CID Report: 0177-04-CID259-80266

• DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
UNITED STATES ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
3rd MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID)
78th MILITARY POLICE DETACHMENT (CID) (FWD)
BAGHDAD, CZ
APO AE 09342

CIMPR-FR.
3 Aug 04
MEMORANDUM FOR SEE DISTRIBUTION
SUBJECT: CID REPORT OF INVESTIGATION — FINAL (C)/SSI —0 177-04-CID259-8026.9r­
/5C2B/5Y2E/5X1
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
1. UNKNOWN DATE AND TIME; AL-BAGHDADI AIR BASE, IZ
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 23 Jul 2004, 0900 HRS. 6 4' 1
I' I 117 9-
111106 INVESTIGATED BY: SA. A A

SUBJECT: 1. (UNKNOWN); (NFI); [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT (INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT (INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE] [CONSPIRACY(INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)]
5. VICTIM: 1. (UNKNOWN); (NFI); [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT (INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)] [CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT (INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)] [CONSPIRACY
(INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)]
INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY:
On 21 Jun 04, this office received Request for Investigation (RFI) 0290-04-CID001 from the
United States Army Criminal Investigation Command, 6010 6 th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060­
5506 (USACIDC), which requested this office investigate allegations documented in an excerpt
from the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) on the Treatment by the Coalition
Forces of Prisoners of War and Other Protected Persons by the Geneva Conventions in Iraq
during Arrest, Internment and Interrogation, dated Feb 04,
The conduct of this investigation could not determine if the offenses of Aggravated Assault,
Cruelty and Maltreatment, and Conspiracy occurred. During the course of this investigation, theidentity of the victim could not be ascertained.
STATUTES:
Article 128, UCMJ: Aggravated Assault (Insufficient Evidence) Article 93, UCMJ: Cruelty and Maltreatment (Insufficient Evidence) Article 81, UCMJ: Conspiracy (Insufficient Evidence)
-
DODDOACID004133
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
(.7

0177-04-CID259-80262
EXHIBITS/SUBSTANTIATION:
Attached:
?c-6 64-/
1. Agent's Investigation Report (AI 9 , detailing the receipt of RFI;review of RFI; coordination with CP
Battalion. and the 22nd Military Police 67
2. AIR of S his office, 23 Jul 04, detailing coordination with the 22 n°Military Police a a ion, amp victory, 1Z.
3. International Committee of the Red Cross Report, 10 Feb 04. Not Attached:
None.
The originals of Exhibits 1 and 2 are forwarded with USACRC copy of this report. The location

of the original of Exhibit 3 is unknown.
STATUS: This is a Final Report. Commander's Report of Disciplinary Action Taken is not

required.
Report Prepared By:

Report Approved By:
Distribution:
1-DIR, USACRC, 6010, 6th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (original)
1-Thru: CDR, 22 nd MP BN (CID), APO AE 09342Thru: CDR, Sti MP Group (CID) To: CDR, USACIDC, A 0
, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060 „
1-USACIDC, ATTN: Ms . (email only) t.,7e...-3( 64- .5 1-PMO, MNF-I (e-mail on 1-CID LNO, MNF-1, APO AE 09335 (e-mail only) 1-Office of the Staff Judge Advocate, Ill Corps, ATTN: CPT
(email only)
1-File 6 7c-4, g6-3
DODDOACID-0041 34

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVF
AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT

0177-04-CID259-80266

CID Regulation 195-1

Page 1 of 1

BASIS FOR INVESTIGATION: About 0900, 21 Jun 04, this office received Request for
Investigation (RFI) 0290-04-CID001 from the United States Army Criminal Investigation
Command, 6010 6 th Street, Fort Belvoir, VA 22060-5506 (USACIDC), which requested this
office investigate allegations documented in an excerpt from the International Committee of the
Red Cross (ICRC) on the Treatment by the Coalition Forces of Prisoners of War and Other.
Protected Persons by the Geneva Conventions in Iraq During Arrest, Internment and
Interrogation, date Feb 04.

(776-6 6
About 1300, 21 Jun 04, SAM. reviewed the excerpt included in RFI 0290-04-CID001,
which reflected 25 detainees alleged they were abused while detained at the Al-Baghdadi Air
Base. These detainees alleged they were forced to sit on their knees with their hand cuffed
behind their backs for long periods of time; they endured frequent beatings on various parts of
their bodies; and were subjected to sleep deprivation; and other types of maltreatment. (See

excerpt for details)
1716-.6 199--
About 1300, 23 Jun 04, S and SA
• this office,
MM.. A.....
coordinated with CP ‘4-3
Office of the Staff Rage Advocate, 6 7e-7 fr- --Multi-National Force — IrIq'Wt)',.. aglidi•, Ira.‘who reviewed the files maintained by his
.
office. The review did not disclose any information pertaining to this investigation. CPT
OM stated ICRC has never released names of alleged victims, due to possible repercussions 47641 directed 'toward the detainees. CPTimpprovided a copy the ICRC report on the Treatment
.,...-.2.ze ..!-,-
by the Coalition Forces of Prisoners OfWar and Other Protected Persons by the Geneva
Conventions in Iraq During Arrest, Internment and Interrogation, date Feb 04. A review of the
report did not disclose any names relative to this investigation. (See report for details)

I1 ,. ilik-/

About 1330, 23 Jun 04, SA ,.and SA
....._ coordinated with CO 7C---Yea
lirtm.,.
s . _ ; Staff Judge Advocate, MNF-I, B-47:1-a-,Chwho advised no contact should be
ma a with
ICRC due to the sensitive relationship they have with the Coalition Forces. Also,
the ICRC respects the confidentiality of the detainees and will not provide any names of the
victims due to the fear of possible repercussions directed towards the detainee.

PC--4 e4-"1
About 1315, 29 Jul 04, SA coordinated with 22' d MP BN (CID), Camp Victory,
Iraq and obtained the full idea--6fNI
fir
Office of the
Staff Judge Advocate, CENTCOM, MacDil MLA T Yllr'''''''''''2 4 7-1,6
‘...3
DODDOACID-004135
SA
78 th MP Detachment (Forward) (CID) Special Agent
,

Baghdad, Iraq APO AE 09342
Signat

Date: Exhibit: 29 JUL 04 CID Form 94 3
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

AGENT'S INVESTIGATION REPORT 0177-04-CID259 —09A,
CID Regulation 195-1
PAGE 1 OF 1 PAGES
DETAILS

During administrative review by 22 nd Military Police (MP) Battalion (BN), (CID) (FWD), APO AE 09342 it was determinedthis office needed to re-open this investigation as a Report of Investi . . ...ROI 0
,4,0mplete additional investigativeactivity. This office needs to locate, fully identify, and interview MAJ . Chief, International Law, CENTCOM-CCJA (NFI) to obtain additional information to assist this investigation.MLAST ENTRY/// /
to
DODDOACID-004136
(7 TYP. SIGNAT]
SA 78th MP Det (CID) (FWD), 09342 CID FORM 94-E
CTAL USE ONLY.EXHIBIT
1 007' 95
PROTECTIVE MARKING IS EXCLUDED FROM
AUTOMATIC TERMINATION (Para 13, AR 340-16)

aft
(When Data Is Entered)

Page(s)
30

Referred to:
U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND 7115 SOUTH BOUNDARY BLVD ATTN: CCJ6-DM MACDILL AIR FORCE BASE FLO' DA 3-3621-5101 -
MS. JACQUELINE SCOTT scotti@ceritcom.smiLmii
(813) 827-5341/2830
DODDOACID-0041 37

UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

DATE: 26 JULY 2004

FROM: SAC, 78TH MILITARY POLICE DET (CID) (FWD)
TO:

DIRECTOR, USACRC, USACIDC, FORT BELVOIR, VA
CDR, HQUSACIDC ATTN: CIOP-ZA, FORT BELVOIR, VA
CDR, 22ND MILITARY POLICE BATTALION (CID) (FWD)

CDR, 3D MILITARY POLICE GROUP (CID)
CDR, 78TR MILITARY POLICE DET (CID) (FWD)

MNF-I, CHIEF OF STAFF, DETAINEE OPS
PROVOST MARSHAL, MNF-I
LNO CID, MNF-I (FOR FURTHER DISTRIBUTION)

SUBJECT: CID REPORT -INITIAL/SSI -0177­
04-CID259-80266-

/5C2B/5Y2E/5X1

DRAFTER : SA 1
(7,-- ,
RELEASER: SA

1.
DATES/TIMES/LOCATIONS OF OCCURRENCES:
UNKNOWN DATE AND TIME; AL BAGHDADI AIR BASE, IZ

2.
DATE/TIME REPORTED: 23 JUL 2004, 0900 HRS

6,764( 6.-1
3. INVESTIGATED BY: SA,

9--
4.

SUBJECT: 1. (UNKNOWN); (NFI); [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT]
[CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] [CONSPIRACY]

5. VICTIM:

1. (UNKNOWN); (NFI); [AGGRAVATED ASSAULT]
[CRUELTY AND MALTREATMENT] [CONSPIRACY]

6.

INVESTIGATIVE SUMMARY: THE INFORMATION IN THIS REPORT
IS BASED UPON AN ALLEGATION OR PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION
AND MAY CHANGE PRIOR TO THE COMPLETION OF THE
INVESTIGATION.

THIS IS AN'OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM" INVESTIGATION.

ON 21 JUN 04, THIS OFFICE RECEIVED REQUEST FOR

INVESTIGATION (RFI) 0290-04-CID001 FROM THE UNITED STATES
ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND, 6010 6TH STREET, FORT
BELVOIR, VA 22060-5506 (USACIDC), WHICH REQUESTED THIS
OFFICE INVESTIGATE ALLEGATIONS DOCUMENTED IN AN EXCERPT
FROM THE INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF THE:RED CROSS

(ICRC) ON

THE TREATMENT BY THE COALITION FORCES OF PRISONERS OF WAR
AND OTHER PROTECTED PERSONS BY THE GENEVEA CONVENTIONS IN

UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
DODDOACID-004138
UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

IRAQ DURING ARREST, INTERNMENT AND INTERROGATION, DATED FEB
04.

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION REVEALED NUMEROUS DETAINEES AT
CAMP VILIGANT, BAGHDAD CENTRAL CONFINMENT FACILITY, ABU
GHRAIB, IZ (BCCF) ALLEGED-THEY WERE ABUSED WHILE DETAINED

AT THE AL-BAGHDADI AIR BASE. THE DETAINEES
ALLEGED THEY
WERE FORCED TO SIT ON THEIR KNEES WITH THEIR HAND
RESTRAINED-BEHIND-

THEIR BACKS FOR LONG PERIODS OF TIME;
THEY ENDURED FREQUENT BEATINGS ON VARIOUS PARTS OF THEIR
BODIES; WERE SUBJECT TO SLEEP DEPRIVATION; AND OTHER TYPES

OF MALTREATMENT.

ON 23 JUN 04, COORDINATION WITH THE OFFICE OF THE STAFF
JUDGE ADVOCATE, MULTINATIONAL FORCE - IRAQ, BAGHDAD, IZ,
DISCLOSED THE

ICRC HAS NOT RELEASED THE NAMES OF THE
VICTIMS DUE TO POSSIBLE REPURCUSSIONS DIRECTED TOWARD THE
DETAINEES.

ON 23 JUN 04, A REVIEW OF THE COMPLETE REPORT GENERATED BY
THE ICRC DISCLOSED NO FURTHER INFORMATION REGARDING THE
IDENTITIES OF THE ALLEGED VICTIMS.

ON 24 JUN 04, THIS INVESTIGATION WAS CLOSED IN THE FILES OF
THIS OFFICE.

ON 23 JUL 04, DURING AN ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW OF THIS CASE
FILE, IT WAS DETERMINED A REPORT OF INVESTIGATION SHOULD BE
INITIATED AND FURTHER INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITY CONDUCTED.

EFFORTS ARE ON GOING TO LOCATE, FULLY IDENTIFY, AND
INTERVIEW THE UNKNOWN SUBJECT(S) AND UNKNOWN VICTIMS.

INVESTIGATION CONTINUES BY USACIDC.

7.

COMMANDERS ARE REMINDED OF THE PROVISIONS OF AR 600-8-2
PERTAINING TO SUSPENSION OF FAVORABLE PERSONNEL ACTIONS AND
AR 380-67 FOR -

THE SUSPENSION OF SECURITY CLEARANCES OF
PERSONS UNDER INVESTIGATION.

8.

CID REPORTS ARE EXEMPT FROM AUTOMATIC TERMINATION OF
PROTECTIVE MARKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 3, AR 25-55.

UNCLASSIFIED - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
f
DODDOACID-004139
3 2
SEG, VCE NUMBER ,
INVE., fltATIVE PLAN
01 7 7-04-C10295 lalDr)tbDATE OFFENSE
VICTIM' 21 Jun 04 Cruelty and Maltreatment I Unknown
'DATE
DATE
PLANNED ACTIVITY
COMPUSIED
NOTED 21 Jun 04 Locate. fully. identify, and interview unknown N;ictins21 Jun 04
Datenniue locating of Al-Baghdadi Air Base 21 .h0104 Obtain complete copy of !CRC Report 21 Jun 04
Determine %vital unit maimed the holding facility at Al-Baghdadi Air East21 Jun 04 Loewe, full • ID and interview !CAC Doctor who examined unidentified victim2i Jun 04
Determine identity ofV-' s
ioiho died in Saddam Hussein Islamic School21 Jun 04 Coordinate with MAI;
.. ..
MISCELLANEOUS ACTIVITY
ACTION COMPLETED ACTION
CIC )(MEI' COMPLETED
FINAL EVIDENCE REVIEW INITIAL SRO REVIEW
FINAL CIC REVIEW PINAL-514.0 REVIEW --
CONTACTS/M.10HE WUMBERS
INVE-c'TICA -11Vr
• PI-KINE NIAIEIER
VICTIMS I -VIEWED
24 hours
RSON 4)!etwrr+111111111
EYE WITNESSES 24 hours
INTERVIEWED
EVIDENCE DEPOSITED 1 duty dayLAB REQUESTS 5 duty daysRFA'S SENT OUT 5 duty days
MEANINGFUL SW ACTIVITY 10 duty daysRFA FOLLOW UP
15 duty days
KNOWN SUBJ FINALS
15 duty days
UNFOUNDED FINALS
15 duty days
UNKNOWN SUB.! FINALS
30 cal days
ACTION TAKEN 30 cal da s
-
Fog..em.y LAw satgr--Azot
r"....ummimmun TCCENS=
LC $Uidt..•.1¦11•11111•01.1•1111•1111V
."41.Z7RYw
WZllM1nit
(CID Requiatzon 195 ­
1)
Ora-o4 - C.2.3 251
Tum , Qa z . MD MEM
Subialti OF SIVVESTIGATIVL AC1T
a
fficc. 2.1 . kAss"Q-.030,1 r_pz caft; -614-It dk,
1,-md,6G-t cito;a:,:;;•-td «1 7C IZC-Eaft:. (4 CLkod

lakPl'u°4 I pt,,AeLiod P-7 1-Cote tittrevli)
6.7c-t, De.II

Ha", tiSok (1.
5 AutAit Gab Cd4t4u.e -eirk
YAWN 67-464-/
I
iflodi 4 (At buitv: 640--,
cp.". 6See /.1-SizArdevalegi /7 -7
2ZoLidoef
64- 3 Cask/it-I.:0,a 4 ca-ggrattseeAvte 10/elitivt
64'1 gsdia c:M-e&-Arof oloriire 4:11WAs64111111111111WhfrehriI
SACIAwirlifiorore.
;LDS Pga6t41-4
c.01Ikt) I Wel
I .1sh ;5 e1Crc_kt.C:ftIft(04 eiitir 1./1-601--/- ea AO
retokk 410I
7ell& ;Ail-Q.0374W Aff 4
&A). CZVC,rkDSII egi CA_ Lsv; tag -4//.
044 (I Coairicr6
Nrs-oH-
ftr'le °t41);-5"fe)1414;.e-(14/
Advic tretiigarlytmer;ir
Arm Tat( PreS Ao+ te (got
0, V-0 cl
Lf›E. -awe
C .r4P...1'
Et. LIS= 1.71:i
EXIV4.1.:;;Pp2r1
AGENTS ACTIVL._ SUbilARY
Contzol Numbez

(T.T.0 Regulation

02.77-04-CrD259
Crattia
=HZ.

E. AMD AGM?? sumpar or INVESTZCATIVE ACT/IVITY
2:', :'.:1 ,:z: • 2Jr:nqaci1:.r.57

re

:EP: 2sit:alon -;1.,::;y 2:- Mi-.tar" ?olice

4
4.6 d iFw, AFC AE C9342

etermined this

i was

(-'i- office needed to re-open this

pp.I()7(-' investigation a
s a Report of Invest.igation (ROI) to

I c 1piete addili
ono:. investigative activi-!:

3iface..zee.cis —
mi;C• cte, fully identify, and intenriew11 -Chief, inte-national Taw4-'4 rfr
J.. toch,Laan additi.,
assist this in7estigat!.on onal information to

;b111110111111161 rz-4537mta OZ -.6 ‘4;-(6,41-.4) 1,415sZ
13 546 41 /C4;44
•
ArtItb isrIktclvel)
tecet4Ic3Cr
ce.4.asro 47c-664-/
e4fetalw 4.6
t.t.•tofr
2--.gito
3, •10:it do
Aitz vule pritv,), v kiaL,1,044gri kutl
Cotititnot Satatk, t
s ps; 44IctitnI4.441I.11,41Ietatotit ts
v5. antvrovil (731 ,¦4j
/ 4.4-5

Ogod,-6°
6,1c/Q6vt- Juliai") Ls'
ic.fo
djak kA ,j 45 4,6 41 .4eri /:5
1,44 D/saiwei (.4 ,51K .
tiallfrie am" 6./ 414V:ii, p#'//oe; Ott/ &Naps.
IV
.41 4f, frerititAi
Gz--4
caa• ••••••¦••¦•••¦•••¦•*.
-ron...wrosaumeriasomme
FORm 28

PFVJEOUS EGIZIONS OF T)tIS FORK WILL ST

1 Oat 8C

UNTIL EXRAUSTED

AGENTS ACTIV1— SOiNARY
CONTRCIL• NUMBER
1CTD Regul a Lan
I TUE ,
Ewa. AK ALUM
MAMMY Or UNISTIGATVE ACTIVITY
Aucliner
. ..

elazbwm-/Z7; 1111.
b"/ 6--/ (,7e_ft„...
kz
V• 720 't3?
-7A?
"1ln, C. -s.
4*-
ml
5.244.teita ft:4
icre
0,, I% p.uc, oN4,
V•cor..ft ria
4L.
1^-804-1-
L.4)
LAY)
LC. t.
.
Sik 676-31/5k3
reseti.71-e r.A.caU 4-0
"17
N:4
-1,‘‘
Cocti-clixodeci / 4140E-I srp,
wtk reld.t.„) dot. 76466'
0 cowicom.siv4.11.4:1
7C -Ifa-1 ett4 bNic
4 s •
).0eci 3
. re S etroL sii ,,
erCZ-Ck7C-3(
.7c-4 ci Ia t-rc.
•et% Pe tett ek Ly COL
%•e.
emu; I o
C-C¦ r
atikkAitbik •
64v
zc alt4 7e--3X
der:, ,44 eywcul
, cre.111111110,.

C2:I FORM 29

PPXV1CMS LD:T/OMS OF THIS FORM WILL B1 OM

UNTIL EXIMUSTED

_

-

-4
DODDOACID-004143

or?? c'f•cip25•9. pe., z(6,
21. In Camp Vigilant, the section of Abu Ghraib
prison were most persons deprived of their liberty
held for security reasons were confined, the ICRC
interviewed persons deprived of their liberty who
alleged to have been ill­
treated by CF soldiers while

temporary held in Al-Baghdadi Air Base. Out of the

7C-8O persons deprived of their liberty that reported

to have been held there, 25 alleged to have suffered

ill-treatment. They stated that they had been made

s:: on their knees for long hours while handcuffed in

the back, that they had endured frequent beating on

parts of the body, incl

...:ding the genitals,

while hooded, and that they nad been subjected to

sleep dhprivation. A method described in the

allegations consisted in forcing persons deprived ct

the__ liberty to lie face down, their hands cuffed

behind their back and shackled to their ankles for two

to three boars. While in this position, soldiers

would allegedly insert in'their mouths cloths full of

dust and hot pepper, • One person deprived of his

liberty arrested on 21 August alleged that he had been
hooded, beaten and placed naked in front of an air
conditioning machine while cold water was thrown on
his body. A dog, initially with a muzzle, attached
him with its paws and then bit him on the right thigh

(according to the examination of the ICRC doctor, he
had marks compatible with a dog bite). In the right
shoulder he had a hepatoma and _;near marks compatible

with repeated whipping cr beating. He had wrist marks

compatible withtight fieri-cuffs.

The ICRC also collected allegations of deaths as a

result of harsh internment conditions, ill

-treatment,

lack of medical attention, or the combination thereof,
notably in Tikrit holding area formerly known as the
Saddam Hussein Islamic School.

RE or-Plc/AI-use egf_y
LA1 biAgamfArr Stil 1Yv/

Cruelty and Maltreatment
9. TYPE
Unknown

5. %loam
IC_
Unknown
REPORTS TYPE
SUSPENSE COMP
! 6. CASE DESCRIPTION RFI 0290-04-CID001 regarding allegations of abuse documented in -aff Mk) atiA)
ICRC Report, Feb 04. 5:04 C. 6Mt qjzito
• it. °TITER ACTION 2 •3•01...
112. CM FUNDS ACTION I RQRD COMPL 0,711/
DATE AMOUNT
. . .
FLo
f.:2C1A1-kke. fug'
tr.(_.4 CA4 Fbra.J0E-An 3SNI:t7.1-1.ig"
6, C-vrr
•ft.r
F CW2 S dal ent
From:
W2 MNC-I Special Agent 7C elf 6a-
Sent:
18, 2004 4:36 PM
To: (USA)
Subject:
67C.,.:
Misr
67 c---3, 6
CID has been tasked to investigate all allegations of Detainee Abuse within the Theater of Operations for Iraq. We currently have approximately 50 open actions, ranging from a slap in the face to deaths. We are required on a weekly basis to provide investigative updates to CID Command, who in turn briefs the SECDEF. at the end of the
M. It has
been nothing less than a great challenge Identifying whether or not the detainees are prOviding false Information, a
can probably imagine. Our office consists of five agents. We do some traveling in the local
area. but are limited .s you
Currently, we have two allegations of abuse that have originated from the International Committee of the Red Cross.
One of the victims has been Identified as Mr The other v m is as an Iraqi Detainee at
era
the Al-Baghdad/ Air Base during the time frame of 23 .1til 04 Further identifying Informa identified
tion
pertaining to these victims would greatly assist this office in investigating these allegations of abuse by Coalition Forces. Any assistance provided Is greatly appreciated.
FOk ,FFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

v177-6 'V- C2''2
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
U. E. ARMY CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION COMMAND
solo 6" STREET FORT savant VIRGINIA 22060-5506
REPLY TO
4Tnblif.0 ft OP

S: 1 Aug 04

CIC:-CC

16 jun C4

!ei7MCRANDIP-1. FOR Cceemandee, 3rd Mi2itary Police Group (C1,71, USACIDC
CIRC-Ov), 46P, Nerzh Street, Fcrest Park, GA 30297

SUBJECT; Request for Investigation (0290-04-C1D001)

1. On 2 Jun 04, this headquarters received information from the
Detainee Assessment Task Force, USACIDC, Ft Belvoir, VA, reaarding
excerpts from the Report of the International Committee of the Red
Cross;ICRC} on the Treatment by the Coalition Forces of Prisoners
of War and Other Protected Persons by the Geneva Conventions in
Iraq During Arrest, Internment and Interrogation, dated Feb 04,
wherein a detainee reported being'abused while detained at Al­Bagh:ladi Ai: Base, to include a dog bite.

6fr(

2.
Ceordination was made with MAJ Chief. :nternati•na:, Law, CENTCOM CCJA, who re ated t,:eMultinational Force-:raq fMNF-I), has overall responsibility for the Iraq theater of operatiohs and is the senior headquarters to CJTF-7. According to MAIM the MIq-I would be the responsible party to make both 676-1(6fr policy and legal determination concerning allowing USACIDC access tc :CRC employees. As such, this headquarters was unable to obtain additional information concerning the referenced ICRC allegation. A search cf all available USACIDC data failed to disclose the initiation of a USACIDC investigation concerning the referenced ICRC allegation.

3.
Request a Report of Investigation be initiated concerning the

information reflected above.

4. Request ackn•wLedomeht of this RFI nc later than 24 Jun 04.
Further', request the sequence/report c investigation (R011 number
of the rivesLigation no later than 1 Jul 04. A response to this

RF:, ro include sequence/ROI number and the status of the

investigation, will be forwarded to this headquarters, ATTN: CIOP-
COP, no Later than the above suspense date. If no ROI is
initiated, that information will be provided tc this headquarters.
A:: correspondence will clearly identify the HQUSACIDC control

number.

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

F...m•C
Pao',lac Pipe•
1. .
DODDOACID-004147
/770Y-c2,,2
-
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

SUBJECT: Request for Investigation (0287-04-CID001)
CIC?-CO

74. 42/64'-2-
S. Point of .contact for this action is CW241011111110111101at

r:33 80E0111 or. 011110@nelvoir.artyanil.

FCP THE DEPCTY CRTEF CF STAFF, G-3:

/// 54 110 /if. b -74-6 U1
1 no

as
Chief, investigative Operations
Division

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE

9
. DODDOACID-004148
`
06-11b0.--
CW3 (ZINC-1 Special Agent O/ 77- c)`-i •Ci 1)2_S "-ti"eiZ
6,74--of 64— -›
From:
(USA)
Sent:

09, 2004 11:56 PM
-6/-.
To;
MN Special ?Q-I or
Cc:
(USA); J
Subject: (USA) !, 7c - 64. 3
Ghie (774---6
Glad to meet you. I'm the segs, representative to the cENTcOm Detainee Tiger Team We also maintain a detainee
abuse catabase ill try to help.
To restate your questions

74,--16I4‘
1) do we have any information concerning alleged abuse to Mr.
'CRC?

s repartee by the
a. Dc you know where the abuse took place? •
b What the type of abuse was it? (presumably physical to some extent but could also be mental/emotional)
c Any indication of when the abuse took place or at what point of capture. transfer

: or detention?
2) do we have any information concerning alleged abuse at Al-Beghdadi Air Base to an unknown victim as reported by the
ICRC?
a. What the type of abuse wasit? (presumably physical to some extent but could also be mental/emotional)
b Any indication of when the abuse took place or at what point of capture, transfer. or detention?

COL
Sill !rest your assistance by finding the ICRC reports concerning the allegations above
MAJ 6 -7e---4(
647-3
Do these ring any bells? Please check the database
.
R
t.TCIMP 67d.-3 4 6‘•-3
CENTCOM
DSN: (312) 651 .

COM: 13131 B27
NIPR cen om. mil
SIPR; oentcom.smil.mil

----Original Message----
‘1
From: 3 MNC-I Special Agent 67d-(r 64Sent: rtUrsday, iter 09, 2004 1:45 AM To:1111111111tol USAF) Subject: FW: Abuse (legations
-3/4‘fr-f
Sir.
We would like to get your assistance in identifying a possible abuse victim The case agent has tried to make contact with
MAJIMIbut has been unsuccessful. Please G see the email traffic below
Thanks
Chiefillinnt
-6 7C --(/. 6
-
10
O C.-J rATV..:J
Ga
676' SSG FANC-1 CID S eci I • e t 7c4 frf
From:
vcmain.hq.c.,5.arrny.mil on behalfoaIIIMIMIBSSG IIANC-1 CIDSpecialAgent
Seat September24.2004 12:10AM
Tca (;),-,.m.arrny. mil' 7c--.21. ,170.* is--
Subject • :ti•n

ess (77c.2-
wee .

e.s egv, CW 1IIIIIIcoordinated .'ii.:. you bender:lice
otmrsining rift.rmation related tb" detainee as allegazLons reported by
Ir2C. Ig order for this cffice Lc ccn•hacl a fair, zherough, and time:v

investigation, there Is more information needed
abs.Lit the vLctims c r!le
a:Legeticna. 7his infcrmatiog ia being sought fcr the iistLptor
p.;i—oses nir :here is an. 1: .-azion made by a Mx.

(7 7 6K
use a:_eptions Tr A2 3aghdadi
ZaSe, arta c:her a1:egations where 7.he idenrffica:icn cf sub)eeLs in the ICRC

repnrts is simply "m Trictim."
ah Der Inbe Atine 7ask Fcrce Z2nd Mi E :CI:: (F1CDAPC AE D5342.
r-ff 1C“
28:-.222411111
The sword of :Justice has n'o scabbard" - Antione De Riveral

1.
Page 1 of 1
.."160?-cliC/ b25-91r0Z6O
us .arrnvi,il:+
FrOM ariar
Sent gilder, September 17, 2004 1.52 arn
791111110111111-anco-n.inii
(.7 -7C,-9— 7
• us-arrny.rivi
Subject .coordintition

ISM
Greetings. Last week, CW coordinated with you concerning obtaining int
reputed by the ICRC. The dons
t have been mentioned pertained to a M.
Internment Serial Number abuse allegations at the AI Eaghdadi For se, and other va aunknown victim(s). Wit InVOlving an
You continued assistance is appreceated,
S
67c -lfh -/
ti rce 22nd P4P SN (czo;;FWD; APO, AE 0934Z-DSN: 31-
Att us.anny.rnil 'Heave ere ern. - Voltaire
https:iTwebrr.aiL us. army. ro i Vfratne.htm '?rtfl'os s .tru e& lang =en.
9,17/2004
-1
DODDOACID-004151

/16 6'd
0177-04i' Ci.AZ SF -6-0 266
F CW2 PANC-I Special Agent
CW2 MNC-! Special Agent -7C-1, ‘4-1
Subject: se legations
,11.1 1.e
MAS 12I -3( 616
Currently , we have two allegations of abuse that '4,1*Ut.-::;;;.• • +g .of the Red
Cross. One of the victims has been Identified as Mr

The other victim is
purely identtfled as an Iraqi Detainee at ttie Al-Baghd - Air Sase ring the time frame of 23 .hit 04. Further ALe
identifying inforrnation pertaining to these victims woukl greatly assist this office in investigating these allegabons
of
abuse by Coalition Forces.
I had previously coordinated with you last week regarding the above persons. I was wondering If

you had a chance to
review my previous correspondence.
Any assistance provided is greatly appreciated.

, 64,
Detainee: se Task Farce
DSN 82

j
13
DODDOACID-004152