 17&-I-b2--
NONE [NATURAL DEATH]

SUBJECT: 1.

4.

IBRAHEIM, NASEF JASEM; 1 JAN 41; M; OTHER;

VICTIM: 1.

5.

COMPOUND THREE, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYH PRISON, IRAQ; Z (NEI)

[NATURAL DEATH].

INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS

6.

BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND MAY
CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.

1BRAHE1M': MANNE

MT'•

01459

Page(s)


Referred to:
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/ PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl@cen.amedd.army.mil (210) 221-7826
01 458

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT 0007-04-C1D259-80133
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE I OF 1 PAGES
DETAILS
On 23 Aug 04, this office received the Final Autopsy Report, ME 04-12 pertaining to Mr. Nasef J. IBRAHIM, Compound three, Camp Ganci, Abu Ghurayb Prison, Iraq, which revealed the cause of death as Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease Resulting in Cardiac Tamponade and the manner of death as Natural. (See Report for details)///LAST ENTRY///

TYPED AGENT'S NAME AND SEQUENCE NUMBER SIG, DATE
7C.r r 19
SA 11) -1
23 Aug 04
78th MP Det (CID) (FWD), 09342 CID FORM 94-E IJ t UN!. Y EXHIBIT (7? I OCT 95 PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16) (When Data Is Entered)
01457
101 11 • (MA bfv
Toy. 01.A Lt1C. 010 ( ¦rj
FX1-11811
.01456 5
FILE NUMBER:1 ?`6 `r to Fro /33
STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT I\n1i1DATED1'CONTINUED:
STATEMENT (Continued)

AFFIDAVIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT I, ,,,_..Y UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. WHICH BEGINS ow rAt.'m
76-i-/ / b6 -e/tt
I 'API Ll Cl•ILJO LIPI rpm... . ¦ ,
THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT.I HAVE CIO
UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
HOUT
AND WITHOUT COER N.
6,/(Signature of Persoffiataking Statement)
WITNESSES: Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law
, 20 o -/

to administer oaths, this( day of U:11101
ftz-do n6/91 --F?-clq
HO Cripu.:PLY.9 A
at )1s-1
7e--eil, &-
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
-(Signature of Person Administenng yaw)
7e-e-/
,1-nig oath)
(lypea Natiltfv
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS j3C A) VC' prjj-
(AuthvTo Administer Oaths)

INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT b61GE1OF 2 PAGES
4
-(..¦ A1C),V(=. (I)0 ud_
01455
SWORN STATEMENT
Far usa of ttes form. see AR 190-45: tho proponent agency is OOCSOPS

PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT

Title 10 USC Suction 301; Titre 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated Nonflter 22.. 1943 (SSW
To provide commander and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ORITY:
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:
Your social security number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facirnate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES:
DISCLOSURE:

Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
. TIM)6. a FILE NUMBER
2. DATE tYYYYMMOM
I. EL ON -
._.K 04/ ddo61/_&7cit /96, .01.0 i -1.07)i--cs -C1 -,,
. . ,-, c.. ,
4 p fer ,h ro ,,, /6,...., - 4,­
/IW(.4 - 6 7. GRADEIST T7
• • - •---p....._ 6"- el 5,6
..
id- Lt, b6-4-1-
[AU"
B. URGANIZA 1 tUrrUtt AUUH[JJ •-• n r
,
r? u- MP t-Agjil fun

9.
7e r/ & - LI , WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
-as/
6a4c.; 3 rarit.e
rl r4iLeir.5 —Cei-i Is I
,‘ etc,/
a p, cl (----Aa7z
,0e-Amee L /SY / // 4'4_5 rr-, 4 /1/ kJ
.7-' Iva S. a, A.,,,71-/530 1,, .„,,

4 54/.._ • ,,,,,-,,,,,f7.
--7(-' 116-,
cjitt
,.. 5 . ,,, j/ii.,?; „ (7----00 a-f- --frke Si -,/ 0 --)

ra iD --/, )-h10E&I
a
if"- i. (/ e.c1 o v--1 S . i.:4' 7L71/e

a--(. Ita-- d • -Ike 74..,001, Ls (--/-4,-,
44

/41 m 4` .0 arrhi--u2, c,/
„,i Z 31.( e) r r(p-olit .e-, I c., , , 'A Au -4 _5-

/5 //if tie( s '-/4 pi le -)/
,Li LI ;- 7 -e.

A 11 0 4 t k ).- , 5 0/ vc ,-f 11 14,,, 7ro c , e eci Li-to jib' c„ fir.,-, /1.,-
c/to ,..-i It if. t 0-zi 6,.” 0,.,..„:,.,/
71-1,,4._ ,/, ile c,,,ised

H1A j 1./3. cl yup K"' 4 / yo c.-3/` I '70-
77,,,,-/- -- a I-AC,/ . 7I---Q_ i ,p77C--",,-c-ic, 76 ,-, (Ci f'-CP ci"/ /(' 3.54 rs

--34,--,
, w-/

ey,
_ ct,
r.1.---JS
--------1-______
.0 EXHIBIT 11. INITI A. — 1 STATEMENT 1I , PAGE 1 OF / PAGES
4.00ITIONAI PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT ___ BATED _
:-HE BOTTOM Of EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST REAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE SEATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 1 BA FORM 2023. JUL 72. IS OBSOLETE USA P X W I C' 1

01451

ROI NUMBER
0007-04-CID259-80133

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT
CIO ROgUlaCiOn 195-1 PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES

-1 -e-interviewed SPC ' laev--y who

About 1500, 16 Jan 04, SP 7C-6W
provided a sworn statement reiterating details from his previous
related he was assigned to Ganci 3, Abu Ghurayb

interview. SPC 7C"4. 1 )26, 4
Prison, Baghdad, Iraq, and was notified that a detainee was feeling ill
-76-4/t74-4 related he informed his

and had fallen to the ground. SPC
Tactical Operations Center (TOC) of the situation and medics were

7d(-1/, 4tp-9for

(See Sworn Statement of SPC

dispatched to the scene.
details).///LAST ENTRY///

MP Dei (CID), 3 MP GRP (CID),

I

‘7\-')C- I-19C-, -1
Baghdad, Iraq, APO AL 09335

Exim,(11'

1

FOR OFIICIAL 11!7;V, ONLY

CID FORM (34

01453
Page(s)



Referred to:
U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/ PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT SAM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6013
MR. JOHN PETERSON John.Petersonl@cen.amedd.army.mil (210) 221-7826
01452

ROI NUMBER
0007-04-C1D259 -80133
AGENT'S INVESTIGATION RE PORT
CID Regulacion 195
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES
ttended the autopsy of Mr. ABRAHEIM,
SA7C -1)Nri
bout 0910, 11 Jan 04,
United States Navy (USN), Office
,13`.-/-// /V.-4f-
which was conducted by LTC of the Armed Forces Medical Examiner, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology (AFIP), Rockville, Maryland 20850. LTC 7e-,67/-h-,/elated the preliminary
Cause of Death as Arthrosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease (ACD) and the Manner of Death as Natural. Photographs were exposed by Photographers 1SN, Rockville, Maryland 20850, of the
ate 3 rd Class -/C-q /4•-471 autopsy and prepared a compact disc containing all images exposed. (See Preliminary Autopsy Report and Compact Disc for details) .///LAST ENTRY///
Dp.G1-3,1.133,.T;c1 N
• 33vi33;1333'-31Lm ,
17.1b MP Det ;, CI D.) , 3 n MP GRP (CID) ,
1c7,4 7
:;A
APO AF 09335
Baghcbd, 1 raq,
Exit' BiT
3347.3--:
Will. '
1 196 -I •-
01:1:1(71I\I llr3V, ONLY
ClD FORM q ,1
01451
660 ((-2922 /33
AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT

PAGE 2 OF 2 PAGES

CID Regulation 195-1

towardand observed several prisoners carrying a blanket with what appeared to be a body insideof what 1c-q, ari6lated he notified the Guard Post at the gate
the gate of the compound. SPChe observed and was informed medical personnel were enroute.
320th
7c - 4-1 bet"-9iterviewed SFC
-7 -I
About 2110, 8 Jan 03, SA
MP BN, AGPC, who stated approximately 1530 he was notified by the TOC a detainee had .-43tated he dispatched a trauma team at 1535. SFC
/04,
turned blue in Ganci 3. SFC 7 e
.4:1 when the trauma team arrived the detainee was deceased, and they transported
7C-q ) b6-4/--76-4 -b4.-klated he proceeded to the Medical
the detainee to the Medical Treatment Area. SFC 1 20th MP BN, AGPC. T
)v Lit.
7C--v
Treatment Area with LTC
detainees' lips were white, pupils were dilated and he was not breathing. The trauma team did
•C-91 Li 4.
196-4 pronounced the detainee dead. SFC
/
not perform CPR. At 1554, LTC 7c -4
stated the detainee had a pre-existing heart condition.

7e-di, 196-4/ who stated around 1545, 8
rviewed LTC
About 2130, 8 Jan 03, SA ie=--// bt9-1 --47/
Jan 03, he heard a detainee was being transported to the Medical Aid Station. LTC
stated when he arrived the detainee had no heart rate, no respiration, no responsiveness to deep

ministered upon3tated no CPR was liad
LTC 16 b6­
pain stimulation, and eyes were dilated. ee
e the
-Y d
155 4. LTC 7C-4/ /196his arrival and he pronounced the detain dead at
the manner of death was natural.
preliminary cause of death was Cardio Pulmonary Arrest,
and///////////////////////////////////////////////
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////LAST ENTRY///////////

Prisoner Interview Team (CID)(FWD)

C-1 ibb'A

SA Abu Ghraib, Iraq, APO AE 09335
/22 _ __ __
Special Agent, . Exhibit:
Date:

ie
8 Jan 04

-1 b6-I
CID Form 94

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

01450
(TT oci-vac}-10/33
AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT

PAGE 1 OF 2 PAGES
CID Regulation 195-1

) /042-4
q) b&--/ ,erviewed SPC
About 2030, 8 Jan 03, SA 76-both of 320 th Military Police Company (MP Co), Abu
-t D&- Ll
SPC 1C-1
Ghraib Prison Complex, APO AE 09335 (AGPC), who both related that on 8 Jan 03 they were serving as the Trauma Team assigned to work the Prisoner Camps and attend to any Trauma related cases involving prisoners. They related sometime after 1500 they were notified by radio to report to Ganci 3, AGPC, is response to a prisoner that was having difficulty breathing. They arrived approximately 1-2 minutes after being notified and discovered an elderly prisoner who was unresponsive and unconscious. They checked for vital signs with negative results and the prisoner was turning blue from the nipples up; pupils were fixed and dilated; no brachial or carotid pulse was detected. CPR was not initiated. They related they immediately transported the body to the Medical Treatment Area of the Inprocessing Center for further treatment by the
Medical Doctor.
7C-1,
-76-0 Fib -/-SA
About 2040, 8 Jan 03, SA ZI/d, -/r, SA # 154111, which
both of this office, examined the body of Nasef Jasem IBRAHEIM, Detainee
was located at the Medical Treatment Area, Inprocessing Center, AGPC. A visual inspection of

the body revealed a lack of evidence of physical trauma and no bruising or other wounds were
noted. Rigor Mortis was beginning to onset and Livor Mortis was apparent on the back of the
deceased. The deceased was photographed for identification purposes using a Kodak EasyShare

DX 4330.
AGENT'S COMMENT: The deceased was laying on his back within a body hag.
and SSG
-7(2-44 ) 106-4-
About 2100, SA "2C-6 471 nterviewed SPC ", both of 320-th Military Police Battalion (MP BN), AGPC,
--/c--1-1-h6­who related around 1530, 8 Jan 03, a prisoner, subsequently identified as the deceased son (NFI),
came to the gate of Ganci 3, AGPC, and reported his father was not breathing, had turned blue
lated he told the prisoner to bring the sick

and had fallen down. SPC be ".
individual to the gate and then he called the Tactical Operations Center (TOC) and requested medical personnel. They further related a couple minutes later, the son and the brother of the sick prisoner arrived carrying the sick prisoner on a blanket to the gate and was taken outside the gate to await medical personnel, who arrived at the same time the sick prisoner was brought to the gate and immediately began an assessment. They related the medics immediately, with in a minute or two, transported the sick prisoner to the Medical Treatment Area in the lnprocessing
Area.
and SPC

7C--0 s
SA 7C---1 1 bo1 interviewed SSG 06-
About 7110. 8 Jan 03, ioth of 3200h MP Co, AGPC, who related around 1530, 8 Jan
H. 196 -4
in Guard Tower #3, which is adjacent to Ganci 3, along the Western Edge.
03. they were present

. .._
.1
Prisoner Interview Team (CID)(FND)

Abu Ghraib, Iraq, APO AE 09335

Special Agent , -
Exhibit:

Date;

8 Jan 04
IC' 1 / b67
CID Form 94

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

01449

Report Approved By:Report Prepared By:
le/ -1 ) 1910-1
Distribution:
1-DIR, USACRC, 6010, 6 th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (originals with exhibits)
1-Thru: Cdr, 10th Military Police Battalion, ATTN: Ops Officer (with exhibits) Cdr, 3D MP Group, (CID), ATTN: S-3, APO AE 09335 (e-mail only/less exhibits)
To: Cdr, USACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-ZA, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (e-mail
only/less exhibits
1-CDR, 320th MP Battalion, Abu Ghurayb, Iraq APO AE 09335 (with exhibits)

----32hief Counsel, CPA, Office of General Counsel,
l-SJA, (ATTN: COL 7e -'2i bb
APO AE 09335. (e-mail only/less exhibits)
-1 ,e-mail only/less exhibits)

I-CID LNO, V Corps (ATTN: SA
1-PMO, 1 AD (ATTN: LTC, , APO AE 09336 (e-mail only/less exhibits)

4
1-PMO, V CORPS (ATTN: SFC P-' 6¦ 14e-mail only/less exhibits)
1-Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, 6825 16 th Street NW Washington, DC 20306-
6000 (with exhibits)
1-File

01447

STATUTES: None (Natural Death).
EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION:
ATTACHED: L-4/1;t-'1, 8 Jan 04, detailing receipt of
-
Agent's Investigative Report (AIR) of SA
1.
initial notification, and the coordination with SA 7c..-/ l ik../

; he
6-1 8 Jan 04, detailing the interview of SPC
2. AIR of SA
examination of Mr. IBRAHEIM's body, the interviews of SPC /64 /Z, 4/- SSG
)
7c..--q) Li-°eiind LTC
fr11'.`1-SG -76-417114 SPC 76-11, kb-7 7c
.1121 1 Jan 04, detailing the autopsy of Mr. 7c- " 1-/)
3.
AIR of SA 1G-I J

Preliminary Autopsy Report of Mr. ABRAHEIM, 11 Jan 04.

4.

66,
16 Jan 04, detailing the re-interview of SPC
5.
AIR of SA

16 Jan 04, detailing his knowledge of
6.
Sworn Statement of SPC 76-4-6­the incident.

Compact disc 1\4E04-12, containing all photographs of autopsy. (USACRC copy
7.
only).

NOT NITACIIED:
None.
The originals of exhibits 1, through 3, 5, and 6 were forwarded with the USACRC copy of this report. The originals of exhibits 4 and 7 are retained in the files of the Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Building 102, 1413 Research BLVD, Rockville, MD 20858
STATUS: This is a Final (C) Report. This investigation was terminated in accordance with Section V, Chapter 4-17 a (6), CID Regulation 195-1, in that the Special Agent in Charge determined that furtherance of the investigation would be of little or no value or leads remaining to be developed were not significant. Commander's Report of Action
Taken (DA FM 4833) is not required.
Leads Remaining:
Canvass interview all detainees located in Compound 3.
Final autopsy report.
01446

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
1211-1 MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID) (FWD)
BAGHDAD BRANCH OFFICE
APO AE 09335

30 Jan 04CIRC-ABE (195)
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION-FINAL (C) REPORT-0007-04 -CID259-80133-5H9A
1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1. 8 JANUARY 2004/1554 HRS - 8 JANUARY 2004/1600 HRS; COMPOUND
THREE, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ

DATE/TIME REPORTED: 8 JANUARY 2004, 2004 HRS
2.
/ ) -/ b)--, SA -7C-./ b6
3.
INVESTIGATED BY: SA
Oar--7c.,-/ / •-/ /2.2--

4.
SUBJECT: 1. (NONE); !NATURAL DEATH]

1. IBRAHEIM, NASEF JASEM; 1 JAN 41; M; OTHER; COMPOUND

5.
VICTIM:
THREE, CAMP GANCI, ABU GHURAYB PRISON, IRAQ; XZ (NF1) [NATURAL

DEATI I].
6. INVESTIGATION SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT IS
BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND
MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION.

This is an "Operation Iraqi Freedom" investigation
This office received a serious incident report from the 10 111 Military Police Battalion
(CID) (ABN) (FWD), Baghdad, Iraq regarding the death of a prisoner at the Abu

Ghurayb Prison, Iraq.
This investigation revealed that Mr. IBRAHEIM died of natural causes when he suffered
Cardiac Tamponade as a result of Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease.

On I 1 Jan 04. an autopsy was conducted on Mr. 113R A1-111M indicating Mr.
IIBIZAHFIM's cause of death as Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease resulting in
Cardiac Tamponade and the manner of death as Natural.


01445
0007-04-C1D259-80133

STATUTES:
None (Natural Death).
EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATIONS:
ADDED ATTACHED:

8.
AIR of SA X-4 1 bb-/ 23 Aug 04, detailing the receipts of the Final Autopsy Report.

9.
Final Autopsy Report #ME 04-12, 18 FEB 04, pertaining to Mr. IBRAHIM.
ADDED NOT ATTACHED:
None.
The original of Exhibit 8 was forwarded with the USACRC copy of this report. The

original of Exhibit 9 is maintained in the files of AFIP, 1413 Research Blvd, Bldg 102,
Rockville, MD 20850.
STATUS: This is a Final Supplemental Report.

-. / A. RV' -de
72,-1 1% -/
Special Agent in Charge
DISTRIBUTION:
1 - DIR, USACRC, 6010, 6th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (originals)
I — THRU: CDR, 22" Military Police Battalion (CID), Baghdad, IZ THRU: CDR, 3rd Military Police Group (CID), Fort Gillam, GA. To: HQUSACIDC, ATM CIOP-ZA, Fort Belvoir, VA
1 - CID LNO, MNC-1, (ATTN: SA Z--1/0: 4 mail only/less exhibits)
Camp Victory, APO AE 09335 (Email

,
1 — PM MNC-1 (ATTN: COL 7C— 3 ,
only/less exhibits)
1 — SJA, Special Prosecutor, Central Criminal Court of Iraq (CCCI), Office of General
Council, Camp Victory, 1Z APO AE 09335 (e-mail only)
1— OAFME, 1413 Research Blvd, Suite 102, Rockville, MD 20850

1 - File
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

01444

MP CID DET
le. -Li / ix,3--Y-WO2 12T :,,:::_,,,,,
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,I.,. .,11,,,,,,1
-;k!.--c-r i 1.2.4,-, `4. . 7,V\14 CJTF7-OPS
From: -Thursday, January 08, 2004 8:09 PM
Sent: (6us.army.smil.mil ; CVV2
4ID DMAIN 43MP DET; 87th-CID;
, CW2 Detachment CDR;To:
(PIT) (CID);
CW2 CFLCC/3A-FWD 44 MP DET; -7(
CW4 10TH MP BN LOGSEC, Cc:
ye-
Detainee Deaths
Subject:
An ROI will be initiated on all detainee deaths and a AFIP autopsy will
be conducted.
This Hqs will make the AFIP notification

ht; -I
CW4, MP
Operations Officer

014%?”

Doc_nid: 
2432
Doc_type_num: 
66