AR 15-6 Investigation: Statement of Soldier re: Incident at Ramadi Palace, Iraq, July 11-12, 2003

Itemized List of Evidentiary Exhibits
I - Initial statement by
II - Initial statement b
III-Statement of n initial questioning o
IV-Statement of upon initial questioning o
V-Initial statement o taken by and privacy act statement and mandatory form taken by VI-Initial statement of I taken by. AO privacy act statement and manddisclosure orm taken by
.__
VII-Initial statement of mac act statement'ind mandatory disclosure fen -rn-Pkell. VIII-Initial statement of riVacy act statement and mandatory disclosure rruta IX-Initial statement o snd privacy act statement and mandatory disclosure fortn taken by X-Initial statement of Rights warning waiver certificate taken by XI-Rights warning waiver ceil Cate(non-waiver) o taken by
XII-Statement of, egarding questioning of all soldiers involved.
XIII-Applicable portions of OPORD for Operation Thunder Payback
XIV-Packet of 4 Questionnaires handed out to soldiers to get a general understanding of the view on treatment of detainees in general and of the events in this particular mission.
008188

SWORN STATEMENT For use of this form, see AR 19045; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SSW AUTHORITY: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified. PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: Your social security number is used as an addtional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES: - -

Disclosure of our social securi number is vgluntar 4. FILE NUMBER
DISCLOSURE: 2. DATE IYVWMMbD) 3. TIME
3
1. LOCATION 2003/01/31
Rifles Base Ar Ramadi Iraq not -_FIR T,N' '..IDDLE NAME
8. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
94th MP CO Rifles Base Ar Ramadi Iraq
,FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:9. , WANT TO MAKE THE

1 , ithillillibncips
rved civilian
On 2003/07/29 at a ro . 1630hrs I was in the company area of the 94th MP COJ wspe4g w marf..WOW­
n the da . _ed.ii::-.
i
was talking about a raid he went on earlier stated he bound and on the ground, being guarded by an StAn ' -on the
"Mik
e as who kick a detainee several times, approx. times or A ut the t . all 6'0'; An'
.. .. 01al1c dist e to observe this incident.1111,
observed ck and 'd he was with ye Squad leader, told him teis_ta.
6r$,110.111e-. .

detainee on or saidelliIllillL'
...
: eve Convention'
underthe
_..ordered .tosto that the cletainee-Wat -PrOte. . 1) 3
his lane. said he told don't follow the Geneva Convention, so why should we!"

said several lower ' ' Wed in the area stated
going to bring the incident up the soldiers involved Chain of Command.
saidjie, %vas
'0 -

sal
A. :_...,'
Q. 1ihere anything you would like to add to your statement?
/IIQ. No
t-AKING STATEMENT
11. INITIALS OF PE PAGE 1 OF PAGES
10. EXHIBIT
DATED
AT

ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER
USAPA V1.00
MUST BE BE INDICATED.
DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLETE
DA FORM 2823. DEC 1998
008189
2003/31/07
TAKEN AT Rifles Base DATED
STATEMENT OF
3 I.
9. STATEMENT (Continued) 1111111
sed11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111111111111111111111111111111
11111111
AFFIDAVIT •

4 ‘;/-
HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TOME THIS STATEMENT OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
2 . I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE
EGINSOkPAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGE
BY ME. THESTATEMENT1STRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY. WITHOUT HOPE oFogNO,oR REWARD; WITHOUT THREAT
OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, GA, NLAW

WHICHPIIIIIIIIII"
3 / 6
Subscribed and sworn to befdra me, a person authorized by law to
WITNESSES:

day of July 2003
administer oaths, this 31
at RifleS )3a$C, AT 14114di Iraq
t 2
Administering Oath)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
11111111111111
{Typed Naine of Person Administering Oath)
'

Artical 136 (b)(4) UCMJ
(Authority To Administer Oaths)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING
PAGE 2 OF 2 PAGES
USAP A V1.00
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
ISSN).
C Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 AUTHORITY:
Title 10 US­PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with'means by which information may be accurately identified.
Your social security number is used as an additionaValternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval. ROUTINE USES: Disclosure of yoUr social security number is voluntary.
DISCLOSURE 4. FILE NUMBER
DATE (YYVYMMDD)• . TIME
2.
1. LOCATION
2003/07/98-3/ NA6
Rifles Base, Ar Rama& 7. GRA E/STATI)S
6. SSN
NAME,:MIDDLE NAMELAST14,1/0E
1 WNW
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS8.
94TH MILITARY POLICE COMPANY, CAMP RIFLES, IRAQ

9. , WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
1,
f 29 July 2003, the following information was told to me by company medic,IMIOMIIIIIIIIPi in theIn the late a emoon o_ at Camp Rifles Base in the front yard of the company HQ location: In the mornmg of 29 Jut
presence q ..
2003 111111111111111111111 was with the company 2nd platoon members that were assisting 3rd ACR soldiers conducting a raid. After
ab use an Iraqi prisoner. grip
were detained and bound up he observed one of the 2nd platoon MP's physicallyq detainee that wasseveral baof an Ira i
oximatel 100 meters away a US AMY MP stepping on the ck
, 0 d from kickin the detainee three different times.
la in ontheround with his hands bound behind his back. The MP appeared from the company's 2nd asked .those around bin' who the MP was and was told it w told him
squad leader the
platoon. When he stated the MP- shouldn't be kicking the Iraqi proc eeded to turn the

bad prote
then went over and if in itc of
sted, Iraqi bly
to stay in his lane. atomment that the was pro ba
t w4.5clgse by t
detainee's face in theadt-L comments that-theGeneava Conventions don't apply
-. tesTildie
indiVidual that had killed an Aiiiiiieiii Army Officer
here., He could not identify who the other soldiers were. from his area of operations. Approx
- - - the 2nd Platoon Sgt was called to report to the company operations
lato.on members he resides with. As I
'
had already departed with tbc,Ist ,
thirtfinifinie. - 4rrival, w --'-'-' had reported to him immediately
10 ,told Me, he stated that __ ,_
Of what,
began info e may ve-Appeared to have been an incident Vidhat Iraqi detainee.
eniiSsion that tfroir­
after returnin , of the incident was the MP's were moving the detainee into a better positioii=juSt the stated that' ''. that because of the seriousness of the possibility that a violation
bindings that ivaeriepthg,bis hands tied. I told
had ocO ed our MPI would be looking into the incident.

o r
Q.
A. YOu have anything you would like to add to your statem nt at this time?
Q. i-
A. No ent11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111End .
L 3r -1/
MAKING STATEMENT I
11. INITIALS OF= 2 PAGES
PAGE 1 OF
10. EXHIBIT
DATED ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT OF
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER
MUST BE BE INDICATED. USAPA V1.00 DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLETEDA FORM 2823. DEC 1998
rTAKEN AT

t, 0 819 I
DATED
TAKEN AT
STATEMENT OF

ilk 3
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111111N
AFFIDAVIT
tO
' HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT
WHICH BE NS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGE 2. I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE
BY ME. THE STATEMENT
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT. . .
,
a ing-taternent)
900-r 0
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by la to WITNESSES: July 21 3
administer oaths, this 30 day of
at Rifles
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
yped flame of Person Administering Oath)
Artical 136 4 UCMJ
(Authority To Administer Oaths)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT 2 OF 2 PAGES
PAGE
IMO L '3 I-
USAPA V1.00
PAGE 3. DA FORM 2823. DEC 1998

C 0819,2

DOD 006823

SWORN STATEMENT For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SSN).
AUTHORITY: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified. Your social security number is used as an additionat/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:
ROUTINE USES:
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social, security number is voluntary.
2. DATE (YYYYMMDD) 3. TIME -4. FILE NUMBER
1. LOCATION
Rifles Base, Ar Ramadi Iraq 2003/07/31 ` go?
7. GRADEJSTATUS
LAST NAMg,f1ASt NAME, MIDDLE NAME 6. SSN 3);1,
00

8. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
94th MP CO Rifles Base Ar Ramadi
9.
, I -5 i' WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
I,
On the 30th day of July 2003 and I went to FOB Maddog to interview 411/01/1.1111. He told us that on the
kicking a detainee that was already "flexLcufted. in -the back, neck, and head.
morning of the 29th he witnessed soldier kicks the detainee anymore that he was going to kick the soldier. He also told
U n seem this he yelled out that
uad leader - e. After this, said he would take care of it and went towards.....
mgat location he sgt, It down on the detainee's back to change the flex-cuffs and while doingffi-s

'
that e back to him and told him to "stay in his lane". When werubbed the detainee's' face;,in the dirt. said
the investigators asked...to put all of this in a statement e said that he didn't have a problem with and expressed how he didn't want anybody getting in trouble. Ile just wanted some accountability in the company He wrote a
r . , ,, , , .
just had his foot on the detainee and was not kicking him. It seemed thatAatemeutia#4.saidin the statement that
w40-# , relizeei we were thele oirati'"o kial* —eistity-thathit-story-Softened-up. furtheimorelewent onto-write that
oily had his hand on the back of the detainees neck holding him down while he changed the_ flex-cuffs and not rubbing hiss fatb in the dirt like he had told us when we first started talking to him. The statement that was more . -i a m id fMOO
identcal to the vethl stateent we recieved EA() rt
)

11. INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
10. EXHIBIT
PAGE 1 OF PAGES
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS
OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER
MUST BE BE INDICATED.
DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLET
DA FORM 2823. DEC 1998

C88193
SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190.45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT AUTHORITY: Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; ED. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 ISSN!. PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:
To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
Your social security number is used as an additionallalternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES:
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
4. FILE NUMBER1. LOCATION Aipas /3 Is-6,-2. DATE (YYYYMMDDI 3. TIME
2-1;03 07?-24 l .S---
irt 114--,z4.-y oi Wil'" 10 7. GRADEISTATUS

6. SSN
5. LAST NAME,f101:NAIVIE, MIDDLE NAME
8. ORGANIZATION` ORA RESS
/ /-4,9-7 e C 79.P.%) ..47:::-C•-.3e). -/1 7 3

S. , WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
-- -1•47 •
O'll 3vo7-,-1owhile_oplieryI e u..6, 1,) 111.1111114-0.o4v: f4e-7 10':ivi"li) 1v7dc'I '''''' Pir
/ .

5-t, 21 ec.e. e,i7-er:- Iv_ s°, d 50 ,id1 er i ;ler !leallit.ki-`" to k'le- MEW °I7'(-7,91-

1.11101-
&) kick 3 deft?! 0 .e. c idv t.,) a5 b, 170 5.17) ,,,2ch 26 j.o1720/5 z' "c-& bell?'"
171`.2 .7c k: 2s9c2 Coky/i 2,i7, ASler al111. real! ze,,L (jet 4,79),:,0- wore_
6 211e-1Iv 1-),,,. i 't-'11112i/j )' ht 51--Ore,-e--0.7?-r )47? )2- 12c- was jAi-pvel,po11/5 4'-r )
, - -.1
• c.
Ok7 111 iii 70- 6 Cy--. bize defenpec 5 JtienIquki-, 1111111110 5-c21 061---8 :re'. -,) 1--1 ,•17a b tb zi-h, did nor L, e,,,,. z.43 .fb-7 JZ) ber,./x-.7 1.,, bz,-z.
(1 ke-='t aiiiiii.a n „L I-1A-74. 1115 $tetekv-.2e7ir
‘./ 4, 1,-,-7, 1 eon/ ii(-- e6(.H, 1717 ht S On 1`4ei /2 eec4.
--,. iiir 0 , . de to/ ,-7 e -e- le-../' del& i -i e e 5
12&1' I/ '"-- Pre g . -The 7111/P iorif-we, e2Illed--:/7) MEW tile /6-, E:s se,,e,.
the. 1 i9C le,i- 1ov1)I ,-•( 7 -E'Lle det 6,7 ee, aYirme., .ri-n- pass/Ne. Ic.k,-,1, -5-friVPfil
10411 241 ali-17/5 4, ey.bi--fe) J v59 e f--",•,, -Jtiefr,-­
09 0 Gieca/i7e e5 17;2, lalliras e)
5re-Tin' -- i-wrs spr !'v H.5 c,,„, 1.,1„t-f )3, MM. 14.41 .-1-•
vP7 ilc-,-rotv Iv ' 7-14 6”
5/)1 17 " C I '''.7 G-a ! 44-. /1) K1 1214 5 pi,/,yt.,_1(. If nt:::- l I oic:‘, il / 4-7 /16-47 V11
fl
10. EXHIBIT 11. INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE 1 OF ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING TAKEN AT DATED THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED. 1 PAGES
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 DA FORM 2823, JUL 72,
008194

DOD 006825

DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT OF 1974
AUTHORITY: The solicitation of.1)ersonal information in conjunction
with this investigation is authorized under Title 10 USC 3012.

PURPOSE:-The purpose for collecting this information is to obtain

facts and make recommendations to assist

Comrnder in determi

ing_what.

action to take with regard to: .
D-'7,--P(

-

ROUTINE USES:
Information obtained during the conduct of this
investigation will be used to document relevant facts regarding the
incident concerned. it will be used to determine the cause(s)
leading to the incident, establish individual

-responsibilities,
negligence, and make recommendatiOns for corrective actions and/or

appropriate administrative actions. Any information you provide is
to_membes-of. the Da'i2;artment- of Defense-wha havee

-a -need

for it in th

ance of their duties.

DISCLOSURE MANDATORY 0•VOLUNTARY, AND THE EFFECT- OF NOT PROVIDING
INFORMATION

The information vou furnish is voluntary. There will be no adverse

effect on you for not fr

..rmishing the -information other than that

certain-

facts or informatirm ­
might not be otherwise available to the

Commander
for his decision in this matter.

The information vou furnish is mandatory. Failure to provide the
reauested information could result in disciplinary or other advrs

-a

action against Vou under Article 134, UEMJ.

, having been advised of -the above oroViSions of the Pritacy Act agree to provide information
concerning

the above cited incide

b

008195

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190.45; the proponent agency is OOCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
AUTHORITY: Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; £.0. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SSNL
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: Te provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ROUTINE USES: Your social security number is used as an additiOnallaltemate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.

-DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
1: LOCATION 2. DATE (YYYYMMDDI 3. TIME 4. FILE NUMBER
1 __, ,,, _ -,...
1:01. ri :-. ;11.1,'..1
5, os-rOttDi*.Ffils-rNANtEMIDDLE NAME 6 SSN ,7. GRADEISTATUS

7
UNILALIUN.DWADIIRESS
tilliff ('-
9.
1, , WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH: .. s...:,
--..r...f -, 1 •.';,--...." '. --.:; ••-‘, 7, IL.. 4 is ' , ..t)!_r:! ii._):.. .!:-I -..,-, i ): ' ‘. :-, z ;._ i•:, , ...._ -...:,• 1-i ', : :A., ,?....-: .
\AI 1. .+, i‘..V:.. .s. P; --it' i " il \ i':. -77" L ',1. t, .:?. -:,,- r • • :,..-.1. L : , ,•i,. :-- .
•k-•.=",. --: • 14-:. \ yrilN.:-.7. -k hi: • 1 i %,:q. ..
i•.: •-•,-, t,..! 4 f. .-y.,.2", , 7.; e: il :.;,:--":....1 -.,., • , , ,, ; , ,, , , --I r.s. 3.. r. -.:1.?-,4:;-.75, .. ., , , -, • • c f 1 : , . • •
. :. .: tl .• ! c , . . • --ri•o•:,:;7.1-,, -. .•:: ,.., 3,..i. c 1 k ,, A S \-. 4. -.1t1. '1 k '1:.k4).. -1 4;:::\:i' , ¦ 1,-N E
-r ! ?.,,c i •- = 1, 1:¦-,, --1--4: ..., A !••;-. -„,-,„Lez-, : -.7...7t. t - CP. v..? ;.:.--: 1.-i'', :- --1' 4.-.'1 • l-1.-: t t---C2.--'1-•-• 7-.
_• :. •._ i ---• -• -,_ ..
.------rl, l':-', ..‘ 2 ' •
1• 1_ 1 i— ,T' i-,-1) . ii. iy ,,:: . tisk ..I.:) V-) , '''• (l i. - L) =-21 !'". ' -'•- • .-. t .... -' f.' t: ..----.-. '..::.!
.:: el 0 .2.- f'i -.T.; -— T.- '....S-...;, -::ili'l, r''' it `,...:' -ff , ,, -1 r :.% A---c, .,.',..„--,:•;„....-'21,-;,-:-. :-.;-IA_•k .c.•...-t-tE: L'
1, .'I --i i '7i- i 1 -• '=;--7!--'-;• --.., — (-, • "-
c.
• ••-•'• "C "o•-:-kVV\k-7.
--"1-1- t"2" -. .i f"--1.1.1, ..- .2.••:,-•-,-,.. '--. 472.7 -;=!',' :I, --. .. ,,

.....,:-. 5•;-----; O ,L'. 1...s, ,..---i-r .:—VT -"i„, ,,::,,- _ ,.
i'' .' 1 ' k • I.: ( 1 I':

— . , -.-"1. A , • . ..-t, r. ,
...
. , _ ..-_,
(• •-•- , ‘ IIIIIIIMIIr A \,

•• • •,--1:,-:-.-•:., -'7 -• •.'),_ ..-..-,(--(••:.., f,j '-c.-,-0.---.-T t--, , ,AJ V3'1;71, i'1,---; -%..1 = As .:f _'• ,. .t,.1 r5 Ll..?•.. j --1 -1:
PPi L.kA i vi I:. it's --1 t t-,...: . , -; Ar

..\ k 1 -...k; /4 ----
--,ct 111.111111111111111, C' k F.‘,(•t )6 :i. 1 Cr k ET. • -IC\ -
. . -
1.-42-!•• I--.1.' .1.7_1 r,+-I. ,I . t_Cti.::......, ...(1. 6 A...? i..k-ci , e1 --", t-?•,.... •,-,•,. • .., 1...kie¦,1--t1/421::::.1-t•t.,k ¦....1 .:-.., z. •,.., , kr:-f‘ I'''. 5 rj A .-'1_ r...' ',•..! ('. t t..1 0 1 \-1 0 e f) cu;L: .., A-y-ko .,3
-e' If.-A_:--e" :r 1,-) _!---k-'-y-1 A -'' f
l k.. •( I —CIS' L=vr ----,,e.-7_ --,-; Pcft, .) ;__ 1? ,
C f‘ :,. N -% %
J . It, -‘
(•-/-•
,-, -. ..._ _ , , -1 !-4/ ,'.••• (-). E . 4-••••••,•:1',7 --T'e4,e:\,7\--•,•••• 1.:--.-f,
1,... ...j \ \ k LG . .,:\ ,-' k!. , c ...,, MONO (NI -f-. ,.cs: t .t.k.,-,,C2- C.: 10 •-.1 E::•••7 '..-'--:•-•-- ' ''' 'i, A ", 7
-- _i
-v-'., v .., -
'sr, . ki -4-.. 1 ,,f "! ,'\ r t t ' ri ',..•., . -., 1A C. 15-C z.-1 1.-:J1. ,.: ;.
-1-:; 1.;-c•---1-- -
.1 ' • .7" ---- .. ‘'--,'• • ,-:••¦ a .1 -V71 (,:-._ /:. f-',-, ,;), , ; 2 -De; !.::: t.,-_.„j : ••: -., ., 7 -; k-
•' t. • • , — • ,
'
T t'''-- -: \ 'S Lr:: k i\-:1 C--i -, k
..1..t kii... ,-,..., c_ 0 I c7:,_. t v 1-.74'2'. C „ f, :,._ \', i-i'.0 : ',.. - r V\-• \ :: t, ;_'*, -...' -(.(jt :e, 'C'' . 1" .1-:-'1.\. i.'; ..'"!

Is.:1 ( A-,,„(.0 .•).1 -r-s-1,._:•. ge; i.----_ n,-..y .'-y) .,,\. if) 1,;..Is ,,...: k,1._,.... -1*() {-• ,-..-1 ' 4 ',-..)
10. EXHIBIT PERS N MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE 1 OF PAGES

3 i-L, -t,
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 OA FORM 2823, JUL 72. IS OBSOLETE USAPA VI.00

00819 ,

-
USE THIS PAGE IF NEEDED. IF THIS PAGE IS NOT NEEDED, PLEASE PROCEED TO FINAL PAGE OF THIS FORM.
'
DATED )OM-TAKEN AT FA.,,
STATEMENT OF
1)
-. --!
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
c, (74',
6\o ; •o;o' •CtA(1.—­
14\ -1::
)t) 0 ."-1 11 .0 Li- 1
s"4:"P's.\-)Q f-) .` `,/ tl:s0
).:":::
yo• (TY1-
A T
nsu ¦-)
t --c4
) C
t;._).
V,-L1
t';\ rq
,TO 76,..; 6o.,0
At .
F (7...5 I
k 0
1,N (-1,-c..
rtic.--id
1:3Q.c.)c :1 tu' 45 0- ( kils3
c, (.5 c-C-',1 Y 14
1-1-0
0(2
It'
41:
ii i.c)ict ci eff,-' 1 r fir% 4: M f •:;;-'.-S K . I c\:. 4 . - , -tif,, .

co v.y ifs:: ... A, : • 1:-...-4,. , r,:i. .. IDL'.1ct. v-Icx-%
..A -1-1,....,-. ..i u, ,.) 1, ..4.. •._,.. i7,47_,,,.:. , , ,,• .‘.! ii4-:\ •-,‘ • L t,. A.. ; :.., .-- •
A , ç \'
i-:' e .:-•.; 1"-.: ,ii..
7 (..'t. \ ,. ,:`-' \ , f i-,.
X 7r...-t) IT) 1 :: -CO --- 1 ' iN '--t. .,:, 1.-.t.-...L:
L 7, ....i. ,;_ e' ', ,c., ,J ,c_ ;:-.; r-k. -.., —i 1A-s...
0

r\?. Did Y'CV ,':;(- 6 f',..)-;1's 1 1!--i C L PI Y-.. t.6 ...% -k; C'. V.67 i ifs .2 r) "i7i -/.:" . .
_.. h
it-le r.-f 41 c, p ...CC .-x. ;„., (1...2,....c.(.., . . i • c. if; ‘; 1).4. b I:. -..'.(. it '. v-,
i. , ,A .s .., •.•:, , , ..-7, ,--.: .; ;.,-. 1-.1.. \",...-... ikk'i.,-. i . N.}
I t- ::. -;'.. —i' i'a ,t.,-
t = .;.': i \ i: C '¦:.' , 4... e." f0.• , :. .
'r,s;;. "... -1:' I -` 'j -...: ....1 , ': . ,i • -
--;. --,i 1.1 .,.,-...) -••; •""-:111 -;. c c; '-ii,l) C:. ' r( :f
. rl i ,-; ,, .(:;
.(d tvt • •
• c„-vy 1.1--• L L. ; . •
,
( • cl".¦
• 1•?.)1 1...
•
cQ si.o •o" • 1-.1 i 'oI '1 ,-c• ‘• .rt“7 f
• , t
\61
, ofc, 3 I IA \

'
r_.!
g 's-N • -7; -T-71- • irz: t ' -19.
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE OF 4: PAGES
• USAPA V I.00
PAGE 2, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998

008197

DOD 006828

STATEMENT OF
TAKEN AT DATED
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
AFFIDAVIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH EGINS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGE.
. I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. [HAVE INITIALED. ALL CORRECTIONS:AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH TAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR WARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE,t UNAWFUL I UC E
T.-
WITNESSES: Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law to
administer oaths this ?C) day of s:to‘y
AS)
at
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
of Person Administering Oath)
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS aril Cal e rson. Administering Oath) 13 6( (1% JCIIJ (AuthorilVTo Administer Oaths)
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT PAGE

PAGE 3; DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
USAPA V I.00
12 08 196

DOD 006829

I.

1 , 11111.1.1111111111.
¦1
3 , -1°1' 'PtX Ett-- €_,0 pr,) 11111111.1111111 13q-S1 0 rE
postTU) A
I t-A
-i , 2b P '"'`ift'"" '-)1Qt-i E- iZ- W--& \9-6..k)
a

DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT OF 1974

AUTHORITY: The solicitation of Ilersonal information in conjunction

with this investigation is authorized under Title 10 USC 3012..

PURPOSE: The purpose for collecting this information is to obtain

facts and make recommendations to assist tie CO.

nder in determin-
ing what action to take with regard to: ./2-i, j/ 2.212
6/1-727-(

ROUTINE USES: Information obtained during the conduct of this
investigation will be used to document relevant facts regarding the
incident concerned. it will be used to determine the 'oause(s)
leading to the incident, establish individual responsibilities;:
negligence, and make recommendations for corrective actions and/or
appropriate administrative actions. Any information vou provide is

-disclosable to members of the De.Dari..ment'Of -Defense who haveaneed
for it in the.

Y-formanct of their duties.

DISCLOSURE MANDATOROoR -voLUNTARY AND THE EFFECT OF NOT PROVIDING

INFOPMATIOT:

The infolluation you furnish is voluntary. There will be no adverse
effect on you for 1-it fi=ishing the information other than that
certain facts or information might not be otherwise available" to the
Commander for his decision in this matter.

The information you furnish is mandatory. Failure to provide the
reauested information could result in disciplinary or other •adverse
action against you under Ar ticle 1 3L,UCMJ.

Pi-
.

, having bten advised of the above
Droviion5 of the rivacy Act agree to provide information concerning
the above cited in ident.

1111111p1M*
C 98'4,00

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 19045; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
AUTHORITY: Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 /SM.
To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: Your social security number is used as an additionallalternate means of idehtification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
ROUTINE USES: Oisclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
'DISCI:MK; . 2. DATE (YVYYMMOD) 3. TIME
4. FILE NUMBER
1. LOCATION ... 003 0730 16'39
F6:b fICIAkr
7. GRADE/STATUS
6. SSN . ,
5. LAS • DLE NAME
8. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
Sb
ii411 Al P ao) P)
WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
L—r11111101111111111111011.----,
(1 J`i Ti-d-1-/ aoc 3 a( cfror?,-,.t.,--: 6-1L- e /7 0 ti 00 tris Pi, ten 1 .-) l /cJ &e 0/ 3C__ Wt 5
u, 413 033. &iliac' pbs---e-z//ted 0-

ecitt:c.yr .-e-,‘.79 . • /1 A ra ;c vi c,-Y); kV 1/49r1c1
50,--1-1 -r.r) pe/ -;0^e-te/-(laic se,e---c-,1 ei,.,,,,,„z,, 6-r iii,.44,-,, , ii, /0)414,—,

-t-4,-.
e let.-6,--- GI Aic, he-c-is4e,--
, o" -eke --a vi
r,„0„,,1 e/„6..,,,) :,..---kie,,,) /'eld , ' 0 1 ila -t
e. c--4-/acid , f--) -11--e
sei,--6,0,1 itd,.vidt,,A1.5 AlAit 2,,r—-Is or, 4
wt-t--ect
se -o , )o
.1."--od., ce,,--7 off -el'ewho twe---c 0 c-1-,./44, -4-.."---6,.. v-c 4--rd
;0 ..-4-) of -t-ke fel,d
V. A
4,±1,-, , ...r,v,„
Ak-tc-e-,... - 1 .1-.. e 7--v.,e,,,-.:,i - : --/f,,,./-7: - . : d,, ,,,„;),‘ , , i _g_...
he„,01 0, ,a, 1 , --,1e.(2-...---7, ' ....-7a
6:r" s t.e,--f„-/a , ,... . ,..j
ij„epe A,/,_
C7 vezi eictdr, ' 414
-(---e AL WI a crew
. . ``fie
•1.4 7 _. it gce-I-ve -71-Le"t
1/Jike,,, -1-a,-r i'Lk-ed a k-1
, %id ,. v , .. c 1 k a (5- ,
-Ele 414 ,,,-e Ao cc:5e, -r ,:-.f.,,ilkd
//-4.„-i-bc,,,kil se=ii-C4/-4 / 5 i,_ srec-ts a-t-
e. vent ) SF; -(-/a,,-,3
c•ss-....c-ia, c,e . _i_,.../4.s-

the-ct,l'e'i .60 or-re.- 7
P5Co..4-1-e,---
1....e.'e-
Lot- 5-e a i-76-1
it. - 7 re 64 5 -- / 2 ) f-,-, -de
lit -0014 d 4...ece ivise,....,, We i../4ixe-of
Vet 4" -/".. .-.-.5 21'.4----(7u '-1 11-'"e4'...) - Ika -f eisvI

SO4 19ACA LI III4 -I...hays-, .7-L-
aele../- $00
o 3
eaa ,1,111.
tli cpc-7--dil
..-
)tera .1-g " i of 6i-:t ,` g --;" 1194-P9 7 j j
17 moo
wt. \dere zip .6?) ay) -Pa.C.i doom 0---eLe jiv—d--.6 ' II -1-1'.ee
ov,e.--/-1-ea--.d
4 I 1 i..5,1,,.e la 11..,_ 61,244...s . a:-
1,...4.4- lie; fil so y.-e.....1,4.-(i , , e , . b4 ilk
f04 , ,:t1-1.-.e 2- "IleS ei...,,e
co ,,,-.. va., e,,, -Ks _s ,-,-, ; la ,....-.1--, '' yo,.., / ..9 0-(-0, _r,,g, ,,-, ll c4 -6,703 -6-3-a --)
1.l.'''•
00 .e.,,.11,t-f ii:;..,52, si,,4 l " vend e-ii,s hey .-,,gyref'-' -e-Lfj t
4"G/ keAl{ ',id. f .4,,,

I( L jetA-' cl-ee :f k,-) 4 6 X-5 s ,
...7 scd"--61
IcI o'-. A /-/t,‘4 5 -t k de , ''.7e e
S 011'd e/01 W,"-enc -61,0.4.--cik•
.tiv/04 .
,^ -,,, -i-' -eice--.
lo -11-c. --1-f-,4 t( ‘,14,-t Sr .-/as ,
.at alet-4.),te S. ',Ad -1-A-Ve.,
' I. a i 0 I . a .,..--, ' 1-e--",5
,A5 656e 1-.-h i v . e .‘ we,c. j ° piq rat"641 Iwir 4--c'ee1 i --.

ji-4 k"7 ' ; . f 1-', 1,4,1.4-e, AA-ei• /cle • tie t-vac .:5-,--e.AA44-..
-etc .1-,ri-e-t 0 14,7
At.) j.4 frin.€7 - i

40-6-;
SON MAKING STATEMENT
11. INI -
10. EXHIBIT
PAGE 1 OF _3___ PAGES
TAKEN A T DATED
I
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT Of THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING .
... __ ... ___.......... mmom

OR FORM „
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998

C 08201

STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT DATED 9, STATEMENT (Continued)

Alintimiim
, HAVE READ'OR HAVE HAD READ TO. ME THIS STATEMENT
WHICH B , SON PAGE 3 • I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE
BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE

CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR.REWARD WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR U
3
ighatu e iff-PeithilM,i0fg4*-ternent)
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authorized by law to
administer oaths, this 304 " day of ji t l r r r-(903
at WITNESSES:
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS na n Administering Oath )
5
rr Administering Oath)
1(41;cctl 136OC-Ir
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS (Authorily o Administer Oaths)
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE PAGES
vtz
USAPA V1.00
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
008202

DOD 006833

DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT OF 1974

AUTHORITY:. The solicitation of ;personal information in Onjunction
with this investigation is authorized under Title 10 USC 3012.

PURPOSE: The. purpose for collecting this information is to obtain
facts and make recommendations to assist the C

ander in determin-
ing hat action to take with regard to: e

.

0-EkT-17•-s 7
ROUTINE USES: Information obtained during the conduct of this
investigation will be

used to document relevant facts regarding the
incident concerned. it will be used to determine the cause(s)
leading to the incident, establish individual responsibilities,

negliaence, and make recommendations for corrective actions and/or
appropriate administrative actions

.. Any information You provide is

disolosable to-membes-afthe-Deartment-of-Defensa who- :riave a= need
for it in the-pe:11-J_o • ance of their duties.

DISCLOSUP MANDATORY 0' VOLUNTARY, AND THE EFFECT OF NOT PROVIDING

INPOPMhT ON:

The
information you furnish- is voluntary. There will be no adverse
effect on vou for not frrnishing

-L2=? information other than that
certain facts or information might not be otherwise available:to ths
Commander for his decision in this matter.

The information You furnish is mandatorv. Failure to provide the
reouested information could result in disciolinary or other adverFe
action against vou under Article 13%, UCMJ.

1,

., having-been advised of the above

Provisions of.

Privacy Act agree to provide information concerning

the above cited i cident.

6 -2
C08203

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
)
AUTHORITY: Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.G. 9397 dated November 22. 1943 Ism).
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ROUTINE USES: Your social security number is used as an additionalIalternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
1. LOCATION 2. DATE LYYMMDO) 3. TIME 4. FILE NUMBER
-
RiaeS Lc, 65--roRAm eaDi zc(o'S 5-1 4)9 2(3 SZD
5. LAST NAME, -FlkiST NAME, MOLE NAME 6. SSN ¦ 7. GRADE/STATUS
3 f6
8. OR ADDRES
914 hi? C c-.) L.4:- m 0,co.I .:DeWiz.v iki /4
9.
t
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH: 0 4 2_9 Ail C.)--
po It...; 3 -r-HE-RAI-b z. ID 6.--rA i 1.1 c: S co (IRE 2 i.?LA:r._ci A 41
, .

p L +9-c-c.:. c , ;•,_ T. ti. e_ e-S P.c.-:,0 N1CJ L.),m-DE P.. 04E-scdpevlskeN c,,c
—
-
1,.. . . . _ Mk\ rc,siTt scNi 1-Livi 5
111111111111111111111111-rti e -- -r--Li¦ d r ...1 -56

—q Re — -on
' -. e31--U ek (J -.e....s--oA•y -i . x_. ,oOP--Le 'S c0.zyrix. --ret E-1:,, e--1/q-; t,te -5 %, = C4) s-...fa_v ci b 3 tc -1
' "
pMee 14,
G_,c..)--r
oi.t --r-rt e 5/kv__DeP-.0,c c!).k) .--. C•C
•1-1-7 '
_
__...,
_ 1-(-) c, *:!_z"-ya t•-4-
.k.,)ipi
.fc-.,Pil---,a ,.... 1--,..i ? , ps__
e's 1
/4 '."15e ( ..c. .0z. ,
3-94, wt. H . --2._ 41cifecs , A T " -THAT -r, , ,,,, --
cik-tr.l. -13e iN:' la ci .0,1 ---se y,..14 ..)
) 1-Heated

11 ,-.
4 illatilina 4 S.

iwpRcc_ i-fe.cl
-n-if?..e4 .-ref 3.4 iv Ltel.._./ e H. po5,1 Th'o Nt
i /4 T-H e-

--niRRer AxiD
pitsj si-c.:1 ,-, )-4-4R.ry\
kJ I4-c Ai ri.S Fe ea
ixtli i-I e LQA-5
1-•ve L.Ls n-/ ..
WV i .5._ ei Yo

'flitii, -t ‘ .4 S iii p 's .-/-4 1.4.6--
C'" ) ""r% A.',1"•9-4-77-t? Rt. re c -r DerA , Ale S 3 f¦JeLl i 4 l3 0 s,..E., -1riewt e i
-7-14e."1: A . 5 K 44_, t- i A —I-4ause c-j, d we-
•1?e ?I, .-t- ri
14 7 - b nel -I-rei e s/16(.:, kici A to 1-$.1 I r-i 6-. .i uirl S 5 (...:tk ;4 ('S'''' (.1
.,,
WI' t-i Aia . i_te(4, s,')..ice / Si'ciA4 1.--r 4 14 T t- i i N5 pLAce t;
ti-X i' k---S,4(.1)
5s' in :LA-R-.Tc)
64 i. r ,4a 's w. tie 0,1.-,v7-i-,-)iii , L. C.--s-ri'-k-
CoCr cc) A, A A,-r,4414 a --re., L_,
__ ,
f 4:bp_ ..?0.5 ; ri ' LI e coll'i r 3orrt 1402 A4 OS 0 /4 -I-HS ,.!-±.. -`-•*P"'
MA vi)4 •
...
THA -r ti-e '11,4t 11-Alj.c-
.
e, Ni /
aeric,r..,..5 tk.4CcH-
... -,
• f 4:i; 4'1rW 4:10:&1 -01: ¦" .-4-1-
. . _ t,tAcivi--: . ---r --n-{e Diri4 i ¦ ue. S posiTechr
TO CAL. rvi
10. EXHIBIT 11. INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE 1 OF PAGES

ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING 'STATEMENT OF ZaltedL. TAKEN AT R.Oirejiair BATED voscDOL-1
THE BOTTOM Of EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE Misr BEAR THE INITIALS Of THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE RE INDICATED.
OA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLETE USAPA Vi to
OA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
\pr
008204
DOD 006835

STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT •S—C, DATED cd-S 0C4
9. STATEMENT (Continued(
C /Wyk 2 ? 1., CF /1156 THet4 CALLe2 :34CK.oTb CLA I' T SL-3 See 4(3cise trei=kyvi ed A S e ci-lec4ied vo_C (-) s 3 "IHQ '5 5 T T,-, e 'To c O1LC Q C e) S 34 -7

-edI i'-'
74-te Ti-ve
)" JK
c?..:1
-Tri 6 c, 5 .-•ro sex:4 1 /4 p-Vr I eL,
p
j4•1 e Hear) .5 •pv. e'ridt itL) e
C9_,e S-1 pI.J 1_1— ; Toe
e.
AFFIDAVIT
I, , HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH BEG GE-1 -•
,AN
- - . -I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME THE STATEMENT IS TRUE I HAVE INITIALED ALL CORRE AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFU R UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
-ISgthituth of
WITNESSES: Subscribed and sworn to before m administer oaths, this at

133 CI
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
(Toied et
C--I /3 '9 (4( /177
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS (Authority To Administer O bthY
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE -Z. OF PAGE

PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 USAPA 01.00
n 0 .8 2 0 5
DOD 006836
DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT OF 1 974

AUTHORITY: The solicitation of 1.Jersonal information in conjunction

with this investigation is authorized under Title 10 USC 3012,

PURPOSE: The purpose for collecting this information is to obtain
facts and make recommendations to assist thia-7Comm -der in determin­ing at_action to tak with regard to: .

ROUTINE USES:

USES: Tnformaton obtained during the conduct of this
investigation will be used to document relevant facts regarding the
incident concerned. it will be used to determine the cause(s)
leading to the incident, establish individual responsibilities,
negligence, and make recommendations for corrective actions and/or
appropriate administrative actions. Any information you provide is
diseIbtable to membel.:„s of the Derartment of Defense who have a need
for it in r.of their duties.

oer
DISCL0SUR MANDATORv OR VOLUNTARY, AND THE EFFECT OF NOT PROVIDING

INFORMATI N:

Th:2 information you. urnish is voluntary. There will be no adverse
effect on you for nnt fl-rnisbino the information other than that
certain facts or informatir-n illaht not be otherwise available tothe
Commander for his decision in this matter.

The information You furnish is mandatory. Failure to provide th ,==

.12 6 `,/-
.reouestedinformation could retult in discinlinary or other advers.e • • • action against you Under A-rticle 134, UCMi.
havinc been advited of the above
agree to provide information concerning
. the above cited incid nt.

-2
0 8 0 6

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-46/he proponent a ency is . ODCSOPS
LOCATIO DATE i FILE NUMBER

LA$.1144N1, FIRST ME , RAD /
31 (a
011-GANI2ATION OR ADDRESS
q/-m /41 p 0_, .,

, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
i cite .e:j-cl --:c. - 1 vi-r., r,-
0.1 c. vs thr .4_,7(- - - 4 (A 7 -
17/1i1 c2.-F---')-• 1
7'4u_, ? .-c-,,,1 c_ i— /7) c L4-i4 b'e_iiii, cl

v.- c, 3 -3 --"-/ De-.k.'"q-.c-J c-5.-n
0-)i- 2.1 J:-(/ 0 -3 , T. -z 6' c
.
icy i LL VZ.,...., ,1 .1, hu ki.-.-4_ 7-- tr..] K 1,1
fki... 1 e..t.. 6,.._.Q.s. . 1,, ,„. vi....e,c
a- - "e' 7La i e‘
6¦-4. w 4-5 -o al z 4-
io,}.(„( e.,_, its F
6--1 cLkic.-e,2A-_ tyi, r. fC, •,:/\ 0 ,,----,- ..t,4 ;4,, r 4-,:c .1--i,,j
a si 4 (--,.47, 7c.;
tri.„. ,...: k , r_,.,f„,,,,,„ bi , 1„4_,(_. „(97. „,,..}.,-, 4 ,„,..” 7/..., i..:.,-, ,,c `'r es
6,„)., j„..., i c
pis, rr tt_r ,C,,5,2. ,_---"Its
69 '44--fi---c-, v--1,,....-.(...--,--, ,r ./--e L L

"1"-..,,,, 4
-,11',.5,-5 a" (,,,,-1,5
r f , L .,(4,-a_e¢._ -.:,
-
-446-, ti-f --/-7,--.i-0 ni I e-. '-' 4.-' t -r\ ket, g '51AA'-
id ci:. I di 0/1
5-cr=.6-,4‘e.4._ ..L)oL.c._;‹, ((. e, ? :16.-ci`" ,`
lt-/s/V-..1-IL( r2"--.... 1 \ , _ ,

(,..u.,...z .... ci-.) R. 17-, ='. vt._._ a ,..-,0-.. ,L j yea-,5y A: g. K.- ( 02'
GA. CI' t-e-5c:1 ci e -
I:, (c. k - . ( ol,

c.--, e. /----514. A e ,----, itc; G-1,....., ci
.i-..'11"--
'')k. (4..1 , ii-, - - - r Gt 6 c--_..(C_ 4. GI. J 1--4 j

-, 1k.
(../-, e_),.../ ( ‘.L.-' t-5,
Pt.4-g-' ri4--. CO 1 '-(--Cec 5.'" ) , ./1,-, 'A ./Ji.=; r ite s cr4ed
1,,,/-0 C. jz. .4..,,,c1 0 c_kc.,_ Ce.,_ 12:,1/4."-¦ C., cr li IIIIIIIIIIIPIIIII
at-4-jtc ' -,
/ CA" e-94-j't it,jg..... Et t ) c e_. cC5 C 'q.-'I-C.-%
t-VV1Z-f 6.5--I c - - , i(--)z I --

OM C.:-.1
c_c_ t-j-ko-yv.. cp ks.,f-: 6 , .;.-t_ a pc..) f".
. Zlz.„7 ___I fc..- e (e..... I-)
IT-.1-f-i_ p— t''' (7'12 . ,..,-,----

4 ., 1 5 k.-A, ,A.r
--,c;,_, -1 c......-... G.,-.r.,- G ,
G -,c;,_-.
v.r..tu, AL.,,„,,,, 1/4., c,,e) 3 1.,,G-7,._; ( L=- -.-----(--c-' ii----'-c--() c.-tn 4

, —I
1_,_/-,,„,„, ,_ --)
4'-'-/c( (k
itc.:-rt..c.,„ (., 4.),. (e
-4"(-, 1111111111111111111 i„ s 5 ci S 5ccr-3 i 0.-.) ..e.. -(-it_.,.1,1/4.4 ,^._‘-_, et) ItIg' (4
-
.1 . v—
..1-4.-Tc-(,k,L-f-k ,--, E rt'v,---t(--lc)--'
ji . c,_,,. ,_ t„,„,.,..., , 45..TY"-5,-.7. (.......,y It kv./17 e,-. — -3---

c,_, e.:.---71-iL._,. _,
c...a -kklit.z_j-• 71,. L, -0-"Lcz e )
tc, kV:A Vte..... (€ q_ ---
‘,:.-"e4 VI `-i S-C(-_4 .:- i ; -i
)....:. 4a, ‘," 1 ,. 0
FL 6-;‘,1 ,:
S44 . c 0 ( -Cl [7.--•.1 r-67_, (..",e" -f i----, iz-,, c,.-..H.--hr-,..4_ ,:------,..
ik(--• L11-5"--. t 1`e gill EXHIBIT 1 INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
1
'PAGE 1 OF _ c_
I
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT OF.TAKEh AT .DATED.CONTINUED."
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT AND BE INITIALED AS
"PAGE OF PAGES.' WHEN ADDITIONAL PAGES ARE UTILIZED, THE BACK OF PAGE 1 WILL BE LINED OUT, AND THE

STATEMENT WILL BE CONCLUDED ON THE REVERSE SIDE OF ANOTHER COPY OF THIS FORM.
USAPPC V2.00
DA FORM 2823,JUL 72 SUPERSEDES DA FORM 2823,1 JAN 68,WHICH WILL BE USED.
P 08 207

STATEMENT OF TAKEN AT /es
9. STATEMENT (Cogtinyea ? ¦ ,d= KcZ_ (-(4_
h427 0-ra cl
b k.A 1,1„6-17-o71-1-sar fie10/1-di / o )( AZ c-c-A-t_
vt,..t 5 7

WHICH BEGINS ON PAGE 1, AND ENDS ON PAGE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. !HAVE INITIALED ALL STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWA
WITNESSES:
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
AFFIDAVIT
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT:MADE ECTIONS AND HAVE INITIALED THE BOTTOM OFEACH PAGE-CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE. MADE THIS 0, WITHOUT THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND WITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR UNLAWFUL INDUCEMENT.
1Siiiiituie •ersOR emen
Subscnbed and swom to bafore me, a person authorized by law to administer oaths this 77-4 day of
S 4s/ at
(4YPiiiiiit'Adinigslering Oath'
I . 6,.:-,Z7t): 4/ 1/1-11'1 1-
144*Ni T Adnikister Oathil
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT
PAGE OF c PAGES

PAGE 3, DA FORM 2813, DEC 1998
USAPAV1.00
008205

DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT OF 1974

AUTHORITY: The solicitation of Personal information in conjunction-

with this investigation is authorized under Title 10 USC 3012.

PURPOSE: The purpose for collecting this information is to obtain

facts and make recommendations to assist the omman in determin-

ing what action tc‘ take with. regard to: '7 ,1e

r•4.2

ROUTINE USES: Information obtained during the Conduct -of this

investigation will be used to document relevant facts regarding the

incident concerned. it will be used to-deterMine the cause(s)

leading to the incident, establish individual responsibilities,

negligence, and make -recommendations for corrective actions and/or­
appropriate- administrative actions. Any information. You provide is

discicsable-tc-Metbels'-Of.Of'DefenSe-Who have a need--

-

for it in the performance of their duties.

DISCLOSUR IANDI,TORY )OP VOLUNTARY, AND THE EFFECT OF NOT PROVIDING

INFORM .

N:

The information you fUrnish is voluntary. There will be no adverse

effect on Poli for not furnishing the information other than that

certain facts or information might not be otherwise available to the

Commander for his decision in this matter.

fot
2

The information you furnish is Mandatory. Failure to provide the reauested. Could in discinlinary or other adverse action against you under 2--.rt1cle 1:34, UCMi.
I, ., having been advised of the above
,-,7-ovisions or t P iVacy Act agree to provide information concerning
the above cited inc dent.

3

C 08209

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 19045; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
AUTHORITY:

Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; EO. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 ISSN).
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE:

To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ROUTINE USES:

Your social security number is used as an additionalfaltemate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.

1. LOCATION 2. DATE IYYYYMAIDDI 3. TIME 4 FILE NUMBER
x wile 5-4%, 71- 40
.c--r-Y-3 U &.c 9t1
LAST 14 ME, FI ST.NA E, MIDDLE NA ' 6. SSN 7. GRADE/STATUS
8. 0 IZ IDN OR ADDRESS
Pi .1 FL --/ TL, •.
.

1.
, WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OATH:
(ill 41 J i'L'' 0) et o sb.30 0-6' pro vi le/ q 7-?9 4c
, i
Ra id, l'iJe ( v Air- a ,2_ de ?i ire c='s rA-41 w? re 11- (V, ‘"7-i / A ,-71;-
reels, Ply 5-e / ,‘ 4 it, 4 i 'l IIIIIIIIIIIah kie re /00

/ /:5-1 ' b i -r Vd&ta, a
(4 n-ile yeeek 4r r 65-1 f e r 6'19 e, vie -. ,--ie ,,,,,.., )4
.....____...
_
lit , e e,04 -IIIIIIIIIIIIIII stqc-,71*-4/ lire r''''COc-i,1 ,"4. e). ("-e j a ve_
tik enq Cor. ,...._a „if -71:6 C e..),e e cc/ -111ep ---4t.e.--e 4 e5-,- /-4,..,--4 „Lo e,.....,,.
'

0 Qi--. li 5. c...-e .0 -e e055 5 le.
-.5.00h e 1 5 4-4e/ (-4 - 'I!, 24-"c-ey300_5
a ,,c1 e 4 c 6,-/-ed -71,16-e, A -4,74- , rat-4,-,61_, f 7L Air -1---;me ,,,z-A

e 1 _/ .93,0
41e ict'iher5 i..-.Cr'e_ ClX. CCW7C4i, '4 a' p 'Ace.— t'‘4 flr'
4i / 'ti 5 e e.;,.,4 OO/9 e-0,-ke, / 5 e e--re e - - - ''711 3 eki..,,-'„ior

GC- 1- 4
"fC rcek led 2

,5 7
0(-i•b-4 AA ery-4-- /47,-,,,- h, j /.e 64 'a ('-' 445 'Ale ,etv if
-
.9 kr 41-1, er t-'rei--¦ I-4Z 17Pf
a P/4" -1-*'?thi 4.4d his 1-4rdir,:e-) eiff ,-/115-vii),
e_--
0 OA look

oa/-de -1.4-hee a-4 -T. ecor- fed A,.5 brollw-, Liat. I
41,0_

d e Ai .,e es i n er 0 4 A (-i. u+'1 1- ee-5 -/4/ 111 is -2e7he _.:E-c.--e, ./-ii,
fl) .Pte sc efle. 'I de il a ike-e. vA;v16,1 0,-&-i-4.-544-7 .,t -ct,,-c ei.“,„..1/4..4' c.„ /
4.-7-v
cv tke I b ed 5 &el( toj oni. ; het re 41‘.- 4 ,----"-ag 117 14 1 e le-AAtck,
7',e
he cakt c A, ple-te '11 e 59.-11efice. r i-k e-i5 it "cli `-` c''` 5't C`''''''',,024c-e-r, 41,1-
5 1.7.4,,i, wt -:-.1-5 LI red t''.' (do/ r /Y() 6- 47-c --,

coil- ,r, l-K vil -I, ..c et-A .,-c, /-jir." ,be&ee,7
004.0 flier e, ir 0/1 A i'm • . . j: I-45 0 15/'i ektm-leV l'16, ,',t _ ,, hleh‘er,
' / J, , / )11E Aancaet5. 0 K 7.1-4t1' e'.0/9 f-tca
tit 0 de kik, t °ea .1-1 Opt a 6 ..,/ , . A 5 1
„a ,, fr.. s-,
r r.'..s-0($..co ./..
570 -*to ,7r ,..i.e- Sers ai---•.).% 4'0' 4 4 , 71 e '', 6' / ..1 e' e " 4211(
d ,-01 .:z' -5 ('€ aey de /-4 lire e C4 13 4 C e‘f 1'7 Gcc.2y ","••

10. EXHIBIT 11. INITIALS 0 N MAKI(N;33TTEt ....1 PAGE 1 OF ..)--.. PAGES
ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT Of TAKEN AT DATED
THE BOTTOM Of EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS Of THE PERSON MAKING THE srATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 DA FORM 2823, JUL 72, IS OBSOLETE USAPA 01.00
C082 i 0
DOD 006841
STATEMENT OF AKEN AT uo../--DATED 17/4
9. STATEMENT (Continued)
AFFIDAVIT
I. _, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME THIS STATEMENT WHICH B ON PA I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HA'YE INITIALED ALL CORRECTIONS AND HAVE 4•11TIA.LED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. I HAVE MADE THIS STATEMENT FREELY WITHOUT HOPE OF BENEFIT OR REWARD; ; WITHOUT THF-'IEAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND •MITHOUT COERCION, UNLAWFUL INFLUENCE, OR .UNL i
Subscribed and sworn to before me, a person authoried by law to
WITNESSES:
administer oaths, this l ac?­
LtT7 day of
•
at A(Ne.s,
ORGANIZATION OP ADDRESS
Li
ype ° 'ame qerso AekiiiiiisterMg Oathl
/.-cpere I•3 6/ 9 (07-1-u-
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS (Authority To M oister Oaths.
-T-
INITIALS OF PERSON MAKING STATEMENT 3 4 7/ 1 PAGE OF PAGES
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 V1.00
P 082111

DOD 006842

•
1

•• RIGHT::; WARNING PROCED'ARE/VVAIVER CERTIFICATE
or use of this form. see AR 190-30; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
i

1
DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT
I

I
AUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Cede, Section 3012(0)
PRINCIPAL TURP SE: To provide commander:. and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ROUTINE USES: Your Social Security hit:--fiber is ;;Cd as air adOitionailaiterrate means of identification to iacilitate tiling and tettlevai.
DISCLOSURE: SCiCSIJI• Of yr.r...:r Socia• Security Numder is yo.a.;r1t-.;7.

TION 2. DATE I 3. TiME , 4. PE.E NO.
__.
/-7...-../_"5_ 6e. "7.-37-.---/,.5'"--...CC2 —i-7.-"V -CY(1...,9" C•fi _ : .:a3c)-C
NAME 11...asf, •irst, 114;! B. ORG ANIZATION OR ADDRESS

I _ . Z-/"7 4/ "I' '
------------------• •-
b. • 7. GRADE:STATUS
„....._ A
• k...--"Y' A e6 _____..4 PART i - RIGHTS WA(VERINON-WAIVER CERTIFICATE
.
1
i Seat n A. Rights
7/ "/ .-.
1 ..: investigator whos , ',erne. a: , pcurs hek•.v tolv ice Ma:. bc:si . s is V. the United States Army / /..(72(.. /.-,/ al 2 .
. and wanted to question rile. about the following offensels/ of which I am . • suspected/ . . --.fl'.7.1.s;.7-7.-E,,,--ze.---,7,-20,217 ---ns'_—...___L.C--."/ `"?/..Z.1 5. I
i Be ore heishe asked me any questions ebout the oflenser.$). however. heishc made it clear to rue that ! have the following rights;
1 do iiot have to answer any qtrestioter say any hang. _

2 Anything f say or do can b.' used as evidence against me in a criininal Inal.
If
1
3. IFor personnel subject odic 1iCkl..1 I have the right to :eh: privately to 3 lawyer hefore. during, and alter questioning and to have a ¦ awyer present with me
I during questioning. This lawyer can be a civilian lawyer I arrange for at no expense to the- Government or a Military lawyci dotaiied for nix at no expense to me.
; or both. . .
.

”
i
I lFor civilians not subject to :he LICMJ,i I have the right to talk privately to a lawyer before. during, and after questioning and to have a lawyer preseni with
I me owing questioning. I understand that this lawyer can he one that i arrange for a: Inv own expense, or if I cannot afford a lawyer and want one. a lawyer
will be appointed for me before any questioning begins. . .

-4. li I ant now'wiliing to discuss the offense's) under investviation, whh or withoLh a lawyer prexern. I have a right 10 step answering question:: Cl any lime, or
speak privately with a lawyer before answering lurthe!. aven ii i sic., the waiver below.
E
d. COMMENTS (Continue on reverse side;
1 Section B. Waiver
I understand my; rights as stated above. rare now willing to discuss the oftenselst under investigation and make a statement Withotit talking to alawyer first and . without 'hating a lawyer present with me.
VIEVVEE
_... • — . _

WITNESSES (If available) ! 3. SiGNATUR'E IN ...
. . .
1 a. "!AME ITVpe or Print;

l b. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS AND PHONE I
I 1
2a. NAME (Type or Print)
1---: • ..
b. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS AND PHONE A NIZATiON OF IWt:itglitATOWT'.;''''
I fr-1/ ii4G-?, ... . , ‘i-
Section C. Non-waiver •
/ 1. I do not want to give up my rights
r :..i I want a lawyer LI I do not vv..: : to be questioned or say anything
t
_
•
12. SIGNATURE OF INTERVIEWEE .
.
ATTACH THIS VVAIVP• CERTIPICATE TO ANY SWORN STATEMENT (OA FORM 23231 SUBSEQUENTLY EXECUTED BY THE SUSPECT/ACCUSED .
JSAPA 2.01
EDITION OF NOV 84 IS OBSOLETE
DA FORM 3881, NOV 89
008212

DOD 006843

SWORN STATEMENT
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943
pr;iw:IPAL. PURPOS ISSN). To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately icie-r.tIfied.
n ¦DuTINE USES:
Your social security number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and
!DISCLOSURE:
Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
;

ATION
2. DATE (YYYYMMDD) 3. TIME
4. FILE NUMBER
///S
LAST NAM FIF1 3T,NAME, MIDDLE NAME
6. SSN
.0A616
TION R ADDRESS

7V 11-' Ales
.
WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER
11 ,A-cjaa
/LA
Netzts tlAySeffi
porse.s„,4
or„,;.
5,51 c 5 /Keit t,„4
itzet a c,cr_ 1­
Le
tA,17,:,
q cA .11.eic L' Xck 11,
CA"'Ci"(o q ,„o11, ,1r 0...,of
Ills ? 4's kr 11;c. Cc_ cel
q ' ICI 1 iA ol A i r- Cie in; v¦-e-‹ 4, , CA, L ;Lc
,..7,,f,, , ,,
rt,,,,,
otis ft,
p evl '
;Le. 0 ft{ c-k CJOi 1.-e5S..eci n.....e. ,:,-, h-,5 %
1/eri.64....4-L cc,,Id t,,,List,L1 fill..$1.‘ I 4.45 ,u-ce,,,1 i;k, 1, ke-er ii;K-, os
ci,I,L.-- .1-
foss 'int( . (PL,, ) ­
tvr wc-{ ..tro ,,,,,,i -10,..c,v-ci64-e 5...ecovlef ps-t.,,, I :14 "'•' -11.,--1-0 L4.,.,A s 1,1_ oliect. 4
1.c-s- Lc:L._ k„,21-1,, LI, Lack
c.ii 4,,,e ., Al -11-,.;s i-Ivi-, / e-,,,./lei
c L,,,- L . s-teck-,,i-1,, (4,,,5o
/ . 9 -,1-ct,4 Q, ti, ,-Vi-, 1--t- -rii.,y! if iTs;. -4 5,,,,:5,-4 v-
t 'co c, 5.6proAllteyi c._ Uh-s-e_k_ ._„ttt,'"c, AAA OA 1, S ctt,c3.1):,.e 10 -1z, c-i-i--L...T ki.c-c-c 4A-e-y5iv ---,11--*, .2,,

,,, ,.- iars
I d, i„,....4.,-,,,,,A .---Lip id,d ,,,,i t,„...._._/
. 4,,,..„d,,,,, ,. le, r,,,, e,,,tir-ar 0---/-An-Gur.....e( rattc i
/wstal, ity -6.4 197. ff.tcA-j_ it cv, lit's $1,6,:',.(,-.4c, / Lc_ it., i.cRi. i idy.0,
Cfruc4- jcia.,,,, .

-114;s fe,,,,1 I Aid ,,,J,41,,,t w 11, ,;kes_J-,‘ey-,
6.,10( ANI-4-cfm-uo 0,f1.L5,, ros;htut-c_ "i'' 0,4 7(A-ce-trot,6; ,,,.."..i0-1,-,c,

Ire 54),-..k 47,4,-a Jr-5 ....1-c SP-x-42-1.4,j 4,„54, 50 ) -115 44 h_,:y(. 1(4 4,1
-4 cX 161 .---111--i
1.61t-t P-C..-/
iqi-ch Ig1/4 14-1.--, sor
-C ff-5, ad / 'ilzi I
t --7--e --Pt;,--c 4 shoe-."1—
1,fitt;(4 14r (r
a ere' c k Cit‘i by' wt,16 II/1 5 ly-c7C 4c-c/t ri-A-kt-• I
/' -le k• f -. -it, 4 _R__ -
i ...4 i ,
. -,._ — ,.../A P. e... '1 v 1 kala-vr . Al (tvi 5 6), 4, 1 . ..,__ C
:.:„..,031T
11 44;1 !,,,,.s .:V Pl. 7.I:', ''' ):MAKING STATEMEN 7
, _ : PAGE i OF • i
..'!".'.)ONAL PAGE.' t1UST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEILlEAD 01L____ TAKEN AT DA7ED
::,: ..:•7 1-0.4.; OF E. :pi 4,901TtoPiAI PAGE MUST BEAR 77-I1.-11-.77,',.1".:­
; or r".'i PrEsGti ;;;;/KING THE STATEMENT
• •-., .1. -;E r.,E INDIC./ ED. Awr:
.------,---.*..4..........,......., r).\ F-70RIV1
2823 )EC 1998
DA FORM ::P2:1, 72. IS Or;SOLFTE
C 0 8 2 1 •3
DOD 006844

• "."1111.1.111111111111111MINWRNIII.F ,
For use of this form, see AR 190-45; the proponent agency is ODCSOPS
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT AUTHORITY: -Title 10 USC Section 301; Title 5 USC Section 2951; E.O. 9397 dated November 22, 1943 (SW. PRINCIPAL'PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately ROUTINE USES: Your social security number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval. DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your social security number is voluntary.
1. LOCATION 2. DATE (YYYYMMDD) 3. TIME 4. FILE NUMBER
5. LAST NAME, FIRST NAME, MIDDLE NAME • 7. GRADEISTATUS
..8.--(01-ttrAcri1ZATION OR ADDRESS
-----_________ I9.
I, , WANT TO MAKE THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT UNDER OA ----ss."\,,
—11-4 ) IN-e.tA-c il :e-i-c Ea sft, 04icx.„.; k—ee St IA/illsCLA V.--c,. 5 ( c5-P-A C c ii,---c_diob....
oss,,,...t..--e.....-1 L/..7, ;

IC• IA c, v`r ao- f'U
l-cd
111111/friirMiti-r, v, f re C9-e-ei
qr-1-1011111111 tvL. , sviorct tA.2.10- Lk.,..s -.
re-kr
49 14 ,t-f uS-6_251)/%e
wi4 -1,-ifer Q v lit,e-4 5 -- - - - GA-' ,_ .6 -5 I,
.
C.1. t2e•- L,I•••-^ (0o5 e r¦
s,-5 ye,
1S lkitt_c o.

'5 hov14.
1 c4. J\:s t r•-C,c Ali; yt. e 1, fIII* -5 c, 4; , ric
1
0 / 41 (:)K iv e riC.,1,„ -Pr v-art, g......4; ecf rz 5-6,; ,...,J. 4, eas:.,,-, if i., s..e ei(
1(
z, f.;;),2. . (` C i c
0, vv,s oisch rA0-(0.A .A. i --c- -
/` l llacAct-lo -i kt,10 4jzz fl, st,t;' e
.1"t4S 1
U , r
lite ti "Sec) 5 fit5 ii_,...I t Le....atte, r, rf mcy,,-r 11,oolcio0-, 4-4-5o,-, ,,, 4ogeno (7, /Le
17..,-e 6 i, 4 e 4.

061./ . tki . ' c' it i r"--641-A.0 cl S 44 %,5- iet1 0 -. c I/1 4 t-T -74 ; 4c uu-c r.e N'
.1
7 1 1
°frtjej bfc -5 41Y -via 1111 I° it( et (If it‹. , 11( 1A-ci-e..lo h...e. 4-ea.,. II,/ f„.t. , ,-) 4
/
..... _ -
0.._. Oar
( 19 3 7//'h
'-- ".-)/) ./Y`-'''' Un 7 -1,'" -6"`"/e" 41e-7-4 6--'-,?_:__ e Tr', . h,..-es-c,-- „2, :,1-7.- ,, -,.. 7

rte' mss SSS
g.. '47 7. 7-1.;"e. 41111111110 l...

,1--a --) ..-_-_,
-1, -----y gr
-4- — IVO
' illt4.'4 111.PF
11.01ti'lL _ . --
10. EXHIBIT 11. INITIALS OF P MAKING STATEMENT eD.,
PAGE-1.-af PAG

ADDITIONAL PAGES MUST CONTAIN THE HEADING "STATEMENT TAKEN AT DATED
THE BOTTOM OF EACH ADDITIONAL PAGE MUST BEAR THE INITIALS OF THE PERSON MAKING THE STATEMENT, AND PAGE NUMBER MUST BE BE INDICATED.
USAPA V 1.00
DA FORM 2823, JUL 72; IS OBSOLETE

DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998
C 0 8 2 1 (1
ll
_ TAKEN AT a-JL (AA'S Al DATED o4,C S
STATEMENT
9 STATEMENT /Cot I/if-icier/1
AFFIDAVIT "0;::e9
, HAVE READ OR HAVE HAD READ TO ME. THIS STATEMENT
N: PAGE ;ANUENOS 0 PAGE 77_. I FULLY UNDERSTAND THE CONTENTS OF THE ENTIRE STATEMENT MADE 1:1
WHICH B
BY ME. THE STATEMENT IS TRUE. I HAVE INITIA'

L ORRECTIONS ANDHAVE,.iNITIALED THE BOTTOM OF EACH PAGE eNT FREELY; ` S WARD, WITHOUT
CONTAINING THE STATEMENT. t HAVE MADE THI THREAT OF PUNISHMENT, AND 'WITHOUT COERCIONNNLAWFUL INFLU 4ga
3
g Statement)
Subscribe
WITNESSES:
ay of
adr'7 41 9 1§i.P¦ 0 •
at
ORGANIZATION OF ADDRESS
34
Tylied.fileM&Of
"frir/C-/0' I
(Authority io Ad; Ingster Oaths.
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
INITIA ER N VI(IG TEMENT
. PAGE 3 OF 3 PAGES
US P A 1.00
PAGE 3, DA FORM 2823, DEC 1998 .
008215

DOD 006846

• RIGHTS WARNING PROCEDURE/WAIVER CERTIFICATE ..-
•
For use of this form, see AR 190-3D; the prOponent agency is ODCSOPS
DATA REQUIRED BY THE PRIVACY ACT
AUTHORITY: Title 10, United States Code, Section 3012(g)
PRINCIPAL PURPOSE: To provide commanders and law enforcement officials with means by which information may be accurately identified.
ROUTINE USES: Your Social Security Number is used as an additional/alternate means of identification to facilitate filing and retrieval.
DISCLOSURE: Disclosure of your Social Security Number is voluntary.

t. C
ON, 2. ,,..,-DATE TIME FILE NO.
Last, First, MO 8. ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS
g rk//X7-6-"il.5(

6. i-SN, GRADE/STATUS
' . .
Sec ion A. Rights
PAT 1 - RIGHTS WAIVER/NON-WAIVER CERTIFICATE
, ....-
The investigator whose name appears below told me that he/she , is with the United States Army PlihT-777---C-A-'
---'
wanted I que ion bout the following offenselsl of which I am
.—.."
t .1sPectedijcerriresel-,
Before he/she asked me any0600ns about the offersetsl:hOWever, he/She-made it clear to me that I hay the following rights:
1. I do not have to answer any question or say anything.
-aY ­
-2.- An¦jthingl---& de`catrrbe,Usbd=as , eiirdenee'againtt-rrie'-in-acrirriinartrial. '
_.
3. -(For personnel subject °the-UCMJ I have the right to talk privately to a lawyer before, during, and alter questioning and to have a lawyer present with me
during questioning. This lawyer can be a civilian lawyer I arrange for at no expense to the. Government or a military lawyer detailed for me at no expense to me, or both.
of

/For civilians not subject to the UCMJ) I have the right to talk privately to a lawyer before, during, and after questioning and to have a lawyer present with me during questioning. I understand that this lawyer can be one that I arrange for at my own expense, or if I cannot afford a lawyer and want one. a lawyer will be appointed for me before any questioning begins.
4 If I am now willing to discuss the offense's) under investigation, with or without a lawyer present, I have a tight to stop answering questions at any time. or
speak privately with a lawyer before answering further, even if I sign the waiver below.

).,
.....-'
5.'COMMENTS (Continue on reverse side) .,"-- -. -...--. -.-(7‘C--6.-e7 4-)"-C24 4 ¦••= r--/—
(.."-'-uvoms`s or-054 TS-X-‘':);":A ,44-64e -c5f_,.,. „..., a

--- . 7,-1/ --..-.....­
...,....."--/-71-cf---
Section B. Waiver
I understand my lights as stated-above, I am now willing to discuss the offense's) under-investigation and make a statement_ talking to a lawyer first and
, , ,
without Paving a-lawyer present with me.

...
WITNESSES (If evadable! SIGNATUBE OF 'INTERVIEWEE
NAME (Type' or Print)
b.
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS AND PHONE .

b.
ORGANIZATION OR ADDRESS AND PHONE .: :-"OfiGANIZATiON OF INVESTIGATOR'-

2a NAME (Type or Print;
,..
74I 7-' fklfrX 7-
.2 eY
Section C. Non-waiver . .
1. I do not want to give up my rights
gr. I want a lawyer 0 I do not want to be questioned or say anything
..,. /
...
ATT TEMENT (DA FORM 2823) SUBSEQUENTLY EXECUTED BY THE SUSPECT/ACCUSED .
USAPA 2.04
DA FORM 3881, NOV 89 EDITION OF NOV /34 IS OBSOLETE

C08216

DOD 006847

I, questioned all soldiers known to be involved in the
incident involving the raid on 20111,03 and also questioned others whom found
witnessed enough to warrant investigation. I initially questioned and then
eery briefly for an understanding of background And then questione
on hiSnpinions and was informed that he felt _acl attempted to ba.6141-46
on his initial statements at Rifles Base. I t en :ife:tione -
who had already had statements taken by . I questioned t ein on the contents
their statements as well as on secondaryquestions that I had For context purposes, the
first thing I did was have alk me through the whole operation from
preparation until ending. I then questioned him on his statement, what he witnessed and
then any questions I had or discrepancies I noticed. Based on my questions I found out
that he was very angry at what he perceived was kicking and that got him started. He
could not say with certainty that he actually saw kicking as all he saw was foot movement
from his peri iheral vision. Also, he started to yell at a soldier near the detainee
and a soldier in the turret of the vehicle that was across from
it tuitio out to bealp. The two of them were yelling at each other
as getting madder. Ito im about the perception that and
that he had backtracked on his statements and questioned 1ilihà6ifl it. He
exp ame that at this time he realized the seriousness of the situation and did not want to
get soldiers in trouble 1 had madeit clear that his responsibility is to remember what he
saw, not worrying about getting soldiers in trouble. He verified that he "perceived"
actions but could not say that those particular actions actually took place. The only thing
he Knows he saw was "foot movement" and he cannot confirm that he saw
put a detainees head in the dirt. He also admitted he was very angry duringAnV
ycnts., ue to his perception and his confrontations with the two soldiers
. He also. toldrilp, that when he made the statements initially at Rifles b to
nd he remembers saying to them that it looked like the
detain weregettirigkie ed. It was not verified. Same for the face in the dirt. I also
asked him for a background on the mission itself to get and idea on how much, if any our
soldiers had been briefed to go get the killers. He explained that that he was at the
briefing and that it was briefed that they were going to get the FOX 6 killers but that this
was not a vigilante mission. He also state at the 5s were in fact briefed on treatment of
detainees. He did mention that the did tateiliat he was a friend of
Fox 6 but did not give any particulafOiderT Also he said confronted the
,
suspected killer, talked to him and left, that's it He also said he never spoke to any of the
soldiers that were orl the ground near the detainee and that after he got told to stay in his
lane by he did not speak to him again but remained very angry
stated that he did not see any of the supposed kicking incidents but only heard it second hand from 111111111111110. He did however state that he "heard profanities" coming from soldiers the detainees but could not say what soldier was saying what. I also asked if he saw a soldier with his foot on a detainees head and he replied that he was moving but that he did see a soldier have his foot on the upper body of the detainee, was also able to verify that a good brief did occur prior to the mission and tiitncspecific instructions were given out for any type of vigilante justice and that proper treatment of detainees was covered. I now talked to 2" Pit.
saw on of the soldiers put his foot on one of the detainees but did

133 Li

008217

.
not witness a kick nor did he see later on put the etainees face in the dirt.
He was involved in an argument across HUMVEE u•ets with and from
his statements, he was attempting to counter what was yelling to defend his
own latoon's soldiers. He was the one arguing about the'Geneva convention and also
told not to yell about the Geneva convention when h was
threaten' his own soldiers.
rim
p
did not witness o kick a detainee but did an ort as security. He did make the
admit to talking to t em as he was walking back and
statement that they(soldiars ould listen to them as long as they completed a sentence in
English He seemed rid did not feel that an soldiers did anything wrong.
denied that either he or ever kicked a detainee. He was the dedicate security with him and only sa put his foot on him to secure
him when he went ti hten zi ties that it appeare t e detainee was trying to get out of.
He also stated that came up and told them to stop kicking detainees and
that he was surprised he wouldsay that. He den -an wron doing and thought that th
detainees were treated well. He also stated that put new flexcuffs on the
detainee and moved his head to stop the detainee from looking ar rid. He also stated
that he remembered the detainee saying "thank you mister" after did this.
asked a few questions about his rights waiver warning and whe I &plaint e-TeastWwas-more-than willing to sign it and-talk. He strongly-denied kicking a detainee and explained that a detainee was moving and he moved his foot to position it on the detainee's back to roll him back over on his chest s uld rea ply zipcuffs while main -ntrol of his weapon. He also stated that came up and told him an o stop kic - ,the detainee and was surprised as they had not kicked anyone. enied seeing , rub a detainees face in the ground and explained that willingly reapplied zipties himself when he realizedy were too tight on etainee.
seemed very concerned when read his rights warning waiver. I walked Mint 'tbirgYthe sheet and the instructions by the numbers and eventually he did say he thought it best if he talk to a lawyer. The instructions clearly state not to coerce in any wa aa: held 0 all questions and we wento Rifles to find an attorney. After
On finding , .at TOC he helped me find . in the chow hall. I explained the situation ad wha told that He would need to tal to IDS but that I could still ask him . 1
questions and he could listen and answer Voluntarily. I informed 111111. of this we
moved to Patriot Base second floor. He did answer all questions I as 'e . The first
question I asked was whether he saw any soldier kicking detainees and he said no. I then
asked if he had rubbed a detainees face in the dirt and he emphatically denied it
explained that he briefs his soldiers to take care of detainees and when he heard accuse them of kicking a soldier went over and told them to stop. He explained that they were taken aback by the accusation and informed him that neither one was kicking a
detainee. He then explained that he had knelt down with one knee between a detainee's
shoulder blades because it was brought to his attention that the zip ties on the detainee
were too tight. He explained that the detainee kept trying to look back at him and he kept
turning his head back so he was facing forward and not observing him. He also expressed that he was very mad at for calling him out in front of people. He told_ graphewould willing y go see the First Sergeant with him if he had a problem -

63 -I-L

C08218

BATES PAGES 8219 — 8221
(IDA: OTJAG — Administrative Law)
ARE NON-RESPONSIVE AND HAVE BEEN

REMOVED

Date / rcie-0-3
Soldier
b3 '09 -2/
Questioner
Did you take part in or see any portion of the incident being investigated which took
place on the morning of 29AUG03 and if the answer is yes, what was your involvement?
CS I LoAS 0 0t-weg-SCR' 1 64 PC-, 3") , Q.k), SCr
TeAm 73-C.

Did your higher command at this or any other time issue any directive on the way
captured personnel are to be treated and if so, explain to the best of your ability .
\ieS,. Te..Eliv_n3 e. CA.-e-CUR--Ci 8'? 1(.-t. t.-C.R.2 --r,Roo r wiEV--(-
--t, ee .5-ccrLea-A-nep , to c P f_2 $-- - 5 is ict L50 Y\A Al_ KE. ID _

14 ikilike 1 c OA A (LK. EK..
of 7-0-e L.C.F1-14A LCD v., I 1­
a 1•3 BHC I
A5 -r," IrJ1-41C1-1- / 140 ,-)Ce._ 6A. LO c A--T-tor3 Oe_"TA I:0ED ...

-blas your higher cOinmand at any time issued specific directives on treatment of
and did they for this raid? What was your understanding of the reasons for this operation
and how did that affect your actions? `1i2 , 11k4.5 R R.-¦ -D 4....) ,1-3 cam (•3(. `T-E

)
-z ,..(--e 2 An A-17 0..0 0 0k- (--g e VED 919A-'"\---"TM{ i t\31 OIS:) OA-1.5 ti-s 1--1- 0 ---rt_iik r c oc pct./ 0 ,\_) ,
Xte.-l_41 c:76,4" 6 t), R-e---E- a 1-
c AA icDrar 0

_C-t) `Tf--. ee_Pv--cT„ kx.)15fActo (3,.; A C e, ak) fY¦ A fL V_ -I" IA E .v\ ,.., 1 TIA.
L2) -z. , p -1--I L ,...,%E K 0c-el.\ 1 c_ 1 -v-tre- \I
t_tc -c-lo ,--) E..sti-P, 11,-4---( e-,-C.. 4ie..1c--g -C) -t I
Do you believe that the actions you took or witnessed were justified and appropriate and

1.0 t \.11 0 n- k_S
based on your anwer, why yes or no? --Th ia'f:1-% "/ E 5, --rt-A E. ­t_,-fd-c u.SE. (.Z _ A ,-)G 0,1-14 1 Ot tsi , Ne,e, g-r 1-1.2.Q0 --a-wok-0 t o k_f-A Ls ii.-) ...re___
i t-i Mrs C.

) O "Ci+E y IA) cse IP TiED 1 c4,r,“-?LIT
C AL-,6-0,1, 2Y 24' P
A r rg_ei c.-NA-i---t_ c y 30 M' , of..12._ W. .14.-S r, b . {' x
-.?r6,3 c .-5 ri-to ;3 , A P Tilt-
12 A cb ...e.__15 \-- f o.: •T-t-lx.--s- vote\ 155 1 O JO
7 lAc. 1,..\0 cflp,e_ 0 oe_ N A- A,k—e— cZ -1-1,-i e Have you ever seen other soldie treating detainees in a way you consider to be inappropriate and if so, when and where? "J 6 , C.3 ) -r-'1 -4 Ath9, S t"--Z 0 -D0. c '1-(2._•040%--
A."3 t M a-T)
VI CA-CP-) Gtr "" i
'44\ c_ 3 42•9/96'0 A-6 (^/
: NA-i5'tt-.1 1-3 5
U 3"1)(OR'..55 I P )1- k-- :1-_-;,-. M A f;­
p. )..) D
A-3- Ok.)*--r k-; rot-‘CMAZ5 , v1' ,
e , C\ v t C) A. ,-.Ds '-c- ctl-EcK '-11\1 -7-s .

What is your understanding of the Geneva Conventions in regard to treatment of
prisoners of war and how do you believe this applies to your situation? Has your
leadership briefed you on this topic? )

R ( 0C ¦ 4--N., ,o.
?.`. (2_ vC: (---k 0- b -1 -T6 1'k-A 't
z,-A E. 6.o 1--_ ,2_ -;) A-Q v

i-i
yocz_. C oST-c
w 1 G 6__
()1c7,c(",,,r \
) 6r rvk
oi,Ny 1-4-a CROM OW ILI 11-1(.1
f^ O82 2 2
DOD 006851
•
• '-jcL
-1: .:-f ¦._y3. t_
. 6.,
t
"51
T.) r
•
4,
CCy, \ I
t
'
11111011111111111 u
vs:
?•:F %
"1:•;.1.) .
L. rc
N-k, to -1-1) 13E_
17)(C._(-
C.;-_
TI-1:?. 6 P-b i
T N41_ d.)e 0, 1 -,,N. ,c¦ ,--_, ¦./....0 i J. 6
( --0 e... ..", ,, f..) 6 c_) I

1•' c e„ 1 0 .1)l-isk (.. ( p ' cii fi.'
D
PLI
,--
o ..:-. 0,-1 5
'Pal K
CO C Ls) . .13C-C 1 a._ Krki.. 71-1
C3)
C f-s(

C08223

Did you take part in or see any portion of the incident being investigated which took
place on the morning of 2911i0

7.240d if the answer is yes, what was your involvement?
byt
.
FS ve•-/•4'4,ri 64-) t* b e
v,:yessrve
4,d
z,in -61`ed elt4-„i-ttes ,
Did your higher command at this or any other time issue any directive on the way
captured personnel are to be treated and if so, explain to the best of your ability .
Az-G--Etc 100`e obee, 4-, (0od,6 fi-&•6 „7"

/
g7 5 or Ati.Wee orxe_elaovne,i4,r1 47 019---t.-0-4-
Ae-c -4e1-7o7/A°_ eic)

.
Has Your higher command at any time issued specific directives on treatment Of -detainees
and did they for this raid? What was your understanding of the reasons for this operation
and how did that affect your actions?

Clog ,f co, s d;redeot 1•-s ‘5, tita •(- ekt-aehe-eS cs5,p-n4 ga to/ eXceSS,1,e_ 47^ "er ve.--194.1 A4s._s_e_j 142,e';et/S/
601-k _c LSS
Do you believe that the actions you took or witnessed were justified and appropriate and based on your anwer, why yes or no?doio_T7-bekc v-e 4 06f---0 -,-ts-b.k-te-C pa° -1.-.). S.5, cN4nefT;^---4A
4A-071 It.-•. 'el-eir-OS
i-,, rtes e,se s ifesei -6 .se--1-4 &Ai_ /la , -.4 -1--L-s -ta 1-1,-4-e K1-0-i 1
7
tfri4 k€5 vs n.,,,,e_ 1 --if-e S eadd.,..._ '.5AI, ..)&....e
Have you ever seen other soldiers treating detainees in a way you consider to be inappropriate and if so, when and where?
3 3 tj c 1,46147-i-, /Iv-1' 1)t-1 66 -4.-s-‘ees
3 -1-•
y-i), gaerz/ Te-j' s 2,./-;t4 bh-t -1--r-o4cc-C-76'14 / -5 Lt/4 , (.47-e J1 . - )1,s---1fexj;ri e4c1/4 4 i ce
What is your understanding of the Geneva Conventions in regard to treatment of prisoners of war and how do you believe this applies to your situation? Has your leadership briefed you on this topic?
fie5/ we ItAt.--(._ ,,,,,..iA p l'it Aeneati. terel fre tAl--2 -PI 11-11-sc I-e,A-f
iki ele 1."-e5 4--a-r-et .4".4elo----e-v.c.-6-or( =;'-, .,/-'s ) ,-41
.5iiteiT .--
Y e ..-0 1 fr-c-s 144 "'NJ riet
4 A At.h,

0082 2 (I
Did you take part in or see anon of the incident being investigated which took
place on the morning of 29 d if the answer is yes, what was your involvement?
Yr5 ) ;IAA/ A.-6.e.e. f4 k )IV4 1A-01 itt 6,c eke. 4-c,

Did your higher command at this or any other time issue any directive on the way
captured personnel are to be treated and if so, explain to the best of your ability .

--itz r,... _t vs-1 ,r,,I.c .,, , .a il iy , .g., o., i,,,, c i-
YC 5. 1 4o -17.,..,1 iti,...... litto 1 7_, 60 o - -rl v't 1,, Cl .k, itt
cliMout.,4 ,r Ztet IAe c is i c,--,_ i ,^ Or z-Lti- 10 at tr, er 1.2r 444-?‘ 0-- ) 0 r re541.P;•4 , e_.\ r_. 0 A
c
1M, rUrig 6..-egt C.I.r•-s)--A tv 1 0,.,rAxt&EA, cAtnldhceeri ite...ccp-e...0. 45 c}--11.,-4C pz.6 V4 e.
Has commad at any time h-6 directives-on treatment of detainees
H your higher comm-issued speci­and did they for this raid? What was your understanding of the reasons for this operation and how did that affect your actions? tsi t, 110-.. ,„,,t ,AL r 1,..,,, e, 1 4 k1 4, 1.-c -,--/- tr.,
re , " y, I
CA-t L.:,,,,,ce,‘ tk --- w ' r o r-cy.t 1-e,..:cA. ii,
s .14,-e N arct. les 0-C k ef--O.C.r% w.4...e-z\ ro,4,-) i,4.,_.
.' i tl f(0 4- W-fevc ,1 A ,.i, 4-k 1 *- -
&4C't& -t( K 6 -L-A Ac ,' A c At/ c -7,i...is , c
1 44 as cki-k-, 1
Ci V1Cl¦ I
1/C6uS dGscr, tle cA
Do you believe that the actions you. ook or witnessed were justified and appropriate and
based on your anwer, why yes or no? i.e,„1 ta /14 ) 44ViVi. le VC IS e• g CM-/(

atc rfk.cci Fc&11 Yen in, M4401, rtey 6, r.--evvt.etil5 and 196,5; (ac,_ 5 Lt.-Ail cer
pOSS,I, (.c ac-1-;1'netS.,
Have you ever seen other soldiers treating detainees in a way you consider to be
inappropriate and if so, when and where?

What is your understanding of the Geneva Conventions in regard to treatment of prisoners of war and how do you believe`this applies to your situation? Has your leadership briefed you on this topic? L &,,... -.4-, C. c). vz ,17..,,, s s IA. 04 tic + L '4 A' ty
1 r
..1...e..4 0. I( tjja:"e_t 5, f -e.ttc(el oi.v1/401 oor4s c A fr_ Cyt Ai6....,1„,... ,...... 1 LA.,i4(..4 (Jo 5 s ; h.I..„ i ...-1, 14 tyr...,:e

c f c41,41 c( , eov vt‹ ir,g, t.t. . it .C.:.et , o t it-
...eir 1 , c.). ...y 5,4= ea... •)9 e--1- -1- z -y 6..1.--t ,.... 31 1.
„ 7/ /1
-Ai;1-i,al-I ol^ 1-1-1 C.Le tz,n_te,_„5 vu'i.' 41s-4,-- 1-4 4--et./-e¦-e4_ 14 1-644aa—e, L.15 • VI XI :(4, 1. (.41 ti t-,-,
G, r ce o) .114,--c e=,4,-Ct 4-. (.44_, 11_ , ‘,,-, r“4 c,,,0,5.44_,,....4., t„...j. 4,,,ev-e j
le a -6.. C. IlltOrr COLL4.,61f-jeL L.CA 1-/c5 Ve h;tit ) :05 60,,.A_ etS
prct c; (ctly 10037. it e- X-5
-II( t-ZZLEhr et4 ° 2' f1J • ho,s tly lorht,d ,,, ci.4 al.;„,.._ A ). c ., 0 0 8 2 2 5
Date a
Soldier
Questioner
Did you take part in or see any portion of the incident being investigated which took place on the morning of 29Atie03 and if the answer is yes, what was your involvement?.7"-c4/ (--\)
5 /4.piZcz. rvi -s
44.4z,vv. --r it e cl Nom ci A.
Did your higher command at this or any other time issue any directive on the way captured personnel are to be treated and if so, explain to the best of your ability .
•,„ut .e. ri., re-P._e__ CI --tiferrrEtzk, 1 ,....." eoc.A."-c-___-Q. -r-ci_. t-') j c-
_C-Wvl 11,1-C-rk--,
f,.4.e_e...,
4 r re-. e
S.e ft..," L. e S o p N4,
K., A-AL.'S e... c3 V 12174 , ,,ie ., --/-¦ `...-t t.-
Tel e 5-A a. c....k. 7 H ,e,
t .4.G ;4=14,, ,•1. -T-j )-.4e. 7 rt . d-r c.3 1-4.-e-d e ef )
69. Tete
(4.,..j Lc? ',j e. --..,,c,,
•T kt-e Della . is./ t S c 'ti-+e
S44_0 i ce 4-1 'S p, o 1,1 cll. A t3....5 e.-
-Has your higher command at -time-issued:specific directives_on treatment of detainees c", and did they for this raid? What was your understanding of the reasons for this operation and how did that affect your actions?
i4..,e.9.4._ i'v e ,sI TA t.c. BA--)-(c S putt ivc--._Al 3c-- c.,c.-_-, 44_,:._
i,(Je.
AA DS 1 8.. sae_ ) Dor-, `1--/14 I, "z 21-;! 1 Yvicl delido‘vt, e Sic--4:(7--us
,....s ___ c_,..9 i724,..pr:s cf"..-

.14,/%-et 11,4?__ I THe I-2. s AT-r,... ar..,,t 00(Z s . Ti4e_oC,tplc., ra-_-€._ •--ri-ie) 3 -e fq.e-Spz f.,. e.c, t e_
Cclizt--7- 14 'c-'.1 ict-p.-, A-C -7-c,
1:2R--/1,u .7:-. CD = il . --r S .--1;c1":1-- I. - 1 r 1 ssJ.5e -"r4 t! tu,s4 4._.

4114 4 c-..,_,R...e ACT -e d , e v e. -VA A ,.. .OdlVC 14'AI-Pel.S .-fr , 1/4 .P ,-.Sk C i't: ----)
R.A..N 1. S 4
Do you neheve that the actions you took or witnessed were justified and appropriate and -,
-----..
based on your anwer, why yes or no? --N--
Lte,.s , nia scow r-e I i_.. ) rtX 14430-; 6 i:31 e'Th d iv e_5 e u-t.R. -iz,c, t-----.
pe..,- c.-_ -e 1 T 14 t‘ t... YKOVr-V14e- rt..' I it„,}45 L./ lflt‘T-4.74 c' +Z ---r-H-, R
5 Agr9 A-S I.A....-es.X._ AS -rile..o504;5 a ..p we 441..11‘.. sc,i__C) I e R Have you ever seen other soldiers treating detainees in a way you consider to be inappropriate and if so, when and where?
AX) 10 1)6'1!
What is your understanding of the. Geneva Conventions in regard to treatment of prisoners of war and how do you believe this applies to your situation? Has your leadership briefed you on this topic?
L.,,),/epSTA-/kid f 'AI cS t -5 .cic:ra ,'n.•e S 4-12.e. Te, 8 e (.)
rvtv, ,
i4ViV1 P411%.11') 4!t--4 L.,.., ; Ti.!-b , .c.-1.1... . '1"..... . AJooph---sS% ‘c._ A L 48(...se ,-s
I4 /...4-0 LI-eci C.A..C. t De• kI;nied pA-s-c'ed LA./ i-(117-I S ,.t.;" eciled
I
7? 5/14-4((-1 5'ec..L.9._e -1--/-1.e. vt-t.
4 S 4 fri. ra i 1174(-/eo
0 "-, r 8e. BR i' e -.,;" c} rn
-4i-v2
4--" i
Teo': 4;-'5 0 A.-, THE'o.e. y..F.ae..c1---eCI -rney4:7-114 f- ?L' 7-c„4-' E),-774,t. e
008Z26 3--0j