CID Report 190-04-CID259-80234

<p>An investigation of detainee abuse that occurred while the detainee was being transported from Al Baghdadi to the Baghdad International Airport and then on to Abu Ghraib prison. The investigation established insufficient evidence to show allegations of aggravated assault and Cruelty, and Mistreatment occurred.</p>

Doc_type: 
Investigative File
Doc_date: 
Wednesday, February 2, 2005
Doc_rel_date: 
Monday, September 19, 2005
Doc_text: 

• D PARTMNT. -0E-TH' ARMY • MIWARce:p0­.0c0 DETACHMENT tom (FWD) UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND EIA.01.­-.11M0414 APO AE 09342 CIMPR-FR 2 February 2005 . MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION SUI3JECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION - SUPPLEMENTAL FINAL/SSI - 0190-04.; CID259-80234-15C213/5Y28 +J DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES: 1 4 MAR 2004/ 0001 FIRS MAR 2004/2359 HRS, UNKNOWN LOCATION (AL BAGFIDADI / BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP)), IRAQ (IZ) DATE/TIME REPORTED: 28 JUN 2004, 0900 HRS . . . . . INVESTIGATED BY SA • ••• • • . •:• • ..6„ 6• •6.6 .. • .66• , SUBJECT 1:(uNf.No*N);•(NE1);-[AGGRAVATED ASSAULT (UNFOUNDED)] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT (UNFOUNDED)] • pc- VICTIM: • 1 . 11111111111111111111111 CW; IRAQI; I ; M, WHITE; XZ; DATE OF CAPTURE 26 FEB -4 MAR 04; [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT(UNFOUNDED] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT(UNFOUNDED)] INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: On 28 Jun 04, this investigatiOn was initiated based upon receipt of a Memorandum of Transmittal (0067-04-CID789) from the Prisoner Interview/Interrogation Team (PIT), 75 th (BCCF), Abu Ghraib, Military Police Detachment, Baghdad Central Confinement Facilitya (AGI), regarding allegations Mr was abused while being detained by U.S. Coalition Forces at Al Baghdadi and the Baghdad International Airport (BIAP), IZ. . • Investigation established sufficient evidence to prove the offenses of Aggravated Assault and Cruelty and Maltreatment did not occur as alleged Investigation clearly demonstrated Mr .1'1111100147as no—raWil Throrinjutetittritre-duringmhi rehensienr g intaioiatiOns. Throughout the investigation, numerous medical exams documented there were no indications of abuse or any allegations of abuse made by Mr ...Wring the medical 4 76-5', FOR OFFICIAL USE 9NLY, 014880 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE 0000'0 1 1 90-04-C11)2SO:80 234 n_, exams:Further, duritig the interrogations by the Federal Ilureau o f tatiancouclUPted within ourS and days of s apprehension, there were no repOr0 o 004 or claims of abuse : 7e_c,ofr Medical and interrogation reports , consistently report eing xn good health With no -injuries_ or allegations of abuse, This provided sufficient contra& evidence to proVe the leged, Mr._all d he was put in stress positions, punched id his face and stomach;_ with -, 76.6%Zikt" an UPI en ed_and later Punched in the stomach until he lost consciousness; Mt. 1- stated he felldoWnon barbed wires and was dragged by his feet until he received cuts to bis. , a bo_dy state unknown individuals pulled his arms and legs backward, causing his 4 7Z- .6(shoulder to :dislocate; elated the abuse occurred at Al Baghdadi, IZ, by unlcnown&7C-fc 660. • person(s) and BIAP; Il, by agents. of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). • Numerous intervieV, OM agents and medical personnel involved in the interview and medical d • screening of Mr.411111111.determined he was transferred froni Al Baghdadi, IZ, to 13IAP, under pc- • their care, between 4 7 Mar 04, during which time he was medieally screened and no , obseryations of recent injuries were evident, FBI personnel , reported at no time during their f - interviews of Mr_was he harmed in any way. The only reference to any injuries noted iii e- any of the FBI Interrogation Reports was a report ,by one of the interrOgators that Mr_47e..0; V blisters and. scratch on his feet from walking around without hoes, so the appeared to have interrogator provided Mr. _"flip-flops" to protect his feet. 67e. -4e, 1- g Additionally, medical screenings of Mr. _conducted on 11 Mar 04 and 13 Jul 04, indicate_g • he was in good health and make no reference to any cuts, scrapes, bruises, marks or any dislocated shoulders._ • STATUTES: Article 128; UCMJ! Aggravated Assault (Unfounded) Article 93, UCMJ: Cruelty and Maltreatment (Unfounded) . EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION: Added Attached: 23. Agent Investigation Report (AIR) o f SA _detailing the re-opening of this investigation based upon the receipt of the review by the 11 th MP Battalion (CID), the results of the review o f this investigation and the action completed to properly document the finding of this investigation, AddedNot Attached: None 44ZsUgdiLiktedVOItigsta, The original of exhibits 23' is forwarded with USACRC copy of this report. . 014881 2 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 0000'02 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE 90-04-00259-80234 . . . STATUS: W... is a Supplemental a ReportNo DA Fomi 4833 (Commander's Report of Action) is per,Z.ig ful this ;_l-eStict -;I:M. • Report Pr0134.1:64, 66'.( •1-DIX USACRC, 6910; 61 Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (original) 1-Thru CDR., 22nd MP BN (OD) (FWD), APO AE 09342 • Thm: CDR, 3rd MP Group (CID) To CDR, USACIDC, ATTN: CIOP-ZA, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060 • 9t 1-PMO, MNF-I (e-mail only) CID LNO, MNF-T, MO AE 09342 (e-mail only) P6 1-Office of the Staff Judge Advocate, III Corps, ATTN: CP (email only) 1-File • 014832 3. • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 000003 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE DOD-023957 DEPARTMENT OF ME Al.t2 • ., 01.011,ITARY POLICE 01100 CID . • . wormy POLICE DETACHMENT (CID) Two)._, UNITED STATES Agiviy cRIMINAL givtaTiGA-npN COMMAND . • BAGHDAD, • APO AE 004 •6• CIMPR-FR 20 October 2004 MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION SUBJECT' REPORT OF INVESTIGATION — FINAL/SSI -0190:64-CID250-80234—. /5C2B/5Y2E/5X1,6. 1. DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES: 1. 4 MAR 2004/ 0001 HRS— 11 MAR 2004/2359 HRS; UNKNOWN LOCATION (AL BAGHDAD( I BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP)), IRAQ (IZ) DATE/TIME REPORTED: 28 JUN 2004, 0900 HRS INVESTIGATED BY SA SUBJECT1 ....(UNKNOWN), (NEI); [AG GRAVATED6[CRUELTY AND MALTREATM ENT] [CONSPIRACY] •6• • -• ••:-•6• • .6:-• •• ;6. • - VICTIM 1. CIV; IRAQI; IS WHITE; XZ; DATE OF CAPTURE; 26 FEB 4 MAR 04; (NFI); [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT] "[CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] [CONSPIRACY] . . . . INVESTITIVE SUMMARY This investigation was initiated upon receipt of Memorandum of Transmittal 0067-04-01D789, from the Prisoner Interview/Interrogation Team (Pfp, 751n• Military Police Detachment, Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (BCCF), Abu Ghraib; IZ (AGI), regarding allegations Mr.., . was abused while being detained by U.S. Coalition Forces at Al Baglidadi.and BIAP, IZ.6. , , . . • • ,/,,, Investigation established there was insufficient evidence to prove or disprove the offenses occurred as alleged by Mr./IN mr.4111110atle9ed he was put in stress positions, punched " in his face and stomach, choked with an unidentified tool, and later punched in the stomach i •e_.‘%;-41. until he lost consciousness. Mr...stated he fell down on barbed wires and was draggedP,', ,,,,, ,• by his feet until he received cuts to his body: Mr.41111111.tated unknown individuals pulled his Mins and legs backward, causing his shoulder to disl6Cate. Mr.4111111related the abuse '6 ?Cr-eA-r- occurred at Al Baghdad', IZ, by unknown person(s) and BIAP, IZ, by agents of the Federal • Bureau of Investi ation . FBI -FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 0 1 4 8'8 3 • • LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE • • • • 000004 DOD-023958 3) Ogorto. )09100.10 the interview„I-00000o , 004 6• 1*0000:4 iot0iY10w4 .1 dol ermined. he was transE,ferred from AI Pootwoa IZ, to ptiVi 0.44r their cares between which time he was medically screened and no observations of 1001t. ini6aek Mar 04 v000:ovictot,*EBl personnel indicated at no time during their interviews of he • in enY way; - - . . . . , conducted on 11 Mar 04 and 13 Jul 04 `7 " • • medical6•_ • Ad screenings 'Jere _ neither of Which ClOOOrnentedtre.etrnent foti Or noticeable injuries to his person, which might haVe 9"7.04sed. by punching' -"-being -'4' 21.-1-z 7"1' across barbed wire, STATUTE Articie 128, UCMj: Aggravated. Assault Article 93, UCMJ: CrueltY and Malireatmenf Article 81; UCMJ: Conspiracy EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION; Attached: '_ • . , 7 Jul 04; detailing the receipt of 1. Agent's Investigation Report (AIR) of SA , • M_ e_Of Transmittal 0067-04-CID7(39;'cbcirdin000 with /the FB,J; interview of SGT . . _ and query of 1st Cavalry Division Detention Facilities. .6 --7?‘‘`''6 z6• • 2. $Worn statement. of SOT 7 Jul 04. .4* ..'” -2. • ". the coordination with A CO, 202 MI Battalion . a AIR Of .S , ailing__ (RN), Baghdad Central Confinement,Facility (BCCI*),Abu Ghraib, IZ (AGI); interview of Mr: and interview of SPAM :064":(‘-44 • 21JudetJun. 4 . . . ible Prisoner Abuse, Abu Ghurayb Prison (lu raib), 16 Jun 04, 4. Statement of Pos s - detailing allegations of abuse made by Mr. .0 5. Detainee records of Mr.(13 pegei): • •. •. -.x7 c-K-(6' K rn 19 Jun 04, including English translation. • . -• 6. Sworn Stateent of Mr. • . . • OG.:-/1 _ -- fe 7. AIR of SA 1-4 JUI 94, detailing the receipt,of Request For Assistance (RFA), , ,.., 4 a allaan re-interview of Mr.d photo graphs of Mr.. .476-6 okte-. Collection of intetrogati6h reports; interview CPT • • • : • • ,_• . 8. Detainee PreinterrogatiOn Evaluation ; 11 Mar 04., 14 Jul 04, including English translation. 9. Sworn statement of Mr. 10.Photographs of Mr. 7e-/,14-/ 16 Aug 04, detailing the receipt of RFA;, and Coordination with the 11.AIR of SA 4.e.st• FBI and U.S. Ai% CriminalInvestigatich Command: AWL J. 26 Aug 04, detailing the receipt of RFA; interview of SA 12 AIR of SA SA and S ‘ 7e,.4 is fr- f 014884' FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE' 090005 6 ) 5 0190-,04-Cf1)250-13034 •6•6.6.6 . • 5• .6 13. FBI report, Case ID #; 315E-HQ-1404383 SUB VBIED / lED, 1 Mar 04. '14. Sworn Statement of SA . •. ,. • — ... ( 7.swort.1sla.totto00t•o 16:Sworn Statement of SA. :19 Aug 17, Photographic COVer$beetehd . COntactsheet,'.depicting•photOgraphS of Mr, . personnel during hisinterview. . . 7e: •-• 24 Aug 04, - • •1 • • ." P • - . 10.. Sworn Statement of$A 2.6 Aug. - .6 , 20 AIR of S. .24 Sep 04, detailing the receipt of RFA and interview of SA 21. AIR of SA 17 Oct 04, detailing final coordination with the Office of the Staff.b 76 Judge Advocate, Camp Victory, 14 • • . • • Not Attached:. . Maintained in original case file. • '7Z-• 22. Personal Data Report and Interrogation Reports of Mr.111111Pki (Documents classifiedaa . . • • / "Beotet.n) • • • • • The Originals of exhibits 1 through 3, 6, 7, 9 through 12, and 14 through 21, are forwarded with USACRC copy of this report The originals of exhibits 4, 5, and 8, a r e maintained in the files of the Magistrate Cell, BCCF, AGI. The originals of Exhibit 13are maintained in the files of the Federal. Bureau of Investigation, Washington; D.C. . . STATUS: This is a Final (C) Report. This investigationwas terminated in accordance . paragraph4-17(a)(6) as the SpecialAgent in Charge and the Battalion Operations Officer determined that furtherance of the investigation would be of little or no value and leads remaining to be developed would not impact on the investigative findings of this investigation. Leads Remaining: a-1 _ a. Locate, fully identify, and interview members of the detaining unit to determine where Mr. p• ( 411111vas detained after capture. • b, Conduct canvass interviews of individuals conducting detainee operations, at Al Baghdadi, IZ, . to determine if any instances of abuse were documented involving detainees and if they observed and signs of abuse or injury while Mr. as under their control 014835 • 3 , FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 0 0. 0 0 0 6 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE .,6.6. .- .6. ' ,.6 ..6 .6.. .6. . ,. ....6, • 1-but u*ka,_, .0.10., 6th. Street, Fort. oovoir, ,,wv.zzpog.70§90 (original) • 14.17iro; CDR, 227.F .0 BN (CID) (FWD), APO AE 0034.2':•:1., '' • .•!' : .- - ---•:' . .. 1-0 CDR, $;'-:ci Iv. Group (0.10.-...-. . -. :•.;:'.; - : - • • - ,•, i . . • • •• , . ...• •,. • •% • ..: .., .• • . . • To:, CDR, USACIDC, Arv, cloP-zA i. Fort Belvoir, VA 22060 . • 1-PMO, kliNF,1 (6-#011. only) . :. ' . • 1-To: CID 1,40„401F-4, APO AE 09342 (e-mail only) • .,:. :,,',,•::.,' 1-Office-of the Staff Judge Advocate, III Corps, ATTN: CPT(emailonly) 1).2 .;/ .. . 1-File • • 014886 4 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY . LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE . r • 000007 Rot Numpg eceived a Meinotandint, of Transinittal, 00 .67-61-C11)789 fix:4n the , central Confinement Facility (BCCF), Abu Ghraib, Iraq that Mr.., reported he was abused while detained ai13 A ri - SA and S this office, Coordinated with SA, .„, irea& ureau of . Iraq and briefed him on the at ohs -o a use that may involve FBI Special Agents. SA stated 11..c wouldiiifiOuihiS67e/t‘/1.1art ''s and did hot want smile nvestigation.. investigation., . . AGENTS COMMENT: 'SA rovided a copy of the case file for their records. 4 6'...(6.1 4s7c-Kr‘ke • About 1005, 7 Jul 04, SA • interviewed SGTAMIMIIMIIIIIIIB 50r Military Police Company, elder, APO AE 09034 (dep oy to Iraq) who provided a sworn statement whe ein he stated he could no r e-tim er Mr. being released to him, but identified his signature on the DD Form 270$ SA stated the DD Form 2708 bearing "with minor bruises & scratches" was not in his handwriting and he did not know who added the sentence on to the remarks block of the form. SGT stated if he received 4.67c-detained with any type of marks mi their bodies he would docuinent the mark.% on the DD Form 2708 and have .a medical screening conducted. on the individual prior to entering into the facility. /7e About 1200, 7 Jul 04, SAgenimogroonducted a query of the ls' Cay Detention Facilities, BIM; Iraq data base in 'a search for interrOgation reports that were drafted to document the interrogation of Mi. The search did not disclose any Summary Interrogation Reports (SIR), further revealing Mr. as not interrogated at the 501 4 Military Intelligence detention facilities.///Last Entry/// TYPED. AG_AME AND SEQUE C .NUMBE AN] •-• -•*"4 • 8 MP OFF (CO)(FWD) -BAGHDAD, IRA() SIGNATURE DATE iu194 CID FORM 94 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY L 0 14 VV. FEB 77 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE 000008 r 04 ic1.02$9.*8023. 1 WORN.$TATEMENT Fax NUMBER LOCATION • 190,047CP259-80234: • BIAP DATE 0of NAM S acleigtatus: E-5/AD_, Police Company, Bauinhoider, APO AE 09034 AN:• TO MA_FOLLOW' NG STATEMENT 'UNDER OATH • pe/ ( am now showing you a DD Form 2708 bearing your. Signature and dated 4 Mar 04; do you recognize this form? A: yes. Q: Is your signature on the form? Ar Yeg, it is- Q: Is everything correct on the form? A: AlI except "minor bruising/scratches", . Q: Do you know who wrote on this form besides you? A: No._ ._• Q.: If a detainee arrived with bruises and scratches, what would be your protocol? A: First I would have him medically checked. Q. How would the medical personnel document the injuries? A They log it onto a medical screening sheet, which is a separate sheet._67e'-zC6- Q: Do you remember receiving detainee , rom the FBI on 4 Mar 04? ._. A: No, its been quite some time, Q How many detainees have you received from the FBI? A: Maybe a handful, and usually MI notifies us that the FBI is bringing someone in We will keep FBI detainees separate &Pm all other detainees (and they are strict about it we are not suppose to talk to them, we only feed them and escort them to the bathrooms, that is it. The FBI detainee normally retains there civilian clothes and does not get issues a red jump suit. Q: Do you ever recall talking with a FBI Agent, where the FBI agent has talked about their interrogation technkpies? A No they are very Quiet about it. Q Have you ever noticed a detainee that appeared he/she was abused after the FBI has interrogated the detainee? A: No. Q Has there ever been a question of how ,adetainee was handled during interrogation and --1-­ -Lnktirtifedv4irrIardistesd INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT: Page 1 of 3 Pages fc•A OFFICIAL USE ONLY • 0 1 4883 FOR. OFFICIAL USE ONLY • . LAW gNFO.CEMENTSEN$MVE rfoobog EXHIBIT -C113259-80254 "Statement 0 A.: • en-" _the FBI Would signfor detainee. from. your facility, Where would they take the facility, -• •6"6• •6e6•6.••••• .• •6•6• •6. • •.6—6•• detainee for interrogation?).: 00f4i0tyt eonldn't tell $og,. • • . If the FBI, faciiity would they sign for the detaineeOn a P.O.FOrin21081:: • A: Yes they have .• • .. • • • ,• . Do yonknow why the :. etaineefilewould,be _a DD orm 2708? • A: The only thing I could think is the records got lost in e _ Q: Is t iere any reason to belieie FBI Agents abused A; I don't see any reason why, every time they came to see ilk they were very polite._be...4-Qi On DD Form PA dated Mar 04, releasing_ r-om your custody to the . FBI, under Personal Property it states "see 4137"; why would_ is? A; That the FBI Agent took some evidence, apparently if the form says "see 4137" _z‘4 Q. Do you have a copy of the DA Form 4137 pertaining to Mr. _A7c-r7 A: MI has all the records.. Q: Where would I be able to locate a copy of the records? A; 5014 MI is supposed to maintain a copy of the file for one year., Q: Would the FBI have to coordinate with MI prior to releasing a detainee into your . custody? . A: Yes. Q: Was there any eiceptions to this pore1 y .9 - A: No, Absolutely not. Q: Is the e anything you would like to add to this statement? . _. A: N_411111111111111111i11111End of Statementrn/////////////M/MONOMMONOM////// 4 76-6.6 - INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT: 014889 Page "313'' FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY ExHIBIT # 000010 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE Case Nib. 0190 -04-CtD259-80234 difon Jul 94, at fraA, CA;ntii9Jed:'! AFFIDAVIT ‘! ; • A HAVE OR HAD Rgisp. TO mg THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE AND ENDS ON PAGE 3, I FULLY UNDERSTOOD THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITTALP1,1) THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING TO.E'.51N,PMF,Kg I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT TFIRmit oti.,e0¦4$1.4yTNT, WITHOUT • , . COERCION, umAwrtjt. INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL IN '47_4 ‘-F• WITNESSES: • Subscribed and ay/00 to before rild, a person authorized by lawth, to atititinist' day of Jill 2.904. at 61 ORGANIZATION AND ADDRV.S • Special 4i1 • bz-44( . ART 136 T_TCMT (Aut1ior4tO Oniaister &aft) INITIALS OF PERSON MAIGNG STATEMENT: W7 0 1 4 8 9 0 Page 3 or 3 Pages FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FOR officiAL USE (*Cy.6. LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE EXHIBIT #00211 F R C/b Regulation 1 , DETAILS 6, . BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION.: On 17 Jun 041. the 504th.10llit*Joolif 060, Brigade 0:04 Joint Interrogation and 0.0(#0100. 00o* (JIOC ),__Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (00CP)i bu Ohrtiyeb: 1ra (AGI), repotted that detainee' ationat Detainee 7 Reporting System Ocl3Sy NFT, *000 110 Was p its ètained by OaiitiOn ' Forces ,(CE), prior to his arrivrt BcCF. A614: • , • • , • out 10(k,1:,.J4,0.0.4 ;...17060voci 'a goo* written „ th4•office0420.0 MI Battalion (BN), BOOF.•,.A01; detailing allegations. (See Statement) / / • • '.4i • • :'• :••••• -• •-• -•6 .„ . •. . •6 .. About 1700, 17 eviowoofmm.•.c.iotoloao fire; During the review, it couId 7 not be 0000104 whether vas captured on 26 Feb 04 or 4 Mar 04, nor the capturing unit Two statementsthe:regfaliO41,44-or Investigation (rB.1) :*".01(**400.0006.tho.reSoh. for **root and oovprof . .. -, • ... 000.04.•ReCeipta back and fooh between the FBI arid the 21501st Military Police stating In good health..." Each release to the FBI for oestionlhg, .6.747-4c •,.. transported to B0cF. on 11 Mar 04, via helicopter, in "OSI/FBI" custody. (See Detainee File) -• • • • • • • • • •• • About 132,944 104 SA of ..1,1, .. this . 0000i ,_,...„ 6 c//01:wrio.provklel•P sworn statement 67 0-0006.. 14a '4$o'41loopon$; 00 -p05m.w0010otoryl TrOsIPtiOn-of lraolstateoanty.,.:: .. • . .• :•• . . • • .. •• :•••••.. /,‘ . . •••••••••• AOOkitti7iv, 21 : . •fr SPO . interviewed Jun 04, SA 00.10 AO 94,. when he made .a;....00. allegation,: She said Was her fiMt. tr*Vie'.W.:with butha4 been previously interviewed Prior to hetiritervieW with she reviewed No:pc previous interview notes and found no allegation of abuse. During this interview, while covering the circumstances of arrest, he began to explain that during his detention in the BaRndad,‘" ssomeAmerican fOrCes'ouiled.his afros and legs Oackwards, .causing his shoulder to disiocate. She.reCelled seeing a large an.joUnt aoars, to include missingmissing ear, on hiS right side; which 4 • stated was froth a childhood accident. She also recalled finding no medical records in his. detainee file regarding a dislocated atiotildot,, co not recall any other specifics 'about the allegation, . reported. . other than What she had previously reported. r 111M111111111111111111111111/111111111111ASTENTRY111111101111111111111 1111111111111111111111111111111IIII111111111 11.111111111111,1111.101.11 :­ FOR QFFIpiAlo vSt. Qmo 014. 8.91 • ORGANIZATION PRIpOleFt INTERROGATION TEAM (131T)(911)) . Baghdad Central Confinement Facility, Abu Ghtuyeb 0934Z EXHIEPT officiallJ$e CID FORM 94 FOR OFFICIAL U rEnintgIfttiVE ENT USE 0 eferre to: U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA 33621-5101 Master Sergeant Pamela Andrews andrewsp@eentcom.smil.mil 2 014892 • • Referred tot U.S. ARMY MEDICAL COMMAND FREEDOM OF INFORMATION/ PRIVACY ACT OFFICE ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORTH ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT S AM HOUSTON, TEXAS 78234-6011 MR. JOHN PETERSON hnPetersen4@een1ame (210) 221-7826 014893 DOD-023968 eld dui to. Foreign Language Photos.depicting Americans Photos depicting foreign nationals Civilian Agency Records 014894 •¦ • • • • n • • • 0401$1.0.7W: • V1014 OF STATEMENT PROVIDED BY DETAINEE _ NDRS'_• 10'40_ • .• • . • •:_•_ •I am working in Civilian Defense Dept, and when I came back to myfamil _ y, they told me that the American forces came and stormed the house, so I Went back to the forces and I told them that I working in ICDC, and they told me if I can go with them to the base at Albaghdadi, and said_ b cause I know my self that I am umocent. I went with them and they hooded and tied my hands and cut my clothe; and it camouflaged uniform I used ta wear it in or They tortured me and cuffedine in an act called the scorpion, and pouring cold water on me. They tortured me from the morning until the morning of the next day, and when I fell down from the severing tortare I fell On the barbed wires, and then they dragged me from my feet and was wounded and, and they punched me on my stomach, and I am innocent and I have no problems with the Coalition forces and thanks._' • VER1FIE_. TrarislatCf, CategOfy 11, Trans a or Category U. Tiian CorriOration Titan Corporation , ._ • . Assignedlo:,_„ Prisoner ifiterrooation Team. (prr)(ciD) . .75th Military Police (MP) Det. (CID)(FWD)(-) Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (BCCF) • Abil Ghruyeb, Iraq APO AE 09342 • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 014895 UM ENFORCEMENT SENSITIvr • Exhibit (c) For Official Use onlfr-Ufwigliferrianb'ent Use Only Exhibit _ Law Enforcement Sensitive_ • 00'0029 k. • •• • . OF IAL. 01 90-04- '01152 §-80-234 ;...•_• DETAILS .6 ,6 _, . • ,_ •BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION;_Jul 94:i this office received a ate , Assistance . moitoio:4-01b26 00;6Camp a_;,w _ 'ik:bffido t 16 a toot documentation fig olid.' iew a kit* WOO. r ,t) Ok WPW t . ti ire detainee Ile, to indlude all ca ring documentation was 10). Witii Meth 'randUm Of Transmittal 0061-04-C1D7$9. About _04, and-reviewed the B.CCF 1titerr_Ctri,Re 4764.4 0040.4. to6. abuse aliegatior as interrogated on 25 Apr 04 and 14 Jun 04, prior to• the 16 400: .abuse or any physical mistreatment was noted in the 04..0..004006 0...to :tor records. (§00ti'qqttepoo..7i e"oits 00' ecords)_•_• About 1700; 13 Jul . „SA"_Interviewed CPT (DR) 381 st MP SR, Detainee. Aid Station 1 .te ph sica . of $); $CCF, AGI, who stated he conducted a .0.#0,r,. ... • ... •, • „.. • „ • • •• . • • •. • . • •• • erthiS OffiCe.'s.reOpeSt. He stated that._• .as in go_ea tY and was? missing pert_it right eat frbin an injury prior to his arrest. He Stated. that_ hatkoider stir4 .- Detainee_• . . Oh his bOdy :hot OonsiStentwith the MarCh. timeframe. He also stated 04.110 scar the'..detaine• , -_body:Was cOnsiStent*Ith.b#04:..Wiro OR.....1111eske0 the detainee .abOut-Ol: , PO,, ,41 ikkoidentt with led nothing about barbed wire Further, did not atrog m. • ,_•_•_•_• ‘e--.....D.R.41110101e6 provided. 0, Copy . ?f, an initial Medical Screening conducted on _dated 11. Mar ._HO:•h;(* tho-sotcoohth.4.thaqo to mention of abUse other than scars on the wrist, common with extended Use offflexi cuffS', (See' Pfiysical -)tam and Medical Screening) • #61( •. About 1130, 14 AO 04,..SA. with-th0 assistance'of Linguist Office, intervieWed .Detoi0oe ho proVided a sworn staternent .detailing.hiS'aliege (Soo $wo.rq Statement and • raholotiohy. ••• •. . . • . ._ 7e-0‘1 AGENT'S COMMENT: described a black stick that extends like, a knife. Further description given to this Agent, re-yea. e it was similar to an ASP._ • ‘-7 About 1135, 14 Jul 04, SA, exposed photographs of _back and face using a Nikon Digital Camera, which clepicted no scarring consistent with his a iegationg. (See Photographs) Status:- Your RFA has been completed in the attached enclosureS, No further is anticipated by this office. • • 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111(11111111111111111111LAST ENTAY111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111611111111111111111111 .ORGANIZATION pikisO.NekiNTSFIrkooATION TEAM (Rrt)(00 Baghdad Central ConflotibOtit_Abu Otrailsi 030 SIGNATURE DATE _6EXHIBIT izt Jul....,:. . .....,. GID FCR! 94 USE ONLY-LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE flan nix n ReferredL to: U.S. ARMY MEDICAL. COMMAND FREEDOM. OF..INFORMATION . • PRIVACY ACT OFFICE . . ATTENTION: MCFP 2050 WORT171 ROAD, SUITE 13 FORT S .M HOUSTON, TEXAS • 78234-6013 • MR. JOHN PETERSON Jal Petersoni- centrante -mil- (210) 221-7826 014897 Withheld due to: Foreign Language _Photos depicting Americans _Photos depicting foreign nationals _Civilian Agency'Records • 014898 _ to dayy,00.•1100, :• .. • gd twhat-ci ott -ere arrested:. . anbar PrOlhoo.6Heo ,, NitatiMOocii heighbor 1lk^ re did they take erroWereerrest- . , o.000hdaj base in Atanbar Proyinoes; : . • . arrested andijejOrrtieutduS those who :aftested'youl:•: Nho • ••:.:•••••: ,•. • Went tO police station;. and I asked thetli why they were asking for me, and there were •three hurrivees 41.0,4 'of** station, 01 went to a white ••nion:.oah soldier and j said to hirn, ."why you were eeKr • • og former • :,,• ....•,.:: . •:.. i. Describe to us what happenedlys,fhen they took you .to . . . • . en arrived they down my head p'ovor on my eyes and wrapped myeyes w. a blue tape, and they took Me. to a place 1 did not know and thenthey remove the. , head cover oft my oyeswhen they brought me down. froM the•hornve* . and they jefmeset:•••down, and then they entered me rhafoorn and I openfetj my eyes and saw a white American • sOldier. With blue eyes, .00.004010010 with a forple, 'then a black soldier and other two. • sb10.100 . 0.0010 and cut my ototh00‘With.0 scissor and he was lookftig at me angrily and he extended his-fihgerS towards my eyes. as it he wae going to Nll it out, and he cut my clothes,and then they took me to the, henget and let me sat down, I heard some detainees talking about 44Z.5;00-rlvitailleanci they said that he one who is doihd torture: At night they started torturing ootpiori cootoory thai. oba.fhey tied niy.hen4S jo my INS behind my back and thoy polod and I stayed on-0400106 fOr one or two hours, and they tied four OoxeS. -of canned food and Out it on My shoulders, and thes(Qhler00 me fo.MOVe, .and they to legs also.00xes of canned food tied to chains; and lettne . in04, and if I fall -on the groono from been tired, theypoured . cOldWetar•On me, and they sit me dOwn for ten minutes, and after-that they started. .torturthg, egaih• They gave me:Oheci7 two oottles of -water aho they:0000 me to drink it while was huhgry.and they foro4rne to drink it, so I did, and I felt vomiting, then they ordered me to. • drink again, and they were looking at me and laughing : At the next night they• started torturingme and they also tied my legs and hands and 'put theocxes on my shoulders and then theyuntied my legs and put t* . ptizes on the grouno and ordered Me tostep up•and down fast . the Wee, and started. stepping up and down until I felt dizzy and I fell dOwil on the .gfaiho i then they poured cold Ole!' on me to wake the up, 00.they started tortur0g me again until the next morning. Next nighttheytook. me to another hanger and there was a dark room where they tied me to a standing bed and they run loud music like the devil's voices. A pooh came tome and talk to me from babitiorr4 back and said to me oOrlfeeS, and I said to Nth:J.0 not 00w. any thing, then he . sterted punching me on my stomach and my face, and he pUnched meon Mystornach four tirriek and on my face twice, then he got me out after a ION time while I was tied; and two persons wearing civilian clothes came with him; and they hadsOmething black on their eyes, and one of them started 04000g:0 061 and he put it on my neck and he started,poging me backward, and the persOn who was wearing American -clothes, and ho, is the person that have tattoos on his arms, then he started punching me on My stomach hardly and I lost rny:cOhsciousheSCencl then they w0k0d me up endrefOrried me back to the other hanger .-where the clot00001 were in, and they said to the soldiers; torture him, then they•started•.torturing nie again, and it wa tying in the $66rpiOn operation: and. carrying WS. and When I fell 'down on barbed wires tlidy cfradgec1 . 1110 from my feetuntil I get cuts in my body , then they -..... hands to . My legs 001 was transferred to Baghdad- AirpOrt • • While you were in your Way: to Albaghdadi, were your hands. tied?' 00: Official Use Only -. La* Ent rcenyent Use Only -_• Exhibit . 014 9 • (6: 00 -035 -• DOD-023974 190-04-60259-80234 witte4-04,eleteg" Na it Was not tie ..,. 6‘60.. 7166. to us the pe oh with .tf erblue eyes in defei Ne was , had blue eyes, blond hate, vGhitefage# and he put tattoos tan his arrne-Whet') the bIggk Soldier put his fingetS`66`60 40ai did 110 preseed ydur eyeS; pr touched it only?' .6 . A; 114 did not touch my eyes,s, he was threatening me only, _ Describe tO Us the so fon ositicp, A ey tied my hands and legs.behind my back and I was lying on my stomach. Where yOU use. the imatattoo:064; did You Mean the inCident you have Mentioned in your staterr.Jeqt? • N Ye*:: , . Q: Can you deScnbe to us the person who punched you on your face and your stortach while you were in the dark room? _ • • did. Opt. see himclean Itfa;cal,40 there Wad tiO light in thp Ogrn . Can OP descnbe to us the blaCk thing, which weared by the persons wearing civilleh ciothes1 I . A it was black nylon with holeS over the eyeg, • Describe to uS the black tool, which was used by the civilian Person do pull back your neck. N It was solid like a stick with 'a white thing extended frOin it like a knife. Q; Were your eyes covered during these events? A. No; -• ///tnd of Statement//.l. VERIFIED BY:TRANSLATED • Mr. • Mr. Trans a or,. • ategdry tranSWar, ate4OrY I titan CorPOratiOn Titan Corporation • Assigned to Prisoner Interrogation Team (PIT)(CID) 75th Military Police (MP) Det (CID)(FWD)(-) Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (BCCF) Abu Ghruyeb, Iraq APO At 09342 . *eztetlirAtect$1;141 ' For Official Use Only - Law Enforcement Use Only Exhibit 0 014B00 0 0 (1. DOD-023975 d06.. to . Fotoigti Language . Photos depicting Americans • • Photos depicting foreign otional • .Civilian.AgpocyRecords gi 014901 • • FOR °MC/AL USE .ONLY.. • Law EnfoementSpnSitiVe. z 3 4 0 19 0 INVESTIGATION RE ..00:4:00.14100$4 •.... • •• BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION; out 1200, 30 Jul 04, this o ce received a Ca Ssistc*e (RFA) from the 3rd Mill y POlice Group 78 ent(FWD), 474c Baghdad, At 00342 re offenses of -Assault, Cruelty and it, and Conspiracy. A WO 04140. ste4 this office identify, interview pc-a. investigation ..,.. anx ; Dallas Field e, Dallas, TX,_ concerning pertaining iiailOiteerrt NDRS It was further reque sted this obtain toatts satTqii6i*tk. oh a,*().4i skasompui. 4.v.41 POtal* g4 detention, interrogation, and release 044. FBI cv.5todY to Wald -P techniques. ize ce tCt1m 7C.Cf •. About .1.145 5 Aug 04; Oftlina.ted with SA Chief Division Legal • Cou Ce and briefed him on all aspects of the inytijion nselor, FBI, Dallas Field 67 About 1.410 10 Aug 04 , S coordinated with SA who related he coordinated with e. 7 / Mr. Section et, Counter terrorism Sectior, Washingtoii D.C., who stated the mtervie of SA wOuld be coordinas dough the headquarters of the FBI (Washington D.C.). 17e,-/ 4;7 About 1431, 16 Aug 04, SA oordinated with CW Federal Liaison Officer,' USACIDC, and briefed him on aspects of the investigation. All requested investigative activityhas been completed. No further investigative activity is anticipated. Ibis file is closed in the files of this office. III Last Entry/// (4' '4.1WWMAGE141:4111WEQUENG8NUMBER-4 ,_ Fort Hood Resident Agency, 6th MP GRP, (CID), Fort Hood TX 16544 SIGNATURE DATE_ EXHIBIT 16 A.ug 04 • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 0 0,0on 04 O f I. 1FEB 77 FOR OFFICIAL USEONLy_ EXHIBIT • La.w Enforcernent Sensitive _ DOD-023977 AGEN PP7A-#4.( .6 .6 .6 . . . . , . BASIS FOR iN.VES.TI.PA1:19Ni, On 28 Jul6office received Category 1 RecjileatfOr Assistan ce. MP Pp(CIP):APOA0 09342 to locate, fully identify and . interview SA - n Field Office, Federal Siiread. 010;00100* WaahlriotOk DC yo yernen tnan: interrogation6an Iraqi ' • '•• •/ • ' • • • (M110, 1 1 Aug 04, SA,, sworn Statement detailing . hi4 knowledge Of the thtehijaW o rovided an FBI report a synopsis f the ' re* *WO* ' " doW , . 1730;. FQ: who rovided a swot • statement detailing hiS aternent of S or details . . . , _ At 1352, 19 Aug ,04 S nterviewed SA ,....:, WhO provided a sworn statement detailing his itIP, ant of Mr sworh statanient of $ fot details) g 7c-7 e‘-'/ ..‘g pc4. i.....7:-. . 6,6_;. 6. . v ' A0ENT1 'NOTE: 8 _ _ aye SA -SC 6.6. ,, ,s7c(- a :cornpact di arid contact sheet containing photogra hstaken Of M6Uriir hii.inteMeW at the 131AR ' . provided te compact disc and contact sheet to - / . 0 -6-6•6-15 ' 67e-Ktr this. office, SA644.1.10t know the names of the detainees he treated at the mit!: SANIMIllyieitvesgei ,,, _ tho p§roct oefoorid 1_Iliad the *4 folded individual 41.1 cloSest to the camera in photograph in.) as the rc-individijal he treat • . _ .. prepared ai:OOSter sheet ideritifyingiheinn dividuars in the phOtOgraphSa4Oarding t4' )4.7,' SA s'; igentified by SA is the cousin ofeMpviiO•VvaS informing On hirn .Unaware th6. was i ich explains his blindfOrd6a COnth t Sheet and COMpact Disc for details)' : ::: '. . . ' -. -,..:.'" -• - ' : ' ' ' • : , - :•' ' . ' - -aa, ....,. At 1646, 24 Aug ' 04, SA nterviewed S, FP who provided a sworn6,„,.. r statement detailing hit. knOwledge of MM SA gel his only involvement in the inte AI ated, . rview protest wasteL-Y Mr . 666, . picking up6AL ASAD and bringing him to the BIAP. (See Sworn Statement of S or cletails)6Z:- 0./. 6. -, At 1350, 26 Aug 04, s terviwed S , FO w ovided aa SW647c1 i ',6,r" 4 statement detailing his jmoWledge of the interview of M (See SWorn StateMent of S or details) OZ- q • ,656, STATUS: This RFA is OlOsed in the files of this office as no further investigative activity is anticipated.///LAST ENTRY/// FOR officIAL USE 0111:1 LAW ENFORPEMENT SENSITIVE 75th MP. bet (clip) 31), MP Grp, USACIDC . SA Fort Belvoit, VA 22060-5592.. : SIGNAT DATE , EXHIBIT 6 • 024 y .6OFFICIAL USE.: ONLY 14-0-.03 1 'EB 77 0. 00041 DOD-023978 • Referred. to U:S.Diq'MTWWNT O USTIcE FEDERAL INATSTIGATIQN. RECORD INFORMATION DIS SEMINATION RECORDS MANAGEMENT DIVISION -• QOVER.NMENT.RESPOINSE RIVI .6296 - . , , . 1 -Nsy j., ANTA'AVENUt,'NW ASHINGTON D '-Q,0535M01 *.” • • •7 .6 . MS. BELINDKNIGHT 4,•4 src@fk gov ,, -„J:144f oi:41 .tz.*ft,* , ¦¦ -'(202) 3245S .::46744 4*.a.1.4,64.1.4.1NoggAgz.oi44;A-04,• •• 0 1 1,9014 • • 0./94f..;0'....4010'o-414.13y-,, SIIVgRN OtAltME.St • For use of this form,see aR.19045; ti1iiiiatforieit money is 0401' PRIVACY Rol STATEMENT AUTHORITY 114 10 USC 'Section jet; roa 5 USC Section 2:04 E.0:. 9397 40.4.40-• 0.01*Z$, 1943 (800. OP4IPPA!. OUPOsti To iitcv!4:01rii:0400014eP!Otr*Olent Ptflii4t with means by which information may be accurately identified ROUTINE 11SElf, Your social security number is used as fm.#101.000.10.0111 000,4 of ideatifrcation to facilitate fi:ka and. retrieval. DISCLOSURE: aliCidifore Of ilidr ••;,- • • • • 1. LOCATION' : • • DATE . TIME: 75th MOPET (OIDN port Belvoir, VA 22060 2004tos/1 FiApliklitt„,141DoLtNA14. SSR 7. GRAPE/SIAM GS-I3 .(4) oFIONIUT11141 Federal biikean. "Vestigatiali, n field 0 Ce, Washington DC 20535 . ,.waiNT-rp MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH: 67 At, SA . . -.'' : r Q:: What t oriiiiially.eafintred.Mr 4 161 , A 1 dOuit " CiiiK:, . I . think. r i was the Irv. Q:: Whefe was edr_viiii 4i the BIAPI. 674-6e.:::: . H A: ' AL ASAD Aix . . . ." ..‘ 4G Q: Dicl yOn iriterviOW Mr t .. ? / .-: 6 ' 47 4: Yet, .On 29 Feb 0 4-:..- ... ... . _. :. . . . • Qt Do yOU hay any:.Icpowled .used at the AL MAD Air Base prior to you interviewing hina At No • ' .7&-f/6-. “ Mims -G . . . . -7, -1C At:. Otheri.. e his feet scratched nothing was visible, ‘--./.. , , „. dr, , Q Did r ,have any visible. Juju* when you interviewed-hinti at the aASAP Air Base on 29 Feb 04? 4,, ,,4a".. xii than -47"'i6­ ;Q: Did • i.ammireMake ant complaints to'make you about belt% a # ' ....... . . AL ASAD?.6,.7 'V/ 6,k-cf-'• . • t. .140:.- rli. 74=4.a/P,---•::: • .. : .'•-• ' .. -. .. ..7 Q W.h.eii•WaS the ,nett time you interviewed M.M.r. . .. ,.. ' • -... W‘i6" A A few days later at the j3IAfi; He was flown to the'BIAPb• heli . around 2 to 3 asys later; 1111V--. •;-. • • . „.,.,..d Q.:: Who escorted Mr ' the BIAP from AL ASAD9 C- A I think an OSI a en'' t was with hum but I don't knots, ifhe was his actual escort. A' Q: Did have any visible injuries whet!. Yoe. interviewed him at the BIAP. 74'-4';`,5-614"-AeC‘:/ -"-4et‘ • . A: Hit feet belt up and Seratlieed froin -sy'alkin8 around barefoot. That's when I ought li." itm,Sonie flip flops: it Q: Prior to interviewing . did you ever sign for bit on a DD FOrm 270B? 7 -'' PIA‘e,"-r4 , • . ,..--,-.-- -• A: .1•10 I've .neVer: seen a DD .oriti 270 poor to. you showing lite oue today.; .11p p ,==-.-•/4"-.,7 , ,,,,,-,..-_. z,:- Q: Did Mr4111111111.Make att 'COM 1 ' abOut abilse.when you interview . at Iiiin at the BIAP? 6 ..-r..D..Kr • M: No: A firght•iiirse, SA . ..... , . acuially looked at .MAIIIIIItit. : . . .. , .. . , .nothing needed M. be reated. There. WaS,,.. ­ : . ...., _another detainee. narded thatliadentS On .his. Wrist that needed medical attention. I talked to... . . . .. . . :. , . . . .: .. . . . last night and he . . .--ip--,-,a.s s,singaimibut toi -.0. 4, 404 t appear.to need any medical aterittOn, SO he just attended te for a couple of IC'-$- 'n.t.0 I thifor ' .gOt hia injuziepto_pgie plastic cuffs he had ou. aili, .4 74.--•‘./,, -404-:t,tr-,7 .!.. 'Where did the frorn? ..FPFc-,-77-f.0-7.-: .• --!" • 60-:--.7.,' . A: He was .arreStecl ill MI.JHANIMADIA. and hrOtight tel AL ASO on I..thlTilc 29Feb 04. He Witt arreSted by Seine military unit. I clOn't bib*. Weinay haVe talke(1 to bird St AL ASAp, We did talk tO • " at AL ASAD. • /milk .Qt. Did NM coraPlaiii ' inipeing abused by the Ca. .ti,trifig unit? . 674...-f4; .#-'' . - . A; NO:: glik:' 6 '".--4 . g::7-.1 • . : ' .. •,,,,--, 0. ‘.. z-.-. ee'.--- -• A; I t.hfnic he Cake On" e sarne helieopter as 1111111-7!---711"0"/i'-• -• Q.: ' DidlIMISCOMplain tO you AbOuthiSinjOrieSat the BIAP? ...7-_f- . -. 4,.•../-6z-.• , ,,....(0. A:. No, We notieed tern and bad SA caf a nnoit_ iiMor. - . ;.,....1_(.: . fr,-. il • . ‘ • Q; What kind of interrogation tethiniques yon use while interviewing Mr A We ,lust Sat them. in a chair 04'M semi-cirr in front of them, WeSpo O (011ittnthrorpreter. The only thing. . ti on; interpreter we did was yell at times ' 7e-Ark-f6. treated during yOur interviews? .4 c-- sri .r Q: How was Mr and ,.., r.7 / .. ' -L.L..: 4 4.1 A It was cordial, W-e-Offered them MRE's, bottled water, pop tarts and I think power bars. 111 twc.-, r,...,_ Q: Did yon. ever co lete any interrogation reports on Mr after interviewing him? 7C—t7s41-4 A: No. SA and I think SA mpleted them. Z 7G RIikaffiliffer7fir' PAGE 10F 674`--1-1 • PAGES 400111.0.1114 PA6ES MUST CONTAIN TNe I/44Pb* 13:41410.;,T Qt. $ iclAk IME4DittLy -!. DATED THE BOTTOM PP EACI .400; liPN4L.PASE4111$7-844$ Mat TIESENSOthaBfkbflIST B4B5 INPICATEP, • k6•6,6.6• DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 ,..,,DIELA 2828, JUL 72, IS'OBSOLETS 4. UffigIAL USE ONLY EXHIBIr • „ • . DATED 2004/08/11 • ••••• • • -• • SA _4e at Where ota A; Atthe WE 7e-o, Q1 Is there , an 'thin else you wish to add to this statement? • • .6 • . firn.miti llmnoli///ENI) OF STATE .011/11.0/0 not1ollotioilitowth1100 ..„ • AFFIDAVIT I,_ , HAT HEAD OR HAVE HAD READ to ME IIII StATEMENT WHICH BtoiN§. ON PAGE I. AND ENDS O N PAGE • 2 . I FULLY UND ERSTAND THE OONTOligvF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE Bfig., TR STATEMENT IS TRUE. .t HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INItigtot0E6000 OF En0 r4pg, piwtAINiNG THE STATEMEkr, I HAVE.. MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT • • ' • Ottigi,d1441,00di INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFULINDUCEMENT . . 741( ' . (Siti*ii#7 of Person Making Stitlmend WITNESSES: Subscribed and sworn to Ootoinio, a Filson authorized by liv.f to administer oaths, this 11 das, of 6• August , 2004 at 76th MP DET (C11)5 $ Fort Belvoir, VA 22060. fl.!1!?!s . 5 USC 363 ' • ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS pup fyite To AtImkistei baths} r(Pt OfPIC emu& OF SON MAKING STATEMENT . W E4R3111.CEalEhrt sEism_I 4 7cf-t,a.-GE 2 OF PAGER . , -" 7 PAOE DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 01 40 V114 8 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY IF DOD-023981 SI*0).i.10 StAltf40$ brbib of alls. see '10A 00 proponent 0001.4 ODCSOP ._111140'. 'ACT ;TAIIM:01' Title 10 Pc Section 30.I Title,5 USC Section 290;4030140001040.b1 PRINCIPAL. PURPOSE :. To if:v:44(400E40i and fb4.000bbbbbi officials with 044 by which iRfomtat ori may be accurately idenpfied ; ROUTINE_•_Y.Oiliiiilattatirhib i.40:44 **lb* kdditigOolialtOPIO means of 14001Ko0411 facilitate DISbiestist_of_iimitiOr-LtiiotoOtiiyK LQCATIoN 2:: DATE MAP.V1P.11?".. 75th MP DET Fort Belvoir VA 2:2060„. • 2004/00/12 • 8: ORGANIZATION QR ADDRESS ,„. _• _•_ ._, fec10 _'ea# Oflnyeatigation, Washington Field Office, Washington DC 20535 iiittcria MAKE THE 04440 StAfaigiO1)08. OATH; 1. S Q: -".VilatittutLon _-, .70a0.It A.3.•• .T.hejteite he was ieked.utihy. the Tcpc then turned over , to rtes ' AL ASAD. I ean'ireMember what unit Q WhereWat gr._detained prior to**hit: at the BIAP9 •fe.7 - A wo..gt.st -_---46­ plei bit#* , ..'ef At; -: )3a$04.4,74-0.se • ... # Qpid. you intet*iew mk . at the AL AsAD-Air Base? 7C` .4. 4. '-ei ,A,,, Yes, on 29 Feb 04 ?4"--'/' 4.70:77y7:' , • ;.-- - ' - : • Q Do yon . g.,4 y ledge of Mr being abused at the AL ASAP Air Base 64 to you interviewing him? _him? _• ' A: lloo. (C71-. . . ... . • . : . Q Did. Mi have any visible injUtiet h when you interviewed_him a e bk ;Ajlo i..,AAltDase on 29 Feb 04? ‘7(..'":6. A: Not that Wereif a hundred years 'old. He was just messy and_._,_ 9: s .10A -, (k: DI:V.14r make any complaints to you about being abUseti at AL A _-, ‘7,4'.-- 0; Ofr'-`7". A lic?....goitze..*:4•41baek wi. 4.0Ote froth$10epin ''on a hard Tloor 74-4 di.e. , Q ' When was the next tome you iiite . ._ -'' 6 :7 :4.(4:.(''' f' A A few days later 'at:the:MO 7ti _ _.. 0:-' Wiiii escorted•t._from AL ASA '04­ ......... _..„,..4.0P"r-• ..,..... , . ... A:. I thint it iiiiii _ou-a liewcopto,--,(PP, "T_. /..,' e..p 4 41.0 7c.. _.__ .. Q, I . . .6. a.ve .anyy.3.,st le.inittrieS 'when ou "fervieWej in at"theBIAI 01 (a ' • 1 - • - Af. NO:- He-WO:A* dirty. and. had nO. theet . _. .--/, ts"0"-r • -.., ' - • - ._• ' i -2-‘...er- Q:: PriOrMinterkiewnIZMralliptdidyotreiier sign for hirn oil a DO Form 2708? PP - -- ° • ' •• _•_ . g`'` Q:: DO • Oil kW*, whyMr4111111ftwat reeeived back i:g1 a DD Form 2708 with "minor bruising .and scratches"? - '‘76-_II- i -• ikv No; I dort rmow .why itbg ii§ted tere: The.Writing On.* DD Form 270$ "received in good health" and . "'with minor hruising am. Soratohesn looks differeinte. pe hal ito,44.1es w.lien we received him or brought hit back, He had no shoes 0SA.alifijo'bought ltirrt tOrnelW ,#,' 74-7; 44' 1":" • . - Qt DitiV_' Make 40 Cotordakto 'to yOtt about Anse ¦Allien.yoll '7, . -.‘"i67 iAtOvioAre.c.1 at .high at the DI?6- .,.. A.: NOW'_7 ---.-_ b4--,,, - . . .: ., ::.- .. ... • .• :.-..... ......•.... .7A? 4 , --;:-. . Q; Whatkind of itentgation techniques' did: y o it use while interviewing MS1111111111 _4 7471. .-a f: ' A: He Sat ina chair sad we *ould sit Semi-cirCtilar arOund hit% We wouldthroW " event questions at hit quickly to confuse hint. N.:We WoUld'ask. general .qUestiontind then throw one in that *at pertinent to see if he WOuld slip to: It was a relaxed as it could be.. The tail., tlth'n':­ ...Wie did Wat yell and tat. WO during do_to confuse him.41111. -6-7c-*.'1,ky . Q: 46.4 was. Mi'i_and treated *144 Yciu,r lUterYieWs?.6X-K.7. 6.61 . .-- ' s_. - ' ._'_ A.; He was. treated.ProfeSsionally.. We gave-hit, food: Let hiln tako 7palts"andute the latrinp when h • needed tO ''''764_/1. 'IQ! Did you opt cci lete any nuerrOgatton reports owl*ter intemeWingluM? 6 *-' . .... . ... . . M Yet after the 29 el). 04 interyieW. rt livas Tovided.to y-n .., Q: Ate tete aty mOre. repor.ta CO,tiCenging :t4 , .01:1 P°6:Pr Owdiclolirtio.°ri 15i;ot Did tMY14040tr.v4il‘47.4 7-421tOsOf after iliintervieWt? 67C ' i.t.' (‘.:..--14.-4• • '_ Ai rtiot to the interview on 29 Feb.04 he _eiprind 54 phOtograplied. To the best of my knowledge they should be located with the . Original file at the 131.Ar. ‹. .../(pk . rz, . ...,,, Q .--Wliti _ cab:hide_'''_irvieWS of-Mr_with '_. on? 40'(:• . • 1706-,, - SA PAGE 1 OF '1711ts.' - ADDMONAI PAW *St CONTO rifothoe-sp: FF)00. DATED Ptit.OTTON iA:e1 bthhli*AL P;16E *Sr 8 ; UMBER MIST BE BE INDICATED. " DA FORM 2823, DEC 1990 OA FORM 2823, AIL 74 IS OBSOLETE ,_- FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY EXHIB • 0/7q70.., Fort Belvoi•, e. y0 w.44:0 adc fo thus statement? OF S. 41/10011/1/1/11/11011////// ////1/0 a 191 z,-(1‘4,-( AFFIDAVIT .6,6• HAVE ssAntill HAVE HAD READ TO Kty!S STATEMENT' WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE L AN ENRs. ON PAGE62 _. I FULLY MOS?* THE CONTENTS OF THE EM7RE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE:1 HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND NAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE OtAtMEAlt 1 HAVE MADE THIS STATFMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD; WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT; AND if_ "— R UNLAWFUL . • 6744/ 6S'IgnalurfP '_. WITNESSES: Subscriber! BO sworn to Of* me, a perspri authorized by law to adminiater oatirS,_12 '4'0 of'August. 2004 at 15th Mil DET (CM), Fort telibfi',.YA 22066 7e—ifa il,¦ YMITLZT • dig , f,IL LI I oRRANIzApoN OR ADDRESS AIrgholityroAdmin4sterOghst LAW ENFORCEMENT sENsmve: INITIALS Of p PASTES . PAGES POO DEC FOR OFFICIAL *ONLY ' 8. ($ • ,6.6•6• 2y -•-••••• ,6 - RN sTATEmEN SWO.1 , For de of 1his far see AR 1904; the proponent • PRIVACY AcTsritT.popT,,. f.'0).p.o.(soitooliritte•:$ USC Section 2951 .O 9397 dated November 22. 1943 fSSNJ to provide commanders ajid law enforcement offitidis with moans by Which wonnatron may be accura ide4 Your social secunt ingth Disclosure of your social security awn. , . . Federal Bureau of Investigation s:hiO4ton Field Offices Was* 6:00. • 1, • .. • , : 4 . . .. 6... _•_- V. , WANT TO MAKE THE. FOLLOWING STATEMENT pipet UAT:tk_• . ._ .xy-•;-.7.,.1. .. ,_.... .,ope t*.tlip131A_ran .44. I:..wa. st.:9 ...:. 0. #044. XS. .:10.4 P4 t_. ,0 15 144=' 04';. • S_._...,„_... ometime 4. *I cir 00144100 MO 04 SA .• • 1101111..16.. .. ._ _ ..„,_tP:O..t.9 .100k at 't 404P10 of 0.0tateeS•theY.Were,m.te0404. r tog;,' . •Tivent. with them to the. ... OW* hii*Liti`-.. mos.. ti.. 40.*erspro):)ably •.. AntofvieW.g4k7io.tr..,-,e4t. :p IA i . .4'4* one of them IOt..*4u1Stleir-•411 ?-7,. . o' . *64 .troni: fle.4.0uff.k. ij-:y*niOie like an irritational wound not a big deep lieerati* The detaineel. treated had already had ' lialidake.§' on ' wrists and'a.Okiei from someone previously iitoAdink him treatment i•jUkt cleaned the wounds, Oiled some ,• cream and redressed the WOtind.s : anti-bacterial . I examined his feet but there were no obvious wounds Q:-What was the..,of the vidpal -you --e3teg?se A.-o.o.iiie.: 7.: • :: 1 clooif....* .-. . . Qt.. 1:)j.d. YOili. treat • they tiuneeL.,-,.. • A NO 1.. did not. ". 7eti-fc/..s 0,,• •: _._ ._--_•_• - ....-r.:.... -_•_::•• ..._-_•• .•_ ._-_• •iri--_. -' __•_•_•_.. •_. . • :(/: Did.ettli ee comin t yo out being abused while in custody at any time? A:•;;• gti,..":• . .7C-., •• .i.e ,:. .. ; .. Q Did. oip_ , ohae.:010 di t treat appear to be wounded or in need of any medical treatment? * I recall . 1 having4reSging on his wrists but did NA appear to be in any dig' tresgi_of to the roornj-treated the one I thought00 medical attention Neither one had any obvious open or bleeding wounds ., 4..7 4 - 4.c../50...;.. k ifi.,R--*460MVie*s of the 404*W, 91• ix - ' •-•6 , i4ate,..ii‘th ' Q Was first time you met either of the.detaiiiees? . A. Y ,:04.-7-41,ci.., r • Q Do pave any knOwledke of these detainees being abused by their capturing unit? Q:, DO :_'ocv ivho tile de,4thees capturing Unit LS? A N. _..,, 6 7e"-. -ile;/‘-..-K.' -• . - Q. Ls — - . riling eLse you. wish tO add to this statenient? . . k'N . //////i/////1/4/7/5-: /11/r////////////////.//END OF STATEMillik////////////////////// 111111111111111111111.11111111111111111111 12/6///' .111.F ,A9nali1 1317. l'4N01111041aNGOATEME ?AGO OF PAGES .... . .. ....... ..... 40MOIVAL PAGES MU. S.T CoNTAlltrif liEADINg"iStATEld: -DATEQ • UPHLAAL uspotity ..•.. #0.7,70Af EACIIADDITiONAL PA (IFmusterA 'far megligisT.S.feEitimOara . . . . DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 atAggp47,811.g.vrrtuAL uSE72, IS ossotE,T.ONLY 01 4 9 g AFFIDAVIT • .6.6.6. •• HAVE READ DR HAVE READ To Mg TMS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS 0 PAGE '62 . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE 0010. EOTS. OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE: I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED.IHtDOTTOM gEAN•hOt.DOKA1005THE.sTATEmENT, I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WIT1400THOE OF BENEFIT mown, WITHOUT THREAT OF RDNISONi -NFL 44, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMEN • .6. 764ill lament) horalby law b administer oaths this_19 of . August. , 2 4 at 75th MP DET (co, Poi Etelvoir, VA 2206(1 . WITNESSES: SObscribeif and sworn to before ne, a person autiz INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE pAg:. OF ., 26PAGES, POE i,DAiont 23,DEC 199a . FOR OFFICIAL USE oNLy 9 1C) 7) 5 ; • 3:)SQ DSC 001 6 DSO 001 P$07001$ DSC_ 0019 DSC_0022 . s DSC. 0023 DSC 0024 DSC 002$ DSC_0026 • DSC,_0027 Salelat S a1e1a2 U63 . • MrI Mn Mn mt. (Frortt Left to and Si rom Left rorn Left to RI r.914 Left to Ri. and SA (From Lel and SA Mt (From Left to Ri Photograph of Mr *eggr, st 7 S ET (F1)SA 7c--4.4(--7 (From Left to • Right) InfOrtilaiat, Mr — thi 051 Agent-(1\1FIP47‘..5, j OfrOFFI LiSE-OMY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENS)Tivr . . FOR OFFICIAL USE 01)11,•Y _ 014911 r'*. EXHIBIT ) r) 51 1 Foreign Poreit Language .. Photos depicting .Ainericans • Photos depicting foreign nationals Civilian Agency Records 01 491.2 SWORN SIM*. fo:use of Phis fait, e .).•biLli;44‘i; PRO. ACT STATEMENT AU HOfilT1' Title 10 USC Be4kri, E.O. 900:0* Novem6or#06.44 (4'; PRINCIPAL PopepoE to:Piovitf0 0001304.04 and law enforcement officials with means biW4ichinkt0640 may maybe accurately identified; .; ROUTINE USES. • Yiiitrittdrif46..00titionkott$ ded:4 ee ar.i.001.0400 to facilitate Oiland retneva DISCLOSURE Disclosure of your social_ •• 1; LOCATION 2. DATE (rwmppt FILE NUMBER 754 hew:, DE's (CID), Pt Belvoir, 20004 84 , AT, 144M..?.11357.,NAK11411:04 41,41 n Field Offi C 20533 40 Y.01.2.$419!1 •, • "_. WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWiNGITATEMENT UNDER OATH'; *_" „.. „. „. .. „ „.. .. .. , 0i:i 13 lin 04 I arrived in._and Wit stationed at the )14p.: 14 early modh 04, $4. 'asked me to .0.]plek up . a Ciiiipl'of46t.4.0es from AL AAII and bring 0144i back. to the Busy se they could interviewfl I ew a Blackhawk to AL AMP; picked up the detainees andbfOnglit them to the BMFon the same day:,4 • I filled out 4. form transferrin ' • the taineesz764 fibni the_Ll Army to the.PaCCOntioI, I handed, over thetWo detaineeS to SA' 'af*i .$ '404 I .. .: . , strived at th0: 1$4V.. ''---:.::..',.: ','..' i• -•::: ...;.•:' ,'...'. ' .:•.. , .. : -::, :'::' • • . '• - . P77 Q. What unit gave YOU control of the two det ainees? A;-:. It was the 1St 'AM- I can't remember tie 604 Unit . 1.;_ , Q Did yob: knO* the names of the taine4 you fiansferteat,76—_ , . told nae: their names when. we arrived at the MAP, A: No Only when r *rote thot at the form: $ Q: • Dia = a etainees bilk& an complaints of abuse to yOn while in yolit dogtrot? „ A; No..7d7-#/' .,. , . • .: .. • .. ' • — '. ' . Q Did ees look inured or abusedinany way? A: No _7..e-46."0"'K -: ... .. _. Qi.: Did'_part in the nitervieWs of the detainees? . A:. No ._.. . n Q .... a4 you out when you amved at the BIAP? '•&.-4 .6•.' I filled it out fO . A; I.d..1t-0644**9.0.0,..ftt, for, a soldier from 1St AD- (): Is ther' . ' ything else Toti, .Sti. to add.t0 this statement? . . . A: No 7g:. .f •f`fe:' ..... ' . --STATENIE////////////////y///////////////////////////////////- -. --. • • .6. •AitERDISTlitt iOitittet PAGE 1 OF PAGES ADDITIONAL PAGES, MUST CONTAINTHE HEAPING 7TATEMENTOE - AKEN AT DATED •• •: OFF101;.AL,1014913 751E.OtiLy6 #14. apiraw0 ADDIpthig PAGE MI/ST BE)lar.` =REF eiGANUMBER Me BE B E INDICATED: OA FORM 2823, DEC 1998:_ DA FDRAI 2023; JUL 72; IS OBSOLETE FOR OFFICIAL use ONLY Poit Belvoir; V TAKEN AT AFFIDAVIT •, HAVE READ co :1-1Ary$. HAD.REAO TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON . PAGE_• 2 . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTII4E.,0000q..IYiPg BY ME, THE STATEMENT IS TOE I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTION S AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAININ • MOO, I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND'WitHOUT _ UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT., 6.4-0.. 6 WITNESSES; Subserthed aM sWom to before ma, a person authorized bylaw to administer oaths, this:. : 624 of -August 62004 at 75th MP DET (CID), Fort BehrOir, VA 22060- ,14, ORGANIZATION OltADDRESS: lAtithirity To Adini#tet 0,§01 LAVV ENFORCEMENT. SENS!`„P''.:':' INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE 3, DA iimif 2823 DEC 1998. . FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY eife,6-cip..2.0 -er107.?, 6 delerr-90-4-roe,e', ''• • • : •6• .•••6•6SWORN 6-6•• .•6•6.6•6•..„6.66• • • For use of this fenii, see AR .19045; the titepinent agency is OOCSOPS. _• • fli!v4CY. AT STATEMENT • • .._,• AtritithiiTY:_ Title 10 USC Section_Tole USC Section 79g1; EA, 9397 idea November 4 . 1943 OD,.• PRINCIPAL PURPOS E. _fopioirideConT6ndi; and law enforcement officiala with Maine* which ilifigrnati'o0 may be accuratelyentified: ROUTINE_ . • Your social security number mused as an aillikiintilhAtefeate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval • DISCLOSUREi.:_• Disclosure of your social security number is !Mittel:_ .• •_'_• ' jñi 1• LOCATION 2. DATE tryrrmAippi 3. ;7IME4. FILE NUMBER 7. 75th MP DET (CD), Fort Belvoir, VA 22060 20(141041 6. SSN: FIRST NAME MIDDLE NAME: 7. GRADEISTATUS GS-13(4) • B. ORGANIZATION OR AllrifigSS:"-' ..,•Yt;: • ,;•:•:' _- Fed' it.of Investigation, WashiitWashington,_—erai BUre-" gton Field Office r 20535 ,_. • • 67e-ea-g' ,WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER DADE A: SA_ Q; S 4-7(-4 Q: What 'find originaIrtaptured Mr A: I believe it Was7 : ill who were 'trained up at infantry. Their was also an OSI agen involved. I don't imoW his naine. .6.;6 • detained Prior to arriving at the BIAP? ‘.; Q: Where was_ ,. _47 4-- ‘, a 6.-- cc- A We first met him at the AL ASAD Air Base. Q: Did you interview Mr_at the AL AS_ir Base? A Yes, on 29 Feb 04. I also fingerprinteclakotographed and took a DNA sample of Q: Do ou haw any knotledge of Mr _being abused at the AL ASAD Air Base prior to interyiewing him? A: No _, 6 7e-_,-- P-_- •_' Q: • Did_ av y visible injuries when you interviewed him at the AL ASAD Air Base on 29 Feb 04? 470,-(.6. A: No. ,..- ,,_. ,._ .-6 Q: Did any com laints to you about being ibtsp abusedat AL AAD? 0 ' ta,`"ee? 6154,- cc • A: NO, The o_g he complained about was b " - tired andno t any sleep..._• ,_ . Q: When was the nett time you interviewed to _7 oft‘kr.- A: Within a week down at the BIAP._ 4'. fe-• • '. ' -. . Who escorted Mr_'to the B_om AL _,_• '76 (4142_— A4. CA'7-- fc Q Did Mr_any visible injuries when you interviewed him at the BIAP? 4 76' A: He had some dndages on his wrists and f_e_Diju_* ;ip gar) wrists looked like they were fromthe rubbing of the flexi cuffs and the feet looked like open blisters. _C- r"I-66`1' . ,AQ: Prior to interviewing MrIIIIMIdid yo ever sign for him on a DD Form 2,708? 6,7e-c...6‘.- I 646 tit; NO. I didn 't sign for him. I believe it was SA.11111 go /7C-%.4a., 7 e 4/66 -' Q: Do you know why Mr_was received back on a D Form 2708 with " or biRising...an4.5„cratches"? A: Probably because of his wrist and feet injuries. He was dirty as all hell..1111 Q: Did Wen=4 any complaints to you about abuse when you interviried•at him at the BIAP? ob• 7C-17 PO: No __476--g. Pt-. 6A-Ec. Q:_./_ .M. • of interrogation techniques did you use while interviewing Mr 41.11.11_• A: In the beginning we would build rapport with _Then we wpuld ask him questions. Some times we would yell at him when we caught him in lies. 106 7606-* Q: How was Mr 4111111111tre= during your naterviews?if A: We brought a medic for his abraisions. We offered him food and Water. He was seated in a chair the whole time-and wasnever put in any odd positions._i, 7C4 6.-4 *- Q: Did you ever complete any interrogation r o on Mr _r interviewing him? ‘76-664-‘C. A: I didn't. The other agents completed those_ 6-4( • Q: Did you photograph or video tape Mr _• or to or after the interviews? 176' i7 r A: I photographed him at the AL MAD.•_rovided you those photographs. Q; Who conducted the interviews of_wi you. 6.74"-liba-/` • A SA 4111111/11111 and S _Their was an OSI agent at the BIAP who came in during the end of the interview. I tvl don't remember his name._7e-_ :_ reports on Mr_6e ik it r. . Q Were are the interroga_located? -_ ._ A: Copies can be found at the BIAP, The original copies should be located in the Green Zone. _7C°-: Iv #...—...,-1 AKIN .SIMEMENT T'AGETOF • • 76-4 FOR MAL, `j. ADDITIONAL PAVES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADIN 1711 G IEMEAILOR ENFORCEDIENTL SENSITIVF °Area THE 95 CM OFEACH A0q1700 PAGEMUSTBEM ffE liTIMACS 01 ME PERSONMAKING rfif srarmyr, Ail/DAVE Aft/AMER MUST 'BEBE CliTED. . . DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 "Imagism! "ITO 69 RN 1 4 915-EXHIBIT it4lo8).2k 9;:-ATM_ "' • 440 this statement? OF STATE IMMIll:////11 ////0/17/1///00///0/8/iii// Itilitilt . icwOd if AFFIDAVIT , I, NIB READ OR HAVE HAD READ To ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1; AND ENDS ON:PAg'62 . I klitY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE STATEMENT MA%6• . . BY M. THE STATEMENT IS 00.1 I-I)* INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED Tflt BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT, I HAVE MADE THIS . : STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT AND WITHOUT COERCION UNLAWFU i triit OR UNLAWFUL B¦iiimEmpr.. 464 ingStiitOpe# on authonzed by law to wrrgssEs: giA*44 .6. oaths this -day of August 2004 at 14p. ftei• PöiBeivoir, VA 22O6 0.4 •1 7 CY • - • . . • ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS. ininisteristga 5 USC ORGANIZATION. OR ADDRESS plutharik To Agrigniiter Oath; I yam O rgnoN mAKING STATEMENT Act DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 _ • 0 3/450 '0APe-C. 171).27S 9i 8 Cliz. 3 4 ROI NUMBER • -OtStr:04=C 11:10347 AGENT'S. INVESTIGATION REPORT CID Regulation 195-1 PAGE DETALS BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: About 1200, 30 Jul 04, this office received a Category 1 Request For Assistance (RFA) from tte 70 Military Police Detachment (CID)(FWD), 3rd Military Police Group (CHID), Baghdad, Iraq APO AE 09342, regarding the offenses of Assault, Cruelty and Maltreatment, and Conairacyji(i 4011111.1.1. seq. AWFort (It was requested this office locate, fully identify, and interview SA . Worth Resident Agency, 2601 Meacham Boulevard, Suite 500, Dallas -Division, Federal Bureau of 6 tiga.tion (113I), Fort Worth, TX 76137 (FWTX), concerning his knowledge of prisoner abuse pertainingNrssaisIt was further requested._min any interrogatioa reports e.77Ceand to obtain a sworn statement from pertaining to Mr. allallt k detention, interrogation, and release from FBI custody; to include interrogation techniques utilized on Mr. OEM -1615r • 6,-"-k‘i----About 1010, 24 Sep 04, SA and SA seq. 411111..his office, conciucW1tie./ a verbal interview of SA seq. yFort Worth Resident Agency, 2601 Meacham Tal Boulevard, Suite 500, Dallas Division, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) ; Fort Worth, TX 76137 (FWTX), who stated he had arrived in Iraq on 4 Mar 04 and began duties as a liaison to the Iraq N , Police Force (I -, , r.a dad, Iraq. SA stated he was not ...op • v4i;.h detaining, transpong,i for ting NDR SA ',members hearing about Mr. ‘7G-4 1 because he was missing part of his ear. S no witness any assaults on Mr.d_ had no idea where he had been held. a a 6 o eikint &ring his rotation in Iraq i( his . unit 11441* ,s.oy a lot of their original documents due to the increase in violence in Baghdad. • SA111.111K R/ The time it was believed his unit would have to leave Baghdad i a h9r ­ gso tie documents were destroyed to artysktApn from falling into enemy hands. SA sffeereni-ad searched fo documents pertainhirfourf detention and interrogation, but could not find them. SA stated his tour of duty in Iraq was from 4 Mar 04 to June 04. .. ,,,,,,, 1L6-41 . Agent's Comment: Sesigmlir agreed only to a verbal interview, which was conducted in the presence of SA41.11.1111Whief Legal Counsel, Dallas Division, FBI, FWTX. ///LAST ENTRY/// g 76-tlie‘-/f • FM OFF)CIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SEMS T. -TYPEDAGENT'SSIAME;AND -SEQUENCEN MBERt-ORGA N IZATIONEte2:::!`:-.7 .. '77.1,77n!!777M721-2 6 .. • Tti4 Fort Hood Resident Agency, USACIDC, SA Fort Hood, TX 76544 CID FORM a FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY (Automated) 014917 EXHIBI DOD-023992 FOR optio Ab§-q,1140, 1700t. 04i Sl S . 06g04-. by Mi... . • FOR OFF16141. USE ONLY /AIN ENFORCERENT SENSffiti. -Aaise¦aiirc TYPE AGENTS , NAME AND SEQUENCE. NuMpg0- ORGANIZATION . 22— MP (CiDxFvy0); 78'° MP (cici)(hivb), Detainee • 4u$OTa0s.PitsiOeg Camp ViCiOrYt Iraq ; APO AE Pug: • DATE •' • . EXIiIBiT • 17. 0004 • Fog OFFICIAL USE ONLY-LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE. 014918• 006072 • 0: 7115 S A. . • MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLORIDA33621-5101 .. • • MOtOt:S0t Ore:M. 014919 4. fi AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT ikOl.f4.144it.. -, .1 • • „ .0190704-C11)259-80234:. CID Regulation .6, 19" • pikoe I OF 2 PAOES., • At-vas BASIS FOR RE-INVESTIGATION: About 1530, 1 Feb 05 this office and 1 1thMP Battali on (CID) .Operations Officer, Camp Victory, Iraq conducted a review of this investigation to ensure the administrative and investigative requirements were Met within the provisions of CII) ation 195-1 and CID rational Directives. It was decided to reopen this investigation, conduct a thorough review of 's investigation and determine if the investigative summary Supported the listed offense and justified the listing of those offenses as "insufficient evidence". . . . SUMMARY OF SIGNIFIGANT EVENTS: About 0900,2 Feb 05, the undersigned conducted a thorough review of this investigation and determined the investigation clearly demonstrates the detainee was not injured during his apprehension or subsequent interrogations by the FBI. This fact was documented within hours of the event by both the FBI Interrogator and a medical screening conducted two days after his apprehension. The review indicates the investigation. does not support listing the offenses as "Insufficient Evidence' rather, clearly indicates the offense did not occur as alleged and should therefore list the offenses as "Unfounded". A . - review of the Report of Investigation completed on 20, Oct 04 (original maintained in the files of the USACRC), revealed the following documentation/testimony to supporting this conclusion.. • Exhibit 14 FBI 342 clearly documents the detainee was interviewed by three FBI agents, an interpreter and a nurse (who subsequently made sworn statements — Exhibits 14, 15, 16, 18 and 19). During the course of the FBI interviews, there Was only one minor issue related to the lack of shoes present and the FBI actually gave the detainee "flip-flops" to protect his feet. Exhibit 7: Agent's investigation Report of S toad 14 tun 04, contains information from a medical professional (CPT who examined the 47&31 . . . 13 04) for evidence of Injury and otmd nothing consistent withdetainee,(at 1700 his the injuries the oetairiee repoiLed. It was specifically noted there were no injuries consistent with falling on barbed wire. - • ['his provides sufficient contradictory evidence to prove the assault/cruelty did not occur as alleged. Also there is no evidence nor proof of any attempts at conspiracy, which requires at east two partied to commit. - ' TYPEDAGENP-$'41AMAND SEQUENGE:bitiMBER- ._-_ 413th. Mp bet (cicxFwcy ,6 `• 46 63rd MR Grp (CID), USACIDC ' 'SA6 Camp Victory, Iraq APO AE 09341 DATE •_ S EXHIBIT — 2 FEB 05 4 A . . , OR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 000087 DOD-023995 APPNI.7.4 ROl NUMBER • •• .• . C![?./3604.01,0r. ) 195.01 • • !c * • PAGES .. : ., I6,6. :6::6 , •:6 :6.6. . ¦ . % ...•,, About 30 2 eb,- 5; the 41.1 etsi e e0or a d WI ...7 . , - :- ommander, ' De4chni6ilt (CID) *I SA *Ions 4.!• .:. ... .., • „ ; :,•.,.• ion (CII)), -W O reviewed and agreed with 0'0040104a ófthis •iil:r61k: •, •6 .6. About 10000 2 Feb 05, the tilvimii0ed prepared and transmitted Supplemental Final Report of Investigation documenting the above 14ndiriga and changing the 0401 . dreite$ .04?4,4 Evidence" to "Unfounded", and removing thc offen se of Conspiracy from this investigation, as it was determined the offenses did not occur as alleged. ///LAST ENTRY//I ¦ • i. Fp 77 • • Afr up, pet. poxFv.vpy3rd: MP Grp (CID),.0)8C.IGQ kill APO AE•09342 • . : DATR 2 FEB 05 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 014921 -ORG_NALZUgLi . 000088 DOD-023996 CLASSIFIED `= FOR OFFIC DATE, 2 JU1 0 0 FROM' SAC, 78Th MILITARY POLICE DET (CID) (. FWD)' TO. DIRECTO1, USACc, USACIDC, FORT BELVOIR, VA CDR, HQUSACID ATTL CIOP-ZA, FORT BELVOIR, VA CDR, 22..`•MILITARY: POLICR. BATTALION (CID.) (FWD) CDR, 3] MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID) CDR, 78 MILITARY POLICE DT (CID) (FWD) F-'r CIIEF OF STA, DETAINEE OPS PROVOST MARSHAL MN-I LNO CID, MTF-I (FOR FURTHER DISTRIBUTION) UECT CID REPORT.. TNI3At1/t - 010-04-cr29-80234-• /5c23/5Y2E/5x1 DRAFTER; -. RELEASER:. 1 DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES 1:.. 4 MAR. 2004/ 0001 HR -11 MAR 2004/2359 ERS, UNKNOWN LOCATTON AT BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), IZ : ........ :. S.. 2 DATE/TIME REPORTED 28 JUN 2004, 0900 HRS TESIth!rE BY .. 4. SUBJECT: 1. (UNKNOWN) ; M; (NFl) [ASSAULT] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] [CONSPIRACY] 2. (to); M; (Nn). [ASSAULT] [CRUELTY, AND H. T EATMEiNrT] . dSIRA.CYJ. I 5 VICTIM 1 CIV, NDR$ - M, (NFl) [ASSAULT] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] ( [CONSPIRACY]. . . . 6. .INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION.IN THIS REPORT IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION AND MAY .HANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTIGATION THIS I S AN "OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM" INVESTIGATION. THIS INVESTIGATION WAS INITIATED UPON,RECEIPT OF MEMORANDUM OF TRANSMITTAL 00704-C1D789 FRO4. PRISION INTERROGATION CLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ° H4 922 29. cLASSIFP) --- FOR °PM O TEAM (PIT) 4. PAPOD.Aa CENTRAL c9N.F. 471,04t vAciti Y (BCCF)-, *P1-14ITI0, iR4Q.,....(A..dT);.. THAT isl:t. REPORTED :171:T/C14).'-,. . I '.... "J'-- Aismp.MTILt DtTAINkl °X B/AP _ . . - t .:-. PREI1IMINAR INVESTIGATION V. %TAD MR LI WAS CAPTURED AND PgTA;NOr.).AT AN 174[100W DETENTION FACILITY ON BIAP WHERE HE WAS .INTg.RROPNPP BY 80...)b4 AGENTS OF THE FEDERAL BUREAU O INVESTIGATION (FBI) MR REPORTED HETORTUR ED FOR APPROXIMATELY 24 HOURS AND VE­ 4 ON 10*D WIRE* FURTHER, MR. nomREPORTED try 6.7 DRAGGED sHIS FEET AND PUNCHED HIM. IN THE ABDomV, ' A 1011414 Oft .3)Odtit4 . : ,t).7-TRA.M1) 7101 kot. aimlbE-VA.Thrtti:-K.'‘‘. FILE REVEALED MR flPO. IN THE FBI. QVSTOPY... (42b4-7'. . • •....• : EFFORTS ON-GOING TO LOCATE THE TIFT2YrTo itA9ILITy ON BIAP, WHEREMWAS DETAINED ,M76*. 440.--14 . - EFFORTS ARE ON—GOING TO LOCATE MR •MCOMPLETE b 7 6" DETAINEE FILE AND MEDICAL RECORDS. EFFORTS ARK'. ON—GOING TO LocATg;FT44712ATTTgy: AND INTERVIEW FBI SPECIAL AND FBI /57C-./,‘‘:( SPECIAL AGENT • INVESTIGATION CONTINUES BY U8ACIDC.. 7. COMMANDERS ARE REMINDED OF 'THE PROVISIONS OF AR 600-8-2 PERTAINING TO SUSPENSION OF FAVORABLE PERSONNEL ACTIONS AND AR 380-67 FOR THE SUSPENSION.OF SECURITY CLEARANCES OF PERSONS UNDER, INVESTIGATION.. 6 . . . CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT . FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE' WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55. UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE Win4923 000090 6: CASE DESCRIPTION_ R¦11/SSI 29 Jim eported he, was Aimed white he was detained at -WAP, 1311.71. aabc I ...1¦•• 11i OTHER ACTION 12. 01) FUNDS ZI D6Tb4 ACTION' COWL DATE .„. . 14 stgDP:i gra7. A Pk7.::t.;41 2k3A.104 . • PQFf OFFIcoAk,V5E. 0:110( °' 4.0 g 4.; 60.0 - tapipt ENFoRcgoaff seisr.nv6. 00i • DOD-023999 LEAVORCEILIM: Sptrarrill 4 9 2.5 0 0 0 0 0 2 . DOD-024000 crokol. FOR OFFICIAL USE Ority mF090FIEFT SEIM"! 01492-6 i. OID FORM 28 PREVIOUS Eighoi¦rs OF THIS FORS WII L BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED 000Q DOD-024001 1000451u1 04' 6101 00t 7N94 616-40( 1.9.0,0). $4104 16'4W .. 1.5330,„.,aq:41 04_• t5b L Coordinat with SA Director Federal Bureau of Investigation, and Ime e allegations of abuse that Ma involve FBI Special Agents.. .stated die would inform his headquarters and d'd not want Onvestiga .4_• AGENTS COMMENTS : SA as provided a copy of the case file for their records. • . • The FBI :Agents names were sent via email to the SAC to provide to conmiand forthe lOcatiOii of the Agents; Interview .of SO See AIR for details) COordination and search of 1 st Cav DIP database. Database contains all Surnmar9Interrogation Reports. (SIR) of detainees who were interrogated by MI at their facilities. (See AIR for details) •, Drafted RFA to BCCF request the re-interview and medical screening of Mr. MOP 6 76-64.K. To SAC for review. 44' s,„(9. .ri „ .6.6• kepli_on . 6648. ---------J— - :-FOR-OFFteletliStOtit:v LAW ENFORCEITENT SERRim CID FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDII1ONS OF THIS FORM WELL HE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED 01492 7 .401)1) pv poi GENTS: ACITV:tiTi ui 6 location aitreta:61:-. 9-- - n Field Office and was leid Received 'acknowledgment to BCCF their case X1111150 is (01 04-04-CID789).. : '.•-••••;• Ieceived 1 Into Report from I3CCV related they received two iiiterrogOionIeports that were prior to 1-1.; and& not disclose he reportedbeing abused. :4764" Emailed SA and requested an estimated date of the re-interview. To SAC for rpvic*, gfikit420) lo 0).e too °2- ULF- CO"Ipcerips I °A jerAk; 6.e._Ff,pci IrrIzart)5A0 F 4„tume ekkk ce4-14-12.0c-s SS -70 _1011111111111. t*.dirobtxt•Oia• FOR. (*MAL USE OHO LAW ENFOTICEUENT SENpliVq. • • , I 014328_ -6 • 000005 CIO FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL RE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED • rs... osx_; Suit au e nail to B ereTeP9rts ere m ¦Arl encl°surest Info Report from BCCF 'Jim 04. It appears the detainee was Itedeiired ns prior to 1 the interrogations of ab4se arrest on 2 6 Feb 04, but it is unlPiown whom and where he was ixn.sterre.4 inedical examination did not disclose any scars that Would be consistent to e with babed. wire cuts; ti 014929 000006 cm FORM 28 • Oct 88 rItgylOUs EDITIONS OF.T018 FORM.. WILL BE USED UNTIL EVRAUSTEP_ • ‘• . -"6 •Q4 0900, 4 Aug 04 676 015.4.g 04 1090,4Aug94 . 06-4 stimmAuv •4/ PrOvidedRV. wieticlOSitreStOpFq Received canAtdRFAfr;qu,PFC ready to . and Fort Flo the :7. Received A.cknowledgernent froin 75.- Nip . et, Fort Beivoir, VA case numbs; (0095-Q4-C1li12) • ze4-/ Received Acknowledge en rt Hood. RA, SA case number (00507Q4-CTM4. SAelated his office coordinated WithCW5 4WS.4,4 ID 9 ectea they pass the RPA and information to FBI USACC Internal Affairs to conduct the interview and CO) sit in onh the interview when. it tOok Place 0-1 ‘ 764 Received i st Info Report via email from SA 75th kW-Det, Fort L 76, Belvoir, VA who stated he spoke with SA ho related he had tor coordinate with his supervisor prior t9 g to . he did not know who • captured detaihee#11116 but he gw he was detained at Al Baghdadi base. Sent an email to 75 MP Det, Fort Belvoir relating this offir would coordinate hetherwit 11gACIDC requesting guidance for the interview of SA FBI IA conduct the interview or CM AgentS. Case file to SA Need to coordinate with Mr_and discuss this case pertaumag to the interviews of FBI agents and collection of FBI documents pertaining to detaiteeiggiri wbefteint 1•10.01, FOR OFFCAL USE On LAW ENFOnernir eff1;errnt CD) FORM 74 1 Oct 81) PREVIOUS EDOMS .0F THIS FORM WILL BE USEI) UNTIL EXHAUSTED 014930 000 "7 AGENTS /WY ControlNu(n)lit:r . (cm.atgtilationns-0:: 0196-04-ciD29-80134 IME, DATE, AND AGETsIT #Ainakti*E-46;thii. eceiv email_ ort 13.040 which iiidi4.to *.. interview of iiiio for 9 —*to Aug 04. Posted to . f.de.4.7e" • . . .: .. . : , . . . 4.. • ' L166. / ( -./ -f65a. 6Ang 04: Received email ? ho related a time was still not set for F._' interview o to 00. Oef(e--e?- • . 0652 9 Aug 04. , ,L) Received email 110 related a time was still not set for 1/ b (`' ( I interview of Postedto • _ug 04 • / / Received email froth S whO related a time was still not set RI' ,.....,._:.,::.. 676-4 otor I interview of •PoSted to file. 6e, 4 Pe- 51 -10 Aug 04 R9 ail.f:Fotn SA Fort Hood, who related he coordinated , 4‘.-( FBI; lPalaS).WhO stated he coordinated with Mr. 7' Section Chief Counterterrorism Section, Washington. D.C., Who stated the interview would be coordinated 0:031ghthe HQ of FBI (WashingtOR).i I 130C ated that CID' b 7c• '1,7 Command_coordinate with D.C. qffillrherronlifkbpleted, Posted email to file. '0030 12 Aug 04 Received email from SA who related. the interview of was completed. S dated SA•• enied any .ahns 1:20 Mr. AdditionSA related S.A. SA and SA erejOyalyeslwith the apprehensiori and/or interviews Of IsAr Be@ff.ri station at WFO. Requested S 1 ws of thOse personnel as well, . Posted email to file_ C‘-/ :1.123.12 AU 04 Sent email response to SA onceming whether or not his office0e/ would be coordinating with. OD Comniand for the interview of SA_or if this office needed to initiate contact with CID Command and HQ. FBI, bit Washington D.C. Posted to file. .. 4 ‘‘. ­_1000; 13 Aug 04 it." Received email from h o related the additional interviews would be completed. Posted to fi e, tit " • 1030; 13 Aug, 04 About 1030, 13 Au 04 rece'ved email from SA Iv related the 0-1 interview of SA was completed. S reiterated information provi SA LiiQui 67 chic s ti es related the int of as Scheduled orS7 1300, 19 Aug 04: An interview had not yet been scheduled. Posted to file.. 67-/ x4r-i CID WEN 28 PREVIOUS EDTrIONS OF THIS EMESSICiart&SOMEI _ Oct 80 014931W/0 _• LAW ENFORCEIENT SE.3617M c011.0'0J:..N.40#Y0."..'-' , • •: Regulatioti ....0190404Cr02$9-8614* :-.. Triqt, nAta; SUMMARY OF INVESTIGATIVE AC1TIVIT' _ • , e 09:0011...A):1‘8‘0,_• 4's fjpiicerning the irherview of SA :with ,..„._CWS _ 1: 1 0 (kit o Would bern,akin ti''''"44*"4.--CID d .aii.a FBI,t7et.i.r„ Of,the interview of _. elated thefr office would '.eiosingt_kVA: POS ft4417.4. . has Tice he file concerning coordination with the FBI And Agent's Comment Requested SA aft of_ ,_._. •- - 17 Aug 04 J email from SA_relating he had no correspondence, AW4A. • information was discussed over d_tine. Posted email to file. • • 0006k 1 gAng 04 About 0900, 18 Aug 04, received eniail from SA elating the interviews of the remaining FBI agents at the WFO would be completed on 19 _ Aug 04, with'the exception of SP_which would be completed on 24 b,7 Aug 04. posted einails to file. About 0900, 19 Aug 04, received email from S 'ho Mated A764 interviews were still pending. Posted to file. 4 76//_• Atig 04, SA._ eived_ortnation report fro *Ito related the intetiifeW of SA _was COniplete,related his only involvement was treating ttiO:CtetaiI10* $A47 *owded some hotOgrapha ofalllian 4 his oditsinalleitoPC A ._related he had identified the indiVidnalS in$0 the photographs except for one unknown OSI guy . . Agent's Comment s related the forward photos and sworn .state•entsw:oulcl be forward:6 .­ 11*i* the inal Infont aZioport. Pending , interview o d . • 4tril Received email from SA_Who related interviews of e pending. FOR OFF/CEAL krSit Omi„.1 h_eurennetrpttoakt-g. ot;.p.:-?,v(0 0'2 n.lrirrjralr enr • -•_•_-. 014932 •CID FoR111 ..13 • • PREVIOUS EDMONS OF THIS r %AM WILL 11311 USED UNTII, EXHAU.STED_,_ .-.'00000 9 1 Oct 80_. 9944-CW25940 =iv , message from SA o related interview of as re-scheduledfor 1300, 26 Aug 04. 4.'"f0A .`#' 4. ecei*ediness o ho related the interview of SA , 17e-9 plated: related he was unaware of_ who capturing unit was and did not witness any abuse, nor did comp am tXlint about ablise. • e--411('‘4- CID FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXH_AUSTED_014 9 33 000010 I Oct 80 . • DOD-024008 ME, DA% AND. AGE e coo wi CW5 of WerY/L*9.. osted to , ‘7,=464.7 elating he would coordinate with Mr. . 4 . Received onnation report from S A which indicated thepG-fref`' interview of as not conducted as the requestto be forwarded to CII) Conunand, via B1HQ. No significant investigative activity was conducted. ,6764-1(‘-‘16- 4 ig‘ /fie • ftla ro7E04 of' ‘trif PD•sra, tip ,-r-c.6 FcTi OFFICAM. USE %my " ejp 14(4.10 if..Palride14:01&5t1KAV e r F 000011 014934_ Cm FORM 28. PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED I Opt 80 ontrgl Niiinliet, • EtsrtS:Act MTV. (CID ftekutati6n i9S4)-1 1ME, iikrk, COO •t WOO fope, ' 6.6• , ..•:•..„. "..• S'erit 4114 to VI ,popstmg a scattig.of RFA. Agent's comment; t Sep 04, fiqresponse had been received: 'fl rUiftadAfiagi '5E714§VP E • • . CII FORM 28 PREVIOUSEDiTIONS OF THIS FORM WILL BE USED UN.TH; EXHAUSTED 01.4935 . -000012 1 Oct 80 -, 0,1,5,Seil 04 a 145;18 $ 04 . 401 12:55, 2 Sep 04 Pe:. f 10 25;.74.$0 04 0e-1.1 (0 4.012;fl.4. Hui!•FFIr • ,ge Sentenlai C mtervieW of no related:he believed FBI Internal Affairs ,6 • re he contact the OPS to deteitaine how the was join& to 'be completed. 4 74-K:tC‘ reviewed final information report and attached documents from SA Forti3elvoir, VA. Poste40 file, 6 76-1`,. • ailed SITUP. 6.60. 4-76-o6-( Sent email to SAC requesting status of interview of- Posted to file. Forwarded email to Mr. *requesting status of RFA to Fort Hood. No responsereceived from previous correspondence:: 1146, 24 Sep 0176,4 cki Drafted SITREP: It 15: 0940, 28. Sep 04 1405,28 Sep 04 / t ‘V OM 8 Oct0406,6 I: 2Q . 1000, 14_gst 04X1e4 I.20` 67e-5641- Sent email to Mr. 'via SIPRNET email. Awaiting response concerning interview. of 7:0-6 irk/ Received.email from SA amp Doha, Kuwait, with attached AIR from the Fort Hood CR t gene The interview of Iliferevealed 5 Was not present for the interrogations of and had no documentation concerning See AIR for details: .,!‘ ? r"' IC6" r Drafted SITRE Review of file Chief as discussed, this case is pretty much done. The detainee claims he vas abused at a detention facility in Al Bagfhdadi prior to being interviewed by the I FBL FBI interrogators and medical personnel relate he had no recent injuries or „_. FOROFFICCAL USE OHO CID FORM 28 PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF I Oct6so W 014936 . 000011 M= lEftt • DOD-024011 1,NumBEIK CONTD0 . AGENTS ACTIVITYY Regnlation 1954) , 259 8 02 .privrp r co; TAM, DArg, AND AGENT I SVMMAR Y nisin_di mi. t be conSistent withhis . claimS,_I perSondel re a'they did not abuse the detaktee and Aso exposed photographs of him during interview, The description ofthe abuse he received would have clearly left marks or injuries, which was not the case. I will coordinate with SJA and clog", barring any adclitirmal pertinent,. investigative activity requested by their office or input from you, To SAC for review. Received and reviewedthe final infoimation report and MR of SA Posted, to file. • Drafted SITUP, 04-3,0-5 (0.4b 0,0-4.160.44 S Fc.Jr opa40.145 t5A., -0.4P6tit4 C...tostc- ofpico. LAN Loa-UilatiE;i7. 37.747rt. CID FORM 28 paEvioUS EDITIONS OF rms FORM WILL BE USED UNTIL EXHAUSTED 014937 0 o 0 i4 1 Oct SO DOD-024012 106; Oct 04 04,....f.4 doritta. Obiobet summARk or ximstidATivz Acitivrim AC; Rev'dt Not comp eteetoilowni 1, Good case work ;and ocumeutatIO.n,, 2. Noted your review and coordination with.SIA. 3., Concur to close this down as insufficient evidence to proVe of disprove. If thg 'victim sustained the injUries' e related, he definitely would have had File back to S 1111461 .N.c..4 foo-k. -1-35 sik, rod. lepow. p-,ea 01 11 U.:10 •M. -00_0015 CID FOOM.28 • Ampvidlit Ebitxpla pit tpxg'FokK kit Pi ulpb.ONT'L'ExpAdiTEb:M i Oct pp DOD-024013 'S 'd, Note CO 1. Rev'd final report, transmitted and posted to 6e, File to. SPC fi, for distro: 67e-lea-a. 2, FOfward per .dis.. 3 1¦10.4834.04404 .. 4, N6 evidei* Oolleeted:. 5, EMail giily 00*.-• $10 :6.11:004.kNwarded,. ,(e FOrward file to SAC closure.on 54 log. 7& lam' 7. Forward to DATE. fox 014e en co v\ ckko • reel& AA C42,ed 014 CID FORM 28 9 3 9 081.51S PREVIOUS EDITIONS 1 Oct 80 . OE THIS FORM WILL BE TiSED UNTIL EXHAUSTED. 0--Y.-4w -:::: 1‘4, • 4444:"944- Namb • SSN 001.. • Rank • MACO4 6• zz place of Birth Work TOW . , Home Tele,_ • Unit Address Federal Bureau of Investigation. WaShinCtOo Field Offidif:' ...," biStad of Columbia United States State _-_• Country, - Resident • .6.6 .6. • .6•6•6• .6 6. Address. oun Sponsor First:. MIddle ,_• Sponsor SSN _ Sponsor Rank Sponsor Unit _ Street • Address_ City -_ State Country . Sex_M - Male _Deceased_. N - No- Height_5' 8" _Citizenship_US -United States Weight_175 lbs _Education EZ - Secondary Diploma .6•6• Eye Color_HAZ • _Fingerprints Build_Home Tele MED - Medium , _ Complexion_LIT -Light MOS Martial Status M -Married DressiDisguise . Age 44-44. Clearance TSt- Top Secret Race_R3 -White Photographed N - No Ethnicity_E2 - Not Hispanic _ETS Date Hair Style_LS -Length -Short _Fugitive Hair Color_BLK -Black .. _Juvenile_N -No Facial Hair Demeanor_COP -Cooperative _ ._Glasses _ PCSIDROS . Marks -FOB OfFICAL USE CRIIY 0 1 4 9 4 0 LAW ENFORCEMENT) SENSTIM • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY_ ,,vc50001.7 Nan* SSN • Rank MACO r,`:..!.Y' • :4, Place of Birth. . ' Homo Tele. Unit Address Federal Biireau of investioaton. Washington Field 0 ice - _ biittict of t C R001000 Addeest sponsor Last First AEddle Sponsor SSN ' . _ Sponsor Rank . Sponsor Unit _ Address_Street • • • City Sta_ Country_. Sex ._M - Male _Deceased ,_N , No Height_.. Citizenship •• US - United States. _-Weight_ 210 lbs . _Education_EZ - Secondary Diploma Eye Color HAZ -Fingerprints _ ..... . . _ 476-7‘‘'..ctr Build_Borne Tele ._ ME6_- Medium Complexion_HI' - Light _MOS .. . Martial Status . M - Married._ Dress/Disguise Age '_41 - 41 _Clearance_TS1 -TOO Secret Race_R3 - White _Photographed _N _ No Ethnicity_E2 - Not Hispanic _ETS Date flak Style_BD-Bald _Fugitive.. Hair Color_BRN - Brown _. Juvenile_-_No_ _ - Facial Hak_ Demeanor' COP Cotioera. tiVe • ' 6 • • Marks 1-Qh OKICAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEItieft SENSMVE 01494 1 $0 •0 0 18 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY ' Name SSN . Rank. Mace of Birth . Home Tete; Unit Address, Resident Address • . Sponsor Sponsor SSN Sponsor Unit Address SeX_ Ork 'eteral Buie of ihvestlOatiori,Washitiotert Field Offic _ Sfee Last Street City_• -Male Height._5' r Weight_ 165 lbs Eye Color_BR Build_THN -Thin Complexion_Ln--Lialli Martial Status S -Single6 Age_40 -46 . Race_ R3 - White Ethnicity_E2 - Not Hispanic Hair Style LS -Length - Short Hair Color_BRN - Brown Facial Hair man Marks District of dcifunibia _• United States Stater_ POI:Intl • -, our! Middle. First Sponior Rank State_ ._Counvy _t-ieceised_N -No _Citizenship_US - United States _Education_EZ - Secondary Dioloma _Fingerprints _ Home Tele • • MOS Dress/Disguise Clearance _ _ -rs1 Too Secret6 _Photographed . N -No EIS Date Fugitive Juvenile • N - Demeanor COP - Cooperative . FQFi QFPQ1.4 fN)m..y SeiStr. "_ 000019 • QM 0149.42 Name. Iddle SSN • Dog Rank Mace of Birth Home Tele. tate,. Work Tele s 06404 4e c----41 UnitAddresS Federal Bureau of irivesticiatioh. Washington Field Office : _ City_ Distdd of Columbia State. United States Resident Address *Sponsor " Last _ First_ Mtddle Sponsor SSN . Sponsor Rank _ Sponsor U n it _ Address_ .. Street . City_ . State-_ Country Sex._. M - Male _DeceaSed_N - Height Citizenship . US - United States Weight_200 lbs Education_EZ- Secondary Diploma Eye Color_HAZ Fingerprints _ Build_THN - Thin Home Tele Complexion_LIT - Light MOS MartialStatus - Sinole Dress/Disguise Age _ 26-26 . _Clearance Mit Too Secret Race_R3 White _Photographed. N No Ethnicity_E2 - Not Hispanic ETS bate_. Hair Style_LS - Length - Short Fugitive . Hair Col&_BRN - Brown Juvenile._ N - N o Facial Hair _ Demeanor_COO - Cooperative Glasses Marks FOE OFFICIAL USE OW( SERSITINT tilAN ENFORCEIPT FOR OFFICIA L USE ONLY_014943 Le' )000020 •. INTERV Name • .t.j.-z"..v` ;:;.;It':,Aii.,4A SSN. Rank ' • • MAC cir Place of Birth '7.i,•;,•,5g411.7.eatigtgiNe4 . . Work Tele. Noti* TO*. .„, Unit'Address :OeciiirilEfutiau of fekt6stiOailoo. MshiiicitOo Field Office •• !6: District of Columbia. • Unifed.States:..6. . Rat* • - • .crooptist Resident k.4 • oe:4 '- AddraSS Sponsor Last First . Middle Sponsor SSN Sponsor Rank, _ Sponsor Unif . _ Address_Street City_ . State_ Country _ sec m - mate • Deceased_. N - No ' . ' Height_0'2^ _Citizensbiti_US - United States Weight_250 lbs_ Education_EP - Masters Degree , Eye Color_HAZ . _Fingerprints Build ._LRG -1AF-cm Home Tete Complexion . Light MOS Martial Status . M - Married _Dress/Disguise _ Age ._45 - 45 _Clearance_TSI - Too Secrt Race_R3 - White _Photographed N Ethnicity_.E2 - Not Hispanic ETS Date Hair Style_LS - Lenath - Short Fugitive Hair Color_r4-RN rar,-;wn Juvenile N-No Facial Hair Demeanor COP - Cooperative Glasses . Marks t*Wif 0064 %SE ailYlivE LAIN ENFORCE-MT Sea 01.494/4 60.601. FOR OFFICIAL USE omy eA&' G1901092 =844 Title it5; ii 80 _nuaticr and ofhet_al aticliamaYalkhigive means of c on to facilitate Piing eat retnevai ..6 : , ... v , , • • • ., • PM.0.104 PURPOSE. TO Pro*tiii commanders and lawenforcement041.010: With, DISCLOSURE Disclosure .o Or social security number is .. -. .. ., . Means_ bii:i6ich-iniCititiiiiii ma . be acCiiiiiiiitideritified.:. : '_-'_-• . ........: ,•6.• . REC CODE Acii64Po.lig• .'*'.... Pgg..$031ATTFP: . SESNVMPP3 , •-• YEAR UNIT. R91 NUMB g.L.. TO. WE .CoNT.IRQL # ....,...,_. • 9..... snywAi.. QA, Fl MID OTHER pNUMB P0P 0 KJON.t WW1 .; POSITION' INDUSTRY SECURITY' FNYBIPA1. MARK 1€044.4, 38 ALIAS-NICKNAME(S), 39 4,1g•Niciaimvig(s) IF_CONTRACTOR_ ( CONTRACTOR NUMBER AtIAS-NICKNAME(S) oRGANizArioN ..2 71.1 ci,. 114 5 Ll RY SERVICE_-_SUBUNIT FORT 117( • COUNTRY ZIP CODE/APO ' 14-6PO4._ CITY ._ • STATE couNTRy. ZIP CODE/APQ ApbRESS. FAiRLYMEMBER DATA Jrl11/_!FAMILY REL SPONSOR LAST NAME SPONSOR FIRST NAME' . SPONSORMIDDLE NAME .. „6•„ I SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER ISPON GRADE . SPON mcAr. . SPONSOR UNIT ADDRESS _. ppm; zip CODE1APQ_. ISPON PHONE NUMBER SPONSOR CITY. NST SPON ClY OFFENSE - OFFENSE CODE: . OFFENSE CODE_ IL!O_'OFFENSE CODE 6 ul6OFFENSE COD E; r • • _ ADMINISTRATIVE PCS/DEROS . [UNIT TELEPHONE# 'DATE INTERVIEW (START) _INTERVIEW (START) I_ I. • ETS TIME INTERVIEW (END) • y.ACE OF INTERVIEW(EPr OWPRINT PLACE OF INTERVIEW (8TART)1DATEINTERVIEV4 (END) . . . ._ ._._ VEHICLE DATA._. LICENSE # / DECAL #- . DISPOSITION 1 -CORPORATION DATA CONTRACTOR NUMBER • • FED SERV/PROD # CORPORATION NAME CORP CITY CORP' ST CORP MY CORP ZIP CODE/APO CORP ADDRESS CONTRACT NUMBER EDITION OF 1 AUG 87 WILL BE USED UNITL EXHAUSTED . DEC CID FORM'44-R 014945_...000022 Ci Exh Laorcemen nsi ve • L,atfc_or • eMent enst Ve • 019,0454-01.)2$98634 ROUTINE USES: Your sociai Security personal information are 0$04. as an additional/alternate • means of identification to *IWO:ping and retrieval. • PURPOSE To provic1,0 coolFoxt.*I[Pr. DISCLOSURE: )51440.0 of your soNiat security AuP1b4! enforcement officials vgitti:00aii•S by which mfornwtion *4,. be is Yiginitatt accurately laghtified. 1 REC code 2 Action Code 3 Date 5 Yet4t : NOMbef , 8 ROW Cas.e 9 Cotrigit .44 10. /*if . • 12 mit1.41 • 14 $044.Seeiiii Nümb i7 18 PoTt-si 2Q SOX': 22 tbnie. 23 Height 24 Weli 26Eye BrO Bro 37 Alias- NiCIOiame(s)-MAID_, 38 Mat- Nielgiaine(s) 39 Alias- Nielmarne(s) • 42 Military SVC_43 Subunit 47 Zip Cocle/APO. Weishacton 52 zip Co ' lie SPONSOR, D 55 SPOPsoTi.astNaa1g_ ' 15•SpiansOr. Firgt Nathe . 57 Sponsor Middle Name 61 Sponsor Unit Address . . . 62 SPON City 63 SPUN Si 64 SPUN CTY _ITSPON Zip Code/APO_ 182Y ._._. OFFENSE. r66 Offense Code 67 UFC: 1 68 Offense Code 69 UFC I 70 Offense Code_71 UFC I 72 Offense Code 73 UFC I _AD1V1INISTRATIVE DATA HOME PHONE # ETS_PCS/DEROS_bate IYW Start: Time IVW Start INTERVIEWER Place 1VW Start . Date IVW End_Time IVW End_Place NW End Fingerprint_I Photo • rVehicle Data Disposition • 110g/C010' DATA 74 Contractor #/HOR PHONE # 75 FED SERV/PROD #/RELATION_I 76 CORP Naine/RELNITVE NAME 11 _. , I -77 Corp Addrett 78 Corp Cdy . 1 79 Corp State._80 Corp CTY 81 Corp Zip Code — • 82 Contract Number EMAIL: BASD 44- HO R: BLOOD:_' • Phone: EMAJL us.army.rriii CELL ?_ CID Foym 44-R (Autonnde4) " vabeuseduntil exhau • 1 Dec 81 FAlim"1 Aug _._ OR OFFiCkAL 000023 LAW SIMCE11. "EkigEtail. vF DOD-024021 ENFORCEMENT SEIflVE .„_„.. , (DEFARTMENT OF TIlEAVM. iiraiiitirrAWftitibt BATTALION 01-# UNITED STATES ARMY 00,4041, n¦tvgst0400$ COMMAND • BAGHDAD,.; APO AE 0042_ -. St 28 Feb, OS.. •- • CTIYIPL.PA ib OS MEMORANDUM FOR Contnander, 48 th MP Detachment (CI)), Camp Victory, APO AB • MO' SUBJECT; eqtiest for Correction — Report of Investigation 619079-CID259-80234 ._. L Reference CID Regulation 195-1, CID Operations: 2. A review of the listed Report of Investigation was conducted by this headquarters to ensure administrative and investigative requirements were met JAW the cited regulation. . . Administrative and investigative deficiencies were identified and are documented in the attaehtd sheet. •, 4. Request acknowledgment of this request no later than 4 Feb 65. A response to this request to include the status of the investigation will be forwarded to this headquarters, no later than the . above suspense date. • oint of contact for this action is the undersigned at DSN iraq.centcom.mil . 1 Encl. as • 0 1 4 94.1 • oaViA.t....USE ONLY . LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE• • 0 0 0 0 2 4 DOD-024022 • p0*-0Mt%tia • , $4ktgriVi f6 •6.6•6,6 •6•6•6..• •6 •.6 ._ •_•_: • ,_.•_. .••_•_•_. -• -**** O R 0E04 04010 (MS.A:p4ftsOit • 4TREA Fhtd,gg! ;' • • .• • .14 INV does not support 'o gated offenses. for *us ' 0101401g of those offenses as"instif&ient review ",of the investigation cIe oristrateg the detainee wa not injured whin he was interviewed i*.40 FBI On 2 Feb 2004 • • Exhibit 14i Mt 40 : i .c1ely documeflt4 .the *0140, , irttrviewe4 by three Fa agents, ,_. aili0tv ',14made sworn ' . : 0*:: - 'a: .100P • i ;.. statemen:ts • __14 15f . t ''L_:,....,1 p g ' _was 6 '.. one itiiiOr issue reii.1-to the lao_.. hO4p. •9414 piff,tha Xd ormi:Cafeilet olas. 7 :::: 04V..for i'.`:::::::lypo,nieCt — ti• , ___-7. 'Z..=c41$41: iirsr ., _ t1°11 ckoce. dinj Cat 1700 i ' evidence _injury ail.found nothing consistent ' -6 injuries the ent with :P6 : . , . oilbrdetainee reported. i ,. noted there 0 n -L.. . were n 4' k 0 ` 1 n frcoMI S i s t e n t voi, Palin$nsistent l barbed WIre, This provides sufficient contradictory evidence to prove . the assault/cruelty did not occur as alleged. Also there is no evidence net proof of any attdinpts at conspiracy, which requires at least two parties to commit (only one subject is indexed). 2, The case (once unfounded, with conspiracy removed) does net require a FINAL C It is simply a FINAL and there is no requirement to list "Leads to:OW:lie •, Recommendation: Complete a 1St Supplemental reflecting the reopening of the investigation,tuiTOUnd the offenses reported, delete the 'conspiracy reference and document the review of therelevant facts in a supplementary AIR, which will be an added exhibit in the FSU closing this case. • 014'948 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY - LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITiv : 000025 . CIRFIt-PIT • 24 Jula .04 MEMORANDUM FOR Speci41APilt in Chaige, Police ) netachthellt ' • (di)), Baghdad, Iraq, APO. A.E. 09342 • • SUBJECT: Memorandum of Transmittal (00674)4-CID789)" 1, On 17 Jun 04, the 504th Military Intelligence (MI) Brigade (BDE), Joint Interrogation and Debriefing Center (JIDC), Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (BCCF), Abu Ghruyeb, Iraq (AGI), reported that detainee National Detainee Reporting System ,6•7G -**-P' RS) MEM NFI, alleged he was abused While detained by Coalition Forces (CF), prior tope-okr arrival at BCCF, AGI. 2. The results of our preliminary investigative actions are documented in the attached enclosures andare forwarded to your office for action deemed appropriate. •-• • 3. Point of contact for this re rt is SA it DNVT or e-mail: Pe--4 ‘‘a./ 46 .. us arfiiv mu Of • •6 , ::?•• 416-4 e‘---7 ?C-Ita-/ End • , 1.mg of..SA CW2, MP 2. Statement of SPC. Special Agent in Charge 3. Svgirit Statethent ofilial4 7e-C ‘i.‘‘`‘e‘ 4. Translation of Statetnent ' 5. Detainee File 6. CID Form 44 . 7. Dossier • • OFFICIA U LPW ENFORCEME.10 $ENarriVE • 014949_• For Official Use Only Exhibit ' Law.Enforcement Sensitive -000026 CIMPR-FR 27 it4 04 MEMORANDUM FOR Special Agent in Charge, Washington RA (CID), 3-rd Military Police , . . (MP) Orenp (CID), 105 Fenton Circle, Fort Myer, VA 22211 . . • • , , . •- Special Agent inichatge; 38.01mp l*T (op), P.O.. Box V, Building 2200 Support Ave, Fat 1-1Ood, TX 76544 SUBJECT: Request for AsSistance (RFA) (0190-04-CID259-80234) • 1. This is a CAT 1 .Investiiation. Results will be provided to the office of origin within 24 hours of receipt Reasons for non-compliance with the 24-hour response time limit will , expeditiously provided to this office. 2. This office is currently conducting an investigation of Assault, Cruelty and Maltreatment, and • Conspiracy. On 29 Jun 04, this office received a Memorandum of Transmittal (0067-04- • CID789) from Prison Interrogation Team (1," Baghdad Central Confinement Facility (BCCP) Abu Ghyraib, _ • 1¦TDRS as abused while pe-- Ghyraib, Iraq (AGI), that Mr. detained at Baghdad International Airport IAP), Baghd ad, Iraq. 3. Preliminary investigation revealed on 4 Mar 04, FBI Special Agents apprehended Mr. • at an unknown location and released him on 4 Mar 04, to the 501 Militaiy Police company,_. BAP. Iraq, who provided security for the 1st Armored Divisions Detention facili •on a DD FOnn 2708. on 5 Mar 04, FBI Special Agents. signed for custody of Mr. on a DD Forrn0C4 606 2708 and orted him to an unknown location for inteirogatinpu oses. ue to a missing • • DD Form 2708 documenting the FBI releasing custody of Mr.. It could not be #‘7-Cj‘ --c ---- established when he returned to the facility or if he returned to the facility and what condition he . , /76-K469" 4. On 7 Jul 04, SGT_ 501st MP company provided a sworn statement relating L 74( he could not recall mr, entering his facility, but recognized his handwriting on the DO Form 2708 and state iviird0:witli. bruises & scratches" on the DD Form 2708 was not in his handwriting. SGT slated if MillIllPad bruises and scratches he would have 17e. requested a meclica "screening prior to him entering the facility. 5. On 7 Jul 04, a uery of the detention facilities database revealed Mr_as mterrogated nary rite igence person= • . FOR. OFFICIAL USE ONLY • LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE-014950 ,6• DOD-024025 cm' D259 *8 _ irCr Otti11 ,„..on IoOSITF'131 Ot.T. 01Y01 • .the 7e4 Request YO.14 ofg Og loqate, fully Iden, to w S nest our office. 4oertOliftOxil SA w 0 ea 6 was detained. 'prior toarrivingat BIAP and into unto Ascertain if he is any ow e e o abused'at the us ention facility, Ascertam if h e noticed any type oinjuries on Mr tfMr cipotted to hum that he was • equest you (where e interrogation repoits.from the FBI pertaining to 67 are located, if he ereports, request you obtain a copy. Request you faun' a detailed sWO to all aspects of Mr.411111111111111• rtistatenien , :" • " detention, interrogation and release from the FBI custody , to include interrogation techniques.. .utilized on. Mr. Request you ask how Mr , as treated while in ar cuspdy.SA eeh eliminated as a suspect, 67 9; Washin Request te, fully identify and interview , If' ce ascertai was detained rior to arriving at BIA1? acid into his, custody, Ascertaini le as any knowledge ,, irrx& i* of*. RequeSt your office . _ ,..,. captured M.r. and where he ie­ bein :abused at the previous detention facility. Ascertain if he noticed any type b-- (4 -)c-P ' of injuttelbt and if Mr.111Irreported to him that he was abused• - Request you il, e-c.ibi.i , :.. . ere the interrogation reports from tine FBI are located, if he has apcess to SZ.664,7-e the reports, request ou obtain a coPy. Request you a.* SA *f he has any 6,7e-titc‘..-f knOwledge.of Mr. apturing and detainin unit o abniini and assaulting detainees -67470.4614 during.interrogatiOns t ,.Request you show SA the DD Forni 2708 bearing the word$4 76'i4 --/ minor bruising 4 scratches" and have him expexplain vfhy Mr. ' as received. with 67066147: injuries. ReqUest ' 0ii obtain' a. detailed sworn statement from SA ertaining to all‘Te--66 7,` SA ask , aspects of Mr. detention, interrO ation and release fro the FBI custody, to iriclude.6. ... , ,,,,,, -c6-1‘zce,interrogation tee ties ij. Request yoU ask how Mr. as treated fc-(4 16‘.- iied on Mt. . ,while in FBI custody. SA not been eliminated as a suspect; -..,. eCk- : 10, Request yonask r email • us.armyrnr1 pleasd'aCkziowledge receipt of this RFA. Conduct any other 47C-11" investigative ac, vity and questions deemed necessary. Please notify this office prior to closing )1 POC is SA t WVT -67c-64 -( ." FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY • . LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE' 3 ,014951 nnoO28 DOD-024026 t. CIMPRRIt_ SU $JE T: Request for Assistance A) (0190-04-C 250 802 Encls .1- Initial Repo4 2-Apprehension Form 3-. (3) DD FotM 4- Dossier of Si4tmeiit o_ ' 6- St.gienteilt of 7-AIR of SA • • 5 fte.tte, FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE . _ 3 014952 000029 04-C1. 0259 • CIJAM-FR fltll 04 • - MEMORANDUM FOR Special Agent in Charge, Prison, Interrogation Team, Baghdad Central • Confinement Facility .(BCCF), Abu Ghyraib, Iraq APO AE 09335 SUBJECT: Request for Assistance (RFA) (0190-04-CID259-80234) 1. This is a CAT 1 Investigation. Results will be provided to the office of origin within 24 hours of receipt, Reasons for non-compliance with the 24-hour response time limit will 776• expeditiously provided to this office. ,_. •2. This office is currently conducting an investigation of Assault, Cruelty and Maltreatment, and COnspiradY. On 29 Jun 04, this office received a Memorandum of Transmittal (0067 704- CID789) from Prison Interrogation Team Opt $414141 Central Confinement Facility (13CCF), _ Abu Oh311*1), Iraq (AQ1); that Mr._ ND4 _was abused while detained at Baghdad International Airport (BIAP); Baghdad, 3. Preliminary investigation revealed 4 Mar 04, FBI Special Agents apprehended Mr._t an unknown location and released him• on 4 Mar 04, to the 501st Military Police cOnipany, Iraq, who secured. theist Armored Divisions Detention facility, on a DD Form 2708. On 5 Mar za4 04, FBI Special Agents signed for custody of Mr.411 on a DD Form 2708 and transported 67‘7'-ul him to an unknown location for interrogation PiiitibseS. Due to a missing DD Form 2708_,_•_r, documenting the FBI releasing CuStody of Mr,alIlljljio the 501 st MP Company, it could not be b7e-160-A--established when he returned to. the facility or if he returned io the facility and what condition he ¦616 • . . .• was in: 04-i ‘ . 4. On 7 Jul 04, SGT ._, 501!' MP company provided a sworn statement relating ,, he could not recall Mt: riteritg his facility, but recognized his handwriting on the DL) 6 7e-rfrb .0-- r ' Form 2708 and stated .th bruises &scratches" on the DO Form 2708 was not in his • _z, ,.. handwriting. SGT_fated if Mr._ad bruises and scratches he Would have 67 6 bv"fr requested a medical screening prior to him en enng the facility. _- • Al__ 5. On 7 Jul 04, a query of we detention facilities database revealed Mr.• _.vas not interrogated by Military Intelligence personnel, due to there was no Summary Interrogation Report (SIR) record on file. : _ '_'_• . ' •_' . ,_•_. lTineObtain . ismyrom his detainee file maintained at Abu Ghyraib, to include interrogation reports pc , . FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY *, LAW ENFORCEMENT'SENSITWE • , eIntitata I ocumentation pertaining to the capture and d,etention of Mr. 014953 • 0 0 0 0 3 0 • Ii*or you re-inietview an rovide better Li of his specificallyof detention wadetained or was he tri sported to ano sc 1911 . die WO detained and when e' re Pyva$ 'd he return inie detenti011 faoi on of e interro - ... - the fact the PT-. 4094 not aP hOP on eir au leo hiSel CV raid his Qt1Se and apprehend hun during the rat StateS e was "tortured" an act named the "scorpion", ascertain what he means id detail and Where Ti e hetrd_, ..'e wor . ' sco ion", Request you ascertain th e specifies'of fallingg into barbed wire. . .._ , _ Mr , fated he was dragged by his feet; request you ascertain the .details of how long he wasb 7e- nr ragged,hether he was clOthed, how he was dragged, wbOdragged hum and what was theground structure he was dragged on Request you , obtain :a detailed sWoriistatement of Mr. , a itz...fi If there are questions pertaining to his answers,'request you clarify h is answers. 67c7'9''' 8. Request ou coordinate• . , with the medical staff and have them conduct a full medical screening z-7 of O document if his allegation of falling on barbed wire was consistent with any 7_s' rr scars hiiiiiyhAves. . s • • e-s at DNVT r ease acknowledge receipt' of dais RFA. Conduct any other mvestigaA ve ac A vi and questions deemed necessary. (1) Encls 1- Initial Report CW2, 1VIF... SPecial Agent In Charge . FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE 2 014954 000031 DOD-024029 r) " DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY • -• MILITARY POLICE ogueoyioil (CID) • 4110 .0101)TA1O! 00000 :OAttAPON ic.114.:', • . _. .P b. BOX V • . Fokt Hooti, TEXAS its44-04o,. 01:90 04 -CID 259 -8 10234 .6• 47. REPLY TO. ATTENTION. OF CIEZ/Z-CBD • • 28 Sep 04: MORANDUM FOR. Special Ag_-Charge, 70 Military Police Detachment (Cm) (FWD), MilitariPoliee Group (CO, APO Al: 09342 SUBJECT: 7th Infontaiioil Report (0650-04-013034) OP. Aug 04, your gequeit Ot Aisistance (0190-04-013259-80234) was received by this office:. All requested investigative activity has been completed.. . ._._. • Man-hours expended: a. Administrative hours:_2 b. Investigative hours:_4 _ c. Travel hours: 6 • d , _Fund EXpenditures: None .3. Point of contact is SA t DS1NT commercial gip 476-6 or email a Ood:Tfra-yrnil, • Enclosure 1. AIR of SA „ Fii)h OF„CgAL USE • - WEN' *REI IENT SENSITIVE 014955 • 000032 DOD-024030 ,...*"...e.t .. •......„.„. .., .. ... ... - -... , . . ....,. s,.. ,.. tit...i.‘ 1.•' y 0P1": ....141.(C10)Tt° .0 - (Cu ID) ..-''''''. -..‘ ,, POLICE m.,01$0 04T 12 'E : Oi64101,*.R. ,.,0 01yjm 4P-. C -APHM ' F T.itF.11:.....'. , -----A 74' MI j' _EvrRIMINA,V INVESTIGATION6;..,--4::: -....., . UNilt0 WVsTt.,.......,NYJ .--,,. .,......'„ : - 261-6 . 3D .`'ffig'it'..0 44.,00:40.:.:616 ...., -,..... - 9, 401iii - - -VIRGINIA _t. 2207, tBELVPIR ) i: 0 6 .0, 4 I. u 2 9 , 'CI .., ( • . . ' 26 Aug 260 4 . . . . . , .. • • :, . . . . .-.... ..,' . . i. . MEMORANDUM FOR Commander; 70' MP PET (CIO) 8-0 10 . GO iy, USACIDC, ' .: 'APO . At 09342 . - • -' .-, . ,, • '''' . • StIP,JtCTil. 22nd In fOrritatj...on Report (0095-04-CID122). 0:4.0nCe .Reque st For $ st 019-0-04-cb2”-862 11 4. . rreceived thia.offioo, on 2$ J121.'044 2. 'Yo1.14. zrequest was completed and documented. in the attached • encloeilre, 1, No Privacy Act disclOsures were made and no • .0015 funds were expended. Man-hours expendedt a, iwtsoigat4.ve; 12 )6,,,-_ ... Travel 0_ .. 0 Adtro,rii$ttatiiie 8 • • _ :6 •6: .6, .6-•, •6 f6•6-,6 • office_,... ..;..t5lht. of chtact,ithid,..di •i.$. SA, _ DSN Pei/ , • ...... . emaili . .,:C0fTlIrOi. al-' 4. , /t 60-7(. ..• us,arty,m 7P7..-Mft '' -/ •. _ .76' • • i6'6'6 Li4-iF‘c-( ,,.. -.,..:::: .. 10 EnolS _______,. - •• ,1, w:41 44a A,n. Charge6•• •1, ArA o4 SAIIII.F .26 . s:A- 2: .SwOrli. Siaternent: of SA 3 worn btement of SA • 4. ergen ( 5, 4..f6tent of szi6.;6 .e..... ‘.4f-f-1 • Worksheets of 82V • roit QICP. USE oigpt PRINTED ON •6!Weg...P_p PAPER •• 014956 • e06 OFFIGAL6MAY . LAW ENFORCEUERrir SENS0.90033 17:10' DOD-024031 •.: . co:41. -4:0t.i$Deot; 1..0 coltip4ct Disc. FO. °FOCAL 1)-SE OHLY POTICEMERMOSillii TOR 0,MR.I. USE ONLY . PRINTED QN ECYCLEE) PAPER 0 14957 76 .41. 0 0 0 3 4 DOD-024032 li:64*14 0;•: )•e '6• (RT 000 0.$0•040s--te (cw) , • • tisiTto sto'ito kagx.00o$.4.100:100#0s common)... BOX V FORT 0006i TUO. 1440140. REPLY TO. 01 90'04'CI-DiS9r80234 61TENTIoN OF d1gP.'033) 17 Aug 04- IVIEMORANiAJM FOR Special Agent-in-charge, 3Miii..Police Group (CID), 78 th Military Police netachmeni (CID) (FE), Bagbdad, fráAPO AB. 09342 SUBJECT: 541 Information Report (1360-04-CID034) 1. Reference is made to your Request for Assistance (RFA) 0063-04-CM838-77739, received on 12 May 04. The request has been completed, and no further investigative activities are anticipated. 2. Man-hours expended: Investigative 2 Administrative 2 Travel 3. There were no privacy act disclosures or .0015 funds expended. 4. Point of contaat for this office is SA t DSN ommercial 41b: or e-mail a r 7‹-ri- • G`7&/1!‘"/ (1) Enclosures: 176-1/4 1. AIR of SA • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY -Law Enforcement Sensitive • 6 014958 000035 DOD-024033 .6• • .6 ,• : • DEPARTMENT OF fHE A Prisonqr 41.9 OC, to 22 ..: #11"4iiiotide Battalion (ClD)(19ND) _ Baghdad cc Al : AO AE 09 14 401 0 MjIVIDRAN.DVM e•oik 40001 AgOt in Charge,7 th Military PoliCe .(MP) Dètachrnent - • (1.0)1.•040gViati,, e,..*i44d,•• otoif AP AE 000: - • , - • . •. • SUBJECT Information Fiopprt (0104 7040. 07$9).. •1', Reference your RFA (0190-04-CID259-80234), dated 7 July 04, is complete. 2, Man-hour expended Were as follows: • a. investigative: • 10 AdnilniStretivel.„ c Travel (s);, • d, .001$ Funds 0• • 0. Privacy Act Disc, •• .• ••• 3 Point of....60ntwfor this report is SA -.t DNVT r 6- us.army.miI.L7 • 164.,(6c-K •Ends . AIROfS 2 InterrogatiOn ReportS and Records , • spotial Agent in Charge 3, Physical Exarif -: • 4, Medical $Creening. • 5, Sworn .Statenient. Translation of Iraqi Statement •7; CD containing Photographs s 014959 _ • For Official Use Only ••_000036 Law Enforcement Sensitive DOD-024034 RA pertaining t0 the interview Ot #110 Wo A • *- FOR OFFICIM USE or 014960 .6• .6 LAW ENFORCENV SEND"`;,. 000 03 7 • • ,•¦•-• .4464 .6!6• 1.1 • eqja Oen 61/V4 MNC-I 22d t/r1 (61D) S-3 kcpritcorli. miuno„.. "•••••.:'' 28, 200411:02 AM Aje,rf„, • E-mail a., /.Pw, heard from,6as to the con 10t of:Htho interview of SA • ;- Piave n anything on t i$ inal_Me8Saa ICL / MNC-I Special Agent " Sent_; 2E.1 2004 5:43 AN . CW1 MNC-I 22d MP 84 {CID) S-3 67C ,--(1‘-Ve (- - Subject: -CNT 1 RFA$ 4 •, Chief, The. DATF has a couple of RFA's that hare been sent to Fort .Hood, one of which was the one for the interview of the FBI agent,.SAMI M which I have not received any information since• the last time you corresponded with SNC IOW • Do you have an email for the ASAC or the BN CIPS?, Or could you _ , corrOsp0A0 with someone to find out a status?. 4ppreCiate the help, ' .6• •6•6. • Fon OFFIML USE ONLY 0149 61 LAW WM=017 SERSTME 1 00a0-38 _ - g ràr, $0, To Subjeçt A gib (Pia)* tMailtOMts-armY.mil] ' 18 2004 8 VcMain.ng.c5-army.milM--.2/41- Subje 4-c1p034 (Our Case 0190-04-OID9-80234) • The: lot i ,w40.-th4t FI intOrn41 affairs would be conducting the do nOt have a status. . //,`.4r SACCW4 -_, Fort Hood4eeident Agency tort BOO&. .P.C.76$4::_- TELit CBLL#11: ‘4-1 OSNit! FAX# 2 a4.117.1111 .1 CAUTION: This tite0aage May contain law enforcement sensitive. information. bo not disseminate, which includes fotwaratq the contents of this message; the approval of the sender: If you are without not the intended addressee, . Or the person responsible for delivering it to the intended addressee, you maV not copy or deliver it to anyone else. or Use it in any unauthorized maker, To do so is prohibited and may be unlawful. If' you receive this a-mail by mistake, advise the sender immediately by using the reply facility in your, e-mafl software. (2. 76``/%.(1 omain.hq.c5.army.mil @vbmaip..hq. c5. arniy. teMber 13, 2004 7:58 'AM Subject:: RFA 05.-04-CID034 (Our_441-10-7114.-CID259-80234) s_•_ VillGAL 115E Y/ LAW ENFOPCEADIT SEVFOVE eoci morning. ust oualt—_ ingloase wit you concerning the interview of SA , FBI, which was initially going to be conducted by your off ice in RFA _r (06.50-04-CID034), but the local FBI office- refused to let him be interviewed , • until coordination was conducted through CID.Comtnand and FBI Headquarters. oil 8 Sep 04, I reCeiVed a litesa'gd frOM Mr.M•operation . / • • • 014962_00003 . •: . -6. • - 0.1' .i, 6L.. k'..' 0 4' ,,y 4.), 2 ,5 0,... i.,-, 0.-z. s .4:f. offtprk 22514: Og ii00 1/14. mk... 0*.., to.tos.$ii* 00. .0e.-;..:1/' -,1 .:::: . ..,.,..6...•6 oltach. 1,4qUato..4 r01...g04,44rteg., apiptOrOci th.4 ill.t0t0,04 .i 1 . Mi7:',- ,s,ff,W.'041,..h0 :140 .. .#0e0- . .. ........ ...,„....,....,.......: ....•.::.•:,-:... I . have riot.: *4.0,04 .o.i.* .fortA0v ,:'4,toetiAti. tom _10f.D. Cii44404 40d jt16? .. • , needed ti.l. o140(.4t4.0' $t404. of-. t44 $„ao.4viow or 1.-.t. y'611r; 6$116! 'Tims ,.' , ootiti3O th0 141t4t.trA.04 i4o0 014'0.vo.4,,' • . Thank you for your assistan ce, . cyl2 . ..... , :. - ..., 22:19071,1rp1' ::,:( C4.):4•_....4 ... . 7 $Ffg. k41:OZ.i..t. ioitomm.... "Optaj:4:00,. 411.1$0..;..1.1i0:41,0 Force" 00#:.: i.41.14941:., :I.0.killi'.': • ',• ,.. 1. D .. • 740, °T;', • F071 OFFCGAL 1)13E ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SEMII1ME 014963 2 . 0110040 . Just forclarification here, is the FBI going to coordinate with their higher for approval of the interview or do I need to coordinate through Command for the interview? Let me knolN. I will CC , , , this to our BN just to keep them in the loop, but if a formal request it needed, I'm sure we can . a p . make it hben, 76-41 64 --/ (• • Original . SA CID (PILI)" us.army.mil 1/6 Date: TOeSda August10, 2004 10:28 pm' Subject:c.krIRF Frorrt. ' _ . , • SA FBI, Dallas who stated he ei7e- I Coordinated With SA • cdordinated With Section Chief Cou nterterrorism Section, Mr. • Washington, DC, Who • • - stated the the interview 'would be coordinated through the Headquarters of , • • ' • c°.--f/a"--2. the M. (Washington). POC: Mr. SA Te- Ghri -0:1" 1111.11111111,related . that CIO command should coordinated with D.C. to get the the action . • completed:' 476-6 °‘41 special Agent: Fort Flood Resident Agency . Fort Hood,. TX 765:44 comm: 61'41/ » bsw 66‘e/ FOR omcnk, USE NILV .4.9S • • kAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITivip 0 8/11/2004 . . https://webmail.us.anny.mil/frarne.html?rtfPossible=true&lang=eft • rom • *it:WgWsd...0. Cc octati the effort and UpdateS. Actually, we've been trying to locate nd for interview, so if you can altangk,forit,I would appreciate it if youöuld interviews We have to exhaust all leedS and if they to inclode SAIand SA sure the next guidance I would get from Command is to were there during the. interviews, ensureit v‘i ckine,$O we may as well knock it out while we have them all in the sam&Ofac0 : . ' 6'6 ,6.6.6.6•6 .6•6 Please ensure that all items have been answered per the RFA forWarded. for completion. And I don't say that because I think you won't, but we have had several RFA'. 1qt :tithed from other offices without all items being Completed, As you can imagine it's a pain to have to re-send a request; just to find out the person(s) we were trying to track down have relocated or redeployed. Thanks for making. the interview happen. know you must have met with a little resistence as: • far as the FBI is concerned, but % suppose our agency wouldn't have acted any differently, • •6 . : •6 ' 6 : Any chance the agents photodraphedalpbefore and after intentieiiv§; videotaped the , Of that matter? it would definate help cloSind the cate. Special FOrce§ Over here • interviews : have at least began photographing before and after to show no signs of abuse, which are turned. over to our office whenever a complaint is made, which ciefinately speeds up the process. Let me know if you need any additional information. Thanks again, • • Orig inal - Frorn.: W01" us.arm y .mii› — 7 •Date, wootio$dayiA-u g Ust la, 2 Subject ONT. I RFA 0095-04 SA •-• •• Conducted interview of SA oday at 1151. provideda s' ,: , 47t-iF' swoyj his knowledge of Mr • • Int t the AL ASAD Air Base" --'1AVISTega P Zplet CDT SOSITITin 2 --0.14cff 000042 • https://webniail.Us.arnly.milifi-amo.htrurrtalossiblo.--true&lang=en •68/11/2004 p4g-0 ,245f3- ,6• -ir-t-gzo &Irv- R-13z1.1 . a et oil ttO 60 •'•6• POkecl at 5.!N 644ir, • e kirattehtiOri kodi'dihg to S at ,,o1 yo1.4.17:9 alrit$ at all during the iraterVieW procesS, ha no visible. . inl(lrigsfr! • required nth rndiOa.1 treatment I'll be waiting your answer on th00•pth*:, • -agon. •,' . • 75th MP OET (CID) •_ , ; • . FT BEwom, VA 22060 ...* A*.d.••••••••'—' -• FQ7. OFF)CLAL USE OHIN 01.496 LAW ENFORCEMENT SERSITNE . . MA041 bttps://we'bmail.us.anny.mil/fra.nae.htmrrtfPossible=true&lag=en 8/11/2004 $01 iro5 Subject: Chief; , . . .6•6,6• • • • . .6 , .1-1r4..ie the information concerning the inter Foi.out in TAkse:4 for coordination with, Mt.: co Ohl* The CID Case. geht, . i$ SA 2F•brt Hood Resident A40h*Cy i Cornrri - DS1* . Th4.440 the lag 1010040 Im pgiVerhfrig"tbe ititerview; . .• . . •. .• • 00-.0t.-t6d,ifith SA Bti pslles.00 stated. he.coonxnato with • .8ection ccyptortQOPOS:r0Pegtim iii .QCT who^.stated the.inteNiew*oold ooOt roug.1h# HA of FBI (Wathjh4.ttm), POO; SA related that CID 0.0t0)0114.., -hOuldoodrdloate with •, • to get the. goon co •. Also atteoheci:a copy of the RFA sent to Fort HOOd and the Fort Belvoir offiOes, • 0190-04 RFA.pdf (590 KB) • ciff•flpA4 0mA 1 • : . LAINEMPOlitcErATEVT SEBSIIN 1 01496 7 000044 SA 1 /‘dil Just intg owed . Sy the •way, 270$ thai erOas.ihg P the MPS lOokS dOctOted to tne; The writing 'received 'nor. • ruisiod and $cr oOlc:$ a little different: Did youlbokihtdthat or . 0-04,lioolw,-ew : . • noticed it .0-is going to see if he 110$ copy of. it with a y notes: If hot e you can find it with Ve scheduled the interviews of and r 1300; 19 Aug 04. 91o. 7 .6•. FOR OFFICGALI.r5E, Ot011,v LAW ENFOlitErilel SENSIIWIt 496g. 0000,45- htlps://webmailms. 8/12/2004 • 2094712!„0 r4 • us arm mll6 us arm 09 I'll diet this 606.ASAP, Keep in mind it took two wooks. to get one agent in here: There pretty busy like us so it might take 410116 to get four more in here for interviews I contacted the IA rep at WFO and hews going to get a hold of all of the agents to sod if there willing to give statements to this office:. Also, all docurnentS, photos ETC are located at the B1AP in Iraq. I'll keep you postedk -6, SA r • . FOR QFMCGAI. LAW ENFORCEFAEK SIVAir141.111: , .6• t 0046 https://webnail.us.army,mil/frame.htnil?rtfl3ossible=true&lang=ett 8/12/20 r ..." ' F011. OFFICL1L WiE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SETISIM https://webmail.us.anny.rniVfralne.html ?rtfPossible.-- true&lang=ed g,2,,,mp0 4 7 Page oc2. ItE: CAT RFA e , Lit.arit '..mil., 4-ie. f es°' • , From . 56° .10101Y-f.;,NR9i. '9jr , 2001:: a' Zt:.5--:. ,d. Q.-4/, g _.,4`.9 ..‘".) "7 s ,..Q( 4 TO11111 1pvcrnain.ha ,c.arrny.mt.1 6 . co • Bcc •Subject Fwd z tkEt. CAT I RFA me,* 6704 ‘A17 . . o -a Q 13: 4 I D 2 '). - -C - " • The DATF fOrWarCleci an RFA to Ron Hood, TX, for the interview of an FBI Agent in reference to Interrogations conducted by the FBI, and allegations of physical abuse. The Washington Field • Office was able to complete all actions requested, however the Fort Hood CID office related they ,...„ ,. coordinated with cw$ 1111111.1 . for the interview of the last remaining FBIK (SA 41110, as his operations section ielar ed all ifierviews of FBI personnel had to be requested through CID • command through FBI ilot/o0eV?fr + • ci . PC"itf 12 W7 17 Aug 04, was the date of tha /0:_ t (nail and I have received no further correspondence. 4 7e-4 ‘0-1 concerning the interview of SA Would you like me to go direct with CW5 . wOuld you like to contact him to re Uest a status? Thanks for your assistanCe, SA . 76-i; 76-6 11¦11 on t ave any correspondence. h Mr.wit him:yesterday, and then faxed h I talked to. him your RFA. Haven't heard back from him yet. Qri Anal .MeSsa From:: us.army.mil 6 7,,(41 0-1 rmailto. 1. us.arm il] Sen rzlzigit; , 2004 12:27 AM . / z z To SA CM (PKI) 6,76• : Subject; Do you happen to have any copies of email, correspondence between your office and Command.. If you do I'd like, to post it to the file. That way my weekly sitiep will be compensated, Thanks, • • Ori inal Messa e • From: ACID (PKIy ECIYIFY 6?• ILAW ENFORCE-DM SEtzgawne 0 14 97 1 . 13 048 - https://webmail.us.army.mil/frame.html?rtfPossible=true&lang -- - en • 8/31/2004 _ • • Page 2 of2 SAT I kVA, e• t.„ 2. $68 0 2 S: 4 + • • coordinated wIth ON$6at command and pa ssed the RFA d74—ciplir • fro9000010 him per my ASAC. vvo Ore dosirio this down and cde.nrnancrwill follow Lit) with the coordination and interview of the FBI agent • 74..-11,6 Fort Road Resident Agency • Fort COMM • t..)14't, •• .•• • 9 • 000049 • https://webmail..uS,attnyattil/fraine.htmlirtfPossible=true&lang----en. 8/31/2004. rage 1 of z • • .01:1 .6•6.• • sok 110 "WO* 8 2004 3!26 pm . To Ug:arm .m11 6 • Cc . Subject RE: REi. Re: CAT t RFA • FBI aPPto9Pci his intevieW:. Mt, occurring ill becOOkilhatthq the 1W:6/Few in Texag.. Should be thistWeek mope. , .6•6• •47e-if. (;6-1 us.arrny.miL .„„.1 tig.a-irn .milto ic.' f( .4 f . . . . ember 08, 2004 12:08 AM . #. s'e-h 1110 To: vcmain.hq.c3.ermy.mli 6,7e-1/ 9&-f• . subject! Re: RE! RE: CAT 1 RFA ‘0`(-7 Mr.* • Did you happen to get a response,to this RFA concerning the interview of _ from CID Commend? ib7e-/;04-4! • • uri 'nal Messa From @vcmain.hq.c5.army.mil ‘6---1 • Date: 'Tuesday, August 31, 2004 2:49 pm Subject: 1:tE: . RE: CAT I RFA . 4re-(/‘—t' • . . • /i7 C-Al I A" I will shoot this to WA*. Will let you knovv. 411106 ‘76' MesSa .• . • Front:' uS.atiTly..mit 6 '7e-‘ # S'1I • 67e-. . • 5- SOn '1A(Ist 31 2004 12:23. AM • Td: verhailthq.c5larmy.rhil • 7c..--6 ,Subject:. Fwd:, RE: CAT I RFA . . • . The DATF forwarded anRFA to Fort Hood, TX, for the interview of an FBI 4913' ••6600050 'LAW ENFQ0CEFIT:' NSITNIT https://webmail.us.army.millfraine.html ?rtfPossible=t rue 9/9/2004. DOD-024048 rage Z of •6 . cil: 0 0 .,' -- '' -. ' - "--- § e 0 a 4 Agentln':...roorepo to.ipterrogationg oohauctod .y• . . ' - -... b t :e11 FBI; 4n : -' °..' • °-4 ..0 R b 2 5 9 -.....''-. --: . - - - .- • : - •• .. • ... :• . : •_ •,.: , • 41.1000000-phY*0 abuse The woMilojtoii Field Office w44. • - . ..:• .,:• :. • , able to complete an . ...„ . •".. .‘. • ',- • -• ... . _.••• ...., , a . , , • , • . , :,.. • actions requested, hoWe•YOt hefort Hood CIO office related they cOOrOih*dwith. NAOMI.for the interview of the last remaining6ai - : .-, /---' -- FM Agent (SA_._. - .:. 1 '''''' -:''' ' .`,7•,44... .6•• '. '6- - ,6' 6 V6 - 111101 as1111_his operations section related all Intetyiewg. of FBI A76._ 41/ 4•:-'/ , ... 6• • .6•6••6....•6 •6-6•6.•6•6-6.6.•6 •6.•6.,6 ,6 .67 P0.14$4i) 6040 to be requested through CID Command through FBI HQ._ , • • ... .• 17 Aug 04i...wos the date of that email and I have receiV0O. no . • • .• . •• • -•••••,.....„ • furthercorrespondence concerning the interview of SAME" 'Would 4.76-6 6... ..." 00...04 me to ' ,.,_._,..._.,,,• . :. ,,,,,,••:.:••::.,.,:, :: • Go 4iNct with cw5 1.,..;or .vvOuld you Ike to contact hiro to roguest a. .1 staus? Thanks for your assistance, SA • . . Ciffirg:att5E LAW ENFORCED:EMT SENSITEIVE 014914 000051 https://webmail.u.s.army.mil/frame.html?rtfPossible=true&lang=en • 9/9/2004 DOD-024049 Mr. •• Did you happeh to get a response to this RFA concerning the interview of SA rom CID Cohtparld1! . .r.r.:. ' . 100.1. 0$0 ,. ._ 4 7e-. .-6 0', reorot; .vcrriaih,h q .c5.arrtiv.mi.1 ciate:; -114.e.sd.ayi.dgi:4StiS :-, 2004 2:49 pril suboo Reg. Ul. CAT I RFA . `... . . will shoot this tO. Kr._Will.let you know. 6 76—;( 6 • •:„...::• - ..••• • ••••• :---,,,.. 1-7./44 k4.,-f • . Original iviessage.-- 6 7G 0 be.‘" .rmin: us army.mil_ . ti :OrT1),:rn. Ill_p 76 Sent:. 4-10 31,-2004 12:23 AM' To: Vttnaln.hq.c5.army.mit 67e l Subject; F.W.c4 kR .: CAT I RFA_. • .6•6, . m r. 1._ - ( -2 • - • • 6-6• • • The DATF forwarded an RFA to Fort Hood,•TX, for the interview •of an FBI _ ._. - Agent in referende to interrogations conducted by the FBI, and . allegationsof physical abuse. The Washington Field Office was .. • • able to complete all _, . - '_ , actions requested, however the Fort Hood CB), office related they , cOOrdinatedwith CW5111111111111111for the interitieW of the last remaining . 41e-- F81 'gent (SA_' C ‘‘,--te- --,/e_ as his OperatiOns section related all interviews of FRI _ )tiersonrielhad to be reqUested through CID. Command through FBI HQ. , • • 17:Aug 04, was the date of that email and .I havereceived no.. you like me tO 90 direct with CW5 7.64./ C request a_• 4 1 CiW '!"! CowSERS1111 • 014,9? 5 000'052 . https://webrnail.us.artn .miUfraine.hfrnl?rtfile--true&lan=en 9/8/2004 '661'2 status? . Thank$ for your assistance, SA . • • . . I ' PI)R OH;6 v5E.OtikY •• LAW EMPLOCtiiiENT SEISM • U000.53 https://wobrnail.us.army.mil/frame.htnil?rtflle=trueitlan=n _• 0 1 4 9 7 § 9/8/2004 • DOD-024051 . • Pagel of 1 # • . • .•• . From . Senn "6,14day 46(.1st ...4s; 20046 .1,1 II it, 2 T. 6us. army . m67 6-7 'Cc6CW3 CID" 4111111111111'.6-16,! Lo/ • /6 `-c Bch6 Subject CAT 1 RFA 0095-04 '• Conducted interview of S 6bad no involvemerit the intervieW o 6He actually. didn't-even know his name until he 6to the 131AP and SA told him. His invo venient wag ickin 6g )761 Upallillarid another detainee6'end tteheriorthg then .on a biackhawk SA6to;et: ) t6‘6•-cf out the apprehension form and gave it td a soldier from the 1st AD. S is still out of the net: Will get6. him re-scheduled ASAP, ,6`e-4e:4-.../,.6• 76-tifa•---/ 6 • • Pcn °FOC:6:U Qt11,1fVa. SIFORCERERT SENSITIVE 911 000054 . https://webmail.us.aniwanil/frame.html?rtiPossible=true&lang-en • 8/25/2004 . • frt.)6 urs6uglist 19 , 0 uS.arm Co. • Sto Subject CAT today. SAS, row e P0:0110t' ograP 901 , .„. ua s the photos ie except O en interviews of SA and SA -today but had some fa6issueto deal wi , 11.a trri only involvement%id his cousin own OSI guy, re complete. et him re-schedule 'Page l of I 46. T.. • 25 9 $.0 etainees. SA, I have all the 6p7C-17 w6statementS, as iLIPpOsed to be. here 7c. • • • LAW iliFUICMENT SEN SIT E https://Webnaail.us.army.mil/frame.html?rtfPossible=true&lang---en , • ¦6• 0 0. 00055. 8/20/2004 . fag ox .- g? —4-170.06-1 Y• FrOM . W017 - . :... e?, '..11;...6 $ant .e. ries a,7, _44.4.81 210-04 .47..i: ,4,...gizyziw,..,z.::,-g 5 9.. 8 2 3 4 To n ua.atefi C W5 GID" Bc0 Subject CAT '1, RSA 0095.04 Intqn/laWs of still tentative for tomorrow and interview of foe 24 Aug 04. .6o,sPicc::2.L, uesz orvi LAW DIFORCEITUTT SENSITIVE " 9 • • (3149 • 000056 htips://webmaiLus.anny.miliframe.html?rtfPossibre=true&lang=en • 8/19/2004 . . Page 1 ofl •,, i. • • :r•=s'-- :',.?.;:;:_,::'' • „ 6.. • ...,..-L::,,,,?:: : ..;;,,•:.:.:::::...-.,.,.. .. . . • 60760;.;14c,C uip__Isprmy_.milin ...., . • v, PrOrii' emous e,. JA00 1,1i 2004 '01:28••'6 -. •'-'• - • - - • -6• 6•6-6• •-• 5 9 9 P °2 34 Sent T.000Y;04 .".,%., , ,..,..:: - , To 111111111111111111111 111P4L'Krrill ' W3 CM".6•Ug.0*.011-* • d!',:ir ,(Cg. CC6 '6Scc6.-:.• --6••••., ... ,6• .6• Subject 005-04 CAT 1 RFA fi • • /—, at 1000,24 Aug 04: p Scheduled interview of SA6 • r 5-4 • .. • •%.6 FO OFFICIAL VBE LAVV ENFORCEMIT SENSITIVE 614:SS U00057 • • • https://webmalus.anny.mil/franieltrnI?rtfPossible=true8i.14.ng=en. 8/18/2004. : DOD-024055 Pagelof2 '±,4-1.4 Pf.Onl A CIO D'059°$b234 Sent Tudà ' .., 1 171­-2004. 5;Z7 us.àrnW.mil. 91 9 6 C D 25 9' 8 ° 234 Cc • 5c0 $4bject. RE CAT t RFA 44/ rf have any correspondence with mr. talked tO hire yesterday', and then faxed our RFA Haven't heard back from him'. Ye.ti, , ina1,19eSta •ut.arrny.mil sus.arm .mil] 147°"1/47f°'-f , 2004 3.2:27 AM A CID (PKI) 7‘.---//&4-/ • Do VW' happen to have any copies, of email correspondence betWeen your office and Command. -If you do I'd like to post it to the file. That way my weekly sitrep will be Compensated. .6.6•6.6. • Thanks, SA CID (PKir Date Monday, Augus 2004 11:59 pm. Subject CAT I RFA From: • „us.arrny.triil 4 70-4 • SA /.: s•a"--P. 5. I coordinated with CW5 at command and passed the RFA DICr inforMationto him per my ASAC q We are closing this down and command Will follow up with the coordination and interview of the FBI agent„ vlr .•.‘ • pecia ''A • Fort Hood Resident Agency • Fort HOod-6544 DSN: OFFICCIL USE OY. . LAV ENFORCEMENT SEIMITNE0.49.B1-. . 10Q05. 8 littlis://webroaiLus.army.rnil/franle.html?rtf -Possibla--true&lang=ea . • 8/18/2004 • 11/40 1 pfl re*VeWs still scheduled for 19 Aug 04, 4. FOR OFf)(A,:11 USE DEILY • • LAW ElIFORCEDIENT SparilVE oSZ. •https://webmaitus.anny.milgrazne.htinnrtfPossible =true&lanw! 00.0059 • 8/18/2004 DOD-024057 Page,' of I. Front .r911 t” 3 4 -6n us.arm II • .0E-4 4(4‘-- II co . us.arm Boo 9ot 0005-64 Oa 1 ".===^.g:^7=:77. ...t.tomm=7.......mwommemeammomfflom........7.mommone.mmomr.moominemmhamoNnemanmosseem ¦ ammown....remonewWwwwww.moman.m."..............,..Wemmimmi= *paw! SA • intervieWs Still. Solledufed for 19 Aug OAL FOS' maxIME LAWENFOTICErAMIT SENSITOVE • httpS://webinditils.array.miliframe.html ?rtfloossible=true&lang=ei .6• . 01428 3 8/18/19d 0 6 DOD-024058 Yap of 1 Fool, gerit 41: 9 . C1.025 -8 0 2 3 4 ils.arrn .m11_ .?; SubjeCt Ike; cA Thinkk: 4764 I ern no longer in Iraq and I haVe added SA' to the CC block who is assigned to the case: - Ktmat.„, „Tang APO • DS.14.... • FrOni SA CID (PKI)" us.army.mil OCW60—( Date:. G, 200410:28 pm Subject; f6,--4, 0°1 • I 'cpqr FBI, Dallis, who stated he 47c -41"--2- , 1111°''. **SA. Section Chief Counterterforlirn Section; 47G7,14'..7 as, mg_whO_. stated the the interview would be coordinated through the_,- Headquarters of •_-__. . ' , -. _‘VC-IcA4--.' Washingt tailiashingtonl. POC:. MreIIIIIIIIIIIIII. SA' on related _76 -.2 6"--,;. -6 ..: . - • . that clD.'Ornroand should coordinated with D.C. to get the the action completed., • - - Special Agent ._, _. • Fort Hood Resident Agency Fort Hood_6 -44 COMM:_ iCe-40-"( DS1N: 6 / -, FOR OFFICAL USE ONLY LAW EitlIFORCENENT SEMITIVE lattps://webmail.us.army.mil/frameltml?rtfPossible=tnie&Iane-en ._014984 ._000 0 81 . 8/10/2004' DOD-024059 Page I of 1 • .6 '6:6•6 :6 •4/ II) '66:PP- -zs-c ' From6 •6 WC5P6ue.atrn .rnit*6 Sent Tiey, August10, 2004 8:i am To .."! ugArrn Cc Bcc Subject CAT 1 RFA 0095-04 SA • . Spoke wilt) SSAI W.6FBI Who.related he will coordinate With SA6for time and 101644­ ‘7 •date of inter+.404: as of yet SA6• 064/ t‘riP.--1 • • FOR OFFiax U1mio . LAW ENFORCEIIENT SENSITIVE 014985 • 100062 • https://webrnalus.army.mil/frameltml?rtfPossible=true&lang=en 8/10/2004 DOD-024060 • Subject CAT 1 RFA 0095-04 • No word yet from FBI on iriterview, FOR OFFICAL t1E.Carlo • LAW ENFOKEREIff SENSITilvil 014986 •httpg://webniail.us.army.miliframe.himl?rtfPossible=true&lang=en • • 00 9 063.' . . . _._ 8/10/2004. • . . DOD-024061 Yaffe 1 of t • a -44t • • • .. 78702 1 Y.. Frbrrt • ... usar ,204`10: 50 krn To A11.11.11.1111. .army. us.arm .mul Pet Cq WI CID. 6 • E3cc • ubject. CAT 1 1:tEA 0095 -04 • FrOh OFFICAL 1/115E ONO LAW ENFORCETIENT SE ITA https://webniail.us.arrny.mil/frame.hinil?rtfPossible=true&lang---en: 014987 00(W4 8/10/2004. DOD-024062 ;. CAT Subject Re.09$-04 getting a handle on which case is which in.Be Detainee abuse I appreciate the up_date. ettin - 4. abyss, so I'll be with you shortly if I have any additional questionS. Thanks, OlesSa• • From: us.army.mil Date: . .vg.u. t 5, 2004 Subject,:6.F0(0095-04 , • • SA 7C.4. Spoke with SSA_ Who related this SA would provide an interview to this office; SSA_ scheduled the interview 74."4/44— /_, . tentatively for 09 or 10 Aug, e wi contact this office for exact time and date. SA ••¦ ••••-'=4... ................................ ........... OFF)CLAL IME r.-Repry LAW 'ENFORCEMENT $ENSMV , https://webmaiLus.anny.mivframe.htnortfpossibie=trliesdanven 014988 . 000065 8/10/2004 DOD-024063 Page 1• oft , 46,-7&- Fr us.arm-0. 1 4:a -04 —.. cer-o• Z,Sefr ghTP3;: ,_• Sent Tliur'Sda lt Alienist 5.200. 6PM: t0.1 7,3 et To ,--••• ‘.‘.,„, . • •CO .7:COCIb"Thus army mu 71011107 k • • i3co •_ 8111400 CAT . 16 R . 0095-04 . Spoke with SS_who related this 8_ot,ild provide an interview to this office. SSA _ -scheduled the interview 09 or 10 Atig._ a d _tentatively for_He will contact this office for `exact time n 6‘-14 FOR ORM USE MLY LAW ENFORCERENT SENSITM 0149.89 https://webmail.us.artny.mil/frame.htinl?rtfPossible,=tnieklang=en 8/10929:11940 6 6 DOD-024064 Page 1 ofl 't3 u.aen'i .mi Pir CID". SA . Oot an email .ft0h, SP rOference us to wait on interview of SA ecauae of FBI IA involvement !'ll be Stan Mg by to here from you on whether or not you, want me to conduct O•sit on the interview of SA 6rc-rt $A. b76-1/ 7501V1:0 DET (00).- VA 22060 Ft Ge-.. --414• Fct), OFFICL1L USE OtILY _AM ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE •_0 1 4 99 0 000067 littp://webmail.urrily..mil/ftarile.htinl?rtfPossible—lrue&lang.teti ' 8/10/2004 DOD-024065 Page 1 of 1 . , rrorr! @ us.army.mii 10:01 pm: ,6•6 •6• To SA CID PKI .Mil. 14'-.7-1401: 13CO T. Subject Re: RFA Thanks, , .. -..,....-....•:- - , .. . i :. • .. . -. -.. , . , • Do you know if they. will be able to locate the other tio FBI Agents who are Identified in 04 RFA /documents .0frlaill111111; 67e.-4, ‘ .. --,L• SA TT 2264mo- 0„..i..poF,:, . .,?..7:::-.-• . . 78th mp. pu(ci(5). ' • . , . • ....... .:.:,.,...,. APO AE $44 .::„,!:.:::::::-: , , ,..,. ,, Oish0": ¦1001 :::::.' •• • .• .:,:,.,.. . ... . 13161601,M0#40....... From: SA CID (PKI)".11111111.1111110@us.army.mil 67e.--4‘s-1 Date:. Wednesday, August 4, 2004 2:07 am . Subject: RFA . -.(0( Y"haV 1111176( 11aS Field Office concerning the =K­ eI wi •, . _ ' briefed them on ali.the aspects onf hte investigator', and am now wafting for - their reply, I mentioned our office would like to sit h on the interView(wheneVer that happens). Let me know if anything else comes up . 676-6 6C-1 peCial A000;::' -s'i • . Fort Nock ftesident Agency FOrt'l-loOd t.TX_.:16$14.: : • . ,06--‘­ ‘-'-r 1::,siNs.: 4 c-,.." - d‘ .6• . .6 -6. • ° FDA OFF1CLAL USE ONO 0 1499 LAW ENFORCECtiENT SENSITIVE 000068 https://webniaitUs.army.mil/frame.htrahtfPossibla----true&lang=en • . 8/10/2004 DOD-024066 iljtiStgot an email from Hood, and they coordinated with Opns at command they Were ... ,.., .. 6. P0 tO cgordiTiato with FBI IA to conduct the interview. I will pass this oh to 411111114dii ve_G-766---K' ,....6. .. _., ... ., .... w, --: ( I to coordinate with Command today and see if they want you to do the same and justpdLes‘..1 Sit in on the )0terview, I don't beleive, but don't know if the FBI Agents were involved in the I ' abuse They may know the detainees medical condition when they received him, who was on the helicopter who transported him, possibly a unknown covert unit operating in Iraq ; detainee may have reported something to them, ed. These guys are FBI and I don't beleive he can't provide any details We need `a good detailed sworn statement from these guys. I will talkANNINtociay i(71/16.-; . who has knowledge of how the FBI conducted their interragations and pass it on torn." maybe -•;.., ,,that will give some info if they are involved or not Thank you 22fid to 6N (abj' 78th MP DET (CID) APO AE 093422.. . oNvr:67c44rhe' from: W01" 11111111111110@us.army.mil 67C-4a I.! aftc.PV0if 4°43 Pm SA6 7C-KiC00-re- • . .. Spoke with $A yesterday. He has just gotten,back from 676.-6a.-K• Iraq on 2 Aug 04. SA said he would have get an ok through his 67c-(j6ki. .. supervisorsbutdid tell me that any documents you need concerning this matter are located at the FBI headquarters at the BIAP. He also stated he • didn't know the unit who captured but that he was held at the Al ‘7e--6a--(4-• . Baghdad! base . ' . . . • prior to tr find out today if SA. arii"1-6:4O:? is • ' f to provi ell Sworn statement. • SA 75th MP DET (CID) figh o'FIrgAL U OHLY • 014992 • LAW ENFORCEttipn SENSITIVE • 000069' • https://wehmaitus.army.millframe.htmrrtfPossibtrue &lang=en 8/10/2004 • DOD-024067 rsage2of , el 5e E • • • FQR OF.F,UAL LAW 4NFpRez.riapKr SE ismve 01499 3 990070 https://webmail.us.aimy.mil/frame.html?rtfPossible .---true8aang=en 8/10/200 . DOD-024068 rage 01 ) 0€00— L3 C4-"-‘4 er°2-7 If 61 • • Sent Tuesday, 2004 9 30 pm ......................................... us. army •• mU ' BCC., -..• • • . • • Subject Fvvck RE: •• SA • 22nd mt).0,1-(t1 ) 6- • 78th MP PET(CIO)', . • APO A 7 ¦;-..4./X‘ p .DNV,J We are still tryihg to get a good phone # roy the FaI IA for Dalla8,,TX, Wewifi asl to sit in on the interview, and If declined, we will be closing the RFA. If that happens, I beleive you would need to request the information through the CIO Command Federal Liaison Officer: I briefed this to my OPS, CW5 in¦B who coordinated with Cmd OPS, CW5 ale 6-e4124‘-' This is the guidance provided, 6765/ SAC, CW3 Fort Hood Resident Ag ency Fort Hood, -Tx 76544 TEL# CELL# 17N4t: . • - FAX# 2542 33O7, j,7‘ ntid EMAIL: . hood.army.enli - CAUTION: This message may contain law enforcement sensitive information, CO not disseminate, which includes fed-Oar-ding the contents of this 'message, without the approval of the sender., If . you are not the intended 'addressee; or the person responsible for-delivering It to the intended addressee, you may not copy or deliver it to anyone else or use it any unauthorized manner. To do so is prohibited and may be unlawful: If you receive this e-mail by mistake, advise the sender immediately by using the reply facility in your e-mail softWait. • SA CID (F'KI) Sent: Tuesday, August 03, 2004 10:02 AM To: SA CIO (PKI) • fiP, OFFIGGAL 01499.4 • - LAW ENFORCEDIEOT SENSITINT . * 000071 . https://wobrnailais.armir.mil/frarne.littnl?rtfPossible=true&lang----en 8/10/2004 . • DOD-024069 t-t,W Page. ot 3 . . .i 0:40._ ca.40,4,5 geo Subject; F110 Original :( us.army.mil Mailtd -• ,us.arm .mill Sen ine . 6;07 AM 1.)700$193i . ottKil; Co: us.army.mil 4-7 Subje .6.6:• 74*:#46. •-• ?iiZs for the UPOotes. added sAMIIIIIIIIIetto the CC line he is now assigned to this iilVestiliQflq When this investigation was initiated we offered it to the FBI whd declined. CID Command coordinated with the FBI and provided this office with the two FBI Agent's location with guidance to continue investigation. Who did you coordinate with at Command who related the FBI Internal Affairs was going to _ conduct the interviews,. We will have to coordinate with them because there has been no guidance that the FBI was going to condUCt. the interviews or is it just this one interview. Reason I ask is because I have another 0.1?, sent to 75th MP Det to interview another Agent and to locate two other FBI Agents for interviewS. Then I can provide the 75th with the same guidance you were given, Thank you = SA 220d. MP BN (CID) 78th.MP DET A.PO .09:34.Z . •::•••• • • il,er.(pc ,_• • Original Message From: ' SA CID (PKI)" us.army,rnil 76/; Date: Tuesday, August 3, 2004 1:42 am . . , . . • SA Finally received the complete RFA. Our case number is 0650-04- ab034., the . efforts to complete your RFA are ongoing. The SAC discussed this. with OPS at command, and we were directed to refer this to the FBI's internal affairs. We will request to sit in on the interview. Due to the expecteddelay in coordination with the FBI, the SAC directed me to we. will be sending you: weekly reports until we receive word from - the FBI on ' .. . how they will complete the' interview. Mioffupleiajvait.,), 11 ,, e; • . - 014993000072 LAWENFORCEDIENT SENSITOf I •6 _ . . , 'https://webmail.us.army.milgrame.html ?rtfPossible---true&lang=en * 8/10/2004 . • DOD-024070 rage o AT.q. . you gn daily 04.4iS regarding the status and any, information they give us, • • •• owpccAL•LAW ENFoncFMENT sEN4nr Nit 01499 6 . 000073 https://webinaitus.army.mildrame.html ?rtfPossible=true&lan —pn 8/10/2004 DOD-024071 • Pagelof t *-0,4 404:: _Foto us.arm . °7 tr314‘. • Sent 1 mii To "." us.arm ' us.a us.arm .mi A. 009, SA • Spoke With esterday, He has just gotteniback from Iraq on 2 Aug 04, SA said he 67e-1‘11' • would have get an .0 rough his supervisors but did tell me that any docoinent$ you need concerning this matter are located at MO FBI headquarters at the BIAP: He alSO stated he didn't knOw the unit who teptUred , . , . at d tathat he was held t the Al Baghdadi baSe prior to trantport to the BIAR Will find Oat today if SA &7e-77 , IS going . to provide a sworn Statement. 67C-.• 4.--f . . : • / --i,..' • SA S .-/-.f 75th mp. pFT(cim • ,, • FT BEINOIR, VA 22060 / , _., 703 ib fc-°-6 , --t • FipiR OFFIcGAR7 lAe ONLY 4.1140 ENFOIPPERIENT $01$111vir 01499_7 000074' -Irue&lang=en; 8/4/2004 https://webmail.us.arm anil/frame.hthal7.rtfPossible ­ DOD-024072 ) „ •6.•6 • •6•6-•6 --.u•ri. 6 •-• •:• 2004 • Sent TiNmimimimmir_uesday August ‘.:. V4•2IcL.:.;.•,_...'.. . • — j*,,•••-,,,,,-;.:._•,--"-....._,_..:.6..6. 1 -... .: .. • SA Fort• erstin 4801 M P 15 . 4.0..iiii,::iii '''''' i..4...:.!: ". :'. :::.• :.6'i.:,...1::,?;.:,..:,.0.'..1.5 1, . -,,,,,,q,...,•:-.'w•-•,,,,,,, . • - • .,:. • A6:PKI " ua.arrn .mil , Us:ain't' •.iriiil• •.' Bce Subject SA 41 irie eorts to complete your RFA are the cornpete .FA.„ Dur case number ' Finally received_ ._ l t_• _ . 1 6c-tea to refer this to the FBI's internal ongoing: The SAC discussed this with OPS at commas ., and we were affairs, . We will request to sit in on the intervieW,: Due to the expected delay in coordination with the FBI, the: - SAC directed me to inform you that we will be sending YOU weekly reports until we receive word from the FBI on how they will complete the interview.. We will then coordinate with you on a daily basis regarding the status and • . any information they give uS._•_. • i'4°-4‘44 Sciai Ant 'Fort Hood Resident Agency Fort Hood, T.,c 76544 ‘7 COMM;_ _g -7C • kOrri CFf NCtAL U 0+10 o1.4998 tAW ENFORCEMENT teiSrrlyt •000075 8/3/2004 k https.../Avebm:thl.us.eirnY.mil/frame.htinyiktatossible=true&lang=en. . DOD-024073 • . .......'"'..Ideated 60 Camp Victory , .Bag'hdati, ' I added the.neW case agent for this investigation to We nk you t:le.:_h Crg•f line. future_. /cor-' .. r'es.....-...pond" .. en.''.••••-•'..•-...;'.....''''....•'. 1ces 5poulci be Mg C g tohim, Tha--. _' • •-•'.• ••--••••• •nk ..: Xtlyt •• • ' • ‘ 7C-'' 4"-i._• SA• ''''''''''''"-. - - . _ .. •_.. •_•_.• .._.--._.._, 2.64-• . P:..., '.`••..:0,. :. ..... .„.• —_.....•..•... 78th MP. 00•‘..._..........(0._., __,......._, ._.. , ......_ . AP(:)..Aa:09.3•::.,:'::•::,_,,_:. •.: ._•_• • ..._• -._, (7. 6.'-6—:..- DNY_r: /_.( ... ....... . . .. , • • • •... : .• ... : Ori g inal Message, -6•6.6.•,..,.....,...,.t..,..2.,,,,, ,:., • . From: '6 ..s.A CID" • us.army.mil 76-4 t‘a- Date; MOndaliAliNst 4 20(14 0:0S.6-pro..6,:',' . .-.' 'f6,,. : :t6-T•":'....--.•'-:c .6' 6• '.6' . 6r•;•.6...•!6,......, •••6.. :6..1..6• .6' 6•6•6,6 Subject: Re:4, RE.: cal RFA 0190-04-CID259-802.54 •6. • vynete. are y041OCated . in theater? ---OriginalMeSSa e•-•=,-.. -,, .._t_, .' 6 7Z.--/ 1(- From: us.army.mil_- /„. : .US-..antly.mil ]_0 7 "--, („) --E(' ,._.. Serit: Q4 9:45 PM ,6,,. / . To:6 SA CID Subject: Ike: RE: Cat 1 RFA 0190-04-CID259-86234 - Thank you SA 22nd MP BN 78th MP DET (CID) 9342, DNVT: _. 40 APO AE(1, 111111111.14-(/ P ­ Original Message 7-7 From: SA CID" us.arrny,mo›* Date: Friday', July 30; 2004 5:02 pm • Subject: RP: Cat 1 RFA 0190-04 -CID259-86234 . SA .176-1; -_ • ._• 1,7 May 04 ancrinoil a be fora year I have istrwara your requett to SA411004111.111RDUTY • AGENT),._ '_ron oFnetAL thEbtliot _Original MeStagg',----. 4—_0; ._l • 4W .?..z,A+IFOTIUSAIENT 0,099 SENS! 0 0 0 0 7 6'https://lkebmailais.atiny.milltrania ..htinnrtfit'ossible=ti-ue&Janr-tra ' 8/10/2004' • ._, DOD-024074 • • • .• .... • Fr ••. • • 0z, '; 21045'.•iO4.. AM • Cat 1 RFA 0194..-04,41.020-8t.4.34 y. r. • •. •i ,• 5 "•(- to vnot.i. boor. receive d . • — .6• • • • • . aknowiedgerflent. If he • the office see if he received this prior to.oporoo a •riaW.,- questions prior to conouotitip the interview please • send me an • . . • • email and I will clarify it • ..•6r.6•6•61. • Thanks, • - • • . . , SA.....,......... ... . .. ,... • 40...pip:BN (M)::-'•:-•,-..--•:,;.-.•:.•••••,- ›..5, 7sth MP DET (CID) , • APO , Ag. 09842 ... : :.: .1, .:••.: .6 ..7t• ,(,, 6,6. ,...(,..6. » DNVT: 411111111.. • 6 • FOR OFF1p0A1, ir4:Otily • k-AW ENForicol.ENT gtiarrive. • . 0 1 5 000 0006 7 7 . • https.://webroaitus.arity.irtiVframe :html?rtfl'ossible--tritie&ling=oo 8/10/2004 . DOD-024075 Pao 1 -of 1 . Ot troO. Sen -Mon'r Oa 2, 204'4 ' ,•C I.P . 2501740234 • To us. arm Ug.artii67-f • Cc Bco Subject CO 1 RFA • ..271Wte:6 .6 4.t ..1....••••¦•••,,,tref4.1....±..----.., • • • FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORMENT SENSITIVE : 01500 1 000078 littps://webmail.us.army.mil/frameltml?rtfPossible=trlettlattg=en, 8/3/2004 DOD-024076 rap ot 1 ID2 5 96 0 . 2 3 4. CC CW3 CID" tit.arrti imil lit . arm Subject Otcr. '1.krA 0091704t '717 supervisor.. No word yet: FOR FFICAL U E otivi iAW glIFORCFAENT SENSITIVE_ 0150. 0 2 0 0,0 0 7 7/31/2004 . - littps://webrnail.us.arrn :thil/frame.htral2rtfPossible=true8&lanr-eti. 6 DOD-024077 of 1 .rOhi Sent 41:45 pm • SA BaHtid .78 • , • :Ut.artri 34 CC 6 Ut.arrr . Bcc Subject Update 0127f-04-CID259-80193 The only peison . here is the linguist LEQ. He has been on leave. I am • pending his return. and will be, complete with this RFA.. • , • .• • 01412'04-CIDMH,P21-; 'There are Only -...006p10. WO have interrogated or been present Two linguist haVe heen.loCated and pending interview., The one interrogator, who was present during the incident time frame, Is On a traveling MI traveling team. he it only*one place for about 2-3 daYS, therefOre, I arri waiting on his return: • 0190-04-CID2$97$0234: You previOusly recelVed the detainee file which contains any mediCal„ interrogation, or other documents prior toa his arrival, If they are not in there; they are not here. I have obtained his two interregation, reports from here prior to the one he made the allegation: No mention of abuse are in therm I obtained the interrogator info on them. If you want the • interrogators interviewed, I will I haVe found, especially now, that if the detainee mentions ahuse, it is recorded and submitted to us, so I find no need to interview the interrogators here, I • can find no.record of FBI Interrogations here. Have •goOrd One:. 676 —t7de SA /5th P7p Det (CID)() - Pridner Interrogation Team . ohraib, Iraq APO AE 09342 • /G---/IriCAPe-1 . FOR oFFCAL USE ONLY 015003. • LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE -110068.0 https://webmail.us.army.mil7frame.html ?rtfOossible=true&lanren, 7/13/2004 • DOD-024078 59:-40 g $4' 000 t, '.-.: 00$ IOW! 004400 Officer ..: Sent rubea ';.20041,64.-Ait:. ... . To:-:: i'.' . • C „,. Vr146 , ,ge.41/ Subject: . FW: Request for IrlfittlatRirt . t. he0 is informatiOn op yOur case involving FBI personnel. Get RFA out to interview. if _ , Vrom OIL) 0M15$ OPP1(s6) tritailtozOincsdP818tOstmtvoitiptid ARMY qmfT MIT], Sent0h4044i J424, 0.4 ()04._ 9?5 PM, To' eggingsmswe$4, ONO:7T Operations Officer! Subject:: nr . 0t:fOr Information 15.16-0-1( According to the FB] SA ig currently at the Wangt4Fley Office and SA at the Dallas Field Office. • If you need assistance in cootainating an interview let us know. ••••••• 4 -26Wr co-( Origibal- Meg$a' From W4 MMC-I Operations 0 fioer tmailtO _ . Iraq. centcom.smil.mil] wi,w6dnesly, 14un:c30, 2004 525 AM D DCSOP 0 1( ) Subject: RE: Request for Information Getting answers from Detachment. It appears that the 2 SAs from FBI are suspects. NV 'want to refer this.investigation to•their inhouse people if possible. We Will answer the 'questions to see; if that is appropriate. . Original Message .FrOm.: CID DCSOPS ORS1(sc} . .- EMailto:CIDDCSOPSORSISC@SBEINOIRDMS.ARMY.SMI14.MIL] Sent Wednesday,_ June 30, 2004 I:OH PM. To: *CW3411Mall-alle (5-mail), cw441111111111111111,(E-mail); oW5411111 . AMIMMOD(5.7 W - 1TTtt:- Request for Information Reference ROI 0190-04-CID259-80234 We briefed HQ, FBI on this cate. As expected, they have a number of . questions. Request you provide as much information as you, can concerning this investigation. . 'el--ill'fityrititrt‘i'dffr--Mt• tht.'t11111111rar iVea`-44 by FBI agents? . 1 7 Did anyone (othet than w'3tne s t476-1-Sel;k4r ) -How was tortured? 74-4 "dragged by his feet and Punched in the abdomen" by FBI agents? -Is it correCt that SA .and SA are the stispecta in this cate? j676-4,4W LOSE ONLY itnnnQi -Was. vu u ULI LAW ENFORCA PENT Sinigrinic 0150046 DOD-024079 the to inteiY bw then d ttdi est you proteid additiotI informat o 01 9 so W9 get back' tchi Oft 25. t)?atocg ,VO. 2004 . FROM: SAC, 780. MT1.41TART,POJACg'OEV(CID) Vt67.0 , TO. ofRECTORi. USAURO. opcTpC FORT HEINOTH', VA, CDR, W$MV:4 ATTN.. CIDPk .fORT PVIc0; VA a0k g.20 MILITARY ;P.OLICE:.:01d*X011 (NM 3D MILITARX POLICE GROUP CDR,1$311i Igo:T.414 POLICE (Cfp) .(FWD) 4410-1VOHM or OTAYre, DETAINEE, al PROVOS m.401(01 mIlEcx cT.P.'t 110-X TO FtiaT4EX Pi,,,MTBrx.91g). ' • •6' •66..6 • • '666•6' 6•66• • . $0117.101, 10VW41444008*2.6j.§0.',84-9fD28-80234-/52H/5YU/50, oWTtA SA RTJEAsNRt SA 1. DIATES/Tim8S/LocATIoN$ 0F 0OcuRRENcEst 1.-4 MAR 2004/ 0001 HRS -11 MAR 2064/2359 HRS; UNKNOWN LOCATION AT BAGHDAD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (BIAP), IZ 2. DATE/TIME REPORTED: 28 JUN 2004', 0900 HRS, SA • •..• • •4 SUBJECT! -(00NOWN);! NM [ASSAULT] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT]. 'tOONSFIRACY1 • . 2. (UNKNOWN); M; (NFI) [ASSAULT] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] '[CONSPIRACY] 5; VICTIM.; 1. Cfv4 Npm ; ; (NEI) fASSAULTI (cRuEl/TX AND MA4TREATMNT3 . 1OONsFXRAQX1 INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY THR INFORmATION IN THIS REPORT IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OAPAtT4KNAHY. INVESTIGATION AND MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE • •, _ COMPLETION THE,INvEsTf87moN, • THIS IS. AN '`OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM"•INVESTIGATION. • THIS INVESTIGATION WAS INITIATED UPON RECEIPT OF MEMORANDUM OF `TRANSMITTAL 0067-Q4-cfp789 FROM PRISION INTERROGATION TEAM (KT) ; pAcjioA0 CENTRAL CONFINEMENT FACILITY (HccF), ABU GHRAIB, IRAQ (AGI),, THAT MR. allirREPORTED . HE WAS ABUSED WHI.I,E DETAINED ON BIAP;. 661( PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED MR._, WAS CAPTURED AND DETAINED AT AN :- UNKNO WN DETENTION FACILITY ON BIAS WHERE HE WAS .INTERROGATED BSS. SPECIAL AGEtTS THE Ft0tRAT018PlitA0 INVESTIGATION (FBI) MR. alliOREPORT ED HE 040,(c!k*r" WAS:TollmED FoR AFrileDgmA:Ttli 24 .119PM AND FM ON HARPED WIRE, FPRTHEkk Jr4 Ni. 0• 9;,111111PitIVATE0 THE TNPWIWALS PRAGOED HIM HY HTS FEET AND PUNCHED HIMCP/r-r(44P-T-• IN THE ABDOHEN., -" • - : kUMW OF DOCUMENTS EXTRACTED FROM MR. alliniDETAINEE FILE REVEALED MR. PP . z2ociresolr WAS IN THE FBI'S CUSTODY, ' ,FF'OJtTS ARE ON7G9TNQ TO LOOATB.THE DETENTION rAci,4Tx 9N BIAP; WHERE MR: /.7e_ie far-- WAS DETAINED. P . OFFICM USE ONLY 015005 000082 El4FORCEMEirtSeurrovir6 DOD-024080 CIDg 9,=g 0 z 3 4 $00A.Tg_.Aag 007.004.0 TO.T40c:.0%. 001,04FTg, p:FTAIITts Fitt AND zproati$!••:Aiig:Cti*cov1/470.'14, LOCAtt:. r(11,14 ;'"''''AGENT AN FI 814gOIAL AGENTi C014.TTibEg uSACitic' 00**,1)0$.1.E0Il4)).g6 Or tllt ktOlttUOI¦1 Ajk:60. 0;;LBLZ. rtAlfAllirkl0 SUSPENSIONt FAVORABLE PERSONNEL ACTIONS AND AR 380=67 FOR THE mpto8x0N a.oc.tinTyqvw4 ­ $ or M011.4 UNDER mrmx'cAni5i4,•. • • gitP6VTS ARg, ts04.tt Ot AUTOMATIC TERMINATION Or PROITOTM MA/WINO ACCORDANCE WITH •044pux: 34,, • "; •h .//, • 1. 614§4 kvottot4,vo opo,a4064,b41:zisio ri. „ , . W?.RNNc' Tb.is message is intended for the use of the indivdua1 o entity t8which i ,0 adclgo'p.od and may c9nt41n. information that is privileged, 1.4w and exempt from disclosure under applicable laW, If tbe'-read.W9f-thissa40 is not the intended t00144ellt or the pTfinie,11,P4 or agent responsible for delivering this message to the in4-endt0 i-6e:ipipnt, youare hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this C6mmi.gaPation is strictly prohibited, Ifyou have received this communication in error, please notify us ittlediataly by reply or bytelephone (703$ 806 0204 and immediately delete this message and all its attaOhept s. ­ FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW. ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE • FOB ()FNMA!. LPSIE OtILY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE _ 015006 , 3 000083 DOD-024081 k600,14; (.4 ...n_ tRFA 01 g -94-c1D259-80234., our case number is 0096-04-CID124 i attempted to tin a ucoordination with SA_and left a message for him at his office. Will get this done ASAP. • sA... t-0.0, fre. ti5 11))_ - .BeW VA 22060 z if e4 6 o , !PR OFF1COI. USE otAN 'LAW E.WPORCEMENT sENsmve • • • • 0150 0 Y . 000084 https://webmail.us.army.mil/frame.html7rtfPossible=true&lane-en 7/29/2004 DOD-024082 Pagel of ,.-.. . .... •' ' POW . 9 H c i i ,'-'....V: .: . sent u rs a ,6• .6..:....,....,,,, i,,,,,,, . v . ;...404 13t , a .. . TO!6•6-ileAitif" :Anil; ,6• SA (Baghdad/78th)" _ us.ar .....m ...-: ......... . . ... .. 'os.a tea 6ril" ' . Q . AC Ba .dad6- " • ••,.....•: s015504 . MO* r'.06. . • . . . • • ,• • • . • . • . • • . oentiemerv,,:• :.•• • • • • •• • • • • . . • ,••••••• • • • • • • we Nye. received the following RFAS: . . 0146.:-.0.4-00 -250-80201 *01.01-04.-C1D.159, 0161 '(?::..*".:'00$0404,*:ort.0**440.1w.,.:.. to044:7-(10$9.0410L.=;. 093A47qopoc:. 61044,troopf.-.00.54-*.t o4.94-04-•,c.lp780 (Cat 1) Yit4704:viiffitorootect as '00o.n . .6.6.•. .os.rossitile, for those not familiar, our of ce curr2nt!y heS several Cat 1 RP.A'$ therefore it may be a while before we get to regular RrAs: 14t.1111$11/ your two are • relatively simple and will probably completed sooner.• 17e1 SA6 b7e-V; • t 75th MP Det tppx-) , • prisoher.Oterrootion Team ' Iraq APO AE .0342 -,•:-6‘=, /6• FOR OFFICOAL . 015008 • . • LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITN _ 000085 https://webmail.us.ant .rniVirame.htpil?rtiPossible=true&lanr--en 6 -7/8/2004 DOD-024083

Doc_nid: 
3825
Doc_type_num: 
66